Mehmet A. Orhan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Mehmet A. Orhan has a total of 54 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- P. Matthijs Bal
University of Lincoln, United Kingdom
13 shared publications Insaf Khelladi
Léonard de Vinci Pôle Universitaire, Research Center, Paris La Défense, France
5 shared publications- Yvonne Gerarda Theodora van Rossenberg
Institute for Management Research, Radboud University Nijmegen, the Netherlands
5 shared publications Yvonne van Rossenberg
5 shared publicationsRossella Sorio
ICN Business School, CEREFIGE, Université de Lorraine, Nancy, France
4 shared publicationsSylvaine Castellano
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 15 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Methods in Psychology
- Vol. 15
Exclusion by design: Methodological sophistication and elitism as gatekeeping mechanisms in industrial-organizational psychology
- 15 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Methods in Psychology
- Vol. 15
Open AccessExclusion by design: Methodological sophistication and elitism as gatekeeping mechanisms in industrial-organizational psychology
- 8 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Interpersonal Violence
- Vol. 41 (21-22) , 9496-9504
Conviction Is Not Commission: A Methodological, Conceptual, and Ethical Critique of Khoshnood et al.
Khoshnood et al. (2026) report a strong association between immigrant background and rape convictions in Sweden using nationwide register data and a matched case-control design. This commentary argues that the study suggests important descriptive evidence on conviction patterns, but that its interpretation exceeds what the data can support. We believe that the central limitation in the published study is that the authors investigate rape conviction as the dependent variable, not actual rape offending . It must be noted that conviction is the filtered outcome of selective criminal justice processes consisting of a series of events, including reporting, policing, prosecution, evidentiary thresholds, legal representation, interpretation, and judicial discretion, which could influence the outcome variable. Additionally, we also argue that omitted confounding factors, including education, language proficiency, legal literacy, legal status, and access to effective defense, may partly explain the observed associations. Finally, we highlight concerns about overreaching interpretation and biased language use in a socially sensitive area, particularly in light of APA guidance on bias-free language use and inclusive scholarly communication. In conclusion, we invite readers to evaluate the findings of the original study more carefully. Simultaneously, we argue that these findings may also be interpreted as evidence of unequal conviction patterns, rather than as evidence of unequal offending propensities.
- 8 October 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Interpersonal Violence
- Vol. 41 (21-22) , 9496-9504
Conviction Is Not Commission: A Methodological, Conceptual, and Ethical Critique of Khoshnood et al.
Khoshnood et al. (2026) report a strong association between immigrant background and rape convictions in Sweden using nationwide register data and a matched case-control design. This commentary argues that the study suggests important descriptive evidence on conviction patterns, but that its interpretation exceeds what the data can support. We believe that the central limitation in the published study is that the authors investigate rape conviction as the dependent variable, not actual rape offending . It must be noted that conviction is the filtered outcome of selective criminal justice processes consisting of a series of events, including reporting, policing, prosecution, evidentiary thresholds, legal representation, interpretation, and judicial discretion, which could influence the outcome variable. Additionally, we also argue that omitted confounding factors, including education, language proficiency, legal literacy, legal status, and access to effective defense, may partly explain the observed associations. Finally, we highlight concerns about overreaching interpretation and biased language use in a socially sensitive area, particularly in light of APA guidance on bias-free language use and inclusive scholarly communication. In conclusion, we invite readers to evaluate the findings of the original study more carefully. Simultaneously, we argue that these findings may also be interpreted as evidence of unequal conviction patterns, rather than as evidence of unequal offending propensities.
