Shawn Chartrand
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Shawn Chartrand has a total of 66 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
A. Mark Jellinek
16 shared publicationsAnna Grau Galofre
Laboratoire de Planétologie et Géosciences, CNRS UMR 6112, Nantes, France
12 shared publications- Antero Kukko
Finnish Geospatial Research Institute, National Land Survey of Finland, 02150 Espoo, Finland
12 shared publications Gordon R. Osinski
Department of Earth Sciences, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, N6A 5B7, Canada
12 shared publications- Chimira Andres
Lassonde School of Engineering, York University, Toronto, Ontario, M3J 1P3, Canada
11 shared publications - Etienne Godin
Centre d’études nordiques, Université Laval, Québec, QC, G1V 0A6, Canada
11 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Earth & Environment
- Vol. 7 (1)
Extreme North American heatwaves in 1941 and 2021 drove widespread but contrasting impacts
- 19 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Earth & Environment
- Vol. 7 (1)
Open AccessExtreme North American heatwaves in 1941 and 2021 drove widespread but contrasting impacts
- Open Access
- 14 September 2026
- Published by Wiley
Sampling suggestions for bedload sediment transport measurements near the threshold of motion
In gravel-bed rivers, sediment transport is commonly intermittent, with low background rates of motion punctuated by short, rare events of elevated activity. Although the physical mechanisms explaining this transport behaviour remain debated, its implications for sediment-transport measurements need to be considered when determining sampling strategy. Here we established a consistent, data-driven framework to quantify convergence metrics, the time and number of samples needed to obtain a representative estimate of average sediment transport. Using Monte Carlo based bootstrap analysis, we quantified the relationship between sampling duration and variability in mean sediment transport estimates. Convergence time varied by up to seven orders of magnitude across experiments, while the number of samples required for convergence varied by only one order of magnitude, showing the importance of sampling frequency. Sampling frequency and transport stage (the ratio of Shields number to critical Shields number) were the dominant controls on convergence metrics. We derived an empirical equation for estimating the number of samples required for convergence, applicable across a wide range of experimental transport conditions and sources of variability.
- 14 September 2026
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessSampling suggestions for bedload sediment transport measurements near the threshold of motion
In gravel-bed rivers, sediment transport is commonly intermittent, with low background rates of motion punctuated by short, rare events of elevated activity. Although the physical mechanisms explaining this transport behaviour remain debated, its implications for sediment-transport measurements need to be considered when determining sampling strategy. Here we established a consistent, data-driven framework to quantify convergence metrics, the time and number of samples needed to obtain a representative estimate of average sediment transport. Using Monte Carlo based bootstrap analysis, we quantified the relationship between sampling duration and variability in mean sediment transport estimates. Convergence time varied by up to seven orders of magnitude across experiments, while the number of samples required for convergence varied by only one order of magnitude, showing the importance of sampling frequency. Sampling frequency and transport stage (the ratio of Shields number to critical Shields number) were the dominant controls on convergence metrics. We derived an empirical equation for estimating the number of samples required for convergence, applicable across a wide range of experimental transport conditions and sources of variability.
- Open Access
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Earth & Environment
- Vol. 7 (1)
Seasonal freezing increases High Arctic erosion and landscape response to climate extremes
- 30 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Communications Earth & Environment
- Vol. 7 (1)
Open AccessSeasonal freezing increases High Arctic erosion and landscape response to climate extremes
- Open Access
- 26 March 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 131 (3)
Collective Particle Entrainment Explored With Experimental Data and Coupled Transfer Functions
Bedload transport in rivers with mixed grain sizes is challenging to predict, with implications for understanding how rivers form and respond to environmental change. Experimental work shows that collective particle entrainment is an important contributing mechanism of bedload transport, and here collective effects to the transport of a sediment mixture are conceptually explored. Two different time series of experimental sediment particle activity (i.e., a measure of the number of particles in motion) for sediments 4–32 mm in diameter are used to indirectly examine the role of collective entrainment. Particle activity was measured at a fixed position using an imaging light table at a time‐averaged resolution of 1 Hz for a duration of approximately 240 min during periods of topographic steady‐state. The two time series reveal a consistent transport behavior within the Fourier domain: activities for smaller particle size populations have increasing power density for decreasing frequency, whereas activities for larger particle size populations have a near uniform power density across all frequencies. Consequently, the activities of smaller particle sizes dominate the power spectra. A set of coupled transfer functions inspired by a probabilistic birth‐death model are developed to conceptually explore the transport behavior evident in the Fourier domain, with two notable results. The transport of smaller particles includes collective entrainment terms that represent mobilization due to both larger and similar particle sizes, whereas larger particles include collective terms limited to similar sized particles. The size‐dependent collective controls on particle entrainment described here offers a testable explanation for further analysis.
