Diego San Mauro
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Diego San Mauro has a total of 112 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Rafael Zardoya
Departamento de Biodiversidad y Biología Evolutiva, Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales (MNCN-CSIC), José Gutiérrez Abascal 2, 28006 Madrid, Spain
63 shared publications - Iker Irisarri
Department of Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology, Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales (MNCN-CSIC), Madrid, Spain
25 shared publications Mark Wilkinson
Department of Life Sciences, The Natural History Museum, London, SW7 5BD, UK
15 shared publicationsDavid J. Gower
Department of Life Sciences, The Natural History Museum, London, SW7 5BD, UK
10 shared publications- Ainhoa Agorreta
Department of Biodiversity Ecology and Evolution, Faculty of Biological Sciences , Complutense University of Madrid, 28040 Madrid , Spain
9 shared publications - David J. Gower
Department of Zoology; Central University of Kerala; Tejaswini Hills; Kasaragod; Kerala; India.; Natural History Museum; London SW7 5BD; UK
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 July 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Genome Biology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (8)
Early Diversification of Membrane Intrinsic Proteins (MIPs) in Eukaryotes
Membrane intrinsic proteins (MIPs), including aquaporins (AQPs) and aquaglyceroporins (GLPs), form an ancient family of transporters for water and small solutes across biological membranes. The evolutionary history and functions of MIPs have been extensively studied in vertebrates and land plants, but their widespread presence across the eukaryotic tree of life suggests both a more complex evolutionary history and a broader set of functions than previously thought. That said, the early evolution of MIPs remains obscure. The presence of one GLP and four AQP clades across both bacteria and archaea suggests that the first eukaryotes could have possessed up to five MIPs. Here, we report on a previously unknown richness in MIP diversity across all major eukaryotic lineages, including unicellular eukaryotes, which make up the bulk of eukaryotic diversity. Three MIP clades have likely deep evolutionary origins, dating back to the last eukaryotic common ancestor (LECA), and support the presence of a complex MIP repertoire in early eukaryotes. Overall, our findings highlight the growing complexity of the reconstructed LECA genome: the dynamic evolutionary history of MIPs was set in motion when eukaryotes were in their infancy followed by radiative bursts across all main eukaryotic lineages.
- 26 July 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Genome Biology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (8)
Open AccessEarly Diversification of Membrane Intrinsic Proteins (MIPs) in Eukaryotes
Membrane intrinsic proteins (MIPs), including aquaporins (AQPs) and aquaglyceroporins (GLPs), form an ancient family of transporters for water and small solutes across biological membranes. The evolutionary history and functions of MIPs have been extensively studied in vertebrates and land plants, but their widespread presence across the eukaryotic tree of life suggests both a more complex evolutionary history and a broader set of functions than previously thought. That said, the early evolution of MIPs remains obscure. The presence of one GLP and four AQP clades across both bacteria and archaea suggests that the first eukaryotes could have possessed up to five MIPs. Here, we report on a previously unknown richness in MIP diversity across all major eukaryotic lineages, including unicellular eukaryotes, which make up the bulk of eukaryotic diversity. Three MIP clades have likely deep evolutionary origins, dating back to the last eukaryotic common ancestor (LECA), and support the presence of a complex MIP repertoire in early eukaryotes. Overall, our findings highlight the growing complexity of the reconstructed LECA genome: the dynamic evolutionary history of MIPs was set in motion when eukaryotes were in their infancy followed by radiative bursts across all main eukaryotic lineages.
- Open Access
Diversity and Molecular Evolution of Antimicrobial Peptides in Caecilian Amphibians
Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are key molecules in the innate immune defence of vertebrates with rapid action, broad antimicrobial spectrum, and ability to evade pathogen resistance mechanisms. To date, amphibians are the major group of vertebrates from which most AMPs have been characterised, but most studies have focused on the bioactive skin secretions of anurans (frogs and toads). In this study, we have analysed the complete genomes and/or transcriptomes of eight species of caecilian amphibians (order Gymnophiona) and characterised the diversity, molecular evolution, and antimicrobial potential of the AMP repertoire of this order of amphibians. We have identified 477 candidate AMPs within the studied caecilian genome and transcriptome datasets. These candidates are grouped into 29 AMP families, with four corresponding to peptides primarily exhibiting antimicrobial activity and 25 potentially serving as AMPs in a secondary function, either in their entirety or after cleavage. In silico prediction methods were used to identify 62 of those AMPs as peptides with promising antimicrobial activity potential. Signatures of directional selection were detected for five candidate AMPs, which may indicate adaptation to the different selective pressures imposed by evolutionary arms races with specific pathogens. These findings provide encouraging support for the expectation that caecilians, being one of the least-studied groups of vertebrates, and with ~300 million years of separate evolution, are an underexplored resource of great pharmaceutical potential that could help to contest antibiotic resistance and contribute to biomedical advance.
