Daina Crafa
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Daina Crafa has a total of 112 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Mathieu B. Brodeur
4 shared publicationsCaitlin M. Stoddart
2 shared publicationsHerman Kwansa
Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland
2 shared publicationsJannik Wiggers
2 shared publicationsKathleen K. Kibler
Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland
2 shared publicationsSaskia K. Nagel
RWTH Aachen University
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 December 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The state of interbrain synchrony research across 20 years: A hyperscanning retrospective
This systematic review article celebrates the 20th anniversary of hyperscanning research by examining the state of the scientific methodologies and findings. In 2002, Montague et al. proposed hyperscanning as a new method for studying human social cognition using fMRI. Ten years later, Cui et al. (2012) introduced fNIRS as a motion-tolerant device that was well- suited for hyperscanning research, especially interpersonal neural synchrony (INS). Though still in its infancy, INS research has gained notoriety, credibility, and momentum since these milestone publications. The best practices and frequent findings in INS research are still emerging. To capture the state of the science, original INS research articles (N=107) published between 2002-2022 were reviewed for study sample characteristics, experimental methods and cognitive domains, data processing and analysis approaches, as well as reported INS findings. A picture of INS hyperscanning research conventions and general findings emerge as outcome of this review.
- 1 December 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe state of interbrain synchrony research across 20 years: A hyperscanning retrospective
This systematic review article celebrates the 20th anniversary of hyperscanning research by examining the state of the scientific methodologies and findings. In 2002, Montague et al. proposed hyperscanning as a new method for studying human social cognition using fMRI. Ten years later, Cui et al. (2012) introduced fNIRS as a motion-tolerant device that was well- suited for hyperscanning research, especially interpersonal neural synchrony (INS). Though still in its infancy, INS research has gained notoriety, credibility, and momentum since these milestone publications. The best practices and frequent findings in INS research are still emerging. To capture the state of the science, original INS research articles (N=107) published between 2002-2022 were reviewed for study sample characteristics, experimental methods and cognitive domains, data processing and analysis approaches, as well as reported INS findings. A picture of INS hyperscanning research conventions and general findings emerge as outcome of this review.
- Open Access
- 4 July 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Social interaction alters neural representations of self-identity: Evidence of possible neural precursors to social learning
Social interaction requires enough social flexibility to accommodate an interlocutor’s perspective. Our previous research demonstrated that suppression of self-identity may be necessary during a social interaction with a friendly stranger if they have different social values. The present study examines neurobiological mechanisms responsible for suppressing self-identity and entertaining the stranger’s perspective. This study takes a semi-naturalistic neuroscience approach. Eighteen participants underwent an fMRI scan immediately after having a social interaction with a stranger. We hypothesized that pairing of activation in the inferior frontal gyrus (IFG) and dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC) because they reflect activation of self-regulation and changes in self-identity. Brain activity in the IFG and dmPFC emerged, supporting our hypothesis and previous behavioral findings, and the precuneus played a key role. Evidence of social learning also emerged, which demonstrated that neural changes may occur before behavioral changes do. These findings suggest that social interaction influences self-identity on a neurobiological level and that neurobehavioral suppression of the social self may be a precursor to social learning. This study is the first to directly compare neural activation associated with active and stable self-concepts in an fMRI scanner after a social interaction. Findings will act as a foundation for future fully-naturalistic neuroscience studies to base hypotheses upon.
- 4 July 2023
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessSocial interaction alters neural representations of self-identity: Evidence of possible neural precursors to social learning
Social interaction requires enough social flexibility to accommodate an interlocutor’s perspective. Our previous research demonstrated that suppression of self-identity may be necessary during a social interaction with a friendly stranger if they have different social values. The present study examines neurobiological mechanisms responsible for suppressing self-identity and entertaining the stranger’s perspective. This study takes a semi-naturalistic neuroscience approach. Eighteen participants underwent an fMRI scan immediately after having a social interaction with a stranger. We hypothesized that pairing of activation in the inferior frontal gyrus (IFG) and dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC) because they reflect activation of self-regulation and changes in self-identity. Brain activity in the IFG and dmPFC emerged, supporting our hypothesis and previous behavioral findings, and the precuneus played a key role. Evidence of social learning also emerged, which demonstrated that neural changes may occur before behavioral changes do. These findings suggest that social interaction influences self-identity on a neurobiological level and that neurobehavioral suppression of the social self may be a precursor to social learning. This study is the first to directly compare neural activation associated with active and stable self-concepts in an fMRI scanner after a social interaction. Findings will act as a foundation for future fully-naturalistic neuroscience studies to base hypotheses upon.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Can I trust you? Differentiating contributions of stereotypes, gender, and faith in others
Stereotypes are often harmful social heuristics that emerge through generalizations about groups of people. Regularly, these groups are classified by their skin color, apparent gender, or other superficial features. Our study mimicked real life by introducing participants (N = 121) to artificially colored images of human faces (blue versus red faces) who looked male or female and to stereotyping information about one of the colors that were either negatively or positively phrased. Participants indicated how much they trusted group members and completed a self-rated scale regarding general faith in others. This study found that the stereotyping information could effectively bias participant ratings, regardless of what color face they initially preferred, F(3,117) = 11.26, p <0.001. Furthermore, participants were more likely to trust female faces regardless of the color, F(1,119) = 27.83, p < 0.001. Marginal evidence revealed that general faith in others contributes to stereotype formation. Factor analysis was performed to further interrogate the findings. Implications and suggestions for future directions are discussed.
