Ayşe Zarakol
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Ayşe Zarakol has a total of 59 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Zeynep Gülşah Çapan
University of Erfurt
2 shared publications - Adhemar Mercado
Philosophical and Theological Research Institute, San Pablo Faculty of Theology, Bolivian Catholic University San Pablo, Avenida Ramón Rivero esquina Oruro No. E-0492, Cochabamba P.O. Box 2118, Bolivia
1 shared publication Alex Vines
Chatham House, UK
1 shared publicationAndrew Jillions
London School of Economics and Political Science, UK
1 shared publication- Ashley Jackson
King's College London, UK
1 shared publication - Atsuko Watanabe
Kanazawa University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Thesis Eleven
Strongmen and warmaking
This essay asks whether warmaking can discipline the contemporary strongman regimes, as Tilly's account of European state formation might suggest it once did absolutism. To probe this question, it briefly revisits two non-European cases: New Kingdom Ancient Egypt and Warring States China. In neither does the European pattern hold. These historical cases help us identify the scope conditions for the mechanism identified by Tilly. Put briefly, warmaking generates the resistance that can constrain a personalised centre if the mechanisms of extraction are still being built rather than inherited, if the resisters to the centre hold their own autonomous resources, and if the pace of centralisation is slow enough to give the resisters time to organise. Most contemporary strongman regimes lack at least the first two of these, suggesting that warmaking in the twenty-first century will not provide the constraint on personalised, centralised sovereignty as it did in early modern Europe.
- 17 September 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Thesis Eleven
Open AccessStrongmen and warmaking
This essay asks whether warmaking can discipline the contemporary strongman regimes, as Tilly's account of European state formation might suggest it once did absolutism. To probe this question, it briefly revisits two non-European cases: New Kingdom Ancient Egypt and Warring States China. In neither does the European pattern hold. These historical cases help us identify the scope conditions for the mechanism identified by Tilly. Put briefly, warmaking generates the resistance that can constrain a personalised centre if the mechanisms of extraction are still being built rather than inherited, if the resisters to the centre hold their own autonomous resources, and if the pace of centralisation is slow enough to give the resisters time to organise. Most contemporary strongman regimes lack at least the first two of these, suggesting that warmaking in the twenty-first century will not provide the constraint on personalised, centralised sovereignty as it did in early modern Europe.
- Open Access
- 20 November 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Organization
- Vol. 79 (S1) , S1-S11
The Future of Global Governance and World Order
This special issue of International Organization is composed of fifteen short essays that consider how longer-term trends (including the rise of China, the anti-globalization backlash, the rise of populism, the emergence of new technologies, the slowing or reversal of democratization in many countries, and the existential threat of climate change), along with recent developments in US foreign policy, are likely to affect the future of global governance and world order. The contributors consider a variety of different issue areas, as well as cross-cutting trends. Some contributors anticipate significant change; others predict incremental change; and still others expect mostly continuity. The collection suggests a future research agenda focused on the impact of long-term trends and immediate shocks on local, regional, and global equilibria.
- 20 November 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Organization
- Vol. 79 (S1) , S1-S11
Open AccessThe Future of Global Governance and World Order
This special issue of International Organization is composed of fifteen short essays that consider how longer-term trends (including the rise of China, the anti-globalization backlash, the rise of populism, the emergence of new technologies, the slowing or reversal of democratization in many countries, and the existential threat of climate change), along with recent developments in US foreign policy, are likely to affect the future of global governance and world order. The contributors consider a variety of different issue areas, as well as cross-cutting trends. Some contributors anticipate significant change; others predict incremental change; and still others expect mostly continuity. The collection suggests a future research agenda focused on the impact of long-term trends and immediate shocks on local, regional, and global equilibria.
