PRPenny S. Reynolds

Penny S. Reynolds

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Penny S. Reynolds has a total of 101 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Reporting and transparency in laboratory animal science: Past achievements, present concerns and future directions

    by Penny S. Reynolds, Esther J. Pearl

    Transparent reporting of animal research is both a scientific and ethical imperative and is linked to both research quality and the principles of Replacement, Reduction, and Refinement (3Rs). Persistent concerns about poor reproducibility, limited translation and research waste have driven reforms in reporting standards and data-sharing requirements. However, despite considerable progress over the past 60 years, substantial gaps remain. Many published studies still lack essential methodological detail, such as animal characteristics, welfare measures, bias minimization methods (such as randomization and blinding), and sample size justification. Non-reporting of negative or null results further distorts the evidence base. A major barrier to change has been inadequate training of researchers in best practices for experimental design and statistical analysis. We describe how standardized reporting frameworks can promote research quality and highlight tools available to assist the researcher in implementing best practices in study design, reporting, and data accessibility. Over the next decade, emerging applications such as automated compliance tools and AI-assisted screening will offer scalable approaches to adoption of reporting standards. Preclinical science itself will be profoundly altered by advances in alternative models, open data, and linked machine-readable research outputs that will shift the research culture from isolated studies to an integrated cumulative evidence ecosystem. However, an expanded evidence base will be of value only if methodological quality is prioritized over novelty. Embedding best practices at study inception coupled with transparency will enhance reproducibility, reduce waste, and strengthen the reliability and translational value of animal research.

  • Open Access

    Experimental Designs for Preclinical Neuroscience Experiments: Part 2—Blocking and Blocked Designs

    by P. S. Reynolds

    Blocking is a key statistical method introduced almost a century ago by Ronald Fisher. Blocking controls the effect of “nuisance” variables that are not of direct interest but introduce unwanted variation into the experimental response. Block factors, such as cage, litter, or time, are used to group experimental units into homogeneous subsets. There are two types of block designs: complete and incomplete. In complete block designs every treatment appears in every block. Examples include the Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) with a single block factor, and variants such as Latin square and Graeco-Latin square designs with multiple block factors. RCBDs are simple, flexible, and the most widely used. Replicated and nested Latin square designs allow more rigorous control of complex nuisance structures with minimal sample size. Incomplete block designs are extremely useful when practical constraints (e.g., caging density or varying litter sizes) restrict complete treatment replication across all blocks. Because not all treatments appear in every block, these designs require computer-generated allocation plans to obtain optimum balance and efficiency. Each of the seven blocking designs described in this paper includes a practical example from the research literature, the corresponding skeleton analysis of variance and R code for random allocation plans. By increasing precision and power to detect treatment effects, blocking promotes ethical research by maximizing the amount of information for a minimum number of animals, supporting the 3Rs principle of Reduction.

  • Open Access

    Experimental Designs for Preclinical Neuroscience Experiments: Part I—Design Basics

    by P. S. Reynolds

    Rigorous, statistically grounded experimental design is central to ethical and effective animal research. Foundational principles for statistically based Design of Experiments (DOE) were established over a century ago by Sir Ronald Fisher. They have since been augmented by modern computational tools that now enable researchers to implement designs that maximize scientific information and benefit while minimizing harms. However, many preclinical investigators are unfamiliar with formal DOE methods. Poorly designed experiments followed by inappropriate statistical analyses contribute to poor reproducibility, translational failure, and unnecessary animal use. This first paper in a three-part series introduces neuroscience researchers to the fundamentals of statistically based experimental design as a substitute for traditional two-group comparisons. Key components of a designed experiment are defined, along with the importance of correctly identifying experimental units to avoid pseudo-replication. Fisher's three essential design principles—randomization, replication, and blocking—are presented as nonoptional practices for controlling bias, managing variation, and ensuring valid statistical inferences. Particular emphasis is placed on probability-based random allocation, the use of validated computer-generated randomization plans, and the role of blocking in reducing nuisance variation. By embedding robust design principles early in study planning, researchers can produce reliable, reproducible, and ethically justifiable data. Subsequent papers in the series will expand on methods for controlling unwanted variation through blocking (Part 2) and outline flexible multivariable design strategies (Part 3). Worked examples and R code are included.

