Lidia Pittarello
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Lidia Pittarello has a total of 191 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Philippe Claeys
Archaeology, Environmental Changes & Geo-Chemistry, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Pleinlaan 2, 1050 Brussel, Belgium
11 shared publications Christian Koeberl
Department of Lithospheric Research University of Vienna Althanstrasse 14 Vienna 1090 Austria
10 shared publications- Steven Goderis
Archaeology, Environmental Changes and Geo-Chemistry (AMGC), Vrije Universiteit Brussel, 1050 Brussels, Belgium
10 shared publications - Vinciane Debaille
Laboratoire G-Time, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Brussels, Belgium
9 shared publications - Christian Koeberl
Department of Lithospheric Research University of Vienna Vienna Austria
5 shared publications - Frank Vanhaecke
Atomic & Mass Spectrometry-A&MS Research Group, Department of Chemistry, Ghent University, Campus Sterre, Krijgslaan 281-S12, 9000 Ghent, Belgium
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Geological Society of London in Journal of the Geological Society
- Vol. 183 (5)
Experimental constraints on the differentiation of CM-like planetary embryos
This study investigates the onset of differentiation of hydrous (ice-bearing) planetary embryos in the early Solar System. To do so, we conducted high-pressure (1 GPa) melting experiments on a CM2 chondrite (MCY12002) across a temperature range of 1050-1400°C, with durations varying from 1 to 24 hours. Heating of the CM chondrite at near-solidus conditions results in the thermal decomposition of hydrated minerals composing the matrix of the meteorite and metamorphic recrystallization of olivine crystals. The resulting mineral assemblages are composed of abundant olivine and scarce Al-rich-low-Ca pyroxene and kirschsteinite. Silicate glass is present in all experiments, increasing from 2 O and CO 2 ) of the starting chondrite. This latter mechanism could explain the gap in oxygen fugacity between the most oxidized chondrites and the most oxidized achondrites, highlighting the impact of volatile loss during the early differentiation of CM-like bodies.
- 12 June 2026
- Published by Geological Society of London in Journal of the Geological Society
- Vol. 183 (5)
Experimental constraints on the differentiation of CM-like planetary embryos
This study investigates the onset of differentiation of hydrous (ice-bearing) planetary embryos in the early Solar System. To do so, we conducted high-pressure (1 GPa) melting experiments on a CM2 chondrite (MCY12002) across a temperature range of 1050-1400°C, with durations varying from 1 to 24 hours. Heating of the CM chondrite at near-solidus conditions results in the thermal decomposition of hydrated minerals composing the matrix of the meteorite and metamorphic recrystallization of olivine crystals. The resulting mineral assemblages are composed of abundant olivine and scarce Al-rich-low-Ca pyroxene and kirschsteinite. Silicate glass is present in all experiments, increasing from 2 O and CO 2 ) of the starting chondrite. This latter mechanism could explain the gap in oxygen fugacity between the most oxidized chondrites and the most oxidized achondrites, highlighting the impact of volatile loss during the early differentiation of CM-like bodies.
- 19 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (7) , 1673-1682
Coexisting wadsleyite and ringwoodite in the Alfianello L6 ordinary chondrite
The occurrence of ringwoodite in shocked L6 ordinary chondrites has been frequently reported, mostly within shock veins. Only recently, ringwoodite has also been found in a fragment from the Alfianello meteorite, occurring as rim or core of olivine clasts in impact melt pockets, in lamellae crosscutting olivine grains in the host rock, and in fine‐grained aggregates in association with wadsleyite. In all cases, ringwoodite shows a higher Fe/Mg ratio than the original olivine, whereas wadsleyite shows a lower Fe/Mg ratio than the original olivine. Detailed TEM studies of the occurrence of both high‐pressure polymorphs allow the identification of the most likely formation process, explaining the coexistence of these polymorphs. The lack of any crystallographic relationships but the complementary Fe/Mg ratios supports formation of the assemblage through fractional crystallization from impact melt under high (shock) pressure conditions. However, the other occurrences of ringwoodite reported in the same sample, traditionally interpreted as resulting from solid‐state transformation, emphasize the heterogeneity of distribution of shock effects and shock‐induced processes recorded in a single meteorite.