- Open Access
- 25 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of International Relations
- Vol. 31 (4) , 814-838
Concept formation in historical International Relations
For a long time, International Relations’ (IR) spatiotemporal parameters could be summarized in two words: Western and modern. The recent growth of Historical IR has contributed to a dramatic extension of these spatiotemporal coordinates, extending the discipline’s gaze to places and times that had previously been neglected. A key challenge that this ‘historical turn’ presents for IR theory, and that we take up in this article, is the proper formulation of analytical concepts capable of ‘travelling’ across different places, cultures, languages and time periods. So far, the existing Historical IR literature on concepts has focused primarily on the historicization of existing categories (especially through conceptual history and genealogical methods) and has not yet addressed the problem of concept formation head-on. In this article, we take up this challenge by theorizing the role of ‘travelling concepts’ in Historical IR – concepts that are neither entirely bound to their specific context nor entirely divorced from it. Returning to Max Weber’s work on ideal types, we suggest that travelling concepts are not only possible for historicist work, but necessary, and that it is therefore important for Historical IR scholars to be open and reflexive about their use of such concepts. By rejecting essentialism and recognizing the historical situatedness of the scholar, Weber encourages us to view the entire lexicon of Historical IR as an evolving archive for conceptual historians of the future to explore.
- 25 October 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of International Relations
- Vol. 31 (4) , 814-838
Open AccessConcept formation in historical International Relations
For a long time, International Relations’ (IR) spatiotemporal parameters could be summarized in two words: Western and modern. The recent growth of Historical IR has contributed to a dramatic extension of these spatiotemporal coordinates, extending the discipline’s gaze to places and times that had previously been neglected. A key challenge that this ‘historical turn’ presents for IR theory, and that we take up in this article, is the proper formulation of analytical concepts capable of ‘travelling’ across different places, cultures, languages and time periods. So far, the existing Historical IR literature on concepts has focused primarily on the historicization of existing categories (especially through conceptual history and genealogical methods) and has not yet addressed the problem of concept formation head-on. In this article, we take up this challenge by theorizing the role of ‘travelling concepts’ in Historical IR – concepts that are neither entirely bound to their specific context nor entirely divorced from it. Returning to Max Weber’s work on ideal types, we suggest that travelling concepts are not only possible for historicist work, but necessary, and that it is therefore important for Historical IR scholars to be open and reflexive about their use of such concepts. By rejecting essentialism and recognizing the historical situatedness of the scholar, Weber encourages us to view the entire lexicon of Historical IR as an evolving archive for conceptual historians of the future to explore.
- Open Access
- 31 July 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Theory
- Vol. 17 (2) , 287-293
Reply to ‘How (not) to advance Global IR: a rejoinder’
This reply responds to criticism of our original symposium, ‘Global IR and the Essentialism Trap.’ We respond to four particular charges and end with a call for Global IR to move beyond its current emphasis on creating a more diverse, equal, and inclusive discipline to identifying specific research programs that demonstrate the necessity of moving beyond the West. We nominate global order and disorder.
- 31 July 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Theory
- Vol. 17 (2) , 287-293
Open AccessReply to ‘How (not) to advance Global IR: a rejoinder’
This reply responds to criticism of our original symposium, ‘Global IR and the Essentialism Trap.’ We respond to four particular charges and end with a call for Global IR to move beyond its current emphasis on creating a more diverse, equal, and inclusive discipline to identifying specific research programs that demonstrate the necessity of moving beyond the West. We nominate global order and disorder.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2025
- Published by All Azimuth Journal of Foreign Policy and Peace in All Azimuth: A Journal of Foreign Policy and Peace
- Vol. 14 (2) , 154-168
All Azimuth Debate: Gradual Reform or Revolution? Pathways to Global IR
This forum article is based on the All Azimuth Debate held at Bilkent University on 3 October 2024. The event was organized by the Center for Foreign Policy and Peace Research in cooperation with Bilkent University’s Department of International Relations. The debate was moderated by Dr. Seçkin Köstem. The forum article demonstrates the scholarly exchange between Dr. Ayşe Zarakol and Dr. Ersel Aydınlı based on the answers that they gave to Dr. Seçkin Köstem’s questions on Global International Relations (IR). This forum article features two leading scholars’ perspectives regarding the definition of Global IR, the main actors and venues for Global IR, the role of English language as the dominant academic language, the essentialism/parochialism trap and pathways for a stronger global representation for the discipline of IR.
