Toby Cubitt
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Toby Cubitt has a total of 60 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- David Pérez-García
Departamento de Análisis Matemático y Matemática Aplicada, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Madrid, Spain
12 shared publications - Johannes Bausch
Google DeepMind, London, UK
10 shared publications - Tamara Kohler
Instituto de Ciencias Matemáticas, Madrid, Spain
7 shared publications - Angelo Lucia
Dipartimento di Matematica, Politecnico di Milano, Milan, Italy
6 shared publications - Ashley Montanaro
Phasecraft Ltd. (United Kingdom)
6 shared publications - Harriet Apel
University College London
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 5 March 2026
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in PRX Quantum
- Vol. 7 (1)
Quantum Phase Estimation Without Controlled Unitaries
In this work we demonstrate the use of adapted classical phase retrieval algorithms to perform control-free quantum phase estimation. We eliminate the costly controlled time evolution and Hadamard test commonly required to access the complex time-series needed to reconstruct the spectrum. This significant reduction of the number of coherent controlled-operations lowers the circuit depth and considerably simplifies the implementation of statistical quantum phase estimation in near-term devices. This seemingly impossible task can be achieved by extending the problem that one wishes to solve to one with a larger set of input signals while exploiting natural constraints on the signal and/or the spectrum. We leverage well-established algorithms that are widely used in the context of classical signal processing, demonstrating two complementary methods to do this, vectorial phase retrieval and two-dimensional phase retrieval. We numerically investigate the feasibility of both approaches for estimating the spectrum of the Fermi-Hubbard model and discuss their resilience to inherent statistical noise.
- 5 March 2026
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in PRX Quantum
- Vol. 7 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessQuantum Phase Estimation Without Controlled Unitaries
In this work we demonstrate the use of adapted classical phase retrieval algorithms to perform control-free quantum phase estimation. We eliminate the costly controlled time evolution and Hadamard test commonly required to access the complex time-series needed to reconstruct the spectrum. This significant reduction of the number of coherent controlled-operations lowers the circuit depth and considerably simplifies the implementation of statistical quantum phase estimation in near-term devices. This seemingly impossible task can be achieved by extending the problem that one wishes to solve to one with a larger set of input signals while exploiting natural constraints on the signal and/or the spectrum. We leverage well-established algorithms that are widely used in the context of classical signal processing, demonstrating two complementary methods to do this, vectorial phase retrieval and two-dimensional phase retrieval. We numerically investigate the feasibility of both approaches for estimating the spectrum of the Fermi-Hubbard model and discuss their resilience to inherent statistical noise.
- Open Access
Encodings of Observable Subalgebras
Simulating complex systems remains an ongoing challenge for classical computers, while being recognised as a task where a quantum computer has a natural advantage. In both digital and analogue quantum simulations the system description is first mapped onto qubits or the physical system of the analogue simulator by an encoding. Previously mathematical definitions and characterisations of encodings have focused on preserving the full physics of the system. In this work, we consider encodings that only preserve a subset of the observables of the system. We motivate that such encodings are best described as maps between formally real Jordan algebras describing the subset of observables. Our characterisation of encodings is general, but notably holds for maps between finite-dimensional and semisimple $C^{*}$-algebras. Fermionic encodings are a pertinent example where a mathematical characterisation was absent. Our work applies to encodings of the the full CAR algebra, but also to encodings of just the even parity sector, corresponding to the physically relevant fermionic operators.
Open AccessEncodings of Observable Subalgebras
Simulating complex systems remains an ongoing challenge for classical computers, while being recognised as a task where a quantum computer has a natural advantage. In both digital and analogue quantum simulations the system description is first mapped onto qubits or the physical system of the analogue simulator by an encoding. Previously mathematical definitions and characterisations of encodings have focused on preserving the full physics of the system. In this work, we consider encodings that only preserve a subset of the observables of the system. We motivate that such encodings are best described as maps between formally real Jordan algebras describing the subset of observables. Our characterisation of encodings is general, but notably holds for maps between finite-dimensional and semisimple $C^{*}$-algebras. Fermionic encodings are a pertinent example where a mathematical characterisation was absent. Our work applies to encodings of the the full CAR algebra, but also to encodings of just the even parity sector, corresponding to the physically relevant fermionic operators.