- 19 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (7) , 1673-1682
Coexisting wadsleyite and ringwoodite in the Alfianello L6 ordinary chondrite
The occurrence of ringwoodite in shocked L6 ordinary chondrites has been frequently reported, mostly within shock veins. Only recently, ringwoodite has also been found in a fragment from the Alfianello meteorite, occurring as rim or core of olivine clasts in impact melt pockets, in lamellae crosscutting olivine grains in the host rock, and in fine‐grained aggregates in association with wadsleyite. In all cases, ringwoodite shows a higher Fe/Mg ratio than the original olivine, whereas wadsleyite shows a lower Fe/Mg ratio than the original olivine. Detailed TEM studies of the occurrence of both high‐pressure polymorphs allow the identification of the most likely formation process, explaining the coexistence of these polymorphs. The lack of any crystallographic relationships but the complementary Fe/Mg ratios supports formation of the assemblage through fractional crystallization from impact melt under high (shock) pressure conditions. However, the other occurrences of ringwoodite reported in the same sample, traditionally interpreted as resulting from solid‐state transformation, emphasize the heterogeneity of distribution of shock effects and shock‐induced processes recorded in a single meteorite.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
A shocked quartz pebble from the Araguainha impact structure, Brazil, investigated by U-stage, CL, and EBSD
Quartz pebbles in the conglomerates of the Devonian Furnas Formation in the central uplift of the 40 km Araguainha impact structure, Brazil, are pervasively crosscut by shear fractures and shocked, showing sets of planar fractures (PFs), planar deformation features (PDFs) and feather features (e.g., von Engehardt et al., 1992). A recent reinvestigation of such pebbles interpreted the shear fractures as resulting from post-shock brittle deformation, but still impact-related (King et al., 2025).A petrographic thin section and a polished mount from one of such pebbles were here investigated by Universal-stage (U-stage), cathodoluminescence (CL) and electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) to characterize the shear fractures. The shear fractures are filled by angular clasts of quartz embedded in a fine-grained quartz matrix, showing neither crystallographic preferred orientation nor recrystallization. The host quartz is twinned and clearly dislocated along the shear zones. A network of thin pressure-solution lines occurs at ca. 60° from the main set of shear fractures. The distribution and orientation of (shock) planar fractures was compared with the orientation of the shear fractures, following the suggestion that they should show a preferred orientation, and this might be related with the shock wave propagation direction (e.g., Pittarello et al., 2020). Further investigations on oriented pebbles are planned to better constrain their deformation history in relation with the impact event.Engelhardt v. et al. (1992) Meteoritics 27:442-457.King et al. (2025) Meteoritics & Planetary Science 60:124-132.Pittarello et al. (2020) Meteoritics & Planetary Science 55:1082-1092.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessA shocked quartz pebble from the Araguainha impact structure, Brazil, investigated by U-stage, CL, and EBSD
Quartz pebbles in the conglomerates of the Devonian Furnas Formation in the central uplift of the 40 km Araguainha impact structure, Brazil, are pervasively crosscut by shear fractures and shocked, showing sets of planar fractures (PFs), planar deformation features (PDFs) and feather features (e.g., von Engehardt et al., 1992). A recent reinvestigation of such pebbles interpreted the shear fractures as resulting from post-shock brittle deformation, but still impact-related (King et al., 2025).A petrographic thin section and a polished mount from one of such pebbles were here investigated by Universal-stage (U-stage), cathodoluminescence (CL) and electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) to characterize the shear fractures. The shear fractures are filled by angular clasts of quartz embedded in a fine-grained