Barbara A. Doll
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Barbara A. Doll has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- J. Jack Kurki-Fox
Biological and Agricultural Engineering, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC
9 shared publications - Daniel E. Line
Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC 27695, USA
4 shared publications - Andrew Fox
Coastal Dynamics Design Lab, Department of Landscape Architecture and Environmental Planning, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC 27695, USA
2 shared publications David Penrose
Biological and Agricultural Engineering Department, NC State University, Raleigh, NC 27695, USA
2 shared publicationsGregory D. Jennings
Biological & Agricultural Engineering Department North Carolina State University Box 8605 Raleigh North Carolina 27695
2 shared publications- Gregory Jennings
Jennings Environmental, LLC, Apex, NC 27502, USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 5 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2680 (5) , 309-319
Using Rain-on-Grid Hydrodynamic Models and Planning-Level Cost Estimates to Prioritize the Creation of “Resilient Routes”
Recent extreme flooding events in the southeastern United States have revealed serious vulnerabilities across the country’s transportation networks and highlighted the urgent need for upgrades. Flood damage has been widespread and addressing all the vulnerable areas would be cost prohibitive. We propose a methodology that combines rain-on-grid (ROG) hydraulic model output with planning-level cost estimates to quickly evaluate potential routes based on the cost to upgrade to a given return period (e.g., 100 years). The continuous water surface elevation (WSE) output from the ROG model allows for analysis of the entire network for both pluvial and fluvial flood risk. Model simulated WSEs were compared at each bridge and culvert and to each 15-m segment of road length. Costs from previous road projects were used to estimate the cost of upsizing bridges and culverts to no longer overtop and raising road segments above the predicted flooding WSE. Road costs included road embankment fill, paving, curbs, traffic control, marking, and shoulder armoring. Estimated costs were summed for each return period. The costs for upgrading each potential route can be compared across a range of return periods. This approach allows planners to quickly identify critical routes that are already safely passible during extreme events or routes that would likely require the least investment to become “resilient” routes. It also helps to reveal areas where overtopping may create significant risks for motorists and pedestrians. This prioritization approach can substantially reduce the number of corridors that should be considered for more detailed analysis and costing.
- 5 November 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2680 (5) , 309-319
Using Rain-on-Grid Hydrodynamic Models and Planning-Level Cost Estimates to Prioritize the Creation of “Resilient Routes”
Recent extreme flooding events in the southeastern United States have revealed serious vulnerabilities across the country’s transportation networks and highlighted the urgent need for upgrades. Flood damage has been widespread and addressing all the vulnerable areas would be cost prohibitive. We propose a methodology that combines rain-on-grid (ROG) hydraulic model output with planning-level cost estimates to quickly evaluate potential routes based on the cost to upgrade to a given return period (e.g., 100 years). The continuous water surface elevation (WSE) output from the ROG model allows for analysis of the entire network for both pluvial and fluvial flood risk. Model simulated WSEs were compared at each bridge and culvert and to each 15-m segment of road length. Costs from previous road projects were used to estimate the cost of upsizing bridges and culverts to no longer overtop and raising road segments above the predicted flooding WSE. Road costs included road embankment fill, paving, curbs, traffic control, marking, and shoulder armoring. Estimated costs were summed for each return period. The costs for upgrading each potential route can be compared across a range of return periods. This approach allows planners to quickly identify critical routes that are already safely passible during extreme events or routes that would likely require the least investment to become “resilient” routes. It also helps to reveal areas where overtopping may create significant risks for motorists and pedestrians. This prioritization approach can substantially reduce the number of corridors that should be considered for more detailed analysis and costing.
