Eduardo S. A. Santos
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Eduardo S. A. Santos has a total of 300 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Shinichi Nakagawa
Collaboration for Open Science and Synthesis in Ecology and Evolution (COSSEE), Department of Biological Sciences, Faculty of Science, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada
27 shared publications - Malgorzata Lagisz
Collaboration for Open Science and Synthesis in Ecology and Evolution (COSSEE), Department of Biological Sciences, Faculty of Science, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada
11 shared publications - Ayumi Mizuno
Collaboration for Open Science and Synthesis in Ecology and Evolution (COSSEE), Department of Biological Sciences, Faculty of Science, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada
9 shared publications - Benedikt Holtmann
Behavioural Ecology, Faculty of Biology, LMU Munich , Großhaderner Str. 2, Planegg-Martinsried 82152
8 shared publications - Carlos Esteban Lara
Dirección Académica, Escuela de Pregrados, Universidad Nacional de Colombia Sede de La Paz, La Paz 200001, Colombia
8 shared publications - Regina Helena Macedo
Universidade de Brasília
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 November 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Who’s gonna feed the kids? Provisioning alternation in dunnock pairs and trios is largely explained by each parent’s own visiting pattern
Theory suggests that parents sharing the care of a brood can reduce the costs of sexual conflict by conditional cooperation: each parent is more likely to return to the nest after its partner has fed the young than after its own visit, so that visits tend to alternate. Alternation, however, also arises without any response between parents, because it depends on how often and how regularly each parent visits. Whether coordination occurs when more than two adults feed the young is largely unknown. We analyzed 4,376 provisioning visits in 297 nest watches at 163 nests of a population of dunnocks (Prunella modularis) in which females breed with one male (socially monogamous pairs) or two males (socially polyandrous trios). We compared observed alternation with five null models that remove coordination while keeping, to different degrees, the visiting pattern of each bird. Parents alternated on 76.9% of the opportunities in pairs and 73.2% in polyandrous groups. Alternation exceeded the two null models that remove each bird’s own interval structure (by 8.3–14.9 percentage points in pairs), but this excess largely disappeared against the three null models that keep it. In pairs, alternation was 2.5 points above a within-bird reshuffling of intervals (OR = 1.16, 95% CI 0.99–1.35; bootstrap 1.04–1.30), and 0.3 points above a null model that also keeps the temporal order of intervals. Pseudo-pairs of birds from different nests filmed on the same day, which could not respond to each other, showed a similar excess (1.8 points). Alternation between the female and the males of polyandrous groups, and among all three members of trios, did not exceed any of the three null models. Alternation did not differ detectably between pairs and polyandrous groups (OR = 0.90, 95% CI 0.68–1.19), although differences of a few percentage points cannot be excluded. A power simulation showed that the analysis would have detected turn-taking that raised alternation by 3.1 percentage points in pairs. Carers in polyandrous groups were at the nest together less often than expected, but this did not differ detectably from pairs. Dunnock parents, whether in pairs or in trios, show little detectable coordination of their provisioning visits beyond that generated by each bird’s own visiting pattern.
