Zhaohui Li
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Zhaohui Li has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Cheng Chi
Department of Electronics, Peking University, Beijing, China
6 shared publicationsQihu Li
5 shared publicationsYang Sun
4 shared publicationsAigen Huang
2 shared publicationsJi-Ying Hu
Department of Electronics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
2 shared publications- Jian Cui
Department of Electronics, Peking University, No.5 Yiheyuan Road, Haidian District, Beijing 100871, China
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 12 March 2020
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 69 (10) , 7328-7340
Fast Focusing of Ultrasound Synthetic Aperture Imaging by Using Virtual Array and Nonuniform Fast Fourier Transform
A fast synthetic aperture (SA) focusing algorithm is proposed in this paper to overcome the problem of huge computational complexity in developing high-performance SA ultrasound imaging systems. The proposed method realizes the fast focusing of SA imaging by utilizing a virtual array (VA) technique in combination with nonuniform fast Fourier transform (NUFFT), i.e. the VA-NUFFT method. The computational performance of the VA-NUFFT algorithm is evaluated with the computational complexity under acceptable beam errors, in comparisons with the conventional delay-and-sum (DAS) method and the frequency-domain direct method (DM), as well as a multiple NUFFT (M-NUFFT) method. Simulation results reveal that under a beam error level less than -57.4 dB, 25 and 10 reduction ratios of entire real operations can be achieved by the VA-NUFFT at a larger SA scan lines of 2048, when compared with the DAS and DM, respectively. In the key SA focusing step, i.e. the “spatial process” step, the computational load of VA-NUFFT is lower than two orders of magnitude of that of the DM. SA imaging of a phantom with four cysts is also simulated and a contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) criterion is adopted for evaluation of imaging quality. CNR results reflect that SA images of using VA-NUFFT make almost no difference to that of DAS focusing under different signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs).
- 12 March 2020
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 69 (10) , 7328-7340
Fast Focusing of Ultrasound Synthetic Aperture Imaging by Using Virtual Array and Nonuniform Fast Fourier Transform
A fast synthetic aperture (SA) focusing algorithm is proposed in this paper to overcome the problem of huge computational complexity in developing high-performance SA ultrasound imaging systems. The proposed method realizes the fast focusing of SA imaging by utilizing a virtual array (VA) technique in combination with nonuniform fast Fourier transform (NUFFT), i.e. the VA-NUFFT method. The computational performance of the VA-NUFFT algorithm is evaluated with the computational complexity under acceptable beam errors, in comparisons with the conventional delay-and-sum (DAS) method and the frequency-domain direct method (DM), as well as a multiple NUFFT (M-NUFFT) method. Simulation results reveal that under a beam error level less than -57.4 dB, 25 and 10 reduction ratios of entire real operations can be achieved by the VA-NUFFT at a larger SA scan lines of 2048, when compared with the DAS and DM, respectively. In the key SA focusing step, i.e. the “spatial process” step, the computational load of VA-NUFFT is lower than two orders of magnitude of that of the DM. SA imaging of a phantom with four cysts is also simulated and a contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) criterion is adopted for evaluation of imaging quality. CNR results reflect that SA images of using VA-NUFFT make almost no difference to that of DAS focusing under different signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs).