quartz matrix, showing neither crystallographic preferred orientation nor recrystallization. The host quartz is twinned and clearly dislocated along the shear zones. A network of thin pressure-solution lines occurs at ca. 60° from the main set of shear fractures. The distribution and orientation of (shock) planar fractures was compared with the orientation of the shear fractures, following the suggestion that they should show a preferred orientation, and this might be related with the shock wave propagation direction (e.g., Pittarello et al., 2020). Further investigations on oriented pebbles are planned to better constrain their deformation history in relation with the impact event.Engelhardt v. et al. (1992) Meteoritics 27:442-457.King et al. (2025) Meteoritics & Planetary Science 60:124-132.Pittarello et al. (2020) Meteoritics & Planetary Science 55:1082-1092.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (3) , 487-503
Combining universal‐stage, backscatter electron imaging and electron backscatter diffraction for improved indexing of planar microstructures in quartz and plagioclase
Quartz and feldspar commonly develop planar microstructures due to shock metamorphism. These are generally investigated and indexed (identifying the crystallographic orientation along which they developed) using a universal stage (U‐stage) on a petrographic microscope. However, the U‐stage method alone can sometimes prove insufficient for correct indexing, for example, due to the size of microstructural features, or challenging, in the case of low symmetry minerals. Neither backscatter electron (BSE) imaging nor electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) analysis can solve this problem individually for a flat surface, as both methods are limited to providing 2‐D microstructural information. We propose a method combining contributions from U‐stage, BSE imaging and EBSD. The combination and plotting of crystallographic orientation (from EBSD), U‐stage measurements of planes and directions, and traces of planar microstructures (from BSE images) in a single reference frame allows the identification of the most probable orientations of features that could not be indexed by applying any single technique. The applicability and limitations of the proposed method were tested on selected shocked quartz and feldspar grains. The method proved to be successful and could be applied to study any 3‐D planar features suspected to be aligned with crystallographic planes of an optically transparent host material.
- 10 February 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (3) , 487-503
Open AccessCombining universal‐stage, backscatter electron imaging and electron backscatter diffraction for improved indexing of planar microstructures in quartz and plagioclase
Quartz and feldspar commonly develop planar microstructures due to shock metamorphism. These are generally investigated and indexed (identifying the crystallographic orientation along which they developed) using a universal stage (U‐stage) on a petrographic microscope. However, the U‐stage method alone can sometimes prove insufficient for correct indexing, for example, due to the size of microstructural features, or challenging, in the case of low symmetry minerals. Neither backscatter electron (BSE) imaging nor electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) analysis can solve this problem individually for a flat surface, as both methods are limited to providing 2‐D microstructural information. We propose a method combining contributions from U‐stage, BSE imaging and EBSD. The combination and plotting of crystallographic orientation (from EBSD), U‐stage measurements of planes and directions, and traces of planar microstructures (from BSE images) in a single reference frame allows the identification of the most probable orientations of features that could not be indexed by applying any single technique. The applicability and limitations of the proposed method were tested on selected shocked quartz and feldspar grains. The method proved to be successful and could be applied to study any 3‐D planar features suspected to be aligned with crystallographic planes of an optically transparent host material.
