José Luis Martí
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
José Luis Martí has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Andreas Føllesdal
2 shared publicationsArchon Fung
2 shared publicationsBernard Manin
2 shared publicationsCristina Lafont
2 shared publicationsDavid Estlund
2 shared publicationsJames Bohman
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 November 2024
- Published by Instituto de Investigaciones Filosóficas in Análisis Filosófico
- Vol. 44 (2) , 355-361
Cinco lecciones garzonianas
- 8 November 2024
- Published by Instituto de Investigaciones Filosóficas in Análisis Filosófico
- Vol. 44 (2) , 355-361
Open AccessCinco lecciones garzonianas
- 15 December 2023
- Published by Pragma Communication
- p. 305-347
Electoral Participation and Non-Electoral Participatory Processes
This chapter aims to contribute to the debate on the relevance of non-electoral participatory processes for electoral participation at local, national and European levels. It first provides a general framework of analysis to better understand the idea of strengthening electoral participation, both in its quantitative and qualitative dimensions. It then looks at some of the European initiatives that have been recently launched with the aim of strengthening EU and national democratic elections. The chapter explores the most important strategies pursued at national and local levels to strengthen democracy by promoting different forms of non-electoral participation, with a special emphasis on some recent democratic innovations. It concludes with a presentation of four case-studies of different instruments/processes of non-electoral participation: the DECIDIM online platform developed by the city of Barcelona, the vTaiwan digital space for citizen engagement in Taiwan, the recent Chilean constitutional convention, and the Conference for the Future of Europe. Even if some take for granted that promoting forms of non-electoral participation is the key strategy to strengthen not only democratic legitimacy in general, but the quantity and quality of electoral participation in particular, we argue that this is not yet a foregone conclusion.
- 15 December 2023
- Published by Pragma Communication
- p. 305-347
Electoral Participation and Non-Electoral Participatory Processes
This chapter aims to contribute to the debate on the relevance of non-electoral participatory processes for electoral participation at local, national and European levels. It first provides a general framework of analysis to better understand the idea of strengthening electoral participation, both in its quantitative and qualitative dimensions. It then looks at some of the European initiatives that have been recently launched with the aim of strengthening EU and national democratic elections. The chapter explores the most important strategies pursued at national and local levels to strengthen democracy by promoting different forms of non-electoral participation, with a special emphasis on some recent democratic innovations. It concludes with a presentation of four case-studies of different instruments/processes of non-electoral participation: the DECIDIM online platform developed by the city of Barcelona, the vTaiwan digital space for citizen engagement in Taiwan, the recent Chilean constitutional convention, and the Conference for the Future of Europe. Even if some take for granted that promoting forms of non-electoral participation is the key strategy to strengthen not only democratic legitimacy in general, but the quantity and quality of electoral participation in particular, we argue that this is not yet a foregone conclusion.
- Open Access
- 22 March 2023
- Published by Universidad Externado de Colombia in Revista Derecho del Estado
- No. 55,p. 87-104
Múltiples velocidades. Sobre Democracia sin atajos, de Cristina Lafont
En su último libro, Democracia sin atajos, Cristina Lafont nos propone un exigente ideal de democracia como autogobierno en el que los ciudadanos deben poder participar en los procesos de deliberación pública con el fin de poderse apropiar e identificar por igual con las instituciones y leyes a las que están sujetos. En el arduo camino de aproximación al ideal, Lafont rechaza los atajos mágicos que prometen la realización instantánea del ideal, como los mini-públicos, bajo algunas de sus interpretaciones. En este comentario defiendo que hay dos tipos de atajos de representación institucional, los de sustitución y los complementarios, y que los segundos son totalmente compatibles con el esquema de Lafont. Con respecto a los de sustitución, argumento que cualquier teoría no ideal plausible de la democracia debería también hacerles espacio, bajo ciertas condiciones democráticas sistémicas estrictas.
