Windo Hutabarat
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Windo Hutabarat has a total of 45 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ashutosh Tiwari
School of Mechanical, Aerospace and Civil Engineering, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, U.K.
12 shared publications - Divya Tiwari
School of Mechanical, Aerospace and Civil Engineering, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, U.K.
7 shared publications - Christopher Turner
Surrey Business School, University of Surrey, Guildford GU2 7XH, UK
5 shared publications - John Oyekan
University of York
4 shared publications Ashutosh Tiwari
3 shared publications- Adrian Leyland
The University of Sheffield
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 19 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Manufacturing Systems
- Vol. 87, 48-61
Mapping technological advances in drilling for aircraft manufacturing: A hybrid bibliometric and expert-guided review
- 19 May 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Manufacturing Systems
- Vol. 87, 48-61
Mapping technological advances in drilling for aircraft manufacturing: A hybrid bibliometric and expert-guided review
- 16 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Surface and Coatings Technology
- Vol. 525
Analysis of sensing modalities for Electrode-Induction Gas atomisation of metal powders
- 16 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Surface and Coatings Technology
- Vol. 525
Analysis of sensing modalities for Electrode-Induction Gas atomisation of metal powders
- 17 December 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters
- Vol. 11 (2) , 1874-1881
Physics-Informed Passive Motion Paradigm for Parallel Robots: A High-Precision Motor-Primitives Framework
Complex embodied systems, whether biological or robotic, must continuously generate goal-directed behaviors while preserving coherence between motor intention and physical feasibility. In parallel robots, this link between intention and mechanics becomes particularly challenging due to their nonlinear, over-constrained kinematics and the absence of intuitive motor primitives. This letter introduces a passive motion paradigm for parallel robots using self-supervised physics-informed neural networks, which reformulates motion generation as the dynamic unfolding of motor primitives driven by attractor fields in actuator space. Unlike traditional forward or optimization-based formulations, the framework integrates analytical kinematics with neural fields to ensure both physical consistency and adaptive motion generation. The method estimates the Jacobian matrix as a physically constrained neural field, merging analytical structure with data-driven learning to achieve robust and interpretable behavior without relying on iterative numerical solvers. Theoretical analysis, simulations, and physical experiments demonstrate the framework's accuracy, stability, and adaptability across different parallel mechanisms.
- 17 December 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters
- Vol. 11 (2) , 1874-1881
Physics-Informed Passive Motion Paradigm for Parallel Robots: A High-Precision Motor-Primitives Framework
Complex embodied systems, whether biological or robotic, must continuously generate goal-directed behaviors while preserving coherence between motor intention and physical feasibility. In parallel robots, this link between intention and mechanics becomes particularly challenging due to their nonlinear, over-constrained kinematics and the absence of intuitive motor primitives. This letter introduces a passive motion paradigm for parallel robots using self-supervised physics-informed neural networks, which reformulates motion generation as the dynamic unfolding of motor primitives driven by attractor fields in actuator space. Unlike traditional forward or optimization-based formulations, the framework integrates analytical kinematics with neural fields to ensure both physical consistency and adaptive motion generation. The method estimates the Jacobian matrix as a physically constrained neural field, merging analytical structure with data-driven learning to achieve robust and interpretable behavior without relying on iterative numerical solvers. Theoretical analysis, simulations, and physical experiments demonstrate the framework's accuracy, stability, and adaptability across different parallel mechanisms.
- 28 November 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 74 (00189456) , 1-12
The Development of a Miniaturized Spectroscopic Reflectance System for Thin-Film Multilayer Thickness Measurements
The in-process inspection of multilayer thin-film thickness across the width of a substrate is a requirement in roll-to-roll (R2R) manufacturing. However, the current inspection systems present limitations related to the nature of the techniques, in addition to the low scalability, modularity, high cost and complexity of implementation on the manufacturing floor. This work introduces the in-house development of a dimension-reduced and modular, single-sensor reflectometer instrument, enabling precise measurement of individual layers within multi-layer coated samples. This work includes the development of a new hardware design integrating a microprocessor, a light source, a logic converter and a spectrometer sensor; additionally, a unique software platform was developed to perform near real-time multilayer coating thickness measurements. Seven electrodeposited samples were created for testing and validation purposes. The results of more than one hundred and thirty measurements per sample show that the thickness of an Indium Tin Oxide (ITO) layer ranged between 125.48 to 138.82 ± 2.87 nm, achieving less than 7% error compared to vendor specifications (specification: 130 nm). Additionally, the thickness measurements from the sensor revealed a linear response of the Poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene):Poly sodium 4-styrene sulfonate (PEDOT:PSS) layer with increasing electrodeposition charge, resulting in thicknesses ranging from 201.47 to 506.03 ± 2.73 nm. The successful thickness single-point measurements lay the foundations for the development multi-sensor array to allow thickness measurements along the full width of coated substrates in R2R manufacturing.
