COClaudia Ottardi

Claudia Ottardi

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Claudia Ottardi has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Residual Stresses in Titanium Spinal Rods: Effects of Two Contouring Methods and Material Plastic Properties

    by Francesca Berti, Luigi La Barbera, Agnese Piovesan, Dario Allegretti, Claudia Ottardi, Tomaso Villa, Giancarlo Pennati

    Posterior spinal fixation based on long spinal rods is the clinical gold standard for the treatment of severe deformities. Rods need to be contoured prior to implantation to fit the natural curvature of the spine. The contouring processes is known to introduce residual stresses and strains which affect the static and fatigue mechanical response of the implant, as determined through time- and cost-consuming experimental tests. Finite element (FE) models promise to provide an immediate understanding on residual stresses and strains within a contoured spinal rods and a further insight on their complex distribution. This study aims at investigating two rod contouring strategies, French bender (FB) contouring (clinical gold standard), and uniform contouring, through validated FE models. A careful characterization of the elastoplastic material response of commercial implants is led. Compared to uniform contouring, FB induces highly localized plasticizations in compression under the contouring pin with extensive lateral sections undergoing tensile residual stresses. The sensitivity analysis highlighted that the assumed postyielding properties significantly affect the numerical predictions; therefore, an accurate material characterization is recommended.


  • Open Access

    A comparative analysis of a disposable and a reusable pedicle screw instrument kit for lumbar arthrodesis: integrating HTA and MCDA

    by Claudia Ottardi, Alessio Damonti, Emanuele Porazzi, Emanuela Foglia, Lucrezia Ferrario, Tomaso Villa, Enrico Aimar, Marco Brayda-Bruno, Fabio Galbusera

    Lumbar arthrodesis is a common surgical technique that consists of the fixation of one or more motion segments with pedicle screws and rods. However, spinal surgery using these techniques is expensive and has a significant impact on the budgets of hospitals and Healthcare Systems. While reusable and disposable instruments for laparoscopic interventions have been studied in literature, no specific information exists regarding instrument kits for lumbar arthrodesis. The aim of the present study was to perform a complete health technology assessment comparing a disposable instrument kit for lumbar arthrodesis (innovative device) with the standard reusable instrument. A prospective and observational study was implemented, by means of investigation of administrative records of patients undergoing a lumbar arthrodesis surgical procedure. The evaluation was conducted in 2013, over a 12- month time horizon, considering all the procedures carried out using the two technologies. A complete health technology assessment and a multi-criteria decision analysis approach were implemented in order to compare the two alternative technologies. Economic impact (with the implementation of an activity based costing approach), social, ethical, organisational, and technology-related aspects were taken into account. Although the cost analysis produced similar results in the comparison of the two technologies (total cost equal to € 4,279.1 and € 4,242.6 for reusable instrument kit and the disposable one respectively), a significant difference between the two instrument kits was noted, in particular concerning the organisational impact and the patient safety. The replacement of a reusable instrument kit for lumbar arthrodesis, with a disposable one, could improve the management of this kind of devices in hospital settings.


  • Anterior support reduces the stresses on the posterior instrumentation after pedicle subtraction osteotomy: a finite-element study

    by Andrea Luca, Claudia Ottardi, Alessio Lovi, Marco Brayda-Bruno, Tomaso Villa, Fabio Galbusera

    The investigation was based on finite-element simulations.


  • Open Access

    Semiautomated 3D Spine Reconstruction from Biplanar Radiographic Images: Prediction of Intervertebral Loading in Scoliotic Subjects

    by Tito Bassani, Claudia Ottardi, Francesco Costa, Marco Brayda-Bruno, Hans-Joachim Wilke, Fabio Galbusera

