Cóilín Minto
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Cóilín Minto has a total of 246 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Giacomo Chato Osio
Unit D.02 Water and Marine Resources, Directorate D—Sustainable Resources, Joint Research Centre, European Commission, Ispra, Italy
7 shared publications- James T. Thorson
Resource Ecology and Fisheries Management Division Alaska Fisheries Science Center Seattle Washington USA
7 shared publications Catherine Longo
6 shared publications- Deirdre Brophy
Marine and Freshwater Research Centre, Atlantic Technological University (ATU), ATU Galway City Galway Ireland
6 shared publications Olaf P. Jensen
Department of Marine and Coastal Science, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, USA
6 shared publications- Colm Lordan
Marine Institute, Rinville, Oranmore, Co. Galway, Ireland
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 3 November 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Environmental Pollution
- Vol. 412
Retrospective and prospective power analysis for PCB temporal trend detection in juvenile harbour porpoises
- 3 November 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Environmental Pollution
- Vol. 412
Retrospective and prospective power analysis for PCB temporal trend detection in juvenile harbour porpoises
- Open Access
- 5 August 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (8)
Dynamic harvest control rules for fish stocks with time-varying productivity
Biological reference points are benchmarks against which stock status can be assessed and are central to fisheries management advice. Calculation of non-proxy reference points depends on the demographic parameters of the stock, particularly stock-recruitment parameters. There is growing evidence of non-stationary, pre-recruit mortality parameters that would imply time-varying reference points. It may be possible, however, to develop robust (time-invariant) harvest control rules (HCRs) that can partially mitigate for dynamic mortality parameters via lagged biomass dependency. It is unclear under what conditions either approach would be preferable. To address this question, we use time-varying stock-recruitment relationships for three contrasting stocks and counterfactually manage plausible histories under: (1) constant proxy fishing mortality F target; (2) time-varying target F; (3) constant biomass-linked HCR; and (4) a time-varying biomass-linked HCR. In contrast to a previous study that found conservation gains with constant, status-quo management targets, we find that time-varying HCR policies were able to maintain higher levels of biomass during low-productivity periods and achieve higher yields during periods of high productivity. These benefits result from not fixing reference points to proxies that become outmoded when productivity varies. We find that a time-varying harvest policy may be advantageous when the productivity signal is strong and persistent over decadal time scales. The performance of a time-varying HCR will also be improved when there is a short time lag between assessing productivity and adjusting the fishing mortality rate. By contrast, a time-invariant HCR will be favored for stocks with weaker productivity signals relative to the short-term recruitment variability or longer assessment lags and possibly older recruitment ages. While some generalization is possible, we recommend that time-varying harvest policies be evaluated on a stock-by-stock basis using this approach.
- 5 August 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (8)
Open AccessDynamic harvest control rules for fish stocks with time-varying productivity
Biological reference points are benchmarks against which stock status can be assessed and are central to fisheries management advice. Calculation of non-proxy reference points depends on the demographic parameters of the stock, particularly stock-recruitment parameters. There is growing evidence of non-stationary, pre-recruit mortality parameters that would imply time-varying reference points. It may be possible, however, to develop robust (time-invariant) harvest control rules (HCRs) that can partially mitigate for dynamic mortality parameters via lagged biomass dependency. It is unclear under what conditions either approach would be preferable. To address this question, we use time-varying stock-recruitment relationships for three contrasting stocks and counterfactually manage plausible histories under: (1) constant proxy fishing mortality F target; (2) time-varying target F; (3) constant biomass-linked HCR; and (4) a time-varying biomass-linked HCR. In contrast to a previous study that found conservation gains with constant, status-quo management targets, we find that time-varying HCR policies were able to maintain higher levels of biomass during low-productivity periods and achieve higher yields during periods of high productivity. These benefits result from not fixing reference points to proxies that become outmoded when productivity varies. We find that a time-varying harvest policy may be advantageous when the productivity signal is strong and persistent over decadal time scales. The performance of a time-varying HCR will also be improved when there is a short time lag between assessing productivity and adjusting the fishing mortality rate. By contrast, a time-invariant HCR will be favored for stocks with weaker productivity signals relative to the short-term recruitment variability or longer assessment lags and possibly older recruitment ages. While some generalization is possible, we recommend that time-varying harvest policies be evaluated on a stock-by-stock basis using this approach.
