Alice MacLean
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Alice MacLean has a total of 83 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kate Hunt
Institute for Social Marketing and Health, University of Stirling, Stirling, UK
16 shared publications - Cindy M. Gray
School of Social and Political Sciences, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK
7 shared publications - Cervantée Erice Koorey Wild
Faculty of Medical and Health Sciences, University of Auckland School of Medicine, Auckland, New Zealand
5 shared publications - Claire Torrens
Faculty of Health Sciences and Sport, University of Stirling, Stirling, UK
5 shared publications - Sarah Nettleton
University of York
5 shared publications - Sue Ziebland
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences University of Oxford Oxford United Kingdom
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Men’s experiences of multiple long-term conditions and/or disability in the UK Game of Stones weight management trial: a mixed-methods evaluation
Objectives: To explore experiences, health outcomes and retention of men with multiple long-term conditions (MLTCs) and/or disability within the Game of Stones weight management randomised controlled trial (RCT). Design: Mixed-methods process evaluation within an RCT where secondary outcomes included the Weight Self-Stigma Questionnaire, EuroQol 5-Dimension 5-Level (EQ-5D-5L), EQ-5D-5L anxiety and depression subscale, Patient Health Questionnaire-4 and retention. Semistructured interviews were conducted at 12 months and analysed using the framework method. Setting: Conducted across three UK trial centres: Belfast, Bristol and Glasgow. Participants: 585 men with obesity (mean (SD) age, 50.7 (13.3) years) were randomised to one of three groups: behavioural text messages with financial incentives, texts alone or waiting-list control. Interviews were conducted with 54 participants from the two intervention groups. Results: 235 (40%) participants lived with MLTCs, 181 (31%) had a single condition, 167 (29%) had no conditions and 165 (29%) had a disability. Of those with MLTCs, 99 were disabled and 93 were living in deprived areas. Participants with MLTCs and/or disability were older, fewer had a degree-level qualification and fewer were in full-time work. Retention at 12 months was higher for men with disability (76%) or no long-term conditions (75%) and lower for men with diabetes (65%). Self-reported weight stigma, well-being and quality-of-life scores improved or stayed the same for men living with MLTCs in the intervention groups; however, results for anxiety and depression screening scores were inconsistent. Participant experiences indicated complex dynamic health, social and life situations which could provide motivation to lose weight for some but not others. Hospitalisation and poor mobility, with inability to exercise, were demotivating for making changes to reach weight loss targets. Conclusions: Men living with MLTCs and/or disability varied from very successful weight loss and improved health to not prioritising or feeling helped by the programme or disengagement due to immobility or diabetes. Trial registration number: isrctn.org Identifier: ISRCTN91974895 .
Open AccessMen’s experiences of multiple long-term conditions and/or disability in the UK Game of Stones weight management trial: a mixed-methods evaluation
Objectives: To explore experiences, health outcomes and retention of men with multiple long-term conditions (MLTCs) and/or disability within the Game of Stones weight management randomised controlled trial (RCT). Design: Mixed-methods process evaluation within an RCT where secondary outcomes included the Weight Self-Stigma Questionnaire, EuroQol 5-Dimension 5-Level (EQ-5D-5L), EQ-5D-5L anxiety and depression subscale, Patient Health Questionnaire-4 and retention. Semistructured interviews were conducted at 12 months and analysed using the framework method. Setting: Conducted across three UK trial centres: Belfast, Bristol and Glasgow. Participants: 585 men with obesity (mean (SD) age, 50.7 (13.3) years) were randomised to one of three groups: behavioural text messages with financial incentives, texts alone or waiting-list control. Interviews were conducted with 54 participants from the two intervention groups. Results: 235 (40%) participants lived with MLTCs, 181 (31%) had a single condition, 167 (29%) had no conditions and 165 (29%) had a disability. Of those with MLTCs, 99 were disabled and 93 were living in deprived areas. Participants with MLTCs and/or disability were older, fewer had a degree-level qualification and fewer were in full-time work. Retention at 12 months was higher for men with disability (76%) or no long-term conditions (75%) and lower for men with diabetes (65%). Self-reported weight stigma, well-being and quality-of-life scores improved or stayed the same for men living with MLTCs in the intervention groups; however, results for anxiety and depression screening scores were inconsistent. Participant experiences indicated complex dynamic health, social and life situations which could provide motivation to lose weight for some but not others. Hospitalisation and poor mobility, with inability to exercise, were demotivating for making changes to reach weight loss targets. Conclusions: Men living with MLTCs and/or disability varied from very successful weight loss and improved health to not prioritising or feeling helped by the programme or disengagement due to immobility or diabetes. Trial registration number: isrctn.org Identifier: ISRCTN91974895 .
