Jaap van Schaik
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Jaap van Schaik has a total of 56 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gabriella Krivek
Zoological Institute and Museum, Applied Zoology and Nature Conservation University of Greifswald Greifswald Germany
5 shared publications - Gerald Kerth
Applied Zoology and Nature Conservation, Zoological Institute and Museum University of Greifswald Greifswald Germany
5 shared publications G. Kerth
Greifswald University
4 shared publicationsRené Janssen
Bionet Natuuronderzoek
3 shared publications- Alexander Scheuerlein
Applied Zoology and Nature Conservation, Zoological Institute and Museum, University of Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany
2 shared publications Anne-Jifke Haarsma
Animal Ecology & Ecophysiology group, Institute for Water and Wetland research, Radboud University Nijmegen, P.O. Box 9010, 6500GL Nijmegen, The Netherlands
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Mammal Review
- Vol. 56 (3)
Long‐Term Individual‐Based Monitoring in Bat Conservation: Insights From Automated PIT ‐Tag Monitoring
Background: The importance of long‐term, individual‐based field studies in answering key conservation questions is widely recognised. However, such studies are rare in bats due to the challenges involved. Aims: This review summarises current knowledge on the outcomes of long‐term, individual‐based monitoring for bat conservation, focusing on data generated by automated passive integrated transponder (PIT) tag monitoring. Methods: We reviewed the literature on long‐term, individual‐based bat monitoring studies for conservation purposes, focusing on automated PIT‐tag monitoring. We performed targeted literature searches on statistical tools for analysing individual‐based data collected using automated systems, and on the challenges and opportunities associated with these methods. Finally, we present two case studies, using information from our own long‐term automated PIT‐tag monitoring of five bat species in Germany. Results: We found that only a limited number of bat species were monitored using automatic PIT‐tag loggers for more than 3 years. Almost all of these species are temperate‐zone bats. Monitoring was performed at summer roosts, including buildings, caves, bat boxes and tree cavities, as well as hibernacula. The respective studies investigated various conservation‐relevant variables, including movement between roosts, demographic parameters such as survival and reproduction, and population trends. Our own research demonstrates how this method can provide conservation‐relevant information that would not have been obtained using count data or classical capture‐mark‐recapture techniques, which require regular handling of bats. Conclusions: Long‐term, individual‐based monitoring remains challenging and resource‐intensive. Automated PIT‐tag monitoring offers new possibilities for long‐term bat monitoring by facilitating the collection of highly relevant conservation data.
- 10 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Mammal Review
- Vol. 56 (3)
Open AccessLong‐Term Individual‐Based Monitoring in Bat Conservation: Insights From Automated PIT ‐Tag Monitoring
Background: The importance of long‐term, individual‐based field studies in answering key conservation questions is widely recognised. However, such studies are rare in bats due to the challenges involved. Aims: This review summarises current knowledge on the outcomes of long‐term, individual‐based monitoring for bat conservation, focusing on data generated by automated passive integrated transponder (PIT) tag monitoring. Methods: We reviewed the literature on long‐term, individual‐based bat monitoring studies for conservation purposes, focusing on automated PIT‐tag monitoring. We performed targeted literature searches on statistical tools for analysing individual‐based data collected using automated systems, and on the challenges and opportunities associated with these methods. Finally, we present two case studies, using information from our own long‐term automated PIT‐tag monitoring of five bat species in Germany. Results: We found that only a limited number of bat species were monitored using automatic PIT‐tag loggers for more than 3 years. Almost all of these species are temperate‐zone bats. Monitoring was performed at summer roosts, including buildings, caves, bat boxes and tree cavities, as well as hibernacula. The respective studies investigated various conservation‐relevant variables, including movement between roosts, demographic parameters such as survival and reproduction, and population trends. Our own research demonstrates how this method can provide conservation‐relevant information that would not have been obtained using count data or classical capture‐mark‐recapture techniques, which require regular handling of bats. Conclusions: Long‐term, individual‐based monitoring remains challenging and resource‐intensive. Automated PIT‐tag monitoring offers new possibilities for long‐term bat monitoring by facilitating the collection of highly relevant conservation data.
