Luisa M. Pettigrew
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Luisa M. Pettigrew has a total of 143 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jessica Watson
Centre for Academic Primary Care (CAPC), Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK
9 shared publications Ha-Neul Seo
5 shared publications- David Alan Cromwell
Department of Health Services Research and Policy, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK
4 shared publications Nicholas Mays
London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine Faculty of Public Health and Policy, Department of Health Services Research and Policy
4 shared publications- Nicholas Mays
Department of Health Services Research and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WC1H 9SH, UK
4 shared publications - Chris Smith
School of Tropical Medicine and Global Health, Nagasaki University, Nagasaki, Japan
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 January 2026
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (763) , 52-53
Winter pressures in general practice in England
- 30 January 2026
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (763) , 52-53
Open AccessWinter pressures in general practice in England
- Open Access
Trends in the shortfall of English NHS general practice doctors: repeat cross sectional study
Objectives To compare the numbers and characteristics of English general practitioner doctors (GPs) across publicly available data sources, and to examine trends in GP numbers relative to population growth and the specialist medical workforce in England. Design Repeat cross sectional study. Setting Three national data sources, England, 2012-24: General Medical Council (GMC) GP and specialist registers; NHS England GP Performers List; and NHS England’s General Practice Workforce and NHS Workforce Statistics datasets. Participants All GMC licensed, fully qualified GPs in England. Main outcome measures Differences over time in total numbers and GP characteristics. Changes in the difference between GMC and NHS general practice GP numbers and characteristics, and analysis of trends relative to population size and equivalent data on specialist doctors. Results As of 31 December 2024, 58 548 GPs were listed on the GMC GP register, 55 958 on the Performers List, but only 38 626 by headcount and 28 197 by full time equivalent GPs in NHS general practice. Between 2015 and 2024, on average, for every five additional GPs licensed by the GMC, NHS general practice lost one full time equivalent GP each year. As a result, the proportion of GMC licensed GPs not working in NHS general practice increased from 27% (13 492) in 2015 to 34% (19 922) in 2024 by headcount and from 41% (20 210) to 52% (30 351) by full time equivalent GPs. Differences were greatest among female GPs, younger GPs, UK qualified GPs, and GPs in London and the South East of England. In contrast, between 2015 and 2024, for every five additional GMC licensed specialist doctors, the NHS gained 4.3 full time equivalent consultants. Taking population growth into account, the number of NHS patients for each full time equivalent GP in NHS general practice increased by15%, whereas the number of patients for each full time equivalent NHS consultant fell by 18%. By the end of 2024, there were twice as many NHS patients for each full time equivalent NHS general practice GP (2260) than for each full time equivalent NHS consultant (1092). Conclusion The growing difference between GMC licensed GPs and those working in NHS general practice is in contrast with trends among specialists. This shift is occurring despite rising patient demand and policy commitments to strengthen primary care. Addressing the underlying reasons for workforce attrition in NHS general practice is critical to achieving the government’s stated goals of strengthening community based care and shifting the focus of care from treatment to prevention.