- 10 December 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 69 (8) , 5369-5384
Synchronous 3-D Imaging and Velocity Estimation of Underwater Targets Using Pulse-Pair Acoustical Imaging Technique
- 10 December 2019
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 69 (8) , 5369-5384
Synchronous 3-D Imaging and Velocity Estimation of Underwater Targets Using Pulse-Pair Acoustical Imaging Technique
- 16 April 2018
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Journal of Oceanic Engineering
- Vol. 44 (2) , 466-481
Strong Scattering Targets Separation Based on Fractional Fourier Transformation in Pulse-to-Pulse Coherent Acoustical Doppler Current Profilers
The influence of the strong scattering targets (SSTs) on the flow cell velocities, i.e., the fish-bias effect, is a common phenomenon existing widely in real-time measurements of ocean and river current profiles when using pulse-to-pulse coherent acoustical Doppler current profilers (ADCPs), because the SSTs with different velocities and excessively high echo strengths are inevitable in the ocean and river background flow mediums. However, there are no effective means to eliminate the SST-caused biases and recover the current profiles accurately. The common solutions to solve the SST problem either neglect the influence simply, or abandon the affected data directly, which of course causes wrong current profiles or even invalidation of the on-site measurement. Therefore, this paper proposes an SST separation method to eliminate the SST-caused biases in ADCPs. By employing a fractional Fourier transform (FrFT)-based method, the SST echoes are separated from the background ones, so that the accurate estimation of both velocities of the flow cells and the SSTs are obtained through respective signals. First, the proposed SST separation method based on FrFT is theoretically analyzed and validated through a simulation model of flow measurement scenarios, which is constructed with a large number of distributed point targets and several SSTs. Then, an ADCP core algorithm is implemented with traditional correlation theory after the SST separation. Next, the performance of the proposed method is evaluated with different-strength SST signals being superposed to the background echoes. At last, the computational complexity of the FrFT algorithm is evaluated to show that the SST separation algorithm does not affect the real-time measurements of the current velocities significantly. The simulation results show that, even when the averaging power of an SST is 60 dB stronger than that of the averaging background echoes, accurate flow velocities of the affected flow cells can be recovered. Moreover, up to five SSTs around one flow cell with a total power 60 dB higher than that of the background echoes can be separated effectively by the separation algorithm with an affordable computational cost, with which both the current profile and the velocities of the SSTs are accurately obtained.
- 16 April 2018
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Journal of Oceanic Engineering
- Vol. 44 (2) , 466-481
Strong Scattering Targets Separation Based on Fractional Fourier Transformation in Pulse-to-Pulse Coherent Acoustical Doppler Current Profilers
The influence of the strong scattering targets (SSTs) on the flow cell velocities, i.e., the fish-bias effect, is a common phenomenon existing widely in real-time measurements of ocean and river current profiles when using pulse-to-pulse coherent acoustical Doppler current profilers (ADCPs), because the SSTs with different velocities and excessively high echo strengths are inevitable in the ocean and river background flow mediums. However, there are no effective means to eliminate the SST-caused biases and recover the current profiles accurately. The common solutions to solve the SST problem either neglect the influence simply, or abandon the affected data directly, which of course causes wrong current profiles or even invalidation of the on-site measurement. Therefore, this paper proposes an SST separation method to eliminate the SST-caused biases in ADCPs. By employing a fractional Fourier transform (FrFT)-based method, the SST echoes are separated from the background ones, so that the accurate estimation of both velocities of the flow cells and the SSTs are obtained through respective signals. First, the proposed SST separation method based on FrFT is theoretically analyzed and validated through a simulation model of flow measurement scenarios, which is constructed with a large number of distributed point targets and several SSTs. Then, an ADCP core algorithm is implemented with traditional correlation theory after the SST separation. Next, the performance of the proposed method is evaluated with different-strength SST signals being superposed to the background echoes. At last, the computational complexity of the FrFT algorithm is evaluated to show that the SST separation algorithm does not affect the real-time measurements of the current velocities significantly. The simulation results show that, even when the averaging power of an SST is 60 dB stronger than that of the averaging background echoes, accurate flow velocities of the affected flow cells can be recovered. Moreover, up to five SSTs around one flow cell with a total power 60 dB higher than that of the background echoes can be separated effectively by the separation algorithm with an affordable computational cost, with which both the current profile and the velocities of the SSTs are accurately obtained.