- Open Access
- 2 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Natural Resource Modeling
- Vol. 39 (3) , e70040
A Process‐Based Theory of Fishing
The processes that lead to the capture of marine organisms in fishing gear are inherently complex, arising from interactions between the deployment of fishing effort, gear efficiency, and species‐specific demography and behaviour. A mechanistic understanding of these processes provides a principled basis for developing management approaches that explicitly account for how different gears interact with different species. Here, we present a general framework for fishing that decomposes capture into the sequential processes of encounter, contact, and retention. We demonstrate how these processes give rise to the emergent properties of catchability and selectivity under varying conditions. Using a set of examples drawn from fish farming, towed gears, and static gears, we show that a common conceptual framework can be applied across diverse fishing contexts, and that the resulting dynamics of catch are consistent with empirical observations. The framework provides a consistent interpretation of fishing effort across gear types and helps to relate existing definitions of fishing processes within a common structure. By synthesising concepts that have traditionally been treated separately in fishing gear technology and stock assessment, this framework provides a flexible basis for incorporating additional biological, technological, and behavioural processes. As such, it offers new insights into how management measures and fishery interactions influence the capture of fish and other marine organisms, with broader implications for fisheries management and ecosystem‐based approaches.
- 2 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Natural Resource Modeling
- Vol. 39 (3) , e70040
Open AccessA Process‐Based Theory of Fishing
The processes that lead to the capture of marine organisms in fishing gear are inherently complex, arising from interactions between the deployment of fishing effort, gear efficiency, and species‐specific demography and behaviour. A mechanistic understanding of these processes provides a principled basis for developing management approaches that explicitly account for how different gears interact with different species. Here, we present a general framework for fishing that decomposes capture into the sequential processes of encounter, contact, and retention. We demonstrate how these processes give rise to the emergent properties of catchability and selectivity under varying conditions. Using a set of examples drawn from fish farming, towed gears, and static gears, we show that a common conceptual framework can be applied across diverse fishing contexts, and that the resulting dynamics of catch are consistent with empirical observations. The framework provides a consistent interpretation of fishing effort across gear types and helps to relate existing definitions of fishing processes within a common structure. By synthesising concepts that have traditionally been treated separately in fishing gear technology and stock assessment, this framework provides a flexible basis for incorporating additional biological, technological, and behavioural processes. As such, it offers new insights into how management measures and fishery interactions influence the capture of fish and other marine organisms, with broader implications for fisheries management and ecosystem‐based approaches.
- Open Access
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Retrospective and Prospective Power Analysis for PCB Temporal Trend Detection in JuvenileHarbour Porpoises
Retrospective and prospective power analyses were conducted to evaluate the ability of thepollutant monitoring programme in UK-stranded harbour porpoises to detect trends in PCBconcentrations (the sum of 25 congeners of polychlorinated biphenyls). Using data from 415juvenile harbour porpoises stranded between 1991 and 2019, we assessed statistical power todetect these trends within Harbour Porpoise Assessment Units and OSPAR Assessment Areas.Retrospective analyses showed sufficient statistical power (80% at 𝛼=0.05) to detect the observedannual declines ranging from 2.64% to 5.10%. At the UK level (England, Scotland and Wales),the current programme can detect a 3.06% annual decline with only 3 samples per year over thefull time series (29 years), and 8 samples per year over a 20-year period. Prospective simulationsindicated that a six-year monitoring period, akin to reporting under the EU Marine StrategyFramework Directive (MSFD), is sufficient to detect annual declines of 10–15% depending on thespatial unit in question. Extending the monitoring period to ten years, consistent with OSPAR’sQuality Status Reporting cycles, substantially improved sensitivity, enabling detection of smallerdeclines (5–10%) with relatively modest sampling effort. Overall, these results demonstratethat the existing monitoring programme is adequately powered to support OSPAR and MSFDreporting requirements, once sufficient individuals are sampled, and provide clear guidance foroptimising future sampling design in data-limited areas. Although focused on harbour porpoises,the framework is applicable to other OSPAR indicator species, including common dolphins, forwhich PCBs likewise pose the greatest contaminant risk for persistent organic pollutants.
