Wim Van der Elst
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Wim Van der Elst has a total of 73 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Jelle Jolles
C Centre for Brain & Learning, Faculty of Behavioral and Movement Sciences , Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam , Amsterdam , The Netherlands
18 shared publicationsGeert Molenberghs
I‐BioStat, Department of Mathematics and Statistics Universiteit Hasselt Diepenbeek Belgium
7 shared publicationsMartin P. J. Van Boxtel
Maastricht University
7 shared publications- Gerard J. P. van Breukelen
Department of Methodology and Statistics, Care and Public Health Research Institute (CAPHRI), Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands
6 shared publications - Geert Molenberghs
Universiteit Hasselt, Hasselt, Belgium
5 shared publications - Ariel Alonso
L‐BioStat, KU Leuven Leuven Belgium
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 12 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Pharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 25 (4) , e70110
The Impact of Model Misspecification on the Individual Causal Association in Surrogate Endpoint Evaluation
Surrogate endpoints are often used in place of expensive, delayed, or rare clinical endpoints in clinical trials. However, regulatory authorities require thorough evaluation to accept these surrogate endpoints as reliable substitutes. One evaluation approach is the information‐theoretic causal inference framework, which quantifies surrogacy using the individual causal association (ICA). Like most causal inference methods, this approach relies on models that are only partially identifiable. For continuous outcomes, a normal model is often used. In this study, we explored the effects of model misspecification across various scenarios. We first considered true data‐generating mechanisms based on multivariate and log‐normal distributions. We then used D‐vine copulas with Gaussian, Clayton, Gumbel, and Frank families to vary the unidentifiable copulas involving counterfactual pairs while preserving the observable bivariate margins, and considered intuitive restrictions on nonidentified correlations, including positivity and conditional independence. In all settings, the identifiability issue was addressed through sensitivity analysis. Finally, we illustrate the proposed sensitivity analyses using clinical‐trial data from schizophrenia studies, evaluating the ICA under several modeling assumptions. The results show that, in most scenarios considered, the impact of model misspecification is small; however, certain departures from the assumed model can materially affect the surrogacy assessment.
- 12 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Pharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 25 (4) , e70110
The Impact of Model Misspecification on the Individual Causal Association in Surrogate Endpoint Evaluation
Surrogate endpoints are often used in place of expensive, delayed, or rare clinical endpoints in clinical trials. However, regulatory authorities require thorough evaluation to accept these surrogate endpoints as reliable substitutes. One evaluation approach is the information‐theoretic causal inference framework, which quantifies surrogacy using the individual causal association (ICA). Like most causal inference methods, this approach relies on models that are only partially identifiable. For continuous outcomes, a normal model is often used. In this study, we explored the effects of model misspecification across various scenarios. We first considered true data‐generating mechanisms based on multivariate and log‐normal distributions. We then used D‐vine copulas with Gaussian, Clayton, Gumbel, and Frank families to vary the unidentifiable copulas involving counterfactual pairs while preserving the observable bivariate margins, and considered intuitive restrictions on nonidentified correlations, including positivity and conditional independence. In all settings, the identifiability issue was addressed through sensitivity analysis. Finally, we illustrate the proposed sensitivity analyses using clinical‐trial data from schizophrenia studies, evaluating the ICA under several modeling assumptions. The results show that, in most scenarios considered, the impact of model misspecification is small; however, certain departures from the assumed model can materially affect the surrogacy assessment.
- 29 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Pharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 24 (1)
Assessing the Operational Characteristics of the Individual Causal Association as a Metric of Surrogacy in the Binary Continuous Setting
In a causal inference framework, a new metric has been proposed to quantify surrogacy for a continuous putative surrogate and a binary true endpoint, based on information theory. The proposed metric, termed the individual causal association (ICA), was quantified using a joint causal inference model for the corresponding potential outcomes. Due to the non‐identifiability inherent in this type of models, a sensitivity analysis was introduced to study the behavior of the ICA as a function of the non‐identifiable parameters characterizing the aforementioned model. In this scenario, to reduce uncertainty, several plausible yet untestable assumptions like monotonicity, independence, conditional independence or homogeneous variance–covariance, are often incorporated into the analysis. We assess the robustness of the methodology regarding these simplifying assumptions via simulation. The practical implications of the findings are demonstrated in the analysis of a randomized clinical trial evaluating an inactivated quadrivalent influenza vaccine.