- Open Access
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
‘The difference between us is that I am an optimist and you are a pessimist.’ An autoethnographic study on suppression of critical scholarship
Critical scholarship constitutes an important part of business and management research, including related fields such as work psychology. However, critical work is also often met with resistance from colleagues and gatekeepers within the discipline. Yet, there is little insight into how this resistance manifests in daily academic practice. This autoethnographic study by multiple critical scholars in work and organizational psychology analyzed 34 events whereby their critical work was suppressed and silenced. Thematic analysis of the events revealed ten different mechanisms through which critical work is suppressed, which could be ordered within four sequential stages of suppression: closing space, discrediting work, discrediting research(-ers), and disciplinary control. Jointly, these stages represent an escalating process of how alternative perspectives, including critical work, are suppressed and silenced in hegemonic fields. The paper contributes to existing critical scholarship by being the first to empirically elucidate how and through which strategies critical work is silenced. The study has important implications not only for the development of critical perspectives within scientific fields, but also for academia more widely, as political and societal forces that undermine academic freedom call for a better understanding of how critical work is suppressed, and how it could be nurtured for a more dignified, equal, and democratic society.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open Access‘The difference between us is that I am an optimist and you are a pessimist.’ An autoethnographic study on suppression of critical scholarship
Critical scholarship constitutes an important part of business and management research, including related fields such as work psychology. However, critical work is also often met with resistance from colleagues and gatekeepers within the discipline. Yet, there is little insight into how this resistance manifests in daily academic practice. This autoethnographic study by multiple critical scholars in work and organizational psychology analyzed 34 events whereby their critical work was suppressed and silenced. Thematic analysis of the events revealed ten different mechanisms through which critical work is suppressed, which could be ordered within four sequential stages of suppression: closing space, discrediting work, discrediting research(-ers), and disciplinary control. Jointly, these stages represent an escalating process of how alternative perspectives, including critical work, are suppressed and silenced in hegemonic fields. The paper contributes to existing critical scholarship by being the first to empirically elucidate how and through which strategies critical work is silenced. The study has important implications not only for the development of critical perspectives within scientific fields, but also for academia more widely, as political and societal forces that undermine academic freedom call for a better understanding of how critical work is suppressed, and how it could be nurtured for a more dignified, equal, and democratic society.
- 21 July 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Organizational Effectiveness: People and Performance
- p. 1-32
Hybrid work and relational dynamics: leadership, favoritism and employee outcomes
Purpose: This study examines how hybrid work reshapes relational dynamics within organizations by investigating how management style and perceived favoritism influence employee wellbeing and workplace withdrawal. Drawing on stewardship theory and leader–member exchange theory, complemented by insights from social identity theory and social role theory, the study explores how hybrid work conditions the relationships among managerial behavior, fairness perceptions, employee wellbeing and workplace withdrawal. Design/methodology/approach: Using survey data collected from 432 employees working under varying degrees of hybrid work arrangements, the study tests a moderated model linking management style, favoritism, employee wellbeing and workplace withdrawal. The relationships are analyzed using partial least squares structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM), which allows the estimation of interaction effects within the proposed model. Findings: The findings show that hybrid work moderates key relational processes rather than exerting uniform effects. In particular, hybrid work weakens the negative association between favoritism and employee wellbeing, while strengthening the positive association between participative management style and wellbeing. In addition, hybrid work conditions the relationship between wellbeing and workplace withdrawal, with differing effects depending on employees’ level of wellbeing. Practical implications: By demonstrating that hybrid work reshapes, rather than eliminates, the effects of management style and favoritism, the study highlights the continuing importance of relational fairness and leadership quality for sustaining positive employee outcomes under hybrid work arrangements. Originality/value: This study extends research on hybrid work and leadership by positioning favoritism as a key relational mechanism linking management style to employee wellbeing and workplace withdrawal in hybrid work contexts.