Open AccessDiversity and Molecular Evolution of Antimicrobial Peptides in Caecilian Amphibians
Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are key molecules in the innate immune defence of vertebrates with rapid action, broad antimicrobial spectrum, and ability to evade pathogen resistance mechanisms. To date, amphibians are the major group of vertebrates from which most AMPs have been characterised, but most studies have focused on the bioactive skin secretions of anurans (frogs and toads). In this study, we have analysed the complete genomes and/or transcriptomes of eight species of caecilian amphibians (order Gymnophiona) and characterised the diversity, molecular evolution, and antimicrobial potential of the AMP repertoire of this order of amphibians. We have identified 477 candidate AMPs within the studied caecilian genome and transcriptome datasets. These candidates are grouped into 29 AMP families, with four corresponding to peptides primarily exhibiting antimicrobial activity and 25 potentially serving as AMPs in a secondary function, either in their entirety or after cleavage. In silico prediction methods were used to identify 62 of those AMPs as peptides with promising antimicrobial activity potential. Signatures of directional selection were detected for five candidate AMPs, which may indicate adaptation to the different selective pressures imposed by evolutionary arms races with specific pathogens. These findings provide encouraging support for the expectation that caecilians, being one of the least-studied groups of vertebrates, and with ~300 million years of separate evolution, are an underexplored resource of great pharmaceutical potential that could help to contest antibiotic resistance and contribute to biomedical advance.
- Open Access
Multiple Instances of Adaptive Evolution in Aquaporins of Amphibious Fishes
Aquaporins (AQPs) are a highly diverse family of transmembrane proteins involved in osmotic regulation that played an important role in the conquest of land by tetrapods. However, little is known about their possible implication in the acquisition of an amphibious lifestyle in actinopterygian fishes. Herein, we investigated the molecular evolution of AQPs in 22 amphibious actinopterygian fishes by assembling a comprehensive dataset that was used to (1) catalogue AQP paralog members and classes; (2) determine the gene family birth and death process; (3) test for positive selection in a phylogenetic framework; and (4) reconstruct structural protein models. We found evidence of adaptive evolution in 21 AQPs belonging to 5 different classes. Almost half of the tree branches and protein sites that were under positive selection were found in the AQP11 class. The detected sequence changes indicate modifications in molecular function and/or structure, which could be related to adaptation to an amphibious lifestyle. AQP11 orthologues appear to be the most promising candidates to have facilitated the processes of the water-to-land transition in amphibious fishes. Additionally, the signature of positive selection found in the AQP11b stem branch of the Gobiidae clade suggests a possible case of exaptation in this clade.
Open AccessMultiple Instances of Adaptive Evolution in Aquaporins of Amphibious Fishes
Aquaporins (AQPs) are a highly diverse family of transmembrane proteins involved in osmotic regulation that played an important role in the conquest of land by tetrapods. However, little is known about their possible implication in the acquisition of an amphibious lifestyle in actinopterygian fishes. Herein, we investigated the molecular evolution of AQPs in 22 amphibious actinopterygian fishes by assembling a comprehensive dataset that was used to (1) catalogue AQP paralog members and classes; (2) determine the gene family birth and death process; (3) test for positive selection in a phylogenetic framework; and (4) reconstruct structural protein models. We found evidence of adaptive evolution in 21 AQPs belonging to 5 different classes. Almost half of the tree branches and protein sites that were under positive selection were found in the AQP11 class. The detected sequence changes indicate modifications in molecular function and/or structure, which could be related to adaptation to an amphibious lifestyle. AQP11 orthologues appear to be the most promising candidates to have facilitated the processes of the water-to-land transition in amphibious fishes. Additionally, the signature of positive selection found in the AQP11b stem branch of the Gobiidae clade suggests a possible case of exaptation in this clade.
- 12 May 2023
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of A genomic timescale for placental mammal evolution.
