Ngandu Balekelayi
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Ngandu Balekelayi has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Solomon Tesfamariam
University of Waterloo
4 shared publications Solomon Tesfamariam
Professor, School of Engineering, Univ. of British Columbia, 1137 Alumni Ave., Kelowna, BC, Canada V1V 1V7
2 shared publicationsEnock Tshimanga Nzokona
1 shared publication- Haile Woldesellasse
School of Engineering, The University of British Columbia, Okanagan Campus, 3333 University Way, Kelowna, BC V1V 1V7, Canada
1 shared publication Kahsay N. Zeraebruk
Dean, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Mai Nefhi College of Engineering and Technology, Asmara, Eritrea
1 shared publicationMedhanie Teklemariam
Manager, Dept. of Public Works Development, Central Region Administration, Asmara Heritage Project, P.O.Box 259, Asmara, Eritrea
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Deterioration-Informed, Time-Dependent Resilience of Water Distribution Systems: Integrating Bayesian Failure Modeling, Reliability, and Hydraulic Supply Pathways
Water Distribution Systems resilience indicators often describe network topology at a fixed condition or measure hydraulic surplus without explicitly accounting for component aging. Resilience informed management of these systems requires metrics that capture how pipe deterioration affects water supply over time. This study develops the Weighted Independent Pathways metric, WIPW(τ), a time-dependent resilience metric linking pipe deterioration, reliability, hydraulic performance, and network redundancy. The framework combines a geoadditive Bayesian deterioration model developed from 37,484 georeferenced observed watermain failures recorded between 1956 and 2025 across a real-world network, material specific age dependent reliability functions, 24-hour pressure-driven hydraulic simulations and weighted independent pathways. WAIC, DIC, and spatially blocked cross-validation were used to select the best performing deterioration model between Weibull, log-linear non-homogeneous Poisson process (NHPP), and Cox-type models. Closed-form NHPP survival functions propagate pipe age and failure uncertainty to the system level, while pathway weights are determined using the CRITIC method and assessed through sensitivity analysis. The framework is demonstrated on the Anytown, C-Town, and Richmond benchmark networks and compared with the Todini resilience index and a time-dependent reliability index (TRI). Results show that WIPW(τ) captures aging-related losses in supply redundancy not reflected by energy-based indicators. Gradient-guided renewal recovers approximately half of the attainable resilience gain at 17–25% of the full renewal cost, supporting resilience based infrastructure renewal prioritization.
- 18 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessDeterioration-Informed, Time-Dependent Resilience of Water Distribution Systems: Integrating Bayesian Failure Modeling, Reliability, and Hydraulic Supply Pathways
Water Distribution Systems resilience indicators often describe network topology at a fixed condition or measure hydraulic surplus without explicitly accounting for component aging. Resilience informed management of these systems requires metrics that capture how pipe deterioration affects water supply over time. This study develops the Weighted Independent Pathways metric, WIPW(τ), a time-dependent resilience metric linking pipe deterioration, reliability, hydraulic performance, and network redundancy. The framework combines a geoadditive Bayesian deterioration model developed from 37,484 georeferenced observed watermain failures recorded between 1956 and 2025 across a real-world network, material specific age dependent reliability functions, 24-hour pressure-driven hydraulic simulations and weighted independent pathways. WAIC, DIC, and spatially blocked cross-validation were used to select the best performing deterioration model between Weibull, log-linear non-homogeneous Poisson process (NHPP), and Cox-type models. Closed-form NHPP survival functions propagate pipe age and failure uncertainty to the system level, while pathway weights are determined using the CRITIC method and assessed through sensitivity analysis. The framework is demonstrated on the Anytown, C-Town, and Richmond benchmark networks and compared with the Todini resilience index and a time-dependent reliability index (TRI). Results show that WIPW(τ) captures aging-related losses in supply redundancy not reflected by energy-based indicators. Gradient-guided renewal recovers approximately half of the attainable resilience gain at 17–25% of the full renewal cost, supporting resilience based infrastructure renewal prioritization.