- Open Access
- 2 October 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (10) , e70531
One Species Hibernates Shorter, the Other Longer: Rapid but Opposing Responses to Warming Climate in Two Sympatric Bat Species
The timing of hibernation represents a key seasonal transition in the annual cycle of hibernators, directly impacting their survival and reproductive success. Ongoing climate change affects many of the factors that influence hibernation phenology, such as weather patterns, food availability and the timing of mating and reproduction. The extent to which individuals should adjust their hibernation phenology in response is likely to vary between species, sexes and age classes. Consequently, long‐term, individualised datasets are essential for capturing individual responses to climate change and understanding the underlying mechanisms. However, such datasets remain exceedingly rare for wild hibernators. Using 13 years of individual‐level RFID‐logging data from over 4000 marked bats, we discovered strikingly different shifts in hibernation phenology in two sympatric species. While Myotis nattereri shortened its hibernation period with warming winters, Myotis daubentonii surprisingly prolonged its hibernation duration. These opposing trends were primarily driven by shifts in hibernation entry in autumn. Within both species, phenological shifts varied by sex and age, with adult males exhibiting the most pronounced changes. In M. daubentonii , adult males extended the duration of hibernation by 1.8 days/year, equating to almost a full month over the study period. In M. nattereri , adult males reduced the duration of hibernation by 2.3 days/year, resulting in a one‐third decrease in total hibernation duration. These remarkable shifts were strongly correlated with autumn temperatures: for each 1°C rise, hibernation entry in M. daubentonii advanced by 9.3 days, whereas in M. nattereri it was delayed by 6.2 days. Our results highlight that hibernation phenology can shift rapidly and in unforeseen, species‐specific ways in response to climate change. As mismatches between hibernation timing and prey availability can impact survival and reproduction, these phenological shifts could significantly affect individual fitness and population viability.
- 2 October 2025
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 31 (10) , e70531
Open AccessOne Species Hibernates Shorter, the Other Longer: Rapid but Opposing Responses to Warming Climate in Two Sympatric Bat Species
The timing of hibernation represents a key seasonal transition in the annual cycle of hibernators, directly impacting their survival and reproductive success. Ongoing climate change affects many of the factors that influence hibernation phenology, such as weather patterns, food availability and the timing of mating and reproduction. The extent to which individuals should adjust their hibernation phenology in response is likely to vary between species, sexes and age classes. Consequently, long‐term, individualised datasets are essential for capturing individual responses to climate change and understanding the underlying mechanisms. However, such datasets remain exceedingly rare for wild hibernators. Using 13 years of individual‐level RFID‐logging data from over 4000 marked bats, we discovered strikingly different shifts in hibernation phenology in two sympatric species. While Myotis nattereri shortened its hibernation period with warming winters, Myotis daubentonii surprisingly prolonged its hibernation duration. These opposing trends were primarily driven by shifts in hibernation entry in autumn. Within both species, phenological shifts varied by sex and age, with adult males exhibiting the most pronounced changes. In M. daubentonii , adult males extended the duration of hibernation by 1.8 days/year, equating to almost a full month over the study period. In M. nattereri , adult males reduced the duration of hibernation by 2.3 days/year, resulting in a one‐third decrease in total hibernation duration. These remarkable shifts were strongly correlated with autumn temperatures: for each 1°C rise, hibernation entry in M. daubentonii advanced by 9.3 days, whereas in M. nattereri it was delayed by 6.2 days. Our results highlight that hibernation phenology can shift rapidly and in unforeseen, species‐specific ways in response to climate change. As mismatches between hibernation timing and prey availability can impact survival and reproduction, these phenological shifts could significantly affect individual fitness and population viability.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Mammalian Biology
- Vol. 105 (4) , 437-448
Diverse but declining? Population genetic structure and genetic diversity of Nathusius’ pipistrelle along the Dutch coastline during the autumn migration period
Migratory bats are experiencing substantial increases in mortality risk from wind energy developments, but data on their migratory behavior and population dynamics are often lacking. Here, we develop a novel microsatellite panel for one such migratory bat species, the Nathusius’ pipistrelle (Pipistrellus nathusii), and apply it to 448 samples collected at stopover sites along the Dutch coast during autumn migration over four consecutive years. With this dataset, we assessed whether the population is genetically sub-structured, characterize its current genetic diversity, and evaluate whether mothers guide their offspring during migration. We found that the population is panmictic and diverse, with an effective population size estimate that cannot be distinguished from infinite. However, we also observed a consistent decline in allelic richness across the sampling period, as well as a heterozygote excess in individuals sampled as juveniles, both suggesting an ongoing population decline. We did not find any parent-offspring pairs in our dataset, which included 30 box captures where adult female and juvenile bats were found roosting together, suggesting that juvenile bats do not follow their mothers during their first migration. Our findings provide an initial characterization and baseline measure of genetic diversity for the Nathusius’ pipistrelle that can be used as a reference for subsequent studies and systematic efforts to monitor the genetic diversity of the species. Given that monitoring population trends of migratory bat species with traditional methods remains challenging, such tracking of genetic diversity may offer a valuable proxy by which to observe substantial population declines if they occur.