- Open Access
- 6 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 27 (1)
‘They are with me on this journey’, the importance of participant-researcher relationships on attendance at follow-up in a behavioural weight management trial: a qualitative study of participant perspectives
Background: Retaining people for the duration of a trial or study can be challenging. This has been a particular difficulty for trials of behavioural weight management programmes. Poor retention can detrimentally impact data quality, validity, reliability, and knowledge translation. A number of behavioural strategies (for example reminders or monetary rewards) have been implemented to improve retention at follow-up in trials. However, research in this area is limited, the evidence is uncertain, and has not considered wider strategies such as style of delivery or the role of participant-researcher relationships within trial processes. The aim of this qualitative study was to explore participant views and experiences of follow-up weight assessments. Methods: Participants ( n = 390) were randomised to protocolised weight assessments, scheduled at 3 and 6 months. These were implemented in an embedded study within a trial of a 12-month text-based behavioural weight management programme. Participants received a task-oriented approach focused on completing weight verification and the case report form or a relational approach focused on building the participant relationship. Assessments were delivered by researchers at three recruiting centres (Belfast, Bristol, and Glasgow). Framework method was used to analyse transcripts of semi-structured interviews with participants. Results: Fifty-four trial participants took part in interviews. Three overarching themes were constructed from the narratives: the value of attending follow-up weight assessments, mode of weight assessment delivery, and contextual and practical factors influencing attendance at weight assessments. The themes provided novel insights into attendance at follow-up outcome assessments in a weight management trial including the emotive nature of attending weight assessments, related to weight stigma. Little distinguished the two groups. Participants spoke of positive relationships with researchers, benefitted from the researcher role within assessments, and desired in-person human contact, each considered by participants to enhance attendance. Conclusion: Participant-researcher relationships have an important role in retention. How researchers approach trial processes, such as outcome assessments, could improve attendance within weight management trials primarily by supporting motivation through mechanisms of change such as a sense of responsibility or accountability. Removal of connection through digital-only interventions, with limited in-person follow-up, has potential implications for retention. SWAT registration: Northern Ireland Hub for Trials Methodology Research SWAT 147, 1/04/2020.
- 6 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 27 (1)
Open Access‘They are with me on this journey’, the importance of participant-researcher relationships on attendance at follow-up in a behavioural weight management trial: a qualitative study of participant perspectives
Background: Retaining people for the duration of a trial or study can be challenging. This has been a particular difficulty for trials of behavioural weight management programmes. Poor retention can detrimentally impact data quality, validity, reliability, and knowledge translation. A number of behavioural strategies (for example reminders or monetary rewards) have been implemented to improve retention at follow-up in trials. However, research in this area is limited, the evidence is uncertain, and has not considered wider strategies such as style of delivery or the role of participant-researcher relationships within trial processes. The aim of this qualitative study was to explore participant views and experiences of follow-up weight assessments. Methods: Participants ( n = 390) were randomised to protocolised weight assessments, scheduled at 3 and 6 months. These were implemented in an embedded study within a trial of a 12-month text-based behavioural weight management programme. Participants received a task-oriented approach focused on completing weight verification and the case report form or a relational approach focused on building the participant relationship. Assessments were delivered by researchers at three recruiting centres (Belfast, Bristol, and Glasgow). Framework method was used to analyse transcripts of semi-structured interviews with participants. Results: Fifty-four trial participants took part in interviews. Three overarching themes were constructed from the narratives: the value of attending follow-up weight assessments, mode of weight assessment delivery, and contextual and practical factors influencing attendance at weight assessments. The themes provided novel insights into attendance at follow-up outcome assessments in a weight management trial including the emotive nature of attending weight assessments, related to weight stigma. Little distinguished the two groups. Participants spoke of positive relationships with researchers, benefitted from the researcher role within assessments, and desired in-person human contact, each considered by participants to enhance attendance. Conclusion: Participant-researcher relationships have an important role in retention. How researchers approach trial processes, such as outcome assessments, could improve attendance within weight management trials primarily by supporting motivation through mechanisms of change such as a sense of responsibility or accountability. Removal of connection through digital-only interventions, with limited in-person follow-up, has potential implications for retention. SWAT registration: Northern Ireland Hub for Trials Methodology Research SWAT 147, 1/04/2020.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2025
- Published by Wiley in Health Expectations
- Vol. 28 (5) , e70459
Trust in Transition: Exploring Changing Trust in Vaccination in the Context of Long Covid in the United Kingdom
Background: New drugs and vaccines usually come with the promise and hope of benefit. We explore stories about the variable and sometimes disappointing effects of Covid‐19 vaccines in the context of post‐Covid‐19 syndrome (‘long Covid’), aiming to understand how people with long Covid made sense of unexpected vaccine responses and how these experiences impacted their trust in vaccination. Methods: We carried out 33 interviews with people who described both positive and negative unexpected vaccine experiences connected to long Covid. Results: Trust and distrust in the multiple potential roles of Covid vaccines in relation to long Covid impacted perspectives on future vaccine uptake. Some participants feared being labelled as anti‐vaxx if they discussed unexpected vaccine impacts. Disengagement by healthcare professionals in discussions about the possibility of individual vaccine harms had the inverse consequence of limiting uptake of further Covid vaccines. Distrust could also grow in relation to unrealised benefits of vaccination—in this case, the official role as protection from severe infection and the unofficial role of treatment. Participants who trusted vaccines as a form of treatment struggled to access them for this use. Conclusion: The gap between scientific discourse—which recognised potential benefits and potential harms of vaccines in relation to long Covid—and public health discourse, which tended to focus on protection from infection, contributed to difficulties in maintaining trust after unexpected vaccine experiences. Further research to better characterise who is likely to benefit from vaccination and who might be at risk of worsening long Covid symptoms would enable better conversations between patients and healthcare professionals when making decisions about further vaccination. Patient or Public Contribution: The study was guided by a patient and public involvement and engagement (PPIE) group from project development through to dissemination. People with long Covid supported recruitment strategies, informed the development of topic guides, reviewed findings and offered suggestions for dissemination. Study participants were also invited to review and feedback on findings.
- 21 October 2025
- Published by Wiley in Health Expectations
- Vol. 28 (5) , e70459
Open AccessTrust in Transition: Exploring Changing Trust in Vaccination in the Context of Long Covid in the United Kingdom
Background: New drugs and vaccines usually come with the promise and hope of benefit. We explore stories about the variable and sometimes disappointing effects of Covid‐19 vaccines in the context of post‐Covid‐19 syndrome (‘long Covid’), aiming to understand how people with long Covid made sense of unexpected vaccine responses and how these experiences impacted their trust in vaccination. Methods: We carried out 33 interviews with people who described both positive and negative unexpected vaccine experiences connected to long Covid. Results: Trust and distrust in the multiple potential roles of Covid vaccines in relation to long Covid impacted perspectives on future vaccine uptake. Some participants feared being labelled as anti‐vaxx if they discussed unexpected vaccine impacts. Disengagement by healthcare professionals in discussions about the possibility of individual vaccine harms had the inverse consequence