- 31 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2679 (11) , 57-67
Characterizing Extreme Rainfall-Induced Culvert Washouts in North Carolina
Recent hurricane and tropical storm-induced extreme rainfall events have caused hundreds of culvert washouts across North Carolina. These failures present serious vulnerabilities in the transportation network and pose a safety risk. As part of this study, the North Carolina Department of Transportation provided records for 1410 locations where hydraulic structures were reported to have washed out during Hurricanes Matthew and Florence and during extreme flooding in 2020. These records were analyzed to characterize the pre-storm properties of the structures and to identify factors that indicate high washout risk based on a remote desktop analysis. Drainage area, watershed characteristics, structure capacity, and physical parameters were calculated and compiled for all washouts. The same data were also compiled for nearby structures that did not wash out in a six-county area. Results indicated washouts were most common in small watersheds (0.5 mi 2 [2 ]), for secondary roads, and for corrugated metal and reinforced concrete culverts with diameters of <72 in. (1.8 m). While the analysis did not reveal any specific parameters or thresholds that definitively predicted a washout would occur, several factors that appear to increase the potential were identified, including absence of a headwall, high headwater over culvert diameter ratios, and lower culvert cross-sectional area to watershed area ratios. We recommend agencies conduct asset inventories and inspections to document existing conditions, identify structures in poor condition or those that are very under-sized, and implement repair and upgrade efforts to help reduce failure risk.
- 31 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2679 (11) , 57-67
Characterizing Extreme Rainfall-Induced Culvert Washouts in North Carolina
Recent hurricane and tropical storm-induced extreme rainfall events have caused hundreds of culvert washouts across North Carolina. These failures present serious vulnerabilities in the transportation network and pose a safety risk. As part of this study, the North Carolina Department of Transportation provided records for 1410 locations where hydraulic structures were reported to have washed out during Hurricanes Matthew and Florence and during extreme flooding in 2020. These records were analyzed to characterize the pre-storm properties of the structures and to identify factors that indicate high washout risk based on a remote desktop analysis. Drainage area, watershed characteristics, structure capacity, and physical parameters were calculated and compiled for all washouts. The same data were also compiled for nearby structures that did not wash out in a six-county area. Results indicated washouts were most common in small watersheds (0.5 mi 2 [2 ]), for secondary roads, and for corrugated metal and reinforced concrete culverts with diameters of <72 in. (1.8 m). While the analysis did not reveal any specific parameters or thresholds that definitively predicted a washout would occur, several factors that appear to increase the potential were identified, including absence of a headwall, high headwater over culvert diameter ratios, and lower culvert cross-sectional area to watershed area ratios. We recommend agencies conduct asset inventories and inspections to document existing conditions, identify structures in poor condition or those that are very under-sized, and implement repair and upgrade efforts to help reduce failure risk.
- Open Access
Assessing Flooding from Changes in Extreme Rainfall: Using the Design Rainfall Approach in Hydrologic Modeling
Quantifying future changes in extreme events and associated flooding is challenging yet fundamental for stormwater managers. Along the U.S. Atlantic Coast, Eastern North Carolina (ENC) is frequently exposed to catastrophic floods from extreme rainfall that is typically associated with tropical cyclones. This study presents a novel approach that uses rainfall data from five dynamically and statistically downscaled (DD and SD) global climate models under two scenarios to visualize a potential future extent of flooding in ENC. Here, we use DD data (at 36-km grid spacing) to compute future changes in precipitation intensity–duration–frequency (PIDF) curves at the end of the 21st century. These PIDF curves are further applied to observed rainfall from Hurricane Matthew—a landfalling storm that created widespread flooding across ENC in 2016—to project versions of “Matthew 2100” that reflect changes in extreme precipitation under those scenarios. Each Matthew-2100 rainfall distribution was then used in hydrologic models (HEC-HMS and HEC-RAS) to simulate “2100” discharges and flooding extents in the Neuse River Basin (4686 km2) in ENC. The results show that DD datasets better represented historical changes in extreme rainfall than SD datasets. The projected changes in ENC rainfall (up to 112%) exceed values published for the U.S. but do not exceed historical values. The peak discharges for Matthew-2100 could increase by 23–69%, with 0.4–3 m increases in water surface elevation and 8–57% increases in flooded area. The projected increases in flooding would threaten people, ecosystems, agriculture, infrastructure, and the economy throughout ENC.