- 26 March 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 131 (3)
Open AccessCollective Particle Entrainment Explored With Experimental Data and Coupled Transfer Functions
Bedload transport in rivers with mixed grain sizes is challenging to predict, with implications for understanding how rivers form and respond to environmental change. Experimental work shows that collective particle entrainment is an important contributing mechanism of bedload transport, and here collective effects to the transport of a sediment mixture are conceptually explored. Two different time series of experimental sediment particle activity (i.e., a measure of the number of particles in motion) for sediments 4–32 mm in diameter are used to indirectly examine the role of collective entrainment. Particle activity was measured at a fixed position using an imaging light table at a time‐averaged resolution of 1 Hz for a duration of approximately 240 min during periods of topographic steady‐state. The two time series reveal a consistent transport behavior within the Fourier domain: activities for smaller particle size populations have increasing power density for decreasing frequency, whereas activities for larger particle size populations have a near uniform power density across all frequencies. Consequently, the activities of smaller particle sizes dominate the power spectra. A set of coupled transfer functions inspired by a probabilistic birth‐death model are developed to conceptually explore the transport behavior evident in the Fourier domain, with two notable results. The transport of smaller particles includes collective entrainment terms that represent mobilization due to both larger and similar particle sizes, whereas larger particles include collective terms limited to similar sized particles. The size‐dependent collective controls on particle entrainment described here offers a testable explanation for further analysis.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Elevation-dependent sensitivity of the snow accumulation period to climate warming in mountain basins
The seasonal snow accumulation period – approximated as the number of days between the autumn onset and spring end of sub-freezing temperatures – varies across elevation in mountain basins, with colder, higher elevation areas accumulating snow for longer relative to warmer, lower-elevation areas. Climate warming will reduce the sub-freezing duration throughout a year and alter the timing and magnitude of snow accumulation and melt, with profound implications for downstream ecosystems, infrastructure, and societies; however, it is not well known how such changes will vary across elevation gradients in mountain basins.Here we present a novel idealized conceptual model to analytically explain how and why the annual sub-freezing period responds differently to climate warming across elevation gradients in mountain basins. We use this model to demonstrate theoretically under what climactic conditions the sub-freezing duration is more sensitive to warming at low elevation areas relative to high elevations, and vice-versa. Both the strength (i.e. the magnitude of change of sub-freezing duration) and the shape (i.e. whether high- or low-elevation regions are more sensitive to warming) of this sensitivity vary non-linearly as a function of mean temperature, temperature seasonality, temperature lapse rate, and the basin elevation range.We then use ERA5-Land climate reanalysis data to apply this novel framework to mountain basins across North America. We find that in basins with warmer climates (i.e. those with mean annual temperatures greater than freezing), the annual number of days below freezing is more sensitive to warming at low elevations. In contrast, in basins with colder climates (i.e. those with mean annual temperatures less than freezing), the annual number of days below freezing are more sensitive to warming at high elevations. We evaluate both the present sensitivity of the sub-freezing duration, as well as observed changes since 1950.We detail two case studies in which we apply our methodology. First, we present how the snow accumulation period may decrease by substantially more in some glacierized areas than others (i.e. Canadian Rocky Mountains vs Coast Mountains). We find that in many glacierized basins, the snow accumulation period is more sensitive to warming in the high-elevation glacierized areas relative to lower-elevation non-glacierized areas. Second, we adapt our methodology to describe the period of the year when heatwaves, defined as persistent periods hotter than the seasonally-varying 90th percentile of temperature, may be warmer than freezing and thus potentially able to modify basin hydrology. We show that the potential for heatwave-driven ablation in mountain basins changes non-linearly across elevation with warming, and that heatwaves may rapidly emerge as a more prominent driver of high-elevation melt. Overall, our study presents a novel modelling framework to assess and project changes to melt-driven hydrological dynamics in mountain basins.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessElevation-dependent sensitivity of the snow accumulation period to climate warming in mountain basins