This study presents the most comprehensive phylogeny of placental mammals thus far. The authors have analyzed 241 whole genomes of all placental mammal orders, representing 62% of placental families. Using both coalescent- and concatenated-based approaches, they have reconstructed a highly robust phylogeny that recovers the major groups Xenarthra, Afrotheria, and Boreoeutheria. Within the latter, Laurasiatheria and Euarchontoglires are found. High support for Euarchonta, Glires, Scrotifera, Fereungulata and Zooamata resolved previous controversies at the supraordinal level {1}. To avoid potential phylogenetic biases (particularly recombination), the authors concentrated on nearly neutral non-coding sites across a broad range of karyotype attributes in chromosomes 1, 21, 22, and X. The reconstructed phylogenetic relationships were further supported with rare genomic changes such as deletions larger than 10bp in size and phylogenetically-informative chromosome breakpoints. A timetree using 37 soft-bounded fossil calibrations placed the origin of placentals at about 102 million years ago {2}. Superordinal divergences occurred almost entirely in the Late Cretaceous due to breakup of continental masses and rising sea levels that promoted allopatry. Intraordinal divergences occurred rapidly after the Cretaceous-Paleocene extinction event {3}. As more high quality genomes are sequenced and assembled throughout the Tree of Life, the present phylogenomic approach ensures high levels of resolution and the end of many historical controversies.
- 12 May 2023
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of A genomic timescale for placental mammal evolution.
This study presents the most comprehensive phylogeny of placental mammals thus far. The authors have analyzed 241 whole genomes of all placental mammal orders, representing 62% of placental families. Using both coalescent- and concatenated-based approaches, they have reconstructed a highly robust phylogeny that recovers the major groups Xenarthra, Afrotheria, and Boreoeutheria. Within the latter, Laurasiatheria and Euarchontoglires are found. High support for Euarchonta, Glires, Scrotifera, Fereungulata and Zooamata resolved previous controversies at the supraordinal level {1}. To avoid potential phylogenetic biases (particularly recombination), the authors concentrated on nearly neutral non-coding sites across a broad range of karyotype attributes in chromosomes 1, 21, 22, and X. The reconstructed phylogenetic relationships were further supported with rare genomic changes such as deletions larger than 10bp in size and phylogenetically-informative chromosome breakpoints. A timetree using 37 soft-bounded fossil calibrations placed the origin of placentals at about 102 million years ago {2}. Superordinal divergences occurred almost entirely in the Late Cretaceous due to breakup of continental masses and rising sea levels that promoted allopatry. Intraordinal divergences occurred rapidly after the Cretaceous-Paleocene extinction event {3}. As more high quality genomes are sequenced and assembled throughout the Tree of Life, the present phylogenomic approach ensures high levels of resolution and the end of many historical controversies.
- 5 November 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of Global patterns and rates of habitat transitions across the eukaryotic tree of life.
The colonization of new habitats is challenging and often requires multiple adaptations, but it can also open up new ecological niches and boost diversification. In this study, Jamy and colleagues explore the patterns, rates, and directions in which eukaryotes have transitioned between marine (deep or shallow), freshwater, and terrestrial environments during their ~2 billion years of evolution. To do so, the authors employ a phylogeny-based approach based on long-read metabarcoding of the rDNA operon, which has proven efficient for characterizing eukaryotic microbial diversity from environmental samples {1} that circumvent the limitations of traditional culture-based sequencing. This focus on microbial eukaryotes is necessary since they represent most of the diversity and evolutionary history of this group. The long-read metabarcoding data produced a resolved phylogenetic backbone that was supplemented with partial 18S data to increase species and habitat sampling. Using this dataset, the authors show that the transitions between marine and non-marine environments are rarer than those between freshwater and soil or between aphotic and euphotic marine zones. A conservative estimate is ~350 total transitions between marine and non-marine habitats and these show a heterogeneous distribution across eukaryotes. There is up to a 200-fold difference in the rates at which the various eukaryotic lineages have transitioned across the salt barrier, and the directionality of this transition is also highly lineage-dependent. Fungi crossed the salt barrier most frequently (72 transitions), followed by cryptophytes and gyristans (Stramenopiles), whereas bigyrans (Stamenopiles) and apicomplexans are among those that least frequently switched between these environments. One of the most remarkable findings is the non-marine origin of eukaryotes, as supported by the ancestral habitat reconstructed for the last eukaryotic common ancestor (LECA). These analyses further support an early habitat transition given that Amorphea and TSAR – two deep eukaryotic lineages that harbor most of the diversity – are inferred to ancestrally occur in freshwater/soil or marine environments, respectively. The authors propose that the early marine transition of the TSAR ancestor could have boosted its diversification. Macroevolutionary inferences of such diverse and evolutionarily ancient groups are not without challenge, as obtaining comprehensive taxon sampling remains virtually impossible. On the other hand, the number of extant species that can be analyzed is limited by experimental and analytical reasons, but more importantly, the majority of eukaryotic diversity is hidden from us by the rampant extinction that wiped out large parts of the eukaryotic tree of life. The type of dataset built by Jamy et al. is perhaps our best chance to approximate this complex topic, as it combines phylogenetic signal and taxonomic and environmental representation. The effect of extinction and taxon sampling is explored in multiple analyses, and the limits of the dataset are also clearly stated. Given the complexity of the question, we might never reach a consensus of a specific number of habitat transitions in eukaryotes, but this study puts forward several robust general patterns and suggestive findings that bring new light to our understanding of eukaryotic evolution and of major habitat transitions.
