Jessica L. Rohmann
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jessica L. Rohmann has a total of 341 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Tobias Kurth
Institute of Public Health, Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
19 shared publications - Marco Piccininni
Institute of Public Health, Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
18 shared publications - Tracey Lynn Weissgerber
QUEST Center for Responsible Research, Berlin Institute of Health at Charité Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
8 shared publications - Bob Siegerink
Department of Clinical Epidemiology, Leiden University Medical Center, 2300 RC Leiden, The Netherlands
7 shared publications Marco Piccininni
Institute of Public Health, Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
6 shared publications- Toivo Glatz
Institute of Public Health, Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Ten recommendations for the use of generative artificial intelligence into epidemiology teaching: Results from an expert workshop
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is rapidly reshaping higher education and research. For epidemiology teaching, this creates a dual challenge: students must learn how to use GenAI critically and effectively, while continuing to develop their reasoning, quantitative, and critical appraisal skills that underpin epidemiological competence. Without thoughtful integration, GenAI may contribute to deskilling among instructors and “never-skilling” among students, while raising important questions around transparency, data protection, ownership, human oversight, and accountability. Building on two years of activities within the joint working group “Teaching in Epidemiology” of three German scientific societies, a three-day expert co-creation workshop was convened in March 2026. Epidemiologists, students, and GenAI experts developed 10 evidence-informed recommendations for epidemiology instructors, which were subsequently refined using feedback from additional students and instructors. Our recommendations for instructors are organized into three domains: governance and good practice, competencies and assessment, and feedback and evidence. They address the need for clear institutional policies, transparent disclosure and human verification of GenAI use, continuing educator development, integration of GenAI literacy into epidemiology curricula, preservation of core epidemiological and scientific competencies, and appropriate assessment strategies. They also emphasize regular student feedback and the need to generate and share evidence on this emerging topic. The recommendations provide practical guidance, including concrete examples and experiences from fellow instructors, to support responsible GenAI integration in epidemiology teaching. While developed in a European context, many of the underlying principles are broadly applicable and can serve as a useful starting point for instructors worldwide.
- 16 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessTen recommendations for the use of generative artificial intelligence into epidemiology teaching: Results from an expert workshop
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is rapidly reshaping higher education and research. For epidemiology teaching, this creates a dual challenge: students must learn how to use GenAI critically and effectively, while continuing to develop their reasoning, quantitative, and critical appraisal skills that underpin epidemiological competence. Without thoughtful integration, GenAI may contribute to deskilling among instructors and “never-skilling” among students, while raising important questions around transparency, data protection, ownership, human oversight, and accountability. Building on two years of activities within the joint working group “Teaching in Epidemiology” of three German scientific societies, a three-day expert co-creation workshop was convened in March 2026. Epidemiologists, students, and GenAI experts developed 10 evidence-informed recommendations for epidemiology instructors, which were subsequently refined using feedback from additional students and instructors. Our recommendations for instructors are organized into three domains: governance and good practice, competencies and assessment, and feedback and evidence. They address the need for clear institutional policies, transparent disclosure and human verification of GenAI use, continuing educator development, integration of GenAI literacy into epidemiology curricula, preservation of core epidemiological and scientific competencies, and appropriate assessment strategies. They also emphasize regular student feedback and the need to generate and share evidence on this emerging topic. The recommendations provide practical guidance, including concrete examples and experiences from fellow instructors, to support responsible GenAI integration in epidemiology teaching. While developed in a European context, many of the underlying principles are broadly applicable and can serve as a useful starting point for instructors worldwide.
