Michael John Priestley Cullen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Michael John Priestley Cullen has a total of 24 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Beatrice Pelloni
Heriot-Watt University and the Maxwell Institute for the Mathematical Sciences, Edinburgh, United Kingdom
2 shared publications - Colin J. Cotter
Department of Mathematics Imperial College London South Kensington Campus SW7 2AZ London United Kingdom
2 shared publications - Jingrui Cheng
University of Wisconsin
2 shared publications - Bin Cheng
Univ Surrey, Dept Math, Guildford GU2 7XH, Surrey, England
1 shared publication C. Piccolo
Met Office
1 shared publication- Charlie P. Egan
Maxwell Institute for Mathematical Sciences Department of Mathematics Heriot-Watt University Edinburgh United Kingdom
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
A new implementation of the geometric method for solving the Eady slice equations
We present a new implementation of the geometric method of Cullen & Purser (1984) for solving the semi-geostrophic Eady slice equations which model large scale atmospheric flows and frontogenesis. The geometric method is a Lagrangian discretisation, where the PDE is approximated by a particle system. An important property of the discretisation is that it is energy conserving. We restate the geometric method in the language of semi-discrete optimal transport theory and exploit this to develop a fast implementation that combines the latest results from numerical optimal transport theory with a novel adaptive time-stepping scheme. Our results enable a controlled comparison between the Eady-Boussinesq vertical slice equations and their semi-geostrophic approximation. We provide further evidence that weak solutions of the Eady-Boussinesq vertical slice equations converge to weak solutions of the semi-geostrophic Eady slice equations as the Rossby number tends to zero.
Open AccessA new implementation of the geometric method for solving the Eady slice equations
We present a new implementation of the geometric method of Cullen & Purser (1984) for solving the semi-geostrophic Eady slice equations which model large scale atmospheric flows and frontogenesis. The geometric method is a Lagrangian discretisation, where the PDE is approximated by a particle system. An important property of the discretisation is that it is energy conserving. We restate the geometric method in the language of semi-discrete optimal transport theory and exploit this to develop a fast implementation that combines the latest results from numerical optimal transport theory with a novel adaptive time-stepping scheme. Our results enable a controlled comparison between the Eady-Boussinesq vertical slice equations and their semi-geostrophic approximation. We provide further evidence that weak solutions of the Eady-Boussinesq vertical slice equations converge to weak solutions of the semi-geostrophic Eady slice equations as the Rossby number tends to zero.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2019
- Published by American Institute of Mathematical Sciences (AIMS) in Journal of Geometric Mechanics
- Vol. 11 (2) , 139-151
Particle relabelling symmetries and Noether's theorem for vertical slice models
We consider the variational formulation for vertical slice models introduced in Cotter and Holm (Proc Roy Soc, 2013). These models have a Kelvin circulation theorem that holds on all materially-transported closed loops, not just those loops on isosurfaces of potential temperature. Potential vorticity conservation can be derived directly from this circulation theorem. In this paper, we show that this property is due to these models having a relabelling symmetry for every single diffeomorphism of the vertical slice that preserves the density, not just those diffeomorphisms that preserve the potential temperature. This is developed using the methodology of Cotter and Holm (Foundations of Computational Mathematics, 2012).
- 1 January 2019
- Published by American Institute of Mathematical Sciences (AIMS) in Journal of Geometric Mechanics
- Vol. 11 (2) , 139-151
Open AccessParticle relabelling symmetries and Noether's theorem for vertical slice models
We consider the variational formulation for vertical slice models introduced in Cotter and Holm (Proc Roy Soc, 2013). These models have a Kelvin circulation theorem that holds on all materially-transported closed loops, not just those loops on isosurfaces of potential temperature. Potential vorticity conservation can be derived directly from this circulation theorem. In this paper, we show that this property is due to these models having a relabelling symmetry for every single diffeomorphism of the vertical slice that preserves the density, not just those diffeomorphisms that preserve the potential temperature. This is developed using the methodology of Cotter and Holm (Foundations of Computational Mathematics, 2012).
- Open Access
Cullen's Stability Principle and Weak Solutions of the Free-surface Semi-geostrophic Equations
The semi-geostrophic equations are used widely in the modelling of large-scale atmospheric flows. In this note, we prove the global existence of weak solutions of the incompressible semi-geostrophic equations, in geostrophic coordinates, in a three-dimensional domain with a free upper boundary. The proof, based on an energy minimisation argument originally inspired by Cullen's Stability Principle, uses optimal transport results as well as the analysis of Hamiltonian ODEs in spaces of probability measures as studied by Ambrosio and Gangbo. We also give a general formulation of Cullen's Stability Principle in a rigorous mathematical framework.
