PAPhilip J. Armitage

Philip J. Armitage

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Philip J. Armitage has a total of 176 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Just a Phase? Weakening Vertical Shear Instability Explains Class II Disk Morphologies: Simulations with Dust Coagulation, Sedimentation, Thermal Relaxation, and Backreaction

    by Thomas Pfeil, Alexandros Ziampras, Shangjia尚嘉Zhang张, Philip J. Armitage, Yan-Fei燕飞Jiang姜

    The vertical shear instability (VSI) is known to create turbulence and strong vertical mixing in protoplanetary disks if thermal relaxation is sufficiently fast. In simulations where this condition is met, VSI can loft dust particles to large altitudes, creating a vertically extended appearance in mock millimeter-wavelength observations, which is inconsistent with the morphology of the majority of observed Class II disks. We present simulations of protoplanetary disks with VSI that are consistent with the observed thin-disk geometries, while maintaining the commonly observed bowl-shaped morphology in scattered light images at micrometer wavelengths. We show that this outcome arises naturally when the effects of dust coagulation, sedimentation, and dust–gas thermal accommodation are taken into account. Sedimentation-driven coagulation removes large amounts of dust from the disk atmosphere, in the process slowing down the dust-driven cooling of the gas. At the same time, a dense midplane layer of millimeter-sized grains forms, which exerts aerodynamic drag on the gas. This results in the termination of the VSI’s corrugation mode. Only weak VSI activity remains in the upper and lower hemispheres. These processes occur on the typical dust growth timescale and suppress strong VSI-induced turbulence within a few hundred thousand years. VSI could thus generally be restricted to the Class I evolutionary stages of protoplanetary disks.

  • Open Access

    On the Formation of Retrograde S-type Planets in Binaries with a Polar Circumbinary Disk

    by Cheng Chen, Philip J. Armitage, C. J. Nixon, Stephen H. Lubow, Rebecca G. Martin

    Retrograde S-type planets have been observed in several binary systems, yet their formation pathway remains poorly understood. With high-resolution hydrodynamic simulations, we demonstrate that a polar circumbinary disk around an eccentric, unequal-mass binary can form and sustain a retrograde minidisk around the primary star. This provides a direct in situ formation channel for retrograde S-type planets. The minidisk forms via a sub-Keplerian accretion stream that is slightly misaligned from the polar disk. The minidisk initially undergoes von Zeipel–Kozai–Lidov (ZKL) oscillations, driving coupled eccentricity and inclination evolution. Rather than oscillating indefinitely, the inner minidisk evolves past the critical ZKL inclination, decouples from the outer disk, and settles into a stable retrograde orbit. This evolution is sensitive to numerical resolution: the retrograde configuration is absent in previous lower-resolution simulations, where the minidisk accretion timescale is too short to sustain ZKL-driven evolution. For a higher disk viscosity, the minidisk remains near-polar due to a shorter accretion timescale. Since protoplanetary disks typically have low viscosity, our results suggest that retrograde S-type planets can form in situ from retrograde minidisks around polar circumbinary disks, and their occurrence rate may be higher than currently estimated.

  • Open Access

    exoALMA. XXIII. Estimating Disk and Planet Properties from Dust Morphologies with DBNets 2.0

    by Alessandro Ruzza, Giuseppe Lodato, Giovanni Rosotti, Philip Armitage, Stefano Facchini, Sean M. Andrews, Jaehan Bae, Marcelo Barraza-Alfaro, Myriam Benisty, Pietro Curone, et al.