- 1 March 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Ultrasonics
- Vol. 84, 63-73
Fast computation of far-field pulse-echo PSF of arbitrary arrays for large sparse 2-D ultrasound array design
- 1 March 2018
- Published by Elsevier in Ultrasonics
- Vol. 84, 63-73
Fast computation of far-field pulse-echo PSF of arbitrary arrays for large sparse 2-D ultrasound array design
- 1 December 2017
- Published by IOP Publishing in Chinese Physics B
- Vol. 26 (12) , 127702
Singular variation property of elastic constants of piezoelectric ceramics shunted to negative capacitance
Piezoelectric shunt damping has been widely used in vibration suppression, sound absorption, noise elimination, etc. In such applications, the variant elastic constants of piezoelectric materials are the essential parameters that determine the performances of the systems, when piezoelectric materials are shunted to normal electrical elements, i.e., resistance, inductance and capacitance, as well as their combinations. In recent years, many researches have demonstrated that the wideband sound absorption or vibration suppression can be realized with piezoelectric materials shunted to negative capacitance. However, most systems using the negative-capacitance shunt circuits show their instabilities in the optimal condition, which are essentially caused by the singular variation properties of elastic constants of piezoelectric materials when shunted to negative capacitance. This paper aims at investigating the effects of negative-capacitance shunt circuits on elastic constants of a piezoelectric ceramic plate through theoretical analyses and experiments, which gives an rational explanation for why negative capacitance shunt circuit is prone to make structure instable. First, the relationships between the elastic constants c 11, c 33, c 55 of the piezoelectric ceramic and the shunt negative capacitance are derived with the piezoelectric constitutive law theoretically. Then, an experimental setup is established to verify the theoretical results through observing the change of elastic constant c 55 of the shunted piezoelectric plate with the variation of negative capacitance. The experimental results are in good agreement with the theoretical analyses, which reveals that the instability of the shunt damping system is essentially caused by the singular variation property of the elastic constants of piezoelectric material shunted to negative capacitance.
- 1 December 2017
- Published by IOP Publishing in Chinese Physics B
- Vol. 26 (12) , 127702
Singular variation property of elastic constants of piezoelectric ceramics shunted to negative capacitance
Piezoelectric shunt damping has been widely used in vibration suppression, sound absorption, noise elimination, etc. In such applications, the variant elastic constants of piezoelectric materials are the essential parameters that determine the performances of the systems, when piezoelectric materials are shunted to normal electrical elements, i.e., resistance, inductance and capacitance, as well as their combinations. In recent years, many researches have demonstrated that the wideband sound absorption or vibration suppression can be realized with piezoelectric materials shunted to negative capacitance. However, most systems using the negative-capacitance shunt circuits show their instabilities in the optimal condition, which are essentially caused by the singular variation properties of elastic constants of piezoelectric materials when shunted to negative capacitance. This paper aims at investigating the effects of negative-capacitance shunt circuits on elastic constants of a piezoelectric ceramic plate through theoretical analyses and experiments, which gives an rational explanation for why negative capacitance shunt circuit is prone to make structure instable. First, the relationships between the elastic constants c 11, c 33, c 55 of the piezoelectric ceramic and the shunt negative capacitance are derived with the piezoelectric constitutive law theoretically. Then, an experimental setup is established to verify the theoretical results through observing the change of elastic constant c 55 of the shunted piezoelectric plate with the variation of negative capacitance. The experimental results are in good agreement with the theoretical analyses, which reveals that the instability of the shunt damping system is essentially caused by the singular variation property of the elastic constants of piezoelectric material shunted to negative capacitance.