of limiting uptake of further Covid vaccines. Distrust could also grow in relation to unrealised benefits of vaccination—in this case, the official role as protection from severe infection and the unofficial role of treatment. Participants who trusted vaccines as a form of treatment struggled to access them for this use. Conclusion: The gap between scientific discourse—which recognised potential benefits and potential harms of vaccines in relation to long Covid—and public health discourse, which tended to focus on protection from infection, contributed to difficulties in maintaining trust after unexpected vaccine experiences. Further research to better characterise who is likely to benefit from vaccination and who might be at risk of worsening long Covid symptoms would enable better conversations between patients and healthcare professionals when making decisions about further vaccination. Patient or Public Contribution: The study was guided by a patient and public involvement and engagement (PPIE) group from project development through to dissemination. People with long Covid supported recruitment strategies, informed the development of topic guides, reviewed findings and offered suggestions for dissemination. Study participants were also invited to review and feedback on findings.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 311-328
Long COVID in Children, Young People and Families
- 1 October 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 311-328
Open AccessLong COVID in Children, Young People and Families
- Open Access
- 9 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Health Expectations
- Vol. 28 (2) , e70253
Rethinking ‘Recovery’: A Comparative Qualitative Analysis of Experiences of Intensive Care With COVID and Long Covid in the United Kingdom
Introduction: Interpretations of ‘recovery’ from illness are complex and influenced by many factors, not least patient expectations and experiences. This paper examines meanings of ‘recovery’, and how it is strived towards, drawing on the example of COVID‐19 infection.Methods: Drawing on qualitative interviews (n = 93) conducted in the UK between February 2021 and July 2022, we compare adults' accounts of being admitted to an Intensive Care Unit (ICU) with COVID‐19 to accounts of being ill with Long COVID, defined as ongoing symptoms for at least 12 weeks postinfection. We conducted a multi‐stage comparative analysis using Nvivo to organise and code the data.Results: We identified similarities and differences in participants' descriptions of their ‘worlds of illness’. For both groups, perceptions of recovery were shaped by the novel, unknown nature of COVID‐19. Participants questioned the achievability of full restoration of prior states of health, highlighted the heterogeneity of ‘recovery trajectories’ and described the hard physical and emotional work of adjusting to changed selves. Themes that revealed differences in ‘worlds of illness’ described included the different baselines, waymarkers, and pathways of illness experiences. Differences in other people's responses to their illness were also evident. For ICU participants, hospitalisation, and especially ICU admission, conferred legitimate patient status and authenticity to their symptoms. Family, friends and healthcare professionals acknowledged their illness, celebrated their survival, and granted them latitude to recover. For Long Covid participants, their patient status often lacked comparable authenticity in others' eyes. They reported encountering a lack of recognition and understanding of their ongoing need to recover.Conclusions: This study highlights how the meanings of illness ascribed by others can influence how recovery is experienced. Our findings highlight the importance of ensuring people are made to feel their illness experiences are legitimate, regardless of hospitalisation status, formal diagnosis or lack of medical knowledge and pathways. They also indicate the value of emphasising the different permutations, and lack of linearity, that recovery can take. This may help to help to guard against a lack of understanding for experiences of recovery which do not meet idealised notions.Patient or Public Contribution: Both studies were guided by an advisory panel that included patient and public involvement representatives with lived experience of Intensive Care/COVID experience and Long COVID respectively. Through regular meetings with the research teams, the advisory panel had input into all aspects of the study conduct, including recruitment methods and content of the interview topic guide and feedback on preliminary analyses. The Long COVID study also included a lived experience coinvestigator who contributed to data interpretation and analysis.
