Paul Cloke
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Paul Cloke has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Eric Pawson
School of Earth and Environment University of Canterbury Christchurch New Zealand
15 shared publications - David Conradson
University of Canterbury
14 shared publications - Harvey C. Perkins
School of Architecture and Planning University of Auckland Auckland New Zealand
14 shared publications - Andrew Williams
Cardiff University
6 shared publications - Clive Barnett
University of Exeter, UK
3 shared publications - Jon May
School of Geography Queen Mary University of London London UK
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-12
Introduction
This chapter introduces the book, the purpose of which is to present a critical assessment of Christchurch as an evolving post-disaster city. The form and nature of the Canterbury earthquake sequence which began in 2010 is outlined, with comparisons made to other tectonic disasters internationally. The historical, environmental and political particularities of Christchurch’s situation as regards its pre-disaster characteristics are discussed. A selection of existing disaster models and narratives is reviewed and critiqued. The book is structured in three parts, dealing with ‘damage and displacement’, ‘recovery and renewal’ and ‘the city in transition’. The ways in which these matters are framed and narrated reflect the positionality and situated knowledges of the authors, which inform a range of interconnected perspectives within the book.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-12
Introduction
This chapter introduces the book, the purpose of which is to present a critical assessment of Christchurch as an evolving post-disaster city. The form and nature of the Canterbury earthquake sequence which began in 2010 is outlined, with comparisons made to other tectonic disasters internationally. The historical, environmental and political particularities of Christchurch’s situation as regards its pre-disaster characteristics are discussed. A selection of existing disaster models and narratives is reviewed and critiqued. The book is structured in three parts, dealing with ‘damage and displacement’, ‘recovery and renewal’ and ‘the city in transition’. The ways in which these matters are framed and narrated reflect the positionality and situated knowledges of the authors, which inform a range of interconnected perspectives within the book.
- Open Access
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
The Post-Earthquake City
This book critically assesses Christchurch, New Zealand as an evolving post-earthquake city. It examines the impact of the 2010–13 Canterbury earthquake sequence, employing a chronological structure to consider ‘damage and displacement’, ‘recovery and renewal’ and ‘the city in transition’. It offers a framework for understanding the multiple experiences and realities of post-earthquake recovery. It details how the rebuilding of the city has occurred and examines what has arisen in the context of an unprecedented opportunity to refashion land uses and social experience from the ground up. A recurring tension is observed between the desire and tendency of some to reproduce previous urban orthodoxies and the experimental efforts of others to fashion new cultures of progressive place-making and attention to the more-than-human city. The book offers several lessons for understanding disaster recovery in cities. It illuminates the opportunities disasters create for both the reassertion of the familiar and the emergence of the new; highlights the divergence of lived experience during recovery; and considers the extent to which a post-disaster city is prepared for likely climate futures. The book will be valuable reading for critical disaster researchers as well as geographers, sociologists, urban planners and policy makers interested in disaster recovery.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Open AccessThe Post-Earthquake City
This book critically assesses Christchurch, New Zealand as an evolving post-earthquake city. It examines the impact of the 2010–13 Canterbury earthquake sequence, employing a chronological structure to consider ‘damage and displacement’, ‘recovery and renewal’ and ‘the city in transition’. It offers a framework for understanding the multiple experiences and realities of post-earthquake recovery. It details how the rebuilding of the city has occurred and examines what has arisen in the context of an unprecedented opportunity to refashion land uses and social experience from the ground up. A recurring tension is observed between the desire and tendency of some to reproduce previous urban orthodoxies and the experimental efforts of others to fashion new cultures of progressive place-making and attention to the more-than-human city. The book offers several lessons for understanding disaster recovery in cities. It illuminates the opportunities disasters create for both the reassertion of the familiar and the emergence of the new; highlights the divergence of lived experience during recovery; and considers the extent to which a post-disaster city is prepared for likely climate futures. The book will be valuable reading for critical disaster researchers as well as geographers, sociologists, urban planners and policy makers interested in disaster recovery.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 164-180
The eastern suburbs
In the years following the quakes, there was significant concern in some quarters regarding the pace of recovery in the eastern suburbs of Christchurch. Attention was drawn to the extent of unrepaired property damage, to the apparent indifference of central government to community concerns and to ongoing problems with disrupted water and sewage infrastructure. The notion of the ‘forgotten east’ began to circulate, capturing the view that eastern areas of the city were somehow being overlooked or under-prioritised in the post-quake recovery. This chapter interrogates this idea, examining the differing levels of attention displayed by state and private sector agencies in their engagements with communities in the eastern suburbs. Were there instances of neglect or failure by the government, business or community organisations involved in the recovery of the eastern suburbs? Through a consideration of available evidence, the chapter seeks to address this question.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 164-180