- 13 March 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Mammalian Biology
- Vol. 105 (4) , 437-448
Open AccessDiverse but declining? Population genetic structure and genetic diversity of Nathusius’ pipistrelle along the Dutch coastline during the autumn migration period
Migratory bats are experiencing substantial increases in mortality risk from wind energy developments, but data on their migratory behavior and population dynamics are often lacking. Here, we develop a novel microsatellite panel for one such migratory bat species, the Nathusius’ pipistrelle (Pipistrellus nathusii), and apply it to 448 samples collected at stopover sites along the Dutch coast during autumn migration over four consecutive years. With this dataset, we assessed whether the population is genetically sub-structured, characterize its current genetic diversity, and evaluate whether mothers guide their offspring during migration. We found that the population is panmictic and diverse, with an effective population size estimate that cannot be distinguished from infinite. However, we also observed a consistent decline in allelic richness across the sampling period, as well as a heterozygote excess in individuals sampled as juveniles, both suggesting an ongoing population decline. We did not find any parent-offspring pairs in our dataset, which included 30 box captures where adult female and juvenile bats were found roosting together, suggesting that juvenile bats do not follow their mothers during their first migration. Our findings provide an initial characterization and baseline measure of genetic diversity for the Nathusius’ pipistrelle that can be used as a reference for subsequent studies and systematic efforts to monitor the genetic diversity of the species. Given that monitoring population trends of migratory bat species with traditional methods remains challenging, such tracking of genetic diversity may offer a valuable proxy by which to observe substantial population declines if they occur.
- Open Access
- 17 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Diverse but declining? Population genetic structure and genetic diversity of Nathusius’ pipistrelle along the Dutch coastline during the autumn migration period
Migratory bats are experiencing substantial increases in mortality risk from wind energy developments, but data on their migratory behavior and population dynamics are often lacking. Here, we develop a novel microsatellite panel for one such migratory bat species, the Nathusius’ pipistrelle (Pipistrellus nathusii), and apply it to 448 samples collected at stopover sites along the Dutch coast during autumn migration over four consecutive years. With this dataset, we assessed whether the population is genetically sub-structured, characterize its current genetic diversity, and evaluate whether mothers guide their offspring during migration. We found that the population is panmictic and diverse, with an effective population size estimate that cannot be distinguished from infinite. However, we also observed a consistent decline in allelic richness across the sampling period, as well as a heterozygote excess in individuals sampled as juveniles, both suggesting an ongoing population decline. We did not find any parent-offspring pairs in our dataset, which included 30 box captures where adult female and juvenile bats were found roosting together, suggesting that juvenile bats do not follow their mothers during their first migration. Our findings provide an initial characterization and baseline measure of genetic diversity for the Nathusius’ pipistrelle that can be used as a reference for subsequent studies and systematic efforts to monitor the genetic diversity of the species. Given that monitoring population trends of migratory bat species with traditional methods remains challenging, such tracking of genetic diversity may offer a valuable proxy by which to observe substantial population declines if they occur.