- 5 November 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of Global patterns and rates of habitat transitions across the eukaryotic tree of life.
The colonization of new habitats is challenging and often requires multiple adaptations, but it can also open up new ecological niches and boost diversification. In this study, Jamy and colleagues explore the patterns, rates, and directions in which eukaryotes have transitioned between marine (deep or shallow), freshwater, and terrestrial environments during their ~2 billion years of evolution. To do so, the authors employ a phylogeny-based approach based on long-read metabarcoding of the rDNA operon, which has proven efficient for characterizing eukaryotic microbial diversity from environmental samples {1} that circumvent the limitations of traditional culture-based sequencing. This focus on microbial eukaryotes is necessary since they represent most of the diversity and evolutionary history of this group. The long-read metabarcoding data produced a resolved phylogenetic backbone that was supplemented with partial 18S data to increase species and habitat sampling. Using this dataset, the authors show that the transitions between marine and non-marine environments are rarer than those between freshwater and soil or between aphotic and euphotic marine zones. A conservative estimate is ~350 total transitions between marine and non-marine habitats and these show a heterogeneous distribution across eukaryotes. There is up to a 200-fold difference in the rates at which the various eukaryotic lineages have transitioned across the salt barrier, and the directionality of this transition is also highly lineage-dependent. Fungi crossed the salt barrier most frequently (72 transitions), followed by cryptophytes and gyristans (Stramenopiles), whereas bigyrans (Stamenopiles) and apicomplexans are among those that least frequently switched between these environments. One of the most remarkable findings is the non-marine origin of eukaryotes, as supported by the ancestral habitat reconstructed for the last eukaryotic common ancestor (LECA). These analyses further support an early habitat transition given that Amorphea and TSAR – two deep eukaryotic lineages that harbor most of the diversity – are inferred to ancestrally occur in freshwater/soil or marine environments, respectively. The authors propose that the early marine transition of the TSAR ancestor could have boosted its diversification. Macroevolutionary inferences of such diverse and evolutionarily ancient groups are not without challenge, as obtaining comprehensive taxon sampling remains virtually impossible. On the other hand, the number of extant species that can be analyzed is limited by experimental and analytical reasons, but more importantly, the majority of eukaryotic diversity is hidden from us by the rampant extinction that wiped out large parts of the eukaryotic tree of life. The type of dataset built by Jamy et al. is perhaps our best chance to approximate this complex topic, as it combines phylogenetic signal and taxonomic and environmental representation. The effect of extinction and taxon sampling is explored in multiple analyses, and the limits of the dataset are also clearly stated. Given the complexity of the question, we might never reach a consensus of a specific number of habitat transitions in eukaryotes, but this study puts forward several robust general patterns and suggestive findings that bring new light to our understanding of eukaryotic evolution and of major habitat transitions.
- 15 September 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of Comparative genomics of mortal and immortal cnidarians unveils novel keys behind rejuvenation.