    The exoALMA large program provided an unprecedented view of the morphologies and kinematics of 15 circumstellar disks, offering a biased but homogenous and well-characterized sample for population-level analysis. Continuum observations revealed numerous dust substructures, known to be potential signatures of embedded planets. We analyze the observed dust morphologies with the simulation-based inference tool DBNets2.0, assuming these are due to embedded planets at fixed locations, to infer the system’s properties. We estimate the putative planet mass, the disk α viscosity, scale height, and dust Stokes number that would reproduce 19 substructures in 13 of the 15 exoALMA disks. We compare our results with literature estimates derived with different methods, and find good agreement in most cases. We further explore the implications of the inferred disk properties for accretion, showing that for the Herbig stars in our sample, the implied viscous accretion timescales are too long to account for their observed stellar accretion rates. Regarding planet migration, our results favor inward migration, with only three putative planets expected to migrate outward. Finally, we check for correlations of the inferred disk and planet properties with the disks’ gas-to-dust mass ratio, nonaxisymmetry index, and masses of the gas, dust, and host stars, finding no remarkable trends.


  • Open Access

    Pulsational Instability of Quasi-stars: Interpreting the Variability of Little Red Dots

    by Matteo Cantiello, Jake B. Hassan, Rosalba Perna, Philip J. Armitage, Mitchell C. Begelman, Yan-Fei Jiang, Taeho Ryu, Richard H. D. Townsend

    The JWST discovery of “little red dots” (LRDs) has revealed a population of compact, red sources at z ∼ 5–10 that likely host supermassive black holes. Recent observations of the gravitationally lensed LRD R2211-RX1 reveal century-scale photometric variability and a hysteresis loop in the luminosity–temperature plane, strongly suggesting that the optical emission originates from a pulsating, stellar-like photosphere rather than an accretion disk. This supports the “quasi-star” hypothesis, where a rapidly growing black hole seed is embedded within a massive, radiation-pressure supported envelope. Here, we investigate the pulsational stability of these envelopes using the stellar evolution code MESA coupled with the nonadiabatic oscillation code GYRE . We identify a theoretical “quasi-star instability strip” with a blue edge at T eff ≈ 5000 − 5200 K. Models hotter than this threshold are stable, consistent with the nonvariable LRD R2211-RX2 ( T eff ≈ 5000 K), while cooler models are unstable to radial pulsations driven by the κ -mechanism in helium and hydrogen ionization zones. For quasi-star masses in the range M ⋆ ∼ 10 4 –10 5 M ⊙ , we find that the unstable fundamental radial modes ( ℓ = 0, n p = 1) have periods in the range ∼20–180 yr. The first overtone ( ℓ = 0, n p = 2) is also unstable or marginally stable in some of our models, with typical pulsation timescales ∼10–30 yr. These oscillations match the comoving frame variability timescale of RX1. We argue that these violent pulsations likely drive enhanced mass loss analogous to super-AGB winds, which could affect the duration of the quasi-star phase and regulate the final mass of the seeded black hole.


  • Open Access

    Magnetic Pressure Dominance Stabilizes AGN Disks against Gravitational Instability

    by Hannalore J. Gerling-Dunsmore, Mitchell C. Begelman, Jacob B. Simon, Philip J. Armitage

    Magnetic effects have long been considered a possible factor in stabilizing the outer regions of active galactic nuclei accretion disks against gravitational instability (GI). However, the computational demands of testing this hypothesis have prevented comprehensive study of this problem. Here, we present results from a suite of six isothermal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) shearing box simulations, three initialized with strong magnetization ( β 0 mid = p gas / p mag = 1 0 2.5 ) and three initialized with weak magnetization ( β 0 mid = 1 0 4 ). For each magnetization, we performed simulations with both strong ( Q 0 = 1.0) and weak ( Q 0 = 10.0) self-gravity, where Q 0 = c s Ω π G Σ 0 is the Toomre stability parameter; we also performed pure MHD simulations for comparison. We find that our strongly magnetized disk stabilized against GI after initialization to critical stability against GI, while our corresponding weakly magnetized disk did not. We show that the strongly magnetized, strongly self-gravitating disk became dominated by magnetic pressure, which led to its stabilization.