Open AccessCullen's Stability Principle and Weak Solutions of the Free-surface Semi-geostrophic Equations
The semi-geostrophic equations are used widely in the modelling of large-scale atmospheric flows. In this note, we prove the global existence of weak solutions of the incompressible semi-geostrophic equations, in geostrophic coordinates, in a three-dimensional domain with a free upper boundary. The proof, based on an energy minimisation argument originally inspired by Cullen's Stability Principle, uses optimal transport results as well as the analysis of Hamiltonian ODEs in spaces of probability measures as studied by Ambrosio and Gangbo. We also give a general formulation of Cullen's Stability Principle in a rigorous mathematical framework.
- Open Access
The Use of Semigeostrophic Theory to Diagnose the Behaviour of an Atmospheric GCM
A diagnostic method is presented for analysing the large-scale behaviour of the Met Office Unified Model, which is a comprehensive atmospheric model used for weather and climate prediction. Outside the boundary layer, on scales larger than the radius of deformation, semi-geostrophic theory will give an accurate approximation to the model evolution. In particular, the ageostrophic circulation required to maintain geostrophic and hydrostatic balance against prescribed forcing and a rate of change of the geostrophic pressure can be calculated. In the tropics, the balance condition degenerates to the weak temperature gradient approximation. Within the boundary layer, the semi-geotriptic approximation has to be used because friction and rotation are equally important. Assuming the calculated pressure tendency and ageotriptic circulation match the observed model behaviour, the influence of the large-scale state and the nature of the forcing on the model response can be deduced in a straightforward way. The capabilities of the diagnostic are illustrated by comparing predictions of the ageotriptic circulation from the theory and the model. It is then used to show that the effects of latent heat release can be included by modifying the static stability, and to show the effect of an idealised tropical heat source on the subtropical jet. Finally, the response of the ageotriptic flow to boundary layer heating in the tropics is demonstrated. These illustrations show that the model behaviour on large scales conforms with theoretical expectations, so that the results of the diagnostic can be used to aid the development of further improvements to the model, in particular investigating systematic errors and understanding the large-scale atmospheric response to forcing.
Open AccessThe Use of Semigeostrophic Theory to Diagnose the Behaviour of an Atmospheric GCM
A diagnostic method is presented for analysing the large-scale behaviour of the Met Office Unified Model, which is a comprehensive atmospheric model used for weather and climate prediction. Outside the boundary layer, on scales larger than the radius of deformation, semi-geostrophic theory will give an accurate approximation to the model evolution. In particular, the ageostrophic circulation required to maintain geostrophic and hydrostatic balance against prescribed forcing and a rate of change of the geostrophic pressure can be calculated. In the tropics, the balance condition degenerates to the weak temperature gradient approximation. Within the boundary layer, the semi-geotriptic approximation has to be used because friction and rotation are equally important. Assuming the calculated pressure tendency and ageotriptic circulation match the observed model behaviour, the influence of the large-scale state and the nature of the forcing on the model response can be deduced in a straightforward way. The capabilities of the diagnostic are illustrated by comparing predictions of the ageotriptic circulation from the theory and the model. It is then used to show that the effects of latent heat release can be included by modifying the static stability, and to show the effect of an idealised tropical heat source on the subtropical jet. Finally, the response of the ageotriptic flow to boundary layer heating in the tropics is demonstrated. These illustrations show that the model behaviour on large scales conforms with theoretical expectations, so that the results of the diagnostic can be used to aid the development of further improvements to the model, in particular investigating systematic errors and understanding the large-scale atmospheric response to forcing.