- Open Access
Chaitin Phase Transition
We construct a family of Hamiltonians whose phase diagram is guaranteed to have a single phase transition, yet the location of this phase transition is uncomputable. The Hamiltonians $H(φ)$ describe qudits on a two-dimensional square lattice with translationally invariant, nearest-neighbour interactions tuned by a continuous parameter $φ\in(0,1]$. For all $φ\in(0,1]$, $H(φ)$ is in one of two phases, one a gapless phase, the other a gapped phase. The phase transition occurs when $φ$ equals the Chaitin's constant $Ω$, a well-defined real number that encodes the Halting problem, and hence is uncomputable for Turing machines and undecidable for any consistent recursive axiomatization of mathematics. Our result implies that no general algorithm exists to determine the phase diagrams even under the promise that the phase diagram is exceedingly simple, and illustrates how uncomputable numbers may manifest in physical systems.Open AccessChaitin Phase Transition
We construct a family of Hamiltonians whose phase diagram is guaranteed to have a single phase transition, yet the location of this phase transition is uncomputable. The Hamiltonians $H(φ)$ describe qudits on a two-dimensional square lattice with translationally invariant, nearest-neighbour interactions tuned by a continuous parameter $φ\in(0,1]$. For all $φ\in(0,1]$, $H(φ)$ is in one of two phases, one a gapless phase, the other a gapped phase. The phase transition occurs when $φ$ equals the Chaitin's constant $Ω$, a well-defined real number that encodes the Halting problem, and hence is uncomputable for Turing machines and undecidable for any consistent recursive axiomatization of mathematics. Our result implies that no general algorithm exists to determine the phase diagrams even under the promise that the phase diagram is exceedingly simple, and illustrates how uncomputable numbers may manifest in physical systems. - Open Access
- 20 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2024 (8) , 1-40
Security of quantum position-verification limits Hamiltonian simulation via holography
A bstract: We investigate the link between quantum position-verification (QPV) and holography established in [1] using holographic quantum error correcting codes as toy models. By inserting the “temporal” scaling of the AdS metric by hand via the bulk Hamiltonian interaction strength, we recover a toy model with consistent causality structure. This leads to an interesting implication between two topics in quantum information: if position-based verification is secure against attacks with small entanglement then there are new fundamental lower bounds for resources required for one Hamiltonian to simulate another.
- 20 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of High Energy Physics
- Vol. 2024 (8) , 1-40
Open AccessSecurity of quantum position-verification limits Hamiltonian simulation via holography
A bstract: We investigate the link between quantum position-verification (QPV) and holography established in [1] using holographic quantum error correcting codes as toy models. By inserting the “temporal” scaling of the AdS metric by hand via the bulk Hamiltonian interaction strength, we recover a toy model with consistent causality structure. This leads to an interesting implication between two topics in quantum information: if position-based verification is secure against attacks with small entanglement then there are new fundamental lower bounds for resources required for one Hamiltonian to simulate another.
- Open Access
A mathematical framework for quantum Hamiltonian simulation and duality
Analogue Hamiltonian simulation is a promising near-term application of quantum computing and has recently been put on a theoretical footing. In Hamiltonian simulation, a physical Hamiltonian is engineered to have identical physics to another - often very different - Hamiltonian. This is qualitatively similar to the notion of duality in physics, whereby two superficially different theories are mathematically equivalent in some precise sense. However, existing characterisations of Hamiltonian simulations are not sufficiently general to extend to all dualities in physics. In particular, they cannot encompass the important cases of strong/weak and high-temperature/low-temperature dualities. In this work, we give three physically motivated axiomatisations of duality, formulated respectively in terms of observables, partition functions and entropies. We prove that these axiomatisations are equivalent, and characterise the mathematical form that any duality satisfying these axioms must take. A building block in one of our results is a strengthening of earlier results on entropy-preserving maps to maps that are entropy-preserving up to an additive constant, which we prove decompose as a direct sum of unitary and anti-unitary components, which may be of independent mathematical interest.