- 29 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Pharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 24 (1)
Assessing the Operational Characteristics of the Individual Causal Association as a Metric of Surrogacy in the Binary Continuous Setting
In a causal inference framework, a new metric has been proposed to quantify surrogacy for a continuous putative surrogate and a binary true endpoint, based on information theory. The proposed metric, termed the individual causal association (ICA), was quantified using a joint causal inference model for the corresponding potential outcomes. Due to the non‐identifiability inherent in this type of models, a sensitivity analysis was introduced to study the behavior of the ICA as a function of the non‐identifiable parameters characterizing the aforementioned model. In this scenario, to reduce uncertainty, several plausible yet untestable assumptions like monotonicity, independence, conditional independence or homogeneous variance–covariance, are often incorporated into the analysis. We assess the robustness of the methodology regarding these simplifying assumptions via simulation. The practical implications of the findings are demonstrated in the analysis of a randomized clinical trial evaluating an inactivated quadrivalent influenza vaccine.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Statistics in Medicine
- Vol. 43 (6) , 1083-1102
An information‐theoretic approach for the assessment of a continuous outcome as a surrogate for a binary true endpoint based on causal inference: Application to vaccine evaluation
Within the causal association paradigm, a method is proposed to assess the validity of a continuous outcome as a surrogate for a binary true endpoint. The methodology is based on a previously introduced information‐theoretic definition of surrogacy and has two main steps. In the first step, a new model is proposed to describe the joint distribution of the potential outcomes associated with the putative surrogate and the true endpoint of interest. The identifiability issues inherent to this type of models are handled via sensitivity analysis. In the second step, a metric of surrogacy new to this setting, the so‐called individual causal association is presented. The methodology is studied in detail using theoretical considerations, some simulations, and data from a randomized clinical trial evaluating an inactivated quadrivalent influenza vaccine. A user‐friendly R package Surrogate is provided to carry out the evaluation exercise.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Wiley in Statistics in Medicine
- Vol. 43 (6) , 1083-1102
An information‐theoretic approach for the assessment of a continuous outcome as a surrogate for a binary true endpoint based on causal inference: Application to vaccine evaluation
Within the causal association paradigm, a method is proposed to assess the validity of a continuous outcome as a surrogate for a binary true endpoint. The methodology is based on a previously introduced information‐theoretic definition of surrogacy and has two main steps. In the first step, a new model is proposed to describe the joint distribution of the potential outcomes associated with the putative surrogate and the true endpoint of interest. The identifiability issues inherent to this type of models are handled via sensitivity analysis. In the second step, a metric of surrogacy new to this setting, the so‐called individual causal association is presented. The methodology is studied in detail using theoretical considerations, some simulations, and data from a randomized clinical trial evaluating an inactivated quadrivalent influenza vaccine. A user‐friendly R package Surrogate is provided to carry out the evaluation exercise.
- 8 September 2023
- Published by The R Foundation
NormData: Derivation of Regression-Based Normative Data
- 8 September 2023
- Published by The R Foundation
NormData: Derivation of Regression-Based Normative Data
- 27 December 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Biopharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 32 (5) , 705-716
Implementing the meta-analytic approach for the evaluation of surrogate endpoints in SAS and R: a word of caution
The meta-analytic approach has become the gold-standard methodology for the evaluation of surrogate endpoints and several implementations are currently available in SAS and R. The methodology is based on hierarchical models that are numerically demanding and, when the amount of data is limited, maximum likelihood algorithms may not converge or may converge to an ill-conditioned maximum such as a boundary solution. This may produce misleading conclusions and have negative implications for the evaluation of new drugs. In the present work, we explore the use of two distinct functions in R (lme and lmer) and the MIXED procedure in SAS to assess the validity of putative surrogate endpoints in the meta-analytic framework, via simulations and the analysis of a real case study. We describe some problems found with the lmer function in R that led to a poorer performance as compared with the lme function and MIXED procedure.