- 28 November 2025
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement
- Vol. 74 (00189456) , 1-12
The Development of a Miniaturized Spectroscopic Reflectance System for Thin-Film Multilayer Thickness Measurements
The in-process inspection of multilayer thin-film thickness across the width of a substrate is a requirement in roll-to-roll (R2R) manufacturing. However, the current inspection systems present limitations related to the nature of the techniques, in addition to the low scalability, modularity, high cost and complexity of implementation on the manufacturing floor. This work introduces the in-house development of a dimension-reduced and modular, single-sensor reflectometer instrument, enabling precise measurement of individual layers within multi-layer coated samples. This work includes the development of a new hardware design integrating a microprocessor, a light source, a logic converter and a spectrometer sensor; additionally, a unique software platform was developed to perform near real-time multilayer coating thickness measurements. Seven electrodeposited samples were created for testing and validation purposes. The results of more than one hundred and thirty measurements per sample show that the thickness of an Indium Tin Oxide (ITO) layer ranged between 125.48 to 138.82 ± 2.87 nm, achieving less than 7% error compared to vendor specifications (specification: 130 nm). Additionally, the thickness measurements from the sensor revealed a linear response of the Poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene):Poly sodium 4-styrene sulfonate (PEDOT:PSS) layer with increasing electrodeposition charge, resulting in thicknesses ranging from 201.47 to 506.03 ± 2.73 nm. The successful thickness single-point measurements lay the foundations for the development multi-sensor array to allow thickness measurements along the full width of coated substrates in R2R manufacturing.
- Open Access
A Spectroscopic Reflectance-Based Low-Cost Thickness Measurement System for Thin Films: Development and Testing
The requirement for alternatives in roll-to-roll (R2R) processing to expand thin film inspection in wider substrates at lower costs and reduced dimensions, and the need to enable newer control feedback options for these types of processes, represents an opportunity to explore the applicability of newer reduced-size spectrometers sensors. This paper presents the hardware and software development of a novel low-cost spectroscopic reflectance system using two state-of-the-art sensors for thin film thickness measurements. The parameters to enable the thin film measurements using the proposed system are the light intensity for two LEDs, the microprocessor integration time for both sensors and the distance from the thin film standard to the device light channel slit for reflectance calculations. The proposed system can deliver better-fit errors compared with a HAL/DEUT light source using two methods: curve fitting and interference interval. By enabling the curve fitting method, the lowest root mean squared error (RMSE) obtained for the best combination of components was 0.022 and the lowest normalised mean squared error (MSE) was 0.054. The interference interval method showed an error of 0.09 when comparing the measured with the expected modelled value. The proof of concept in this research work enables the expansion of multi-sensor arrays for thin film thickness measurements and the potential application in moving environments.
Open AccessA Spectroscopic Reflectance-Based Low-Cost Thickness Measurement System for Thin Films: Development and Testing
The requirement for alternatives in roll-to-roll (R2R) processing to expand thin film inspection in wider substrates at lower costs and reduced dimensions, and the need to enable newer control feedback options for these types of processes, represents an opportunity to explore the applicability of newer reduced-size spectrometers sensors. This paper presents the hardware and software development of a novel low-cost spectroscopic reflectance system using two state-of-the-art sensors for thin film thickness measurements. The parameters to enable the thin film measurements using the proposed system are the light intensity for two LEDs, the microprocessor integration time for both sensors and the distance from the thin film standard to the device light channel slit for reflectance calculations. The proposed system can deliver better-fit errors compared with a HAL/DEUT light source using two methods: curve fitting and interference interval. By enabling the curve fitting method, the lowest root mean squared error (RMSE) obtained for the best combination of components was 0.022 and the lowest normalised mean squared error (MSE) was 0.054. The interference interval method showed an error of 0.09 when comparing the measured with the expected modelled value. The proof of concept in this research work enables the expansion of multi-sensor arrays for thin film thickness measurements and the potential application in moving environments.