Open AccessA mathematical framework for quantum Hamiltonian simulation and duality
Analogue Hamiltonian simulation is a promising near-term application of quantum computing and has recently been put on a theoretical footing. In Hamiltonian simulation, a physical Hamiltonian is engineered to have identical physics to another - often very different - Hamiltonian. This is qualitatively similar to the notion of duality in physics, whereby two superficially different theories are mathematically equivalent in some precise sense. However, existing characterisations of Hamiltonian simulations are not sufficiently general to extend to all dualities in physics. In particular, they cannot encompass the important cases of strong/weak and high-temperature/low-temperature dualities. In this work, we give three physically motivated axiomatisations of duality, formulated respectively in terms of observables, partition functions and entropies. We prove that these axiomatisations are equivalent, and characterise the mathematical form that any duality satisfying these axioms must take. A building block in one of our results is a strengthening of earlier results on entropy-preserving maps to maps that are entropy-preserving up to an additive constant, which we prove decompose as a direct sum of unitary and anti-unitary components, which may be of independent mathematical interest.
- Open Access
- 10 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Annales Henri Poincare
- Vol. 26 (1) , 317-364
A Mathematical Framework for Quantum Hamiltonian Simulation and Duality
Analogue Hamiltonian simulation is a promising near-term application of quantum computing and has recently been put on a theoretical footing alongside experiencing wide-ranging experimental success. These ideas are closely related to the notion of duality in physics, whereby two superficially different theories are mathematically equivalent in some precise sense. However, existing characterisations of Hamiltonian simulations are not sufficiently general to extend to all dualities in physics. We give a generalised duality definition encompassing dualities transforming a strongly interacting system into a weak one and vice versa. We characterise the dual map on operators and states and prove equivalence ofduality formulated in terms of observables, partition functions and entropies. A building block is a strengthening of earlier results on entropy preserving maps—extensions of Wigner’s celebrated theorem- –to maps that are entropy preserving up to an additive constant. We show such maps decompose as a direct sum of unitary and antiunitary components conjugated by a further unitary, a result that may be of independent mathematical interest.
- 10 April 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Annales Henri Poincare
- Vol. 26 (1) , 317-364
Open AccessA Mathematical Framework for Quantum Hamiltonian Simulation and Duality
Analogue Hamiltonian simulation is a promising near-term application of quantum computing and has recently been put on a theoretical footing alongside experiencing wide-ranging experimental success. These ideas are closely related to the notion of duality in physics, whereby two superficially different theories are mathematically equivalent in some precise sense. However, existing characterisations of Hamiltonian simulations are not sufficiently general to extend to all dualities in physics. We give a generalised duality definition encompassing dualities transforming a strongly interacting system into a weak one and vice versa. We characterise the dual map on operators and states and prove equivalence ofduality formulated in terms of observables, partition functions and entropies. A building block is a strengthening of earlier results on entropy preserving maps—extensions of Wigner’s celebrated theorem- –to maps that are entropy preserving up to an additive constant. We show such maps decompose as a direct sum of unitary and antiunitary components conjugated by a further unitary, a result that may be of independent mathematical interest.
- Open Access
Quantum Error Transmutation
We introduce a generalisation of quantum error correction, relaxing the requirement that a code should identify and correct a set of physical errors on the Hilbert space of a quantum computer exactly, instead allowing recovery up to a pre-specified admissible set of errors on the code space. We call these quantum error transmuting codes. They are of particular interest for the simulation of noisy quantum systems, and for use in algorithms inherently robust to errors of a particular character. Necessary and sufficient algebraic conditions on the set of physical and admissible errors for error transmutation are derived, generalising the Knill-Laflamme quantum error correction conditions. We demonstrate how some existing codes, including fermionic encodings, have error transmuting properties to interesting classes of admissible errors. Additionally, we report on the existence of some new codes, including low-qubit and translation invariant examples.