- Open Access
- 16 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (2) , 272-284
New evidence on the formation conditions of the Libyan Desert Glass (Western Egypt): Clues from a dendritic zircon inclusion
Libyan Desert Glass (LDG) is an ~29 million years old, silica‐rich glass found in Western Egypt. Whether this glass formed in an impact cratering context associated with the hypervelocity collision of a cometary/asteroidal body or radiative heating during an airburst is debated. Determination of the formation temperatures and pressures of rare mineral components in LDG can provide key petrogenetic constraints on its origin. Here, we report the occurrence of a zircon inclusion, whose textural, chemical, and crystallographic features point to a rapid formation during solidification of the silica‐rich LDG melt. The study was conducted combining dual beam microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, energy‐dispersive X‐ray spectroscopy, and three‐dimensional electron diffraction. The inclusion is a few tens of micrometer in size and consists of dendritic branches of zircon arranged in a reticulate‐cruciform texture. The high‐silica glass filling interstices between dendrites have longer chemical bonds compared to matrix glass, as indicated by electron pair distribution function analysis, and is enriched in Al 2 O 3 . The lack of incongruent melt products (ZrO 2 , SiO 2 ) suggests that the inclusion formed during cooling from supraliquidus conditions, by dynamic crystallization from an (immiscible) undercooled liquid droplet. Such droplet would derive from shock‐induced melting of a precursor zircon grain, possibly mixed with the SiO 2 ‐rich liquid formed by melting of the LDG precursor material. The formation model proposed for this inclusion does not allow us to discriminate between the two genetic processes proposed for LDG, but sets a new minimum to the liquidus temperature of the corresponding chemical system of ~2250°C.
- 16 January 2026
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 61 (2) , 272-284
Open AccessNew evidence on the formation conditions of the Libyan Desert Glass (Western Egypt): Clues from a dendritic zircon inclusion
Libyan Desert Glass (LDG) is an ~29 million years old, silica‐rich glass found in Western Egypt. Whether this glass formed in an impact cratering context associated with the hypervelocity collision of a cometary/asteroidal body or radiative heating during an airburst is debated. Determination of the formation temperatures and pressures of rare mineral components in LDG can provide key petrogenetic constraints on its origin. Here, we report the occurrence of a zircon inclusion, whose textural, chemical, and crystallographic features point to a rapid formation during solidification of the silica‐rich LDG melt. The study was conducted combining dual beam microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, energy‐dispersive X‐ray spectroscopy, and three‐dimensional electron diffraction. The inclusion is a few tens of micrometer in size and consists of dendritic branches of zircon arranged in a reticulate‐cruciform texture. The high‐silica glass filling interstices between dendrites have longer chemical bonds compared to matrix glass, as indicated by electron pair distribution function analysis, and is enriched in Al 2 O 3 . The lack of incongruent melt products (ZrO 2 , SiO 2 ) suggests that the inclusion formed during cooling from supraliquidus conditions, by dynamic crystallization from an (immiscible) undercooled liquid droplet. Such droplet would derive from shock‐induced melting of a precursor zircon grain, possibly mixed with the SiO 2 ‐rich liquid formed by melting of the LDG precursor material. The formation model proposed for this inclusion does not allow us to discriminate between the two genetic processes proposed for LDG, but sets a new minimum to the liquidus temperature of the corresponding chemical system of ~2250°C.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in European Journal of Mineralogy
- Vol. 37 (5) , 617-626
Chromites in ordinary-chondrite fusion crusts
Chromites from ordinary chondrites of groups H4, H5, LL5, LL6, L3.6 and L6 were studied and compared to an H5 ordinary chondrite processed to form a synthetic fusion crust. Chromites found in the bulk are usually anhedral and relatively large in size (several tens of micrometres), as opposed to chromites formed within the crust, which are consistently smaller (a few micrometres in size) and can display anhedral or subhedral to euhedral habit. The Mg# and Al# values of the chromites in the bulk display typical composition reported for ordinary chondrites, with a limited scatter of Al# (ca. 0.13 ± 0.025) but a large variation in Mg# (from 0.05 to 0.30). Chromites within fusion crusts generally exhibit similar Al# values with respect to those in the bulk but a much larger scatter of Mg# values and a larger average Mg# (up to 0.65). Chromites in the fusion crusts are often associated with magnetite dendrites made up of magnetite octahedral crystals that are 100–400 nm wide; occasionally, other spinel group minerals can be found, such as magnesiochromites and magnesioferrites. In most of the studied samples, several chromite crystals are mantled by magnetite crystals. Textural data collected so far suggest a crystallisation sequence in the fusion crust, starting with olivine and going over chromite to magnetite. A small but significant fraction (∼ 15 %) of chromites grown in the fusion crust display a detectable Ni content, in marked contrast with those found in the bulk, where only ca. 2 % of the analysed chromites display Ni contents above the detection limit. These observations are additionally supported by measurements on the El Hammami (H5) meteorite sample, which was previously processed with an induction-heated plasma wind tunnel in order to create a synthetic fusion crust. Also in this case, chromites found within the fusion crust formed under controlled conditions (temperature measured at the sample surface at 2400–2200 K for 20 s) display similar Al# and considerably higher Mg# compared to those in the bulk, which is similar to the chromites in the natural fusion crusts studied here. Our study shows that chromites of meteoritic origin retrieved from sediment can display significantly higher Mg# values than those of the parent meteoroid if they originate within the fusion crust, providing a way to recognise chromites from ablation spherules.