- 12 November 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessWho’s gonna feed the kids? Provisioning alternation in dunnock pairs and trios is largely explained by each parent’s own visiting pattern
Theory suggests that parents sharing the care of a brood can reduce the costs of sexual conflict by conditional cooperation: each parent is more likely to return to the nest after its partner has fed the young than after its own visit, so that visits tend to alternate. Alternation, however, also arises without any response between parents, because it depends on how often and how regularly each parent visits. Whether coordination occurs when more than two adults feed the young is largely unknown. We analyzed 4,376 provisioning visits in 297 nest watches at 163 nests of a population of dunnocks (Prunella modularis) in which females breed with one male (socially monogamous pairs) or two males (socially polyandrous trios). We compared observed alternation with five null models that remove coordination while keeping, to different degrees, the visiting pattern of each bird. Parents alternated on 76.9% of the opportunities in pairs and 73.2% in polyandrous groups. Alternation exceeded the two null models that remove each bird’s own interval structure (by 8.3–14.9 percentage points in pairs), but this excess largely disappeared against the three null models that keep it. In pairs, alternation was 2.5 points above a within-bird reshuffling of intervals (OR = 1.16, 95% CI 0.99–1.35; bootstrap 1.04–1.30), and 0.3 points above a null model that also keeps the temporal order of intervals. Pseudo-pairs of birds from different nests filmed on the same day, which could not respond to each other, showed a similar excess (1.8 points). Alternation between the female and the males of polyandrous groups, and among all three members of trios, did not exceed any of the three null models. Alternation did not differ detectably between pairs and polyandrous groups (OR = 0.90, 95% CI 0.68–1.19), although differences of a few percentage points cannot be excluded. A power simulation showed that the analysis would have detected turn-taking that raised alternation by 3.1 percentage points in pairs. Carers in polyandrous groups were at the nest together less often than expected, but this did not differ detectably from pairs. Dunnock parents, whether in pairs or in trios, show little detectable coordination of their provisioning visits beyond that generated by each bird’s own visiting pattern.
- Open Access
- 15 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Registered Reports as the default pathway for confirmatory publication
By rewarding speed, volume, and coherent positive narratives, traditional publishing incentivizes questionable scientific practices and analytic flexibility. The latter especially contributes to blurring the distinction between exploration and confirmation, which inflates the apparent strength of confirmatory claims. This systemic issue has gone unchecked for decades, leaving the scientific community with a body of scholarly literature that is unreliable and lacking validity. Registered Reports (RRs) address problematic publishing practices by requiring a priori registration of confirmatory tests, which is peer-reviewed before the research begins (stage 1). The editorial acceptance of a stage 1 plan establishes a commitment to publication regardless of research outcomes. Publication remains, nonetheless, contingent on a second peer review and editorial scrutiny (stage 2) to verify that the approved plan was followed, all deviations were transparently disclosed and justified, confirmatory and exploratory claims are clearly delineated, and the integrity of the design was maintained. Meta-scientific comparisons indicate that RRs reduce outcome-based publication bias and improve methodological rigor without compromising perceived novelty. By making accepted RR protocols and their review history citable research outputs, RRs also strengthen recognition for peer-review work. In this perspective, we argue that RRs should become the primary mode of confirmatory publication moving forward.
- 15 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessRegistered Reports as the default pathway for confirmatory publication
By rewarding speed, volume, and coherent positive narratives, traditional publishing incentivizes questionable scientific practices and analytic flexibility. The latter especially contributes to blurring the distinction between exploration and confirmation, which inflates the apparent strength of confirmatory claims. This systemic issue has gone unchecked for decades, leaving the scientific community with a body of scholarly literature that is unreliable and lacking validity. Registered Reports (RRs) address problematic publishing practices by requiring a priori registration of confirmatory tests, which is peer-reviewed before the research begins (stage 1). The editorial acceptance of a stage 1 plan establishes a commitment to publication regardless of research outcomes. Publication remains, nonetheless, contingent on a second peer review and editorial scrutiny (stage 2) to verify that the approved plan was followed, all deviations were transparently disclosed and justified, confirmatory and exploratory claims are clearly delineated, and the integrity of the design was maintained. Meta-scientific comparisons indicate that RRs reduce outcome-based publication bias and improve methodological rigor without compromising perceived novelty. By making accepted RR protocols and their review history citable research outputs, RRs also strengthen recognition for peer-review work. In this perspective, we argue that RRs should become the primary mode of confirmatory publication moving forward.