Open AccessTrends in the shortfall of English NHS general practice doctors: repeat cross sectional study
Objectives To compare the numbers and characteristics of English general practitioner doctors (GPs) across publicly available data sources, and to examine trends in GP numbers relative to population growth and the specialist medical workforce in England. Design Repeat cross sectional study. Setting Three national data sources, England, 2012-24: General Medical Council (GMC) GP and specialist registers; NHS England GP Performers List; and NHS England’s General Practice Workforce and NHS Workforce Statistics datasets. Participants All GMC licensed, fully qualified GPs in England. Main outcome measures Differences over time in total numbers and GP characteristics. Changes in the difference between GMC and NHS general practice GP numbers and characteristics, and analysis of trends relative to population size and equivalent data on specialist doctors. Results As of 31 December 2024, 58 548 GPs were listed on the GMC GP register, 55 958 on the Performers List, but only 38 626 by headcount and 28 197 by full time equivalent GPs in NHS general practice. Between 2015 and 2024, on average, for every five additional GPs licensed by the GMC, NHS general practice lost one full time equivalent GP each year. As a result, the proportion of GMC licensed GPs not working in NHS general practice increased from 27% (13 492) in 2015 to 34% (19 922) in 2024 by headcount and from 41% (20 210) to 52% (30 351) by full time equivalent GPs. Differences were greatest among female GPs, younger GPs, UK qualified GPs, and GPs in London and the South East of England. In contrast, between 2015 and 2024, for every five additional GMC licensed specialist doctors, the NHS gained 4.3 full time equivalent consultants. Taking population growth into account, the number of NHS patients for each full time equivalent GP in NHS general practice increased by15%, whereas the number of patients for each full time equivalent NHS consultant fell by 18%. By the end of 2024, there were twice as many NHS patients for each full time equivalent NHS general practice GP (2260) than for each full time equivalent NHS consultant (1092). Conclusion The growing difference between GMC licensed GPs and those working in NHS general practice is in contrast with trends among specialists. This shift is occurring despite rising patient demand and policy commitments to strengthen primary care. Addressing the underlying reasons for workforce attrition in NHS general practice is critical to achieving the government’s stated goals of strengthening community based care and shifting the focus of care from treatment to prevention.
- Open Access
- 18 June 2025
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (764) , e175-e182
Counting general practitioners: a comparative repeat cross-sectional analysis of GPs in NHS general practice in England
Background: There have been successive government promises to increase general practitioner (GP) numbers in England. Aim: To compare how NHS general practice GP numbers and trends differ depending on how GPs are defined and data are analysed. Design and setting: This was a comparative repeat cross-sectional study of NHS general practice GP numbers in England. Method: The study compared NHS England’s General Practice Workforce GP data quarterly between September 2015 and September 2024 by headcount and full-time equivalent (FTE); with and without general practice trainees; and relative to population size. Results: Between September 2015 and September 2024, if counting fully qualified GPs and general practice trainees, there was an 18% (41 193 to 48 758) rise in numbers; whereas if fully qualified FTE GPs alone were counted there was a 5% reduction (29 364 to 27 966). Once growth of the population registered with an NHS general practice was considered, the trend in GPs per capita varied between a 6% rise or 15% reduction. There was an increasing difference in the number of patients per GP between practices, with a 5th to 95th percentile range of 1204 and 4139 patients per fully qualified FTE GP in 2015; by 2024 these percentiles increased to 1357 and 5559. Using Office for National Statistics (ONS) mid-year population estimates produced different results as their population estimates are lower than the total number of patients registered with an NHS general practice. Conclusion: How GPs are defined, whether working hours are considered, and what measure of population size is used affects the interpretation of workforce trends. Using fully qualified FTE GPs per capita most closely reflects GP capacity, although there are limitations to current NHS data. Reporting the spread of patients per GP at practice level is necessary to capture the widening variation in GP provision in England.
- 18 June 2025
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in British Journal of General Practice
- Vol. 76 (764) , e175-e182
Open AccessCounting general practitioners: a comparative repeat cross-sectional analysis of GPs in NHS general practice in England
Background: There have been successive government promises to increase general practitioner (GP) numbers in England. Aim: To compare how NHS general practice GP numbers and trends differ depending on how GPs are defined and data are analysed. Design and setting: This was a comparative repeat cross-sectional study of NHS general practice GP numbers in England. Method: The study compared NHS England’s General Practice Workforce GP data quarterly between September 2015 and September 2024 by headcount and full-time equivalent (FTE); with and without general practice trainees; and relative to population size. Results: Between September 2015 and September 2024, if counting fully qualified GPs and general practice trainees, there was an 18% (41 193 to 48 758) rise in numbers; whereas if fully qualified FTE GPs alone were counted there was a 5% reduction (29 364 to 27 966). Once growth of the population registered with an NHS general practice was considered, the trend in GPs per capita varied between a 6% rise or 15% reduction. There was an increasing difference in the number of patients per GP between practices, with a 5th to 95th percentile range of 1204 and 4139 patients per fully qualified FTE GP in 2015; by 2024 these percentiles increased to 1357 and 5559. Using Office for National Statistics (ONS) mid-year population estimates produced different results as their population estimates are lower than the total number of patients registered with an NHS general practice. Conclusion: How GPs are defined, whether working hours are considered, and what measure of population size is used affects the interpretation of workforce trends. Using fully qualified FTE GPs per capita most closely reflects GP capacity, although there are limitations to current NHS data. Reporting the spread of patients per GP at practice level is necessary to capture the widening variation in GP provision in England.
