Brett Hathaway
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Brett Hathaway has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Evgeny Kagan
Carey Business School, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland 21202
4 shared publications - Seyed Morteza Emadi
Kenan-Flagler Business School, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC , USA
4 shared publications - Vinayak Deshpande
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27599
4 shared publications - Maqbool Dada
Carey Business School, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA
3 shared publications - Ivo Adan
Eindhoven University of Technology
1 shared publication Maqbool Dada
Johns Hopkins University - Carey Business School
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 November 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
- Vol. 28 (6) , 1983-2003
Why Are Customers Averse to Service Chatbots?
Problem definition: Despite rapid advances in artificial intelligence, the adoption and effective use of customer service chatbots remain slow relative to their capabilities. This paper explores the behavioral reasons for these adoption hurdles. Methodology/results: We use incentivized online experiments to study chatbot uptake. The results of these experiments are threefold. First, people respond positively to improvements in chatbot performance; however, the chatbot channel is used less frequently than expected-time minimization would predict. A key driver of this underutilization is reluctance to engage with a gatekeeper process (i.e., a process with an imperfect initial service stage and possible transfer to a second expert service stage—a behavior that we term gatekeeper aversion). Second, we find that gatekeeper aversion can be further amplified by an additional hurdle—algorithm aversion. Third, we find that chatbot adoption decreases when stakes are higher and when the human/algorithmic nature of the server is manipulated with more realism. Managerial implications: We use an illustrative case to show how the behaviors identified in our experiments affect optimal technology investment and staffing levels and how failing to anticipate these behaviors can lead to suboptimal decisions and higher realized costs. More broadly, our results suggest that adding a chatbot to a service system requires rethinking the entire service process, including technology investment, staffing, and queueing policies. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2024.1141 .
- 1 November 2026
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Manufacturing & Service Operations Management
- Vol. 28 (6) , 1983-2003
Why Are Customers Averse to Service Chatbots?
Problem definition: Despite rapid advances in artificial intelligence, the adoption and effective use of customer service chatbots remain slow relative to their capabilities. This paper explores the behavioral reasons for these adoption hurdles. Methodology/results: We use incentivized online experiments to study chatbot uptake. The results of these experiments are threefold. First, people respond positively to improvements in chatbot performance; however, the chatbot channel is used less frequently than expected-time minimization would predict. A key driver of this underutilization is reluctance to engage with a gatekeeper process (i.e., a process with an imperfect initial service stage and possible transfer to a second expert service stage—a behavior that we term gatekeeper aversion). Second, we find that gatekeeper aversion can be further amplified by an additional hurdle—algorithm aversion. Third, we find that chatbot adoption decreases when stakes are higher and when the human/algorithmic nature of the server is manipulated with more realism. Managerial implications: We use an illustrative case to show how the behaviors identified in our experiments affect optimal technology investment and staffing levels and how failing to anticipate these behaviors can lead to suboptimal decisions and higher realized costs. More broadly, our results suggest that adding a chatbot to a service system requires rethinking the entire service process, including technology investment, staffing, and queueing policies. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2024.1141 .
- 28 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 34 (9) , 2814-2832
Customer Service Operations: A Gatekeeper Framework
Customer service has evolved beyond in-person visits and phone calls to include live chat, AI chatbots and social media, among other contact options. Service providers typically refer to these contact modalities as “channels.” Within each channel, customer service agents are tasked with managing and resolving a stream of inbound service requests. Each request involves milestones where the agent must decide whether to keep assisting the customer or to transfer them to a more skilled—and often costlier—provider. To understand how this request resolution process should be managed, we develop a model in which each channel is represented as a gatekeeper system and characterize the structure of the optimal request resolution policy. We then turn to the broader question of the firm’s customer service design, which includes the strategic problem of which channels to deploy, the tactical questions of at what level to staff the live-agent channel and to what extent to train an AI chatbot, and the operational question of how to control the live-agent channel. Examining the interplay between strategic, tactical, and operational decisions through numerical methods, we show, among other insights, that service quality can be improved, rather than diminished, by chatbot implementation.