- 27 December 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Biopharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 32 (5) , 705-716
Implementing the meta-analytic approach for the evaluation of surrogate endpoints in SAS and R: a word of caution
The meta-analytic approach has become the gold-standard methodology for the evaluation of surrogate endpoints and several implementations are currently available in SAS and R. The methodology is based on hierarchical models that are numerically demanding and, when the amount of data is limited, maximum likelihood algorithms may not converge or may converge to an ill-conditioned maximum such as a boundary solution. This may produce misleading conclusions and have negative implications for the evaluation of new drugs. In the present work, we explore the use of two distinct functions in R (lme and lmer) and the MIXED procedure in SAS to assess the validity of putative surrogate endpoints in the meta-analytic framework, via simulations and the analysis of a real case study. We describe some problems found with the lmer function in R that led to a poorer performance as compared with the lme function and MIXED procedure.
- 21 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in Pharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 20 (6) , 1216-1231
The individual‐level surrogate threshold effect in a causal‐inference setting with normally distributed endpoints
In the meta‐analytic surrogate evaluation framework, the trial‐level coefficient of determination quantifies the strength of the association between the expected causal treatment effects on the surrogate (S) and the true (T) endpoints. Burzykowski and Buyse supplemented this metric of surrogacy with the surrogate threshold effect (STE), which is defined as the minimum value of the causal treatment effect on S for which the predicted causal treatment effect on T exceeds zero. The STE supplements with a more direct clinically interpretable metric of surrogacy. Alonso et al. proposed to evaluate surrogacy based on the strength of the association between the individual (rather than expected) causal treatment effects on S and T. In the current paper, the individual‐level surrogate threshold effect (ISTE) is introduced in the setting where S and T are normally distributed variables. ISTE is defined as the minimum value of the individual causal treatment effect on S for which the lower limit of the prediction interval around the individual causal treatment effect on T exceeds zero. The newly proposed methodology is applied in a case study, and it is illustrated that ISTE has an appealing clinical interpretation. The R package surrogate implements the methodology and a web appendix (supporting information) that details how the analyses can be conducted in practice is provided.
- 21 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in Pharmaceutical Statistics
- Vol. 20 (6) , 1216-1231
The individual‐level surrogate threshold effect in a causal‐inference setting with normally distributed endpoints
In the meta‐analytic surrogate evaluation framework, the trial‐level coefficient of determination quantifies the strength of the association between the expected causal treatment effects on the surrogate (S) and the true (T) endpoints. Burzykowski and Buyse supplemented this metric of surrogacy with the surrogate threshold effect (STE), which is defined as the minimum value of the causal treatment effect on S for which the predicted causal treatment effect on T exceeds zero. The STE supplements with a more direct clinically interpretable metric of surrogacy. Alonso et al. proposed to evaluate surrogacy based on the strength of the association between the individual (rather than expected) causal treatment effects on S and T. In the current paper, the individual‐level surrogate threshold effect (ISTE) is introduced in the setting where S and T are normally distributed variables. ISTE is defined as the minimum value of the individual causal treatment effect on S for which the lower limit of the prediction interval around the individual causal treatment effect on T exceeds zero. The newly proposed methodology is applied in a case study, and it is illustrated that ISTE has an appealing clinical interpretation. The R package surrogate implements the methodology and a web appendix (supporting information) that details how the analyses can be conducted in practice is provided.