- 9 April 2025
- Published by Wiley in Health Expectations
- Vol. 28 (2) , e70253
Open AccessRethinking ‘Recovery’: A Comparative Qualitative Analysis of Experiences of Intensive Care With COVID and Long Covid in the United Kingdom
Introduction: Interpretations of ‘recovery’ from illness are complex and influenced by many factors, not least patient expectations and experiences. This paper examines meanings of ‘recovery’, and how it is strived towards, drawing on the example of COVID‐19 infection.Methods: Drawing on qualitative interviews (n = 93) conducted in the UK between February 2021 and July 2022, we compare adults' accounts of being admitted to an Intensive Care Unit (ICU) with COVID‐19 to accounts of being ill with Long COVID, defined as ongoing symptoms for at least 12 weeks postinfection. We conducted a multi‐stage comparative analysis using Nvivo to organise and code the data.Results: We identified similarities and differences in participants' descriptions of their ‘worlds of illness’. For both groups, perceptions of recovery were shaped by the novel, unknown nature of COVID‐19. Participants questioned the achievability of full restoration of prior states of health, highlighted the heterogeneity of ‘recovery trajectories’ and described the hard physical and emotional work of adjusting to changed selves. Themes that revealed differences in ‘worlds of illness’ described included the different baselines, waymarkers, and pathways of illness experiences. Differences in other people's responses to their illness were also evident. For ICU participants, hospitalisation, and especially ICU admission, conferred legitimate patient status and authenticity to their symptoms. Family, friends and healthcare professionals acknowledged their illness, celebrated their survival, and granted them latitude to recover. For Long Covid participants, their patient status often lacked comparable authenticity in others' eyes. They reported encountering a lack of recognition and understanding of their ongoing need to recover.Conclusions: This study highlights how the meanings of illness ascribed by others can influence how recovery is experienced. Our findings highlight the importance of ensuring people are made to feel their illness experiences are legitimate, regardless of hospitalisation status, formal diagnosis or lack of medical knowledge and pathways. They also indicate the value of emphasising the different permutations, and lack of linearity, that recovery can take. This may help to help to guard against a lack of understanding for experiences of recovery which do not meet idealised notions.Patient or Public Contribution: Both studies were guided by an advisory panel that included patient and public involvement representatives with lived experience of Intensive Care/COVID experience and Long COVID respectively. Through regular meetings with the research teams, the advisory panel had input into all aspects of the study conduct, including recruitment methods and content of the interview topic guide and feedback on preliminary analyses. The Long COVID study also included a lived experience coinvestigator who contributed to data interpretation and analysis.
- Open Access
Men with long-term conditions in the Game of Stones text messaging and financial incentives trial: an exploratory mixed methods study
Men living with multiple long-term conditions and obesity are under-represented in behavioural weight management trials. Within an effective text messaging and financial incentives trial, our aim was to explore retention, secondary mental health and wellbeing outcomes, and experiences of men with multiple long-term conditions. Methods Mixed methods process evaluation within a 3-group randomised controlled trial: behavioural text messages with financial incentives, texts alone and waiting-list control, for 583 of 585 men with obesity. Trial retention, mental health and wellbeing outcomes, and experiences were compared for 235 (40%) participants with multiple long-term conditions, 181 (31%) with single conditions, 167 (29%) with no conditions, and for 165 (29%) with disability. Semi-structured interviews, analysed using the Framework method, explored experiences with weight trajectories. Concurrent descriptive and qualitative analyses were undertaken. Results Of the 235 (40%) trial participants with multiple long-term conditions, 99 were disabled and 93 were living in deprived areas. Participants with multiple long-term conditions and/or disability were older, fewer had a degree level qualification, and fewer were in full time work. Retention at 12 months was higher for men with disability (76%) or no long-term conditions (75%), and lower for men with diabetes (65%). Self-reported weight stigma, wellbeing and quality of life scores improved or stayed the same for men living with multiple long-term conditions in the intervention groups, however, results for anxiety and depression screening scores were inconsistent. Participant experiences indicated complex dynamic health, social and life situations which could provide motivation to lose weight for some but not others. Hospitalisation and poor mobility, with inability to exercise, was de-motivating for making changes to reach weight loss targets. Conclusion Men with multiple long-term conditions varied from very successful weight loss and improved health, to not prioritising or feeling helped by the programme or disengagement due to immobility or diabetes.
Open AccessMen with long-term conditions in the Game of Stones text messaging and financial incentives trial: an exploratory mixed methods study
Men living with multiple long-term conditions and obesity are under-represented in behavioural weight management trials. Within an effective text messaging and financial incentives trial, our aim was to explore retention, secondary mental health and wellbeing outcomes, and experiences of men with multiple long-term conditions. Methods Mixed methods process evaluation within a 3-group randomised controlled trial: behavioural text messages with financial incentives, texts alone and waiting-list control, for 583 of 585 men with obesity. Trial retention, mental health and wellbeing outcomes, and experiences were compared for 235 (40%) participants with multiple long-term conditions, 181 (31%) with single conditions, 167 (29%) with no conditions, and for 165 (29%) with disability. Semi-structured interviews, analysed using the Framework method, explored experiences with weight trajectories. Concurrent descriptive and qualitative analyses were undertaken. Results Of the 235 (40%) trial participants with multiple long-term conditions, 99 were disabled and 93 were living in deprived areas. Participants with multiple long-term conditions and/or disability were older, fewer had a degree level qualification, and fewer were in full time work. Retention at 12 months was higher for men with disability (76%) or no long-term conditions (75%), and lower for men with diabetes (65%). Self-reported weight stigma, wellbeing and quality of life scores improved or stayed the same for men living with multiple long-term conditions in the intervention groups, however, results for anxiety and depression screening scores were inconsistent. Participant experiences indicated complex dynamic health, social and life situations which could provide motivation to lose weight for some but not others. Hospitalisation and poor mobility, with inability to exercise, was de-motivating for making changes to reach weight loss targets. Conclusion Men with multiple long-term conditions varied from very successful weight loss and improved health, to not prioritising or feeling helped by the programme or disengagement due to immobility or diabetes.