- 10 September 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in European Journal of Mineralogy
- Vol. 37 (5) , 617-626
Open AccessChromites in ordinary-chondrite fusion crusts
Chromites from ordinary chondrites of groups H4, H5, LL5, LL6, L3.6 and L6 were studied and compared to an H5 ordinary chondrite processed to form a synthetic fusion crust. Chromites found in the bulk are usually anhedral and relatively large in size (several tens of micrometres), as opposed to chromites formed within the crust, which are consistently smaller (a few micrometres in size) and can display anhedral or subhedral to euhedral habit. The Mg# and Al# values of the chromites in the bulk display typical composition reported for ordinary chondrites, with a limited scatter of Al# (ca. 0.13 ± 0.025) but a large variation in Mg# (from 0.05 to 0.30). Chromites within fusion crusts generally exhibit similar Al# values with respect to those in the bulk but a much larger scatter of Mg# values and a larger average Mg# (up to 0.65). Chromites in the fusion crusts are often associated with magnetite dendrites made up of magnetite octahedral crystals that are 100–400 nm wide; occasionally, other spinel group minerals can be found, such as magnesiochromites and magnesioferrites. In most of the studied samples, several chromite crystals are mantled by magnetite crystals. Textural data collected so far suggest a crystallisation sequence in the fusion crust, starting with olivine and going over chromite to magnetite. A small but significant fraction (∼ 15 %) of chromites grown in the fusion crust display a detectable Ni content, in marked contrast with those found in the bulk, where only ca. 2 % of the analysed chromites display Ni contents above the detection limit. These observations are additionally supported by measurements on the El Hammami (H5) meteorite sample, which was previously processed with an induction-heated plasma wind tunnel in order to create a synthetic fusion crust. Also in this case, chromites found within the fusion crust formed under controlled conditions (temperature measured at the sample surface at 2400–2200 K for 20 s) display similar Al# and considerably higher Mg# compared to those in the bulk, which is similar to the chromites in the natural fusion crusts studied here. Our study shows that chromites of meteoritic origin retrieved from sediment can display significantly higher Mg# values than those of the parent meteoroid if they originate within the fusion crust, providing a way to recognise chromites from ablation spherules.
- 13 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 60 (9) , 2283-2292
A terrestrial rock instead of an ureilite: Caution is recommended to scientists working on material received from meteorite collections
Planetary scientists heavily depend on meteorite curation facilities for the preparation and allocation of protected (e.g., Antarctic), highly valuable extraterrestrial specimens. In this work, a fragment of the Dyalpur ureilite obtained from a museum is discussed. The sample is found to contain microstructural, geochemical, and isotopic features inconsistent with any meteorite. The fragment consists of pargasitic amphibole, Ni‐sulfides, and chromite grains in Fo92 olivine groundmass, cut by serpentine veins. Amphibole geothermobarometry yields equilibrium conditions that are not compatible with the assumed ureilite parent body. Assuming the fragment represented a rare clast in an ureilite, further analyses were performed. Both the oxygen isotopic composition and the extremely low level of cosmogenic radionuclides confirm the terrestrial origin of the fragment; it is a partially serpentinized peridotite. This work stresses the importance of petrographic characterization of samples used for (isotope) geochemical analyses, of a well‐documented sample curation, and of cosmogenic nuclide measurements for the unequivocal identification of extraterrestrial material. Finally, caution is recommended before making sensational claims in cases of anomalous results.