  • Compassion Fatigue Rounds (CFR): A Proactive Brief Intervention to Introduce Mental Health Awareness in a Veterinary Clerkship

    by Janet L. Sosnicki, Penny S. Reynolds

    The mental health and well-being of veterinary students and graduate veterinarians is a critical area of concern. Veterinary students experience high levels of psychological distress, particularly during transitional periods such as clinical training. While mental health interventions typically target pre-clinical years, the unique challenges faced by clinical students are often overlooked, resulting in inadequate support during important periods of professional development. To address this gap, Compassion Fatigue Rounds (CFR) were introduced. CFR is a proactive, integrated intervention within one clinical clerkship program. The rounds address compassion fatigue, burnout, and self-care practices through a small group discussion facilitated by the clinical instructor. An evaluation of CFR was conducted through anonymous online student surveys administered between March and September 2023. Following CFR, students self-reported an increase in knowledge, confidence, and preparedness regarding the mental health challenges in veterinary medicine. Students overwhelmingly reported positive experiences, pointing to the potential effectiveness of CFR in educating, engaging, and supporting clinical students on mental health well-being. This study offers preliminary evidence for integrating mental health education into the clinical year curriculum and serves as a practical guide for clinical instructors.


  • Development of a Prognostic Prediction Model for Clinically Significant Prostate Cancer Based on Lesion Zone and Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Value Quantification

    by Rani Ashouri, Penny S. Reynolds, Shay Rajavel, Kunal Hanchate, William Snead, John M. DiBianco, Jason Joseph, Paul Crispen, Padraic O'MAlley, Joseph R. Grajo, et al.

  • Study design: think ‘scientific value’ not ‘p-values’

    by Penny S Reynolds

    Statistically based experimental designs have been available for over a century. However, many preclinical researchers are completely unaware of these methods, and the success of experiments is usually equated only with ‘ p < 0.05’. By contrast, a well-thought-out experimental design strategy provides data with evidentiary and scientific value. A value-based strategy requires implementation of statistical design principles coupled with basic project management techniques. This article outlines the three phases of a value-based design strategy: proper framing of the research question, statistically based operationalisation through careful selection and structuring of appropriate inputs, and incorporation of methods that minimise bias and process variation. Appropriate study design increases study validity and the evidentiary strength of the results, reduces animal numbers, and reduces waste from noninformative experiments. Statistically based experimental design is thus a key component of the ‘Reduction’ pillar of the 3R (Replacement, Reduction, Refinement) principles for ethical animal research.


  • Laboratory Animals presents Special Issue Biostatistics Notes

    by Romain-Daniel Gosselin, Penny S Reynolds

  • Urinalysis and culture results of free‐catch urine samples in dogs: a randomised controlled trial

    by W. W. Mandese, M. Suero, P. S. Reynolds, S. Kariyawasam, S. Beatty, F. Griffin

    Objectives: To evaluate the prevalence of bacterial presence in free-catch urine samples preceded by either a standardised prepped ("clean-catch") protocol versus unprepped (non-cleaned) voiding. Materials and Methods: The study was a single-centre prospective single-blinded randomised controlled trial. Urine samples were obtained from 100 client-owned dogs presenting for routine evaluation. Dogs were randomly assigned to either the prepped group (preputial or peri-vulvar area cleaned with sterile saline before collection) or the unprepped group (no preliminary cleansing) stratified by sex. Urinalysis and urine culture (blood and MacConkey agar) were performed on all samples. Significant bacterial presence on urine culture was defined as >10(4) colony forming units (CFU)/mL. Results: There were no statistically significant associations between prepped versus unprepped collection method or sex with a urinalysis positive for bacteriuria. However, on culture, significant bacterial growth was almost five times more likely to be associated with males relative to females (odds ratio 4.59, 95% confidence interval 1.61 to 13.10). The probability of finding a positive culture was not statistically associated with prep method (odds ratio 1.43, 95% confidence interval 0.50 to 4.08). Clinical Significance: For the majority of dogs without clinical signs of urinary tract infection, free-catch urine collection does not result in significant bacteriuria found on analysis or culture. The presence of bacteria found in free-catch samples may be secondary to sample contamination or subclinical bacteriuria. Sample contamination or subclinical bacteriuria may be more prevalent in male dogs.