The seasonal snow accumulation period – approximated as the number of days between the autumn onset and spring end of sub-freezing temperatures – varies across elevation in mountain basins, with colder, higher elevation areas accumulating snow for longer relative to warmer, lower-elevation areas. Climate warming will reduce the sub-freezing duration throughout a year and alter the timing and magnitude of snow accumulation and melt, with profound implications for downstream ecosystems, infrastructure, and societies; however, it is not well known how such changes will vary across elevation gradients in mountain basins.Here we present a novel idealized conceptual model to analytically explain how and why the annual sub-freezing period responds differently to climate warming across elevation gradients in mountain basins. We use this model to demonstrate theoretically under what climactic conditions the sub-freezing duration is more sensitive to warming at low elevation areas relative to high elevations, and vice-versa. Both the strength (i.e. the magnitude of change of sub-freezing duration) and the shape (i.e. whether high- or low-elevation regions are more sensitive to warming) of this sensitivity vary non-linearly as a function of mean temperature, temperature seasonality, temperature lapse rate, and the basin elevation range.We then use ERA5-Land climate reanalysis data to apply this novel framework to mountain basins across North America. We find that in basins with warmer climates (i.e. those with mean annual temperatures greater than freezing), the annual number of days below freezing is more sensitive to warming at low elevations. In contrast, in basins with colder climates (i.e. those with mean annual temperatures less than freezing), the annual number of days below freezing are more sensitive to warming at high elevations. We evaluate both the present sensitivity of the sub-freezing duration, as well as observed changes since 1950.We detail two case studies in which we apply our methodology. First, we present how the snow accumulation period may decrease by substantially more in some glacierized areas than others (i.e. Canadian Rocky Mountains vs Coast Mountains). We find that in many glacierized basins, the snow accumulation period is more sensitive to warming in the high-elevation glacierized areas relative to lower-elevation non-glacierized areas. Second, we adapt our methodology to describe the period of the year when heatwaves, defined as persistent periods hotter than the seasonally-varying 90th percentile of temperature, may be warmer than freezing and thus potentially able to modify basin hydrology. We show that the potential for heatwave-driven ablation in mountain basins changes non-linearly across elevation with warming, and that heatwaves may rapidly emerge as a more prominent driver of high-elevation melt. Overall, our study presents a novel modelling framework to assess and project changes to melt-driven hydrological dynamics in mountain basins.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
A Physical Model of Permafrost Sorted Stripe Formation in the Canadian High Arctic
Hillslopes in the Canadian High Arctic can express curious quasi-linear sorted stripe patterns, physically resembling rills but with no obvious evidence of active particle transport via sustained surface water flows following rainfall or snowmelt. This motivates several questions which at present are little explored. First, how do the physical characteristics of the pattern vary down the hillslope in response to changing hillslope geomorphology (e.g. slope, elevation, etc.)? Second, what mechanism(s) causes sorted stripe patterns to initiate and develop, and what are the roles of freeze-thaw, granular, and fluid-flow-driven processes? Several attempts have been made to model the formation of sorted stripe patterns using rules-based approaches, or analytical models derived from these rules; however, a comprehensive physical model of sorted stripe formation has yet to be developed, and we currently lack even a characterization of how the pattern is distributed across a hillslope.Here, we present a characterization of the sorted stripe patterning found on a hillslope on Tallurutit (Devon Island), Nunavut and examine topographic controls of hillslope track characteristics. By analyzing topographic lidar data, we find that there is not one preferred cross- or downslope spacing of the stripes; rather, the size and shape of stripes varies down the hillslope. This alludes to the idea that there are several processes at work to form hillslope sorted stripe patterns. We present a physical model of stripe formation involving initial fracturing of the hill due to thermal stresses, heaving from ice lens growth, and mobilization of stones due to the creation of critically-steep topographic gradients and ice needle formation. We motivate this model using the characterization of the sorted stripe pattern distribution, field observations, and an analysis of thermal and tensional stresses.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessA Physical Model of Permafrost Sorted Stripe Formation in the Canadian High Arctic