- Open Access
- 29 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Integrity and Peer Review
- Vol. 11 (1) , 35
Effectiveness of the researcher-led “Peerspectives” peer review training course on review quality, knowledge, and skills among doctoral students in the biomedical sciences: a pre-post study
Background: Peer review remains a cornerstone of scientific knowledge dissemination, yet comprehensive, practically relevant training is limited. This inspired us to develop Peerspectives , a peer review training course for doctoral students in the biomedical sciences in Berlin, Germany. We aimed to assess the effectiveness of the Peerspectives course on editor-judged quality of peer review reports. Methods: Doctoral students in health research fields who enrolled in the Peerspectives course between October 2020 and August 2022 were invited to participate in the study, and 80 consented. The ~18 week-long course provided training on the structure, purpose, and conduct of peer review and editorial processes in biomedical journals. It included 12 h of lectures, homework assignments, and 12 h of hands-on, small-group workshops, during which students reviewed original research manuscripts currently under consideration at The BMJ under the guidance of experienced mentors. The primary outcome was the overall quality of the peer review reports as judged by two independent BMJ editors using the global score of the Review Quality Instrument (RQI) pre- and post-intervention. Additionally, we compared participants’ post-course scores with those of actual BMJ reviewers. We also compared participants’ self-assessed knowledge and skills related to scholarly peer review (1–5 Likert scale) before and after the course. Results: After course completion, the editor-assessed overall quality of the participants’ peer review reports was higher than before the course (median increase of 0.5 points, p < 0.001; mean increase of 0.36 points, p < 0.001). The RQI scores of participants’ post-course reports were not non-inferior to those of actual BMJ reviewers for the same manuscripts. Self-assessed peer review-related knowledge skills increased across all questionnaire items after course completion. Greatest improvements were seen in understanding reviewer expectations (increase in means from 2.9 to 4.5), confidence in reviewing (2.5 to 3.9), and knowing what to look for while reviewing (2.8 to 4.2). Conclusions: Providing doctoral students with comprehensive training resulted in an editorially significant increase in review report quality and improved understanding of the role and expectations of peer reviewers in the scholarly publishing processes and confidence in giving constructive feedback. Pre-registration: https://osf.io/vndcx
- 29 May 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Integrity and Peer Review
- Vol. 11 (1) , 35
Open AccessEffectiveness of the researcher-led “Peerspectives” peer review training course on review quality, knowledge, and skills among doctoral students in the biomedical sciences: a pre-post study
Background: Peer review remains a cornerstone of scientific knowledge dissemination, yet comprehensive, practically relevant training is limited. This inspired us to develop Peerspectives , a peer review training course for doctoral students in the biomedical sciences in Berlin, Germany. We aimed to assess the effectiveness of the Peerspectives course on editor-judged quality of peer review reports. Methods: Doctoral students in health research fields who enrolled in the Peerspectives course between October 2020 and August 2022 were invited to participate in the study, and 80 consented. The ~18 week-long course provided training on the structure, purpose, and conduct of peer review and editorial processes in biomedical journals. It included 12 h of lectures, homework assignments, and 12 h of hands-on, small-group workshops, during which students reviewed original research manuscripts currently under consideration at The BMJ under the guidance of experienced mentors. The primary outcome was the overall quality of the peer review reports as judged by two independent BMJ editors using the global score of the Review Quality Instrument (RQI) pre- and post-intervention. Additionally, we compared participants’ post-course scores with those of actual BMJ reviewers. We also compared participants’ self-assessed knowledge and skills related to scholarly peer review (1–5 Likert scale) before and after the course. Results: After course completion, the editor-assessed overall quality of the participants’ peer review reports was higher than before the course (median increase of 0.5 points, p < 0.001; mean increase of 0.36 points, p < 0.001). The RQI scores of participants’ post-course reports were not non-inferior to those of actual BMJ reviewers for the same manuscripts. Self-assessed peer review-related knowledge skills increased across all questionnaire items after course completion. Greatest improvements were seen in understanding reviewer expectations (increase in means from 2.9 to 4.5), confidence in reviewing (2.5 to 3.9), and knowing what to look for while reviewing (2.8 to 4.2). Conclusions: Providing doctoral students with comprehensive training resulted in an editorially significant increase in review report quality and improved understanding of the role and expectations of peer reviewers in the scholarly publishing processes and confidence in giving constructive feedback. Pre-registration: https://osf.io/vndcx
- Open Access
- 14 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Learned Publishing
- Vol. 39 (1)
Collaborating With Early Career Researchers to Enhance the Future of Scholarly Publication: A Guide for Publishers
The scholarly publishing system is adapting to many changes, including open access and open data mandates, artificial intelligence, and other new technologies. Members of the research and publishing communities are working to establish a more equitable, fair, and rigorous system that serves researchers' evolving needs. Early career researchers (ECRs) are drivers of change, and publishers may wonder why and how they should involve ECRs in shaping the future of scholarly publishing. We held a virtual unconference to explore this issue with publishers and ECRs who were working to improve publishing. Some participants sought to improve peer reviewer or editor performance, whereas others sought to improve the publishing system itself through iterative or transformative change. Strategies for collaborating with ECRs to shape the future of scholarly publishing included peer review programmes, editorial programmes, ECR‐led journals, ECR boards and committee representatives, and other ECR‐initiated activities. ECRs particularly wanted to see three things improved: (1) Sharing research outputs other than publications, (2) addressing technological limitations to create systems that meet the research community's needs and facilitate knowledge advancement, and (3) fostering diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility. We offer tips for publishers on how to collaborate with ECRs to enhance scholarly publishing, appeal to and learn from younger researchers, and better meet researchers' needs.