The eastern suburbs
In the years following the quakes, there was significant concern in some quarters regarding the pace of recovery in the eastern suburbs of Christchurch. Attention was drawn to the extent of unrepaired property damage, to the apparent indifference of central government to community concerns and to ongoing problems with disrupted water and sewage infrastructure. The notion of the ‘forgotten east’ began to circulate, capturing the view that eastern areas of the city were somehow being overlooked or under-prioritised in the post-quake recovery. This chapter interrogates this idea, examining the differing levels of attention displayed by state and private sector agencies in their engagements with communities in the eastern suburbs. Were there instances of neglect or failure by the government, business or community organisations involved in the recovery of the eastern suburbs? Through a consideration of available evidence, the chapter seeks to address this question.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 53-70
Governance and the cartographies of recovery
This chapter discusses questions of governance and the deployment of various cartographies of recovery. It explores pre-earthquake experiments in governance, when collaborative and community-informed processes had been introduced to map out possible city futures. Such processes were initially replicated in 2011 in a citizen-based project called ‘Share an Idea’ from which the city council drew up what became known as the ‘citizen’s plan’ for city centre recovery. But the Crown, responding to concerns about investor confidence and resourcing, quickly overrode this plan with its own blueprint, created by experts in a 100-day timeframe. This employed panoptical cartographies to impose a modernist vision of precincts and ‘anchor projects’ across the damaged cityscape, overriding local concerns about the fate of heritage buildings. The blueprint did however incorporate elements of Share an Idea, particularly the concern for a more pedestrian-friendly and greener city, and taking greater cognisance of Māori cultural markers. The progress and reception of the blueprint are assessed.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 53-70
Governance and the cartographies of recovery
This chapter discusses questions of governance and the deployment of various cartographies of recovery. It explores pre-earthquake experiments in governance, when collaborative and community-informed processes had been introduced to map out possible city futures. Such processes were initially replicated in 2011 in a citizen-based project called ‘Share an Idea’ from which the city council drew up what became known as the ‘citizen’s plan’ for city centre recovery. But the Crown, responding to concerns about investor confidence and resourcing, quickly overrode this plan with its own blueprint, created by experts in a 100-day timeframe. This employed panoptical cartographies to impose a modernist vision of precincts and ‘anchor projects’ across the damaged cityscape, overriding local concerns about the fate of heritage buildings. The blueprint did however incorporate elements of Share an Idea, particularly the concern for a more pedestrian-friendly and greener city, and taking greater cognisance of Māori cultural markers. The progress and reception of the blueprint are assessed.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 147-163
Landscapes of consumption
This chapter considers the striking effect of the earthquakes on leisure, shopping and culture in Christchurch’s city centre and suburbs. Theoretically, the chapter is guided by ideas about the centrality of consumption in contemporary capitalist growth and, within that, the importance of landscapes of consumption. The impulse to regenerate the city’s consumption landscapes and associated activities is illustrated using examples of the Crown’s development of multiple large ‘anchor projects’ – such as Te Pae (the convention centre) and the very successful Margaret Mahy Family Playground – and government and private sector support for the revitalisation of retailing, hospitality, tourism, cultural and heritage projects and restorations. The anchor projects were designed to attract consumers and to hold property investors and their capital in place. The chapter concludes by reflecting on how the spatial competition between places to attract consumers and consumption practices depends on and drives a further cycle of consumption, that of carbon.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 147-163
Landscapes of consumption
This chapter considers the striking effect of the earthquakes on leisure, shopping and culture in Christchurch’s city centre and suburbs. Theoretically, the chapter is guided by ideas about the centrality of consumption in contemporary capitalist growth and, within that, the importance of landscapes of consumption. The impulse to regenerate the city’s consumption landscapes and associated activities is illustrated using examples of the Crown’s development of multiple large ‘anchor projects’ – such as Te Pae (the convention centre) and the very successful Margaret Mahy Family Playground – and government and private sector support for the revitalisation of retailing, hospitality, tourism, cultural and heritage projects and restorations. The anchor projects were designed to attract consumers and to hold property investors and their capital in place. The chapter concludes by reflecting on how the spatial competition between places to attract consumers and consumption practices depends on and drives a further cycle of consumption, that of carbon.
