FLFrederick Curtis Lubbe

Frederick Curtis Lubbe

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Frederick Curtis Lubbe has a total of 328 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Trade‐offs and bet‐hedging in clonal offspring allocation

    by F. Curtis Lubbe, Lars Götzenberger, Roswitha Schmickl, Kenneth Oberlander, Tomáš Procházka, Jitka Klimešová

    Reproduction is vital to maintain populations and species, yet because of finite resources, organisms often specialise in their reproductive allocation strategies, such as with many plants prioritising seed size or number (i.e. size/number trade‐off). Alternatively, plants may make multiple types of seeds, as seed heteromorphism, a form of bet‐hedging to increase offspring survival under variable environmental conditions. Those strategies are well described for seeds, but many plants also reproduce clonally, and such reproductive allocation strategies remain unknown for clonal offspring because of difficulties in measuring and standardising allocation to individual offspring across a large number of species. To better understand potential trends in clonal offspring allocation, we studied the southern African clade of the genus Oxalis , where mature offspring bulbs are physiologically distinct from the mother plant. We assessed number, size, protection and placement of clonal offspring for 104 species grown from individual bulbs in pots in a greenhouse. We also measured investment (as dry mass) in below‐ground support structures: spacer stems and roots, tunics and contractile roots. We found a trade‐off between size and number of clonal offspring, where plants produce fewer large bulbs and more small bulbs, similar to the well‐known trade‐off between seed size and number. We also identified a trade‐off in distribution versus protection of offspring bulbs, as indicated by greater offspring bulb production correlated with investment in below‐ground spacers. For two thirds of the species, individual parental bulbs placed offspring in multiple locations simultaneously, here identified as clonal offspring heteromorphism. Offspring bulb size also varied with depth, with individual plants producing relatively larger bulbs deeper in the soil and smaller bulbs closer to or above the soil surface. Synthesis . This is the first study assessing trends in offspring allocation and protection across a large set of species. These trends indicate multiple coordinated trade‐offs and potential bet‐hedging, implying that investment in clonal reproduction is resource‐limited and adapted for unpredictable environmental conditions.

  • Grassland bud and shoot demography depend on both amount and frequency of nitrogen addition

    by Jiatai Tian, Zhiming Zhang, Niwu Te, Jin Tao, Deliang Kong, Jinlei Zhu, Yunhai Zhang, F. Curtis Lubbe, Scott L. Collins, Wentao Luo, et al.

    The amount and frequency of atmospheric nitrogen (N) deposition have dramatically increased, profoundly influencing population regeneration, community composition and productivity in grasslands. Perennial species in grasslands primarily grow and expand clonally, yet it remains unclear how their below‐ground buds and above‐ground shoots respond to the amount and frequency of N deposition. We conducted a long‐term (2008–2022) N addition experiment in a semiarid grassland. The experiment included nine addition amounts (0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 10, 15, 20 and 50 g N m −2 year −1 ) and two addition frequencies: low frequency (twice per year) and high frequency (once per month). This allowed us to assess the interactive effects of N addition amount and frequency on bud density, shoot density and the ratio of bud to shoot density (meristem limitation index, MLI) in semiarid grasslands. We found a significant interaction between N addition amount and frequency on community bud and shoot densities. Community bud and shoot densities declined with increasing N amount under low addition frequency but remained stable under high addition frequency. However, community MLI was unchanged under low addition frequency but increased with increasing N amount under high addition frequency. Both N addition amount and frequency significantly altered the composition of community buds and shoots, with more pronounced effects under low versus high addition frequency. Bud and shoot densities and MLI declined with N amount under both addition frequencies for bunchgrasses. In contrast, rhizomatous grasses exhibited increased bud density and MLI under high N addition frequency, while shoot density remained unchanged regardless of addition frequency. These demographic responses did not alter above‐ground net primary productivity (ANPP) but shifted community composition toward greater dominance of rhizomatous grasses under N addition. Synthesis. These results suggest that grassland bud and shoot responses to N deposition depend on both the deposition amount and frequency. Commonly used low frequency N addition experiments may lead to inaccurate plant demographic and community responses to chronic N deposition.


  • Litter manipulation alters the belowground bud bank and aboveground shoot density in a temperate grassland

    by Jianqiang Qian, Jiatai Tian, Xiangyuan Zheng, Dongmei Li, F. Curtis Lubbe, Dan Liu, Junjie Yang, Jirong Cao, Qibing Wang, Zhiming Zhang


  • Top Cited Papers

    Drought intensity and duration interact to magnify losses in primary productivity

    by Timothy Ohlert, Melinda D. Smith, Scott L. Collins, Alan K. Knapp, Jeffrey S. Dukes, Osvaldo Sala, Kate D. Wilkins, Seth M. Munson, Maggie I. Anderson, Meghan L. Avolio, et al.