- 28 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 34 (9) , 2814-2832
Customer Service Operations: A Gatekeeper Framework
Customer service has evolved beyond in-person visits and phone calls to include live chat, AI chatbots and social media, among other contact options. Service providers typically refer to these contact modalities as “channels.” Within each channel, customer service agents are tasked with managing and resolving a stream of inbound service requests. Each request involves milestones where the agent must decide whether to keep assisting the customer or to transfer them to a more skilled—and often costlier—provider. To understand how this request resolution process should be managed, we develop a model in which each channel is represented as a gatekeeper system and characterize the structure of the optimal request resolution policy. We then turn to the broader question of the firm’s customer service design, which includes the strategic problem of which channels to deploy, the tactical questions of at what level to staff the live-agent channel and to what extent to train an AI chatbot, and the operational question of how to control the live-agent channel. Examining the interplay between strategic, tactical, and operational decisions through numerical methods, we show, among other insights, that service quality can be improved, rather than diminished, by chatbot implementation.
- 1 May 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Operations Research
- Vol. 71 (3) , 843-859
The Gatekeeper’s Dilemma: “When Should I Transfer This Customer?”
When Should I Transfer This Customer? “Please hold while I transfer you to next level of support.” Most of us have been on the receiving end of this message. In this study, the authors look at transfers from the service worker’s perspective. They create an online experiment in which participants play the role of call center agents who need to decide whether to transfer a virtual service request or continue attempting to resolve it. Consistent with compensation schemes common in call centers, participants receive a bonus for each successful resolution and may pay a penalty if they transfer. The authors find that these incentives generally work well; however, agents appear to overreact to transfer penalties by handling more requests than they should and transferring too few requests. Although this may be good news for customers who dislike being transferred, such behaviors may be costly for the call center; thus, managers need to be careful when rolling out complex compensation schemes.
- 1 May 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Operations Research
- Vol. 71 (3) , 843-859
The Gatekeeper’s Dilemma: “When Should I Transfer This Customer?”
When Should I Transfer This Customer? “Please hold while I transfer you to next level of support.” Most of us have been on the receiving end of this message. In this study, the authors look at transfers from the service worker’s perspective. They create an online experiment in which participants play the role of call center agents who need to decide whether to transfer a virtual service request or continue attempting to resolve it. Consistent with compensation schemes common in call centers, participants receive a bonus for each successful resolution and may pay a penalty if they transfer. The authors find that these incentives generally work well; however, agents appear to overreact to transfer penalties by handling more requests than they should and transferring too few requests. Although this may be good news for customers who dislike being transferred, such behaviors may be costly for the call center; thus, managers need to be careful when rolling out complex compensation schemes.
- 1 April 2022
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 68 (4) , 2806-2823
Personalized Priority Policies in Call Centers Using Past Customer Interaction Information
To increase revenue or improve customer service, companies are increasingly personalizing their product or service offerings based on their customers' history of interactions. In this paper, we show how call centers can improve customer service by implementing personalized priority policies. Under personalized priority policies, managers use customer contact history to predict individual-level caller abandonment and redialing behavior and prioritize them based on these predictions to improve operational performance. We provide a framework for how companies can use individual-level customer history data to capture the idiosyncratic preferences and beliefs that impact caller abandonment and redialing behavior and quantify the improvements to operational performance of these policies by applying our framework using caller history data from a real-world call center. We achieve this by formulating a structural model that uses a Bayesian learning framework to capture how callers’ past waiting times and abandonment/redialing decisions affect their current abandonment and redialing behavior and use our data to impute the callers’ underlying primitives such as their rewards for service, waiting costs, and redialing costs. These primitives allow us to simulate caller behavior under a variety of personalized priority policies and hence, collect relevant operational performance measures. We find that, relative to the first-come, first-served policy, our proposed personalized priority policies have the potential to decrease average waiting times by up to 29% or increase system throughput by reducing the percentage of service requests lost to abandonment by up to 6.3%. This paper was accepted by Vishaul Gaur, operations management.