- Open Access
- 20 November 2024
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in BJGP Open
- Vol. 9 (2)
General practice characteristics associated with pay-for-performance in the UK: a systematic review
Background: The Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF), a pay-for-performance programme, has been the most widespread quality initiative in NHS general practice since 2004. It has contributed between 25% and 8% of practices’ income during this time, but concerns about its effect on equity have been raised. Aim: To understand which practice characteristics are associated with QOF performance. Design and setting: A systematic review was conducted, focusing on NHS general practice in the UK. Method: MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL+, Web of Science, and grey literature were searched for studies examining the association between general practice characteristics and QOF performance. Results: Twenty-two studies, published between 2006 and 2022, exploring the relationship between six population and 15 organisational characteristics and QOF measures were found. Most studies were cross-sectional, of English general practices, and used data from the early years of QOF. A negative association was frequently found between overall QOF performance and socioeconomic deprivation; increasing proportion of registered patients aged >65 years; increasing list size; increasing mean GP age; and Alternative Provider Medical Services contracts. Group practices (versus single-handed), more full-time equivalent (FTE) GPs, and being a training practice were frequently associated with better overall QOF performance. The associations of most other characteristics with performance were inconsistent. Conclusion: Associations with characteristics both within and outside practices’ control were identified. Pay-for-performance instruments may systematically disadvantage practices serving those at greatest risk of ill-health such as older and more deprived populations. Given the cross-sectional design of many studies and focus on the early years of QOF, more up-to-date evidence is needed to understand if and why these relationships persist.
- 20 November 2024
- Published by Royal College of General Practitioners in BJGP Open
- Vol. 9 (2)
Open AccessGeneral practice characteristics associated with pay-for-performance in the UK: a systematic review
Background: The Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF), a pay-for-performance programme, has been the most widespread quality initiative in NHS general practice since 2004. It has contributed between 25% and 8% of practices’ income during this time, but concerns about its effect on equity have been raised. Aim: To understand which practice characteristics are associated with QOF performance. Design and setting: A systematic review was conducted, focusing on NHS general practice in the UK. Method: MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL+, Web of Science, and grey literature were searched for studies examining the association between general practice characteristics and QOF performance. Results: Twenty-two studies, published between 2006 and 2022, exploring the relationship between six population and 15 organisational characteristics and QOF measures were found. Most studies were cross-sectional, of English general practices, and used data from the early years of QOF. A negative association was frequently found between overall QOF performance and socioeconomic deprivation; increasing proportion of registered patients aged >65 years; increasing list size; increasing mean GP age; and Alternative Provider Medical Services contracts. Group practices (versus single-handed), more full-time equivalent (FTE) GPs, and being a training practice were frequently associated with better overall QOF performance. The associations of most other characteristics with performance were inconsistent. Conclusion: Associations with characteristics both within and outside practices’ control were identified. Pay-for-performance instruments may systematically disadvantage practices serving those at greatest risk of ill-health such as older and more deprived populations. Given the cross-sectional design of many studies and focus on the early years of QOF, more up-to-date evidence is needed to understand if and why these relationships persist.