    As droughts become longer and more intense, impacts on terrestrial primary productivity are expected to increase progressively. Yet, some ecosystems appear to acclimate to multiyear drought, with constant or diminishing reductions in productivity as drought duration increases. We quantified the combined effects of drought duration and intensity on aboveground productivity in 74 grasslands and shrublands distributed globally. Ecosystem acclimation with multiyear drought was observed overall, except when droughts were extreme (i.e., ≤1-in-100-year likelihood of occurrence). Productivity losses after four consecutive years of extreme drought increased by ~2.5-fold compared with those of the first year. These results portend a foundational shift in ecosystem behavior if drought duration and intensity increase, from maintenance of reduced functioning over time to progressive and profound losses of productivity when droughts are extreme.


  • Capital and income breeders among herbs: how relative biomass allocation into a storage organ relates to clonal traits, phenology and environmental gradients

    by Timothy Harris, Andrea Kučerová, Martin Bitomský, Alena Bartušková, Frederick Curtis Lubbe, Jitka Klimešová

    Summary: Perennial herbs of seasonal climates invest carbon into belowground storage organs (e.g. rhizomes) to support growth when photosynthetic acquisition cannot cover demands. An alternative explanation interprets storage allocation as surplus carbon that is undeployable for growth when plants are limited by nutrients/water. We analysed relative investments to rhizomes to see to which of these explanations they align, and asked whether they scale with biomass of aboveground organs in individual species and whether clonal growth traits, phenology or environmental conditions explain investment among populations or species. We measured biomass of rhizomes, aboveground stems and leaves in 20 temperate herbaceous perennial species, each at two localities, establishing allometric relationships for pairs of organs. We correlated relative rhizome investment with clonal traits, environmental gradients and phenology, across species. For pairs of organs, biomass typically scales isometrically. Interspecific allocation differences are largely explained by phenology. Neither interspecific nor intraspecific differences were explained by clonal traits or environment. Storage organs of perennial herbs do not comprise deposition of carbon surplus, but receive greater allocation in capital breeders (early‐flowering), than among income breeders (late‐flowering) relying on acquisition during growing season. Capital and income breeders in plants deserve further examination of benefits/costs.


  • Open Access

    New opportunities for grassland species in warming temperate winters

    by F. Curtis Lubbe, Andrea Kučerová, Martin Bitomský, Jitka Klimešová

    Temperate winters are getting warmer, the length of the growing season is increasing and mid‐winter fluctuations of warm and freezing temperatures are more frequent. Although typically winter dormant, some herbaceous perennials can maintain or grow green leaves during the winter and more species may do so as winters become warmer. For wintergreen leaves to provide an advantage, they must be able to photosynthesize during the warm spells but also withstand freezing temperatures and fluctuations between the two conditions. To understand the leaf traits of wintergreen herbs, we studied three widely distributed perennial species: Bellis perennis , Plantago lanceolata and Trifolium repens . For contrast between winter and growing season leaves, we measured three common leaf economic traits (LDMC, SLA and leaf N content). To assess freezing tolerance, we measured the ice nucleation temperature and LT50 after frost exposure in winter leaves. To confirm photosynthetic ability, we measured photosynthetic efficiency ( Fv / Fm value) in winter and late spring. Additionally, we surveyed the green and dead leaf coverage for herbaceous species in a lawn community from winter to early summer (four surveys in total). We used our observations to determine phenological categories and compared them to historical observations of wintergreenness. All three species had denser leaves with lower nitrogen content in winter than in the growing season and relatively high tolerance of freezing temperatures (average of −8°C ice nucleation temperature and −15°C LT50). Both winter and growing season leaves were capable of photosynthesis, but the efficiency was greater for growing season leaves. In the community survey, a majority of the plant species had green leaves in winter, and many were without dead winter leaves. Many wintergreen herbs had previously been labelled ‘summer green’. With these initial investigations into the traits and phenology of wintergreen herbs, we confirm that wintergreen leaves have different traits from typical growing season leaves and are capable of both photosynthesis and freezing tolerance. Wintergreen herbs have a broad range of phenological strategies and differ from observations 20 years ago. In many temperate regions, winter is becoming a new growing season and thus should be included in phenological studies. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.


