Ted Underwood
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Ted Underwood has a total of 37 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- John Stephen Downie
School of Information Sciences, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Champaign, Illinois, USA
4 shared publications - Wenyi Shang
University of Missouri
4 shared publications - Glen Layne-Worthey
HathiTrust Research Center, School of Information Sciences, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Champaign, IL, USA
3 shared publications - Yuerong Hu
Department of Information and Library Science, Luddy School of Informatics Computing and Engineering, Indiana University Bloomington , Bloomington, Indiana, 47401
3 shared publications - Jana Diesner
University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
2 shared publications - Zoe LeBlanc
School of Information Sciences, University of Illinois Urbana Champaign, Champaign, IL, USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 13 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Digital Scholarship in the Humanities
- Vol. 41 (Supplement) , i89-i106
Comparative analysis of classics book review data created by users across Douban and Goodreads
While empirical research on online book reviews has advanced our understanding of book reception and everyday reading, more cross-platform and comparative analyses are needed to cross-examine and enrich existing perspectives on these topics. This paper presents our comparative analysis of user-created reviews of “classics” across two platforms: Goodreads based in the U.S., and Douban based in China. With book tagging, rating, and reviewing data collected from the two platforms, we examined how 144 classics identified by users on Goodreads and 141 classics on Douban were characterized and received across platforms. Our analysis reveals how book reviewers’ interests in and opinions about classics differ across platforms and demonstrates the necessity of gaining a more comprehensive understanding of classics. We also contribute a parallel dataset of classics across Goodreads and Douban for future investigations. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first parallel classics dataset across Anglophone and non-Anglophone platforms. In addition, we identify three primary challenges in aligning and comparing cross-platform data regarding metadata quality, rating systems, and multi-lingual data processing. We present these challenges and discuss how we managed to overcome them. Our case study furthers existing conversations on the characterization and reception of classics online and informs future cross-platform online book review studies.
- 13 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Digital Scholarship in the Humanities
- Vol. 41 (Supplement) , i89-i106
Comparative analysis of classics book review data created by users across Douban and Goodreads
While empirical research on online book reviews has advanced our understanding of book reception and everyday reading, more cross-platform and comparative analyses are needed to cross-examine and enrich existing perspectives on these topics. This paper presents our comparative analysis of user-created reviews of “classics” across two platforms: Goodreads based in the U.S., and Douban based in China. With book tagging, rating, and reviewing data collected from the two platforms, we examined how 144 classics identified by users on Goodreads and 141 classics on Douban were characterized and received across platforms. Our analysis reveals how book reviewers’ interests in and opinions about classics differ across platforms and demonstrates the necessity of gaining a more comprehensive understanding of classics. We also contribute a parallel dataset of classics across Goodreads and Douban for future investigations. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first parallel classics dataset across Anglophone and non-Anglophone platforms. In addition, we identify three primary challenges in aligning and comparing cross-platform data regarding metadata quality, rating systems, and multi-lingual data processing. We present these challenges and discuss how we managed to overcome them. Our case study furthers existing conversations on the characterization and reception of classics online and informs future cross-platform online book review studies.
- Open Access
- 3 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 12 (3)
Who decides what is read on Goodreads? Uncovering sponsorship and its implications for scholarly research
Attracted by the promise of a broader and more egalitarian sample of readers than published book reviews provide, researchers are increasingly scraping social reviewing platforms like Goodreads for data about readers’ behavior. Yet, treating online book reviews as direct proxies for readers and books can be problematic, as they are socially and technically constructed artifacts shaped by platform dynamics, whether between developers and users, or book industry stakeholders and reviewers. To uncover these complexities, we computationally curated 331,211 self-identified incentivized book reviews to understand the growth of incentivized content, and how these purportedly equal-access social reviewing spaces are re-inscribing the inequalities of traditional book reviewing and publishing. Our findings underscore the necessity of critical examination of both online book reviewing and cultural datasets derived from social media platforms. With the growing restrictions on access to platform data for research, this study also demonstrates the potential for a mixed-method analysis of historical scraped datasets; an approach that will likely be of interest to many researchers working with cultural data moderated by black-box algorithms. With this method, our research reveals for the first time the scale of the phenomena of incentivized book reviews that is well known to users of Goodreads but remains largely anecdotal. Additionally, it illuminates the rise of sponsored content while contributing to broader discussions on computational approaches to digital economies of prestige and the responsible use of platform-mediated cultural datasets across disciplines.