- 2 July 2025
- Published by All Azimuth Journal of Foreign Policy and Peace in All Azimuth: A Journal of Foreign Policy and Peace
- Vol. 14 (2) , 154-168
Open AccessAll Azimuth Debate: Gradual Reform or Revolution? Pathways to Global IR
This forum article is based on the All Azimuth Debate held at Bilkent University on 3 October 2024. The event was organized by the Center for Foreign Policy and Peace Research in cooperation with Bilkent University’s Department of International Relations. The debate was moderated by Dr. Seçkin Köstem. The forum article demonstrates the scholarly exchange between Dr. Ayşe Zarakol and Dr. Ersel Aydınlı based on the answers that they gave to Dr. Seçkin Köstem’s questions on Global International Relations (IR). This forum article features two leading scholars’ perspectives regarding the definition of Global IR, the main actors and venues for Global IR, the role of English language as the dominant academic language, the essentialism/parochialism trap and pathways for a stronger global representation for the discipline of IR.
- 8 May 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Political Science Quarterly
- Vol. 140 (2) , 434-435
Shadow Empires: An Alternative Imperial History by Thomas Barfield
- 8 May 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Political Science Quarterly
- Vol. 140 (2) , 434-435
Shadow Empires: An Alternative Imperial History by Thomas Barfield
- Open Access
- 22 November 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Ethics & International Affairs
- Vol. 38 (2) , 200-208
Rethinking International Order
This essay focuses on the concept of “international order” and its uses and misuses. It argues that the concept of “order” should not be conflated with the concept of a “system,” and that it makes more sense to speak of world order than international order because the former accommodates political units beyond the nation-state. Drawing on my recent book Before the West (2022) I show how the concept of “world order” travels better in history and also speculate about how it can help us think about the future as well.
- 22 November 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Ethics & International Affairs
- Vol. 38 (2) , 200-208
Open AccessRethinking International Order
This essay focuses on the concept of “international order” and its uses and misuses. It argues that the concept of “order” should not be conflated with the concept of a “system,” and that it makes more sense to speak of world order than international order because the former accommodates political units beyond the nation-state. Drawing on my recent book Before the West (2022) I show how the concept of “world order” travels better in history and also speculate about how it can help us think about the future as well.
- Open Access
- 30 September 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Political Sociology
- Vol. 18 (4)
Thinking through 1492: IR's Historiographic Operation(s) and the Politics of Benchmark Dates
This Collective Discussion aims to open up space for an international political sociology of the production of historical knowledge that interrogates the politics around benchmark dates and what becomes knowable and unknowable through them. Specifically, it examines 1492 as a historiographical device through which to unpack how the discipline of IR knows history. 1492 presents a relevant case for this interrogation, for it is central for the historical narratives of a variety of approaches. In this sense, the different contributions do not seek to recover an alternative, ‘better’ history of 1492, but rather to explore its politics of knowledge production: what types of histories it makes visible, what types it precludes, and in what way it partakes in the reproduction of specific hierarchies of knowledge and the power structures that operate through them. In doing so, the Collective Discussion makes visible – and thus opens up for discussion – the historiographical operations performed by periodization and benchmark dating in IR, pointing to a way forward for an international political sociology of knowledge production in the discipline.