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessRetrospective and Prospective Power Analysis for PCB Temporal Trend Detection in JuvenileHarbour Porpoises
Retrospective and prospective power analyses were conducted to evaluate the ability of thepollutant monitoring programme in UK-stranded harbour porpoises to detect trends in PCBconcentrations (the sum of 25 congeners of polychlorinated biphenyls). Using data from 415juvenile harbour porpoises stranded between 1991 and 2019, we assessed statistical power todetect these trends within Harbour Porpoise Assessment Units and OSPAR Assessment Areas.Retrospective analyses showed sufficient statistical power (80% at 𝛼=0.05) to detect the observedannual declines ranging from 2.64% to 5.10%. At the UK level (England, Scotland and Wales),the current programme can detect a 3.06% annual decline with only 3 samples per year over thefull time series (29 years), and 8 samples per year over a 20-year period. Prospective simulationsindicated that a six-year monitoring period, akin to reporting under the EU Marine StrategyFramework Directive (MSFD), is sufficient to detect annual declines of 10–15% depending on thespatial unit in question. Extending the monitoring period to ten years, consistent with OSPAR’sQuality Status Reporting cycles, substantially improved sensitivity, enabling detection of smallerdeclines (5–10%) with relatively modest sampling effort. Overall, these results demonstratethat the existing monitoring programme is adequately powered to support OSPAR and MSFDreporting requirements, once sufficient individuals are sampled, and provide clear guidance foroptimising future sampling design in data-limited areas. Although focused on harbour porpoises,the framework is applicable to other OSPAR indicator species, including common dolphins, forwhich PCBs likewise pose the greatest contaminant risk for persistent organic pollutants.
- Open Access
- 7 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 27 (5) , 1193-1209
Climate‐informed stock‐recruitment models identify potential environmental links for commercial fish stocks
Several studies have demonstrated non‐stationarity in marine fish maximum per capita recruitment rate, which may be linked to regional environmental drivers. Exploring relationships between environmental drivers and time‐varying recruitment rate will provide insight into recruitment processes, and suggest how fisheries managers may adapt biological reference points and adjust harvest‐control rules in response to changes in the ecosystem state. To test for significant effects on the recruitment rate of 48 commercial United States fish stocks with nonstationary per‐capita recruitment, environmental indices from two Atlantic and three Pacific regions are incorporated into a state‐space dynamic Ricker stock‐recruitment model. We developed two model variants for incorporating climate into the state‐space model, one based on the climate variable itself and the other on its rate of change. Simulation tests indicated that if the true system has a climate driver, most of the time a climate‐enhanced model will detect it. However, the different model variants may have similar statistical support, such that model selection may be unable to distinguish the ecological hypotheses of the climate‐recruitment interaction. For 35 (73%) of the true stock time series, at least one environmental variable was identified as nominally significant for improving on the non‐climate dynamic model. The simulation results indicate that the identified environmental indices likely do impact recruitment of the given stocks, even if the form of that effect may not be clearly identified. Our results can now support more detailed stock‐specific analyses of fisheries dynamics, climate drivers, model specification and ultimately management action in the future.