Open AccessAssessing Flooding from Changes in Extreme Rainfall: Using the Design Rainfall Approach in Hydrologic Modeling
Quantifying future changes in extreme events and associated flooding is challenging yet fundamental for stormwater managers. Along the U.S. Atlantic Coast, Eastern North Carolina (ENC) is frequently exposed to catastrophic floods from extreme rainfall that is typically associated with tropical cyclones. This study presents a novel approach that uses rainfall data from five dynamically and statistically downscaled (DD and SD) global climate models under two scenarios to visualize a potential future extent of flooding in ENC. Here, we use DD data (at 36-km grid spacing) to compute future changes in precipitation intensity–duration–frequency (PIDF) curves at the end of the 21st century. These PIDF curves are further applied to observed rainfall from Hurricane Matthew—a landfalling storm that created widespread flooding across ENC in 2016—to project versions of “Matthew 2100” that reflect changes in extreme precipitation under those scenarios. Each Matthew-2100 rainfall distribution was then used in hydrologic models (HEC-HMS and HEC-RAS) to simulate “2100” discharges and flooding extents in the Neuse River Basin (4686 km2) in ENC. The results show that DD datasets better represented historical changes in extreme rainfall than SD datasets. The projected changes in ENC rainfall (up to 112%) exceed values published for the U.S. but do not exceed historical values. The peak discharges for Matthew-2100 could increase by 23–69%, with 0.4–3 m increases in water surface elevation and 8–57% increases in flooded area. The projected increases in flooding would threaten people, ecosystems, agriculture, infrastructure, and the economy throughout ENC.
- Open Access
- 14 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 50 (6)
Quantifying streambank erosion: A comparison of physical surveys, aerial imagery and UAS LiDAR surveys
Excessive or accelerated streambank erosion can harm stream ecosystems and negatively impact water supply and infrastructure systems. Streambank erosion can be the most significant source of in‐stream sediment loads and associated contaminants. Site‐specific, low‐cost and timesaving methods to quantify active erosion rates are needed to identify and prioritize locations for restoration actions focused on reducing sediment loads and improving stream functions. Therefore, we examined several methods for quantifying streambank erosion at smaller spatial and temporal scales that are typical of most restoration projects. Physical surveys, aerial imagery analysis and Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) based light detection and ranging (LiDAR) surveys were conducted to document erosion at three streams in the Blue Ridge and Ridge and Valley regions of Virginia. Three methods were used to quantify bank retreat: 1) cross‐section (XS) surveys, 2) top‐of‐bank (TOB) surveys and 3) aerial imagery analysis. The bank retreat rates were compared to rates estimated from aerial images collected during 2007 to 2019. All three methods were then paired with field‐measured bank heights to estimate the volume of erosion. Reachwide erosion volumes were also estimated with digital elevation models (DEM) of Difference (DoD) using LiDAR data collected with an UAS. The estimated eroded sediment volumes varied widely across all methods but were of a similar magnitude. DoD produced the lowest estimated sediment loads, highest uncertainty and was statistically different from the average of the maximum erosion measured at all cross‐sections. The volume of streambank erosion ranged from 0.18 to 1.26 m3/m/yr across all sites for all methods excluding DoD. Based on the small size of our study streams and the short monitoring period (one to two years), DoD was the least suitable method. Selecting the appropriate method for documenting and quantifying erosion depends on the time available, the purpose of estimating erosion, the resolution required and stream conditions.