- Open Access
- 15 October 2026
- Published by The Company of Biologists in Biology Open
- Vol. 15 (10)
Mate choice copying in non-human animals: an update of two meta-analyses
Mate choice copying, the use of social information from others' mating decisions, is a taxonomically widespread form of social learning that can shape sexual selection. Two meta-analyses concluded that social information has a moderate positive effect on mate choice; however, both are based on literature searches that are now at least 7 years old. We asked whether the overall average effect they reported remains supported. Using a multilingual, grey-literature-inclusive search across seven languages, we added 69 effect sizes from 29 studies and harmonised the two source metrics, giving 227 Hedges' g effect sizes from 87 studies and 172 log odds ratios from 69 studies across 33 species. Reanalysed with phylogenetically informed multilevel models, the overall effect remained positive and significant but was appreciably smaller [Hedges' g=0.45, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.25 to 0.66, versus 0.58; odds ratio=1.81, 95% CI: 1.34 to 2.45, versus 2.71]. Heterogeneity was high, located within studies and among species rather than across the phylogeny. Small-study effects were strong on both scales, and correcting for them drew the mean towards zero. In some species, individuals do copy conspecifics' mate choices, but the effect is smaller, more variable, and more sensitive to publication bias than previously estimated.
- 15 October 2026
- Published by The Company of Biologists in Biology Open
- Vol. 15 (10)
Open AccessMate choice copying in non-human animals: an update of two meta-analyses
Mate choice copying, the use of social information from others' mating decisions, is a taxonomically widespread form of social learning that can shape sexual selection. Two meta-analyses concluded that social information has a moderate positive effect on mate choice; however, both are based on literature searches that are now at least 7 years old. We asked whether the overall average effect they reported remains supported. Using a multilingual, grey-literature-inclusive search across seven languages, we added 69 effect sizes from 29 studies and harmonised the two source metrics, giving 227 Hedges' g effect sizes from 87 studies and 172 log odds ratios from 69 studies across 33 species. Reanalysed with phylogenetically informed multilevel models, the overall effect remained positive and significant but was appreciably smaller [Hedges' g=0.45, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.25 to 0.66, versus 0.58; odds ratio=1.81, 95% CI: 1.34 to 2.45, versus 2.71]. Heterogeneity was high, located within studies and among species rather than across the phylogeny. Small-study effects were strong on both scales, and correcting for them drew the mean towards zero. In some species, individuals do copy conspecifics' mate choices, but the effect is smaller, more variable, and more sensitive to publication bias than previously estimated.
- Open Access
- 7 October 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Human disturbance and the magnitude and predictability of phenotypic divergence
Environmental change can drive phenotypic change within species, but it remains unclear whether such responses produce a general and predictable degree of phenotypic divergence across populations. We conducted a preregistered reanalysis of PROCEED v6.2, comprising 7,186 contrasts from 254 references and 253 species, to test whether the magnitude and predictability of phenotypic divergence differ among disturbance contexts and across temporal, biological, and methodological characteristics of studies. We used ln M to quantify phenotypic differences between paired population samples relative to the variation retained within them and fitted phylogenetic location--scale meta-regressions to model average divergence and residual heterogeneity jointly. Across the dataset, average phenotypic divergence was substantial but did not consistently exceed within-population variation, while total heterogeneity reached 96.6%, providing little support for a universal magnitude of divergence. Disturbance contexts differed more strongly in predictability than in average divergence. Landscape change and introduced populations showed greater divergence than in situ natural variation, while landscape change was also comparatively predictable. By contrast, responses to introduced species consistently showed greater variation among contrasts than most other contexts, whereas the lower predictability of hunting or harvesting and in situ natural variation depended partly on a single large Pacific salmon dataset. Moderator associations should be interpreted cautiously because study characteristics were unevenly represented and partly confounded, and some results were sensitive to robustness analyses. Overall, environmental change can produce substantial phenotypic divergence, but neither its magnitude nor its predictability is uniform across systems. Accounting for heterogeneity therefore reveals when broad comparative responses are likely to generalize and when population-specific evidence is required.