- 21 July 2026
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Organizational Effectiveness: People and Performance
- p. 1-32
Hybrid work and relational dynamics: leadership, favoritism and employee outcomes
Purpose: This study examines how hybrid work reshapes relational dynamics within organizations by investigating how management style and perceived favoritism influence employee wellbeing and workplace withdrawal. Drawing on stewardship theory and leader–member exchange theory, complemented by insights from social identity theory and social role theory, the study explores how hybrid work conditions the relationships among managerial behavior, fairness perceptions, employee wellbeing and workplace withdrawal. Design/methodology/approach: Using survey data collected from 432 employees working under varying degrees of hybrid work arrangements, the study tests a moderated model linking management style, favoritism, employee wellbeing and workplace withdrawal. The relationships are analyzed using partial least squares structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM), which allows the estimation of interaction effects within the proposed model. Findings: The findings show that hybrid work moderates key relational processes rather than exerting uniform effects. In particular, hybrid work weakens the negative association between favoritism and employee wellbeing, while strengthening the positive association between participative management style and wellbeing. In addition, hybrid work conditions the relationship between wellbeing and workplace withdrawal, with differing effects depending on employees’ level of wellbeing. Practical implications: By demonstrating that hybrid work reshapes, rather than eliminates, the effects of management style and favoritism, the study highlights the continuing importance of relational fairness and leadership quality for sustaining positive employee outcomes under hybrid work arrangements. Originality/value: This study extends research on hybrid work and leadership by positioning favoritism as a key relational mechanism linking management style to employee wellbeing and workplace withdrawal in hybrid work contexts.
- Open Access
- 9 June 2026
- Published by MIT Press in Quantitative Science Studies
- Vol. 7, 1-70
Authorship inequality and elite dominance in management and organizational research: A review of six decades
Ideally, scholarly publishing should be fair, meritocratic, and inclusive of diverse groups of researchers. However, many disciplines, including management and organizational research (MOR), remain far from this ideal. We investigate the extent of authorship concentration across three closely related MOR subfields: Management (MNGT), Human Resource Management (HRM), and Industrial-Organizational Psychology (IOP), by analyzing 60-year publication trends across 42 top-tier journals, covering over 60,000 publications. The findings reveal growing authorship inequalities and a more pronounced dominance of a scientific elite. Specifically, a small group of researchers has accumulated disproportionate influence over time. IOP, in particular, exhibits more skewed disparities, with its most prolific scholars publishing significantly more than their counterparts in MNGT and HRM. Moreover, IOP shows greater recurrence of the same authors across journals’ top-10 most-published lists, indicating stronger elite dominance. Network analyses further reveal that IOP is characterized by a large, densely interconnected component, with many authors linked to the same tightly knit collaborative networks, unlike MNGT and HRM, which suggests that publishing success in IOP is more strongly associated with collaboration within a small scientific elite. We conclude by proposing changes in how diversity theorized across research, policy, and practice to address rising inequalities and promote a more inclusive research environment. Peer Review: https://www.webofscience.com/api/gateway/wos/peer-review/10.1162/QSS.a.492
- 9 June 2026
- Published by MIT Press in Quantitative Science Studies
- Vol. 7, 1-70
Open AccessAuthorship inequality and elite dominance in management and organizational research: A review of six decades
Ideally, scholarly publishing should be fair, meritocratic, and inclusive of diverse groups of researchers. However, many disciplines, including management and organizational research (MOR), remain far from this ideal. We investigate the extent of authorship concentration across three closely related MOR subfields: Management (MNGT), Human Resource Management (HRM), and Industrial-Organizational Psychology (IOP), by analyzing 60-year publication trends across 42 top-tier journals, covering over 60,000 publications. The findings reveal growing authorship inequalities and a more pronounced dominance of a scientific elite. Specifically, a small group of researchers has accumulated disproportionate influence over time. IOP, in particular, exhibits more skewed disparities, with its most prolific scholars publishing significantly more than their counterparts in MNGT and HRM. Moreover, IOP shows greater recurrence of the same authors across journals’ top-10 most-published lists, indicating stronger elite dominance. Network analyses further reveal that IOP is characterized by a large, densely interconnected component, with many authors linked to the same tightly knit collaborative networks, unlike MNGT and HRM, which suggests that publishing success in IOP is more strongly associated with collaboration within a small scientific elite. We conclude by proposing changes in how diversity theorized across research, policy, and practice to address rising inequalities and promote a more inclusive research environment. Peer Review: https://www.webofscience.com/api/gateway/wos/peer-review/10.1162/QSS.a.492