- 14 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
- Vol. 50 (6)
Open AccessQuantifying streambank erosion: A comparison of physical surveys, aerial imagery and UAS LiDAR surveys
Excessive or accelerated streambank erosion can harm stream ecosystems and negatively impact water supply and infrastructure systems. Streambank erosion can be the most significant source of in‐stream sediment loads and associated contaminants. Site‐specific, low‐cost and timesaving methods to quantify active erosion rates are needed to identify and prioritize locations for restoration actions focused on reducing sediment loads and improving stream functions. Therefore, we examined several methods for quantifying streambank erosion at smaller spatial and temporal scales that are typical of most restoration projects. Physical surveys, aerial imagery analysis and Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) based light detection and ranging (LiDAR) surveys were conducted to document erosion at three streams in the Blue Ridge and Ridge and Valley regions of Virginia. Three methods were used to quantify bank retreat: 1) cross‐section (XS) surveys, 2) top‐of‐bank (TOB) surveys and 3) aerial imagery analysis. The bank retreat rates were compared to rates estimated from aerial images collected during 2007 to 2019. All three methods were then paired with field‐measured bank heights to estimate the volume of erosion. Reachwide erosion volumes were also estimated with digital elevation models (DEM) of Difference (DoD) using LiDAR data collected with an UAS. The estimated eroded sediment volumes varied widely across all methods but were of a similar magnitude. DoD produced the lowest estimated sediment loads, highest uncertainty and was statistically different from the average of the maximum erosion measured at all cross‐sections. The volume of streambank erosion ranged from 0.18 to 1.26 m3/m/yr across all sites for all methods excluding DoD. Based on the small size of our study streams and the short monitoring period (one to two years), DoD was the least suitable method. Selecting the appropriate method for documenting and quantifying erosion depends on the time available, the purpose of estimating erosion, the resolution required and stream conditions.
- Open Access
- 29 April 2024
- Published by University of Vermont Press in Journal of Ecological Engineering Design
- Vol. 2 (1)
Long-term Channel Geometry Adjustments for Reference Streams in the North Carolina Piedmont
The evaluation of reference streams can inform stream restoration designs, ecological function targets, hydraulic and sediment transport regimes, and project success criteria. Reference streams are often assumed to be in a state of quasi-equilibrium, with a hydraulic geometry representing a long-term average of a channel’s form that has developed under relatively constant morphological boundary conditions. However, more rapid changes in boundary conditions, such as water or sediment discharge, bed material size, or streambank vegetation, can result in accelerated changes to channel morphology and the development of new hydraulic geometry relationships . The goal of this study was to evaluate the morphologic equilibrium of reference streams by quantifying their long-term adjustments in riffle cross-section dimensions (i.e., width, mean depth, and cross-sectional area) and discharge. Eighteen reference streams in the Piedmont of North Carolina, United States, originally assessed in 2007, were resurveyed in 2017 and 2018 (hereinafter referred to as 2018). The adjustment in riffle channel geometry was quantified and evaluated by analyzing existing boundary conditions and changes in watershed land cover and precipitation patterns. Hydraulic geometry relationships (i.e., geometry parameters and discharge versus drainage area) from 2007 and 2018 were nearly identical and no statistically significant differences were detected in bankfull discharge, cross-sectional area, width, or mean depth. Inspection of individual sites revealed bankfull cross-sectional area adjusted by 0% to 19% at most sites, however 4 urbanizing sites adjusted by more than 25%. The adjustments in discharge and area from 2007 to 2018 were significantly correlated with impervious cover, indicating channel geometry adjustments are likely the result of changes in discharge that occur as a result of changes in watershed conditions and land cover. Changes in precipitation did not appear to be drivers of adjustment, as patterns were similar during the 10.5-year period preceding each field survey in 2007 and 2018. These data were used to update the regional curve relationships, and other summary morphological data compiled can be used to help guide future stream restoration designs. The geometry adjustments and percent erosion reported for the more stable reference streams can serve as a gauge for evaluating the degree of change in channel geometry measured at both degraded and restored streams.