- Open Access
- 20 July 2018
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
The use of Semigeostrophic Theory to Diagnose the Behaviour of an Atmospheric GCM
A diagnostic method is presented for analysing the large-scale behaviour of the Met Office Unified Model, which is a comprehensive atmospheric model used for weather and climate prediction. Outside the boundary layer, on scales larger than the radius of deformation, semigeostrophic theory will give an accurate approximation to the model evolution. In particular, the ageostrophic circulation required to maintain geostrophic and hydrostatic balance against prescribed forcing and a rate of change of the geostrophic pressure can be calculated. In the tropics the balance condition degenerates to the weak temperature gradient approximation. Within the boundary layer the semigeostriptic approximation has to be used because friction and rotation are equally important. Assuming the calculated pressure tendency and ageotriptic circulation match the observed model behaviour, the influence of the large-scale state and the nature of the forcing on the model response can be deduced in a straightforward way. This process is illustrated by comparing predictions of the ageotriptic circulation from the theory and the model. It is then used to show that the effects of latent heat release can be included by modifying the static stability, and to show the effect of an idealised tropical heat source on the subtropical jet. Finally the response of the ageotriptic flow to boundary layer heating in the tropics is demonstrated. These illustrations show that the model behaviour on large scales conforms with theoretical expectations, so that the results of the diagnostic can be used to aid the development of further improvements to the model.
- 20 July 2018
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessThe use of Semigeostrophic Theory to Diagnose the Behaviour of an Atmospheric GCM
A diagnostic method is presented for analysing the large-scale behaviour of the Met Office Unified Model, which is a comprehensive atmospheric model used for weather and climate prediction. Outside the boundary layer, on scales larger than the radius of deformation, semigeostrophic theory will give an accurate approximation to the model evolution. In particular, the ageostrophic circulation required to maintain geostrophic and hydrostatic balance against prescribed forcing and a rate of change of the geostrophic pressure can be calculated. In the tropics the balance condition degenerates to the weak temperature gradient approximation. Within the boundary layer the semigeostriptic approximation has to be used because friction and rotation are equally important. Assuming the calculated pressure tendency and ageotriptic circulation match the observed model behaviour, the influence of the large-scale state and the nature of the forcing on the model response can be deduced in a straightforward way. This process is illustrated by comparing predictions of the ageotriptic circulation from the theory and the model. It is then used to show that the effects of latent heat release can be included by modifying the static stability, and to show the effect of an idealised tropical heat source on the subtropical jet. Finally the response of the ageotriptic flow to boundary layer heating in the tropics is demonstrated. These illustrations show that the model behaviour on large scales conforms with theoretical expectations, so that the results of the diagnostic can be used to aid the development of further improvements to the model.
- 5 September 2017
- Published by Springer Nature in Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis
- Vol. 227 (1) , 215-272
Classical Solutions to Semi-geostrophic System with Variable Coriolis Parameter
- 5 September 2017
- Published by Springer Nature in Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis
- Vol. 227 (1) , 215-272
Classical Solutions to Semi-geostrophic System with Variable Coriolis Parameter
- 13 November 2016
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 143 (702) , 278-287
The impact of high vertical resolution in the Met Office Unified Model
Recent numerical model results suggest that the −5/3 energy spectrum on wavelengths less than about 500 km in the free atmosphere reflects motions where the rotational and divergent kinetic energies are comparable. This can be reproduced by models with sufficient horizontal resolution. This article examines the sensitivity to vertical resolution. If the small‐scale regime is dominated by stratified turbulence with a large Froude number, the appropriate vertical resolution is set by U/N, where U is a horizontal velocity scale and N the Brunt–Väisälä frequency, and thus only depends on the degree of stratification. This is estimated to imply a vertical grid length of no more than a few hundred metres. In this article, we use additional diagnostics of the vertical structure to show that the Froude number increases as the vertical resolution is increased. This is consistent with theories of stratified turbulence based on shear instability, while it is not consistent with the idea of layered two‐dimensional turbulence. We also show that the treatment of gravity wave breaking is improved by the use of higher vertical resolution. However, the overall character of the model horizontal and vertical spectra does not change much when the vertical grid length is reduced from 720 to 180 m in the upper troposphere, with proportional reductions elsewhere. While the model simulates regions where a breakdown to turbulence would be expected, it does not have sufficient resolution to produce explicit turbulence and the horizontal resolution is not sufficient to show a −5/3 spectrum.