- Open Access
- 3 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Organization
Reproduction of form in Management and Organization Research: Why and how compulsively repetitive publishing kills academia
This paper analyzes academic research practice in Management and Organization Research drawing on the concept of reproduction of form. Reproduction of form refers to the continuous repetition of discourse shaped by authoritative ideology. While discourse originates from and is influenced by ideology, its performative meanings become increasingly ambiguous, paradoxical, and ultimately meaningless over time. We analyze the manifestation of reproduction of form by intertwining theory and empirical illustration from four top-tier management journals, and discuss two paradoxes relating to the emergence of reproduction of form. To further understand its functioning, we employ a psychoanalytic reading of reproduction of form and its inherent paradoxical nature. Freud’s repetition compulsion is used to understand why individuals engage in reproduction of form, while Lacan’s notion of the second death provides a framework to understand it from a collective perspective. Finally, we use Žižekian philosophy to understand individual and collective behavior through the notion of the undead . We conclude the paper by identifying how a parallax view, or taking a wholly different perspective, may deliver more constructive ways to convey academic knowledge and insights.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Organization
Open AccessReproduction of form in Management and Organization Research: Why and how compulsively repetitive publishing kills academia
This paper analyzes academic research practice in Management and Organization Research drawing on the concept of reproduction of form. Reproduction of form refers to the continuous repetition of discourse shaped by authoritative ideology. While discourse originates from and is influenced by ideology, its performative meanings become increasingly ambiguous, paradoxical, and ultimately meaningless over time. We analyze the manifestation of reproduction of form by intertwining theory and empirical illustration from four top-tier management journals, and discuss two paradoxes relating to the emergence of reproduction of form. To further understand its functioning, we employ a psychoanalytic reading of reproduction of form and its inherent paradoxical nature. Freud’s repetition compulsion is used to understand why individuals engage in reproduction of form, while Lacan’s notion of the second death provides a framework to understand it from a collective perspective. Finally, we use Žižekian philosophy to understand individual and collective behavior through the notion of the undead . We conclude the paper by identifying how a parallax view, or taking a wholly different perspective, may deliver more constructive ways to convey academic knowledge and insights.
- Open Access
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Authorship Inequality and Elite Dominance in Management and Organizational Research: A Review of Six Decades
Ideally, scholarly publishing should be fair, meritocratic, and inclusive of diverse groups of researchers. However, many disciplines, including management and organizational research (MOR), remain far from this ideal. We investigate the extent of authorship concentration in three closely related MOR subfields: Management (MNGT), Human Resource Management (HRM), and Industrial-Organizational Psychology (IOP), by analyzing 60-year publication trends across 42 top-tier journals, covering over 60,000 publications. The findings reveal growing authorship inequalities and a more noticeable dominance of a scientific elite. At the individual level, a small group of researchers has accumulated disproportionate influence over time. IOP, in particular, shows more skewed disparities, with its most productive scholars publishing significantly more than those in MNGT and HRM. Moreover, IOP shows a higher recurrence of the same authors in the top-10 most-published lists across journals, indicating more pronounced elite dominance. Network analyses further reveal that IOP is characterized by a large, densely interconnected component, with many authors linked to the same tightly knit collaborative networks, unlike MNGT and HRM. This suggests that publishing success in IOP is more strongly associated with collaboration within a small scientific elite. We conclude by proposing changes to the theorization of diversity across research, policy, and practice to address rising inequalities and ensure a more inclusive research environment.