Hillslopes in the Canadian High Arctic can express curious quasi-linear sorted stripe patterns, physically resembling rills but with no obvious evidence of active particle transport via sustained surface water flows following rainfall or snowmelt. This motivates several questions which at present are little explored. First, how do the physical characteristics of the pattern vary down the hillslope in response to changing hillslope geomorphology (e.g. slope, elevation, etc.)? Second, what mechanism(s) causes sorted stripe patterns to initiate and develop, and what are the roles of freeze-thaw, granular, and fluid-flow-driven processes? Several attempts have been made to model the formation of sorted stripe patterns using rules-based approaches, or analytical models derived from these rules; however, a comprehensive physical model of sorted stripe formation has yet to be developed, and we currently lack even a characterization of how the pattern is distributed across a hillslope.Here, we present a characterization of the sorted stripe patterning found on a hillslope on Tallurutit (Devon Island), Nunavut and examine topographic controls of hillslope track characteristics. By analyzing topographic lidar data, we find that there is not one preferred cross- or downslope spacing of the stripes; rather, the size and shape of stripes varies down the hillslope. This alludes to the idea that there are several processes at work to form hillslope sorted stripe patterns. We present a physical model of stripe formation involving initial fracturing of the hill due to thermal stresses, heaving from ice lens growth, and mobilization of stones due to the creation of critically-steep topographic gradients and ice needle formation. We motivate this model using the characterization of the sorted stripe pattern distribution, field observations, and an analysis of thermal and tensional stresses.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Seasonal variation of hydrologic connectivity for High Arctic stream segments
In the High Arctic, new channel networks are developing relatively rapidly within 10s of years, typically attributed to exteneded thaw seasons under climate change and late season permafrost loss. During the 2024 field season on Tallurutit (Devon Island), we visited a developing channel network where relatively flat pools are connected by steeper channelised segments which exhibit evidence of recent gravel and sand transport. However, despite visiting during a storm event, we did not observe active sediment transport and only limited surface-water runoff. This brings up the question: How does the hydrologic connectivity between channel segments and surface runoff fraction change across a thaw season?We developed a new box model that couples surface and subsurface water flow between pools conserving enthalpy to explore the hydrologic response of an analogue landscape segment across a thaw season. Using this model, we first use synthetic rainevents to identify the key factors modulating the hydrologic response and then use new weather data from Tallurutit and historic climate data to explore when surface water erosion is likely to occur under typical climate conditions and for future climate scenarios.Subjecting the landscape to the same magnitude-duration rainevent in the early versus late thaw season shows that surface water runoff fraction is greatest early in the thaw season as the shallow thaw front limits subsurface water storage. This results in successive overspill events that rapidly transport water across pools and promote erosion. In the late thaw season, subsurface water storage dominates and pools are connected via subsurface water flow. As a result surface water flow and resultant erosion is minimised. We summarise a key implication of our work through a reservoir response time that depends on the bed permeability, pool length, and thaw depth which modulates whether a pool will dampen a hydrologic signal or transmit it downstream.Combined with grain-scale laboratory experiments which show that bed erodibility is inversely proportional to thaw depth, this work suggests that the formation and evolution of channel networks in the High Arcitc is primarily driven by early season discharge events. Under climate change, the frequency and magnitude of early season rainstorms and heatwaves, resulting in rapid snowmelt, are becoming more common. This suggests that the observed rapid channelisation in the High Arctic is related to early season climate extremes, instead of long-term warming averages and late season permafrost loss.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSeasonal variation of hydrologic connectivity for High Arctic stream segments