  • Open Access

    The Astrometric Resoeccentric Degeneracy: Eccentric Single Planets Mimic 2:1 Resonant Planet Pairs in Astrometry

    by Daniel A. Yahalomi, Tiger均Lu陆, Philip J. Armitage, Megan Bedell, Andrew R. Casey, Adrian M. Price-Whelan, Malena Rice

    Detections of long-period giant exoplanets will expand dramatically with Gaia Data Release 4, but interpreting these signals will require care. We derive the astrometric resoeccentric degeneracy: an astrometric analogue of the well-known radial velocity degeneracy in which a single eccentric planet can mimic two circular planets near a 2:1 period ratio. To first order in eccentricity, the sky-projected motion of a single eccentric orbit decomposes into a fundamental mode and first harmonic with an amplitude proportional to that eccentricity. A pair of coplanar, circular planets in a 2:1 orbital resonance produces the same harmonic structure: the outer planet sets the fundamental mode, while the inner planet supplies an apparent first harmonic. We present a mapping between the harmonic amplitudes and effective eccentricity ( e eff ) of a single planet that mimics a 2:1 configuration, demonstrating that e eff = 2 1/3 ( M p ,2 / M p ,1 ), the masses of the inner and outer planets, respectively. Using simulated Gaia data, we show that (1) coplanar 2:1 systems are statistically indistinguishable from a single eccentric planet and (2) mutual inclination can break this degeneracy. This bias favors detecting mutually inclined systems, often fingerprints of a dynamically hot history—traces for processes such as planet–planet scattering or secular chaos. Determining the planetary architectures in which this degeneracy holds will be essential for measuring cool-giant occurrence rates with Gaia and for inferring their dynamical evolution histories.


  • Open Access

    The Growth of the Central Black Holes in Quasi-stars

    by Jake B. Hassan, Rosalba Perna, Matteo Cantiello, Philip J. Armitage, Mitchell C. Begelman, Taeho Ryu

    Observations by JWST have confirmed the presence of supermassive black holes (BHs) at redshifts z ≳ 10, lending support to scenarios in which BHs experience rapid growth through intense gas accretion. Here we investigate the growth of a BH embedded at the center of a quasi-star, a theoretically predicted object formed via direct collapse. In a quasi-star, the central BH accretes at a highly super-Eddington rate, while the excess energy is transported outward by convection and radiated at approximately the Eddington luminosity of the entire star. We employ the open-source stellar evolution code MESA to construct quasi-star models and follow the time-dependent growth of the central BH under different prescriptions for the accretion rate at the inner boundary R i , and further considering the effect of winds. For the case R i = NR B , where N is a constant and R B is the Bondi radius corresponding to the mass of the BH and the gas infalling onto it, our models terminate when the BH mass reaches a critical value M crit ( N ) = c s , i 3 / ( 12 N 3 G 3 π ρ i ) (where c s , i and ρ i are the sound speed and density at R i , respectively), a limit we also derive analytically. Models that feature an inner convective region matched to an outer adiabatic envelope exhibit BH growth up to approximately M BH / M ⋆ ≃ 0.33, largely independent of the stellar mass M ⋆ itself. This ratio is approximately preserved even in the presence of mass loss, as several properties of the model are independent of the quasi-star’s total mass.


  • Open Access

    On the Orbital Evolution of Binaries with Polar Circumbinary Disks

    by Cheng Chen, Philip J. Armitage, C. J. Nixon

    Binaries occur in many astrophysical systems, from young protostellar binaries in star-forming regions to supermassive black hole binaries in galaxy centers. In many cases, a circumbinary disk of gas forms around the binary with an orbit that may be misaligned to the binary plane. Misaligned disks around nearly circular binaries evolve into disks that are either aligned or counteraligned with the binary orbit. However, if the binary is sufficiently eccentric, then it can be more likely that the disk will end up in a polar-aligned configuration in which the disk angular momentum vector aligns with the binary eccentricity vector. We use smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations, evolved to an approximate steady state under mass injection, to determine the orbital evolution of a binary with a polar-aligned disk for a range of binary-disk parameters. We find that, in all of the cases we have simulated, the binary shrinks with time. The decay rate is larger than for binaries surrounded by aligned or retrograde disks with matched disk parameters. The rate of shrinkage is largely unaltered by the size of the sink radii employed for the binary stars, but for small enough sink radii some of the models exhibit long-lived polar circumprimary disks, which are continually fed mass from the circumbinary disk. We discuss our results in the contexts of planet formation in young polar-aligned disks and merging supermassive black holes in galaxy centers.