- 1 April 2022
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 68 (4) , 2806-2823
Personalized Priority Policies in Call Centers Using Past Customer Interaction Information
To increase revenue or improve customer service, companies are increasingly personalizing their product or service offerings based on their customers' history of interactions. In this paper, we show how call centers can improve customer service by implementing personalized priority policies. Under personalized priority policies, managers use customer contact history to predict individual-level caller abandonment and redialing behavior and prioritize them based on these predictions to improve operational performance. We provide a framework for how companies can use individual-level customer history data to capture the idiosyncratic preferences and beliefs that impact caller abandonment and redialing behavior and quantify the improvements to operational performance of these policies by applying our framework using caller history data from a real-world call center. We achieve this by formulating a structural model that uses a Bayesian learning framework to capture how callers’ past waiting times and abandonment/redialing decisions affect their current abandonment and redialing behavior and use our data to impute the callers’ underlying primitives such as their rewards for service, waiting costs, and redialing costs. These primitives allow us to simulate caller behavior under a variety of personalized priority policies and hence, collect relevant operational performance measures. We find that, relative to the first-come, first-served policy, our proposed personalized priority policies have the potential to decrease average waiting times by up to 29% or increase system throughput by reducing the percentage of service requests lost to abandonment by up to 6.3%. This paper was accepted by Vishaul Gaur, operations management.
- 1 March 2021
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 67 (3) , 1508-1526
Don’t Call Us, We’ll Call You: An Empirical Study of Caller Behavior Under a Callback Option
Although call centers have recently invested in callback technology, the effects of this innovation on call center performance are not clearly understood. In this paper, we take a data-driven approach to quantify the operational impact of offering callbacks under a variety of callback policies. To achieve this goal, we formulate a structural model of the caller decision-making process under a callback option and impute their underlying preferences from data. Our model estimates shed light on caller preferences under a callback option. We find that callers experience three to six times less discomfort per unit of time while waiting for callbacks than while waiting in queue, suggesting that offering callbacks can increase service quality by channeling callers to an alternative service channel where they experience less discomfort while waiting. However, after controlling for expected waiting times, callers generally prefer waiting in a queue over accepting a callback and waiting offline. This suggests that managers of this call center may want to spend efforts in educating their customers on the benefits of the callback option. Using the callers’ imputed preferences, we are able to conduct counterfactual analyses of how various callback policies affect the performance of this call center. We find that in this call center, offering to hold the callers’ spot in line or to call back within a window (guaranteed timeframe) reduces average online waiting time (the average time callers wait on the phone) by up to 71% and improves service quality by decreasing callers’ average incurred waiting cost by up to 46%. Moreover, we find that offering callbacks as a demand postponement strategy during periods of temporary congestion reduces average online waiting time by up to 86%, increases service quality by up to 54%, and increases system throughput by up to 2.1%. This paper was accepted by Vishal Gaur, operations management.
- 1 March 2021
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 67 (3) , 1508-1526
Don’t Call Us, We’ll Call You: An Empirical Study of Caller Behavior Under a Callback Option
Although call centers have recently invested in callback technology, the effects of this innovation on call center performance are not clearly understood. In this paper, we take a data-driven approach to quantify the operational impact of offering callbacks under a variety of callback policies. To achieve this goal, we formulate a structural model of the caller decision-making process under a callback option and impute their underlying preferences from data. Our model estimates shed light on caller preferences under a callback option. We find that callers experience three to six times less discomfort per unit of time while waiting for callbacks than while waiting in queue, suggesting that offering callbacks can increase service quality by channeling callers to an alternative service channel where they experience less discomfort while waiting. However, after controlling for expected waiting times, callers generally prefer waiting in a queue over accepting a callback and waiting offline. This suggests that managers of this call center may want to spend efforts in educating their customers on the benefits of the callback option. Using the callers’ imputed preferences, we are able to conduct counterfactual analyses of how various callback policies affect the performance of this call center. We find that in this call center, offering to hold the callers’ spot in line or to call back within a window (guaranteed timeframe) reduces average online waiting time (the average time callers wait on the phone) by up to 71% and improves service quality by decreasing callers’ average incurred waiting cost by up to 46%. Moreover, we find that offering callbacks as a demand postponement strategy during periods of temporary congestion reduces average online waiting time by up to 86%, increases service quality by up to 54%, and increases system throughput by up to 2.1%. This paper was accepted by Vishal Gaur, operations management.