- 20 November 2020
- Published by Wiley in Statistics in Medicine
- Vol. 39 (26) , 3867-3878
On the relationship between association and surrogacy when both the surrogate and true endpoint are binary outcomes
The relationship between association and surrogacy has been the focus of much debate in the surrogate marker literature. Recently, the individual causal association (ICA) has been introduced as a metric of surrogacy in the causal inference framework, when both the surrogate and the true endpoint are normally distributed and when both are binary. Earlier work on the normal case has demonstrated that, although the ICA and the adjusted association are related metrics, their relationship strongly depends on unidentifiable parameters and, consequently, the association between both endpoints conveys little information on the validity of the surrogate. In addition, in the normal setting, the magnitude of the ICA does not depend on the mean of the outcomes. The latter implies that identifiable parameters such as mean responses and treatment effects provide no information on the validity of the surrogate. In the present work it is shown that this is fundamentally different in the binary case. We demonstrate that the observed association between the outcomes as well as the success rates in both treatment groups are quite predictive for the ICA. It is shown that finding a good surrogate will be more likely when the association between the endpoints is large, there are sizeable treatment effects and the success rates for both endpoints are similar in both treatment groups. These results are demonstrated using extensive simulations and illustrated on a case study in multi-drug resistant tuberculosis.
- 20 November 2020
- Published by Wiley in Statistics in Medicine
- Vol. 39 (26) , 3867-3878
On the relationship between association and surrogacy when both the surrogate and true endpoint are binary outcomes
The relationship between association and surrogacy has been the focus of much debate in the surrogate marker literature. Recently, the individual causal association (ICA) has been introduced as a metric of surrogacy in the causal inference framework, when both the surrogate and the true endpoint are normally distributed and when both are binary. Earlier work on the normal case has demonstrated that, although the ICA and the adjusted association are related metrics, their relationship strongly depends on unidentifiable parameters and, consequently, the association between both endpoints conveys little information on the validity of the surrogate. In addition, in the normal setting, the magnitude of the ICA does not depend on the mean of the outcomes. The latter implies that identifiable parameters such as mean responses and treatment effects provide no information on the validity of the surrogate. In the present work it is shown that this is fundamentally different in the binary case. We demonstrate that the observed association between the outcomes as well as the success rates in both treatment groups are quite predictive for the ICA. It is shown that finding a good surrogate will be more likely when the association between the endpoints is large, there are sizeable treatment effects and the success rates for both endpoints are similar in both treatment groups. These results are demonstrated using extensive simulations and illustrated on a case study in multi-drug resistant tuberculosis.
- 30 October 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Biometrics
- Vol. 78 (1) , 35-45
Identifying individual predictive factors for treatment efficacy
Given the heterogeneous responses to therapy and the high cost of treatments, there is an increasing interest in identifying pretreatment predictors of therapeutic effect. Clearly, the success of such an endeavor will depend on the amount of information that the patient‐specific variables convey about the individual causal treatment effect on the response of interest. In the present work, using causal inference and information theory, a strategy is proposed to evaluate individual predictive factors for cancer immunotherapy efficacy. In a first step, the methodology proposes a causal inference model to describe the joint distribution of the pretreatment predictors and the individual causal treatment effect. Further, in a second step, the so‐called predictive causal information (PCI), a metric that quantifies the amount of information the pretreatment predictors convey on the individual causal treatment effects, is introduced and its properties are studied. The methodology is applied to identify predictors of therapeutic success for a therapeutic vaccine in advanced lung cancer. A user‐friendly R library EffectTreat is provided to carry out the necessary calculations. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved
- 30 October 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Biometrics
- Vol. 78 (1) , 35-45
Identifying individual predictive factors for treatment efficacy
Given the heterogeneous responses to therapy and the high cost of treatments, there is an increasing interest in identifying pretreatment predictors of therapeutic effect. Clearly, the success of such an endeavor will depend on the amount of information that the patient‐specific variables convey about the individual causal treatment effect on the response of interest. In the present work, using causal inference and information theory, a strategy is proposed to evaluate individual predictive factors for cancer immunotherapy efficacy. In a first step, the methodology proposes a causal inference model to describe the joint distribution of the pretreatment predictors and the individual causal treatment effect. Further, in a second step, the so‐called predictive causal information (PCI), a metric that quantifies the amount of information the pretreatment predictors convey on the individual causal treatment effects, is introduced and its properties are studied. The methodology is applied to identify predictors of therapeutic success for a therapeutic vaccine in advanced lung cancer. A user‐friendly R library EffectTreat is provided to carry out the necessary calculations. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved
- Open Access
- 17 August 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Cancer
- Vol. 20 (1) , 1-8
Identifying predictive biomarkers of CIMAvaxEGF success in non–small cell lung cancer patients
Background: Immunosenescence biomarkers and peripheral blood parameters are evaluated separately as possible predictive markers of immunotherapy. Here, we illustrate the use of a causal inference model to identify predictive biomarkers of CIMAvaxEGF success in the treatment of Non–Small Cell Lung Cancer Patients. Methods: Data from a controlled clinical trial evaluating the effect of CIMAvax-EGF were analyzed retrospectively, following a causal inference approach. Pre-treatment potential predictive biomarkers included basal serum EGF concentration, peripheral blood parameters and immunosenescence biomarkers. The proportion of CD8 + CD28- T cells, CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, CD4/CD8 ratio and CD19+ B cells. The 33 patients with complete information were included. The predictive causal information (PCI) was calculated for all possible models. The model with a minimum number of predictors, but with high prediction accuracy (PCI > 0.7) was selected. Good, rare and poor responder patients were identified using the predictive probability of treatment success. Results: The mean of PCI increased from 0.486, when only one predictor is considered, to 0.98 using the multivariate approach with all predictors. The model considering the proportion of CD4+ T cell, basal Epidermal Growth Factor (EGF) concentration, neutrophil to lymphocyte ratio, Monocytes, and Neutrophils as predictors were selected (PCI > 0.74). Patients predicted as good responders according to the pre-treatment biomarkers values treated with CIMAvax-EGF had a significant higher observed survival compared with the control group (p = 0.03). No difference was observed for bad responders. Conclusions: Peripheral blood parameters and immunosenescence biomarkers together with basal EGF concentration in serum resulted in good predictors of the CIMAvax-EGF success in advanced NSCLC. Future research should explore molecular and genetic profile as biomarkers for CIMAvax-EGF and it combination with immune-checkpoint inhibitors. The study illustrates the application of a new methodology, based on causal inference, to evaluate multivariate pre-treatment predictors. The multivariate approach allows realistic predictions of the clinical benefit of patients and should be introduced in daily clinical practice.
- 17 August 2020
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Cancer
- Vol. 20 (1) , 1-8
Open AccessIdentifying predictive biomarkers of CIMAvaxEGF success in non–small cell lung cancer patients
Background: Immunosenescence biomarkers and peripheral blood parameters are evaluated separately as possible predictive markers of immunotherapy. Here, we illustrate the use of a causal inference model to identify predictive biomarkers of CIMAvaxEGF success in the treatment of Non–Small Cell Lung Cancer Patients. Methods: Data from a controlled clinical trial evaluating the effect of CIMAvax-EGF were analyzed retrospectively, following a causal inference approach. Pre-treatment potential predictive biomarkers included basal serum EGF concentration, peripheral blood parameters and immunosenescence biomarkers. The proportion of CD8 + CD28- T cells, CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, CD4/CD8 ratio and CD19+ B cells. The 33 patients with complete information were included. The predictive causal information (PCI) was calculated for all possible models. The model with a minimum number of predictors, but with high prediction accuracy (PCI > 0.7) was selected. Good, rare and poor responder patients were identified using the predictive probability of treatment success. Results: The mean of PCI increased from 0.486, when only one predictor is considered, to 0.98 using the multivariate approach with all predictors. The model considering the proportion of CD4+ T cell, basal Epidermal Growth Factor (EGF) concentration, neutrophil to lymphocyte ratio, Monocytes, and Neutrophils as predictors were selected (PCI > 0.74). Patients predicted as good responders according to the pre-treatment biomarkers values treated with CIMAvax-EGF had a significant higher observed survival compared with the control group (p = 0.03). No difference was observed for bad responders. Conclusions: Peripheral blood parameters and immunosenescence biomarkers together with basal EGF concentration in serum resulted in good predictors of the CIMAvax-EGF success in advanced NSCLC. Future research should explore molecular and genetic profile as biomarkers for CIMAvax-EGF and it combination with immune-checkpoint inhibitors. The study illustrates the application of a new methodology, based on causal inference, to evaluate multivariate pre-treatment predictors. The multivariate approach allows realistic predictions of the clinical benefit of patients and should be introduced in daily clinical practice.