The sequencing and comparative characterization of genome data has become routine for a growing number of organisms {1}. It is undeniable that every single organism has particularities and intrinsic interest, but perhaps one with a certainly unique and very remarkable biological feature is the immortal cnidarian Turritopsis dohrnii. This is the only known animal with the ability to rejuvenate indefinitely by experiencing ontogeny (life cycle) reversals after sexual reproduction, thus becoming biologically immortal. In this study, Pascual-Torner and co-authors report the draft sequence and comparative analysis of the genome of T. dohrnii, as well as that of closely-related (but non-immortal) Turritopsis rubra. Their results identify specific variants (sequence or copy number variants) in candidate genes or pathways related to aging mechanisms. Among these, and compared to other cnidarians, T. dohrnii likely has: (1) better machinery of DNA replication and repair by having extra copies of polymerase genes POLD1 and POLA2, (2) more efficient response to oxidative stress by extra copies of thioredoxin (TXN) and glutathione reductase (GSR), and (3) reduced telomere attrition by an extra copy of ribonucleoprotein GAR1 as well as a specific sequence change at a conserved position in POT1 gene, thus yielding enhanced cellular plasticity. Other variant highlights in T. dohrnii include also candidate genes or pathways affecting stem cell senescence and exhaustion (duplication of transcription factor gene GLI3 that likely improves stem cell function) and intercellular communication and apoptosis (expansion of BMP7 copies possibly affecting apoptosis modulation). As the authors acknowledge themselves, future refinements and depuration of the genome draft sequence, as well as further comparative analyses (including expansion of the taxon sampling of Turritopsis species) are still needed. Nonetheless, the findings of this study are certainly significant to better understand the mechanisms of biological immortality in animals, as well as its potential applications.
- 15 September 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of Comparative genomics of mortal and immortal cnidarians unveils novel keys behind rejuvenation.
The sequencing and comparative characterization of genome data has become routine for a growing number of organisms {1}. It is undeniable that every single organism has particularities and intrinsic interest, but perhaps one with a certainly unique and very remarkable biological feature is the immortal cnidarian Turritopsis dohrnii. This is the only known animal with the ability to rejuvenate indefinitely by experiencing ontogeny (life cycle) reversals after sexual reproduction, thus becoming biologically immortal. In this study, Pascual-Torner and co-authors report the draft sequence and comparative analysis of the genome of T. dohrnii, as well as that of closely-related (but non-immortal) Turritopsis rubra. Their results identify specific variants (sequence or copy number variants) in candidate genes or pathways related to aging mechanisms. Among these, and compared to other cnidarians, T. dohrnii likely has: (1) better machinery of DNA replication and repair by having extra copies of polymerase genes POLD1 and POLA2, (2) more efficient response to oxidative stress by extra copies of thioredoxin (TXN) and glutathione reductase (GSR), and (3) reduced telomere attrition by an extra copy of ribonucleoprotein GAR1 as well as a specific sequence change at a conserved position in POT1 gene, thus yielding enhanced cellular plasticity. Other variant highlights in T. dohrnii include also candidate genes or pathways affecting stem cell senescence and exhaustion (duplication of transcription factor gene GLI3 that likely improves stem cell function) and intercellular communication and apoptosis (expansion of BMP7 copies possibly affecting apoptosis modulation). As the authors acknowledge themselves, future refinements and depuration of the genome draft sequence, as well as further comparative analyses (including expansion of the taxon sampling of Turritopsis species) are still needed. Nonetheless, the findings of this study are certainly significant to better understand the mechanisms of biological immortality in animals, as well as its potential applications.
- 24 June 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of Mixing genome annotation methods in a comparative analysis inflates the apparent number of lineage-specific genes.
Comparative genomics is an increasingly important field in the current era of high-quality genome data generation. Structural genome annotation, i.e. identifying which genes are present and where, remains one of the most challenging analytical bottlenecks, and several bioinformatic pipelines have been proposed to this end. The choice of annotation pipeline can have dramatic effects on structural annotation {1,2}, but there is a lack of general rules for deciding on the best method. Consequently, annotation methods are often handpicked a priori, or multiple annotations are compared and/or merged, yielding substantial differences among the genomes that become publicly available. In this study, Weisman and co-authors investigate the effect of different annotation methods on comparative genomics outcomes. Specifically, they focus on lineage-specific genes that are restricted to a single species or group (i.e. clade). Such lineage-specific genes have sometimes been proposed to represent genetic novelties associated with unique adaptations of the lineage and to often emerge de novo from non-coding DNA (e.g. {3}). This study shows that a majority of the putative lineage-specific genes found (on average more than half, sometimes up to a 15-fold increase) actually derive from the fact that different methods were used to annotate the genomes. To further explore this, the authors select four groups of organisms (cichlid fishes, bats, primates, and rodents) for which at least two sets of annotations are publicly available and infer lineage-specific genes for increasingly broad clades, combining homogeneous vs. heterogeneous annotations in three different combinations. The proportion of lineage-specific genes is highest (from 1.4- to 15-fold) when one annotation method was used for all the ingroup species and another was used for all the outgroups, whereas this effect is smallest when annotation methods are heterogeneous in the focal lineage, other ingroup taxa, and the outgroup (from almost no changes to a maximum of 5.7-fold). This study raises concern about the artifactual inference of lineage-specific genes and their possible link to lineage-specific adaptations. More generally, it forces us to critically consider available genome annotations and to incorporate additional verification steps when performing comparative genomics. The authors propose that a simple sequence similarity search against six-frame translations of all open reading frames (ORFs) in the other genomes can easily reduce spurious lineage-specific genes to below the levels inferred with uniform annotations (often below 100). As stated by the authors, other challenges remain for comparative genomics, including the limitations of current sequence similarity and hidden Markov model (HMM) profile methods to detect homology. Another important aspect that merits further exploration is the annotation heterogeneity that derives from the use of different evidence for gene model annotations, and specifically the use of RNAseq datasets with varying degrees of source diversity (from different tissues, developmental stages, environmental conditions, etc.).
