ATAlison Todes

Alison Todes

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Alison Todes has a total of 20 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • The Planning Profession in South Africa

    by Philip Harrison, Alison Todes

    The planning profession in South Africa has consolidated since the early 2000s through the Planning Professions Act 2002, the establishment of a statutory registration council and non-statutory organisations, some pursuing transformational agendas. Accreditation of planning schools was re-established from 2007 and focused on agreed competencies from 2014. The number of registered professional planners has grown and diversified in terms of race and gender. Yet the planning profession has not necessarily risen in status or confidence, and there is no ‘regulative bargain’. This chapter explores these tensions, locating the discussion in literatures on professions and on the planning profession internationally. It outlines the history of the South African planning profession, its institutionalisation post-apartheid, its size, shape and markets. It discusses planning's identity crisis and the debate over reserving certain kinds of work for registered planners. It considers questions of integrity, values, and ethics. Although planning was intended to play key roles in spatial transformation, there is a sense of powerlessness, that markets and politics dictate what planners do, while the institutional environment limits planning impact. Moving forward, planners need to exercise voice and link to other organisations to promote just, sustainable spatial transformation.

  • The Forces at Work Internationally and the New Promise of Planning

    by Philip Harrison, Alison Todes

    South Africa is distinctive, reflecting its historical trajectory but also deeply influenced by changing global contexts and influence. The period under study is bookended by two global crises – the 2008/2009 global financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic of 2020–2022. These have profoundly shaped the milieu for planning, although their consequences are not yet fully understood, and partly explain global diffidence around planning, despite the affirmation of planning in global agendas such as the Sustainable Development Goals and the New Urban Agenda. There are however other shaping global trends including the accelerating impacts of climate, the destabilising and enabling effects of new technologies, and growing social polarisation. However, despite global processes, planning has evolved unevenly and differently across regions of the world. In East Asia, for example, planning is more ambitious, directive, and technocratic than in Western Europe and North America, where planning in its regulatory forms is simultaneously retreating in response to an economic growth imperative and plays an expanded role in responding to the sustainability drive. There are similarly complex and contradictory trends across other regions of the world. In Africa, planning systems with their colonial roots are adapting unevenly to contextual realities including rapid urbanisation, informality, persisting poverty, and the rise of a consumerist middle class.

  • Conclusion

    by Philip Harrison, Alison Todes

    Since 2008, there have been improvements in planning legislation, systems, and instruments, and local innovations in planning. However, our study indicates a negative mood amongst planners nationally, to the extent that the legitimacy of planning is at stake. Part of the explanation has to do with the state of the world, with a growing sense of global polycrisis, but there is a strong perception among planners of a deterioration in South Africa's governance system, which reflects national challenges. As a conclusion, the pragmatic concern is ‘what do we do?’ as planners under these adverse circumstances. The space for large-scale transformative projects may be over, but there is intellectual hope in less ambitious approaches, including the incremental progressivism of São Paulo's Eduardo Marques, the prefigurative planning of Simin Davoudi, and the pathways through governmental crisis elaborated by scholars in challenging contexts such as Lebanon. In South Africa, there are possible pathways of engagement with the remaining pockets of state capacity, civil society, and social entrepreneurialism in the private sector, with emergent platforms where governance is being renegotiated through crisis. Our specific recommendations for planning include (1) Moderating the expectations for planning; (2) Planners taking a more assertive leadership role in the public domain in relation to spatial issues; (3) More creative and inclusive approaches to participation in planning; (4) Engaging the contextuality of South Africa more effectively, including in respect of informality; (5) Discerning the quiet patterns of emergence, and build on these to support incremental spatial transformation; and (6) Resolve the flaws in systems and processes of planning that remain despite the planning reforms of recent decades.

  • The South African Context

    by Philip Harrison, Alison Todes

    The post-2008 era is periodised into the Mbeki, Zuma, and Ramaphosa presidencies. As the Mbeki era ended in 2008, South Africa was still basking in the afterglow of its transition to democracy, and economic growth had been robust up until the global financial crisis, but the HIV/Aids crisis had taken its toll, and economic empowerment had only benefitted a small elite. Under the Zuma presidency, 2009–2017, the national economy slumped, and governance deteriorated, as networks of criminality and corruption through state structures (referred to as “state capture”) and the new national power elite fragmented. The Ramaphosa era (2017–present) began with promises of a new dawn and the restoration of good governance, but the economy was anaemic, with COVID-19 as a major shock; leadership was weak; political instability seriously impacted the performance of metropolitan cities; and patrimonial networks remained deeply embedded. In terms of spatial process, there were significant shifts in population in the early post-apartheid years as black people moved to areas of economic opportunity, although many of the socio-spatial divides of apartheid persisted. Population growth was focused on the major metropolitan cities in Gauteng and the Western Cape. However, the preliminary results from Census 2022 suggest that trends may be shifting. After a long period of economic stagnation and growing vulnerability in cities, combined with weakened urban governance, black African households are investing in the previous homelands, while mainly white middle-class households are semigrating from Gauteng to the coastal cities.