- 17 December 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessDiverse but declining? Population genetic structure and genetic diversity of Nathusius’ pipistrelle along the Dutch coastline during the autumn migration period
Migratory bats are experiencing substantial increases in mortality risk from wind energy developments, but data on their migratory behavior and population dynamics are often lacking. Here, we develop a novel microsatellite panel for one such migratory bat species, the Nathusius’ pipistrelle (Pipistrellus nathusii), and apply it to 448 samples collected at stopover sites along the Dutch coast during autumn migration over four consecutive years. With this dataset, we assessed whether the population is genetically sub-structured, characterize its current genetic diversity, and evaluate whether mothers guide their offspring during migration. We found that the population is panmictic and diverse, with an effective population size estimate that cannot be distinguished from infinite. However, we also observed a consistent decline in allelic richness across the sampling period, as well as a heterozygote excess in individuals sampled as juveniles, both suggesting an ongoing population decline. We did not find any parent-offspring pairs in our dataset, which included 30 box captures where adult female and juvenile bats were found roosting together, suggesting that juvenile bats do not follow their mothers during their first migration. Our findings provide an initial characterization and baseline measure of genetic diversity for the Nathusius’ pipistrelle that can be used as a reference for subsequent studies and systematic efforts to monitor the genetic diversity of the species. Given that monitoring population trends of migratory bat species with traditional methods remains challenging, such tracking of genetic diversity may offer a valuable proxy by which to observe substantial population declines if they occur.
- Open Access
- 20 June 2023
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 29 (17) , 4939-4948
Heat over heritability: Increasing body size in response to global warming is not stabilized by genetic effects in Bechstein's bats
How well populations can cope with global warming will often depend on the evolutionary potential and plasticity of their temperature‐sensitive, fitness‐relevant traits. In Bechstein's bats (Myotis bechsteinii), body size has increased over the last decades in response to warmer summers. If this trend continues it may threaten populations as larger females exhibit higher mortality. To assess the evolutionary potential of body size, we applied a Bayesian ‘animal model’ to estimate additive genetic variance, heritability and evolvability of body size, based on a 25‐year pedigree of 332 wild females. Both heritability and additive genetic variance were reduced in hot summers compared to average and cold summers, while evolvability of body size was generally low. This suggests that the observed increase in body size was mostly driven by phenotypic plasticity. Thus, if warm summers continue to become more frequent, body size likely increases further and the resulting fitness loss could threaten populations.
- 20 June 2023
- Published by Wiley in Global Change Biology
- Vol. 29 (17) , 4939-4948
Open AccessHeat over heritability: Increasing body size in response to global warming is not stabilized by genetic effects in Bechstein's bats
How well populations can cope with global warming will often depend on the evolutionary potential and plasticity of their temperature‐sensitive, fitness‐relevant traits. In Bechstein's bats (Myotis bechsteinii), body size has increased over the last decades in response to warmer summers. If this trend continues it may threaten populations as larger females exhibit higher mortality. To assess the evolutionary potential of body size, we applied a Bayesian ‘animal model’ to estimate additive genetic variance, heritability and evolvability of body size, based on a 25‐year pedigree of 332 wild females. Both heritability and additive genetic variance were reduced in hot summers compared to average and cold summers, while evolvability of body size was generally low. This suggests that the observed increase in body size was mostly driven by phenotypic plasticity. Thus, if warm summers continue to become more frequent, body size likely increases further and the resulting fitness loss could threaten populations.