    The present study proposes a semi-automatic software approach to reconstruct 3D subject-specific musculoskeletal model of thoraco-lumbar spine from radiographic digitized images acquired with EOS system. The approach is applied to evaluate the intervertebral loads in 38 standing adolescents with mild idiopathic scoliosis. For each vertebra a set of landmarks was manually identified on radiographic images. Coordinates were processed calculating vertebral configuration in 3D space: i) location; ii) dimensions; iii) rotations. Spherical joints simulated discs, ligaments and facet joints. Body weight distribution, muscles forces and insertion points were placed according to physiologic-anatomical values. Inverse static analysis, calculating joints reactions in maintaining assigned spine configuration, was performed with AnyBody software. Reaction forces were computed to quantify intervertebral loads and correlation with the patient anatomical parameters was then checked. Preliminary validation was performed comparing the model outcomes with that obtained from other authors in previous modelling works and from in vivo measurements. The comparison with previous modelling works and in vivo studies partially fulfilled the preliminary validation purpose. However, minor incongruities were pointed out that need further investigations. The subjects intervertebral loads were found significantly correlated with the anatomical parameters in the sagittal and axial planes. Despite preliminary encouraging results that support model suitability, future investigations to consolidate the proposed approach are necessary. Nonetheless, the present method appears to be a promising tool that once fully validated could allow the subject-specific non-invasive evaluation of a deformed spine, providing supplementary information to the routine clinical examination and surgical intervention planning.


  • Instrumentation failure following pedicle subtraction osteotomy: the role of rod material, diameter, and multi-rod constructs

    by Andrea Luca, Claudia Ottardi, Maurizio Sasso, Liliana Prosdocimo, Luigi La Barbera, Marco Brayda-Bruno, Fabio Galbusera, Tomaso Villa

    Pedicle subtraction osteotomy (PSO) has a complication rate noticeably higher than other corrective surgical techniques used for the treatment of spinal sagittal imbalance. In particular, rod breakage and pseudoarthrosis remain burning issues of this technique. Goal of this study was to investigate the biomechanical performance of several hardware constructs. The study was performed using two validated finite element models of the lumbosacral spine (L1–S1) incorporating a PSO on L3 and L4, respectively. Both models were instrumented two levels above and below the osteotomy site. Different combinations of materials (Ti6Al4V and Cr–Co) and device configurations (bilateral single vs. double rod, rod diameters of 5 and 6 mm) were investigated. The loading was represented considering a force of 500 N (imposed along the spinal curvature and connecting the vertebral bodies) and pure moments of 7.5 Nm in flexion-extension, lateral bending and axial rotation. The results were evaluated in terms of range of motion (ROM), load, and stresses acting on the instrumentation. A comparable ROM was found for all the models. The simulations showed a different behavior of the devices: increasing the stiffness an 8–19% increase of the load was calculated on the rod. However, the stress on the instrumentation resulted higher on Cr–Co devices and on smaller rods. The highest stress reduction (up to 50%) was ensured using double rod constructs. The bilateral double parallel rods configuration resulted the best to reduce the stresses on the spinal fixators at the osteotomy site. However, the high loads acting on the rods with respect to the physiologic condition could slow down the bone healing at the osteotomy site.


  • Open Access

    Vertebroplasty and Kyphoplasty for the Treatment of Thoracic Fractures in Osteoporotic Patients: A Finite Element Comparative Analysis

    by Claudia Ottardi, Luigi La Barbera, Luca Pietrogrande, Tomaso Villa

    Background: Vertebral compression fractures occur in the thoracolumbar junction, causing the collapse of the vertebral body. For their treatment, vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty are used, but it is still unknown which technique is to be preferred. Methods: Finite element models of the thoracic spine were developed to evaluate the outcomes of vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty. A mild and severe collapse of T10 treated with vertebroplasty or kyphoplasty was studied. Stresses on the endplates and intradiscal pressures were extrapolated to determine the stress distribution in the adjacent structures. Results: The validation ensured a correct stiffness and a proper kinematic of each functional spinal unit. The results demonstrated that a consolidation following vertebroplasty caused slight variations of intradiscal pressures and stresses. If a kyphoplasty was performed after a mild collapse of the vertebral body, a 25% stress reduction on endplates was found. In cases of severe collapse, when a partial height restoration was achieved, a 15% stress reduction was obtained, while with a full recovery of the anterior wall of the collapsed vertebra, there was a further reduction of 40%. Conclusions: To reduce the stresses on the adjacent endplates and the risk of fracture, the results suggest a kyphoplasty is to be preferred, trying to restore the initial vertebral body height.