- Open Access
The changing shape of English general practice: a retrospective longitudinal study using national datasets describing trends in organisational structure, workforce and recorded appointments
Objective To describe trends in the organisational structure, workforce and recorded appointments by role in English general practice. Design Retrospective longitudinal study. Setting English general practice. Data sources and participants NHS England, Office for Health Improvement and Disparities and Care Quality Commission national administrative datasets covering between 5 to 10 years from 2013 to 2023. Results Between 2013 and 2023, the number of general practices fell by 20% from 8044 to 6419; the average practice list size increase by 40% from 6967 to 9724 patients. The total population covered by providers with over 100 000 registered patients reached 2.3 million in 2023 compared to 0.5 million in 2017. The proportion of practices under individual ownership decreased from 13% to 11% between 2018 and 2023; there was little change in the proportion owned by partnerships, incorporated companies or NHS bodies, which respectively averaged around 80.3%, 6.9% and 0.7%. Between 2015 and 2022, there was a 20% rise in the total full-time equivalent (FTE) general practice workforce, including Primary Care Network staff, from 1.97 to 2.37 per 1000 patients because of an increase in multidisciplinary other 'Direct Patient Care' (DPC) and administrative roles. The number of nurses remained stable, and the number of qualified general practitioners (GPs) decreased by 15%. In September 2022, there were 0.45 FTE qualified GPs per 1000 patients; GPs and other DPC roles, excluding nurses, each represented 19% of the FTE per 1000 patients workforce; administrative roles represented 51%. The general practice workforce is predominantly female. A quarter of GPs qualified overseas. Between 2018 and 2023, there was no clear upward or downward trend in total appointments per 1000 patients with, on average, half provided by GPs. Conclusions Since 2013, there has been a shift in general practice towards larger practices with more multidisciplinary teams, alongside a reduction in the number of FTE qualified GPs per 1000 patients. We recommend that the impacts of these changes on access, quality and costs are closely monitored.
Open AccessThe changing shape of English general practice: a retrospective longitudinal study using national datasets describing trends in organisational structure, workforce and recorded appointments
Objective To describe trends in the organisational structure, workforce and recorded appointments by role in English general practice. Design Retrospective longitudinal study. Setting English general practice. Data sources and participants NHS England, Office for Health Improvement and Disparities and Care Quality Commission national administrative datasets covering between 5 to 10 years from 2013 to 2023. Results Between 2013 and 2023, the number of general practices fell by 20% from 8044 to 6419; the average practice list size increase by 40% from 6967 to 9724 patients. The total population covered by providers with over 100 000 registered patients reached 2.3 million in 2023 compared to 0.5 million in 2017. The proportion of practices under individual ownership decreased from 13% to 11% between 2018 and 2023; there was little change in the proportion owned by partnerships, incorporated companies or NHS bodies, which respectively averaged around 80.3%, 6.9% and 0.7%. Between 2015 and 2022, there was a 20% rise in the total full-time equivalent (FTE) general practice workforce, including Primary Care Network staff, from 1.97 to 2.37 per 1000 patients because of an increase in multidisciplinary other 'Direct Patient Care' (DPC) and administrative roles. The number of nurses remained stable, and the number of qualified general practitioners (GPs) decreased by 15%. In September 2022, there were 0.45 FTE qualified GPs per 1000 patients; GPs and other DPC roles, excluding nurses, each represented 19% of the FTE per 1000 patients workforce; administrative roles represented 51%. The general practice workforce is predominantly female. A quarter of GPs qualified overseas. Between 2018 and 2023, there was no clear upward or downward trend in total appointments per 1000 patients with, on average, half provided by GPs. Conclusions Since 2013, there has been a shift in general practice towards larger practices with more multidisciplinary teams, alongside a reduction in the number of FTE qualified GPs per 1000 patients. We recommend that the impacts of these changes on access, quality and costs are closely monitored.