- 13 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 60 (9) , 2283-2292
A terrestrial rock instead of an ureilite: Caution is recommended to scientists working on material received from meteorite collections
Planetary scientists heavily depend on meteorite curation facilities for the preparation and allocation of protected (e.g., Antarctic), highly valuable extraterrestrial specimens. In this work, a fragment of the Dyalpur ureilite obtained from a museum is discussed. The sample is found to contain microstructural, geochemical, and isotopic features inconsistent with any meteorite. The fragment consists of pargasitic amphibole, Ni‐sulfides, and chromite grains in Fo92 olivine groundmass, cut by serpentine veins. Amphibole geothermobarometry yields equilibrium conditions that are not compatible with the assumed ureilite parent body. Assuming the fragment represented a rare clast in an ureilite, further analyses were performed. Both the oxygen isotopic composition and the extremely low level of cosmogenic radionuclides confirm the terrestrial origin of the fragment; it is a partially serpentinized peridotite. This work stresses the importance of petrographic characterization of samples used for (isotope) geochemical analyses, of a well‐documented sample curation, and of cosmogenic nuclide measurements for the unequivocal identification of extraterrestrial material. Finally, caution is recommended before making sensational claims in cases of anomalous results.
- Open Access
- 23 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 60 (4) , 744-756
Shock‐heated graphite in three IAB iron meteorites—Implications on the formation of diamond
Iron meteorites, originating from the deepest parts of their parent bodies and separated during major break‐up events, surprisingly rarely contain diamonds despite experiencing similar pressure–temperature conditions as diamond‐bearing ureilites. In this study, graphite from three non‐magmatic IAB iron meteorites Canyon Diablo, Campo del Cielo, and Yardymly was analyzed using micro‐Raman spectroscopy, revealing the presence of the graphite G‐band, the disorder‐induced D‐band, and occasionally the D′‐band. Temperature estimates based on the G‐band full width at half maximum (ranging from 1155 to 1339°C) are consistent with those found in ureilites. However, unlike in ureilites, no diamond bands were detected, as confirmed by μ‐X‐ray diffraction. The absence of diamonds is interpreted to be related to the thermal and mechanical properties of the iron meteorite matrix. Its high thermal diffusivity results in similar temperatures to ureilites, but its ductility dissipates shock‐wave energy through plastic deformation, unlike the brittle ureilite matrix, which more effectively transmits the energy. Consequently, graphite in iron meteorites was heated but did not experience the high‐pressure conditions required for diamond formation. Thus, we propose that impacts must either involve substantial energy or that graphite must be located close to the impact site, where it can experience high energies before these dissipate.
- 23 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 60 (4) , 744-756
Open AccessShock‐heated graphite in three IAB iron meteorites—Implications on the formation of diamond
Iron meteorites, originating from the deepest parts of their parent bodies and separated during major break‐up events, surprisingly rarely contain diamonds despite experiencing similar pressure–temperature conditions as diamond‐bearing ureilites. In this study, graphite from three non‐magmatic IAB iron meteorites Canyon Diablo, Campo del Cielo, and Yardymly was analyzed using micro‐Raman spectroscopy, revealing the presence of the graphite G‐band, the disorder‐induced D‐band, and occasionally the D′‐band. Temperature estimates based on the G‐band full width at half maximum (ranging from 1155 to 1339°C) are consistent with those found in ureilites. However, unlike in ureilites, no diamond bands were detected, as confirmed by μ‐X‐ray diffraction. The absence of diamonds is interpreted to be related to the thermal and mechanical properties of the iron meteorite matrix. Its high thermal diffusivity results in similar temperatures to ureilites, but its ductility dissipates shock‐wave energy through plastic deformation, unlike the brittle ureilite matrix, which more effectively transmits the energy. Consequently, graphite in iron meteorites was heated but did not experience the high‐pressure conditions required for diamond formation. Thus, we propose that impacts must either involve substantial energy or that graphite must be located close to the impact site, where it can experience high energies before these dissipate.