- 19 June 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 66 (10) , 2647-2657
High-Resolution Real-Time Underwater 3-D Acoustical Imaging Through Designing Ultralarge Ultrasparse Ultra-Wideband 2-D Arrays
Acoustical imaging systems are an important kind of instrumentation for underwater investigation. Currently, angular resolutions of most existing real-time underwater 3-D imaging systems are around 1°, which cannot meet the high-quality imaging requirement in a relatively far distance. Enhancing the angular resolution of a real-time 3-D imaging system needs enlarging the aperture size of its receiving 2-D array. However, the huge number of elements is not affordable for a traditional fully sampled uniform large 2-D array with half-wavelength interelement spacing to achieve a high angular resolution. This paper proposes the concept of ultralarge ultrasparse ultra-wideband (UUU) 2-D arrays for achieving the high angular resolution of underwater 3-D acoustical imaging systems. The design method of UUU 2-D arrays is demonstrated through the example of designing an annular 2-D array with only 100 elements. The capabilities of the designed annular UUU 2-D array are evaluated, showing that it can achieve a 0.1° angular resolution and a −32 dB maximum sidelobe level. The imaging simulations of complicated targets also demonstrate that the designed annular UUU 2-D array can satisfy the requirement of high-resolution underwater 3-D acoustical imaging. The element number of the designed annular UUU 2-D array is 4 orders of magnitude lower than that of a fully sampled uniform 2-D array, which provides a viable choice for developing high-resolution real-time underwater 3-D acoustical imaging systems.
- 19 June 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 66 (10) , 2647-2657
High-Resolution Real-Time Underwater 3-D Acoustical Imaging Through Designing Ultralarge Ultrasparse Ultra-Wideband 2-D Arrays
Acoustical imaging systems are an important kind of instrumentation for underwater investigation. Currently, angular resolutions of most existing real-time underwater 3-D imaging systems are around 1°, which cannot meet the high-quality imaging requirement in a relatively far distance. Enhancing the angular resolution of a real-time 3-D imaging system needs enlarging the aperture size of its receiving 2-D array. However, the huge number of elements is not affordable for a traditional fully sampled uniform large 2-D array with half-wavelength interelement spacing to achieve a high angular resolution. This paper proposes the concept of ultralarge ultrasparse ultra-wideband (UUU) 2-D arrays for achieving the high angular resolution of underwater 3-D acoustical imaging systems. The design method of UUU 2-D arrays is demonstrated through the example of designing an annular 2-D array with only 100 elements. The capabilities of the designed annular UUU 2-D array are evaluated, showing that it can achieve a 0.1° angular resolution and a −32 dB maximum sidelobe level. The imaging simulations of complicated targets also demonstrate that the designed annular UUU 2-D array can satisfy the requirement of high-resolution underwater 3-D acoustical imaging. The element number of the designed annular UUU 2-D array is 4 orders of magnitude lower than that of a fully sampled uniform 2-D array, which provides a viable choice for developing high-resolution real-time underwater 3-D acoustical imaging systems.
- 29 November 2016
- Published by IOP Publishing in Chinese Physics B
- Vol. 25 (12) , 127701
Investigations of thickness-shear mode elastic constant and damping of shunted piezoelectric materials with a coupling resonator
Shear-mode piezoelectric materials have been widely used to shunt the damping of vibrations where utilizing surface or interface shear stresses. The thick-shear mode (TSM) elastic constant and the mechanical loss factor can change correspondingly when piezoelectric materials are shunted to different electrical circuits. This phenomenon makes it possible to control the performance of a shear-mode piezoelectric damping system through designing the shunt circuit. However, due to the difficulties in directly measuring the TSM elastic constant and the mechanical loss factor of piezoelectric materials, the relationships between those parameters and the shunt circuits have rarely been investigated. In this paper, a coupling TSM electro–mechanical resonant system is proposed to indirectly measure the variations of the TSM elastic constant and the mechanical loss factor of piezoelectric materials. The main idea is to transform the variations of the TSM elastic constant and the mechanical loss factor into the changes of the easily observed resonant frequency and electrical quality factor of the coupling electro–mechanical resonator. Based on this model, the formular relationships are set up theoretically with Mason equivalent circuit method and they are validated with finite element (FE) analyses. Finally, a prototype of the coupling electro–mechanical resonator is fabricated with two shear-mode PZT5A plates to investigate the TSM elastic constants and the mechanical loss factors of different circuit-shunted cases of the piezoelectric plate. Both the resonant frequency shifts and the bandwidth changes observed in experiments are in good consistence with the theoretical and FE analyses under the same shunt conditions. The proposed coupling resonator and the obtained relationships are validated with but not limited to PZT5A.