- Open Access
Long-term Effects of Text Messages with Financial Incentives for Men with Obesity: Two-year Follow-up of the Game of Stones trial
Objectives: To compare the difference in percentage weight change at 24 months following a 12-month text messaging with financial incentive intervention compared to a waiting list control group, and to compare the text messaging alone group to the control group. Design: Assessor-blinded three-arm randomised clinical trial. Setting: Three disadvantaged communities from the UK. Participants: 585 men with body mass index (BMI) of ≥30kg/m 2 enrolled between July 2021 and May 2022, of which 377 participants (64%) completed 24 months’ follow-up. Interventions: 12 months of daily behavioural text messages combined with financial incentives; 12 months of the same text messages alone; or waiting for 12 months followed by receipt of the first 3 months (months 12-15) of text messages (control). Main outcome measures: Within-participant change from baseline weight. Results: At 24 months, the mean percent weight change (standard deviation) was −3.9% (6.9%) for the text messaging with financial incentives group, −2.6% (6.8%) for the text messaging alone group, and −2.2% (6.8%) for the control group. Compared with the control group, the mean percent weight change was not significantly greater in the text messaging with financial incentives group (mean difference, −1.0%; 97.5% CI, −2.6 to 0.6; P = .22) or the text messaging alone group (mean difference, −0.0%; 97.5% CI, −1.6 to 1.5; P = .95). At least 5% weight loss at 24 months was achieved by 52 (40%) participants in the text messaging with financial incentives group; 32 (28%) in the text messaging alone group and 43 (32%) in the control group. Conclusions: A scalable, low-cost text message with financial incentives intervention supported clinically relevant maintenance of weight loss 12 months after the intervention ceased, including those from disadvantaged backgrounds. What is already known on this topic: Men, particularly those in lower socio-economic groups, engage less frequently in existing weight loss interventions and services, and might benefit from gender-sensitized interventions. The Game of Stones trial showed that a 12-month intervention consisting of text messaging with endowment financial incentives resulted in statistically significant weight loss in men with obesity compared with control. What this study adds: At 24 months, participants receiving 12 months of behavioural text messages with financial incentives displayed continued weight loss which is likely to be clinically important for some men. This digital, scalable, low risk text messaging with financial incentives intervention, with low participant and staff burden, shows promise for longer-term weight maintenance in men, including those living in the most deprived areas.