- 14 November 2025
- Published by Wiley in Learned Publishing
- Vol. 39 (1)
Open AccessCollaborating With Early Career Researchers to Enhance the Future of Scholarly Publication: A Guide for Publishers
The scholarly publishing system is adapting to many changes, including open access and open data mandates, artificial intelligence, and other new technologies. Members of the research and publishing communities are working to establish a more equitable, fair, and rigorous system that serves researchers' evolving needs. Early career researchers (ECRs) are drivers of change, and publishers may wonder why and how they should involve ECRs in shaping the future of scholarly publishing. We held a virtual unconference to explore this issue with publishers and ECRs who were working to improve publishing. Some participants sought to improve peer reviewer or editor performance, whereas others sought to improve the publishing system itself through iterative or transformative change. Strategies for collaborating with ECRs to shape the future of scholarly publishing included peer review programmes, editorial programmes, ECR‐led journals, ECR boards and committee representatives, and other ECR‐initiated activities. ECRs particularly wanted to see three things improved: (1) Sharing research outputs other than publications, (2) addressing technological limitations to create systems that meet the research community's needs and facilitate knowledge advancement, and (3) fostering diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility. We offer tips for publishers on how to collaborate with ECRs to enhance scholarly publishing, appeal to and learn from younger researchers, and better meet researchers' needs.
- 11 November 2025
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Neurology
- Vol. 105 (9) , e214225
Effect of Mobile Stroke Unit Dispatch on Process Parameters and Functional Outcomes in Patients With Acute Stroke
Prehospital stroke management on mobile stroke units (MSUs) shortens time to IV thrombolysis (IVT) and improves functional outcomes. Because IVT effects are time-dependent, optimizing workflows and dispatch-related processes may enhance MSU benefits. The B_PROUD-2.0 study aimed to determine the effect of additional MSU dispatch on functional outcomes in acute stroke patients under optimized MSU organization and service delivery. In the nonrandomized, controlled B_PROUD-2.0 study (May 2019-April 2021) conducted in Berlin, Germany, MSUs were simultaneously dispatched with conventional care ambulances for suspected stroke emergency calls, whenever available. We compared outcomes and process parameters between dispatch groups (additional MSU dispatch vs conventional care only) among patients with cerebral ischemia with disabling neurologic symptoms and no contraindications to reperfusion treatments. We used data from the Berlin dispatch center and records from the B_SPATIAL registry, consisting of 15 Berlin hospitals with stroke units. We performed pooled analyses with the B_PROUD-1.0 primary population (February 2017-April 2021) and with an extended cohort that also included patients with reperfusion treatment contraindications. The primary and co-primary outcomes were 3-month modified Rankin Scale scores (0: no deficits to 6: death) and 3-tiered disability scale scores. Effect estimates for these outcomes were obtained from ordinal logistic regressions, adjusting for a priori selected covariates after multiple imputation for missing values. Coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic and limited funding hindered full implementation of procedural improvements. A total of 1,050 patients (mean age: 74 years, 46.7% female) were included in B_PROUD-2.0 (vs 1,500 planned). We found no statistically significant effect of MSU dispatch on primary (common odds ratio [cOR] 0.90, 95% CI 0.72-1.14) or co-primary (cOR 0.86, 95% CI 0.63-1.17) outcomes in B_PROUD-2.0, and higher odds of IVT ≤1 hour of dispatch in the MSU group (OR 10.15, 95% CI 7.10-14.51). In pooled B_PROUD-1.0+2.0 primary population analyses (N = 2,666, mean age: 73 years, 46.8% female), we found a beneficial effect on primary (cOR 0.80, 95% CI 0.67-0.96) and co-primary (cOR 0.79, 95% CI 0.64-0.97) outcomes. The average effect on all stroke/TIA patients in the extended cohort (N = 4,336, mean age 75 years, 47.6% female) was also favorable (primary cOR 0.85, 95% CI 0.75-0.95; co-primary cOR 0.86, 95% CI 0.75-0.99). While we did not observe statistically significant differences in functional outcomes in the underpowered B_PROUD-2.0 study, we found beneficial effects considering both B_PROUD study periods, also when including all stroke/TIA patients. ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT03931616. Registered: April 26, 2019. First patient enrolled: May 9, 2019. The B_PROUD-2.0 study provides Class III evidence that the addition of MSUs to conventional care ambulances did not improve functional outcomes at 3 months compared with conventional care ambulances alone in patients with acute ischemic stroke.