In the High Arctic, new channel networks are developing relatively rapidly within 10s of years, typically attributed to exteneded thaw seasons under climate change and late season permafrost loss. During the 2024 field season on Tallurutit (Devon Island), we visited a developing channel network where relatively flat pools are connected by steeper channelised segments which exhibit evidence of recent gravel and sand transport. However, despite visiting during a storm event, we did not observe active sediment transport and only limited surface-water runoff. This brings up the question: How does the hydrologic connectivity between channel segments and surface runoff fraction change across a thaw season?We developed a new box model that couples surface and subsurface water flow between pools conserving enthalpy to explore the hydrologic response of an analogue landscape segment across a thaw season. Using this model, we first use synthetic rainevents to identify the key factors modulating the hydrologic response and then use new weather data from Tallurutit and historic climate data to explore when surface water erosion is likely to occur under typical climate conditions and for future climate scenarios.Subjecting the landscape to the same magnitude-duration rainevent in the early versus late thaw season shows that surface water runoff fraction is greatest early in the thaw season as the shallow thaw front limits subsurface water storage. This results in successive overspill events that rapidly transport water across pools and promote erosion. In the late thaw season, subsurface water storage dominates and pools are connected via subsurface water flow. As a result surface water flow and resultant erosion is minimised. We summarise a key implication of our work through a reservoir response time that depends on the bed permeability, pool length, and thaw depth which modulates whether a pool will dampen a hydrologic signal or transmit it downstream.Combined with grain-scale laboratory experiments which show that bed erodibility is inversely proportional to thaw depth, this work suggests that the formation and evolution of channel networks in the High Arcitc is primarily driven by early season discharge events. Under climate change, the frequency and magnitude of early season rainstorms and heatwaves, resulting in rapid snowmelt, are becoming more common. This suggests that the observed rapid channelisation in the High Arctic is related to early season climate extremes, instead of long-term warming averages and late season permafrost loss.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Erodibility of frozen riverbed sediments
Cryosphere degradation due to climate change results in increased sediment availability, mobilization, and transport (Knight & Harrison, 2012; Lane et al., 2017; Micheletti & Lane, 2016; Beel et al., 2020; Li et al., 2021a; Zhang et al., 2021; Syvitski et al., 2022; Zhang, 2022). The change in magnitude and timing of water delivery and sediment transport alters river patterns (Lafrenière & Lamoureux, 2019; Fortier et al., 2007), such as via increasing channelization (Liljedahl et al., 2016; Li et al., 2021a; Chartrand et al., 2023). Despite the obvious signs of landscape transformation by rivers, the effects of climate change on High Arctic fluvial incision and sediment transport remain poorly quantified due to limited understanding of how thawing substrate, water availability, and erodibility interact.Although frozen landscapes are expected to erode slower than their temperate counterparts, Eschenfelder et al. (in review) found that frozen riverbeds may erode faster. In their laboratory flume experiments, they observe injections of surface water into a frozen bed of uniform-sized spherical glass beads (D50 of ~1.9 mm), delivering heat and momentum fluxes to the thaw front. This increased subsurface melting and drove development of pressure gradients which enhanced surface erosion. They argue that later in the thaw season, when the upper layer of the bed has thawed in a more homogeneous fashion, water injections into the bed are physically accommodated and hence do not contribute to elevated surface erosion.The glass bead substrate of Eschenfelder’s experiments has a high porosity (p = 0.4) and permeability, supporting significant hyporheic flow. However, natural sediments vary in size and composition, altering porosity and permeability. Furthermore, sediment size variability affects thawing rate (Gatto, 1995; Costard et al., 2003, 2014) and erosion rate (Einstein, 1950, Mitchener & Torfs, 1996; McCarron et al., 2019; van Rijn, 2020; de Lange et al., 2024).In the proposed follow-up experiments, we plan to use various mixtures of glass beads (D50 = 0.88, 1.9 and 4.1 mm), and natural sediments, to alter porosity and permeability. The natural sediment distribution will be scaled to reflect substrate compositions observed during past field campaigns to the Canadian Arctic. We hypothesise that, if these water injections into the bed are still present in lower porosity sediments, fine grained beds will erode slower than courser grained beds, despite a lower threshold of motion. Furthermore, experiments with multiple freeze-thaw cycles will be performed, allowing assessment of a potential positive feedback loop where past-seasons’ thaw front undulations and surface topography can impact current season’s flow patterns – imparting “memory” onto the landscape.With these experiments we will assess erosional mechanisms in a variety of grain sizes, allowing us to further explore the mechanisms of erosion in frozen riverbeds, ultimately aiding the understanding of spatial variability in channel incision in the field.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessErodibility of frozen riverbed sediments