Open AccessLong-term Effects of Text Messages with Financial Incentives for Men with Obesity: Two-year Follow-up of the Game of Stones trial
Objectives: To compare the difference in percentage weight change at 24 months following a 12-month text messaging with financial incentive intervention compared to a waiting list control group, and to compare the text messaging alone group to the control group. Design: Assessor-blinded three-arm randomised clinical trial. Setting: Three disadvantaged communities from the UK. Participants: 585 men with body mass index (BMI) of ≥30kg/m 2 enrolled between July 2021 and May 2022, of which 377 participants (64%) completed 24 months’ follow-up. Interventions: 12 months of daily behavioural text messages combined with financial incentives; 12 months of the same text messages alone; or waiting for 12 months followed by receipt of the first 3 months (months 12-15) of text messages (control). Main outcome measures: Within-participant change from baseline weight. Results: At 24 months, the mean percent weight change (standard deviation) was −3.9% (6.9%) for the text messaging with financial incentives group, −2.6% (6.8%) for the text messaging alone group, and −2.2% (6.8%) for the control group. Compared with the control group, the mean percent weight change was not significantly greater in the text messaging with financial incentives group (mean difference, −1.0%; 97.5% CI, −2.6 to 0.6; P = .22) or the text messaging alone group (mean difference, −0.0%; 97.5% CI, −1.6 to 1.5; P = .95). At least 5% weight loss at 24 months was achieved by 52 (40%) participants in the text messaging with financial incentives group; 32 (28%) in the text messaging alone group and 43 (32%) in the control group. Conclusions: A scalable, low-cost text message with financial incentives intervention supported clinically relevant maintenance of weight loss 12 months after the intervention ceased, including those from disadvantaged backgrounds. What is already known on this topic: Men, particularly those in lower socio-economic groups, engage less frequently in existing weight loss interventions and services, and might benefit from gender-sensitized interventions. The Game of Stones trial showed that a 12-month intervention consisting of text messaging with endowment financial incentives resulted in statistically significant weight loss in men with obesity compared with control. What this study adds: At 24 months, participants receiving 12 months of behavioural text messages with financial incentives displayed continued weight loss which is likely to be clinically important for some men. This digital, scalable, low risk text messaging with financial incentives intervention, with low participant and staff burden, shows promise for longer-term weight maintenance in men, including those living in the most deprived areas.
- Open Access
Mental health and weight loss in men: an exploratory mixed methods study of the Game of Stones trial
Objective: Weight management interventions can affect mental health. Mental health can affect engagement with weight loss interventions or services. This study explored mental health and wellbeing outcomes, retention and participant experiences of mental health within the Game of Stones trial. Methods: Mixed methods process evaluation within a 3-group randomised controlled trial: behavioural text messages with financial incentives, texts alone, and waiting list control, for 585 men with obesity. Secondary outcomes analysed descriptively included: Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale, Weight Self-Stigma Questionnaire, EQ-5D-5L, EQ-5D-5L anxiety and depression subscale, Patient Health Questionniare-4, and retention. Three categories of participants were compared: ever diagnosed with a mental health condition (n=146; 25.0%), latent mental health condition (n=142; 24.3%) no mental health condition (n=295; 50.6%). Semi-structured interviews (n=54) were conducted after 12 months and analysed using Framework method. Results: A higher proportion of men who self-reported ever having a mental health condition had a disability, multiple long-term conditions, were under financial strain and were single compared to those with those with a latent mental health condition and no mental health condition. Improvements from baseline were shown for weight stigma, wellbeing and PHQ-4 at 12 months for men in intervention groups with a mental health condition and latent mental health condition. EQ-5D-5L Visual Analogue Scale scores improved across all mental health categories and trial groups, but EQ-5D-5L and EQ-5D-5L-AD scores were inconsistent. Retention at 12 months was 76.0% (mental health condition), 70.4% (latent mental health condition) and 72.5% (no mental health condition). The qualitative evidence indicated that stress, anxiety and depression were experienced in different ways by men during the programme. Mental health difficulties were unique to the individual, could be episodic, recurrent, cyclical or ongoing and were a barrier to behaviour change for some but not for others. Conclusion: The trial was able to engage and retain men regardless of mental health category. Behavioural text messages with or without incentives helped some men lose weight, but not others. Observed heterogeneity for mental health and wellbeing measures is problematic for weight management trials with men.