- Open Access
Electronic health record-based behaviour change interventions aimed at general practitioners in the UK: a mixed methods systematic review using behaviour change theory
Objectives Electronic health record (EHR) systems are used extensively in healthcare; their design can influence clinicians’ behaviour. We conducted a systematic review of EHR-based interventions aimed at changing the clinical practice of general practitioners in the UK, assessed their effectiveness and applied behaviour change theory to identify lessons for other settings. Design Mixed methods systematic review. Data sources MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTRAL and APA PsycINFO were searched up to March 2023. Eligibility criteria Quantitative and qualitative findings from randomised controlled trials (RCTs) controlled before-and-after studies and interrupted time series of EHR-based interventions in UK general practice were included. Data extraction and synthesis Quantitative synthesis was based on Cochrane’s Synthesis without Meta-analysis. Interventions were categorised using the Behaviour Change Wheel and MINDSPACE frameworks and effectiveness determined by vote-counting using direction of effect. Inductive thematic synthesis was used for qualitative studies. Results Database searching identified 3824 unique articles; 10 were included (from 2002 to 2021), comprising eight RCTs and two associated qualitative studies. Four of seven quantitative studies showed a positive effect on clinician behaviour and three on patient-level outcomes. Behaviour change techniques that may trigger emotions and required less cognitive engagement appeared to have positive effects. Qualitative findings indicated that interventions reassured clinicians of their decisions but were sometimes ignored. Conclusion Despite widespread use, there is little high quality, up-to-date experimental evidence evaluating the effectiveness of EHR-based interventions in UK general practice. The evidence suggested EHR-based interventions may be effective at changing behaviour. Persistent, simple action-oriented prompts appeared more effective than complex interventions requiring greater cognitive engagement. However, studies lacked detail in intervention design and theory behind design choices. Future research should seek to optimise EHR-based behaviour change intervention design and delineate limitations, providing theory-based justification for interventions. This will be of increasing importance with the growing use of EHRs to influence clinicians’ decisions. PROSPERO registration number CRD42022341009.
Open AccessElectronic health record-based behaviour change interventions aimed at general practitioners in the UK: a mixed methods systematic review using behaviour change theory
Objectives Electronic health record (EHR) systems are used extensively in healthcare; their design can influence clinicians’ behaviour. We conducted a systematic review of EHR-based interventions aimed at changing the clinical practice of general practitioners in the UK, assessed their effectiveness and applied behaviour change theory to identify lessons for other settings. Design Mixed methods systematic review. Data sources MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTRAL and APA PsycINFO were searched up to March 2023. Eligibility criteria Quantitative and qualitative findings from randomised controlled trials (RCTs) controlled before-and-after studies and interrupted time series of EHR-based interventions in UK general practice were included. Data extraction and synthesis Quantitative synthesis was based on Cochrane’s Synthesis without Meta-analysis. Interventions were categorised using the Behaviour Change Wheel and MINDSPACE frameworks and effectiveness determined by vote-counting using direction of effect. Inductive thematic synthesis was used for qualitative studies. Results Database searching identified 3824 unique articles; 10 were included (from 2002 to 2021), comprising eight RCTs and two associated qualitative studies. Four of seven quantitative studies showed a positive effect on clinician behaviour and three on patient-level outcomes. Behaviour change techniques that may trigger emotions and required less cognitive engagement appeared to have positive effects. Qualitative findings indicated that interventions reassured clinicians of their decisions but were sometimes ignored. Conclusion Despite widespread use, there is little high quality, up-to-date experimental evidence evaluating the effectiveness of EHR-based interventions in UK general practice. The evidence suggested EHR-based interventions may be effective at changing behaviour. Persistent, simple action-oriented prompts appeared more effective than complex interventions requiring greater cognitive engagement. However, studies lacked detail in intervention design and theory behind design choices. Future research should seek to optimise EHR-based behaviour change intervention design and delineate limitations, providing theory-based justification for interventions. This will be of increasing importance with the growing use of EHRs to influence clinicians’ decisions. PROSPERO registration number CRD42022341009.