- 24 June 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of Mixing genome annotation methods in a comparative analysis inflates the apparent number of lineage-specific genes.
Comparative genomics is an increasingly important field in the current era of high-quality genome data generation. Structural genome annotation, i.e. identifying which genes are present and where, remains one of the most challenging analytical bottlenecks, and several bioinformatic pipelines have been proposed to this end. The choice of annotation pipeline can have dramatic effects on structural annotation {1,2}, but there is a lack of general rules for deciding on the best method. Consequently, annotation methods are often handpicked a priori, or multiple annotations are compared and/or merged, yielding substantial differences among the genomes that become publicly available. In this study, Weisman and co-authors investigate the effect of different annotation methods on comparative genomics outcomes. Specifically, they focus on lineage-specific genes that are restricted to a single species or group (i.e. clade). Such lineage-specific genes have sometimes been proposed to represent genetic novelties associated with unique adaptations of the lineage and to often emerge de novo from non-coding DNA (e.g. {3}). This study shows that a majority of the putative lineage-specific genes found (on average more than half, sometimes up to a 15-fold increase) actually derive from the fact that different methods were used to annotate the genomes. To further explore this, the authors select four groups of organisms (cichlid fishes, bats, primates, and rodents) for which at least two sets of annotations are publicly available and infer lineage-specific genes for increasingly broad clades, combining homogeneous vs. heterogeneous annotations in three different combinations. The proportion of lineage-specific genes is highest (from 1.4- to 15-fold) when one annotation method was used for all the ingroup species and another was used for all the outgroups, whereas this effect is smallest when annotation methods are heterogeneous in the focal lineage, other ingroup taxa, and the outgroup (from almost no changes to a maximum of 5.7-fold). This study raises concern about the artifactual inference of lineage-specific genes and their possible link to lineage-specific adaptations. More generally, it forces us to critically consider available genome annotations and to incorporate additional verification steps when performing comparative genomics. The authors propose that a simple sequence similarity search against six-frame translations of all open reading frames (ORFs) in the other genomes can easily reduce spurious lineage-specific genes to below the levels inferred with uniform annotations (often below 100). As stated by the authors, other challenges remain for comparative genomics, including the limitations of current sequence similarity and hidden Markov model (HMM) profile methods to detect homology. Another important aspect that merits further exploration is the annotation heterogeneity that derives from the use of different evidence for gene model annotations, and specifically the use of RNAseq datasets with varying degrees of source diversity (from different tissues, developmental stages, environmental conditions, etc.).
- 27 May 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of A species-level timeline of mammal evolution integrating phylogenomic data.
The ever-increasing pace at which genome sequences are determined provides an unprecedented opportunity for better phylogenetic and molecular dating, yet application at the genomic scale remains challenging. In this paper, Álvarez-Carretero and co-authors test a new two-step approach for Bayesian molecular clock dating that can effectively analyze large (taxon- and gene-rich) genomic datasets. The method is illustrated using the placental mammals, whose divergence times and associated macroevolutionary patterns have remained contentious, particularly with regards to their possible diversification occurring before, during, or after the End-Cretaceous massive extinction {1}. The new two-step approach begins with the inference of a dated phylogeny with many genes and fewer species (72 taxa, 15K loci, 32 fossil calibrations). The resulting age estimates (and uncertainties) are used, together with 60 additional fossil calibrations, to constrain 13 subtrees with many taxa and fewer loci (almost 5000 species and ~200 loci). An important aspect is the use of non-overlapping loci in the two steps, which is important in Bayesian statistics. The authors show that genomic data has the ability to increase the precision of molecular clock analyses. They further indicate that future improvements are unlikely to occur through just the addition of genomic data, but instead through the use of more and better fossil calibrations. The authors conduct a comparison of two commonly used relaxed molecular clock models (auto- vs. uncorrelated) and find strong support for the presence of rate autocorrelation. In contrast to the impact of the assumed molecular clock model, different resolutions of controversial topological relationships in the mammal tree have little effect on the inferred ages, probably because they correspond to short tree branches. From an evolutionary viewpoint, the new timeline of mammalian evolution finds overall younger ages than previous Bayesian dating studies that used smaller datasets. The divergence of most mammal orders occurred near the K-Pg boundary, thus being compatible with the soft explosive or long fuse models of placental mammal evolution {1}, which place their diversification after this massive extinction event. Alternative scenarios such as the deep-Cretaceous origin of mammal orders or the Paleogene origin of placentals are not compatible. The proposed two-step Bayesian molecular dating is a promising approach for genome-scale studies aiming to estimate divergence times with high precision, as it considerably speeds up the analyses and reduces computation times.