- 7 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 27 (5) , 1193-1209
Open AccessClimate‐informed stock‐recruitment models identify potential environmental links for commercial fish stocks
Several studies have demonstrated non‐stationarity in marine fish maximum per capita recruitment rate, which may be linked to regional environmental drivers. Exploring relationships between environmental drivers and time‐varying recruitment rate will provide insight into recruitment processes, and suggest how fisheries managers may adapt biological reference points and adjust harvest‐control rules in response to changes in the ecosystem state. To test for significant effects on the recruitment rate of 48 commercial United States fish stocks with nonstationary per‐capita recruitment, environmental indices from two Atlantic and three Pacific regions are incorporated into a state‐space dynamic Ricker stock‐recruitment model. We developed two model variants for incorporating climate into the state‐space model, one based on the climate variable itself and the other on its rate of change. Simulation tests indicated that if the true system has a climate driver, most of the time a climate‐enhanced model will detect it. However, the different model variants may have similar statistical support, such that model selection may be unable to distinguish the ecological hypotheses of the climate‐recruitment interaction. For 35 (73%) of the true stock time series, at least one environmental variable was identified as nominally significant for improving on the non‐climate dynamic model. The simulation results indicate that the identified environmental indices likely do impact recruitment of the given stocks, even if the form of that effect may not be clearly identified. Our results can now support more detailed stock‐specific analyses of fisheries dynamics, climate drivers, model specification and ultimately management action in the future.
- Open Access
- 20 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Pilot study on the differential accumulation of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and legacy organochlorines in common dolphins (Delphinus delphis) from the Celtic Seas ecoregion: considerations for future monitoring
Common dolphins (Delphinus delphis) are marine sentinels employed to better inform the health status of the marine environment. This study examined contaminants in blubber and hepatic tissues from individuals sampled in the OSPAR Celtic Seas Region. It provides novel insights into tissue-specific accumulation, congener profiles, and biologically driven variability by integrating historical and contemporary datasets from both lipid- and protein-affinity pollutant classes. A suite of 32 PFAS congeners was detected, PFBS and HPFHpA occurred exclusively in blubber, suggesting some lipid affinity. Hepatic ∑PFAS6 concentrations were higher and more variable than in blubber, confirming the liver as the optimal matrix. Hepatic ∑PFAS7 profiles were related to age, sex, and maturity status. PFOS (C8) and PFOSA (C8) dominated hepatic burdens, particularly in sexually immature males. Longer-chain PFAS (PFUnA, PFDA, PFTrA) were found to be proportionally higher in mature individuals. Assessment of blubber PCBs highlighted limitations of the commonly used proxy suite: ICES7. CB149 and CB187 ranked among the top-five congeners detected. With the exception of PFOS, integrated analysis revealed minimal correlation between PFAS7 and legacy organochlorines (ICES7 CBs, ∑DDT), both within and across tissues, reflecting differing physicochemical properties such as binding affinity and lipophilicity, and potentially distinct exposure pathways. These findings have implications for toxicological risk assessment, as co-exposure to compounds with differing toxicokinetics may lead to distinct or synergistic effects within individuals. This study serves to provide evidence of pollutant burdens and impacts in top sentinel species in support of evaluating Good Environmental Status under the EU Marine Strategies Framework Directive.
- 20 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessPilot study on the differential accumulation of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and legacy organochlorines in common dolphins (Delphinus delphis) from the Celtic Seas ecoregion: considerations for future monitoring
Common dolphins (Delphinus delphis) are marine sentinels employed to better inform the health status of the marine environment. This study examined contaminants in blubber and hepatic tissues from individuals sampled in the OSPAR Celtic Seas Region. It provides novel insights into tissue-specific accumulation, congener profiles, and biologically driven variability by integrating historical and contemporary datasets from both lipid- and protein-affinity pollutant classes. A suite of 32 PFAS congeners was detected, PFBS and HPFHpA occurred exclusively in blubber, suggesting some lipid affinity. Hepatic ∑PFAS6 concentrations were higher and more variable than in blubber, confirming the liver as the optimal matrix. Hepatic ∑PFAS7 profiles were related to age, sex, and maturity status. PFOS (C8) and PFOSA (C8) dominated hepatic burdens, particularly in sexually immature males. Longer-chain PFAS (PFUnA, PFDA, PFTrA) were found to be proportionally higher in mature individuals. Assessment of blubber PCBs highlighted limitations of the commonly used proxy suite: ICES7. CB149 and CB187 ranked among the top-five congeners detected. With the exception of PFOS, integrated analysis revealed minimal correlation between PFAS7 and legacy organochlorines (ICES7 CBs, ∑DDT), both within and across tissues, reflecting differing physicochemical properties such as binding affinity and lipophilicity, and potentially distinct exposure pathways. These findings have implications for toxicological risk assessment, as co-exposure to compounds with differing toxicokinetics may lead to distinct or synergistic effects within individuals. This study serves to provide evidence of pollutant burdens and impacts in top sentinel species in support of evaluating Good Environmental Status under the EU Marine Strategies Framework Directive.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (4)