- Open Access
- 7 December 2023
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Global Health
- Vol. 8 (12) , e014442
The role of Primary Health Care, primary care and hospitals in advancing Universal Health Coverage
- 7 December 2023
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Global Health
- Vol. 8 (12) , e014442
Open AccessThe role of Primary Health Care, primary care and hospitals in advancing Universal Health Coverage
- Open Access
- 15 August 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-21
Workplace-based knowledge exchange programmes between academics, policymakers and providers in the health and social care sector: a scoping review and mapping exercise
Knowledge mobilisation can be achieved through various routes. This can include immersive, in-person time spent in a different workplace with people from other disciplines or sub-sectors. By doing so participants mobilise and exchange knowledge through observing the dynamics of a different workplace; by learning directly from others with different expertise and/or through sharing their own expertise. We have called this form of knowledge exchange ‘Workplace-based Knowledge Exchange Programmes’ (WKEPs) and have focused on their role in the health and care sector because of the importance of knowledge mobilisation in this field yet their relatively low profile in the literature. This study explores the main characteristics of WKEPs among academics, providers, and policymakers in the health and care sector in the United Kingdom (UK) through a scoping review and mapping exercise. We systematically identified 147 academic articles (between 2010 and 2022) and 74 websites which offered WKEPs as part of, or all of, their knowledge mobilisation activities (between 2020 and 2022). Characteristics were grouped into structures, processes, and outcomes. WKEPs lasted between one day and five years and were mostly uni-directional. Exchange ambitions varied, aiming to benefit both the participants and their working environments. They commonly aimed to build networks or collaborations, improve understanding of another field and bring back knowledge to their employer, as well as improve leadership and management skills. Almost all programmes were for healthcare providers and academics, rather than social care providers or policymakers. In-person WKEP activities could be categorised into four domains: ‘job shadowing’, ‘work placements’, ‘project-based collaborations’, and ‘secondments’. The aims of many of the WKEPs were not clearly described and formal evaluations were rare. We used the findings of this study to develop a framework to describe WKEP activities. We suggest the use of common language for these activities to aid participation and research, as well as recommending principles for the comprehensive advertising of WKEPs and reporting of experiences after participation in WKEPs. We recommend the establishment of an online repository to improve access to WKEPs. These resources are necessary to strengthen understanding and the effectiveness of WKEPs as a mechanism for knowledge mobilisation.
- 15 August 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-21
Open AccessWorkplace-based knowledge exchange programmes between academics, policymakers and providers in the health and social care sector: a scoping review and mapping exercise
Knowledge mobilisation can be achieved through various routes. This can include immersive, in-person time spent in a different workplace with people from other disciplines or sub-sectors. By doing so participants mobilise and exchange knowledge through observing the dynamics of a different workplace; by learning directly from others with different expertise and/or through sharing their own expertise. We have called this form of knowledge exchange ‘Workplace-based Knowledge Exchange Programmes’ (WKEPs) and have focused on their role in the health and care sector because of the importance of knowledge mobilisation in this field yet their relatively low profile in the literature. This study explores the main characteristics of WKEPs among academics, providers, and policymakers in the health and care sector in the United Kingdom (UK) through a scoping review and mapping exercise. We systematically identified 147 academic articles (between 2010 and 2022) and 74 websites which offered WKEPs as part of, or all of, their knowledge mobilisation activities (between 2020 and 2022). Characteristics were grouped into structures, processes, and outcomes. WKEPs lasted between one day and five years and were mostly uni-directional. Exchange ambitions varied, aiming to benefit both the participants and their working environments. They commonly aimed to build networks or collaborations, improve understanding of another field and bring back knowledge to their employer, as well as improve leadership and management skills. Almost all programmes were for healthcare providers and academics, rather than social care providers or policymakers. In-person WKEP activities could be categorised into four domains: ‘job shadowing’, ‘work placements’, ‘project-based collaborations’, and ‘secondments’. The aims of many of the WKEPs were not clearly described and formal evaluations were rare. We used the findings of this study to develop a framework to describe WKEP activities. We suggest the use of common language for these activities to aid participation and research, as well as recommending principles for the comprehensive advertising of WKEPs and reporting of experiences after participation in WKEPs. We recommend the establishment of an online repository to improve access to WKEPs. These resources are necessary to strengthen understanding and the effectiveness of WKEPs as a mechanism for knowledge mobilisation.