- Open Access
- 3 December 2022
- Published by IWA Publishing in Journal of Hydroinformatics
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1-19
Bayesian geoadditive water pipe failure forecasting model by optimizingthe updating period
Municipal water managers rely on pipe deterioration models to plan maintenance, repair, and replacement. Although efforts have been made to increase their accuracy, these models are subject to uncertainties in the predictions. In this paper, an optimization procedure of the Bayesian updating period of the parameters of an existing deterioration model is proposed to sequentially reduce the uncertainty in the prediction of the water pipe breakage rate variable. This latter is modeled using a structured geoadditive regression technique where covariates are allowed to have linear (e.g., categorical) and nonlinear (e.g., continuous) relationships with the response variable. Unknown and unobserved covariates are included in the model through a geospatial component that captures spatial auto-correlations and local heterogeneities. The optimization procedure searches through the time series data to identify the optimal updating period horizon that corresponds to the minimum error between the predicted coefficient of determination between predictions and observations using the unupdated and updated models. The process is repeated until the entire time series data is covered. The application of this approach to failure data of large Canadian urban water systems shows a significant reduction in the uncertainty of the parameters and increases the accuracy in the prediction of the output response variable.
- 3 December 2022
- Published by IWA Publishing in Journal of Hydroinformatics
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1-19
Open AccessBayesian geoadditive water pipe failure forecasting model by optimizingthe updating period
Municipal water managers rely on pipe deterioration models to plan maintenance, repair, and replacement. Although efforts have been made to increase their accuracy, these models are subject to uncertainties in the predictions. In this paper, an optimization procedure of the Bayesian updating period of the parameters of an existing deterioration model is proposed to sequentially reduce the uncertainty in the prediction of the water pipe breakage rate variable. This latter is modeled using a structured geoadditive regression technique where covariates are allowed to have linear (e.g., categorical) and nonlinear (e.g., continuous) relationships with the response variable. Unknown and unobserved covariates are included in the model through a geospatial component that captures spatial auto-correlations and local heterogeneities. The optimization procedure searches through the time series data to identify the optimal updating period horizon that corresponds to the minimum error between the predicted coefficient of determination between predictions and observations using the unupdated and updated models. The process is repeated until the entire time series data is covered. The application of this approach to failure data of large Canadian urban water systems shows a significant reduction in the uncertainty of the parameters and increases the accuracy in the prediction of the output response variable.
- 7 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Water Resources Management
- Vol. 36 (15) , 6169-6185
Comparison of the Performance of a Surrogate Based Gaussian Process, NSGA2 and PSO Multi-objective Optimization of the Operation and Fuzzy Structural Reliability of Water Distribution System: Case Study for the City of Asmara, Eritrea
- 7 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Water Resources Management
- Vol. 36 (15) , 6169-6185
Comparison of the Performance of a Surrogate Based Gaussian Process, NSGA2 and PSO Multi-objective Optimization of the Operation and Fuzzy Structural Reliability of Water Distribution System: Case Study for the City of Asmara, Eritrea
- 1 November 2021
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Pipeline Systems Engineering and Practice
- Vol. 12 (4) , 04021037
Optimization of Water Distribution System Operation with Multiple Tanks and Pumps: Application for Asmara, Eritrea’s Water Supply System
Pump energy consumption is the major operational cost of water distribution systems (WDS). Defining better pump operation policies can reduce the cost and the enhance service provided. The nonlinear hydraulic behavior of WDS makes the pump scheduling problem complex, especially in large WDS in which several tanks and pumping stations coexist. The nonlinear hydraulic behavior of WDS is captured using numerical simulation. However, the required energy calculations were computed from the flow rate and head increase after the pumping stations. There are many optimization algorithms for the reduction of the operational cost. The majority of these algorithms are applied to hypothetical case studies with reduced feasible solution spaces. When the search space becomes large and many alternatives (pumps combinations) are possible, most of the proposed algorithms fail. Thus, the application of these algorithms in real case studies is very limited, and water utility managers still rely on human expertise to schedule pump operation rather than on automatic scheduling. This paper proposes the use of a genetic algorithm for large WDS with a many tanks and pumps. Offline hydraulic simulations allow the definition of water level bounds in the tanks. The combination of the pumps is determined a priori and the optimization algorithm is run in a reduced search space. These preparations allow the genetic algorithm to identify quickly the optimal policy and reduce the cost of energy consumption. The proposed framework was applied to the WDS of the city of Asmara, Eritrea, with 12 tanks and 9 pumping stations. The results showed that the tanks controlled by pumps worked perfectly and the water level was kept within the defined ranges. However, the constraints were not fulfilled for uncontrolled tanks. This application showed the limitations of methodologies proposed in the literature, and it is suggested that further techniques be found to schedule the pump working policies of large WDS while reducing the violations of constraints.