- 29 April 2024
- Published by University of Vermont Press in Journal of Ecological Engineering Design
- Vol. 2 (1)
Open AccessLong-term Channel Geometry Adjustments for Reference Streams in the North Carolina Piedmont
The evaluation of reference streams can inform stream restoration designs, ecological function targets, hydraulic and sediment transport regimes, and project success criteria. Reference streams are often assumed to be in a state of quasi-equilibrium, with a hydraulic geometry representing a long-term average of a channel’s form that has developed under relatively constant morphological boundary conditions. However, more rapid changes in boundary conditions, such as water or sediment discharge, bed material size, or streambank vegetation, can result in accelerated changes to channel morphology and the development of new hydraulic geometry relationships . The goal of this study was to evaluate the morphologic equilibrium of reference streams by quantifying their long-term adjustments in riffle cross-section dimensions (i.e., width, mean depth, and cross-sectional area) and discharge. Eighteen reference streams in the Piedmont of North Carolina, United States, originally assessed in 2007, were resurveyed in 2017 and 2018 (hereinafter referred to as 2018). The adjustment in riffle channel geometry was quantified and evaluated by analyzing existing boundary conditions and changes in watershed land cover and precipitation patterns. Hydraulic geometry relationships (i.e., geometry parameters and discharge versus drainage area) from 2007 and 2018 were nearly identical and no statistically significant differences were detected in bankfull discharge, cross-sectional area, width, or mean depth. Inspection of individual sites revealed bankfull cross-sectional area adjusted by 0% to 19% at most sites, however 4 urbanizing sites adjusted by more than 25%. The adjustments in discharge and area from 2007 to 2018 were significantly correlated with impervious cover, indicating channel geometry adjustments are likely the result of changes in discharge that occur as a result of changes in watershed conditions and land cover. Changes in precipitation did not appear to be drivers of adjustment, as patterns were similar during the 10.5-year period preceding each field survey in 2007 and 2018. These data were used to update the regional curve relationships, and other summary morphological data compiled can be used to help guide future stream restoration designs. The geometry adjustments and percent erosion reported for the more stable reference streams can serve as a gauge for evaluating the degree of change in channel geometry measured at both degraded and restored streams.
- Open Access
Estimating Changes in Peak Flow and Associated Reductions in Flooding Resulting from Implementing Natural Infrastructure in the Neuse River Basin, North Carolina, USA
As the frequency of more intense storms increases and concerns grow regarding the use of dams and levees, the focus has shifted to natural infrastructure (NI) for flood mitigation. NI has shown some success at small scales; however, little work has been carried out at the large watershed scale during extreme events. Three NI measures (afforestation, water farming, and flood control wetlands) were evaluated in the Neuse River Basin of eastern North Carolina. Detailed geospatial opportunity and hydrologic modeling of the measures were conducted in three subwatersheds of the basin and results were extrapolated to other subwatersheds. NI opportunity was greater and associated modeled peak flow reductions were larger for two subwatersheds located in the lower portion of the basin, where there is less development and flatter land slopes. Peak flow reductions varied spatially depending on the type and placement of NI combined with the hydraulic and morphologic characteristics of the stream network. Extrapolation of reductions to other subwatersheds produced a 4.4% reduction in peak flow for the 100 year storm at the outlet of the river basin in Kinston as a result of water farming on 1.1%, wetlands controlling runoff from 5.7%, and afforestation of 8.4% of the river basin.
Open AccessEstimating Changes in Peak Flow and Associated Reductions in Flooding Resulting from Implementing Natural Infrastructure in the Neuse River Basin, North Carolina, USA
As the frequency of more intense storms increases and concerns grow regarding the use of dams and levees, the focus has shifted to natural infrastructure (NI) for flood mitigation. NI has shown some success at small scales; however, little work has been carried out at the large watershed scale during extreme events. Three NI measures (afforestation, water farming, and flood control wetlands) were evaluated in the Neuse River Basin of eastern North Carolina. Detailed geospatial opportunity and hydrologic modeling of the measures were conducted in three subwatersheds of the basin and results were extrapolated to other subwatersheds. NI opportunity was greater and associated modeled peak flow reductions were larger for two subwatersheds located in the lower portion of the basin, where there is less development and flatter land slopes. Peak flow reductions varied spatially depending on the type and placement of NI combined with the hydraulic and morphologic characteristics of the stream network. Extrapolation of reductions to other subwatersheds produced a 4.4% reduction in peak flow for the 100 year storm at the outlet of the river basin in Kinston as a result of water farming on 1.1%, wetlands controlling runoff from 5.7%, and afforestation of 8.4% of the river basin.