- 11 November 2025
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Neurology
- Vol. 105 (9) , e214225
Effect of Mobile Stroke Unit Dispatch on Process Parameters and Functional Outcomes in Patients With Acute Stroke
Prehospital stroke management on mobile stroke units (MSUs) shortens time to IV thrombolysis (IVT) and improves functional outcomes. Because IVT effects are time-dependent, optimizing workflows and dispatch-related processes may enhance MSU benefits. The B_PROUD-2.0 study aimed to determine the effect of additional MSU dispatch on functional outcomes in acute stroke patients under optimized MSU organization and service delivery. In the nonrandomized, controlled B_PROUD-2.0 study (May 2019-April 2021) conducted in Berlin, Germany, MSUs were simultaneously dispatched with conventional care ambulances for suspected stroke emergency calls, whenever available. We compared outcomes and process parameters between dispatch groups (additional MSU dispatch vs conventional care only) among patients with cerebral ischemia with disabling neurologic symptoms and no contraindications to reperfusion treatments. We used data from the Berlin dispatch center and records from the B_SPATIAL registry, consisting of 15 Berlin hospitals with stroke units. We performed pooled analyses with the B_PROUD-1.0 primary population (February 2017-April 2021) and with an extended cohort that also included patients with reperfusion treatment contraindications. The primary and co-primary outcomes were 3-month modified Rankin Scale scores (0: no deficits to 6: death) and 3-tiered disability scale scores. Effect estimates for these outcomes were obtained from ordinal logistic regressions, adjusting for a priori selected covariates after multiple imputation for missing values. Coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic and limited funding hindered full implementation of procedural improvements. A total of 1,050 patients (mean age: 74 years, 46.7% female) were included in B_PROUD-2.0 (vs 1,500 planned). We found no statistically significant effect of MSU dispatch on primary (common odds ratio [cOR] 0.90, 95% CI 0.72-1.14) or co-primary (cOR 0.86, 95% CI 0.63-1.17) outcomes in B_PROUD-2.0, and higher odds of IVT ≤1 hour of dispatch in the MSU group (OR 10.15, 95% CI 7.10-14.51). In pooled B_PROUD-1.0+2.0 primary population analyses (N = 2,666, mean age: 73 years, 46.8% female), we found a beneficial effect on primary (cOR 0.80, 95% CI 0.67-0.96) and co-primary (cOR 0.79, 95% CI 0.64-0.97) outcomes. The average effect on all stroke/TIA patients in the extended cohort (N = 4,336, mean age 75 years, 47.6% female) was also favorable (primary cOR 0.85, 95% CI 0.75-0.95; co-primary cOR 0.86, 95% CI 0.75-0.99). While we did not observe statistically significant differences in functional outcomes in the underpowered B_PROUD-2.0 study, we found beneficial effects considering both B_PROUD study periods, also when including all stroke/TIA patients. ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT03931616. Registered: April 26, 2019. First patient enrolled: May 9, 2019. The B_PROUD-2.0 study provides Class III evidence that the addition of MSUs to conventional care ambulances did not improve functional outcomes at 3 months compared with conventional care ambulances alone in patients with acute ischemic stroke.