- 1 November 2021
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Pipeline Systems Engineering and Practice
- Vol. 12 (4) , 04021037
Optimization of Water Distribution System Operation with Multiple Tanks and Pumps: Application for Asmara, Eritrea’s Water Supply System
Pump energy consumption is the major operational cost of water distribution systems (WDS). Defining better pump operation policies can reduce the cost and the enhance service provided. The nonlinear hydraulic behavior of WDS makes the pump scheduling problem complex, especially in large WDS in which several tanks and pumping stations coexist. The nonlinear hydraulic behavior of WDS is captured using numerical simulation. However, the required energy calculations were computed from the flow rate and head increase after the pumping stations. There are many optimization algorithms for the reduction of the operational cost. The majority of these algorithms are applied to hypothetical case studies with reduced feasible solution spaces. When the search space becomes large and many alternatives (pumps combinations) are possible, most of the proposed algorithms fail. Thus, the application of these algorithms in real case studies is very limited, and water utility managers still rely on human expertise to schedule pump operation rather than on automatic scheduling. This paper proposes the use of a genetic algorithm for large WDS with a many tanks and pumps. Offline hydraulic simulations allow the definition of water level bounds in the tanks. The combination of the pumps is determined a priori and the optimization algorithm is run in a reduced search space. These preparations allow the genetic algorithm to identify quickly the optimal policy and reduce the cost of energy consumption. The proposed framework was applied to the WDS of the city of Asmara, Eritrea, with 12 tanks and 9 pumping stations. The results showed that the tanks controlled by pumps worked perfectly and the water level was kept within the defined ranges. However, the constraints were not fulfilled for uncontrolled tanks. This application showed the limitations of methodologies proposed in the literature, and it is suggested that further techniques be found to schedule the pump working policies of large WDS while reducing the violations of constraints.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2020
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 12 (20) , 8733
Geoadditive Quantile Regression Model for Sewer Pipes Deterioration Using Boosting Optimization Algorithm
Proactive management of wastewater pipes requires the development of deterioration models that support maintenance and inspection prioritization. The complexity and the lack of understanding of the deterioration process make this task difficult. A semiparametric Bayesian geoadditive quantile regression approach is applied to estimate the deterioration of wastewater pipe from a set of covariates that are allowed to affect linearly and nonlinearly the response variable. Categorical covariates only affect linearly the response variable. In addition, geospatial information embedding the unknown and unobserved influential covariates is introduced as a surrogate covariate that capture global autocorrelations and local heterogeneities. Boosting optimization algorithm is formulated for variable selection and parameter estimation in the model. Three geoadditive quantile regression models (5%, 50% and 95%) are developed to evaluate the band of uncertainty in the prediction of the pipes scores. The proposed model is applied to the wastewater system of the city of Calgary. The results show that an optimal selection of covariates coupled with appropriate representation of the dependence between the covariates and the response increases the accuracy in the estimation of the uncertainty band of the response variable. The proposed modeling approach is useful for the prioritization of inspections and provides knowledge for future installations. In addition, decision makers will be informed of the probability of occurrence of extreme deterioration events when the identified causal factors, in the 5% and 95% quantiles, are observed on the field.
- 21 October 2020
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 12 (20) , 8733
Open AccessGeoadditive Quantile Regression Model for Sewer Pipes Deterioration Using Boosting Optimization Algorithm
Proactive management of wastewater pipes requires the development of deterioration models that support maintenance and inspection prioritization. The complexity and the lack of understanding of the deterioration process make this task difficult. A semiparametric Bayesian geoadditive quantile regression approach is applied to estimate the deterioration of wastewater pipe from a set of covariates that are allowed to affect linearly and nonlinearly the response variable. Categorical covariates only affect linearly the response variable. In addition, geospatial information embedding the unknown and unobserved influential covariates is introduced as a surrogate covariate that capture global autocorrelations and local heterogeneities. Boosting optimization algorithm is formulated for variable selection and parameter estimation in the model. Three geoadditive quantile regression models (5%, 50% and 95%) are developed to evaluate the band of uncertainty in the prediction of the pipes scores. The proposed model is applied to the wastewater system of the city of Calgary. The results show that an optimal selection of covariates coupled with appropriate representation of the dependence between the covariates and the response increases the accuracy in the estimation of the uncertainty band of the response variable. The proposed modeling approach is useful for the prioritization of inspections and provides knowledge for future installations. In addition, decision makers will be informed of the probability of occurrence of extreme deterioration events when the identified causal factors, in the 5% and 95% quantiles, are observed on the field.