- 29 November 2016
- Published by IOP Publishing in Chinese Physics B
- Vol. 25 (12) , 127701
Investigations of thickness-shear mode elastic constant and damping of shunted piezoelectric materials with a coupling resonator
Shear-mode piezoelectric materials have been widely used to shunt the damping of vibrations where utilizing surface or interface shear stresses. The thick-shear mode (TSM) elastic constant and the mechanical loss factor can change correspondingly when piezoelectric materials are shunted to different electrical circuits. This phenomenon makes it possible to control the performance of a shear-mode piezoelectric damping system through designing the shunt circuit. However, due to the difficulties in directly measuring the TSM elastic constant and the mechanical loss factor of piezoelectric materials, the relationships between those parameters and the shunt circuits have rarely been investigated. In this paper, a coupling TSM electro–mechanical resonant system is proposed to indirectly measure the variations of the TSM elastic constant and the mechanical loss factor of piezoelectric materials. The main idea is to transform the variations of the TSM elastic constant and the mechanical loss factor into the changes of the easily observed resonant frequency and electrical quality factor of the coupling electro–mechanical resonator. Based on this model, the formular relationships are set up theoretically with Mason equivalent circuit method and they are validated with finite element (FE) analyses. Finally, a prototype of the coupling electro–mechanical resonator is fabricated with two shear-mode PZT5A plates to investigate the TSM elastic constants and the mechanical loss factors of different circuit-shunted cases of the piezoelectric plate. Both the resonant frequency shifts and the bandwidth changes observed in experiments are in good consistence with the theoretical and FE analyses under the same shunt conditions. The proposed coupling resonator and the obtained relationships are validated with but not limited to PZT5A.
- 27 May 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 65 (8) , 1739-1748
Robust Precise Time Difference Estimation Based on Digital Zero-Crossing Detection Algorithm
Precise time difference (time interval) measurement has been widely applied in communication, detection, and metrology. Among the various methods of time difference measurement, the analog zero-crossing detection method and the full digital processing methods are commonly used in ultrasonic flow measurement application. Conventional full digital processing methods, which take advantage of total signals' waveforms, can have high accuracy in high signal to noise ratio (SNR) when employing a high enough sampling frequency and extremely high performance digital signal processors; but their accuracies are severely limited by the hardware costs and can be easily affected by the noise and the distortion of signals. As a viable method, the analog zero-crossing detection method can achieve high resolution, whose accuracy, however, is easily influenced by the detection threshold and baseline shifts of the received signals, as well as the noises. In this paper, the digital zero-crossing detection algorithm is proposed for ultrasonic flow measurement to achieve high-precision and high-robustness time difference estimation at relatively low hardware costs, i.e., a relatively low sampling rate (e.g., 10 Msamples/s) and a relatively low computational load. The digital zero-crossing detection algorithm is performed with the signal reconstruction and the least-square fitting technologies. The simulation and experiment results show that compared with conventional methods, the proposed method presents higher accuracy and higher robustness, especially in the case of low SNR.
- 27 May 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 65 (8) , 1739-1748
Robust Precise Time Difference Estimation Based on Digital Zero-Crossing Detection Algorithm
Precise time difference (time interval) measurement has been widely applied in communication, detection, and metrology. Among the various methods of time difference measurement, the analog zero-crossing detection method and the full digital processing methods are commonly used in ultrasonic flow measurement application. Conventional full digital processing methods, which take advantage of total signals' waveforms, can have high accuracy in high signal to noise ratio (SNR) when employing a high enough sampling frequency and extremely high performance digital signal processors; but their accuracies are severely limited by the hardware costs and can be easily affected by the noise and the distortion of signals. As a viable method, the analog zero-crossing detection method can achieve high resolution, whose accuracy, however, is easily influenced by the detection threshold and baseline shifts of the received signals, as well as the noises. In this paper, the digital zero-crossing detection algorithm is proposed for ultrasonic flow measurement to achieve high-precision and high-robustness time difference estimation at relatively low hardware costs, i.e., a relatively low sampling rate (e.g., 10 Msamples/s) and a relatively low computational load. The digital zero-crossing detection algorithm is performed with the signal reconstruction and the least-square fitting technologies. The simulation and experiment results show that compared with conventional methods, the proposed method presents higher accuracy and higher robustness, especially in the case of low SNR.