- Open Access
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 108-125
Voluntary and community sector responses
In the aftermath of the earthquakes, a number of voluntary and community organisations became involved in the provision of emergency relief and support to affected residents and neighbourhoods. Other organisations directed their efforts towards longer-term advocacy and community development work, sometimes in an overtly politicised manner. In an exploration of this diverse activity, this chapter examines faith-based organisations, resident-led advocacy and activism and a novel movement that became known as the Student Volunteer Army. It describes each of these forms of voluntarism, while also considering their sometimes uneasy relationship with state recovery agencies. The position of this voluntarism in relation to politically conservative aspirations for rebuilding the city and more progressive forms of place-making is also considered.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 108-125
Open AccessVoluntary and community sector responses
In the aftermath of the earthquakes, a number of voluntary and community organisations became involved in the provision of emergency relief and support to affected residents and neighbourhoods. Other organisations directed their efforts towards longer-term advocacy and community development work, sometimes in an overtly politicised manner. In an exploration of this diverse activity, this chapter examines faith-based organisations, resident-led advocacy and activism and a novel movement that became known as the Student Volunteer Army. It describes each of these forms of voluntarism, while also considering their sometimes uneasy relationship with state recovery agencies. The position of this voluntarism in relation to politically conservative aspirations for rebuilding the city and more progressive forms of place-making is also considered.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 15-32
The fracturing of a vulnerable city
This chapter assesses the extent and nature of the physical fracturing of the city and its region as a result of the Canterbury earthquake sequence. It explores the forms that material damage took, and considers the extent to which these were the product of, or exacerbated by, particular vulnerabilities that, with the benefit of hindsight, can be attributed to characteristics of the city’s built environment and its social organisation. Given that Christchurch is the second largest city in a country well-known for seismic activity, one that sits astride a major global tectonic plate boundary, the chapter asks why it was not better prepared. The paradox explored is that the city proved so vulnerable to the earthquakes despite widespread measures for protection and security, specifically building codes and the extent of property insurance. This is followed by an outline of the extent of death and destruction, and the pattern of immediate disaster response.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 15-32
The fracturing of a vulnerable city
This chapter assesses the extent and nature of the physical fracturing of the city and its region as a result of the Canterbury earthquake sequence. It explores the forms that material damage took, and considers the extent to which these were the product of, or exacerbated by, particular vulnerabilities that, with the benefit of hindsight, can be attributed to characteristics of the city’s built environment and its social organisation. Given that Christchurch is the second largest city in a country well-known for seismic activity, one that sits astride a major global tectonic plate boundary, the chapter asks why it was not better prepared. The paradox explored is that the city proved so vulnerable to the earthquakes despite widespread measures for protection and security, specifically building codes and the extent of property insurance. This is followed by an outline of the extent of death and destruction, and the pattern of immediate disaster response.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 129-146
From transitional activities to place-making
This chapter examines how a number of transitional organisations sprang up in the aftermath of the earthquakes, making multifaceted contributions to the cultural, artistic, creative and ecological use of temporary spaces. Through a series of experimental projects, these organisations began to articulate alternative ethical and aesthetic expressions of collective life after the earthquakes. Although for some residents and commentators these transitional sites and practices represented an ephemeral and messy frivolity, for others, they helped to foster a set of enlivening affective atmospheres in the recovering city. These enlivening atmospheres were often in stark contrast to the collective feelings associated with the top down activities of central government. Over time, a number of these transitional organisations have evolved into more formal agencies of place-making in the city, seeking to continue meaningful liaison with local communities but also to perpetuate experimental projects and novel forms of decision-making.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 129-146
From transitional activities to place-making