- 7 October 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessHuman disturbance and the magnitude and predictability of phenotypic divergence
Environmental change can drive phenotypic change within species, but it remains unclear whether such responses produce a general and predictable degree of phenotypic divergence across populations. We conducted a preregistered reanalysis of PROCEED v6.2, comprising 7,186 contrasts from 254 references and 253 species, to test whether the magnitude and predictability of phenotypic divergence differ among disturbance contexts and across temporal, biological, and methodological characteristics of studies. We used ln M to quantify phenotypic differences between paired population samples relative to the variation retained within them and fitted phylogenetic location--scale meta-regressions to model average divergence and residual heterogeneity jointly. Across the dataset, average phenotypic divergence was substantial but did not consistently exceed within-population variation, while total heterogeneity reached 96.6%, providing little support for a universal magnitude of divergence. Disturbance contexts differed more strongly in predictability than in average divergence. Landscape change and introduced populations showed greater divergence than in situ natural variation, while landscape change was also comparatively predictable. By contrast, responses to introduced species consistently showed greater variation among contrasts than most other contexts, whereas the lower predictability of hunting or harvesting and in situ natural variation depended partly on a single large Pacific salmon dataset. Moderator associations should be interpreted cautiously because study characteristics were unevenly represented and partly confounded, and some results were sensitive to robustness analyses. Overall, environmental change can produce substantial phenotypic divergence, but neither its magnitude nor its predictability is uniform across systems. Accounting for heterogeneity therefore reveals when broad comparative responses are likely to generalize and when population-specific evidence is required.
- Open Access
- 5 October 2026
- Published by Peer Community In in Peer Community Journal
- Vol. 6
prepR4pcm: An R package for preparing data and trees for phylogenetic comparative methods
Phylogenetic comparative methods require species names in a trait dataset to match tip labels in a phylogenetic tree. Yet this apparently simple prerequisite is often one of the most fragile steps in a comparative workflow. Names may differ because of, for example, formatting, taxonomic revisions, synonyms, or spelling errors. If these differences are resolved informally, species can be lost from analyses, and the reasons for their loss can be difficult to reconstruct. Here, we present
- 5 October 2026
- Published by Peer Community In in Peer Community Journal
- Vol. 6
Open AccessprepR4pcm: An R package for preparing data and trees for phylogenetic comparative methods
Phylogenetic comparative methods require species names in a trait dataset to match tip labels in a phylogenetic tree. Yet this apparently simple prerequisite is often one of the most fragile steps in a comparative workflow. Names may differ because of, for example, formatting, taxonomic revisions, synonyms, or spelling errors. If these differences are resolved informally, species can be lost from analyses, and the reasons for their loss can be difficult to reconstruct. Here, we present
- Open Access
- 2 October 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Weak and species-specific morphological change in Atlantic Forest birds across two decades of warming
Birds are widely expected to shrink as the climate warms, but few tropical studies span decades. In the central Amazon, mean body mass fell in all 77 species studied and a third of species lengthened their wings. We analysed 24 years (1995–2018) of morphology from 73 passerine species (12,571 live-capture records; ATLANTIC BIRD TRAITS) across the Brazilian Atlantic Forest, a region that warmed by about 0.25°C per decade. The records came from 47 research programmes whose sites changed over time, so we modelled contributor and municipality explicitly and checked by simulation that these models recover trends planted in the real sampling structure. Unadjusted models suggested a steep wing-length decline and increases in bill width and trait variability. Once sampling turnover was modelled, the wing decline was less than half as steep (−1.0% per decade, 95% credible interval spanning zero), and the bill-width and variability changes disappeared. Body mass declined by 0.9% per decade, close to the mean Amazonian rate of 1.0%, but its interval spanned zero (−2.8 to +1.0%). Responses varied strongly among species, and most species showed no change distinguishable from zero. Wings did not lengthen, and among individuals measured for both traits, mass tended to be retained relative to wing length. Neither trait was associated with interannual temperature anomalies. Atlantic Forest passerines thus show neither the consistent mass loss across species nor the wing elongation reported from the Amazon, although their average mass change is compatible with the Amazonian rate. Compiled trait databases can extend long-term monitoring to under-studied tropical regions, but only when sampling structure is modelled: ignoring it here would have more than doubled the estimated wing decline.
