Peter Ian Alexander Kinnell
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Peter Ian Alexander Kinnell has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
P I A Kinnell
Faculty of Science and Technology
2 shared publicationsP. H. Walker
2 shared publicationsA. J. Moss
1 shared publication- Bofu Yu
School of Engineering and Built Environment, Griffith University, Nathan, Australia
1 shared publication C. Di Stefano
Dipartimento dei Sistemi Agro-Ambientali, Università degli Studi, Viale delle Scienze, 90128, Palermo, Italy
1 shared publicationD. Cummings
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Soils and Sediments
- Vol. 25 (9) , 2626-2633
A Comment on “Empirical modelling of soil erosion using unit plot data at Sparacia experimental area (southern Italy)”
Purpose: To comment on the results presented by Pampalone et al. J Soils Sediments 24(6) 2535-47, Pampalone et al., J Soils Sediments 24:2535–47, 2024 on the effects of slope length and gradient on average annual soil losses over 5 years at the Sparacia experimental area in southern Italy. Methods: Analysis of erosion data presented by Pampalone et al J Soils Sediments 24(6) 2535-47, Pampalone et al., J Soils Sediments 24:2535–47, 2024 in respect to the relationships between soil loss per unit EI 30 and slope length and gradient. Results: The relationships between soil loss per unit EI 30 and slope length and gradient for the experiments reported by Pampalone et al. J Soils Sediments 24(6) 2535-47, Pampalone et al., J Soils Sediments 24:2535–47, 2024 differ appreciably from those used by the RUSLE. Contrary to assumptions underpinning USLE-based models, runoff ratios at Sparacia vary with slope length and gradient. Conclusions: Variations in runoff ratios with slope length and gradient cause discrepancies between the effects of topography at Sparacia and equations normally used to account for the effects of topography in USLE-based models. The number of erosion events reported by Pampalone et al. J Soils Sediments 24(6) 2535-47, Pampalone et al., J Soils Sediments 24:2535–47, 2024 may not be sufficient to make definitive conclusions on how erosion varies with slope length and gradient in the long term that USLE based technology focuses upon. In addition, sedimentation during the sampling procedure adopted to determine the bulk sediment concentration for erosion events at the Sparacia experimental site may have affected the veracity of the measured soil losses.
- 12 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Soils and Sediments
- Vol. 25 (9) , 2626-2633
Open AccessA Comment on “Empirical modelling of soil erosion using unit plot data at Sparacia experimental area (southern Italy)”
Purpose: To comment on the results presented by Pampalone et al. J Soils Sediments 24(6) 2535-47, Pampalone et al., J Soils Sediments 24:2535–47, 2024 on the effects of slope length and gradient on average annual soil losses over 5 years at the Sparacia experimental area in southern Italy. Methods: Analysis of erosion data presented by Pampalone et al J Soils Sediments 24(6) 2535-47, Pampalone et al., J Soils Sediments 24:2535–47, 2024 in respect to the relationships between soil loss per unit EI 30 and slope length and gradient. Results: The relationships between soil loss per unit EI 30 and slope length and gradient for the experiments reported by Pampalone et al. J Soils Sediments 24(6) 2535-47, Pampalone et al., J Soils Sediments 24:2535–47, 2024 differ appreciably from those used by the RUSLE. Contrary to assumptions underpinning USLE-based models, runoff ratios at Sparacia vary with slope length and gradient. Conclusions: Variations in runoff ratios with slope length and gradient cause discrepancies between the effects of topography at Sparacia and equations normally used to account for the effects of topography in USLE-based models. The number of erosion events reported by Pampalone et al. J Soils Sediments 24(6) 2535-47, Pampalone et al., J Soils Sediments 24:2535–47, 2024 may not be sufficient to make definitive conclusions on how erosion varies with slope length and gradient in the long term that USLE based technology focuses upon. In addition, sedimentation during the sampling procedure adopted to determine the bulk sediment concentration for erosion events at the Sparacia experimental site may have affected the veracity of the measured soil losses.