- Open Access
- 24 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 59 (11) , 2956-2980
Fe, Zn, and Mg stable isotope systematics of acapulcoite lodranite clan meteorites
The processes of planetary accretion and differentiation, whereby an unsorted mass of primitive solar system material evolves into a body composed of a silicate mantle and metallic core, remain poorly understood. Mass‐dependent variations of the isotope ratios of non‐traditional stable isotope systems in meteorites are known to record events in the nebula and planetary evolution processes. Partial melting and melt separation, evaporation and condensation, diffusion, and thermal equilibration between minerals at the parent body (PB) scale can be recorded in the isotopic signatures of meteorites. In this context, the acapulcoite–lodranite meteorite clan (ALC), which represents the products of thermal metamorphism and low‐degree partial melting of a primitive asteroid, is an attractive target to study the processes of early planetary differentiation. Here, we present a comprehensive data set of mass‐dependent Fe, Zn, and Mg isotope ratio variations in bulk ALC species, their separated silicate and metal phases, and in handpicked mineral fractions. These non‐traditional stable isotope ratios are governed by mass‐dependent isotope fractionation and provide a state‐of‐the‐art perspective on the evolution of the ALC PB, which is complementary to interpretations based on the petrology, trace element composition, and isotope geochemistry of the ALC. None of the isotopic signatures of ALC species show convincing co‐variation with the oxygen isotope ratios, which are considered to record nebular processes occurring prior to the PB formation. Iron isotopic compositions of ALC metal and silicate phases broadly fall on the isotherms within the temperature ranges predicted by pyroxene thermometry. The isotope ratios of Mg in ALC meteorites and their silicate minerals are within the range of chondritic meteorites, with only accessory spinel group minerals having significantly different compositions. Overall, the Mg and Fe isotopic signatures of the ALC species analyzed are in line with their formation as products of high‐degree thermal metamorphism and low‐degree partial melting of primitive precursors. The δ66/64Zn values of the ALC meteorites demonstrate a range of ~3.5‰ and the Zn is overall isotopically heavier than in chondrites. The superchondritic Zn isotopic signatures have possibly resulted from evaporative Zn losses, as observed for other meteorite parent bodies. This is unlikely to be the result of PB differentiation processes, as the Zn isotope ratio data show no covariation with the proxies of partial melting, such as the mass fractions of the platinum group and rare earth elements.
- 24 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 59 (11) , 2956-2980
Open AccessFe, Zn, and Mg stable isotope systematics of acapulcoite lodranite clan meteorites
The processes of planetary accretion and differentiation, whereby an unsorted mass of primitive solar system material evolves into a body composed of a silicate mantle and metallic core, remain poorly understood. Mass‐dependent variations of the isotope ratios of non‐traditional stable isotope systems in meteorites are known to record events in the nebula and planetary evolution processes. Partial melting and melt separation, evaporation and condensation, diffusion, and thermal equilibration between minerals at the parent body (PB) scale can be recorded in the isotopic signatures of meteorites. In this context, the acapulcoite–lodranite meteorite clan (ALC), which represents the products of thermal metamorphism and low‐degree partial melting of a primitive asteroid, is an attractive target to study the processes of early planetary differentiation. Here, we present a comprehensive data set of mass‐dependent Fe, Zn, and Mg isotope ratio variations in bulk ALC species, their separated silicate and metal phases, and in handpicked mineral fractions. These non‐traditional stable isotope ratios are governed by mass‐dependent isotope fractionation and provide a state‐of‐the‐art perspective on the evolution of the ALC PB, which is complementary to interpretations based on the petrology, trace element composition, and isotope geochemistry of the ALC. None of the isotopic signatures of ALC species show convincing co‐variation with the oxygen isotope ratios, which are considered to record nebular processes occurring prior to the PB formation. Iron isotopic compositions of ALC metal and silicate phases broadly fall on the isotherms within the temperature ranges predicted by pyroxene thermometry. The isotope ratios of Mg in ALC meteorites and their silicate minerals are within the range of chondritic meteorites, with only accessory spinel group minerals having significantly different compositions. Overall, the Mg and Fe isotopic signatures of the ALC species analyzed are in line with their formation as products of high‐degree thermal metamorphism and low‐degree partial melting of primitive precursors. The δ66/64Zn values of the ALC meteorites demonstrate a range of ~3.5‰ and the Zn is overall isotopically heavier than in chondrites. The superchondritic Zn isotopic signatures have possibly resulted from evaporative Zn losses, as observed for other meteorite parent bodies. This is unlikely to be the result of PB differentiation processes, as the Zn isotope ratio data show no covariation with the proxies of partial melting, such as the mass fractions of the platinum group and rare earth elements.