- 2 October 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessWeak and species-specific morphological change in Atlantic Forest birds across two decades of warming
Birds are widely expected to shrink as the climate warms, but few tropical studies span decades. In the central Amazon, mean body mass fell in all 77 species studied and a third of species lengthened their wings. We analysed 24 years (1995–2018) of morphology from 73 passerine species (12,571 live-capture records; ATLANTIC BIRD TRAITS) across the Brazilian Atlantic Forest, a region that warmed by about 0.25°C per decade. The records came from 47 research programmes whose sites changed over time, so we modelled contributor and municipality explicitly and checked by simulation that these models recover trends planted in the real sampling structure. Unadjusted models suggested a steep wing-length decline and increases in bill width and trait variability. Once sampling turnover was modelled, the wing decline was less than half as steep (−1.0% per decade, 95% credible interval spanning zero), and the bill-width and variability changes disappeared. Body mass declined by 0.9% per decade, close to the mean Amazonian rate of 1.0%, but its interval spanned zero (−2.8 to +1.0%). Responses varied strongly among species, and most species showed no change distinguishable from zero. Wings did not lengthen, and among individuals measured for both traits, mass tended to be retained relative to wing length. Neither trait was associated with interannual temperature anomalies. Atlantic Forest passerines thus show neither the consistent mass loss across species nor the wing elongation reported from the Amazon, although their average mass change is compatible with the Amazonian rate. Compiled trait databases can extend long-term monitoring to under-studied tropical regions, but only when sampling structure is modelled: ignoring it here would have more than doubled the estimated wing decline.
- Open Access
- 31 August 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in MetaArXiv
An item bank of reporting items and concepts in evidence synthesis reporting guidelines
Evidence synthesis integrates findings from multiple research studies, and its value for decision making depends on complete, transparent reporting. Authors often rely on reporting guidelines, checklists, flow diagrams, or structured text guiding manuscript reporting, but they still struggle to implement what counts as clear, complete reporting. A central issue is that many guidelines address the same underlying concepts using different wording, making it unclear whether differences between guidelines are meaningful or merely semantic. To address this, we compiled an item bank of 2,249 reporting items from 59 unique evidence synthesis reporting guidelines (from 83 studies, 68 checklists), using a six-step process: literature searching and screening, item collation, readability analysis, concept extraction, and overlap assessment. Compiled items were relatively verbose (mean words/item = 19.9) and linguistically complex (Moving-Average Type-Token Ratio = 0.959), indicating limited reuse of consistent wording—likely making items harder to interpret and compare. Because items can contain multiple concepts, and concepts can recur across items and guidelines, we identified 403 unique reporting concepts. Guidelines also showed modest conceptual overlap (Jaccard Similarity Index = 0.166, n = 1,830 pairwise comparisons), suggesting some concepts were widely shared across reporting guidelines for different methodologies and disciplines, pointing to clear potential to harmonise reporting guidance and reduce duplicated effort. We provide all reporting items and concepts in the supplementary files. We further discuss trends and gaps in item use and wording across guidelines, outline applications of the collated item bank, and note limitations that point to future research. Together, our findings offer much-needed direction for developing and harmonising future reporting guidelines, an essential step toward more consistent and transparent reporting across evidence synthesis.
- 31 August 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in MetaArXiv
Open AccessAn item bank of reporting items and concepts in evidence synthesis reporting guidelines
Evidence synthesis integrates findings from multiple research studies, and its value for decision making depends on complete, transparent reporting. Authors often rely on reporting guidelines, checklists, flow diagrams, or structured text guiding manuscript reporting, but they still struggle to implement what counts as clear, complete reporting. A central issue is that many guidelines address the same underlying concepts using different wording, making it unclear whether differences between guidelines are meaningful or merely semantic. To address this, we compiled an item bank of 2,249 reporting items from 59 unique evidence synthesis reporting guidelines (from 83 studies, 68 checklists), using a six-step process: literature searching and screening, item collation, readability analysis, concept extraction, and overlap assessment. Compiled items were relatively verbose (mean words/item = 19.9) and linguistically complex (Moving-Average Type-Token Ratio = 0.959), indicating limited reuse of consistent wording—likely making items harder to interpret and compare. Because items can contain multiple concepts, and concepts can recur across items and guidelines, we identified 403 unique reporting concepts. Guidelines also showed modest conceptual overlap (Jaccard Similarity Index = 0.166, n = 1,830 pairwise comparisons), suggesting some concepts were widely shared across reporting guidelines for different methodologies and disciplines, pointing to clear potential to harmonise reporting guidance and reduce duplicated effort. We provide all reporting items and concepts in the supplementary files. We further discuss trends and gaps in item use and wording across guidelines, outline applications of the collated item bank, and note limitations that point to future research. Together, our findings offer much-needed direction for developing and harmonising future reporting guidelines, an essential step toward more consistent and transparent reporting across evidence synthesis.