Trends in Lusitanian and boreal marine fish assemblages in the Celtic Seas ecoregion in the context of fisheries management and environmental change
Ocean warming is expected to drive shifts in fish species distributions, with Lusitanian (warm water) species expanding northward and Boreal (cold water) species retreating in the Northeast Atlantic. This study analysed data from International Bottom Trawl surveys to investigate community-level trends in marine fish populations in the Celtic Seas Ecoregion around Ireland. Using a simple community analysis approach, we investigated if previously reported shifts in the distribution of Lusitanian and Boreal species persisted after a period of temporary cooling and the introduction of fisheries management measures in the region. We then re-estimated trends using a random walk model to account for spatial variability and used dynamic factor analysis to identify common trends across species. No clear community-wide shifts in distributions of Lusitanian and Boreal species were detected, instead, abundance changes were localised and species specific. Significant increases in Lusitanian species were observed in the southeast (ICES area 7g) where both sea surface and near-bottom temperatures have shown some evidence of warming. Several commercially exploited species including European anchovy (Engraulis encrasicolus), hake (Merluccius merluccius), and elasmobranchs such as thornback ray (Raja clavata) showed strong increasing trends. Post-2007 cooling in water temperatures followed by renewed warming, together with management measures may have moderated large-scale biogeographic shifts while facilitating recovery of certain stocks. Overall, changes in fish community composition around Ireland appear to reflect complex interactions between environmental variability and fisheries management.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (4)
Open AccessTrends in Lusitanian and boreal marine fish assemblages in the Celtic Seas ecoregion in the context of fisheries management and environmental change
Ocean warming is expected to drive shifts in fish species distributions, with Lusitanian (warm water) species expanding northward and Boreal (cold water) species retreating in the Northeast Atlantic. This study analysed data from International Bottom Trawl surveys to investigate community-level trends in marine fish populations in the Celtic Seas Ecoregion around Ireland. Using a simple community analysis approach, we investigated if previously reported shifts in the distribution of Lusitanian and Boreal species persisted after a period of temporary cooling and the introduction of fisheries management measures in the region. We then re-estimated trends using a random walk model to account for spatial variability and used dynamic factor analysis to identify common trends across species. No clear community-wide shifts in distributions of Lusitanian and Boreal species were detected, instead, abundance changes were localised and species specific. Significant increases in Lusitanian species were observed in the southeast (ICES area 7g) where both sea surface and near-bottom temperatures have shown some evidence of warming. Several commercially exploited species including European anchovy (Engraulis encrasicolus), hake (Merluccius merluccius), and elasmobranchs such as thornback ray (Raja clavata) showed strong increasing trends. Post-2007 cooling in water temperatures followed by renewed warming, together with management measures may have moderated large-scale biogeographic shifts while facilitating recovery of certain stocks. Overall, changes in fish community composition around Ireland appear to reflect complex interactions between environmental variability and fisheries management.
- Open Access
- 6 March 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (3)
Disentangling the effects of climate, population dynamics, and fishing on the body size of key commercially important species in the Celtic Sea Ecoregion
Shrinking body size is proposed as a universal response to warming among marine ectotherms. However, in fish, body size is determined by multiple interacting factors which must be disentangled to predict how climate change will impact populations. This study investigated length variability and its drivers in commercially important demersal species across three areas within the Celtic Sea Ecoregion: the North of Ireland/Malin Sea, West of Ireland, and the Celtic Sea, over two decades (2003–2023). Mixed-effects models were used to partition length variability into its intrinsic (age, sex) and extrinsic components. Generalised additive models were used to link length variability to extrinsic factors (temperature, abundance, recruitment, fishing pressure and the North Atlantic Oscillation). Results revealed spatial heterogeneity in length-at-age and varying levels of temporal synchrony in length trends within and between species. Density-dependent mechanisms explained a significant proportion of the variability, with smaller mean sizes associated with increases in abundance and recruitment, while fishing effects were generally weak and mostly consistent with density release among survivors. Across species, length was sensitive to fluctuations in environmental variables at both regional (temperature) and broad (North Atlantic Oscillation) scales. The temperature-size rule predicts faster juvenile growth but smaller adult size under warming. Across species, temperature effects on adult size were consistently negative. However, evidence for positive juvenile responses to warming was limited in gadoids, potentially reflecting the exclusion of age-0 fish in early maturing species. These results highlight that the universality of shrinking body size under warming extends across demersal species in the Celtic Sea Ecoregion, while also underscoring the difficulty of disentangling true climate responses from population-based data in complex ecological systems.