- Open Access
- 10 July 2023
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Leader
- Vol. 8 (1) , 15-19
Workplace-based knowledge exchange programmes between academics, policy-makers and providers of healthcare: a qualitative study
Background: Workplace-based knowledge exchange programmes (WKEPs), such as job shadowing or secondments, offer potential for health and care providers, academics, and policy-makers to foster partnerships, develop local solutions and overcome key differences in practices. Yet opportunities for exchange can be hard to find and are poorly reported in the literature. Objectives: To understand the views of providers, academics and policy-makers regarding WKEPs, in particular, their motivations to participate in such exchanges and the perceived barriers and facilitators to participation. Methods: A qualitative study involving semistructured interviews with 20 healthcare providers, academics and policy-makers in England. Rapid data collection and analysis techniques were employed. Interviews formed part of a wider scoping study that mapped the characteristics and existing literature related to WKEPs. Results: Interviewees reported being motivated to develop, sponsor and/or participate in WKEPs with a clear purpose and defined outcomes that could demonstrate the value of the time out of work to their organisations. Perceived barriers included competitive application processes for national fellowships, a lack of knowing how to identify with whom to undertake an exchange (varying ‘tribes’), and the burdens of time, costs and administration regarding arranging exchanges. WKEPs were reported to work best where there was a perceived sense of shared purpose, long-standing relationship and trust between organisations. Facilitators included existing confidentiality agreements and/or shared professional standards, as well as funding. Conclusion: WKEPs were reported to be valuable experiences but required significant organisational buy-in and cooperation to arrange and sustain. To benefit emerging partnerships, such as the new integrated care systems in England, more outcomes evaluations of existing WKEPs are needed, and research focused on overcoming barriers to participation, such as time and costs.
- 10 July 2023
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Leader
- Vol. 8 (1) , 15-19
Open AccessWorkplace-based knowledge exchange programmes between academics, policy-makers and providers of healthcare: a qualitative study
Background: Workplace-based knowledge exchange programmes (WKEPs), such as job shadowing or secondments, offer potential for health and care providers, academics, and policy-makers to foster partnerships, develop local solutions and overcome key differences in practices. Yet opportunities for exchange can be hard to find and are poorly reported in the literature. Objectives: To understand the views of providers, academics and policy-makers regarding WKEPs, in particular, their motivations to participate in such exchanges and the perceived barriers and facilitators to participation. Methods: A qualitative study involving semistructured interviews with 20 healthcare providers, academics and policy-makers in England. Rapid data collection and analysis techniques were employed. Interviews formed part of a wider scoping study that mapped the characteristics and existing literature related to WKEPs. Results: Interviewees reported being motivated to develop, sponsor and/or participate in WKEPs with a clear purpose and defined outcomes that could demonstrate the value of the time out of work to their organisations. Perceived barriers included competitive application processes for national fellowships, a lack of knowing how to identify with whom to undertake an exchange (varying ‘tribes’), and the burdens of time, costs and administration regarding arranging exchanges. WKEPs were reported to work best where there was a perceived sense of shared purpose, long-standing relationship and trust between organisations. Facilitators included existing confidentiality agreements and/or shared professional standards, as well as funding. Conclusion: WKEPs were reported to be valuable experiences but required significant organisational buy-in and cooperation to arrange and sustain. To benefit emerging partnerships, such as the new integrated care systems in England, more outcomes evaluations of existing WKEPs are needed, and research focused on overcoming barriers to participation, such as time and costs.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 30 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Systematic Reviews
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-20
Barriers and facilitators to clinical behaviour change by primary care practitioners: a theory-informed systematic review of reviews using the Theoretical Domains Framework and Behaviour Change Wheel