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessAuthorship Inequality and Elite Dominance in Management and Organizational Research: A Review of Six Decades
Ideally, scholarly publishing should be fair, meritocratic, and inclusive of diverse groups of researchers. However, many disciplines, including management and organizational research (MOR), remain far from this ideal. We investigate the extent of authorship concentration in three closely related MOR subfields: Management (MNGT), Human Resource Management (HRM), and Industrial-Organizational Psychology (IOP), by analyzing 60-year publication trends across 42 top-tier journals, covering over 60,000 publications. The findings reveal growing authorship inequalities and a more noticeable dominance of a scientific elite. At the individual level, a small group of researchers has accumulated disproportionate influence over time. IOP, in particular, shows more skewed disparities, with its most productive scholars publishing significantly more than those in MNGT and HRM. Moreover, IOP shows a higher recurrence of the same authors in the top-10 most-published lists across journals, indicating more pronounced elite dominance. Network analyses further reveal that IOP is characterized by a large, densely interconnected component, with many authors linked to the same tightly knit collaborative networks, unlike MNGT and HRM. This suggests that publishing success in IOP is more strongly associated with collaboration within a small scientific elite. We conclude by proposing changes to the theorization of diversity across research, policy, and practice to address rising inequalities and ensure a more inclusive research environment.
- Open Access
- 19 February 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Authorship inequality and elite dominance in management and organizational research: A review of six decades
Ideally, scholarly publishing should be fair, meritocratic, and inclusive of diverse groupsof researchers. However, many disciplines, including management and organizational research(MOR), remain far from this ideal. We investigate the extent of authorship concentration in threeclosely related MOR subfields: Management (MNGT), Human Resource Management (HRM),and Industrial-Organizational Psychology (IOP), by analyzing 60-year publication trends across42 top-tier journals, covering over 60,000 publications. The findings reveal growing authorshipinequalities and a more noticeable dominance of a scientific elite. At the individual level, a smallgroup of researchers has accumulated disproportionate influence over time. IOP, in particular,shows more skewed disparities, with its most productive scholars publishing significantly morethan those in MNGT and HRM. Moreover, IOP shows a higher recurrence of the same authors inthe top-10 most-published lists across journals, indicating more pronounced elite dominance.Network analyses further reveal that IOP is characterized by a large, densely interconnectedcomponent, with many authors linked to the same tightly knit collaborative networks, unlikeMNGT and HRM. This suggests that publishing success in IOP is more strongly associated withcollaboration within a small scientific elite. We conclude by proposing changes to thetheorization of diversity across research, policy, and practice to address rising inequalities andensure a more inclusive research environment
- 19 February 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessAuthorship inequality and elite dominance in management and organizational research: A review of six decades
Ideally, scholarly publishing should be fair, meritocratic, and inclusive of diverse groupsof researchers. However, many disciplines, including management and organizational research(MOR), remain far from this ideal. We investigate the extent of authorship concentration in threeclosely related MOR subfields: Management (MNGT), Human Resource Management (HRM),and Industrial-Organizational Psychology (IOP), by analyzing 60-year publication trends across42 top-tier journals, covering over 60,000 publications. The findings reveal growing authorshipinequalities and a more noticeable dominance of a scientific elite. At the individual level, a smallgroup of researchers has accumulated disproportionate influence over time. IOP, in particular,shows more skewed disparities, with its most productive scholars publishing significantly morethan those in MNGT and HRM. Moreover, IOP shows a higher recurrence of the same authors inthe top-10 most-published lists across journals, indicating more pronounced elite dominance.Network analyses further reveal that IOP is characterized by a large, densely interconnectedcomponent, with many authors linked to the same tightly knit collaborative networks, unlikeMNGT and HRM. This suggests that publishing success in IOP is more strongly associated withcollaboration within a small scientific elite. We conclude by proposing changes to thetheorization of diversity across research, policy, and practice to address rising inequalities andensure a more inclusive research environment
- Open Access
- 14 January 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Vol. 18 (4) , 451-456
Animals laboring for humans: Integrating animal dignity into I-O psychology