- Open Access
Implementation of a Flexible and Lightweight Depth-Based Visual Servoing Solution for Feature Detection and Tracing of Large, Spatially-Varying Manufacturing Workpieces
This work proposes a novel solution for detecting and tracing spatially varying edges of large manufacturing workpieces, using a consumer grade RGB depth camera, with only a partial view of the workpiece and without prior knowledge. The proposed system can visually detect and trace various edges, with a wide array of degrees, to an accuracy of 15 mm or less, without the need for any previous information, setup or planning. A combination of physical experiments on the setup and more complex simulated experiments were conducted. The effectiveness of the system is demonstrated via simulated and physical experiments carried out on both acute and obtuse edges, as well as typical aerospace structures, made from a variety of materials, with dimensions ranging from 400 mm to 600 mm. Simulated results show that, with artificial noise added, the solution presented can detect aerospace structures to an accuracy of 40 mm or less, depending on the amount of noise present, while physical aerospace inspired structures can be traced with a consistent accuracy of 5 mm regardless of the cardinal direction. Compared to current industrial solutions, the lack of required planning and robustness of edge detection means it should be able to complete tasks more quickly and easily than the current standard, with a lower financial and computational cost than the current techniques being used within.
Open AccessImplementation of a Flexible and Lightweight Depth-Based Visual Servoing Solution for Feature Detection and Tracing of Large, Spatially-Varying Manufacturing Workpieces
This work proposes a novel solution for detecting and tracing spatially varying edges of large manufacturing workpieces, using a consumer grade RGB depth camera, with only a partial view of the workpiece and without prior knowledge. The proposed system can visually detect and trace various edges, with a wide array of degrees, to an accuracy of 15 mm or less, without the need for any previous information, setup or planning. A combination of physical experiments on the setup and more complex simulated experiments were conducted. The effectiveness of the system is demonstrated via simulated and physical experiments carried out on both acute and obtuse edges, as well as typical aerospace structures, made from a variety of materials, with dimensions ranging from 400 mm to 600 mm. Simulated results show that, with artificial noise added, the solution presented can detect aerospace structures to an accuracy of 40 mm or less, depending on the amount of noise present, while physical aerospace inspired structures can be traced with a consistent accuracy of 5 mm regardless of the cardinal direction. Compared to current industrial solutions, the lack of required planning and robustness of edge detection means it should be able to complete tasks more quickly and easily than the current standard, with a lower financial and computational cost than the current techniques being used within.
- Open Access
A Knowledge-Based Cognitive Architecture Supported by Machine Learning Algorithms for Interpretable Monitoring of Large-Scale Satellite Networks
Cyber–physical systems such as satellite telecommunications networks generate vast amounts of data and currently, very crude data processing is used to extract salient information. Only a small subset of data is used reactively by operators for troubleshooting and finding problems. Sometimes, problematic events in the network may go undetected for weeks before they are reported. This becomes even more challenging as the size of the network grows due to the continuous proliferation of Internet of Things type devices. To overcome these challenges, this research proposes a knowledge-based cognitive architecture supported by machine learning algorithms for monitoring satellite network traffic. The architecture is capable of supporting and augmenting infrastructure engineers in finding and understanding the causes of faults in network through the fusion of the results of machine learning models and rules derived from human domain experience. The system is characterised by (1) the flexibility to add new or extend existing machine learning algorithms to meet the user needs, (2) an enhanced pattern recognition and prediction through the support of machine learning algorithms and the expert knowledge on satellite infrastructure, (3) the ability to adapt to changing conditions of the satellite network, and (4) the ability to augment satellite engineers through interpretable results. An industrial real-life satellite case study is provided to demonstrate how the architecture could be used. A single blind experimental methodology was used to validate the results generated by our approach.
Open AccessA Knowledge-Based Cognitive Architecture Supported by Machine Learning Algorithms for Interpretable Monitoring of Large-Scale Satellite Networks
Cyber–physical systems such as satellite telecommunications networks generate vast amounts of data and currently, very crude data processing is used to extract salient information. Only a small subset of data is used reactively by operators for troubleshooting and finding problems. Sometimes, problematic events in the network may go undetected for weeks before they are reported. This becomes even more challenging as the size of the network grows due to the continuous proliferation of Internet of Things type devices. To overcome these challenges, this research proposes a knowledge-based cognitive architecture supported by machine learning algorithms for monitoring satellite network traffic. The architecture is capable of supporting and augmenting infrastructure engineers in finding and understanding the causes of faults in network through the fusion of the results of machine learning models and rules derived from human domain experience. The system is characterised by (1) the flexibility to add new or extend existing machine learning algorithms to meet the user needs, (2) an enhanced pattern recognition and prediction through the support of machine learning algorithms and the expert knowledge on satellite infrastructure, (3) the ability to adapt to changing conditions of the satellite network, and (4) the ability to augment satellite engineers through interpretable results. An industrial real-life satellite case study is provided to demonstrate how the architecture could be used. A single blind experimental methodology was used to validate the results generated by our approach.
