KTKaren Trentelman

Karen Trentelman

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Karen Trentelman has a total of 118 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The Getty Peacock Fresco: Unravelling Its History through Technical and Historical Investigations

    by Kenneth Lapatin, Marie Svoboda, Sierra Schiano, Monica Ganio, Karen Trentelman

    Acquired by J. Paul Getty himself in 1968, the Getty Museum’s fragment of a fresco depicting a peacock (68.AG.13) has long been a favorite among visitors. Hitherto considered to be an ancient Roman work produced in Campania circa 70 CE, it has been reproduced as museum merchandise, textbook illustrations, and gift-shop decor. Recent technical examination and analyses combined with historical research, however, reveal that the popular peacock is not in fact ancient, nor does it seem to be a forgery. Rather, it appears to be a reproduction of a now-lost fresco from a Pompeian house that was fashioned to decorate an early twentieth-century “free Greek-style” bungalow designed by architect Robert Alexander Briggs in the English countryside.

  • Art as Evidence: Uncovering the Past Through the Scientific Analysis of Works of Art

    by Karen Trentelman

    The scientific analysis of works of art is carried out to answer questions related to artist’s technique, provenance, historic technologies, and material properties. Utilizing primarily non-invasive imaging and spectroscopic techniques, studies on objects ranging from mummies to Medieval manuscripts to paintings by masters such as Rembrandt and van Gogh will be presented.

  • Open Access

    Portrait of an Etruscan Athletic Official: A Multi-Analytical Study of a Painted Terracotta Wall Panel

    by Monica Ganio, Douglas MacLennan, Marie Svoboda, Claire Lyons, Karen Trentelman

    The Getty’s Etruscan painted terracotta wall panel, Athletic Official, recently has been speculated to be associated with a Caeretan wall panel depicting a Discobolus based on a shared iconography. To better understand the materials and techniques used to create the Getty panel and investigate its relation to extant Etruscan painted terracotta panels, a multi-analytical study was conducted, using broadband visible, IR, and UV imaging, along with scanning MA-XRF, FORS, Raman, SEM-EDS, and XRD analytical techniques. The analytical results together with PCA analysis suggest the clay support of the Getty panel is most similar in composition to that of panels from Cerveteri. A manganese black was identified in the decorative scheme; not commonly employed, this appears to be an important marker for the workshop practice in Cerveteri. Most significantly, the use of MA-XRF scanning allowed for invisible ruling lines on the Athletic Official, presumably laid down at the earliest stages of the creation of the panel, to be visualized. Taken together, the results of this study provide new insights into Caeretan workshop practice as well as provide a framework for better understanding the design and execution of Etruscan polychromy.


  • Vittae Auratae:Interpreting the History and Technology of a Group of Roman Gold Textile Fragments

    by Mary Louise Hart, Monica Ganio, Susan Lansing Maish, Douglas MacLennan, Karen Trentelman

    Fifty-six gold fragments—forty-nine pieces of woven textile and seven of twisted cord—from the collection of the J. Paul Getty Museum were the subject of an art historical and scientific study to a...


  • Open Access

    Seeing red: towards an improved protocol for the identification of madder- and cochineal-based pigments by fiber optics reflectance spectroscopy (FORS)

    by Beatriz Fonseca, Catherine Schmidt Patterson, Monica Ganio, Douglas MacLennan, Karen Trentelman

    Fiber optics reflectance spectroscopy (FORS) is commonly used to non-invasively identify madder- and cochineal-based pigments on works of art, but the significant shifts sometimes observed in the position of their diagnostic absorption features can hinder correct interpretation of the spectra. To better understand these shifts, and improve the ability to confidently identify these pigments, a systematic study was carried out to evaluate the effects of different pigment recipes and laking substrates on reflectance spectra. Sixteen different madder- and cochineal-based pigments were synthesized using historical recipes. Each pigment, painted in four different binding media (gum Arabic, linseed oil, beeswax, and egg yolk), was fully characterized by FTIR and HPLC-DAD-MS prior to FORS measurements. The results of the study showed that, in contrast to the absorption features typically used for identification, features in the first derivative transformation of the FORS spectra provided a more robust means of primary identification. In addition, once it has been identified as cochineal, the absorption features in the spectra of cochineal-based pigments could be correlated to the recipe employed, providing a possible means for inferring the method of manufacture and laking substrate from a non-invasive analysis. The results of this study were used to create a decision tree for the identification of madder and cochineal pigments based solely on FORS.


  • Open Access

    Odilon Redon’s noir drawings: characterization of materials and methods using noninvasive imaging and spectroscopies

    by Nathan S. Daly, Michelle Sullivan, Lynn Lee, John K. Delaney, Karen Trentelman

    The artist Odilon Redon (1840–1916) was a French symbolist known for both the dark, surreal prints and drawings he created in the first half of his career, as well as the colorful pastel works that characterized the second half of his career. This study examines two drawings by Redon in the J. Paul Getty Museum collection—Apparition (ca. 1880–1890) and Head within an Aureole (ca. 1894–1895)—executed during the period in his career in which he was transitioning between these two modes. In order to better understand the materials the artist chose and the methods by which he applied them, two noninvasive, macroscopic characterization techniques—macro X-ray fluorescence (MA-XRF) scanning and reflectance imaging spectroscopy (RIS)—were employed. These techniques allowed the materials present to be distinguished and the relationship between their applications visualized. Coupled with fiber optic reflectance spectroscopy (FORS) and Raman microspectroscopy with principal component analysis (PCA), these results give new insight into the materials and methods used by Redon. Six distinct black drawing materials and a yellow pastel were identified in Apparition, underscoring the complexity of Redon’s noir drawings. As he began using color pastel more frequently he seemed to use a simplified black palette; in Head within an Aureole the artist used only two black drawing materials and three color pastels (two pink and one blue). This research provides a framework for future noninvasive technical analysis of works by Redon in other collections as well as mixed media drawings more generally.