- 22 March 2023
- Published by Universidad Externado de Colombia in Revista Derecho del Estado
- No. 55,p. 87-104
Open AccessMúltiples velocidades. Sobre Democracia sin atajos, de Cristina Lafont
En su último libro, Democracia sin atajos, Cristina Lafont nos propone un exigente ideal de democracia como autogobierno en el que los ciudadanos deben poder participar en los procesos de deliberación pública con el fin de poderse apropiar e identificar por igual con las instituciones y leyes a las que están sujetos. En el arduo camino de aproximación al ideal, Lafont rechaza los atajos mágicos que prometen la realización instantánea del ideal, como los mini-públicos, bajo algunas de sus interpretaciones. En este comentario defiendo que hay dos tipos de atajos de representación institucional, los de sustitución y los complementarios, y que los segundos son totalmente compatibles con el esquema de Lafont. Con respecto a los de sustitución, argumento que cualquier teoría no ideal plausible de la democracia debería también hacerles espacio, bajo ciertas condiciones democráticas sistémicas estrictas.
- Open Access
- 30 April 2022
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in Digital Government: Research and Practice
- Vol. 3 (2) , 1-15
Crowdsourcing Crisis Management and Democratic Legitimacy
In situations of crisis, governments must make decisions under a great uncertainty, complexity, urgency, high social pressure, and great scarcity of resources. We need to maximize the quality of decisions and ensure that we find practical and effective solutions for our problems. The stakes are simply too high. The risk, however, is to give up democratic legitimacy for, in the best case, some form of output legitimacy or technocracy. On the other hand, decisions made in times of emergency are tremendously consequential for our citizens, affecting their fundamental rights and welfare, and it is for decisions like this that democratic legitimacy seems to be crucial. We may be in the apparent dilemma of having to choose between the quality of public decision-making and its democratic legitimacy. This article claims that this is a false dilemma, at least if we take it as an either/or choice. Rather than choosing one value or the other, what we need is to find a proper balance between them on a case-by-case basis. And the article argues that one very promising way to do it is by applying the ideas of crowdlaw and crowdsourcing crisis management based on the potential of collective intelligence, which in turn grounds an ideal of participatory, deliberative, and collaborative democracy.
- 30 April 2022
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in Digital Government: Research and Practice
- Vol. 3 (2) , 1-15
Open AccessCrowdsourcing Crisis Management and Democratic Legitimacy
In situations of crisis, governments must make decisions under a great uncertainty, complexity, urgency, high social pressure, and great scarcity of resources. We need to maximize the quality of decisions and ensure that we find practical and effective solutions for our problems. The stakes are simply too high. The risk, however, is to give up democratic legitimacy for, in the best case, some form of output legitimacy or technocracy. On the other hand, decisions made in times of emergency are tremendously consequential for our citizens, affecting their fundamental rights and welfare, and it is for decisions like this that democratic legitimacy seems to be crucial. We may be in the apparent dilemma of having to choose between the quality of public decision-making and its democratic legitimacy. This article claims that this is a false dilemma, at least if we take it as an either/or choice. Rather than choosing one value or the other, what we need is to find a proper balance between them on a case-by-case basis. And the article argues that one very promising way to do it is by applying the ideas of crowdlaw and crowdsourcing crisis management based on the potential of collective intelligence, which in turn grounds an ideal of participatory, deliberative, and collaborative democracy.
- Open Access
- 10 December 2021
- Published by Cogitatio in Politics and Governance
- Vol. 9 (4) , 465-474
The Democratic Legitimacy of Secession and the Demos Problem
The normative literature on secession has widely addressed the question of under which conditions the secession of a particular territory from a larger state might be regarded as justifiable. The idea of a normative justification of secession, however, remains ambiguous unless one distinguishes between the justice of secession and its legitimacy, a distinction that is now widely accepted in political philosophy. Much of the literature seems to have focused on the question about justice, while, in comparison, very little attention has been paid to the question of under which conditions secession can be regarded as democratically legitimate, as something explicitly different to the question of justice. This article addresses this second question. After some preliminary remarks, the article focuses on the main obstacle to develop a theory of democratic legitimacy of secessions, the so-called “demos problem.” Such problem, it is argued, has no categorical solution. This does not imply, however, that there is no democratic, legitimate way of redrawing our borders. Two strategies are proposed in this article to overcome the difficulty posed by the demos problem: an ideal strategy of consensus building and a non-ideal strategy of decision-making in the circumstances of disagreement.