- 2 July 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessCan I trust you? Differentiating contributions of stereotypes, gender, and faith in others
Stereotypes are often harmful social heuristics that emerge through generalizations about groups of people. Regularly, these groups are classified by their skin color, apparent gender, or other superficial features. Our study mimicked real life by introducing participants (N = 121) to artificially colored images of human faces (blue versus red faces) who looked male or female and to stereotyping information about one of the colors that were either negatively or positively phrased. Participants indicated how much they trusted group members and completed a self-rated scale regarding general faith in others. This study found that the stereotyping information could effectively bias participant ratings, regardless of what color face they initially preferred, F(3,117) = 11.26, p <0.001. Furthermore, participants were more likely to trust female faces regardless of the color, F(1,119) = 27.83, p < 0.001. Marginal evidence revealed that general faith in others contributes to stereotype formation. Factor analysis was performed to further interrogate the findings. Implications and suggestions for future directions are discussed.
- Open Access
- 29 November 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Criticism of the paper “The association between early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and junior author performance”
The authors of this letter represent a large student body who have generally had especially positive experiences with female mentors’ advice and mentorships and do not support the conclusions of the article “The association between early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and junior author performance” because its conclusions regarding gender reach beyond the article’s scope and because the quality of mentorships cannot be analysed only through citation counts. Publications are not equivalent to learning outcomes or professional advancement.After careful review of the aforementioned article, we see numerous scientific flaws. The causal inferences that can be drawn from the observed effects of gender on the mentor-protégé relationship are insubstantial and other aspects of the paper are limited in the reductionist design of their mentor-protégé relationship assessment, which is based on the scientific impact of future papers.
- 29 November 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessCriticism of the paper “The association between early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and junior author performance”
The authors of this letter represent a large student body who have generally had especially positive experiences with female mentors’ advice and mentorships and do not support the conclusions of the article “The association between early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and junior author performance” because its conclusions regarding gender reach beyond the article’s scope and because the quality of mentorships cannot be analysed only through citation counts. Publications are not equivalent to learning outcomes or professional advancement.After careful review of the aforementioned article, we see numerous scientific flaws. The causal inferences that can be drawn from the observed effects of gender on the mentor-protégé relationship are insubstantial and other aspects of the paper are limited in the reductionist design of their mentor-protégé relationship assessment, which is based on the scientific impact of future papers.
- 29 January 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transcultural Psychiatry
- Vol. 57 (3) , 387-407
Traces of culture: The feedback loop between behavior, brain, and disorder
Culture is part of an extensive series of feedback loops, which involve multiple organismic levels including social contexts, cognitive mediations, neural processes, and behavior. Recent studies in neuroscience show that culturally contingent social processes shape some neural pathways. Studying the influence of cultural context on neural processes may yield new insights into psychiatric disorders. New methodologies in the neurosciences offer innovative ways to assess the impact of culture on mental health and illness. However, implementing these methodologies raises important theoretical and ethical concerns, which must be resolved to address patient individuality and the complexity of cultural diversity. This article discusses cultural context as a major influence on (and consequence of) human neural plasticity and advocates a culture–brain–behavior (CBB) interaction model for conceptualizing the relationship between culture, brain, and psychiatric disorders. Recommendations are made for integrating neuroscientific techniques into transcultural psychiatric research by taking a systems approach to evaluating disorders.