- 6 March 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 83 (3)
Open AccessDisentangling the effects of climate, population dynamics, and fishing on the body size of key commercially important species in the Celtic Sea Ecoregion
Shrinking body size is proposed as a universal response to warming among marine ectotherms. However, in fish, body size is determined by multiple interacting factors which must be disentangled to predict how climate change will impact populations. This study investigated length variability and its drivers in commercially important demersal species across three areas within the Celtic Sea Ecoregion: the North of Ireland/Malin Sea, West of Ireland, and the Celtic Sea, over two decades (2003–2023). Mixed-effects models were used to partition length variability into its intrinsic (age, sex) and extrinsic components. Generalised additive models were used to link length variability to extrinsic factors (temperature, abundance, recruitment, fishing pressure and the North Atlantic Oscillation). Results revealed spatial heterogeneity in length-at-age and varying levels of temporal synchrony in length trends within and between species. Density-dependent mechanisms explained a significant proportion of the variability, with smaller mean sizes associated with increases in abundance and recruitment, while fishing effects were generally weak and mostly consistent with density release among survivors. Across species, length was sensitive to fluctuations in environmental variables at both regional (temperature) and broad (North Atlantic Oscillation) scales. The temperature-size rule predicts faster juvenile growth but smaller adult size under warming. Across species, temperature effects on adult size were consistently negative. However, evidence for positive juvenile responses to warming was limited in gadoids, potentially reflecting the exclusion of age-0 fish in early maturing species. These results highlight that the universality of shrinking body size under warming extends across demersal species in the Celtic Sea Ecoregion, while also underscoring the difficulty of disentangling true climate responses from population-based data in complex ecological systems.
- Open Access
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 26 (3) , 372-393
A Comparison of Fleet Dynamics Models for Predicting Fisher Location Choice
Scientific advice for fisheries management rarely takes into account how fishers react to regulations, which can lead to unexpected results and unrealistic expectations of the effectiveness of the management measures. Short‐term decisions about when and where to fish are one of the greatest sources of uncertainty in predicting management outcomes. Several models have been developed to predict how fishers allocate effort in space and time, including mechanistic methods such as gravity and dynamic state variable models, and statistical methods such as random utility and Markov models. These have been individually used to predict effort allocation for various fisheries, but there is no comparative synthesis of their structure and characteristics. We demonstrate strong theoretical links between utility and choice in gravity, random utility, Markov and dynamic state variable models. Using an advanced event‐based simulation framework, we find that mechanistic models bias effort allocation to certain areas when applying commonly used strong assumptions about drivers of effort allocation; and conversely, statistical models accurately predict the distribution of fishing effort under business as usual. However, predictive performance degrades with previously unobserved dynamics, such as a spatial closure. Mechanistic models were less suited to general application under business as usual but provide a useful framework for testing hypotheses about a fishery system in response to policy change. Comparison of simple model formulations yielded significant insight into the characteristics of the models and how they could be used to evaluate alternative management approaches for mixed fisheries.