  • Open Access

    Ecology, ethology, and evolution in the Anthropocene

    by Matheus Sanita Lima, Frederick Curtis Lubbe, Sarah Helen Dias dos Santos, Stefane Saruhashi, Jorden Mikaela Maglov, Joseane Moreira Do Nascimento, Soren Zachary Coulson

    The 53rd Ontario Ecology, Ethology, and Evolution Colloquium (OE3C 2023) took place at Western University (London, Canada) on 25-27 May 2023, attracting 160 participants. This Meeting Review aims not only to recapitulate what was discussed during the event, but also to provide a brief synthesis of how biologists can move forward. The event was organised and run by graduate students and postdoctoral researchers from the Department of Biology at Western University. With three international keynote speakers, seventy talks, and fifty poster presentations, the OE3C 2023 spanned a wide range of contemporary research in Ecology, Ethology, and Evolution (“the 3 E's”). The colloquium theme was “Surviving the Anthropocene: future steps for the 3 E's under pressing planetary issues”, which was complemented by illustrations depicting the fauna and flora of the “Canadian Anthropocene”. Participants discussed what biologists and researchers can do regarding future climate and environmental catastrophes. The meeting culminated in a panel discussion comprising three climate change specialists who examined topics such as the Anthropocene and the Great acceleration, the living planet index, and carbon bombs. Although not exhaustive, these topics served as a starting point for the necessary discussions about how biologists can contribute to the fight for the survival of life on Earth.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Extreme drought impacts have been underestimated in grasslands and shrublands globally

    by Melinda D. Smith, Kate D. Wilkins, Martin C. Holdrege, Peter Wilfahrt, Scott L. Collins, Alan K. Knapp, Osvaldo E. Sala, Jeffrey S. Dukes, Richard P. Phillips, Laura Yahdjian, et al.

    Climate change is increasing the frequency and severity of short-term (~1 y) drought events—the most common duration of drought—globally. Yet the impact of this intensification of drought on ecosystem functioning remains poorly resolved. This is due in part to the widely disparate approaches ecologists have employed to study drought, variation in the severity and duration of drought studied, and differences among ecosystems in vegetation, edaphic and climatic attributes that can mediate drought impacts. To overcome these problems and better identify the factors that modulate drought responses, we used a coordinated distributed experiment to quantify the impact of short-term drought on grassland and shrubland ecosystems. With a standardized approach, we imposed ~a single year of drought at 100 sites on six continents. Here we show that loss of a foundational ecosystem function—aboveground net primary production (ANPP)—was 60% greater at sites that experienced statistically extreme drought (1-in-100-y event) vs. those sites where drought was nominal (historically more common) in magnitude (35% vs. 21%, respectively). This reduction in a key carbon cycle process with a single year of extreme drought greatly exceeds previously reported losses for grasslands and shrublands. Our global experiment also revealed high variability in drought response but that relative reductions in ANPP were greater in drier ecosystems and those with fewer plant species. Overall, our results demonstrate with unprecedented rigor that the global impacts of projected increases in drought severity have been significantly underestimated and that drier and less diverse sites are likely to be most vulnerable to extreme drought.


  • Plantness, Animalness, and Humanness: plant placement within animacy and adjacent scales

    by Frederick Curtis Lubbe, Kenny G. Castillo Alfonzo

    Animacy is an important framework through which humans view and categorize the world, but many objects do not easily fit within this scale. Plants are unique because they are very familiar to humans, yet the features and traits relevant for placement within the animacy scale are generally poorly understood by the public. Animacy occurs at three levels, with the inherent attributes of the object (biology), how they are perceived (cognition), and how they are expressed in languages (linguistics). Animacy is dependent on qualification and perception as alive, mobile, and intentional. In the absence of visible movement, classification is dependent on featural attributes indicating mobility or placement in a group recognized as animate (animalness). Plants have complicated bodies whose forms and structures are frequently clear representations of their life history and function (plantness), more than many animals, yet these signs of movement and activity are rarely recognized. The animacy scale may be more closely based on human similarity (humanness) with humans as the peak of life, mobility, and intentionality. As humans, we can have an anthropocentric viewpoint, rendering plants as scenery or utility, or use anthropomorphic interaction to better understand and recognize the dynamic lives of plants. The goal of this review is to compare the current evidence on the placement of plants within animacy and adjacent scales with the biology and habit of land plants, to better understand human perception and behaviour, and work with this process to educate and inform people about the complex lives of plants.


  • Is the amount of parenchyma in storage organs a good predictor of non-structural carbohydrate storage in herbs?

    by Alexandre Ferraro, F. Curtis Lubbe, Martin Bitomský, Alena Bartušková, Michael Bartoš, Štěpán Janeček, Jana Martínková, Jitka Klimešová