- Open Access
- 19 August 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (16) , 9309
Natural Infrastructure Practices as Potential Flood Storage and Reduction for Farms and Rural Communities in the North Carolina Coastal Plain
Increased global temperatures resulting from anthropogenically induced climate changes have increased the frequency and severity of adverse weather events, including extreme rainfall events, floods, and droughts. In recent years, nature-based solutions (NBS) have been proposed to retain storm runoff temporarily and mitigate flood damages. These practices may help rural farm and forest lands to store runoff and reduce flooding on farms and downstream communities and could be incorporated into a conservation program to provide payments for these efforts, which would supplement traditional farm incomes. Despite their potential, there have been very few methodical assessments and detailed summaries of NBS to date. We identified and summarized potential flood reduction practices for the Coastal Plain of North Carolina. These include agricultural practices of (1) cover cropping/no-till farming; (2) hardpan breakup; (3) pine or (4) hardwood afforestation, and (5) agroforestry; establishing the wetland and stream practices of (6) grass and sedge wetlands and earthen retention structures, (7) forest wetland banks, and (8) stream channel restoration; and establishing new structural solutions of (9) dry dams and berms (water farming) and (10) tile drainage and water retention. These practices offer different water holding and storage capacities and costs. A mixture of practices at the farm and landscape level can be implemented for floodwater retention and attenuation and damage reduction, as well as for providing additional farm and forest ecosystem services.
- 19 August 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (16) , 9309
Open AccessNatural Infrastructure Practices as Potential Flood Storage and Reduction for Farms and Rural Communities in the North Carolina Coastal Plain
Increased global temperatures resulting from anthropogenically induced climate changes have increased the frequency and severity of adverse weather events, including extreme rainfall events, floods, and droughts. In recent years, nature-based solutions (NBS) have been proposed to retain storm runoff temporarily and mitigate flood damages. These practices may help rural farm and forest lands to store runoff and reduce flooding on farms and downstream communities and could be incorporated into a conservation program to provide payments for these efforts, which would supplement traditional farm incomes. Despite their potential, there have been very few methodical assessments and detailed summaries of NBS to date. We identified and summarized potential flood reduction practices for the Coastal Plain of North Carolina. These include agricultural practices of (1) cover cropping/no-till farming; (2) hardpan breakup; (3) pine or (4) hardwood afforestation, and (5) agroforestry; establishing the wetland and stream practices of (6) grass and sedge wetlands and earthen retention structures, (7) forest wetland banks, and (8) stream channel restoration; and establishing new structural solutions of (9) dry dams and berms (water farming) and (10) tile drainage and water retention. These practices offer different water holding and storage capacities and costs. A mixture of practices at the farm and landscape level can be implemented for floodwater retention and attenuation and damage reduction, as well as for providing additional farm and forest ecosystem services.
- Open Access
A Framework for Planning and Evaluating the Role of Urban Stream Restoration for Improving Transportation Resilience to Extreme Rainfall Events
Recent extreme rainfall events produced severe flooding across North Carolina’s Coastal Plain, revealing deep vulnerabilities in many communities. Climate change is expected to exacerbate these problems by further increasing rainfall intensity and the frequency of extreme rainfall events. Due to the risks posed by these changing rainfall patterns, a shift in the approach to infrastructure planning and management is needed for many floodprone communities, particularly in regard to managing streams and floodplains in urban areas. This study proposes a framework for systematically evaluating stream restoration in combination with engineered improvements to culvert and bridge crossings to identify and optimize options for mitigating extreme events in urban areas. To illustrate the methodology, extensive hydraulic modeling was conducted to test four different strategies for reducing flooding along a channelized and armored stream, Big Ditch, located in Goldsboro, North Carolina, USA. The results indicate that neither floodplain restoration nor infrastructure modification alone could alleviate flooding along Big Ditch. Rather, a combination approach would be required to mitigate flooding, which could result in substantial benefits for storms in excess of the 100-year event. The results suggest that shifting to a multi-faceted approach to improve resiliency to extreme events could improve public safety and reduce future damages due to flooding.