- Open Access
- 9 May 2023
- Published by Wiley in Remote Sensing in Ecology and Conservation
- Vol. 9 (6) , 759-774
BatNet: a deep learning‐based tool for automated bat species identification from camera trap images
Automated monitoring technologies can increase the efficiency of ecological data collection and support data‐driven conservation. Camera traps coupled with infrared light barriers can be used to monitor temperate‐zone bat assemblages at underground hibernacula, where thousands of individuals of multiple species can aggregate in winter. However, the broad‐scale adoption of such photo‐monitoring techniques is limited by the time‐consuming bottleneck of manual image processing. Here, we present BatNet, an open‐source, deep learning‐based tool for automated identification of 13 European bat species from camera trap images. BatNet includes a user‐friendly graphical interface, where it can be retrained to identify new bat species or to create site‐specific models to improve detection accuracy at new sites. Model accuracy was evaluated on images from both trained and untrained sites, and in an ecological context, where community‐ and species‐level metrics (species diversity, relative abundance, and species‐level activity patterns) were compared between human experts and BatNet. At trained sites, model performance was high across all species (F1‐score: 0.98–1). At untrained sites, overall classification accuracy remained high (96.7–98.2%), when camera placement was comparable to the training images (45° angle), retraining the detector model with 500 site‐specific annotations achieved an accuracy of over 95% at all sites. In the ecological case study, all investigated metrics were nearly identical between human experts and BatNet. Finally, we exemplify the ability to retrain BatNet to identify a new bat species, achieving an F1‐score of 0.99 while maintaining high classification accuracy for all original species. BatNet can be implemented directly to scale up the deployment of camera traps in Europe and enhance bat population monitoring. Moreover, the pretrained model can serve as a baseline for transfer learning to automatize the image‐based identification of bat species worldwide.
- 9 May 2023
- Published by Wiley in Remote Sensing in Ecology and Conservation
- Vol. 9 (6) , 759-774
Open AccessBatNet: a deep learning‐based tool for automated bat species identification from camera trap images
Automated monitoring technologies can increase the efficiency of ecological data collection and support data‐driven conservation. Camera traps coupled with infrared light barriers can be used to monitor temperate‐zone bat assemblages at underground hibernacula, where thousands of individuals of multiple species can aggregate in winter. However, the broad‐scale adoption of such photo‐monitoring techniques is limited by the time‐consuming bottleneck of manual image processing. Here, we present BatNet, an open‐source, deep learning‐based tool for automated identification of 13 European bat species from camera trap images. BatNet includes a user‐friendly graphical interface, where it can be retrained to identify new bat species or to create site‐specific models to improve detection accuracy at new sites. Model accuracy was evaluated on images from both trained and untrained sites, and in an ecological context, where community‐ and species‐level metrics (species diversity, relative abundance, and species‐level activity patterns) were compared between human experts and BatNet. At trained sites, model performance was high across all species (F1‐score: 0.98–1). At untrained sites, overall classification accuracy remained high (96.7–98.2%), when camera placement was comparable to the training images (45° angle), retraining the detector model with 500 site‐specific annotations achieved an accuracy of over 95% at all sites. In the ecological case study, all investigated metrics were nearly identical between human experts and BatNet. Finally, we exemplify the ability to retrain BatNet to identify a new bat species, achieving an F1‐score of 0.99 while maintaining high classification accuracy for all original species. BatNet can be implemented directly to scale up the deployment of camera traps in Europe and enhance bat population monitoring. Moreover, the pretrained model can serve as a baseline for transfer learning to automatize the image‐based identification of bat species worldwide.
- Open Access
- 12 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 5 (3) , 403-416
How to quantify factors degrading DNA in the environment and predict degradation for effective sampling design
Extra‐organismal DNA (eoDNA) from material left behind by organisms (noninvasive DNA, e.g., feces, hair) or from environmental samples (eDNA, e.g., water, soil) is a valuable source of genetic information. However, the relatively low quality and quantity of eoDNA, which can be further degraded by environmental factors, results in reduced amplification and sequencing success. This is often compensated for through cost‐ and time‐intensive replications of genotyping/sequencing procedures. Therefore, system‐ and site‐specific quantifications of environmental degradation are needed to maximize sampling efficiency (e.g., fewer replicates, shorter sampling durations), and to improve species detection and abundance estimates. Using 10 environmentally diverse bat roosts as a case study, we developed a robust modeling pipeline to quantify the environmental factors degrading eoDNA, predict eoDNA quality, and estimate sampling‐site‐specific ideal exposure duration. Maximum humidity was the strongest eoDNA‐degrading factor, followed by exposure duration and then maximum temperature. We also found a positive effect when hottest days occurred later. The strength of this effect fell between the strength of the effects of exposure duration and maximum temperature. With those predictors and information on sampling period (before or after offspring were born), we reliably predicted mean eoDNA quality per sampling visit at new sites with a mean squared error of 0.0349. Site‐specific simulations revealed that reducing exposure duration to 2–8 days could substantially improve eoDNA quality for future sampling. Our pipeline identified high humidity and temperature as strong drivers of eoDNA degradation even in the absence of rain and direct sunlight. Furthermore, we outline the pipeline's utility for other systems and study goals, such as estimating sample age, improving eDNA‐based species detection, and increasing the accuracy of abundance estimates.