- 27 May 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of A species-level timeline of mammal evolution integrating phylogenomic data.
The ever-increasing pace at which genome sequences are determined provides an unprecedented opportunity for better phylogenetic and molecular dating, yet application at the genomic scale remains challenging. In this paper, Álvarez-Carretero and co-authors test a new two-step approach for Bayesian molecular clock dating that can effectively analyze large (taxon- and gene-rich) genomic datasets. The method is illustrated using the placental mammals, whose divergence times and associated macroevolutionary patterns have remained contentious, particularly with regards to their possible diversification occurring before, during, or after the End-Cretaceous massive extinction {1}. The new two-step approach begins with the inference of a dated phylogeny with many genes and fewer species (72 taxa, 15K loci, 32 fossil calibrations). The resulting age estimates (and uncertainties) are used, together with 60 additional fossil calibrations, to constrain 13 subtrees with many taxa and fewer loci (almost 5000 species and ~200 loci). An important aspect is the use of non-overlapping loci in the two steps, which is important in Bayesian statistics. The authors show that genomic data has the ability to increase the precision of molecular clock analyses. They further indicate that future improvements are unlikely to occur through just the addition of genomic data, but instead through the use of more and better fossil calibrations. The authors conduct a comparison of two commonly used relaxed molecular clock models (auto- vs. uncorrelated) and find strong support for the presence of rate autocorrelation. In contrast to the impact of the assumed molecular clock model, different resolutions of controversial topological relationships in the mammal tree have little effect on the inferred ages, probably because they correspond to short tree branches. From an evolutionary viewpoint, the new timeline of mammalian evolution finds overall younger ages than previous Bayesian dating studies that used smaller datasets. The divergence of most mammal orders occurred near the K-Pg boundary, thus being compatible with the soft explosive or long fuse models of placental mammal evolution {1}, which place their diversification after this massive extinction event. Alternative scenarios such as the deep-Cretaceous origin of mammal orders or the Paleogene origin of placentals are not compatible. The proposed two-step Bayesian molecular dating is a promising approach for genome-scale studies aiming to estimate divergence times with high precision, as it considerably speeds up the analyses and reduces computation times.
- 15 March 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of Placing Ancient DNA Sequences into Reference Phylogenies.
The rapid generation of DNA sequence data for an increasing number of samples posses a challenge as to how best integrate the new information into larger, reference phylogenies already available in the literature or online resources {1,2}. In the particular case of ancient DNA (aDNA), technical issues (often leading to artifacts) are magnified by its intrinsic higher degradation that leads frequently to very low coverage, deamination or large amounts of missing data {3}. In this paper, Martiniano and colleagues present pathPhynder, a software workflow specifically designed to place newly-generated aDNA data into present-day phylogenies, taking into account intrinsic low-coverage or deamination issues. The workflow can be applied to any non-recombining data type (Y-chromosome, mitogenome) and generally outperforms comparable available tools, such as Haplogrouper {4} or Evolutionary Placement Algorithm {1}. Both BAM or VCF files can be used as input in pathPhynder, and a first step of the workflow aims for the assignment of informative SNPs to each branch of the reference phylogeny. Once this is accomplished, there are two alternative methods for sequence placement: the best path method (faster, but less accurate), and maximum likelihood (slower, but more accurate). The authors test the utility of pathPhynder (and the performance against similar programs) by using a newly compiled dataset of Y-chromosome variants (120,908 curated SNPs for 2014 individuals), as well as by improving lineage resolution of low-coverage samples catalogued in the database of the International Society of Genetic Genealogy (ISOGG). Furthermore, and to demonstrate the potential of the workflow methodology for real data, a comprehensive analysis of Y-chromosome variation and diversity in African human populations (ancient and present-day) is conducted, using recently-published data from the literature. The result of this analysis shows examples of genetic continuity in South African lineages that contrast with relative replacement (discontinuity) in some North African lineages. Altogether, pathPhynder stands as a powerful tool for sequence placement in reference phylogenies, potentially even including those of environmental DNA studies.