Open AccessA Framework for Planning and Evaluating the Role of Urban Stream Restoration for Improving Transportation Resilience to Extreme Rainfall Events
Recent extreme rainfall events produced severe flooding across North Carolina’s Coastal Plain, revealing deep vulnerabilities in many communities. Climate change is expected to exacerbate these problems by further increasing rainfall intensity and the frequency of extreme rainfall events. Due to the risks posed by these changing rainfall patterns, a shift in the approach to infrastructure planning and management is needed for many floodprone communities, particularly in regard to managing streams and floodplains in urban areas. This study proposes a framework for systematically evaluating stream restoration in combination with engineered improvements to culvert and bridge crossings to identify and optimize options for mitigating extreme events in urban areas. To illustrate the methodology, extensive hydraulic modeling was conducted to test four different strategies for reducing flooding along a channelized and armored stream, Big Ditch, located in Goldsboro, North Carolina, USA. The results indicate that neither floodplain restoration nor infrastructure modification alone could alleviate flooding along Big Ditch. Rather, a combination approach would be required to mitigate flooding, which could result in substantial benefits for storms in excess of the 100-year event. The results suggest that shifting to a multi-faceted approach to improve resiliency to extreme events could improve public safety and reduce future damages due to flooding.
- Open Access
Flood Flow Frequency Analysis to Estimate Potential Floodplain Nitrogen Treatment during Overbank Flow Events in Urban Stream Restoration Projects
Stream restoration for mitigation purposes has grown rapidly since the 1980s. As the science advances, some organizations (Chesapeake Bay Program, North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality) have approved or are considering providing nutrient credits for stream restoration projects. Nutrient treatment on floodplains during overbank events is one of the least understood processes that have been considered as part of the Chesapeake Bay Program’s Stream Restoration Nutrient Crediting program. This study analyzed ten years of streamflow and water quality data from five stations in the Piedmont of North Carolina to evaluate proposed procedures for estimating nitrogen removal on the floodplain during overbank flow events. The volume of floodplain flow, the volume of floodplain flow potentially treated, and the nitrogen load retained on the floodplain were calculated for each overbank event, and a sensitivity analysis was completed. On average, 9% to 15% of the total annual streamflow volume accessed the floodplain. The percentage of the average annual volume of streamflow potentially treated ranged from 1.0% to 5.1%. Annually, this equates to 0.2% to 1.0% of the total N load retained/removed on the floodplain following restoration. The relatively low nitrogen retention/removal rates were due to a majority of floodplain flow occurring during a few large events each year that exceeded the treatment capacity of the floodplain. On an annual basis, 90% of total floodplain flow occurred during half of all overbank events and 50% of total floodplain flow occurred during two to three events each year. Findings suggest that evaluating only overbank events may lead to undervaluing stream restoration because treatment is limited by hydrologic controls that restrict floodplain retention time. Treatment is further governed by floodplain and channel size.