Open AccessMental health and weight loss in men: an exploratory mixed methods study of the Game of Stones trial
Objective: Weight management interventions can affect mental health. Mental health can affect engagement with weight loss interventions or services. This study explored mental health and wellbeing outcomes, retention and participant experiences of mental health within the Game of Stones trial. Methods: Mixed methods process evaluation within a 3-group randomised controlled trial: behavioural text messages with financial incentives, texts alone, and waiting list control, for 585 men with obesity. Secondary outcomes analysed descriptively included: Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale, Weight Self-Stigma Questionnaire, EQ-5D-5L, EQ-5D-5L anxiety and depression subscale, Patient Health Questionniare-4, and retention. Three categories of participants were compared: ever diagnosed with a mental health condition (n=146; 25.0%), latent mental health condition (n=142; 24.3%) no mental health condition (n=295; 50.6%). Semi-structured interviews (n=54) were conducted after 12 months and analysed using Framework method. Results: A higher proportion of men who self-reported ever having a mental health condition had a disability, multiple long-term conditions, were under financial strain and were single compared to those with those with a latent mental health condition and no mental health condition. Improvements from baseline were shown for weight stigma, wellbeing and PHQ-4 at 12 months for men in intervention groups with a mental health condition and latent mental health condition. EQ-5D-5L Visual Analogue Scale scores improved across all mental health categories and trial groups, but EQ-5D-5L and EQ-5D-5L-AD scores were inconsistent. Retention at 12 months was 76.0% (mental health condition), 70.4% (latent mental health condition) and 72.5% (no mental health condition). The qualitative evidence indicated that stress, anxiety and depression were experienced in different ways by men during the programme. Mental health difficulties were unique to the individual, could be episodic, recurrent, cyclical or ongoing and were a barrier to behaviour change for some but not for others. Conclusion: The trial was able to engage and retain men regardless of mental health category. Behavioural text messages with or without incentives helped some men lose weight, but not others. Observed heterogeneity for mental health and wellbeing measures is problematic for weight management trials with men.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2024
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 46 (8) , 1526-1546
Young adults’ experiences of biographical retrogression whilst living with long COVID
During the early years (2020–2021) of the COVID‐19 pandemic, relatively little attention focused on experiences of people with long‐lasting symptoms, particularly young adults who were commonly understood to be invulnerable to serious effects of the virus. Drawing on narrative interviews with 15 adults in their twenties and living in the UK when they became ill with long COVID, we explore contextual factors which made their long COVID illness experience, and the wholescale disruption to their lives, challenging. We propose that existing adaptations of the concept of biographical disruption are problematic for this group, and instead suggest that ‘biographical retrogression’ may more accurately reflect these young adults’ experiences. For many of these young adults, their illness occurred at a crucial stage in forming or solidifying (presumed) adult trajectories. Secondly, the recency of long COVID did not allow for comparison with an existing ‘grand narrative’ of recovery, so the future course of their illness was not just unknown for them as individuals; there was no prognostic map against which to assess their symptoms. Thirdly, the lives of people with long COVID have been disrupted in the context of global societal disruption by the same virus, rendering their experiences both topical yet invisible.
- 12 June 2024
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 46 (8) , 1526-1546
Open AccessYoung adults’ experiences of biographical retrogression whilst living with long COVID
During the early years (2020–2021) of the COVID‐19 pandemic, relatively little attention focused on experiences of people with long‐lasting symptoms, particularly young adults who were commonly understood to be invulnerable to serious effects of the virus. Drawing on narrative interviews with 15 adults in their twenties and living in the UK when they became ill with long COVID, we explore contextual factors which made their long COVID illness experience, and the wholescale disruption to their lives, challenging. We propose that existing adaptations of the concept of biographical disruption are problematic for this group, and instead suggest that ‘biographical retrogression’ may more accurately reflect these young adults’ experiences. For many of these young adults, their illness occurred at a crucial stage in forming or solidifying (presumed) adult trajectories. Secondly, the recency of long COVID did not allow for comparison with an existing ‘grand narrative’ of recovery, so the future course of their illness was not just unknown for them as individuals; there was no prognostic map against which to assess their symptoms. Thirdly, the lives of people with long COVID have been disrupted in the context of global societal disruption by the same virus, rendering their experiences both topical yet invisible.
- Open Access
- 26 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Disability & Society
- Vol. 40 (5) , 1239-1261
Episodic disability and adjustments for work: the ‘rehabilitative work’ of returning to employment with Long Covid
In March 2023, the Office for National Statistics (ONS 2023) estimated that 1.7 million people in the United Kingdom (UK) were experiencing ongoing symptoms for at least one year following a Covid-...
- 26 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Disability & Society
- Vol. 40 (5) , 1239-1261
Open AccessEpisodic disability and adjustments for work: the ‘rehabilitative work’ of returning to employment with Long Covid
In March 2023, the Office for National Statistics (ONS 2023) estimated that 1.7 million people in the United Kingdom (UK) were experiencing ongoing symptoms for at least one year following a Covid-...