- Open Access
- 2 June 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
The Gatekeeper’s Dilemma: 'When Should I Transfer This Customer?'
In many service encounters front-line workers (often referred to as gatekeepers) have the discretion to attempt to resolve a customer request, or to transfer the customer to an expert service provider within the orga- nization. We study the gatekeeper’s transfer decision using an integrated approach that consists of a field study, an analytical model and a behavioral experiment. Drawing on a proprietary dataset of 9.8 million interactions between the customers and call center agents of a US-based Bank, we formulate and solve a dynamic finite-horizon model that characterizes the gatekeeper’s response to different incentive schemes and to different queueing dynamics. We then conduct experiments to examine how human behavior deviates from the normative implications of the model. We find that: 1) Simple bonus-based incentives lead to transfer behaviors that are broadly consistent with the model predictions; 2) Adding transfer penalties to a bonus- based system uniformly reduces transfer rates, even controlling for incentive differences; 3) Gatekeepers are able to incorporate the state of the queue into their decisions. Taken together, these results help provide behavioral underpinnings for future models of discretionary server behavior in queueing systems.
- 2 June 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessThe Gatekeeper’s Dilemma: 'When Should I Transfer This Customer?'
In many service encounters front-line workers (often referred to as gatekeepers) have the discretion to attempt to resolve a customer request, or to transfer the customer to an expert service provider within the orga- nization. We study the gatekeeper’s transfer decision using an integrated approach that consists of a field study, an analytical model and a behavioral experiment. Drawing on a proprietary dataset of 9.8 million interactions between the customers and call center agents of a US-based Bank, we formulate and solve a dynamic finite-horizon model that characterizes the gatekeeper’s response to different incentive schemes and to different queueing dynamics. We then conduct experiments to examine how human behavior deviates from the normative implications of the model. We find that: 1) Simple bonus-based incentives lead to transfer behaviors that are broadly consistent with the model predictions; 2) Adding transfer penalties to a bonus- based system uniformly reduces transfer rates, even controlling for incentive differences; 3) Gatekeepers are able to incorporate the state of the queue into their decisions. Taken together, these results help provide behavioral underpinnings for future models of discretionary server behavior in queueing systems.
- Open Access
- 8 May 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Personalized Priority Policies in Call Centers Using Past Customer Interaction Information
Companies are increasingly personalizing their product or service offerings based on their customers' history of interactions to increase revenue or improve customer service. In this paper we show how call centers can improve customer service by implementing personalized priority policies. Under personalized priority policies, managers use customer contact history to predict individual-level caller abandonment and redialing behavior and prioritize them based on these predictions to improve operational performance. We provide a framework for how companies can use individual-level customer history data to capture the idiosyncratic preferences and beliefs that impact caller abandonment and redialing behavior, and quantify the improvements to operational performance of these policies by applying our framework using caller history data from a real-world call center. We achieve this by formulating a structural model that uses a Bayesian learning framework to capture how callers' past waiting times and abandonment/redialing decisions affect their current abandonment and redialing behavior, and use our data to impute the callers' underlying primitives such as their rewards for service, waiting costs, and redialing costs. These primitives allow us to simulate caller behavior under a variety of personalized priority policies, and hence collect relevant operational performance measures. We find that, relative to the first-come, first-served policy, our proposed personalized priority policies have the potential to decrease average waiting times by up to 29\% or increase system throughput by reducing the percentage of service requests lost to abandonment by up to 6.3\%.