- Open Access
- 2 April 2021
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 140-152
High-Load Titanium Drilling Using an Accurate Robotic Machining System
Robotic drilling systems have been used in the manufacture of large aerospace components for a number of years. Systems have been developed by several systems integrators in order to accurately drill materials from CFRP to Titanium. These systems, however, have been unable to achieve large diameter holes in Titanium due to reduced structural stiffness and end effector capabilities. Typically, large holes are either drilled using large cartesian CNC-controlled machines or drilled using automated drilling units (ADU). However, there is a pull from aerospace OEMS to move away from large monolithic machines, in favour of flexible robotic system. Flexible robotic systems provide a number of benefits for large structure assembly. The following report primarily outlines drilling trials conducted on the Accurate Robotic Machining System, during which holes from 25 mm to 32 mm ID were drilled in titanium implementing an empirical test schedule. Additionally, a discussion on the benefits of drilling large diameter holes using flexible robotic platforms.
- 2 April 2021
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 140-152
Open AccessHigh-Load Titanium Drilling Using an Accurate Robotic Machining System
Robotic drilling systems have been used in the manufacture of large aerospace components for a number of years. Systems have been developed by several systems integrators in order to accurately drill materials from CFRP to Titanium. These systems, however, have been unable to achieve large diameter holes in Titanium due to reduced structural stiffness and end effector capabilities. Typically, large holes are either drilled using large cartesian CNC-controlled machines or drilled using automated drilling units (ADU). However, there is a pull from aerospace OEMS to move away from large monolithic machines, in favour of flexible robotic system. Flexible robotic systems provide a number of benefits for large structure assembly. The following report primarily outlines drilling trials conducted on the Accurate Robotic Machining System, during which holes from 25 mm to 32 mm ID were drilled in titanium implementing an empirical test schedule. Additionally, a discussion on the benefits of drilling large diameter holes using flexible robotic platforms.
- 17 September 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology
- Vol. 110 (11-12) , 2893-2911
Real-time discrete event simulation: a framework for an intelligent expert system approach utilising decision trees
- 17 September 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology
- Vol. 110 (11-12) , 2893-2911
Real-time discrete event simulation: a framework for an intelligent expert system approach utilising decision trees
- Open Access
Applying a 6 DoF Robotic Arm and Digital Twin to Automate Fan-Blade Reconditioning for Aerospace Maintenance, Repair, and Overhaul
The UK is home to several major air commercial and transport hubs. As a result, there is a high demand for Maintenance, Repair, and Overhaul (MRO) services to ensure that fleets of aircraft are in airworthy conditions. MRO services currently involve heavy manual labor. This creates bottlenecks, low repeatability, and low productivity. Presented in this paper is an investigation to create an automation cell for the fan-blade reconditioning component of MRO. The design and prototype of the automation cell is presented. Furthermore, a digital twin of the grinding process is developed and used as a tool to explore the required grinding force parameters needed to effectively remove surface material. An integration of a 6-DoF industrial robot with an end-effector grinder and a computer vision system was undertaken. The computer vision system was used for the digitization of the fan-blade surface as well as tracking and guidance of material removal. Our findings reveal that our proposed system can perform material removal, track the state of the fan blade during the reconditioning process and do so within a closed-loop automated robotic work cell.
Open AccessApplying a 6 DoF Robotic Arm and Digital Twin to Automate Fan-Blade Reconditioning for Aerospace Maintenance, Repair, and Overhaul
The UK is home to several major air commercial and transport hubs. As a result, there is a high demand for Maintenance, Repair, and Overhaul (MRO) services to ensure that fleets of aircraft are in airworthy conditions. MRO services currently involve heavy manual labor. This creates bottlenecks, low repeatability, and low productivity. Presented in this paper is an investigation to create an automation cell for the fan-blade reconditioning component of MRO. The design and prototype of the automation cell is presented. Furthermore, a digital twin of the grinding process is developed and used as a tool to explore the required grinding force parameters needed to effectively remove surface material. An integration of a 6-DoF industrial robot with an end-effector grinder and a computer vision system was undertaken. The computer vision system was used for the digitization of the fan-blade surface as well as tracking and guidance of material removal. Our findings reveal that our proposed system can perform material removal, track the state of the fan blade during the reconditioning process and do so within a closed-loop automated robotic work cell.