- 10 December 2021
- Published by Cogitatio in Politics and Governance
- Vol. 9 (4) , 465-474
Open AccessThe Democratic Legitimacy of Secession and the Demos Problem
The normative literature on secession has widely addressed the question of under which conditions the secession of a particular territory from a larger state might be regarded as justifiable. The idea of a normative justification of secession, however, remains ambiguous unless one distinguishes between the justice of secession and its legitimacy, a distinction that is now widely accepted in political philosophy. Much of the literature seems to have focused on the question about justice, while, in comparison, very little attention has been paid to the question of under which conditions secession can be regarded as democratically legitimate, as something explicitly different to the question of justice. This article addresses this second question. After some preliminary remarks, the article focuses on the main obstacle to develop a theory of democratic legitimacy of secessions, the so-called “demos problem.” Such problem, it is argued, has no categorical solution. This does not imply, however, that there is no democratic, legitimate way of redrawing our borders. Two strategies are proposed in this article to overcome the difficulty posed by the demos problem: an ideal strategy of consensus building and a non-ideal strategy of decision-making in the circumstances of disagreement.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (6) , 3372
The Planetary Wellbeing Initiative: Pursuing the Sustainable Development Goals in Higher Education
We live in a time of pressing planetary challenges, many of which threaten catastrophic change to the natural environment and require massive and novel coordinated scientific and societal efforts on an unprecedented scale. Universities and other academic institutions have the opportunity and responsibility to assume a leading role in an era when the destiny of the planet is precisely in the hands of human beings. Drawing on the Planetary Health project promoted by the Rockefeller Foundation and The Lancet, Pompeu Fabra University launched in 2018 the Planetary Wellbeing Initiative, a long-term institutional strategy also animated by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Planetary Wellbeing might be defined as the highest attainable standard of wellbeing for human and non-human beings and their social and natural systems. Developing the potential of these new concepts involves a substantial theoretical and empirical effort in many different fields, all of them interrelated by the crosscutting challenges of global complexity, interdisciplinarity, and urgency. Close collaboration of science, humanities, and culture is more desperately needed now than ever before in the history of humankind.
- 18 March 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (6) , 3372
Open AccessThe Planetary Wellbeing Initiative: Pursuing the Sustainable Development Goals in Higher Education
We live in a time of pressing planetary challenges, many of which threaten catastrophic change to the natural environment and require massive and novel coordinated scientific and societal efforts on an unprecedented scale. Universities and other academic institutions have the opportunity and responsibility to assume a leading role in an era when the destiny of the planet is precisely in the hands of human beings. Drawing on the Planetary Health project promoted by the Rockefeller Foundation and The Lancet, Pompeu Fabra University launched in 2018 the Planetary Wellbeing Initiative, a long-term institutional strategy also animated by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Planetary Wellbeing might be defined as the highest attainable standard of wellbeing for human and non-human beings and their social and natural systems. Developing the potential of these new concepts involves a substantial theoretical and empirical effort in many different fields, all of them interrelated by the crosscutting challenges of global complexity, interdisciplinarity, and urgency. Close collaboration of science, humanities, and culture is more desperately needed now than ever before in the history of humankind.
- 28 November 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 339-358
Ruth Zimmerling’s Globalization and Democracy, fifteen years on
- 28 November 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 339-358
Ruth Zimmerling’s Globalization and Democracy, fifteen years on
- 26 March 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Jurisprudence
- Vol. 9 (3) , 504-540
Legitimate actors of international law-making: towards a theory of international democratic representation
This article addresses the identity of the legitimate actors of international law-making from the perspective of democratic theory. It argues that both states or state-based international organisations, and civil society actors should be considered complementary legitimate actors of international law-making. Unlike previous accounts, our proposed model of representation, the Multiple Representation Model, is based on an expanded, democratic understanding of the principle of state participation: it is specifically designed to palliate the democratic deficits of more common versions of the Principle of State Consent. Second, it endorses a qualified version of the Principle of Civil Society Participation, one that is much more restrictive and more critical of the democratic defects of civil society actors than most of its current supporters. Finally, it reveals how the democratic strengths and deficits of both models are best approached as mirroring one another and need to be combined in a complex account of representation.