Background: Understanding the barriers and facilitators to behaviour change by primary care practitioners (PCPs) is vital to inform the design and implementation of successful Behaviour Change Interventions (BCIs), embed evidence-based medicine into routine clinical practice, and improve quality of care and population health outcomes. Methods: A theory-led systematic review of reviews examining barriers and facilitators to clinical behaviour change by PCPs in high-income primary care contexts using PRISMA. Embase, MEDLINE, PsychInfo, HMIC and Cochrane Library were searched. Content and framework analysis was used to map reported barriers and facilitators to the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) and describe emergent themes. Intervention functions and policy categories to change behaviour associated with these domains were identified using the COM-B Model and Behaviour Change Wheel (BCW). Results: Four thousand three hundred eighty-eight reviews were identified. Nineteen were included. The average quality score was 7.5/11. Reviews infrequently used theory to structure their methods or interpret their findings. Barriers and facilitators most frequently identified as important were principally related to ‘Knowledge’, ‘Environmental context and resources’ and ‘Social influences’ TDF domains. These fall under the ‘Capability’ and ‘Opportunity’ domains of COM-B, and are linked with interventions related to education, training, restriction, environmental restructuring and enablement. From this, three key areas for policy change include guidelines, regulation and legislation. Factors least frequently identified as important were related to ‘Motivation’ and other psychological aspects of ‘Capability’ of COM-B. Based on this, BCW intervention functions of persuasion, incentivisation, coercion and modelling may be perceived as less relevant by PCPs to change behaviour. Conclusions: PCPs commonly perceive barriers and facilitators to behaviour change related to the ‘Capability’ and ‘Opportunity’ domains of COM-B. PCPs may lack insight into the role that ‘Motivation’ and aspects of psychological ‘Capability’ have in behaviour change and/or that research methods have been inadequate to capture their function. Future research should apply theory-based frameworks and appropriate design methods to explore these factors. With no ‘one size fits all’ intervention, these findings provide general, transferable insights into how to approach changing clinical behaviour by PCPs, based on their own views on the barriers and facilitators to behaviour change. Systematic review registration: A protocol was submitted to the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine via the Ethics and CARE form submission on 16.4.2020, ref number 21478 (available on request). The project was not registered on PROSPERO.
- 30 August 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Systematic Reviews
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-20
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessBarriers and facilitators to clinical behaviour change by primary care practitioners: a theory-informed systematic review of reviews using the Theoretical Domains Framework and Behaviour Change Wheel
Background: Understanding the barriers and facilitators to behaviour change by primary care practitioners (PCPs) is vital to inform the design and implementation of successful Behaviour Change Interventions (BCIs), embed evidence-based medicine into routine clinical practice, and improve quality of care and population health outcomes. Methods: A theory-led systematic review of reviews examining barriers and facilitators to clinical behaviour change by PCPs in high-income primary care contexts using PRISMA. Embase, MEDLINE, PsychInfo, HMIC and Cochrane Library were searched. Content and framework analysis was used to map reported barriers and facilitators to the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) and describe emergent themes. Intervention functions and policy categories to change behaviour associated with these domains were identified using the COM-B Model and Behaviour Change Wheel (BCW). Results: Four thousand three hundred eighty-eight reviews were identified. Nineteen were included. The average quality score was 7.5/11. Reviews infrequently used theory to structure their methods or interpret their findings. Barriers and facilitators most frequently identified as important were principally related to ‘Knowledge’, ‘Environmental context and resources’ and ‘Social influences’ TDF domains. These fall under the ‘Capability’ and ‘Opportunity’ domains of COM-B, and are linked with interventions related to education, training, restriction, environmental restructuring and enablement. From this, three key areas for policy change include guidelines, regulation and legislation. Factors least frequently identified as important were related to ‘Motivation’ and other psychological aspects of ‘Capability’ of COM-B. Based on this, BCW intervention functions of persuasion, incentivisation, coercion and modelling may be perceived as less relevant by PCPs to change behaviour. Conclusions: PCPs commonly perceive barriers and facilitators to behaviour change related to the ‘Capability’ and ‘Opportunity’ domains of COM-B. PCPs may lack insight into the role that ‘Motivation’ and aspects of psychological ‘Capability’ have in behaviour change and/or that research methods have been inadequate to capture their function. Future research should apply theory-based frameworks and appropriate design methods to explore these factors. With no ‘one size fits all’ intervention, these findings provide general, transferable insights into how to approach changing clinical behaviour by PCPs, based on their own views on the barriers and facilitators to behaviour change. Systematic review registration: A protocol was submitted to the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine via the Ethics and CARE form submission on 16.4.2020, ref number 21478 (available on request). The project was not registered on PROSPERO.