- Open Access
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Neurology
- Vol. 104 (4) , e210169
Use of Stacked Proportional Bar Graphs (“Grotta Bars”) in Observational Neurology Research
Stacked proportional bar graphs (nicknamed "Grotta bars") are commonly used to visualize functional outcome scales in stroke research and are also used in other domains of neurology research. While lending themselves to a straightforward causal interpretation in ideal randomized controlled trials, in observational studies, Grotta bars cannot be generally interpreted causally if they show unadjusted, confounded comparisons. In a sample of recent observational neurology studies with confounding-adjusted effect estimates, we aimed to determine the frequency with which Grotta bars were used to visualize functional outcomes and how often unadjusted Grotta bars were presented without an accompanying adjusted version. We also assessed the methods used to generate adjusted Grotta bars. We identified the 15 top-ranked clinical neurology journals, according to journal impact factor, publishing full-length original research in English. Using PubMed, we retrieved all records published in these journals between 2020 and 2021 after applying a filter for observational studies. We included and systematically examined all observational studies aiming to identify a cause-and-effect relationship with an ordinal functional outcome and confounding-adjusted effect estimate. We determined whether at least 1 comparison using Grotta bars was present, whether the visualized comparisons were adjusted, and which adjustment strategies were applied to generate these graphs. A total of 250 studies met all inclusion criteria. Of these, 93 (37.2%) used Grotta bars to depict functional outcome scale distributions, with 76 (81.7%) presenting only Grotta bars without model-based adjustment. These bars were most commonly presented in studies with stroke patient populations; 87 of 192 studies (45.3%) presented Grotta bars. Among the 17 studies that presented Grotta bars adjusted using a model, the adjustment strategies included propensity score matching (n = 10; 58.8%), regression (n = 6; 35.3%), and inverse probability weighting (n = 1; 5.9%). Studies that presented adjusted associations for functional outcomes commonly showed only unadjusted Grotta bars, which alone have little value for causal questions. In observational research, Grotta bars are most informative if an adjusted version, aligning with adjusted effect estimates, is presented directly alongside the unadjusted version. Based on our findings, we offer recommendations to help authors generate more informative Grotta bars and to facilitate correct interpretation for readers.
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Neurology
- Vol. 104 (4) , e210169
Open AccessUse of Stacked Proportional Bar Graphs (“Grotta Bars”) in Observational Neurology Research
Stacked proportional bar graphs (nicknamed "Grotta bars") are commonly used to visualize functional outcome scales in stroke research and are also used in other domains of neurology research. While lending themselves to a straightforward causal interpretation in ideal randomized controlled trials, in observational studies, Grotta bars cannot be generally interpreted causally if they show unadjusted, confounded comparisons. In a sample of recent observational neurology studies with confounding-adjusted effect estimates, we aimed to determine the frequency with which Grotta bars were used to visualize functional outcomes and how often unadjusted Grotta bars were presented without an accompanying adjusted version. We also assessed the methods used to generate adjusted Grotta bars. We identified the 15 top-ranked clinical neurology journals, according to journal impact factor, publishing full-length original research in English. Using PubMed, we retrieved all records published in these journals between 2020 and 2021 after applying a filter for observational studies. We included and systematically examined all observational studies aiming to identify a cause-and-effect relationship with an ordinal functional outcome and confounding-adjusted effect estimate. We determined whether at least 1 comparison using Grotta bars was present, whether the visualized comparisons were adjusted, and which adjustment strategies were applied to generate these graphs. A total of 250 studies met all inclusion criteria. Of these, 93 (37.2%) used Grotta bars to depict functional outcome scale distributions, with 76 (81.7%) presenting only Grotta bars without model-based adjustment. These bars were most commonly presented in studies with stroke patient populations; 87 of 192 studies (45.3%) presented Grotta bars. Among the 17 studies that presented Grotta bars adjusted using a model, the adjustment strategies included propensity score matching (n = 10; 58.8%), regression (n = 6; 35.3%), and inverse probability weighting (n = 1; 5.9%). Studies that presented adjusted associations for functional outcomes commonly showed only unadjusted Grotta bars, which alone have little value for causal questions. In observational research, Grotta bars are most informative if an adjusted version, aligning with adjusted effect estimates, is presented directly alongside the unadjusted version. Based on our findings, we offer recommendations to help authors generate more informative Grotta bars and to facilitate correct interpretation for readers.