- 27 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 58 (11) , 1677-1690
The vesiculated layer in the anomalous diogenite Northwest Africa 12973
Diogenites, which are part of the howardite–eucrite–diogenite (HED) group, are considered to represent rocks from the lower crust and mantle of a differentiated planetary body, likely the asteroid 4 Vesta. The Northwest Africa 12973 (NWA 12973) meteorite was classified as an anomalous diogenite due to the occurrence of a vesiculated layer. This work reports on the petrographic and geochemical study of two fragments of this meteorite, aiming to better constrain the origin of the vesiculated layer. Whereas the interior of NWA 12973 (here called host) presents the typical characteristics of an olivine diogenite, that is, coarse‐grained pyroxene, olivine ribbons, chromite, and accessory phases, the vesiculated layer presents a fine‐grained pyroxene groundmass with local rounded relics of olivine and interstitial chromite and metal, and is characterized by abundant large vesicles. The contact between the vesiculated layer and the host is sharply defined. The composition of individual minerals does not show any significant differences between the host and the vesiculated layer, suggesting in situ melting. Geothermobarometry indicates a slightly higher crystallization temperature at lower pressure for the vesiculated layer, consistent with melting and crystallization under lower crustal conditions upon exhumation. The trigger for the local melting was likely a large impact event, which was responsible for adiabatic decompression in the central area or deep faulting and frictional melting.
- 27 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Meteoritics & Planetary Science
- Vol. 58 (11) , 1677-1690
The vesiculated layer in the anomalous diogenite Northwest Africa 12973
Diogenites, which are part of the howardite–eucrite–diogenite (HED) group, are considered to represent rocks from the lower crust and mantle of a differentiated planetary body, likely the asteroid 4 Vesta. The Northwest Africa 12973 (NWA 12973) meteorite was classified as an anomalous diogenite due to the occurrence of a vesiculated layer. This work reports on the petrographic and geochemical study of two fragments of this meteorite, aiming to better constrain the origin of the vesiculated layer. Whereas the interior of NWA 12973 (here called host) presents the typical characteristics of an olivine diogenite, that is, coarse‐grained pyroxene, olivine ribbons, chromite, and accessory phases, the vesiculated layer presents a fine‐grained pyroxene groundmass with local rounded relics of olivine and interstitial chromite and metal, and is characterized by abundant large vesicles. The contact between the vesiculated layer and the host is sharply defined. The composition of individual minerals does not show any significant differences between the host and the vesiculated layer, suggesting in situ melting. Geothermobarometry indicates a slightly higher crystallization temperature at lower pressure for the vesiculated layer, consistent with melting and crystallization under lower crustal conditions upon exhumation. The trigger for the local melting was likely a large impact event, which was responsible for adiabatic decompression in the central area or deep faulting and frictional melting.