- 12 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 5 (3) , 403-416
Open AccessHow to quantify factors degrading DNA in the environment and predict degradation for effective sampling design
Extra‐organismal DNA (eoDNA) from material left behind by organisms (noninvasive DNA, e.g., feces, hair) or from environmental samples (eDNA, e.g., water, soil) is a valuable source of genetic information. However, the relatively low quality and quantity of eoDNA, which can be further degraded by environmental factors, results in reduced amplification and sequencing success. This is often compensated for through cost‐ and time‐intensive replications of genotyping/sequencing procedures. Therefore, system‐ and site‐specific quantifications of environmental degradation are needed to maximize sampling efficiency (e.g., fewer replicates, shorter sampling durations), and to improve species detection and abundance estimates. Using 10 environmentally diverse bat roosts as a case study, we developed a robust modeling pipeline to quantify the environmental factors degrading eoDNA, predict eoDNA quality, and estimate sampling‐site‐specific ideal exposure duration. Maximum humidity was the strongest eoDNA‐degrading factor, followed by exposure duration and then maximum temperature. We also found a positive effect when hottest days occurred later. The strength of this effect fell between the strength of the effects of exposure duration and maximum temperature. With those predictors and information on sampling period (before or after offspring were born), we reliably predicted mean eoDNA quality per sampling visit at new sites with a mean squared error of 0.0349. Site‐specific simulations revealed that reducing exposure duration to 2–8 days could substantially improve eoDNA quality for future sampling. Our pipeline identified high humidity and temperature as strong drivers of eoDNA degradation even in the absence of rain and direct sunlight. Furthermore, we outline the pipeline's utility for other systems and study goals, such as estimating sample age, improving eDNA‐based species detection, and increasing the accuracy of abundance estimates.
- Open Access
- 13 February 2023
- Published by Wiley in Animal Conservation
- Vol. 26 (5) , 701-713
Counting in the dark: estimating population size and trends of bat assemblages at hibernacula using infrared light barriers
Accurate population estimates are crucial to developing successful conservation policy, but the underlying data remain difficult to collect for many taxa. This is especially true for elusive species, such as temperate‐zone bats, where visual counts in hibernacula underestimate their population to an unknown extent. Infrared light barriers that count all entering and exiting bats at the entrance of a hibernaculum could offer a more accurate alternative for bat population monitoring. We used infrared video recordings to quantify light barrier accuracy (i.e., concordance between light barrier and video registration of entries and exits) at five hibernacula over 30 weeks during autumn and spring. Subsequently, we developed a standardized methodology to estimate light barrier‐based population sizes based on the number of emerging bats in spring, and compared these estimates to visual counts at 12 sites. Finally, we calculated confidence intervals around the estimated population sizes, and used these to evaluate population trends using 6‐year‐long light barrier datasets from four sites. Light barrier accuracy varied based on the model and precise location of the installation, with the best combination achieving near‐perfect accuracy across the entire emergence phase. When compared to the resulting light barrier‐based population estimates, winter hibernation counts markedly underestimated population totals, recovering less than 10% of the bats at the most complex sites. Moreover, light barrier‐based population trends showed regional patterns of growth and decline, which were not evident in the visual counts. This study demonstrates that light barriers can estimate the population size and trends of bat assemblages with unprecedented accuracy, even at large, complex, or inaccessible hibernacula that cannot be precisely assessed with visual hibernation counts. Installing light barriers at a representative network of sites, where their installation does not require large‐scale entrance modifications, has the potential to revolutionize bat monitoring and contribute to data‐driven conservation.