  • Open Access

    Fragmentation-limited Dust Filtration in 2D Simulations of Planet–Disk Systems with Dust Coagulation: Parameter Study and Implications for the Inner Disk’s Dust Mass Budget and Composition

    by Thomas Pfeil, Philip J. Armitage, Yan-Fei Jiang

    Superthermal gas giant planets or their progenitor cores are known to open deep gaps in protoplanetary disks, which stop large, drifting dust particles on their way to the inner disk. The possible separation of the disk into distinct reservoirs and the resulting dust depletion interior to the gap have important implications for planetesimal formation and the chemical and isotopic composition of the inner regions of protoplanetary disks. Dust fragmentation, however, maintains a reservoir of small grains that can traverse the gap. Dust evolution models are thus instrumental for studies of a gap’s filtration efficiency. We present 2D multifluid hydrodynamic simulations of planet–disk systems with dust coagulation and fragmentation. For the first time, we evolve a series of 2D simulations with dust coagulation over 45,000 planetary orbits and track the dust’s size evolution and origin by using the TriPoD dust coagulation method. We investigate the effects of different planetary masses, fragmentation velocities, and viscosities on the inner disk’s dust mass budget and composition, and highlight the advantages of multidimensional simulations over 1D models. Filtering can only be efficient for high planetary masses, high fragmentation velocities, and low diffusivities. Clear compositional distinctions between the inner and outer disk could not have been maintained by Jupiter’s core if the fragmentation velocity was low, even if α ≲ 5 × 10 −4 . Significant “contamination” of the inner disk by outer-disk dust occurs in much less than 2 × 10 5 yr in this case and even for more-massive objects. This either places tight constraints on the physical conditions in the solar nebula or mandates consideration of alternative explanations for the dichotomy between non-carbonaceous chondrites (NC) and carbonaceous chondrites (CC). Astrophysical constraints on the parameters could discriminate between these possibilities.


  • Open Access

    The Growth of the Central Black Holes in Quasi-stars

    by Jake Hassan, Rosalba Perna, Matteo Cantiello, Philip Armitage, Mitchell Begelman, Taeho Ryu

    Observations by JWST have confirmed the presence of supermassive black holes (BHs) at redshifts $z\gtrsim10$, lending support to scenarios in which BHs experience rapid growth through intense gas accretion. Here we investigate the growth of a BH embedded at the center of a quasi-star, a theoretically predicted object formed via direct collapse. In a quasi-star, the central BH accretes at a highly super-Eddington rate, while the excess energy is transported outward by convection and radiated at approximately the Eddington luminosity of the entire star. We employ the open-source stellar evolution code \texttt{MESA} to construct quasi-star models and follow the time-dependent growth of the central BH under different prescriptions for the accretion rate at the inner boundary $R_i$, and further considering the effect of winds. For the case $R_i=NR_{\rm B}$, where $N$ is a constant and $R_{\rm B}$ is the Bondi radius corresponding to the mass of the BH and the gas infalling onto it, our models terminate when the BH mass reaches a critical value $M_{\mathrm{crit}}(N)=c_{s,i}^3/(12\sqrt{N^3G^3πρ_i})$ (where $c_{s,i}$ and $ρ_i$ are the sound speed and density at $R_i$, respectively), a limit we also derive analytically. Models that feature an inner convective region matched to an outer adiabatic envelope exhibit BH growth up to approximately $M_{\mathrm{BH}}/M_\star\simeq 0.33$, largely independent of the stellar mass $M_\star$ itself. This ratio is approximately preserved even in the presence of mass loss, as several properties of the model are independent of the quasi-star's total mass.