Open AccessQuantum Error Transmutation
We introduce a generalisation of quantum error correction, relaxing the requirement that a code should identify and correct a set of physical errors on the Hilbert space of a quantum computer exactly, instead allowing recovery up to a pre-specified admissible set of errors on the code space. We call these quantum error transmuting codes. They are of particular interest for the simulation of noisy quantum systems, and for use in algorithms inherently robust to errors of a particular character. Necessary and sufficient algebraic conditions on the set of physical and admissible errors for error transmutation are derived, generalising the Knill-Laflamme quantum error correction conditions. We demonstrate how some existing codes, including fermionic encodings, have error transmuting properties to interesting classes of admissible errors. Additionally, we report on the existence of some new codes, including low-qubit and translation invariant examples.
- Open Access
Dissipative ground state preparation and the Dissipative Quantum Eigensolver
For any local Hamiltonian H, I construct a local CPT map and stopping condition which converges to the ground state subspace of H. Like any ground state preparation algorithm, this algorithm necessarily has exponential run-time in general (otherwise BQP=QMA), even for gapped, frustration-free Hamiltonians (otherwise BQP is in NP). However, this dissipative quantum eigensolver has a number of interesting characteristics, which give advantages over previous ground state preparation algorithms. - The entire algorithm consists simply of iterating the same set of local measurements repeatedly. - The expected overlap with the ground state subspace increases monotonically with the length of time this process is allowed to run. - It converges to the ground state subspace unconditionally, without any assumptions on or prior information about the Hamiltonian. - The algorithm does not require any variational optimisation over parameters. - It is often able to find the ground state in low circuit depth in practice. - It has a simple implementation on certain types of quantum hardware, in particular photonic quantum computers. - The process is immune to errors in the initial state. - It is inherently error- and noise-resilient, i.e. to errors during execution of the algorithm and also to faulty implementation of the algorithm itself, without incurring any computational overhead: the overlap of the output with the ground state subspace degrades smoothly with the error rate, independent of the algorithm's run-time. I give rigorous proofs of the above claims, and benchmark the algorithm on some concrete examples numerically.
Open AccessDissipative ground state preparation and the Dissipative Quantum Eigensolver
For any local Hamiltonian H, I construct a local CPT map and stopping condition which converges to the ground state subspace of H. Like any ground state preparation algorithm, this algorithm necessarily has exponential run-time in general (otherwise BQP=QMA), even for gapped, frustration-free Hamiltonians (otherwise BQP is in NP). However, this dissipative quantum eigensolver has a number of interesting characteristics, which give advantages over previous ground state preparation algorithms. - The entire algorithm consists simply of iterating the same set of local measurements repeatedly. - The expected overlap with the ground state subspace increases monotonically with the length of time this process is allowed to run. - It converges to the ground state subspace unconditionally, without any assumptions on or prior information about the Hamiltonian. - The algorithm does not require any variational optimisation over parameters. - It is often able to find the ground state in low circuit depth in practice. - It has a simple implementation on certain types of quantum hardware, in particular photonic quantum computers. - The process is immune to errors in the initial state. - It is inherently error- and noise-resilient, i.e. to errors during execution of the algorithm and also to faulty implementation of the algorithm itself, without incurring any computational overhead: the overlap of the output with the ground state subspace degrades smoothly with the error rate, independent of the algorithm's run-time. I give rigorous proofs of the above claims, and benchmark the algorithm on some concrete examples numerically.