- 26 March 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Jurisprudence
- Vol. 9 (3) , 504-540
Legitimate actors of international law-making: towards a theory of international democratic representation
This article addresses the identity of the legitimate actors of international law-making from the perspective of democratic theory. It argues that both states or state-based international organisations, and civil society actors should be considered complementary legitimate actors of international law-making. Unlike previous accounts, our proposed model of representation, the Multiple Representation Model, is based on an expanded, democratic understanding of the principle of state participation: it is specifically designed to palliate the democratic deficits of more common versions of the Principle of State Consent. Second, it endorses a qualified version of the Principle of Civil Society Participation, one that is much more restrictive and more critical of the democratic defects of civil society actors than most of its current supporters. Finally, it reveals how the democratic strengths and deficits of both models are best approached as mirroring one another and need to be combined in a complex account of representation.
- 5 February 2018
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 724-746
Sources and the Legitimate Authority of International Law
This chapter considers that political philosophers in recent years are paying growing attention to the legitimacy of international law and international institutions and are asking who has the right to rule and adequate standing to create international laws, and how. It attempts to contribute to this debate in normative political philosophy through the more specific lens of democratic legitimacy. After presenting certain conceptual clarifications, the chapter identifies three basic principles of democratic legitimacy: the principle of ultimate popular control, the principle of democratic equality, and the principle of deliberative contestability, which can be instantiated in six more concrete requirements. The chapter continues by exploring the limitations of two influential views on the democratic legitimacy of international law. Finally, the chapter concludes by expressing some scepticism about the degree to which the current system of sources of international law is democratically legitimate.
- 5 February 2018
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
- p. 724-746
Sources and the Legitimate Authority of International Law
This chapter considers that political philosophers in recent years are paying growing attention to the legitimacy of international law and international institutions and are asking who has the right to rule and adequate standing to create international laws, and how. It attempts to contribute to this debate in normative political philosophy through the more specific lens of democratic legitimacy. After presenting certain conceptual clarifications, the chapter identifies three basic principles of democratic legitimacy: the principle of ultimate popular control, the principle of democratic equality, and the principle of deliberative contestability, which can be instantiated in six more concrete requirements. The chapter continues by exploring the limitations of two influential views on the democratic legitimacy of international law. Finally, the chapter concludes by expressing some scepticism about the degree to which the current system of sources of international law is democratically legitimate.
- 3 November 2017
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Analyse & Kritik
- Vol. 40 (2) , 337-358
The Birth of the CrowdLaw Movement: Tech-Based Citizen Participation, Legitimacy and the Quality of Lawmaking
One of the most urgent debates of our time is about the exact role that new technologies can and should play in our societies and particularly in our public decision-making processes. This paper is a first attempt to introduce the idea of CrowdLaw, defined as online public participation leveraging new technologies to tap into diverse sources of information, judgments and expertise at each stage of the law and policymaking cycle to improve the quality as well as the legitimacy of the resulting laws and policies. First, we explain why CrowdLaw differs from many previous forms of political participation. Second,we reproduce and explain the CrowdLaw Manifesto that the rising CrowdLaw community has elaborated to foster such approaches around the world. Lastly, we introduce some preliminary considerations on the notions of justice, legitimacy and quality of lawmaking and public decision-making, which are central to the idea of CrowdLaw.
- 3 November 2017
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Analyse & Kritik
- Vol. 40 (2) , 337-358
The Birth of the CrowdLaw Movement: Tech-Based Citizen Participation, Legitimacy and the Quality of Lawmaking
One of the most urgent debates of our time is about the exact role that new technologies can and should play in our societies and particularly in our public decision-making processes. This paper is a first attempt to introduce the idea of CrowdLaw, defined as online public participation leveraging new technologies to tap into diverse sources of information, judgments and expertise at each stage of the law and policymaking cycle to improve the quality as well as the legitimacy of the resulting laws and policies. First, we explain why CrowdLaw differs from many previous forms of political participation. Second,we reproduce and explain the CrowdLaw Manifesto that the rising CrowdLaw community has elaborated to foster such approaches around the world. Lastly, we introduce some preliminary considerations on the notions of justice, legitimacy and quality of lawmaking and public decision-making, which are central to the idea of CrowdLaw.