- Open Access
- 25 August 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
The intensity of sexual selection and the absence of assortative mating patterns in Prunella modularis (Aves: Passeriformes)
When females and males prefer large mating partners, a size-assortative mating pattern can occur, and larger individuals tend to obtain more partners, thereby increasing the intensity of sexual selection. Considering this, we studied a population of dunnocks (Prunella modularis), a species with a variable mating system. We tested whether (A) assortativity (based on body size and/or condition) occurs, (B) sexual selection is higher in males than in females, as is typically expected, and (C) the sex ratio influences the strength of selection. Despite assessing multiple breeding seasons (individually and combined), we found no evidence of assortative mating. Because we found little evidence that large (or higher-condition) individuals produce more offspring, there should be no strong preference for body size or condition, and assortativity should not occur, as observed. We also found that males faced stronger sexual selection than females, which conforms to long-standing predictions within sexual selection theory. However, this sex difference was of little to moderate magnitude, which is reasonable for a polygynandrous species. Finally, both sexes faced stronger selection when the sex ratio was more male-biased, indicating that (a) some females are better than others in obtaining more than one mate, even when males are abundantly available, and/or (b) males are more willing to accept co-breeding males as the sex ratio becomes more biased.
- 25 August 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessThe intensity of sexual selection and the absence of assortative mating patterns in Prunella modularis (Aves: Passeriformes)
When females and males prefer large mating partners, a size-assortative mating pattern can occur, and larger individuals tend to obtain more partners, thereby increasing the intensity of sexual selection. Considering this, we studied a population of dunnocks (Prunella modularis), a species with a variable mating system. We tested whether (A) assortativity (based on body size and/or condition) occurs, (B) sexual selection is higher in males than in females, as is typically expected, and (C) the sex ratio influences the strength of selection. Despite assessing multiple breeding seasons (individually and combined), we found no evidence of assortative mating. Because we found little evidence that large (or higher-condition) individuals produce more offspring, there should be no strong preference for body size or condition, and assortativity should not occur, as observed. We also found that males faced stronger sexual selection than females, which conforms to long-standing predictions within sexual selection theory. However, this sex difference was of little to moderate magnitude, which is reasonable for a polygynandrous species. Finally, both sexes faced stronger selection when the sex ratio was more male-biased, indicating that (a) some females are better than others in obtaining more than one mate, even when males are abundantly available, and/or (b) males are more willing to accept co-breeding males as the sex ratio becomes more biased.
- Open Access
- 14 August 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Mate choice copying in non-human animals: an update of two meta-analyses
Mate choice copying, the use of social information from the mating decisions of others, is a taxonomically widespread form of social learning with the potential to shape sexual selection. Two meta-analyses concluded that social information moderately and positively biases mate choice, but both rest on literature searches now at least seven years old. Using a multilingual, grey-literature-inclusive search across seven languages, we added 69 effect sizes from 29 studies to the original datasets and harmonized the two source metrics onto common scales, giving 227 Hedges’ g effect sizes from 87 studies and 172 log odds ratios from 69 studies across 33 species. Re-analysed with phylogenetically informed multilevel models, the overall effect remained positive and significant but was appreciably smaller than before (Hedges’ g = 0.45, 95% CI: 0.25 to 0.66, vs. 0.58; odds ratio = 1.81, 95% CI: 1.34 to 2.45, vs. 2.71). Heterogeneity was high and concentrated within studies and among species, not across the phylogeny. We detected strong small-study effects on both scales, and correcting for them drew the adjusted mean towards zero. Overall, in some species, individuals do copy the mate choices of conspecifics, but the effect is smaller, more variable, and more sensitive to publication bias than previously estimated.