- 24 March 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 63 (6) , 803-816
Fast Computation of Wideband Beam Pattern for Designing Large-Scale 2-D Arrays
For real-time and high-resolution 3-D ultrasound imaging, the design of sparse distribution and weights of elements of a large-scale wideband 2-D array is needed to reduce hardware cost and achieve better directivity. However, due to the high time consumption of computing the wideband beam pattern, the design methods that need massive iterations have rarely been applied to design large-scale wideband 2-D arrays by directly computing the wideband beam pattern. In this paper, a fast method is proposed to realize the computation of a wideband beam pattern of arbitrary 2-D arrays in the far field in order to design large-scale wideband 2-D arrays. The proposed fast method exploits two important techniques: 1) nonuniform fast Fourier transform (FFT) and 2) short inverse FFT. Compared with the commonly used ultrasound simulator Field II, two orders of magnitude improvement in computation speed is achieved with comparable accuracy. The proposed fast method enables massive iterations of direct wideband beam pattern computation of arbitrary large-scale 2-D arrays. A design example in this paper demonstrates that the proposed fast method can help achieve better performance in designing large-scale wideband 2-D arrays.
- 24 March 2016
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
- Vol. 63 (6) , 803-816
Fast Computation of Wideband Beam Pattern for Designing Large-Scale 2-D Arrays
For real-time and high-resolution 3-D ultrasound imaging, the design of sparse distribution and weights of elements of a large-scale wideband 2-D array is needed to reduce hardware cost and achieve better directivity. However, due to the high time consumption of computing the wideband beam pattern, the design methods that need massive iterations have rarely been applied to design large-scale wideband 2-D arrays by directly computing the wideband beam pattern. In this paper, a fast method is proposed to realize the computation of a wideband beam pattern of arbitrary 2-D arrays in the far field in order to design large-scale wideband 2-D arrays. The proposed fast method exploits two important techniques: 1) nonuniform fast Fourier transform (FFT) and 2) short inverse FFT. Compared with the commonly used ultrasound simulator Field II, two orders of magnitude improvement in computation speed is achieved with comparable accuracy. The proposed fast method enables massive iterations of direct wideband beam pattern computation of arbitrary large-scale 2-D arrays. A design example in this paper demonstrates that the proposed fast method can help achieve better performance in designing large-scale wideband 2-D arrays.
- 1 October 2015
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-4
Fast calculation of wideband beam pattern for designing large planar array
Owing to the high time consumption of calculating wideband beam pattern (BP) of large planar array, the common design methods which need massive iterations of calculating wideband BP have rarely been applied to design large wideband planar arrays. To solve such a problem, this paper proposes a fast method of calculating wideband BP, based on nonuniform fast Fourier transform and short inverse fast Fourier transform. Compared with Field II which is commonly-used, the calculation speed of the proposed method is increased by about two orders of magnitude with comparable accuracy. It is proven that the design methods which need massive iterations can directly employ wideband BP to design better large wideband planar arrays, based on the proposed fast method of calculating wideband BP.
- 1 October 2015
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-4
Fast calculation of wideband beam pattern for designing large planar array
Owing to the high time consumption of calculating wideband beam pattern (BP) of large planar array, the common design methods which need massive iterations of calculating wideband BP have rarely been applied to design large wideband planar arrays. To solve such a problem, this paper proposes a fast method of calculating wideband BP, based on nonuniform fast Fourier transform and short inverse fast Fourier transform. Compared with Field II which is commonly-used, the calculation speed of the proposed method is increased by about two orders of magnitude with comparable accuracy. It is proven that the design methods which need massive iterations can directly employ wideband BP to design better large wideband planar arrays, based on the proposed fast method of calculating wideband BP.