This chapter examines how a number of transitional organisations sprang up in the aftermath of the earthquakes, making multifaceted contributions to the cultural, artistic, creative and ecological use of temporary spaces. Through a series of experimental projects, these organisations began to articulate alternative ethical and aesthetic expressions of collective life after the earthquakes. Although for some residents and commentators these transitional sites and practices represented an ephemeral and messy frivolity, for others, they helped to foster a set of enlivening affective atmospheres in the recovering city. These enlivening atmospheres were often in stark contrast to the collective feelings associated with the top down activities of central government. Over time, a number of these transitional organisations have evolved into more formal agencies of place-making in the city, seeking to continue meaningful liaison with local communities but also to perpetuate experimental projects and novel forms of decision-making.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 181-198
The more-than-human city
This chapter takes an important theme in urban geography but one often downplayed in post-earthquake recovery, that of the more-than-human city. The chapter explores how actual worlds become assembled when all manner of things (or ‘actants’) contribute to the making of particular geographies, assessing the extent to which opportunities for more lively spaces, hybrid ecosystems and species interactions are being recognised. The question arising here is if through its post-earthquake experience the city is now better placed to move beyond what Donna Haraway has described as the ‘unprecedented looking away’ of the Anthropocene. The chapter examines the ways in which the earthquakes have disturbed the foundational belief of western urban culture: that all of nature is a fixed stage upon which to enact the human drama. The fracturing of this entrenchment is illustrated with both narratives of contest and emerging entanglements, as new experimental configurations of more-than-human relations in the city develop.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 181-198
The more-than-human city
This chapter takes an important theme in urban geography but one often downplayed in post-earthquake recovery, that of the more-than-human city. The chapter explores how actual worlds become assembled when all manner of things (or ‘actants’) contribute to the making of particular geographies, assessing the extent to which opportunities for more lively spaces, hybrid ecosystems and species interactions are being recognised. The question arising here is if through its post-earthquake experience the city is now better placed to move beyond what Donna Haraway has described as the ‘unprecedented looking away’ of the Anthropocene. The chapter examines the ways in which the earthquakes have disturbed the foundational belief of western urban culture: that all of nature is a fixed stage upon which to enact the human drama. The fracturing of this entrenchment is illustrated with both narratives of contest and emerging entanglements, as new experimental configurations of more-than-human relations in the city develop.
- Open Access
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 90-107
City centre recovery and commercial property investment
This chapter considers the impact of the earthquakes, and the demolition of central city buildings that followed, on Christchurch’s commercial property sector. Theoretically, the chapter is guided by ideas about property investment decision-making and associated calculative practices. It begins with a discussion of the loss of workspace in the central city which forced multiple organisations to reorganise and operate beyond the boundaries of the central city. The chapter interprets the ways in which public and private sector agencies engaged in a protracted commercial property recovery effort. That recovery refocused pre-earthquake attempts to stem central city decline in the face of growing suburban competition, particularly from retailing, hospitality and allied services. In illustrating that process, the chapter shows how cooperative, contested and sometimes antagonistic interaction between the Christchurch City Council, Crown agencies, property owners, their insurance companies and the region’s residents have led to a partial regeneration in a situation of staggering complexity.
- 23 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 90-107
Open AccessCity centre recovery and commercial property investment
This chapter considers the impact of the earthquakes, and the demolition of central city buildings that followed, on Christchurch’s commercial property sector. Theoretically, the chapter is guided by ideas about property investment decision-making and associated calculative practices. It begins with a discussion of the loss of workspace in the central city which forced multiple organisations to reorganise and operate beyond the boundaries of the central city. The chapter interprets the ways in which public and private sector agencies engaged in a protracted commercial property recovery effort. That recovery refocused pre-earthquake attempts to stem central city decline in the face of growing suburban competition, particularly from retailing, hospitality and allied services. In illustrating that process, the chapter shows how cooperative, contested and sometimes antagonistic interaction between the Christchurch City Council, Crown agencies, property owners, their insurance companies and the region’s residents have led to a partial regeneration in a situation of staggering complexity.