Cryosphere degradation due to climate change results in increased sediment availability, mobilization, and transport (Knight & Harrison, 2012; Lane et al., 2017; Micheletti & Lane, 2016; Beel et al., 2020; Li et al., 2021a; Zhang et al., 2021; Syvitski et al., 2022; Zhang, 2022). The change in magnitude and timing of water delivery and sediment transport alters river patterns (Lafrenière & Lamoureux, 2019; Fortier et al., 2007), such as via increasing channelization (Liljedahl et al., 2016; Li et al., 2021a; Chartrand et al., 2023). Despite the obvious signs of landscape transformation by rivers, the effects of climate change on High Arctic fluvial incision and sediment transport remain poorly quantified due to limited understanding of how thawing substrate, water availability, and erodibility interact.Although frozen landscapes are expected to erode slower than their temperate counterparts, Eschenfelder et al. (in review) found that frozen riverbeds may erode faster. In their laboratory flume experiments, they observe injections of surface water into a frozen bed of uniform-sized spherical glass beads (D50 of ~1.9 mm), delivering heat and momentum fluxes to the thaw front. This increased subsurface melting and drove development of pressure gradients which enhanced surface erosion. They argue that later in the thaw season, when the upper layer of the bed has thawed in a more homogeneous fashion, water injections into the bed are physically accommodated and hence do not contribute to elevated surface erosion.The glass bead substrate of Eschenfelder’s experiments has a high porosity (p = 0.4) and permeability, supporting significant hyporheic flow. However, natural sediments vary in size and composition, altering porosity and permeability. Furthermore, sediment size variability affects thawing rate (Gatto, 1995; Costard et al., 2003, 2014) and erosion rate (Einstein, 1950, Mitchener & Torfs, 1996; McCarron et al., 2019; van Rijn, 2020; de Lange et al., 2024).In the proposed follow-up experiments, we plan to use various mixtures of glass beads (D50 = 0.88, 1.9 and 4.1 mm), and natural sediments, to alter porosity and permeability. The natural sediment distribution will be scaled to reflect substrate compositions observed during past field campaigns to the Canadian Arctic. We hypothesise that, if these water injections into the bed are still present in lower porosity sediments, fine grained beds will erode slower than courser grained beds, despite a lower threshold of motion. Furthermore, experiments with multiple freeze-thaw cycles will be performed, allowing assessment of a potential positive feedback loop where past-seasons’ thaw front undulations and surface topography can impact current season’s flow patterns – imparting “memory” onto the landscape.With these experiments we will assess erosional mechanisms in a variety of grain sizes, allowing us to further explore the mechanisms of erosion in frozen riverbeds, ultimately aiding the understanding of spatial variability in channel incision in the field.
- Open Access
- 28 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Reply on RC2
Understanding how Arctic catchments respond to rainfall is critical for anticipating hydrological and biogeochemical effects of a warming climate. We use ensemble rainfall-runoff analysis (ERRA) to identify how runoff response to rainfall varies with meteorological, subsurface, and geomorphic conditions across three permafrost catchments: Upper Kuparuk (Alaska) and the Goose and Ptarmigan catchments (Cape Bounty, Canadian High Arctic). ERRA enables us to quantify event-scale runoff responses to rainfall using high-resolution, multi-year hydrometeorological datasets, and test how variations in rainfall intensity, thaw depth, antecedent wetness, and active layer detachments (ALDs) affect runoff behavior. Our results show that peak runoff response increases by more than five-fold in response to increases in antecedent streamflow (a proxy for antecedent moisture), and is also higher in summers with higher average precipitation. By contrast, warmer winters and springs, likely linked to deeper thaw and increased subsurface storage capacity, are associated with reduced runoff sensitivity to rainfall. Furthermore, a paired watershed comparison shows that streamflow and riverine fluxes of dissolved solids, suspended sediment, and particulate organic carbon are more readily mobilized by rainfall inputs when ALDs are present. Considered together, these findings highlight the difficulty in generalizing climate-driven runoff trends in permafrost regions subject to competing and interacting controls, such as precipitation intensity, storage capacity and permafrost stability. Our findings offer a more nuanced alternative to broad classifications of Arctic landscapes as “drying” or “wetting” under climate change.