- Open Access
Engaging doctoral students in peer review: a pre-post study evaluating the effectiveness of the “Peerspectives” course on review quality, knowledge and skills
Objective: To assess the effectiveness of the Peerspectives course on editor-judged quality of peer review Design: Single arm, pre-post interventional study Setting: Peerspectives is a peer review training course developed for doctoral students at the Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Germany Participants: Doctoral students in health research domains who enrolled in the Peerspectives course between October 2020 and August 2022 and consented to participate ( N = 80). Intervention: A semester-long course (approx. 18 weeks) providing training about the structure, purpose, and conduct of peer review and editing processes in biomedical journals. The course consisted of 12 hours of interactive lectures, weekly homework assignments, and 12 hours of hands-on, small-group workshops under guidance of mentors with reviewing and editing experience. Students peer-reviewed real scientific manuscripts under review at a partnering journal, The BMJ . Main outcome measures: The overall quality of the peer review reports as judged by two independent BMJ editors using the global score of the Review Quality Instrument (RQI) pre- and post-intervention. Additionally, participants’ self-assessed knowledge and skills related to scholarly peer review (1-5 Likert scale). Results: After course completion, participants’ RQI scores were higher than before the course (median increase of 0.5 points, pBMJ reviewers for the same manuscripts. Self-assessed peer review-related knowledge skills increased across all questionnaire items after course completion. Largest improvements were seen in understanding what is expected from a reviewer (increase in means from 2.9 to 4.5), confidence in own ability to review (2.5 to 3.9), and knowing what to look for in a manuscript while reviewing (2.8 to 4.2). Conclusions: Providing doctoral students with comprehensive training resulted in an editorially significant increase in review report quality and improved understanding of the role and expectations of peer reviewers in the scholarly publishing processes and confidence in giving constructive feedback. Study pre-registration: https://osf.io/vndcx
Open AccessEngaging doctoral students in peer review: a pre-post study evaluating the effectiveness of the “Peerspectives” course on review quality, knowledge and skills
Objective: To assess the effectiveness of the Peerspectives course on editor-judged quality of peer review Design: Single arm, pre-post interventional study Setting: Peerspectives is a peer review training course developed for doctoral students at the Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Germany Participants: Doctoral students in health research domains who enrolled in the Peerspectives course between October 2020 and August 2022 and consented to participate ( N = 80). Intervention: A semester-long course (approx. 18 weeks) providing training about the structure, purpose, and conduct of peer review and editing processes in biomedical journals. The course consisted of 12 hours of interactive lectures, weekly homework assignments, and 12 hours of hands-on, small-group workshops under guidance of mentors with reviewing and editing experience. Students peer-reviewed real scientific manuscripts under review at a partnering journal, The BMJ . Main outcome measures: The overall quality of the peer review reports as judged by two independent BMJ editors using the global score of the Review Quality Instrument (RQI) pre- and post-intervention. Additionally, participants’ self-assessed knowledge and skills related to scholarly peer review (1-5 Likert scale). Results: After course completion, participants’ RQI scores were higher than before the course (median increase of 0.5 points, pBMJ reviewers for the same manuscripts. Self-assessed peer review-related knowledge skills increased across all questionnaire items after course completion. Largest improvements were seen in understanding what is expected from a reviewer (increase in means from 2.9 to 4.5), confidence in own ability to review (2.5 to 3.9), and knowing what to look for in a manuscript while reviewing (2.8 to 4.2). Conclusions: Providing doctoral students with comprehensive training resulted in an editorially significant increase in review report quality and improved understanding of the role and expectations of peer reviewers in the scholarly publishing processes and confidence in giving constructive feedback. Study pre-registration: https://osf.io/vndcx
- Open Access
- 25 October 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Collaborating with early career researchers to enhance the future of scholarly communication: A guide for publishers
The scholarly publishing system is adapting to many changes including open access and open data mandates, and new technologies, including artificial intelligence. Members of the research and publishing communities are working to establish a more equitable, fair, and rigorous system that serves researchers’ evolving needs. Early career researchers (ECRs) are drivers of change, and publishers may wonder why and how they should involve ECRs in shaping the future of scholarly publishing. We held a virtual unconference to explore this issue with publishers and ECRs who were working to improve publishing. Some participants sought to improve peer reviewer or editor performance, whereas others sought to improve or reform the publishing system itself. Strategies for achieving these goals included peer review programs, editorial programs, ECR-led journals, ECR boards and committee representatives, and other ECR-initiated activities. ECRs particularly wanted to see three things improved: 1) Sharing research outputs other than publications, 2) Addressing technological limitations to create systems that meet the research community’s needs and facilitate knowledge advancement, and 3) Fostering diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility. We offer tips for publishers on how to collaborate with ECRs to enhance scholarly publishing, appeal to and learn from younger researchers, and better meet researchers’ needs.