- 15 March 2022
- Published by H1 Connect
Faculty Opinions recommendation of Placing Ancient DNA Sequences into Reference Phylogenies.
The rapid generation of DNA sequence data for an increasing number of samples posses a challenge as to how best integrate the new information into larger, reference phylogenies already available in the literature or online resources {1,2}. In the particular case of ancient DNA (aDNA), technical issues (often leading to artifacts) are magnified by its intrinsic higher degradation that leads frequently to very low coverage, deamination or large amounts of missing data {3}. In this paper, Martiniano and colleagues present pathPhynder, a software workflow specifically designed to place newly-generated aDNA data into present-day phylogenies, taking into account intrinsic low-coverage or deamination issues. The workflow can be applied to any non-recombining data type (Y-chromosome, mitogenome) and generally outperforms comparable available tools, such as Haplogrouper {4} or Evolutionary Placement Algorithm {1}. Both BAM or VCF files can be used as input in pathPhynder, and a first step of the workflow aims for the assignment of informative SNPs to each branch of the reference phylogeny. Once this is accomplished, there are two alternative methods for sequence placement: the best path method (faster, but less accurate), and maximum likelihood (slower, but more accurate). The authors test the utility of pathPhynder (and the performance against similar programs) by using a newly compiled dataset of Y-chromosome variants (120,908 curated SNPs for 2014 individuals), as well as by improving lineage resolution of low-coverage samples catalogued in the database of the International Society of Genetic Genealogy (ISOGG). Furthermore, and to demonstrate the potential of the workflow methodology for real data, a comprehensive analysis of Y-chromosome variation and diversity in African human populations (ancient and present-day) is conducted, using recently-published data from the literature. The result of this analysis shows examples of genetic continuity in South African lineages that contrast with relative replacement (discontinuity) in some North African lineages. Altogether, pathPhynder stands as a powerful tool for sequence placement in reference phylogenies, potentially even including those of environmental DNA studies.
- Open Access
- 7 March 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Methods and Protocols
- Vol. 5 (2) , 26
Genomic Fishing and Data Processing for Molecular Evolution Research
Molecular evolution analyses, such as detection of adaptive/purifying selection or ancestral protein reconstruction, typically require three inputs for a target gene (or gene family) in a particular group of organisms: sequence alignment, model of evolution, and phylogenetic tree. While modern advances in high-throughput sequencing techniques have led to rapid accumulation of genomic-scale data in public repositories and databases, mining such vast amount of information often remains a challenging enterprise. Here, we describe a comprehensive, versatile workflow aimed at the preparation of genome-extracted datasets readily available for molecular evolution research. The workflow involves: (1) fishing (searching and capturing) specific gene sequences of interest from taxonomically diverse genomic data available in databases at variable levels of annotation, (2) processing and depuration of retrieved sequences, (3) production of a multiple sequence alignment, (4) selection of best-fit model of evolution, and (5) solid reconstruction of a phylogenetic tree.
- 7 March 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Methods and Protocols
- Vol. 5 (2) , 26
Open AccessGenomic Fishing and Data Processing for Molecular Evolution Research
Molecular evolution analyses, such as detection of adaptive/purifying selection or ancestral protein reconstruction, typically require three inputs for a target gene (or gene family) in a particular group of organisms: sequence alignment, model of evolution, and phylogenetic tree. While modern advances in high-throughput sequencing techniques have led to rapid accumulation of genomic-scale data in public repositories and databases, mining such vast amount of information often remains a challenging enterprise. Here, we describe a comprehensive, versatile workflow aimed at the preparation of genome-extracted datasets readily available for molecular evolution research. The workflow involves: (1) fishing (searching and capturing) specific gene sequences of interest from taxonomically diverse genomic data available in databases at variable levels of annotation, (2) processing and depuration of retrieved sequences, (3) production of a multiple sequence alignment, (4) selection of best-fit model of evolution, and (5) solid reconstruction of a phylogenetic tree.