- Open Access
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
All soil loss prediction models are wrong, some more than others, some are useful
Soil loss prediction models are designed to aid making decisions on land management. To do this, they predict erosion for existing and proposed land management options that are tenable on a given soil on a given topography in a given climate. The Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE) and subsequent revisions of it provide the most widely used model for this purpose in the world. While the climate input is reportedly based on the product of storm kinetic energy (E) and the maximum 30-minute rainfall intensity (I30), the model ignores the fact that storm kinetic energy per unit of rain varies with the synoptic conditions that dominate the production of rainfall at a particular location. It also ignores the fact that runoff per unit area can vary with slope length and gradient. However, these failures exist for pragmatic reasons. The mathematical structure of the USLE models is based on predicting the long-term soil loss from the unit plot so that any method that enables that to be achieved can be used to predict erosion for situations that do not conform to the unit plot using appropriate USLE equations for factors such as slope length and gradient. WEPP has for a long time been touted as a replacement for USLE models in the USA but does not predict event soil loss on bare fallow areas better than the EI30 index. Also, parameterization of WEPP focussed on areas where crops are grown on ridges rather than planar slopes. Consequently, WEPP is not an appropriate replacement for USLE models in making land management decisions. Other models like APEX break mathematical rules.:
- 18 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessAll soil loss prediction models are wrong, some more than others, some are useful
Soil loss prediction models are designed to aid making decisions on land management. To do this, they predict erosion for existing and proposed land management options that are tenable on a given soil on a given topography in a given climate. The Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE) and subsequent revisions of it provide the most widely used model for this purpose in the world. While the climate input is reportedly based on the product of storm kinetic energy (E) and the maximum 30-minute rainfall intensity (I30), the model ignores the fact that storm kinetic energy per unit of rain varies with the synoptic conditions that dominate the production of rainfall at a particular location. It also ignores the fact that runoff per unit area can vary with slope length and gradient. However, these failures exist for pragmatic reasons. The mathematical structure of the USLE models is based on predicting the long-term soil loss from the unit plot so that any method that enables that to be achieved can be used to predict erosion for situations that do not conform to the unit plot using appropriate USLE equations for factors such as slope length and gradient. WEPP has for a long time been touted as a replacement for USLE models in the USA but does not predict event soil loss on bare fallow areas better than the EI30 index. Also, parameterization of WEPP focussed on areas where crops are grown on ridges rather than planar slopes. Consequently, WEPP is not an appropriate replacement for USLE models in making land management decisions. Other models like APEX break mathematical rules.:
- Open Access
Comment on calibration, validation, and evaluation of WEPP with natural runoff plot data
15 16 Wang et al (2022) undertook an evaluation of the Water Erosion Prediction Project (WEPP) 17 model on 134 USLE runoff and soil loss plots. Wang et al did not compare the capacities of 18 WEPP and USLE based models to predict soil loss. The importance of doing that on bare 19 fallow plots is illustrated here. Data from comparisons of WEPP, RUSLE2, and the USLE-M 20 undertaken by Kinnell (2017) demonstrated that both RUSLE2 and the USLE-M predicted 21 event soil losses on 4 historic bare fallow USLE plots in the USA better than WEPP. It is 22 apparent that because WEPP is a steady state model designed to model event soil loss for 23 ridged tillage cultivation, WEPP is in not well suited to predicting event soil losses from bare 24 fallow plots that are planar with rills occurring in some storms but not all storms.. Given that 25 calibrated WEPP does not model event soil losses on bare fallow USLE plots better than 26 either RUSLE2 or the USLE-M, the fundamental ability of WEPP to model event erosion 27 under natural rainfall must be questioned at this time. 28 29 30 Keywords: WEPP; RUSLE2; USLE-M; calibration; natural rainfall 31 32 33 2
Open AccessComment on calibration, validation, and evaluation of WEPP with natural runoff plot data
15 16 Wang et al (2022) undertook an evaluation of the Water Erosion Prediction Project (WEPP) 17 model on 134 USLE runoff and soil loss plots. Wang et al did not compare the capacities of 18 WEPP and USLE based models to predict soil loss. The importance of doing that on bare 19 fallow plots is illustrated here. Data from comparisons of WEPP, RUSLE2, and the USLE-M 20 undertaken by Kinnell (2017) demonstrated that both RUSLE2 and the USLE-M predicted 21 event soil losses on 4 historic bare fallow USLE plots in the USA better than WEPP. It is 22 apparent that because WEPP is a steady state model designed to model event soil loss for 23 ridged tillage cultivation, WEPP is in not well suited to predicting event soil losses from bare 24 fallow plots that are planar with rills occurring in some storms but not all storms.. Given that 25 calibrated WEPP does not model event soil losses on bare fallow USLE plots better than 26 either RUSLE2 or the USLE-M, the fundamental ability of WEPP to model event erosion 27 under natural rainfall must be questioned at this time. 28 29 30 Keywords: WEPP; RUSLE2; USLE-M; calibration; natural rainfall 31 32 33 2
- Open Access
- 17 January 2023
- Published by Wiley
The stochastic nature of the transport of coarse material in rain-impacted flows
Traditionally, so-called physically based models of erosion by rain-impacted flow focus on the conservation of mass. Raindrop induced saltation and rolling produce random intermittent movement of soil particles and it seems that the traditional approach to modelling sediment transport in rain-impacted flows does not account for the effects these transport processes well. Arguably, the traditional approach needs to be replaced by one that is better able the deal with the stochastic nature of the transport of coarse material in rain-impacted flows.