- Open Access
Dissipative Quantum Gibbs Sampling
Systems in thermal equilibrium at non-zero temperature are described by their Gibbs state. For classical many-body systems, the Metropolis-Hastings algorithm gives a Markov process with a local update rule that samples from the Gibbs distribution. For quantum systems, sampling from the Gibbs state is significantly more challenging. Many algorithms have been proposed, but these are more complex than the simple local update rule of classical Metropolis sampling, requiring non-trivial quantum algorithms such as phase estimation as a subroutine. Here, we show that a dissipative quantum algorithm with a simple, local update rule is able to sample from the quantum Gibbs state. In contrast to the classical case, the quantum Gibbs state is not generated by converging to the fixed point of a Markov process, but by the states generated at the stopping time of a conditionally stopped process. This gives a new answer to the long-sought-after quantum analogue of Metropolis sampling. Compared to previous quantum Gibbs sampling algorithms, the local update rule of the process has a simple implementation, which may make it more amenable to near-term implementation on suitable quantum hardware. This dissipative Gibbs sampler works for arbitrary quantum Hamiltonians, without any assumptions on or knowledge of its properties, and comes with certifiable precision and run-time bounds. We also show that the algorithm benefits from some measure of built-in resilience to faults and errors (``fault resilience''). Finally, we also demonstrate how the stopping statistics of an ensemble of runs of the dissipative Gibbs sampler can be used to estimate the partition function.
Open AccessDissipative Quantum Gibbs Sampling
Systems in thermal equilibrium at non-zero temperature are described by their Gibbs state. For classical many-body systems, the Metropolis-Hastings algorithm gives a Markov process with a local update rule that samples from the Gibbs distribution. For quantum systems, sampling from the Gibbs state is significantly more challenging. Many algorithms have been proposed, but these are more complex than the simple local update rule of classical Metropolis sampling, requiring non-trivial quantum algorithms such as phase estimation as a subroutine. Here, we show that a dissipative quantum algorithm with a simple, local update rule is able to sample from the quantum Gibbs state. In contrast to the classical case, the quantum Gibbs state is not generated by converging to the fixed point of a Markov process, but by the states generated at the stopping time of a conditionally stopped process. This gives a new answer to the long-sought-after quantum analogue of Metropolis sampling. Compared to previous quantum Gibbs sampling algorithms, the local update rule of the process has a simple implementation, which may make it more amenable to near-term implementation on suitable quantum hardware. This dissipative Gibbs sampler works for arbitrary quantum Hamiltonians, without any assumptions on or knowledge of its properties, and comes with certifiable precision and run-time bounds. We also show that the algorithm benefits from some measure of built-in resilience to faults and errors (``fault resilience''). Finally, we also demonstrate how the stopping statistics of an ensemble of runs of the dissipative Gibbs sampler can be used to estimate the partition function.
- Open Access
- 9 December 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-8
Uncomputably complex renormalisation group flows
Renormalisation group methods are among the most important techniques for analysing the physics of many-body systems: by iterating a renormalisation group map, which coarse-grains the description of a system and generates a flow in the parameter space, physical properties of interest can be extracted. However, recent work has shown that important physical features, such as the spectral gap and phase diagram, may be impossible to determine, even in principle. Following these insights, we construct a rigorous renormalisation group map for the original undecidable many-body system that appeared in the literature, which reveals a renormalisation group flow so complex that it cannot be predicted. We prove that each step of this map is computable, and that it converges to the correct fixed points, yet the resulting flow is uncomputable. This extreme form of unpredictability for renormalisation group flows had not been shown before and goes beyond the chaotic behaviour seen previously.
- 9 December 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-8
Open AccessUncomputably complex renormalisation group flows
Renormalisation group methods are among the most important techniques for analysing the physics of many-body systems: by iterating a renormalisation group map, which coarse-grains the description of a system and generates a flow in the parameter space, physical properties of interest can be extracted. However, recent work has shown that important physical features, such as the spectral gap and phase diagram, may be impossible to determine, even in principle. Following these insights, we construct a rigorous renormalisation group map for the original undecidable many-body system that appeared in the literature, which reveals a renormalisation group flow so complex that it cannot be predicted. We prove that each step of this map is computable, and that it converges to the correct fixed points, yet the resulting flow is uncomputable. This extreme form of unpredictability for renormalisation group flows had not been shown before and goes beyond the chaotic behaviour seen previously.