- 1 September 2019
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Infrastructure Systems
- Vol. 25 (3)
Statistical Inference of Sewer Pipe Deterioration Using Bayesian Geoadditive Regression Model
Several deterioration models have been developed for prediction of the actual and future condition states of individual sewer pipes. However, most tools that have been developed assume a linear dependency between the predictor and the structural condition response. Moreover, unobserved variables are not included in the models. Physical processes, such as the deterioration of pipes, are complex, and a nonlinear dependency between the covariates and the condition of the pipes is more realistic. This study applied a Bayesian geoadditive regression model to predict sewer pipe deterioration scores from a set of predictors categorized as physical, maintenance, and environmental data. The first and second groups of covariates were allowed to affect the response variables linearly and nonlinearly. However, the third group of data was represented by a surrogate variable to account for unobserved covariates and their interactions. Data uncertainty was captured by the Bayesian representation of the P-splines smooth functions. Additionally, the effects of unobserved covariates are analyzed at two levels including the structured level that globally considers a possible dependency between the deterioration pattern of pipes in the neighborhood and the unstructured level that account for local heterogeneities. The model formulation is general and is applicable to both inspected and uninspected pipes. The tool developed is an important decision support tool for urban water utility managers in their prioritization of inspection, maintenance, and replacement.
- 1 September 2019
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Infrastructure Systems
- Vol. 25 (3)
Statistical Inference of Sewer Pipe Deterioration Using Bayesian Geoadditive Regression Model
Several deterioration models have been developed for prediction of the actual and future condition states of individual sewer pipes. However, most tools that have been developed assume a linear dependency between the predictor and the structural condition response. Moreover, unobserved variables are not included in the models. Physical processes, such as the deterioration of pipes, are complex, and a nonlinear dependency between the covariates and the condition of the pipes is more realistic. This study applied a Bayesian geoadditive regression model to predict sewer pipe deterioration scores from a set of predictors categorized as physical, maintenance, and environmental data. The first and second groups of covariates were allowed to affect the response variables linearly and nonlinearly. However, the third group of data was represented by a surrogate variable to account for unobserved covariates and their interactions. Data uncertainty was captured by the Bayesian representation of the P-splines smooth functions. Additionally, the effects of unobserved covariates are analyzed at two levels including the structured level that globally considers a possible dependency between the deterioration pattern of pipes in the neighborhood and the unstructured level that account for local heterogeneities. The model formulation is general and is applicable to both inspected and uninspected pipes. The tool developed is an important decision support tool for urban water utility managers in their prioritization of inspection, maintenance, and replacement.
- 6 June 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Sustainable and Resilient Infrastructure
- Vol. 2 (4) , 153-168
Optimization techniques used in design and operations of water distribution networks: a review and comparative study
Optimal design and operations of water distribution networks (WDNs) are of importance to meet the customer need at a minimal cost. Three main optimization procedures are reported in the literature: deterministic, non-gradient, and real-time optimization approaches. The criteria used in the choices of the optimization technique are linearity or nonlinearity of the constraints and objective function, structure of the problem (stage-wise or not), computation time, quality of the solution (local, global), size of the network, and type of the WDN components. The availability of online data and advances in information communication and technology play a key role toward (near) real-time decision-making in WDNs operations. In this paper, a review of these three approaches (deterministic, non-gradient and real time) and some illustrative applications are presented. Population-based algorithms solutions are compared and the results show better performance of the hybrid discrete dynamically dimensioned search algorithm for a low number of iterations.
- 6 June 2017
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Sustainable and Resilient Infrastructure
- Vol. 2 (4) , 153-168
Optimization techniques used in design and operations of water distribution networks: a review and comparative study
Optimal design and operations of water distribution networks (WDNs) are of importance to meet the customer need at a minimal cost. Three main optimization procedures are reported in the literature: deterministic, non-gradient, and real-time optimization approaches. The criteria used in the choices of the optimization technique are linearity or nonlinearity of the constraints and objective function, structure of the problem (stage-wise or not), computation time, quality of the solution (local, global), size of the network, and type of the WDN components. The availability of online data and advances in information communication and technology play a key role toward (near) real-time decision-making in WDNs operations. In this paper, a review of these three approaches (deterministic, non-gradient and real time) and some illustrative applications are presented. Population-based algorithms solutions are compared and the results show better performance of the hybrid discrete dynamically dimensioned search algorithm for a low number of iterations.