Open AccessFlood Flow Frequency Analysis to Estimate Potential Floodplain Nitrogen Treatment during Overbank Flow Events in Urban Stream Restoration Projects
Stream restoration for mitigation purposes has grown rapidly since the 1980s. As the science advances, some organizations (Chesapeake Bay Program, North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality) have approved or are considering providing nutrient credits for stream restoration projects. Nutrient treatment on floodplains during overbank events is one of the least understood processes that have been considered as part of the Chesapeake Bay Program’s Stream Restoration Nutrient Crediting program. This study analyzed ten years of streamflow and water quality data from five stations in the Piedmont of North Carolina to evaluate proposed procedures for estimating nitrogen removal on the floodplain during overbank flow events. The volume of floodplain flow, the volume of floodplain flow potentially treated, and the nitrogen load retained on the floodplain were calculated for each overbank event, and a sensitivity analysis was completed. On average, 9% to 15% of the total annual streamflow volume accessed the floodplain. The percentage of the average annual volume of streamflow potentially treated ranged from 1.0% to 5.1%. Annually, this equates to 0.2% to 1.0% of the total N load retained/removed on the floodplain following restoration. The relatively low nitrogen retention/removal rates were due to a majority of floodplain flow occurring during a few large events each year that exceeded the treatment capacity of the floodplain. On an annual basis, 90% of total floodplain flow occurred during half of all overbank events and 50% of total floodplain flow occurred during two to three events each year. Findings suggest that evaluating only overbank events may lead to undervaluing stream restoration because treatment is limited by hydrologic controls that restrict floodplain retention time. Treatment is further governed by floodplain and channel size.
- Open Access
Can the Stream Quantification Tool (SQT) Protocol Predict the Biotic Condition of Streams in the Southeast Piedmont (USA)?
In some states, the Stream Quantification Tool (SQT) has been adopted to quantify functional change of stream mitigation efforts. However, the ability of the SQT protocol to predict biological function and uphold the premise of the Stream Functions Pyramid (Pyramid) remains untested. Macroinvertebrate community metrics in 34 headwater streams in Piedmont, North Carolina (NC, USA) were related to NC SQT protocol (version 3.0) factors and other variables relevant to ecological function. Three statistical models, including stepwise, lasso, and ridge regression were used to predict the NC Biotic Index (NCBI) and Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera, and Trichoptera (EPT) richness using two datasets: 21 SQT variables and the SQT variables plus 13 additional watershed, hydraulic, geomorphic, and physicochemical variables. Cross-validation revealed that stepwise and ridge outperformed lasso, and that the SQT variables can reasonably predict biology metrics (R2 0.53–0.64). Additional variables improved prediction (R2 0.70–0.88), suggesting that the SQT protocol is lacking metrics important to macroinvertebrates. Results moderately support the Pyramid: highly predictive ridge models included metrics from all levels, while highly predictive stepwise models included metrics from higher levels, and not watershed hydrology. Reach-scale metrics were more important than watershed hydrology, providing encouragement for projects limited by watershed condition.
Open AccessCan the Stream Quantification Tool (SQT) Protocol Predict the Biotic Condition of Streams in the Southeast Piedmont (USA)?
In some states, the Stream Quantification Tool (SQT) has been adopted to quantify functional change of stream mitigation efforts. However, the ability of the SQT protocol to predict biological function and uphold the premise of the Stream Functions Pyramid (Pyramid) remains untested. Macroinvertebrate community metrics in 34 headwater streams in Piedmont, North Carolina (NC, USA) were related to NC SQT protocol (version 3.0) factors and other variables relevant to ecological function. Three statistical models, including stepwise, lasso, and ridge regression were used to predict the NC Biotic Index (NCBI) and Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera, and Trichoptera (EPT) richness using two datasets: 21 SQT variables and the SQT variables plus 13 additional watershed, hydraulic, geomorphic, and physicochemical variables. Cross-validation revealed that stepwise and ridge outperformed lasso, and that the SQT variables can reasonably predict biology metrics (R2 0.53–0.64). Additional variables improved prediction (R2 0.70–0.88), suggesting that the SQT protocol is lacking metrics important to macroinvertebrates. Results moderately support the Pyramid: highly predictive ridge models included metrics from all levels, while highly predictive stepwise models included metrics from higher levels, and not watershed hydrology. Reach-scale metrics were more important than watershed hydrology, providing encouragement for projects limited by watershed condition.