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 26 (3) , 372-393
Open AccessA Comparison of Fleet Dynamics Models for Predicting Fisher Location Choice
Scientific advice for fisheries management rarely takes into account how fishers react to regulations, which can lead to unexpected results and unrealistic expectations of the effectiveness of the management measures. Short‐term decisions about when and where to fish are one of the greatest sources of uncertainty in predicting management outcomes. Several models have been developed to predict how fishers allocate effort in space and time, including mechanistic methods such as gravity and dynamic state variable models, and statistical methods such as random utility and Markov models. These have been individually used to predict effort allocation for various fisheries, but there is no comparative synthesis of their structure and characteristics. We demonstrate strong theoretical links between utility and choice in gravity, random utility, Markov and dynamic state variable models. Using an advanced event‐based simulation framework, we find that mechanistic models bias effort allocation to certain areas when applying commonly used strong assumptions about drivers of effort allocation; and conversely, statistical models accurately predict the distribution of fishing effort under business as usual. However, predictive performance degrades with previously unobserved dynamics, such as a spatial closure. Mechanistic models were less suited to general application under business as usual but provide a useful framework for testing hypotheses about a fishery system in response to policy change. Comparison of simple model formulations yielded significant insight into the characteristics of the models and how they could be used to evaluate alternative management approaches for mixed fisheries.
- Open Access
- 3 February 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 82 (2)
Gap analysis and review of survey effort disruption in North Sea and North-eastern Atlantic bottom trawl surveys
Fisheries-independent surveys are essential to stock assessment, providing estimates on relative abundance, distribution, and biology of commercially fished species. Environmental, mechanical, and logistical issues can disrupt survey operation and reduce survey effort. We synthesized causes of disruptions to surveys using 25 years of publicly available records for North Sea and North-eastern Atlantic bottom trawl survey operations. We assigned each recorded disruption one of three categories: Spatial—long-term (e.g. windfarms, marine protected areas), Spatial—short-term (e.g. fisheries, mechanical, and legal issues), and random spatial processes (e.g. weather and mechanical issues). Furthermore, we analysed spatiotemporal patterns of survey effort relative to effort targets identified in the survey protocols for bottom trawl surveys in the North Sea and the North-East Atlantic. Lastly, we conducted a case study on the Irish survey (IGFS) to explore the effect of weather, time, and geographic position on the probability of sampling an IGFS station using a binomial generalized additive model. On average, the number of stations sampled was lower than the targets indicated in the sampling protocol for the North Sea and Irish surveys. Weather had consistent effects on effort in all three surveys, implying that their designs are vulnerable to the influence of environmental factors. However, neither storminess (using wave height as a proxy) nor station location was a reliable predictor of sampling probability in the IGFS survey. We provide a framework for analysing the robustness of survey designs to disruption. Our approach could be used in the future to monitor changes in survey effort in relation to protocols, facilitating critical evaluation of survey design efficacy.
- 3 February 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 82 (2)
Open AccessGap analysis and review of survey effort disruption in North Sea and North-eastern Atlantic bottom trawl surveys
Fisheries-independent surveys are essential to stock assessment, providing estimates on relative abundance, distribution, and biology of commercially fished species. Environmental, mechanical, and logistical issues can disrupt survey operation and reduce survey effort. We synthesized causes of disruptions to surveys using 25 years of publicly available records for North Sea and North-eastern Atlantic bottom trawl survey operations. We assigned each recorded disruption one of three categories: Spatial—long-term (e.g. windfarms, marine protected areas), Spatial—short-term (e.g. fisheries, mechanical, and legal issues), and random spatial processes (e.g. weather and mechanical issues). Furthermore, we analysed spatiotemporal patterns of survey effort relative to effort targets identified in the survey protocols for bottom trawl surveys in the North Sea and the North-East Atlantic. Lastly, we conducted a case study on the Irish survey (IGFS) to explore the effect of weather, time, and geographic position on the probability of sampling an IGFS station using a binomial generalized additive model. On average, the number of stations sampled was lower than the targets indicated in the sampling protocol for the North Sea and Irish surveys. Weather had consistent effects on effort in all three surveys, implying that their designs are vulnerable to the influence of environmental factors. However, neither storminess (using wave height as a proxy) nor station location was a reliable predictor of sampling probability in the IGFS survey. We provide a framework for analysing the robustness of survey designs to disruption. Our approach could be used in the future to monitor changes in survey effort in relation to protocols, facilitating critical evaluation of survey design efficacy.