- 30 September 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Political Sociology
- Vol. 18 (4)
Open AccessThinking through 1492: IR's Historiographic Operation(s) and the Politics of Benchmark Dates
This Collective Discussion aims to open up space for an international political sociology of the production of historical knowledge that interrogates the politics around benchmark dates and what becomes knowable and unknowable through them. Specifically, it examines 1492 as a historiographical device through which to unpack how the discipline of IR knows history. 1492 presents a relevant case for this interrogation, for it is central for the historical narratives of a variety of approaches. In this sense, the different contributions do not seek to recover an alternative, ‘better’ history of 1492, but rather to explore its politics of knowledge production: what types of histories it makes visible, what types it precludes, and in what way it partakes in the reproduction of specific hierarchies of knowledge and the power structures that operate through them. In doing so, the Collective Discussion makes visible – and thus opens up for discussion – the historiographical operations performed by periodization and benchmark dating in IR, pointing to a way forward for an international political sociology of knowledge production in the discipline.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 9 November 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Theory
- Vol. 15 (3) , 428-444
Global international relations and the essentialism trap
Global IR is an encompassing term for a range of work that has set out to globalize the discipline in terms of its core concepts, assumptions, and substantive areas of study. Our symposium supports Global IR's goals but also offers some friendly critiques of the project with the aim of increasing its impact and durability. In this Introduction to the symposium, we posit that Global IR is vulnerable to a dynamic that limits its capacity to upend the status quo, which we term the ‘essentialism trap’. Essentialism captures a range of commitments oriented around the notion that the world is constituted by pre-formed, fixed, internally coherent, and bounded social forms. The trap involves the overuse of essentialist categories by radical projects, a process that can result in the reinforcement of status quo categories and assumptions. With reference to previous openings in IR that have succumbed to this trap, we identify the dynamics that lead to this trap and suggest ways in which Global IR can avoid it by leaning more into relationalism and global history, and, thereby, fulfil the promise contained in the range of movements it speaks with and for.
- 9 November 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Theory
- Vol. 15 (3) , 428-444
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessGlobal international relations and the essentialism trap
Global IR is an encompassing term for a range of work that has set out to globalize the discipline in terms of its core concepts, assumptions, and substantive areas of study. Our symposium supports Global IR's goals but also offers some friendly critiques of the project with the aim of increasing its impact and durability. In this Introduction to the symposium, we posit that Global IR is vulnerable to a dynamic that limits its capacity to upend the status quo, which we term the ‘essentialism trap’. Essentialism captures a range of commitments oriented around the notion that the world is constituted by pre-formed, fixed, internally coherent, and bounded social forms. The trap involves the overuse of essentialist categories by radical projects, a process that can result in the reinforcement of status quo categories and assumptions. With reference to previous openings in IR that have succumbed to this trap, we identify the dynamics that lead to this trap and suggest ways in which Global IR can avoid it by leaning more into relationalism and global history, and, thereby, fulfil the promise contained in the range of movements it speaks with and for.
- Open Access
- 9 November 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Theory
- Vol. 15 (3) , 445-461
The United Nations of IR: power, knowledge, and empire in Global IR debates
This paper critiques a core premise of Global IR: the association of knowledge with geography, which we term geo-epistemology. It argues that ‘American’ and Global IR share a Eurocentric spatial imaginary, one that was a product of Western expansion and empire. Through its geo-epistemology, Global IR enables a conservative appropriation of the critique of Eurocentrism in IR. Globality becomes a matter of assembling sufficient geographic representation rather than an analysis of the discipline's political, historical, and spatial assumptions. Anglo-American policymakers and intellectuals invented the national/international world to replace the world of empires and races that came apart in the era of the world wars. This UN world of sovereign nation-states and their regional groupings was the foundational move of both what Stanley Hoffman called ‘the American social science’ – IR – and the American-centred world order. The paper uses the reception and legacy of Hoffman's classic essay to show how culture replaced power and history in the study of the discipline, obfuscating the Eurocentrism of Global IR.
- 9 November 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Theory
- Vol. 15 (3) , 445-461
Open AccessThe United Nations of IR: power, knowledge, and empire in Global IR debates
This paper critiques a core premise of Global IR: the association of knowledge with geography, which we term geo-epistemology. It argues that ‘American’ and Global IR share a Eurocentric spatial imaginary, one that was a product of Western expansion and empire. Through its geo-epistemology, Global IR enables a conservative appropriation of the critique of Eurocentrism in IR. Globality becomes a matter of assembling sufficient geographic representation rather than an analysis of the discipline's political, historical, and spatial assumptions. Anglo-American policymakers and intellectuals invented the national/international world to replace the world of empires and races that came apart in the era of the world wars. This UN world of sovereign nation-states and their regional groupings was the foundational move of both what Stanley Hoffman called ‘the American social science’ – IR – and the American-centred world order. The paper uses the reception and legacy of Hoffman's classic essay to show how culture replaced power and history in the study of the discipline, obfuscating the Eurocentrism of Global IR.