- 14 August 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessMate choice copying in non-human animals: an update of two meta-analyses
Mate choice copying, the use of social information from the mating decisions of others, is a taxonomically widespread form of social learning with the potential to shape sexual selection. Two meta-analyses concluded that social information moderately and positively biases mate choice, but both rest on literature searches now at least seven years old. Using a multilingual, grey-literature-inclusive search across seven languages, we added 69 effect sizes from 29 studies to the original datasets and harmonized the two source metrics onto common scales, giving 227 Hedges’ g effect sizes from 87 studies and 172 log odds ratios from 69 studies across 33 species. Re-analysed with phylogenetically informed multilevel models, the overall effect remained positive and significant but was appreciably smaller than before (Hedges’ g = 0.45, 95% CI: 0.25 to 0.66, vs. 0.58; odds ratio = 1.81, 95% CI: 1.34 to 2.45, vs. 2.71). Heterogeneity was high and concentrated within studies and among species, not across the phylogeny. We detected strong small-study effects on both scales, and correcting for them drew the adjusted mean towards zero. Overall, in some species, individuals do copy the mate choices of conspecifics, but the effect is smaller, more variable, and more sensitive to publication bias than previously estimated.
- Open Access
- 30 July 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Interspecific Bergmann’s rule pattern in birds persists despite seasonal migration
Climatic gradients are thought to shape animal body size, with larger species often occurring in colder environments. Yet trait-climate relationships may reflect current climatic exposure as well as the evolutionary and biogeographic histories that shaped species’ traits. Bergmann’s rule illustrates this challenge, and birds provide a useful test because seasonal migration decouples body size from climatic exposure across breeding and non-breeding seasons. We asked whether migration weakens the interspecific Bergmann’s rule pattern by reducing the negative temperature-body mass slope, or whether migrants instead differ mainly in average body mass. We analysed body mass and seasonal range-climate data for over 10,000 bird species with phylogenetic linear models, comparing resident and migratory species under breeding- and non-breeding-season climate assignments. Body mass declined with temperature in both residents and migrants under both assignments. Migrants showed a slightly shallower slope, but support for a migrant-resident slope difference was limited. Instead, migrants were consistently smaller than residents after accounting for seasonal climatic exposure, and body mass was lower in migrants with larger seasonal temperature shifts. Thus, migration does not appear to erase Bergmann's rule in birds - migratory species retain a negative temperature-body mass relationship while showing a distinct shift toward smaller body size.
- 30 July 2026
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EcoEvoRxiv
Open AccessInterspecific Bergmann’s rule pattern in birds persists despite seasonal migration
Climatic gradients are thought to shape animal body size, with larger species often occurring in colder environments. Yet trait-climate relationships may reflect current climatic exposure as well as the evolutionary and biogeographic histories that shaped species’ traits. Bergmann’s rule illustrates this challenge, and birds provide a useful test because seasonal migration decouples body size from climatic exposure across breeding and non-breeding seasons. We asked whether migration weakens the interspecific Bergmann’s rule pattern by reducing the negative temperature-body mass slope, or whether migrants instead differ mainly in average body mass. We analysed body mass and seasonal range-climate data for over 10,000 bird species with phylogenetic linear models, comparing resident and migratory species under breeding- and non-breeding-season climate assignments. Body mass declined with temperature in both residents and migrants under both assignments. Migrants showed a slightly shallower slope, but support for a migrant-resident slope difference was limited. Instead, migrants were consistently smaller than residents after accounting for seasonal climatic exposure, and body mass was lower in migrants with larger seasonal temperature shifts. Thus, migration does not appear to erase Bergmann's rule in birds - migratory species retain a negative temperature-body mass relationship while showing a distinct shift toward smaller body size.