- 29 January 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transcultural Psychiatry
- Vol. 57 (3) , 387-407
Traces of culture: The feedback loop between behavior, brain, and disorder
Culture is part of an extensive series of feedback loops, which involve multiple organismic levels including social contexts, cognitive mediations, neural processes, and behavior. Recent studies in neuroscience show that culturally contingent social processes shape some neural pathways. Studying the influence of cultural context on neural processes may yield new insights into psychiatric disorders. New methodologies in the neurosciences offer innovative ways to assess the impact of culture on mental health and illness. However, implementing these methodologies raises important theoretical and ethical concerns, which must be resolved to address patient individuality and the complexity of cultural diversity. This article discusses cultural context as a major influence on (and consequence of) human neural plasticity and advocates a culture–brain–behavior (CBB) interaction model for conceptualizing the relationship between culture, brain, and psychiatric disorders. Recommendations are made for integrating neuroscientific techniques into transcultural psychiatric research by taking a systems approach to evaluating disorders.
- Open Access
- 25 January 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The impressionable social self of schizophrenia: Neural correlates of self-other confusion after social interaction
Background: Social interactions require rapid, real-time information integration and performative application of dynamic social information, and can be especially difficult for patients with schizophrenia. Their difficulty processing social information could lie in challenges extracting the information or in updating their actions to accommodate the new information, resulting in behaviors that may appear rigid or inappropriate. Disruptions may emerge in the underlying, requisite behavioral or neural processes. Methods: Seventeen matched healthy controls and seventeen patients with schizophrenia participated in an fMRI study, which included a social interaction priming procedure wherein they met a friendly stranger who held opposite social values from their own. They answered self-judgement questions about their social values two days before the priming experiment and again during the fMRI scan. Results: Controls suppress social values when interacting with the stranger whereas patients with schizophrenia augment the opposite values, simultaneously holding two sets of social values. Compared to controls, patients display hyperactivity in dorsomedial prefrontal cortex and atypical activity in caudate, posterior cingulate and precuneus. Discussion: Patients appear to correctly extract social information but apply the information atypically. They display evidence of atypical social flexibility on both performative and neural measures, resulting in confusion between self and other.
- 25 January 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe impressionable social self of schizophrenia: Neural correlates of self-other confusion after social interaction
Background: Social interactions require rapid, real-time information integration and performative application of dynamic social information, and can be especially difficult for patients with schizophrenia. Their difficulty processing social information could lie in challenges extracting the information or in updating their actions to accommodate the new information, resulting in behaviors that may appear rigid or inappropriate. Disruptions may emerge in the underlying, requisite behavioral or neural processes. Methods: Seventeen matched healthy controls and seventeen patients with schizophrenia participated in an fMRI study, which included a social interaction priming procedure wherein they met a friendly stranger who held opposite social values from their own. They answered self-judgement questions about their social values two days before the priming experiment and again during the fMRI scan. Results: Controls suppress social values when interacting with the stranger whereas patients with schizophrenia augment the opposite values, simultaneously holding two sets of social values. Compared to controls, patients display hyperactivity in dorsomedial prefrontal cortex and atypical activity in caudate, posterior cingulate and precuneus. Discussion: Patients appear to correctly extract social information but apply the information atypically. They display evidence of atypical social flexibility on both performative and neural measures, resulting in confusion between self and other.
- Open Access
- 7 January 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Traces of Culture: The Feedback Loop Between Behavior, Brain, and Disorder
Culture is part of an extensive series of feedback loops, which involve multiple organismic levels including social contexts, cognitive mediations, neural processes, and behavior. Recent studies in neuroscience show that culturally contingent social processes shape some neural pathways. Studying the influence of cultural context on neural processes may yield new insights into psychiatric disorders. New methodologies in the neurosciences offer innovative ways to assess the impact of culture on mental health and illness. However, implementing these methodologies raises important theoretical and ethical concerns, which must be resolved to address patient individuality and the complexity of cultural diversity. This paper discusses cultural context as a major influence on (and consequence of) human neural plasticity and advocates a culture-brain-behavior (CBB) interaction model for conceptualizing the relationship between culture, brain, and psychiatric disorders. Recommendations are made for integrating neuroscientific techniques into transcultural psychiatric research by taking a systems approach to evaluating disorders.
