CCCaroline Catmur

Caroline Catmur

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Recognitions

Top Cited Scholar (2023,2025)

Caroline Catmur has a total of 229 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    A Reliable Effect of Alexithymia, but Not Autism, on Placebo Hypoalgesia

    by Eri Ichijo, Michel-Pierre Coll, Caroline Catmur, Geoffrey Bird

    Perception of pain can be altered by one’s expectations of that pain, producing well-known phenomena such as placebo effects. It has been suggested that perceptual inference functions differently in autism, with perception weighted towards bottom-up sensory evidence rather than top-down expectations. This account would predict reduced placebo effects in autism. However, research also indicates that atypical interoception (perception of bodily sensations) in autism may be better explained by co-occurring alexithymia. This latter finding suggests that any differences in perceptual inference in autism, at least within the interoceptive domain, may be a product of co-occurring alexithymia. We conducted a study in London and Oxford, England, using a placebo hypoalgesia paradigm to assess perceptual inferences in autism and alexithymia. This paradigm permits manipulation of expectations (concerning the magnitude of pain relief) while measuring individual differences in the perception of stimuli (perceived pain). We investigated whether the magnitude of the placebo effect could be explained by autistic and/or alexithymic traits. Ninety-six adults, including autistic people ( n = 28), alexithymic people ( n = 25), and non-autistic, non-alexithymic people ( n = 55) participated in the study. Results showed that alexithymia and trait anxiety were reliable predictors of the magnitude of the placebo effect, but any effect of autism was weaker and unreliable. Results suggest that atypical interoception in alexithymia may explain differences previously thought to relate to autism. Lay Perception of pain can be altered by how one expects that pain to feel, producing well-known phenomena such as placebo effects. Placebo effects occur when a painful sensation is experienced as less painful than it otherwise would be, simply because we expect it to be less painful. Recently, researchers have suggested that the effect of expectation on how we perceive the world is different among the autistic population compared to non-autistic people. We therefore aimed to investigate whether this is the case for pain perception. We conducted a study where we were able to change people’s expectations about how painful an electric shock would be, to see whether this would affect pain perception, and see whether the effect of expectations differs between autistic and non-autistic people. We were also interested in looking at the effect of alexithymia (difficulties in identifying and describing one’s own emotions), which is suggested to affect pain perception and is prevalent in the autistic population. We found that alexithymia and anxiety predicted how susceptible someone was to the placebo effect (i.e., how much expecting a shock would not be painful affected one’s pain perception). These effects were greater than any effect of autism, which was small and unreliable. This study adds to previous research which shows that many of the differences between autistic people and non-autistic people in terms of perceiving bodily sensations, including pain, may be better explained by alexithymia than autism.

  • Open Access

    Who am I playing with? Exploring Idiosyncratic Models of Social Categorisation in Mentalisation

    by Lorenzo Cappiello, Salim Hashmi, Caroline Catmur

    Understanding others’ beliefs and intentions is central to social interaction. Recent work has highlighted the role of individual characteristics (e.g., paranoia) in shaping how people interpret and predict others’ behaviour, yet most existing paradigms rely on simplified stimuli and assume shared or experimenter-defined world models. To address this limitation, we elicited participants’ beliefs about the distribution of two personality dimensions and four player-type clusters in Minecraft and then asked them to rate nine behavioural targets on these dimensions and estimate the likelihood that each target belonged to each cluster. After confirming that trait ratings predicted categorical judgments using multinomial logistic regression, we used participant-specific Bayesian mixture models that combined elicited beliefs with observed trait ratings to predict soft cluster assignments. We compared three model variants, assuming no correlation between traits, a general correlation, or cluster-specific correlations, and contrasted participant-specific (idiosyncratic) priors with group-level priors. Across multiple accuracy and similarity metrics, the idiosyncratic model without trait correlations consistently outperformed alternatives. These findings suggest that participants’ social categorisation is best explained by individualised belief structures operating over relatively independent trait dimensions, with apparent trait interactions emerging primarily at the group level rather than reflecting participant-level inference mechanisms.