- Open Access
- 26 April 2020
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Pediatric Neuropsychology
- Vol. 6 (2) , 96-110
Measuring goal setting in school-aged children: Studying the effects of demographic variables in regression-based norms.
The aim of the study was to establish demographically representative norms for tasks measuring goal setting, and more specifically planning and reasoning in children. Three tasks were administered to n = 195 Ukrainian children aged 5.10 to 14.5 years old: the Spatial Working Memory (SWM), the Stockings of Cambridge (SOC) test, and the Naglieri Nonverbal Ability Test (NNAT). Main outcome per test was accuracy: i.e., the total number correct for the SOC and NNAT, and the total amount of incorrect responses for the SWM. Correlations among accuracy measures varied from − 0.51 to 0.60, indicating these tasks measure related but at the same time unique constructs. Higher age was associated with more accurate test performances on all outcome measures. On the NNAT, we found a curvilinear association between age and accuracy, indicating that younger children’s NNAT accuracy scores increased more with age compared with older children. We found a cubic age effect on accuracy for the SWM and SOC: i.e., test scores were relatively stable at younger and older ages, with a curvilinear increase in test scores in the other age groups. Demographically corrected norms were calculated and presented per test. These indicated that sex was not associated with accuracy scores on any of the tests. Last, a higher level of parental education (LPE) was associated with higher accuracy scores, but only on the NNAT. We conclude that demographic variables in norm analyses enhance insight in the scores and allow for application in clinical settings and research.
- 26 April 2020
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Pediatric Neuropsychology
- Vol. 6 (2) , 96-110
Open AccessMeasuring goal setting in school-aged children: Studying the effects of demographic variables in regression-based norms.
The aim of the study was to establish demographically representative norms for tasks measuring goal setting, and more specifically planning and reasoning in children. Three tasks were administered to n = 195 Ukrainian children aged 5.10 to 14.5 years old: the Spatial Working Memory (SWM), the Stockings of Cambridge (SOC) test, and the Naglieri Nonverbal Ability Test (NNAT). Main outcome per test was accuracy: i.e., the total number correct for the SOC and NNAT, and the total amount of incorrect responses for the SWM. Correlations among accuracy measures varied from − 0.51 to 0.60, indicating these tasks measure related but at the same time unique constructs. Higher age was associated with more accurate test performances on all outcome measures. On the NNAT, we found a curvilinear association between age and accuracy, indicating that younger children’s NNAT accuracy scores increased more with age compared with older children. We found a cubic age effect on accuracy for the SWM and SOC: i.e., test scores were relatively stable at younger and older ages, with a curvilinear increase in test scores in the other age groups. Demographically corrected norms were calculated and presented per test. These indicated that sex was not associated with accuracy scores on any of the tests. Last, a higher level of parental education (LPE) was associated with higher accuracy scores, but only on the NNAT. We conclude that demographic variables in norm analyses enhance insight in the scores and allow for application in clinical settings and research.