- 13 November 2016
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 143 (702) , 278-287
The impact of high vertical resolution in the Met Office Unified Model
Recent numerical model results suggest that the −5/3 energy spectrum on wavelengths less than about 500 km in the free atmosphere reflects motions where the rotational and divergent kinetic energies are comparable. This can be reproduced by models with sufficient horizontal resolution. This article examines the sensitivity to vertical resolution. If the small‐scale regime is dominated by stratified turbulence with a large Froude number, the appropriate vertical resolution is set by U/N, where U is a horizontal velocity scale and N the Brunt–Väisälä frequency, and thus only depends on the degree of stratification. This is estimated to imply a vertical grid length of no more than a few hundred metres. In this article, we use additional diagnostics of the vertical structure to show that the Froude number increases as the vertical resolution is increased. This is consistent with theories of stratified turbulence based on shear instability, while it is not consistent with the idea of layered two‐dimensional turbulence. We also show that the treatment of gravity wave breaking is improved by the use of higher vertical resolution. However, the overall character of the model horizontal and vertical spectra does not change much when the vertical grid length is reduced from 720 to 180 m in the upper troposphere, with proportional reductions elsewhere. While the model simulates regions where a breakdown to turbulence would be expected, it does not have sufficient resolution to produce explicit turbulence and the horizontal resolution is not sufficient to show a −5/3 spectrum.
- Open Access
A rigorous treatment of moist convection in a single column
We study a single column model of moist convection in the atmosphere. We state the conditions for it to represent a stable steady state. We then evolve the column by subjecting it to an upward displacement which can release instability, leading to a time dependent sequence of stable steady states. We propose a definition of measure valued solution to describe the time dependence and prove its existence.
Open AccessA rigorous treatment of moist convection in a single column
We study a single column model of moist convection in the atmosphere. We state the conditions for it to represent a stable steady state. We then evolve the column by subjecting it to an upward displacement which can release instability, leading to a time dependent sequence of stable steady states. We propose a definition of measure valued solution to describe the time dependence and prove its existence.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2015
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics
- Vol. 22 (4) , 403-411
Verification against perturbed analyses and observations
It has long been known that verification of a forecast against the sequence of analyses used to produce those forecasts can under-estimate the magnitude of forecast errors. Here we show that under certain conditions the verification of a short-range forecast against a perturbed analysis coming from an ensemble data assimilation scheme can give the same root-mean-square error as verification against the truth. This means that a perturbed analysis can be used as a reliable proxy for the truth. However, the conditions required for this result to hold are rather restrictive: the analysis must be optimal, the ensemble spread must be equal to the error in the mean, the ensemble size must be large and the forecast being verified must be the background forecast used in the data assimilation. Although these criteria are unlikely to be met exactly it becomes clear that for most cases verification against a perturbed analysis gives better results than verification against an unperturbed analysis. We demonstrate the application of these results in a idealised model framework and a numerical weather prediction context. In deriving this result we recall that an optimal (Kalman) analysis is one for which the analysis increments are uncorrelated with the analysis errors.
- 24 July 2015
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics
- Vol. 22 (4) , 403-411
Open AccessVerification against perturbed analyses and observations
It has long been known that verification of a forecast against the sequence of analyses used to produce those forecasts can under-estimate the magnitude of forecast errors. Here we show that under certain conditions the verification of a short-range forecast against a perturbed analysis coming from an ensemble data assimilation scheme can give the same root-mean-square error as verification against the truth. This means that a perturbed analysis can be used as a reliable proxy for the truth. However, the conditions required for this result to hold are rather restrictive: the analysis must be optimal, the ensemble spread must be equal to the error in the mean, the ensemble size must be large and the forecast being verified must be the background forecast used in the data assimilation. Although these criteria are unlikely to be met exactly it becomes clear that for most cases verification against a perturbed analysis gives better results than verification against an unperturbed analysis. We demonstrate the application of these results in a idealised model framework and a numerical weather prediction context. In deriving this result we recall that an optimal (Kalman) analysis is one for which the analysis increments are uncorrelated with the analysis errors.
- Open Access
On a model of forced axisymmetric flows
In this work, we consider a model of forced axisymmetric flows which is derived from the inviscid Boussinesq equations. What makes these equations unusual is the boundary conditions they are expected to satisfy and the fact that the boundary is part of the unknown. We show that these flows give rise to an unusual Monge-Ampere equations for which we prove the existence and the uniqueness of a variational solution. We take advantage of these Monge-Ampere equations and construct a solution to the model.
Open AccessOn a model of forced axisymmetric flows
In this work, we consider a model of forced axisymmetric flows which is derived from the inviscid Boussinesq equations. What makes these equations unusual is the boundary conditions they are expected to satisfy and the fact that the boundary is part of the unknown. We show that these flows give rise to an unusual Monge-Ampere equations for which we prove the existence and the uniqueness of a variational solution. We take advantage of these Monge-Ampere equations and construct a solution to the model.