  • Open Access

    Associations Between Autism and Self-Reported Dimensions of Interoception

    by Kiera Louise Adams, Caroline Catmur, Geoffrey Bird

    Despite a wealth of research on autism and interoception, there is not a clear consensus about which dimensions of interoception (if any) are related to autism. This study explored whether self-reported interoceptive accuracy, attention and evaluation are related to autism diagnosis and autistic traits. We analysed questionnaire responses from 519 participants, including 232 autistic participants. We found that people with an autism diagnosis had more negative interpretations of their bodily signals than people without an autism diagnosis, and increasing autistic traits in a general population sample were associated with higher interoceptive attention, lower interoceptive accuracy and higher negative interoceptive evaluation. Our findings suggest that interoceptive evaluation should be a priority for future research. Lay Autism is thought to be linked to differences in the way people notice, process and understand signals coming from inside of their bodies. This study explored how both autistic traits and autism diagnoses are associated with the processing of bodily signals. We found that among 519 participants, having more autistic traits meant that people paid more attention to body signals, reported lower accuracy at detecting them and had more negative interpretations of those signals. Autism diagnoses were associated with more negative interpretations of bodily signals.

  • Open Access

    Failure to account for psychiatric symptoms: Implications for the replicability and generalizability of psychological science?

    by Eri Ichijo, Ka Shu Lee, Mirta Stantić, Isabel De Castro, Jennifer Murphy, Aikaterini Vafeiadou, Michael Banissy, Caroline Catmur, Geoffrey Bird

    Background: One of the challenges of psychological research is obtaining a sample representative of the general population. One largely overlooked participant characteristic is sub-clinical levels of psychiatric symptoms. Methods: A series of studies were conducted to assess (i) whether typical psychology study participants had more psychiatric symptoms than the general population, (ii) whether there are sub-groups defined by psychiatric symptoms within the no-diagnosis, no-medication participant pool, and (iii) whether sub-clinical levels of psychiatric symptoms have an effect on standard behavioral tasks. Five UK national datasets ( N > 10,000) were compared to data from psychology study participants (Study 1: n = 872; Study 2: n = 43,094; Study 3: n = 267). Results: Psychology study participants showed significantly higher levels of anxiety and depression and lower well-being, according to four commonly used mental health measures (GHQ-12, PHQ-8, WEMWBS, and WHO-5). Five sub-groups within the psychology study participant group were identified based on symptom levels, ranging from none to significant psychiatric symptoms. These groupings predicted performance on tests of executive function, including the Stroop task and the n-back task, as well as measures of intelligence. Conclusions: This study demonstrates that standard psychology participant pools are unrepresentative and suggests that a failure to account for psychiatric symptoms when recruiting for any psychological study is likely to negatively impact the reproducibility and generalizability of psychological science.


  • Open Access

    Feedback on Mental State Inferences Improves Accuracy and Awareness

    by Bryony Payne, Geoffrey Bird, Caroline Catmur

    Accurate inference of the mental states of others is essential for successful social interaction. Concerningly, previous work shows that humans are less accurate when inferring the views of out-group members relative to in-group members, but are unaware of this difference in accuracy. Across two studies (Experiment 1: n = 142; Experiment 2: n = 90), we asked whether feedback on the accuracy of mental state inferences could increase the accuracy of, and/or recalibrate participants’ confidence in the accuracy of, mental state inferences for outgroup members. Feedback specific to individual targets significantly improved the accuracy of inferences when inferring those targets’ views for both in-group and out-group members but did not generalise to other group members. Furthermore, participants were able to use feedback to calibrate their confidence in the accuracy of their out-group inferences. These results demonstrate that, with targeted feedback, people are more able to understand the minds of both in-group and out-group members and become more aware of their ability to do so.

  • Open Access

    The Role of the Angular Gyrus in Memory for Encoded Perspective and Subjective Re-experiencing

    by Andreea Zaman, Ruby Morton, Paige Seath, Lauren L. White, Anna-Lea Beyer, Ana Massa Villanueva, Arthur Hebb, Caroline Catmur, Charlotte Russell