- 25 October 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessCollaborating with early career researchers to enhance the future of scholarly communication: A guide for publishers
The scholarly publishing system is adapting to many changes including open access and open data mandates, and new technologies, including artificial intelligence. Members of the research and publishing communities are working to establish a more equitable, fair, and rigorous system that serves researchers’ evolving needs. Early career researchers (ECRs) are drivers of change, and publishers may wonder why and how they should involve ECRs in shaping the future of scholarly publishing. We held a virtual unconference to explore this issue with publishers and ECRs who were working to improve publishing. Some participants sought to improve peer reviewer or editor performance, whereas others sought to improve or reform the publishing system itself. Strategies for achieving these goals included peer review programs, editorial programs, ECR-led journals, ECR boards and committee representatives, and other ECR-initiated activities. ECRs particularly wanted to see three things improved: 1) Sharing research outputs other than publications, 2) Addressing technological limitations to create systems that meet the research community’s needs and facilitate knowledge advancement, and 3) Fostering diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility. We offer tips for publishers on how to collaborate with ECRs to enhance scholarly publishing, appeal to and learn from younger researchers, and better meet researchers’ needs.
- Open Access
- 30 August 2024
- Published by Elsevier in The Lancet Regional Health - Europe
- Vol. 45, 101041
Sex and gender bias in chronic coronary syndromes research: analysis of studies used to inform the 2019 European Society of Cardiology guidelines
- 30 August 2024
- Published by Elsevier in The Lancet Regional Health - Europe
- Vol. 45, 101041
Open AccessSex and gender bias in chronic coronary syndromes research: analysis of studies used to inform the 2019 European Society of Cardiology guidelines
- Open Access
- 20 August 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism
- Vol. 45 (2) , 340-351
Rethinking animal attrition in preclinical research: Expressing causal mechanisms of selection bias using directed acyclic graphs
Animal attrition in preclinical experiments can introduce bias in the estimation of causal treatment effects, as the treatment-outcome association in surviving animals may not represent the causal effect of interest. This can compromise the internal validity of the study despite randomization at the outset. Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) are useful tools to transparently visualize assumptions about the causal structure underlying observed data. By illustrating relationships between relevant variables, DAGs enable the detection of even less intuitive biases, and can thereby inform strategies for their mitigation. In this study, we present an illustrative causal model for preclinical stroke research, in which animal attrition induces a specific type of selection bias (i.e., collider stratification bias) due to the interplay of animal welfare, initial disease severity and negative side effects of treatment. Even when the treatment had no causal effect, our simulations revealed substantial bias across different scenarios. We show how researchers can detect and potentially mitigate this bias in the analysis phase, even when only data from surviving animals are available, if knowledge of the underlying causal process that gave rise to the data is available. Collider stratification bias should be a concern in preclinical animal studies with severe side effects and high post-randomization attrition.
- 20 August 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow & Metabolism
- Vol. 45 (2) , 340-351
Open AccessRethinking animal attrition in preclinical research: Expressing causal mechanisms of selection bias using directed acyclic graphs
Animal attrition in preclinical experiments can introduce bias in the estimation of causal treatment effects, as the treatment-outcome association in surviving animals may not represent the causal effect of interest. This can compromise the internal validity of the study despite randomization at the outset. Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) are useful tools to transparently visualize assumptions about the causal structure underlying observed data. By illustrating relationships between relevant variables, DAGs enable the detection of even less intuitive biases, and can thereby inform strategies for their mitigation. In this study, we present an illustrative causal model for preclinical stroke research, in which animal attrition induces a specific type of selection bias (i.e., collider stratification bias) due to the interplay of animal welfare, initial disease severity and negative side effects of treatment. Even when the treatment had no causal effect, our simulations revealed substantial bias across different scenarios. We show how researchers can detect and potentially mitigate this bias in the analysis phase, even when only data from surviving animals are available, if knowledge of the underlying causal process that gave rise to the data is available. Collider stratification bias should be a concern in preclinical animal studies with severe side effects and high post-randomization attrition.