- 17 January 2023
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessThe stochastic nature of the transport of coarse material in rain-impacted flows
Traditionally, so-called physically based models of erosion by rain-impacted flow focus on the conservation of mass. Raindrop induced saltation and rolling produce random intermittent movement of soil particles and it seems that the traditional approach to modelling sediment transport in rain-impacted flows does not account for the effects these transport processes well. Arguably, the traditional approach needs to be replaced by one that is better able the deal with the stochastic nature of the transport of coarse material in rain-impacted flows.
- Open Access
The influence of I30 on erosivity-J
A document by P.I.A. Kinnell. Click on the document to view its contents.
Open AccessThe influence of I30 on erosivity-J
A document by P.I.A. Kinnell. Click on the document to view its contents.
- Open Access
- 19 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Comment on “Zhang, X. C. (2019). Determining and Modeling Dominant Processes of Interrill Soil Erosion. Water Resources Research, 55(1), 4-20. doi:10.1029/2018wr023217”
Zhang (2109) presented results from experiments where 4 sections in 1.8 m long flumes were sequentially exposed to rainfall during 15 minute periods during an hour where rainfall intensity and slope gradient remained constant. The upslope areas were protected by a tarp in one treatment, and a screen placed 5 cm above the soil surface to provide sheet flow protected to some degree from raindrop impact in another treatment. Zhang presented two equations, one for the screen experiments, one for the tarp experiments, for estimating the soil loss rates in the sections under steady state conditions. The equation used for the screen experiments is shown here to produce results that do not conform to well known long established rules that apply to the determination of erosion in a section. In terms of modelling sediment discharge, Zhang applied an equation developed by Zhang and Wang (2017). It is shown here that that equation was not well suited to predicting the discharges in the screen treatment. Zhang also observed sediment discharges were well correlated to stream power even though sediment concentrations were influenced by rainfall intensity. Considerable insights exists in respect to the detachment and transport mechanisms that operate in rain-impacted flows a few millimetres deep but the closeness of the flow surface to the soil surface has a major impact on sediment transport by saltation and rolling. Further study of sediment transport by very shallow rain-impacted flows is warranted
- 19 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in ESS Open Archive
Open AccessComment on “Zhang, X. C. (2019). Determining and Modeling Dominant Processes of Interrill Soil Erosion. Water Resources Research, 55(1), 4-20. doi:10.1029/2018wr023217”
Zhang (2109) presented results from experiments where 4 sections in 1.8 m long flumes were sequentially exposed to rainfall during 15 minute periods during an hour where rainfall intensity and slope gradient remained constant. The upslope areas were protected by a tarp in one treatment, and a screen placed 5 cm above the soil surface to provide sheet flow protected to some degree from raindrop impact in another treatment. Zhang presented two equations, one for the screen experiments, one for the tarp experiments, for estimating the soil loss rates in the sections under steady state conditions. The equation used for the screen experiments is shown here to produce results that do not conform to well known long established rules that apply to the determination of erosion in a section. In terms of modelling sediment discharge, Zhang applied an equation developed by Zhang and Wang (2017). It is shown here that that equation was not well suited to predicting the discharges in the screen treatment. Zhang also observed sediment discharges were well correlated to stream power even though sediment concentrations were influenced by rainfall intensity. Considerable insights exists in respect to the detachment and transport mechanisms that operate in rain-impacted flows a few millimetres deep but the closeness of the flow surface to the soil surface has a major impact on sediment transport by saltation and rolling. Further study of sediment transport by very shallow rain-impacted flows is warranted