    Remembering personal events typically involves reconstructing our original first-person perspective, often accompanied by a vivid sense of re-experiencing the past. The angular gyrus (AnG) has been implicated in both perspective reconstruction and subjective memory experience, yet its specific contribution remains unclear. We investigated the role of the AnG across three studies using a behavioural paradigm in which healthy adults (aged 18–35) encoded a naturalistic video. At retrieval, participants judged whether test images matched their original perspective and rated subjective aspects of the experience, including vividness and re-experiencing. In Study 1 (n=42), vividness ratings significantly predicted accurate perspective discrimination. In Study 2 (n=45), offline repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) to the AnG significantly enhanced perspective discrimination relative to control stimulation, with richness of visual imagery predicting performance. In Study 3 (n=28), online rTMS to the AnG produced a non-significant impairment in discrimination, suggesting possible disruption. Re-experiencing ratings predicted successful discrimination of first-person perspective scenes, particularly under AnG stimulation. Across these studies, we show that the AnG supports memory for encoded perspective and contributes to subjective aspects of episodic retrieval. The direction of its influence may depend on stimulation timing and its interaction with broader cortical networks involved in self-referential processing and memory reconstruction.

  • Open Access

    Anti‐social learning: The impact of language on mentalizing

    by Bryony Payne, Geoffrey Bird, Caroline Catmur

    Theories of cultural evolution suggest that humans may learn to represent others' minds through cultural practices including verbal instruction. It has been demonstrated that humans use less sophisticated mental state words when describing out‐group members compared to in‐group members, but whether this impacts on how out‐group members' minds are represented has not yet been determined. The media is one of the main ways in which information about out‐groups is shared; therefore, across three experiments we explored whether the language used in the media to describe out‐groups, specifically language about mental states, shapes how recipients represent the minds of out‐group members. All three experiments measured the extent to which participants represented out‐group members as individuals with distinctive minds. Experiment 1 compared language in a left‐leaning versus a right‐leaning UK news source. Experiment 2 tested the effect of including or omitting mental states or first‐person language, while Experiment 3 examined the impact of varying the amount of mental state language. We show that participants are more prone to take into account each out‐group member's mind when inferring their mental states when mental state language is used to introduce them. This demonstrates the clear role of cultural learning on how people think about others' minds.


  • Open Access

    Information gathering: Dissociable effects of autistic and alexithymic traits in youths aged 6–25 years.

    by Ka Shu Lee, Emily L. Long, Caroline Catmur, Tobias U. Hauser, Geoffrey Bird

    Autistic youths tend to react negatively to uncertain events. Little is known about the cognitive processes associated with this intolerance of uncertainty, most notably the tendency to actively gather information to minimize uncertainty. Past research has relied on self-report measures that may not allow investigation of the multifaceted processes associated with intolerance of uncertainty, including information gathering. Alexithymia (difficulties in identifying and describing one's own emotions) commonly co-occurs with autistic traits, but its role in information gathering has rarely been considered. Accordingly, 97 typically developing youths (aged 6-25 years) performed an information gathering task in which they were asked to gather information to infer socioemotional (emotional state) and nonsocial (clothing preference) information about another person when information gathering was costly versus not costly. Dimensional autistic traits were associated with more information gathering regardless of costs and information type. Computational modeling suggested this may be because of the delayed emergence of subjective costs of information gathering in high autistic trait individuals, resulting in later guesses. Alexithymia was uniquely associated with inconsistent emotional responses to rewards and losses and to reduced information gathering about emotional states when assessed using parent-report measures. Future validation in youths diagnosed with autism is warranted to test the generalizability of the findings. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).


  • Open Access

    Measuring Movement Imitation

    by Divyush Khemka, Caroline Catmur

    This chapter presents a range of techniques for measuring imitation of others’ movements. We consider methods that measure imitative activity during passive action observation; kinematic measures of imitation; stimulus-response compatibility measures of automatic imitation and imitation-inhibition; and more naturalistic measures of mimicry and action synchrony. Throughout the chapter, we discuss the strengths and limitations of these approaches and conclude with a summary of considerations to bear in mind when choosing an experimental technique, or reviewing work involving such measures.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Defining key concepts for mental state attribution

    by François Quesque, Ian Apperly, Renée Baillargeon, Simon Baron-Cohen, Cristina Becchio, Harold Bekkering, Daniel Bernstein, Maxime Bertoux, Geoffrey Bird, Henryk Bukowski, et al.

    The terminology used in discussions on mental state attribution is extensive and lacks consistency. In the current paper, experts from various disciplines collaborate to introduce a shared set of concepts and make recommendations regarding future use.