  • Open Access

    Rembrandt's An Old Man in Military Costume: Combining hyperspectral and MA-XRF imaging to understand how two paintings were painted on a single panel

    by Douglas MacLennan, Karen Trentelman, Yvonne Szafran, Anne T. Woollett, John K. Delaney, Koen Janssens, Joris Dik

    Over the past several decades the painting An Old Man in Military Costume by Rembrandt Harmensz van Rijn (ca. 1630–31; J. Paul Getty Museum, 78.PB.246) has been the subject of a number of investigations carried out in order to better visualize a second painting beneath the surface figure. The underlying image – the head and shoulders of a man wearing a cloak – is oriented 180 degrees from the upper image and appears to be fairly complete. Scanning macro x-ray fluorescence (XRF) spectroscopy reveals the face is painted with lead white and a mercury-containing pigment (likely vermilion), and the cloak is painted with a copper-containing pigment. Following the revelation and digital color reconstruction of the underlying figure, a number of questions still remained. Here, through the use of infrared reflectance imaging spectroscopy (i.e., hyperspectral imaging) and macro-XRF imaging spectroscopy, together with cross-sections taken from targeted areas, the sequence of painting in both compositions was explored. Of particular interest was the discovery of evidence of multiple attempts to situate the lower figure, and the subsequent application of a blocking-out layer over the lower figure before the artist rotated the panel and executed the upper figure. In addition, examination of the placement of the two images on the panel adds to our understanding of the subtle complexities of Rembrandt's working process.


  • Open Access

    Multivariate analysis of Raman spectra of carbonaceous black drawing media for the in situ identification of historic artist materials

    by Nathan S. Daly, Michelle Sullivan, Lynn Lee, Karen Trentelman

    The identification of black drawing materials in works of art on paper is often important for their conservation and crucial to gain insight about artists' methodologies and the historic use of drawing materials. Traditionally, conservators and curators have had to rely upon visual observation with multiple wavelengths of light and magnification to characterize the materials in drawings, a challenging task further complicated if the media have been manipulated by the artist. The use of carbon‐based pigments in black drawing materials, ranging from charcoals and chalks to pastels and crayons, can be verified in situ using Raman microspectroscopy based on the presence of the two broad spectral bands characteristic of carbonaceous materials. However, the subtle differences in these spectral features between pigments can be difficult to discern, especially in cases with high background fluorescence. Here, we utilized principal component analysis to distinguish a group of 14 reference black drawing materials, both contemporary and historic, in the Raman spectral region of 800–2,000 cm−1. The model generated successfully differentiates between charcoal, chalk, and fabricated stick media, with sensitivity to both the Raman bands of carbon‐based materials as well as the fluorescent background profile. We validated the model using Raman spectra of black media on 19th‐century French drawings from the J. Paul Getty Museum collection that were previously classified visually by microscopic evaluation.


  • Open Access

    Visualizing underdrawings in medieval manuscript illuminations with macro‐X‐ray fluorescence scanning

    by Nancy K. Turner, Catherine Schmidt Patterson, Douglas K. MacLennan, Karen Trentelman

    The element‐specific distribution maps generated by scanning macro‐X‐ray fluorescence (XRF) spectroscopy are providing cultural heritage researchers with information about the composition of materials present in works of art and, more importantly, unprecedented insight into the techniques employed by artists in their creation. One of the advantages of macro‐XRF scanning is that the X‐rays probe materials in subsurface layers, allowing, for example, visualizations of hidden paintings to be produced. Consequently, macro‐XRF scanning has found wide use in the study of paintings, but the high spatial resolution also makes it particularly well suited for the study of the small‐scale painted illustrations and decorative elements found in illuminated manuscripts. The preliminary drawings made by manuscript illuminators to plan a painted composition—known as underdrawings—provide evidence relating to artists' creative vision and working process but are difficult to examine because they are generally hidden under the surface paint layer. Traditionally, underdrawings in a carbon‐based medium are visualized using infrared (IR) imaging. In this study, results of the analysis of painted illuminations from medieval illuminated manuscripts demonstrate that macro‐XRF scanning can visualize underdrawings in other materials, such as iron‐gall ink, metalpoint, and pigmented inks/paints, thus serving as a useful complement to traditional IR imaging. For manuscript illuminations in bound books, this study also discusses the use of interleaving materials to reduce unwanted signals from underlying folios. The ability to reveal manuscript underdrawings will help elucidate artistic intent and workshop practice and provide a new way to examine the history of medieval drawing.


  • Analyzing the Heterogeneous Hierarchy of Cultural Heritage Materials: Analytical Imaging

    by Karen Trentelman

    Objects of cultural heritage significance are created using a wide variety of materials, or mixtures of materials, and often exhibit heterogeneity on multiple length scales. The effective study of these complex constructions thus requires the use of a suite of complementary analytical technologies. Moreover, because of the importance and irreplaceability of most cultural heritage objects, researchers favor analytical techniques that can be employed noninvasively, i.e., without having to remove any material for analysis. As such, analytical imaging has emerged as an important approach for the study of cultural heritage. Imaging technologies commonly employed, from the macroscale through the micro- to nanoscale, are discussed with respect to how the information obtained helps us understand artists’ materials and methods, the cultures in which the objects were created, how the objects may have changed over time, and importantly, how we may develop strategies for their preservation.