- 3 August 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Big Data & Society
- Vol. 12 (3)
Open AccessWho decides what is read on Goodreads? Uncovering sponsorship and its implications for scholarly research
Attracted by the promise of a broader and more egalitarian sample of readers than published book reviews provide, researchers are increasingly scraping social reviewing platforms like Goodreads for data about readers’ behavior. Yet, treating online book reviews as direct proxies for readers and books can be problematic, as they are socially and technically constructed artifacts shaped by platform dynamics, whether between developers and users, or book industry stakeholders and reviewers. To uncover these complexities, we computationally curated 331,211 self-identified incentivized book reviews to understand the growth of incentivized content, and how these purportedly equal-access social reviewing spaces are re-inscribing the inequalities of traditional book reviewing and publishing. Our findings underscore the necessity of critical examination of both online book reviewing and cultural datasets derived from social media platforms. With the growing restrictions on access to platform data for research, this study also demonstrates the potential for a mixed-method analysis of historical scraped datasets; an approach that will likely be of interest to many researchers working with cultural data moderated by black-box algorithms. With this method, our research reveals for the first time the scale of the phenomena of incentivized book reviews that is well known to users of Goodreads but remains largely anecdotal. Additionally, it illuminates the rise of sponsored content while contributing to broader discussions on computational approaches to digital economies of prestige and the responsible use of platform-mediated cultural datasets across disciplines.
- 25 June 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Computational Science
- p. 1-3
The impact of language models on the humanities and vice versa
- 25 June 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Computational Science
- p. 1-3
The impact of language models on the humanities and vice versa
- Open Access
Locating the Leading Edge of Cultural Change
Measures of textual similarity and divergence are increasingly used to study cultural change. But which measures align, in practice, with social evidence about change? We apply three different representations of text (topic models, document embeddings, and word-level perplexity) to three different corpora (literary studies, economics, and fiction). In every case, works by highly-cited authors and younger authors are textually ahead of the curve. We don't find clear evidence that one representation of text is to be preferred over the others. But alignment with social evidence is strongest when texts are represented through the top quartile of passages, suggesting that a text's impact may depend more on its most forward-looking moments than on sustaining a high level of innovation throughout.
Open AccessLocating the Leading Edge of Cultural Change
Measures of textual similarity and divergence are increasingly used to study cultural change. But which measures align, in practice, with social evidence about change? We apply three different representations of text (topic models, document embeddings, and word-level perplexity) to three different corpora (literary studies, economics, and fiction). In every case, works by highly-cited authors and younger authors are textually ahead of the curve. We don't find clear evidence that one representation of text is to be preferred over the others. But alignment with social evidence is strongest when texts are represented through the top quartile of passages, suggesting that a text's impact may depend more on its most forward-looking moments than on sustaining a high level of innovation throughout.
- Open Access
"The teachers are confused as well": A Multiple-Stakeholder Ethics Discussion on Large Language Models in Computing Education
Large Language Models (LLMs) are advancing quickly and impacting people's lives for better or worse. In higher education, concerns have emerged such as students' misuse of LLMs and degraded education outcomes. To unpack the ethical concerns of LLMs for higher education, we conducted a case study consisting of stakeholder interviews (n=20) in higher education computer science. We found that students use several distinct mental models to interact with LLMs - LLMs serve as a tool for (a) writing, (b) coding, and (c) information retrieval, which differ somewhat in ethical considerations. Students and teachers brought up ethical issues that directly impact them, such as inaccurate LLM responses, hallucinations, biases, privacy leakage, and academic integrity issues. Participants emphasized the necessity of guidance and rules for the use of LLMs in higher education, including teaching digital literacy, rethinking education, and having cautious and contextual policies. We reflect on the ethical challenges and propose solutions.
Open Access"The teachers are confused as well": A Multiple-Stakeholder Ethics Discussion on Large Language Models in Computing Education
Large Language Models (LLMs) are advancing quickly and impacting people's lives for better or worse. In higher education, concerns have emerged such as students' misuse of LLMs and degraded education outcomes. To unpack the ethical concerns of LLMs for higher education, we conducted a case study consisting of stakeholder interviews (n=20) in higher education computer science. We found that students use several distinct mental models to interact with LLMs - LLMs serve as a tool for (a) writing, (b) coding, and (c) information retrieval, which differ somewhat in ethical considerations. Students and teachers brought up ethical issues that directly impact them, such as inaccurate LLM responses, hallucinations, biases, privacy leakage, and academic integrity issues. Participants emphasized the necessity of guidance and rules for the use of LLMs in higher education, including teaching digital literacy, rethinking education, and having cautious and contextual policies. We reflect on the ethical challenges and propose solutions.
- Open Access
- 20 December 2023
- Published by Bölcsészettudományi Kutatóközpont in Literatura
- Vol. 49 (3) , 303-323
A távoli olvasás (egyik) genealógiája
It has recently become common to describe all empirical approaches to literature as subfields of digital humanities. This essay argues that distant reading has a largely distinct genealogy stretching back many decades before the advent of the internet – a genealogy that is not for the most part centrally concerned with computers. It would be better to understand this field as a conversation between literary studies and social science, inititated by scholars like Raymond Williams and Janice Radway, and moving slowly toward an explicitly experimental method. Candor about the social-scientific dimension of distant reading is needed now, in order to refocus a research agenda that can drift into diffuse exploration of digital tools. Clarity on this topic might also reduce miscommunication between distant readers and digital humanists.