- 13 February 2023
- Published by Wiley in Animal Conservation
- Vol. 26 (5) , 701-713
Open AccessCounting in the dark: estimating population size and trends of bat assemblages at hibernacula using infrared light barriers
Accurate population estimates are crucial to developing successful conservation policy, but the underlying data remain difficult to collect for many taxa. This is especially true for elusive species, such as temperate‐zone bats, where visual counts in hibernacula underestimate their population to an unknown extent. Infrared light barriers that count all entering and exiting bats at the entrance of a hibernaculum could offer a more accurate alternative for bat population monitoring. We used infrared video recordings to quantify light barrier accuracy (i.e., concordance between light barrier and video registration of entries and exits) at five hibernacula over 30 weeks during autumn and spring. Subsequently, we developed a standardized methodology to estimate light barrier‐based population sizes based on the number of emerging bats in spring, and compared these estimates to visual counts at 12 sites. Finally, we calculated confidence intervals around the estimated population sizes, and used these to evaluate population trends using 6‐year‐long light barrier datasets from four sites. Light barrier accuracy varied based on the model and precise location of the installation, with the best combination achieving near‐perfect accuracy across the entire emergence phase. When compared to the resulting light barrier‐based population estimates, winter hibernation counts markedly underestimated population totals, recovering less than 10% of the bats at the most complex sites. Moreover, light barrier‐based population trends showed regional patterns of growth and decline, which were not evident in the visual counts. This study demonstrates that light barriers can estimate the population size and trends of bat assemblages with unprecedented accuracy, even at large, complex, or inaccessible hibernacula that cannot be precisely assessed with visual hibernation counts. Installing light barriers at a representative network of sites, where their installation does not require large‐scale entrance modifications, has the potential to revolutionize bat monitoring and contribute to data‐driven conservation.
- Open Access
The risk faced by the early bat: individual plasticity and mortality costs of the timing of spring departure after hibernation
Hibernation is a widespread adaptation in animals to seasonally changing environmental conditions. In the face of global anthropogenic change, information about plastic adjustments to environmental conditions and associated mortality costs are urgently needed to assess population persistence of hibernating species. Here, we used a five‐year data set of 1047 RFID‐tagged individuals from two bat species, Myotis nattereri and Myotis daubentonii that were automatically recorded each time they entered or left a hibernaculum. Because the two species differ in foraging strategy and activity pattern during winter, we expected species–specific responses in the timing of hibernation relative to environmental conditions, as well as different mortality costs of early departure from the hibernaculum in spring. Applying mixed‐effects modelling, we disentangled population‐level and individual‐level plasticity in the timing of departure. To estimate mortality costs of early departure, we used both a capture mark recapture analysis and a novel approach that takes into account individual exposure times to mortality outside the hibernaculum. We found that the timing of departure varied between species as well as among and within individuals, and was plastically adjusted to large‐scale weather conditions as measured by the NAO (North Atlantic Oscillation) index. Individuals of M. nattereri , which can exploit milder temperatures for foraging during winter, tuned departure more closely to the NAO index than individuals of M. daubentonii, which do not hunt during winter. Both analytical approaches used to estimate mortality costs showed that early departing individuals were less likely to survive until the subsequent hibernation period than individuals that departed later. Overall, our study demonstrates that individuals of long‐lived hibernating bat species have the potential to plastically adjust to changing climatic conditions, although the potential for adjustment differs between species.
Open AccessThe risk faced by the early bat: individual plasticity and mortality costs of the timing of spring departure after hibernation
Hibernation is a widespread adaptation in animals to seasonally changing environmental conditions. In the face of global anthropogenic change, information about plastic adjustments to environmental conditions and associated mortality costs are urgently needed to assess population persistence of hibernating species. Here, we used a five‐year data set of 1047 RFID‐tagged individuals from two bat species, Myotis nattereri and Myotis daubentonii that were automatically recorded each time they entered or left a hibernaculum. Because the two species differ in foraging strategy and activity pattern during winter, we expected species–specific responses in the timing of hibernation relative to environmental conditions, as well as different mortality costs of early departure from the hibernaculum in spring. Applying mixed‐effects modelling, we disentangled population‐level and individual‐level plasticity in the timing of departure. To estimate mortality costs of early departure, we used both a capture mark recapture analysis and a novel approach that takes into account individual exposure times to mortality outside the hibernaculum. We found that the timing of departure varied between species as well as among and within individuals, and was plastically adjusted to large‐scale weather conditions as measured by the NAO (North Atlantic Oscillation) index. Individuals of M. nattereri , which can exploit milder temperatures for foraging during winter, tuned departure more closely to the NAO index than individuals of M. daubentonii, which do not hunt during winter. Both analytical approaches used to estimate mortality costs showed that early departing individuals were less likely to survive until the subsequent hibernation period than individuals that departed later. Overall, our study demonstrates that individuals of long‐lived hibernating bat species have the potential to plastically adjust to changing climatic conditions, although the potential for adjustment differs between species.