  • Finite element analysis of the lumbar destabilization following pedicle subtraction osteotomy

    by Claudia Ottardi, Fabio Galbusera, Andrea Luca, Liliana Prosdocimo, Maurizio Sasso, Marco Brayda-Bruno, Tomaso Villa

    This study aims to analyze the destabilization produced following a pedicle subtraction osteotomy (PSO), with a calibrated numerical model. A 30° resection was created on L3 and L4. Range of Motion (ROM) and the force acting on the vertebral body were calculated. Osteotomies consistently increased the ROMs. In the intact model, 87% of the compressive load was acting on the vertebral bodies whereas in the destabilized models all the load was on the fractured surface. Osteotomies at both levels induced a marked instability but the PSO at L4 seemed to have a greater influence on the ROM. Despite the significant deformity corrections which could be achieved with PSO, this technique needs further analyses.


  • Open Access

    Planning the Surgical Correction of Spinal Deformities: Toward the Identification of the Biomechanical Principles by Means of Numerical Simulation

    by Fabio Galbusera, Tito Bassani, Luigi La Barbera, Claudia Ottardi, Benedikt Schlager, Marco Brayda-Bruno, Tomaso Villa, Hans-Joachim Wilke

    In decades of technical developments after the first surgical corrections of spinal deformities, the set of devices, techniques, and tools available to the surgeons has widened dramatically. Nevertheless, the rate of complications due to mechanical failure of the fixation or the instrumentation remains rather high. Indeed, basic and clinical research about the principles of deformity correction and the optimal surgical strategies (i.e., the choice of the fusion length, the most appropriate instrumentation, and the degree of tolerable correction) did not progress as much as the implantable devices and the surgical techniques. In this work, a software approach for the biomechanical simulation of the correction of patient-specific spinal deformities aimed to the identification of its biomechanical principles is presented. The method is based on three-dimensional reconstructions of the spinal anatomy obtained from biplanar radiographic images. A user-friendly graphical user interface allows for the planning of the desired deformity correction and to simulate the implantation of pedicle screws. Robust meshing of the instrumented spine is provided by using consolidated computational geometry and meshing libraries. Based on a finite element simulation, the program is able to predict the loads and stresses acting in the instrumentation as well as those in the biological tissues. A simple test case (reduction of a low-grade spondylolisthesis at L3–L4) was simulated as a proof of concept, and showed plausible results. Despite the numerous limitations of this approach which will be addressed in future implementations, the preliminary outcome is promising and encourages a wide effort toward its refinement.


  • Vertebroplasty vs kyphoplasty in osteoporotic vertebral fractures: a finite element comparative analysis

    by Luca Pietrogrande, Claudia Ottardi, Luigi La Barbera, Emanuela Raimondo, Tomaso Villa

    Introduction: Vertebroplasty (VP) and ballon kyphoplasty (BKP) are used in the treatment of the vertebral compression fractures (VCF), that usually result in a typical wedged deformation. It is still under debate which technique is the best, in terms of efficacy, costs, and safety, mainly about the risk of a adjacent new fractures. The aim of this study is to evaluate the biomechanical outcome of vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty by a computational comparative analysis with finite element models. Material and methods: A finite element model of intact T9–T11 spinal segment has been realized and then modified in order to simulate a wedge shaped VCF with a reduction of 25% (angle 13°) and 50% (angle 26°) of the original anterior height of T10 vertebral body. The following conditions have been considered for each model: osteoporotic bone (OP), vertebroplasty on T10 (VP), and kyphoplasty on T10 (KP). Results: Vertebroplasty causes only a negligible variations in the intradiscal pressure (IDP) and on the stress values on the end-plates (EPs). Kyphoplasty with a total restoration produces a reduction of 5% in the IDP below the fracture, while in the EPs a significant reduction of the stress is noticed (20–50%). The presence of the cement core (effect of material) has a negligible, while the wedged shape of the fractured vertebra (effect of geometry has a significant effect. Conclusions: In conclusion it can be stated that the effect of cement injection in the fractured vertebra causes slight variations in stress distribution, as already found in previous studies, that the effect of the geometry of the fractured vertebral body on stress distribution on the EPs is significant, and, consequently, that kyphoplasty offers some advantages respect to vertebroplasty in reducing the stress distribution, in particular on the EPs, if the height of the vertebral body is restored.