  • Planning on the National and Provincial Scales

    by Philip Harrison, Alison Todes

    In 1996, a new National Constitution was adopted which introduced a complex system of co-operative governance with many administrative functions overlapping across the three spheres of government. Planning was ambiguously distributed, and functional responsibilities were clarified over time, including through the interpretation of constitutional provisions by the courts. In broad terms, the role of national government in the planning domain is to create framing legislation, set standards, coordinate across sub-national jurisdictions, and plan for its own areas of responsibility. During the early years of the Zuma era, there were significant reforms and improvements within planning at a national scale including the preparation of a National Development Plan by a National Planning Commission, the Integrated Urban Development Framework, the groundbreaking Spatial Planning and Land Use Management Act (SPLUMA) of 2013, and the City Support Programme in National Treasury. These initiatives served a performative function for a government under increasing pressure for lack of direction and self-serving action but, more positively, represented the initiative of officials deeply concerned at the overall deterioration in governance. The Ramaphosa era was vexing, giving its early promises, with planning reform stalling. However, in frustration at the lack of achievement, the government diverted to overly ambitious initiatives such as new cities and the District Development Model, although they may be moderating into more modest programmes. Across the two presidencies, provincial government struggled to find a meaningful role in planning, losing its land use management functions following a judgement of the Constitutional Court and the introduction of SPLUMA.

  • Planning and Social Transformations

    by Philip Harrison, Alison Todes

    Planning has been posited as an instrument of social transformation with expectations that it should address poverty and inequality, embrace social diversity and informality, and improve conditions of everyday life. This chapter reviews how these issues are taken up by planning in South Africa. It considers how planning has responded to informality; the need for racial redress and questions of decolonisation; gender inequalities; and the specific needs of migrants, children, youth, the elderly, people with disabilities, and LGBTQI+ communities. It also examines the role of planning in relation to the micro-scale of everyday life, considering access to services and social facilities, the quality of public space, safety in the city, and the mobility of residents. The chapter points to the limitations of current planning practice in addressing social transformation in these respects. While levels of basic services have improved, and there are some good practices, they tend to be exceptional, often undertaken through funded international programmes and projects. Much more could have been done. Nevertheless, the chapter highlights potentials for planning to support progressive social change, working carefully with emergent processes, exploring new perspectives, and building on innovative practices.

  • Introduction

    by Philip Harrison, Alison Todes

    A prior volume, Planning and Transformation: Learning from the Post-Apartheid Experience, explored the early years of planning post-apartheid. The book showed how a profession implicated in the practices of apartheid was rehabilitated in the service of a non-racial democracy. Since 2008 there have been positive developments for planning, with new global agendas including the Sustainable Development Goals and the New Urban Agenda affirming planning's role, with significant advances in planning nationally, including clarifying legislation, new planning instruments, and new national planning programmes. However, these advances are not reflected in the current deep pessimism among planners in South Africa, raising challenging questions. As a conceptual framing for this exploration, this chapter draws on a recent literature on the promises and disappointments of state practice. It then provides three necessary dimensions of context. First, it provides a historical overview, explaining the long trajectory of planning in South Africa, through the precolonial, colonial, apartheid, and early post-apartheid periods. Second, it explores the contextualised meaning of planning in South Africa, arguing that planning must be understood in terms of its actual practices. Third, and since planning is an overwhelmingly state-led set of practices, it explores the nature of the state in South Africa and its current crisis, and it explores the nature of the state, and of the crisis in the state, drawing on new literature on political settlement, new elite formation, and the renegotiation of the state.

  • The Promise of Planning

    by Philip Harrison, Alison Todes

    The Promise of Planning explores the experience of planning internationally since the global financial crisis, focusing on South Africa. The book is a response to a decade-plus in which state-led planning has re-emerged as a putative means for achieving developmental goals (as indicated in global initiatives such as the New Urban Agenda) and where planning in South Africa has consolidated in terms of its legal and policy basis. However, the return of planning is happening in an inauspicious context, with economic fragilities, technological shifts, political populism, institutional complexities, and more, threatening to upturn the "new promise of planning." The book provides a careful analytical account of planning in South Africa and how and why its promises have been difficult to achieve. Building on the authors’ previous book, Planning and Transformation, the book sheds light on planning as an increasingly complex and diverse governmental practice within a perpetually changing world. It can be used as a resource for planners who must make good on the new promise of planning while navigating the risks and threats of the contemporary world, as well as students and faculty interested in international planning debates and the South African case.