- 20 December 2023
- Published by Bölcsészettudományi Kutatóközpont in Literatura
- Vol. 49 (3) , 303-323
Open AccessA távoli olvasás (egyik) genealógiája
It has recently become common to describe all empirical approaches to literature as subfields of digital humanities. This essay argues that distant reading has a largely distinct genealogy stretching back many decades before the advent of the internet – a genealogy that is not for the most part centrally concerned with computers. It would be better to understand this field as a conversation between literary studies and social science, inititated by scholars like Raymond Williams and Janice Radway, and moving slowly toward an explicitly experimental method. Candor about the social-scientific dimension of distant reading is needed now, in order to refocus a research agenda that can drift into diffuse exploration of digital tools. Clarity on this topic might also reduce miscommunication between distant readers and digital humanists.
- 31 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal on Digital Libraries
- Vol. 25 (2) , 317-340
Complexities of leveraging user-generated book reviews for scholarly research: transiency, power dynamics, and cultural dependency
- 31 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal on Digital Libraries
- Vol. 25 (2) , 317-340
Complexities of leveraging user-generated book reviews for scholarly research: transiency, power dynamics, and cultural dependency
- 31 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cataloging & Classification Quarterly
- Vol. 61 (1) , 1-19
Descriptive Cataloging Issues for Non-Western Corpora: A Case Study of Late Imperial Chinese Books
Full-text digital libraries (DL) like the HathiTrust open new analytic opportunities for digital humanists and those studying language-specific corpora such as late imperial Chinese books. These analyses rely on DL metadata records to contextualize and validate findings. However, historic Anglo-American cataloging practices introduce difficulties. Our comparative case study of HathiTrust MARC records for Chinese (1,534), English (25,866), and German (7,872) books (the 1500s–1700s) reveals significant problems: data spread across fields; essential data lacunae; lack of normalization; and information transcribed from sources without translation nor explanation. Cataloging practices need updating to support scholars working with Chinese and other Asian materials.
- 31 December 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cataloging & Classification Quarterly
- Vol. 61 (1) , 1-19
Descriptive Cataloging Issues for Non-Western Corpora: A Case Study of Late Imperial Chinese Books
Full-text digital libraries (DL) like the HathiTrust open new analytic opportunities for digital humanists and those studying language-specific corpora such as late imperial Chinese books. These analyses rely on DL metadata records to contextualize and validate findings. However, historic Anglo-American cataloging practices introduce difficulties. Our comparative case study of HathiTrust MARC records for Chinese (1,534), English (25,866), and German (7,872) books (the 1500s–1700s) reveals significant problems: data spread across fields; essential data lacunae; lack of normalization; and information transcribed from sources without translation nor explanation. Cataloging practices need updating to support scholars working with Chinese and other Asian materials.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Society for Sociological Science in Sociological Science
- Vol. 9, 184-205
Cohort Succession Explains Most Change in Literary Culture
Many aspects of behavior are guided by dispositions that are relatively durable once formed. Political opinions and phonology, for instance, change largely through cohort succession. But evidence for cohort effects has been scarce in artistic and intellectual history; researchers in those fields more commonly explain change as an immediate response to recent innovations and events. We test these conflicting theories of change in a corpus of 10,830 works of fiction from 1880 to 1999 and find that slightly more than half (54.7 percent) of the variance explained by time is explained better by an author’s year of birth than by a book’s year of publication. Writing practices do change across an author’s career. But the pace of change declines steeply with age. This finding suggests that existing histories of literary culture have a large blind spot: the early experiences that form cohorts are pivotal but leave few traces in the historical record.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Society for Sociological Science in Sociological Science
- Vol. 9, 184-205
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessCohort Succession Explains Most Change in Literary Culture
Many aspects of behavior are guided by dispositions that are relatively durable once formed. Political opinions and phonology, for instance, change largely through cohort succession. But evidence for cohort effects has been scarce in artistic and intellectual history; researchers in those fields more commonly explain change as an immediate response to recent innovations and events. We test these conflicting theories of change in a corpus of 10,830 works of fiction from 1880 to 1999 and find that slightly more than half (54.7 percent) of the variance explained by time is explained better by an author’s year of birth than by a book’s year of publication. Writing practices do change across an author’s career. But the pace of change declines steeply with age. This finding suggests that existing histories of literary culture have a large blind spot: the early experiences that form cohorts are pivotal but leave few traces in the historical record.