Hernandez et al. (2025), in their focal article, have put the spotlight on the role of animals in I-O psychology. It is true that animals are neglected by I-O psychologists, who have traditionally focused on human beings in the workplace and how they feel, perceive, and behave. It is therefore of great importance to extend our reach and research to animals. In this piece, we raise the question how I-O psychology can theorize on animals in the workplace. In so doing, we advocate integrating a dignity perspective on animals (Bal, 2017; Challenger, 2003) into the field to postulate possible research questions and provide answers as to how I-O psychologists can relate to animals in the workplace. To understand how animals fit into workplace dynamics, it is crucial to broaden our conceptualization of work. Traditionally, work has been narrowly defined as paid, intentional human activity, often tied to formal employment with written contracts. However, recent scholarship in labor studies and human-animal relations challenges this anthropocentric view, advocating for a more inclusive understanding. Work can be defined as the contribution of labor, whether cognitive, emotional, physical, or biological, toward the production, maintenance, or reproduction of value (Porcher & Schmitt, 2012). This definition allows us to recognize animals as workers, not only when they perform visible service or assistance roles but also when their bodies themselves are the object and instrument of labor, such as in meat, dairy, and pharmaceutical industries. Reframing work in this way invites I-O psychologists to engage with the often-unseen labor of nonhuman agents. Moreover, animals are not passive tools but sentient beings with cognition, conscience, attitudes, and feelings (Challenger, 2023). Therefore, I-O psychologists should be concerned with animal workers in the same way they are concerned with human workers, as both contribute to work systems and are affected by the conditions under which they labor. Animals working for humans The primary argument of Hernandez et al. is that animals have long been used within workplaces, in various capacities and roles, such as livestock at farms, therapy animals, rescue dogs, or racing horses. Animals can be perceived as coworkers, who have feelings and attitudes, and as such are anthropomorphized, positioned akin to human beings, with feelings of joy, awe, compassion, or anxiety when integrated into the workplace. Such anthropomorphizing may be appropriate in the context of service dogs or truffle-hunting pigs but also overlooks another dimension of the role of
- 14 January 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Industrial and Organizational Psychology
- Vol. 18 (4) , 451-456
Open AccessAnimals laboring for humans: Integrating animal dignity into I-O psychology
Hernandez et al. (2025), in their focal article, have put the spotlight on the role of animals in I-O psychology. It is true that animals are neglected by I-O psychologists, who have traditionally focused on human beings in the workplace and how they feel, perceive, and behave. It is therefore of great importance to extend our reach and research to animals. In this piece, we raise the question how I-O psychology can theorize on animals in the workplace. In so doing, we advocate integrating a dignity perspective on animals (Bal, 2017; Challenger, 2003) into the field to postulate possible research questions and provide answers as to how I-O psychologists can relate to animals in the workplace. To understand how animals fit into workplace dynamics, it is crucial to broaden our conceptualization of work. Traditionally, work has been narrowly defined as paid, intentional human activity, often tied to formal employment with written contracts. However, recent scholarship in labor studies and human-animal relations challenges this anthropocentric view, advocating for a more inclusive understanding. Work can be defined as the contribution of labor, whether cognitive, emotional, physical, or biological, toward the production, maintenance, or reproduction of value (Porcher & Schmitt, 2012). This definition allows us to recognize animals as workers, not only when they perform visible service or assistance roles but also when their bodies themselves are the object and instrument of labor, such as in meat, dairy, and pharmaceutical industries. Reframing work in this way invites I-O psychologists to engage with the often-unseen labor of nonhuman agents. Moreover, animals are not passive tools but sentient beings with cognition, conscience, attitudes, and feelings (Challenger, 2023). Therefore, I-O psychologists should be concerned with animal workers in the same way they are concerned with human workers, as both contribute to work systems and are affected by the conditions under which they labor. Animals working for humans The primary argument of Hernandez et al. is that animals have long been used within workplaces, in various capacities and roles, such as livestock at farms, therapy animals, rescue dogs, or racing horses. Animals can be perceived as coworkers, who have feelings and attitudes, and as such are anthropomorphized, positioned akin to human beings, with feelings of joy, awe, compassion, or anxiety when integrated into the workplace. Such anthropomorphizing may be appropriate in the context of service dogs or truffle-hunting pigs but also overlooks another dimension of the role of