- Open Access
- 27 October 2021
- Published by Wiley in Remote Sensing in Ecology and Conservation
- Vol. 8 (3) , 284-296
Camera traps with white flash are a minimally invasive method for long‐term bat monitoring
Camera traps are an increasingly popular survey tool for ecological research and biodiversity conservation, but studies investigating their impact on focal individuals have been limited to only a few mammal species. In this context, echolocating bats are particularly interesting as they rely less on vision for navigation, yet show a strong negative reaction to constant illumination. At hibernacula, camera traps with white flash could offer an efficient alternative method for monitoring threatened bat species, but the potential negative impact of white flash on bat behavior is unknown. Here, we investigate the effect of camera traps emitting white flash at four hibernation sites fitted with infrared light barriers, infrared video cameras, and acoustic recorders over 16 weeks. At each site, the flash was turned off every second week. We quantified whether flash affected (1) nightly bat passes using generalized linear mixed models, (2) flight direction of entering bats using permutational multivariate analyses, and (3) latency of the first echolocation call after the camera trap trigger using randomization tests. Additionally, we quantified and corrected for the potential impact of confounding factors, such as weather and social interactions. Overall, white flash did not influence short‐ or long‐term bat activity, flight direction or echolocation behavior. A decrease in nightly bat activity was observed with an increasing proportion of hours with rain. Moreover, flight direction was affected by the presence of other bats, likely due to chasing and avoidance behavior. Our findings highlight the potential of camera traps with white flash triggered by infrared light barriers as a minimally invasive method for long‐term bat population monitoring and observation of species‐specific phenology. Such automated monitoring technologies can improve our understanding of long‐term population dynamics across a wide range of spatial‐temporal scales and taxa and consequently, contribute to data‐driven wildlife conservation and management.
- 27 October 2021
- Published by Wiley in Remote Sensing in Ecology and Conservation
- Vol. 8 (3) , 284-296
Open AccessCamera traps with white flash are a minimally invasive method for long‐term bat monitoring
Camera traps are an increasingly popular survey tool for ecological research and biodiversity conservation, but studies investigating their impact on focal individuals have been limited to only a few mammal species. In this context, echolocating bats are particularly interesting as they rely less on vision for navigation, yet show a strong negative reaction to constant illumination. At hibernacula, camera traps with white flash could offer an efficient alternative method for monitoring threatened bat species, but the potential negative impact of white flash on bat behavior is unknown. Here, we investigate the effect of camera traps emitting white flash at four hibernation sites fitted with infrared light barriers, infrared video cameras, and acoustic recorders over 16 weeks. At each site, the flash was turned off every second week. We quantified whether flash affected (1) nightly bat passes using generalized linear mixed models, (2) flight direction of entering bats using permutational multivariate analyses, and (3) latency of the first echolocation call after the camera trap trigger using randomization tests. Additionally, we quantified and corrected for the potential impact of confounding factors, such as weather and social interactions. Overall, white flash did not influence short‐ or long‐term bat activity, flight direction or echolocation behavior. A decrease in nightly bat activity was observed with an increasing proportion of hours with rain. Moreover, flight direction was affected by the presence of other bats, likely due to chasing and avoidance behavior. Our findings highlight the potential of camera traps with white flash triggered by infrared light barriers as a minimally invasive method for long‐term bat population monitoring and observation of species‐specific phenology. Such automated monitoring technologies can improve our understanding of long‐term population dynamics across a wide range of spatial‐temporal scales and taxa and consequently, contribute to data‐driven wildlife conservation and management.