- 7 January 2020
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessTraces of Culture: The Feedback Loop Between Behavior, Brain, and Disorder
Culture is part of an extensive series of feedback loops, which involve multiple organismic levels including social contexts, cognitive mediations, neural processes, and behavior. Recent studies in neuroscience show that culturally contingent social processes shape some neural pathways. Studying the influence of cultural context on neural processes may yield new insights into psychiatric disorders. New methodologies in the neurosciences offer innovative ways to assess the impact of culture on mental health and illness. However, implementing these methodologies raises important theoretical and ethical concerns, which must be resolved to address patient individuality and the complexity of cultural diversity. This paper discusses cultural context as a major influence on (and consequence of) human neural plasticity and advocates a culture-brain-behavior (CBB) interaction model for conceptualizing the relationship between culture, brain, and psychiatric disorders. Recommendations are made for integrating neuroscientific techniques into transcultural psychiatric research by taking a systems approach to evaluating disorders.
- Open Access
- 21 December 2019
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Social interaction alters self-identity: Adapted methods for measuring active self-concepts
Social interactions require fluid self-concepts to adapt to real-time dynamics – in theory. In practice, fluid processes have been difficult to experimentally quantify. Active self-concepts theoretically respond to social contexts while stable self-concepts are context-independent. Such fluctuations in ‘typical’ adults have rarely been reported. Self-concept research has broad implications; inducing and quantifying active fluctuations is long-sought-after in social psychology. However, since their inception, self-concepts were studied using bicultural participants (e.g., cultural priming experiments) and characterized in psychiatric patients (e.g., ‘fragmented self’). By increasing methodological saliency and ecological validity of popular methods, three studies tested an adapted scale and social interaction priming procedure for differentiating between active and stable self-concepts. Psychometrics, reproducibility and clinical relevance are compared to a common measure of bicultural self-concept fluidity using optimized statistics. Pre-Study controls (N=42) characterize repetition effects. Study 1: Active self-concepts are suppressed in convenience sample of 62 W.E.I.R.D. students. Study 2: Diverse, locally-representative and randomly-sampled adults (N=43) replicates Study 1 findings. Study 3: Patients with schizophrenia (N=27) hold opposing self-concepts, adopting their interlocutor’s while keeping their own. Four distinct flexibility phenotypes emerge. These studies are the first to quantify active self-concepts. This article precedes a manuscript series interrogating replicability, neural activations and cultural-clinical implications.
- 21 December 2019
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessSocial interaction alters self-identity: Adapted methods for measuring active self-concepts
Social interactions require fluid self-concepts to adapt to real-time dynamics – in theory. In practice, fluid processes have been difficult to experimentally quantify. Active self-concepts theoretically respond to social contexts while stable self-concepts are context-independent. Such fluctuations in ‘typical’ adults have rarely been reported. Self-concept research has broad implications; inducing and quantifying active fluctuations is long-sought-after in social psychology. However, since their inception, self-concepts were studied using bicultural participants (e.g., cultural priming experiments) and characterized in psychiatric patients (e.g., ‘fragmented self’). By increasing methodological saliency and ecological validity of popular methods, three studies tested an adapted scale and social interaction priming procedure for differentiating between active and stable self-concepts. Psychometrics, reproducibility and clinical relevance are compared to a common measure of bicultural self-concept fluidity using optimized statistics. Pre-Study controls (N=42) characterize repetition effects. Study 1: Active self-concepts are suppressed in convenience sample of 62 W.E.I.R.D. students. Study 2: Diverse, locally-representative and randomly-sampled adults (N=43) replicates Study 1 findings. Study 3: Patients with schizophrenia (N=27) hold opposing self-concepts, adopting their interlocutor’s while keeping their own. Four distinct flexibility phenotypes emerge. These studies are the first to quantify active self-concepts. This article precedes a manuscript series interrogating replicability, neural activations and cultural-clinical implications.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2019
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 10, 287
Social Values and Determinants of Cultural Fit in Quebec: The Roles of Ancestry, Linguistic Group, and Mental Health Status