- 28 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Open AccessReply on RC2
Understanding how Arctic catchments respond to rainfall is critical for anticipating hydrological and biogeochemical effects of a warming climate. We use ensemble rainfall-runoff analysis (ERRA) to identify how runoff response to rainfall varies with meteorological, subsurface, and geomorphic conditions across three permafrost catchments: Upper Kuparuk (Alaska) and the Goose and Ptarmigan catchments (Cape Bounty, Canadian High Arctic). ERRA enables us to quantify event-scale runoff responses to rainfall using high-resolution, multi-year hydrometeorological datasets, and test how variations in rainfall intensity, thaw depth, antecedent wetness, and active layer detachments (ALDs) affect runoff behavior. Our results show that peak runoff response increases by more than five-fold in response to increases in antecedent streamflow (a proxy for antecedent moisture), and is also higher in summers with higher average precipitation. By contrast, warmer winters and springs, likely linked to deeper thaw and increased subsurface storage capacity, are associated with reduced runoff sensitivity to rainfall. Furthermore, a paired watershed comparison shows that streamflow and riverine fluxes of dissolved solids, suspended sediment, and particulate organic carbon are more readily mobilized by rainfall inputs when ALDs are present. Considered together, these findings highlight the difficulty in generalizing climate-driven runoff trends in permafrost regions subject to competing and interacting controls, such as precipitation intensity, storage capacity and permafrost stability. Our findings offer a more nuanced alternative to broad classifications of Arctic landscapes as “drying” or “wetting” under climate change.
- Open Access
- 28 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Reply on RC1
Understanding how Arctic catchments respond to rainfall is critical for anticipating hydrological and biogeochemical effects of a warming climate. We use ensemble rainfall-runoff analysis (ERRA) to identify how runoff response to rainfall varies with meteorological, subsurface, and geomorphic conditions across three permafrost catchments: Upper Kuparuk (Alaska) and the Goose and Ptarmigan catchments (Cape Bounty, Canadian High Arctic). ERRA enables us to quantify event-scale runoff responses to rainfall using high-resolution, multi-year hydrometeorological datasets, and test how variations in rainfall intensity, thaw depth, antecedent wetness, and active layer detachments (ALDs) affect runoff behavior. Our results show that peak runoff response increases by more than five-fold in response to increases in antecedent streamflow (a proxy for antecedent moisture), and is also higher in summers with higher average precipitation. By contrast, warmer winters and springs, likely linked to deeper thaw and increased subsurface storage capacity, are associated with reduced runoff sensitivity to rainfall. Furthermore, a paired watershed comparison shows that streamflow and riverine fluxes of dissolved solids, suspended sediment, and particulate organic carbon are more readily mobilized by rainfall inputs when ALDs are present. Considered together, these findings highlight the difficulty in generalizing climate-driven runoff trends in permafrost regions subject to competing and interacting controls, such as precipitation intensity, storage capacity and permafrost stability. Our findings offer a more nuanced alternative to broad classifications of Arctic landscapes as “drying” or “wetting” under climate change.
- 28 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-26
Open AccessReply on RC1
Understanding how Arctic catchments respond to rainfall is critical for anticipating hydrological and biogeochemical effects of a warming climate. We use ensemble rainfall-runoff analysis (ERRA) to identify how runoff response to rainfall varies with meteorological, subsurface, and geomorphic conditions across three permafrost catchments: Upper Kuparuk (Alaska) and the Goose and Ptarmigan catchments (Cape Bounty, Canadian High Arctic). ERRA enables us to quantify event-scale runoff responses to rainfall using high-resolution, multi-year hydrometeorological datasets, and test how variations in rainfall intensity, thaw depth, antecedent wetness, and active layer detachments (ALDs) affect runoff behavior. Our results show that peak runoff response increases by more than five-fold in response to increases in antecedent streamflow (a proxy for antecedent moisture), and is also higher in summers with higher average precipitation. By contrast, warmer winters and springs, likely linked to deeper thaw and increased subsurface storage capacity, are associated with reduced runoff sensitivity to rainfall. Furthermore, a paired watershed comparison shows that streamflow and riverine fluxes of dissolved solids, suspended sediment, and particulate organic carbon are more readily mobilized by rainfall inputs when ALDs are present. Considered together, these findings highlight the difficulty in generalizing climate-driven runoff trends in permafrost regions subject to competing and interacting controls, such as precipitation intensity, storage capacity and permafrost stability. Our findings offer a more nuanced alternative to broad classifications of Arctic landscapes as “drying” or “wetting” under climate change.