- Open Access
Use of stacked proportional bar graphs (“Grotta bars”) to visualize functional outcome distributions in observational neurology research
Background and Objectives Stacked proportional bar graphs (nicknamed “Grotta bars”) are commonly used to visualize functional outcome scales in stroke research and are also used in other domains of neurological research. In observational studies that present adjusted effect estimates, Grotta bars can mislead readers if they show unadjusted, confounded comparisons. In a sample of recent observational neurology studies with confounding-adjusted effect estimates, we aimed to determine the frequency with which Grotta bars were used to visualize functional outcomes and how often unadjusted Grotta bars were presented without an accompanying adjusted version. We also assessed the methods used to generate adjusted Grotta bars. Methods In this meta-research study, we systematically examined all observational studies published in the top 15 Clinical Neurology journals between 2020-2021 with an ordinal functional outcome and confounding-adjusted effect estimate. We determined whether at least one comparison using Grotta bars was present, whether the visualized comparisons were adjusted, and which adjustment strategies were applied to generate these graphs. Results 250 studies met all inclusion criteria. Of these, 93 (37.2%) used Grotta bars to depict functional outcome scale distributions, with 73 (81.7%) presenting only Grotta bars without model-based adjustment. Amongst the 17 studies that presented Grotta bars adjusted using a model, the adjustment strategies included propensity score matching (n=10; 58.8%), regression (n=6; 35.3%), and inverse probability weighting (n=1; 5.9%). Most studies with Grotta bars (n=87; 87.9%) were stroke studies. Discussion Grotta bars were most often used in stroke research within our sample. Papers that present adjusted associations for functional outcomes commonly showed only unadjusted Grotta bars, which alone may be misleading for causal questions. In observational research, Grotta bars are most informative if an adjusted version, aligning with adjusted effect estimates, is presented directly alongside the unadjusted version. Based on our findings, we offer recommendations to help authors generate informative Grotta bars and facilitate correct interpretation for readers.
Open AccessUse of stacked proportional bar graphs (“Grotta bars”) to visualize functional outcome distributions in observational neurology research
Background and Objectives Stacked proportional bar graphs (nicknamed “Grotta bars”) are commonly used to visualize functional outcome scales in stroke research and are also used in other domains of neurological research. In observational studies that present adjusted effect estimates, Grotta bars can mislead readers if they show unadjusted, confounded comparisons. In a sample of recent observational neurology studies with confounding-adjusted effect estimates, we aimed to determine the frequency with which Grotta bars were used to visualize functional outcomes and how often unadjusted Grotta bars were presented without an accompanying adjusted version. We also assessed the methods used to generate adjusted Grotta bars. Methods In this meta-research study, we systematically examined all observational studies published in the top 15 Clinical Neurology journals between 2020-2021 with an ordinal functional outcome and confounding-adjusted effect estimate. We determined whether at least one comparison using Grotta bars was present, whether the visualized comparisons were adjusted, and which adjustment strategies were applied to generate these graphs. Results 250 studies met all inclusion criteria. Of these, 93 (37.2%) used Grotta bars to depict functional outcome scale distributions, with 73 (81.7%) presenting only Grotta bars without model-based adjustment. Amongst the 17 studies that presented Grotta bars adjusted using a model, the adjustment strategies included propensity score matching (n=10; 58.8%), regression (n=6; 35.3%), and inverse probability weighting (n=1; 5.9%). Most studies with Grotta bars (n=87; 87.9%) were stroke studies. Discussion Grotta bars were most often used in stroke research within our sample. Papers that present adjusted associations for functional outcomes commonly showed only unadjusted Grotta bars, which alone may be misleading for causal questions. In observational research, Grotta bars are most informative if an adjusted version, aligning with adjusted effect estimates, is presented directly alongside the unadjusted version. Based on our findings, we offer recommendations to help authors generate informative Grotta bars and facilitate correct interpretation for readers.