- 8 May 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessPersonalized Priority Policies in Call Centers Using Past Customer Interaction Information
Companies are increasingly personalizing their product or service offerings based on their customers' history of interactions to increase revenue or improve customer service. In this paper we show how call centers can improve customer service by implementing personalized priority policies. Under personalized priority policies, managers use customer contact history to predict individual-level caller abandonment and redialing behavior and prioritize them based on these predictions to improve operational performance. We provide a framework for how companies can use individual-level customer history data to capture the idiosyncratic preferences and beliefs that impact caller abandonment and redialing behavior, and quantify the improvements to operational performance of these policies by applying our framework using caller history data from a real-world call center. We achieve this by formulating a structural model that uses a Bayesian learning framework to capture how callers' past waiting times and abandonment/redialing decisions affect their current abandonment and redialing behavior, and use our data to impute the callers' underlying primitives such as their rewards for service, waiting costs, and redialing costs. These primitives allow us to simulate caller behavior under a variety of personalized priority policies, and hence collect relevant operational performance measures. We find that, relative to the first-come, first-served policy, our proposed personalized priority policies have the potential to decrease average waiting times by up to 29\% or increase system throughput by reducing the percentage of service requests lost to abandonment by up to 6.3\%.
- Open Access
- 8 March 2019
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Don't Call Us, We'll Call You: An Empirical Study of Caller Behavior Under a Callback Option
While call centers have recently invested in callback technology, the impact of this innovation on caller behavior and call center performance is not clearly understood. Using call center data from a US commercial bank, we perform an empirical study of the callers' decision-making process in the presence of a callback option. We formulate a structural model of the caller decision-making process, and impute their underlying preferences from the data. Our estimates show that callers experience substantially less discomfort per unit of time while waiting for callbacks than while waiting in queue. However, we also find that, after controlling for expected waiting times, callers generally prefer actively waiting in queue over accepting a callback and waiting offline. Using the estimates of our model, we are able to conduct counterfactual analyses of how various callback policies affect the performance of this call center. This helps managers to gauge different callback policies against each other to find the most effective policy before implementing it. Our counterfactual analyses show that offering to hold the callers' spot in line or to call back within a short window improves service quality by decreasing callers' average incurred waiting cost. Moreover, we find that offering callbacks as a demand postponement strategy during periods of temporary congestion substantially increases service quality and system throughput.
- 8 March 2019
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessDon't Call Us, We'll Call You: An Empirical Study of Caller Behavior Under a Callback Option
While call centers have recently invested in callback technology, the impact of this innovation on caller behavior and call center performance is not clearly understood. Using call center data from a US commercial bank, we perform an empirical study of the callers' decision-making process in the presence of a callback option. We formulate a structural model of the caller decision-making process, and impute their underlying preferences from the data. Our estimates show that callers experience substantially less discomfort per unit of time while waiting for callbacks than while waiting in queue. However, we also find that, after controlling for expected waiting times, callers generally prefer actively waiting in queue over accepting a callback and waiting offline. Using the estimates of our model, we are able to conduct counterfactual analyses of how various callback policies affect the performance of this call center. This helps managers to gauge different callback policies against each other to find the most effective policy before implementing it. Our counterfactual analyses show that offering to hold the callers' spot in line or to call back within a short window improves service quality by decreasing callers' average incurred waiting cost. Moreover, we find that offering callbacks as a demand postponement strategy during periods of temporary congestion substantially increases service quality and system throughput.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Queueing Systems
- Vol. 91 (1-2) , 113-142
On first-come, first-served queues with two classes of impatient customers
- 28 October 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Queueing Systems
- Vol. 91 (1-2) , 113-142
Open AccessOn first-come, first-served queues with two classes of impatient customers