Many quantitative cross-cultural research studies assume that cultural groups consist of anyone born and raised in the same country. Applying these criteria to the formation of study samples may produce cohorts that share a country but are heterogeneous in relevant domains of culture. For example, in Canada, Franco- and Anglo-Canadians are generally assumed to represent different linguistic groups but the same cultural group. However, speaking a different first language also can mean exposure to different media, information, and conventions, which are known to shape certain cultural domains, such as social values. Other factors may also produce cultural heterogeneity. For example, ancestral origins and recency of familial migration may influence endorsed social values after exposure to diverse cultures or norms. Mental health status or psychiatric conditions may also influence subscription of social values due to different lifestyle demands. Understanding the nuanced contributions of diverse backgrounds to cultural membership and fit (i.e., the degree to which an individual behaves like other cultural members) is useful when performing quantitative cross-cultural studies to minimize alternative explanations for statistical outcomes. This study used Cultural Consensus Analysis (CCA) to assess the cultural fit of social values for 222 Canadians, who had participated in cross-cultural neuropsychological experiments. CCA is an anthropological statistical method for evaluating cultural agreement of a sample. Participants were systematically evaluated by linguistic groups (French and English), migratory generation (1st–3rd+), and mental health status (healthy and patient). Group and individual variances were statistically interrogated. Results demonstrated that Franco- and Anglo-Canadians represent different cultural groups cohabitating in Quebec. Social values dividing Franco- and Anglo-Canadians were also identified. Second and third generation Canadians held more heterogeneous social values than Canadians, whose families had migrated earlier. Second generation Canadians with psychiatric disorders showed notably reduced cultural fit with other Canadians, which supports other literature reporting difficulties experienced by second generation migrants. However, third and later generations of Canadians with psychiatric disorders held a greater range of social values compared to healthy Canadians but still were good fits for Canadian culture. This study concluded that linguistic group and migratory generation partially determines cultural group for the social values domain while mental health status does not, contrary to theories proposed by previous literature.
- 7 May 2019
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 10, 287
Open AccessSocial Values and Determinants of Cultural Fit in Quebec: The Roles of Ancestry, Linguistic Group, and Mental Health Status
Many quantitative cross-cultural research studies assume that cultural groups consist of anyone born and raised in the same country. Applying these criteria to the formation of study samples may produce cohorts that share a country but are heterogeneous in relevant domains of culture. For example, in Canada, Franco- and Anglo-Canadians are generally assumed to represent different linguistic groups but the same cultural group. However, speaking a different first language also can mean exposure to different media, information, and conventions, which are known to shape certain cultural domains, such as social values. Other factors may also produce cultural heterogeneity. For example, ancestral origins and recency of familial migration may influence endorsed social values after exposure to diverse cultures or norms. Mental health status or psychiatric conditions may also influence subscription of social values due to different lifestyle demands. Understanding the nuanced contributions of diverse backgrounds to cultural membership and fit (i.e., the degree to which an individual behaves like other cultural members) is useful when performing quantitative cross-cultural studies to minimize alternative explanations for statistical outcomes. This study used Cultural Consensus Analysis (CCA) to assess the cultural fit of social values for 222 Canadians, who had participated in cross-cultural neuropsychological experiments. CCA is an anthropological statistical method for evaluating cultural agreement of a sample. Participants were systematically evaluated by linguistic groups (French and English), migratory generation (1st–3rd+), and mental health status (healthy and patient). Group and individual variances were statistically interrogated. Results demonstrated that Franco- and Anglo-Canadians represent different cultural groups cohabitating in Quebec. Social values dividing Franco- and Anglo-Canadians were also identified. Second and third generation Canadians held more heterogeneous social values than Canadians, whose families had migrated earlier. Second generation Canadians with psychiatric disorders showed notably reduced cultural fit with other Canadians, which supports other literature reporting difficulties experienced by second generation migrants. However, third and later generations of Canadians with psychiatric disorders held a greater range of social values compared to healthy Canadians but still were good fits for Canadian culture. This study concluded that linguistic group and migratory generation partially determines cultural group for the social values domain while mental health status does not, contrary to theories proposed by previous literature.
- 6 March 2019
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioral and Brain Sciences
- Vol. 42, e5
The adaptive self: Culture and social flexibility in feedback networks
Culture contextualizes the contents and intentionality of many mental statuses. Cognitive mediation of cultural information shapes these contents and intentionalities, as well as many of the false beliefs of pathology. Flexibility of cognitive mediation processes and resulting beliefs and pathologies may vary by individual, be a key mechanism of the feedback loop, and help characterize network connections.
- 6 March 2019
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioral and Brain Sciences
- Vol. 42, e5
The adaptive self: Culture and social flexibility in feedback networks
Culture contextualizes the contents and intentionality of many mental statuses. Cognitive mediation of cultural information shapes these contents and intentionalities, as well as many of the false beliefs of pathology. Flexibility of cognitive mediation processes and resulting beliefs and pathologies may vary by individual, be a key mechanism of the feedback loop, and help characterize network connections.