TKTracy L. Kivell

Tracy L. Kivell

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Tracy L. Kivell has a total of 168 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Arboreal signals in the skeletal proportions of the Gorilla foot

    by Elliot G. Greiner, Christopher B. Ruff, Andrea Lukova, Aventino Nkwasibwe, Thadee Muhire, Emmanuel Tibenda, Jason S. Massey, Juho‐Antti Junno, Samar M. Syeda, Jean Bosco Noheri, et al.

    Postcranial skeletal proportions in living apes have been linked to patterns of arboreal behaviors within and between populations, offering a comparative baseline for interpreting arboreal behavior in fossil hominoids. We quantified metatarsal and proximal phalangeal lengths across all five pedal rays in Gorilla , comparing western lowland gorillas ( Gorilla gorilla gorilla ), low‐ and high‐elevation Grauer's gorillas ( Gorilla beringei graueri ), and two ecologically distinct mountain gorilla ( Gorilla beringei beringei ) populations: those of Bwindi Impenetrable National Park, Uganda, and the Virunga Massif (Volcanoes National Park, Rwanda). The Bwindi sample, assembled from individuals recovered by the Mountain Gorilla Skeletal Project between 2017 and 2025, represents the first substantial pedal dataset for this population. After separately scaling element lengths by estimated body mass and hindlimb length, Bwindi gorillas' third and fourth metatarsal lengths fell consistently between those of the more arboreal western lowland and highly terrestrial Virunga gorillas, while proximal phalangeal and hallux lengths varied little across populations. Additionally, Virunga gorillas showed longer second metatarsals compared to other populations, a feature we link to their strongly terrestrial locomotor habits. In comparing relative manual and pedal element lengths from the same individuals, metacarpals were relatively longer than metatarsals across all populations in rays 2–5, with this pattern reversed in the hallux; among these, only the second ray showed a significant interpopulation difference, with western lowland gorillas exhibiting relatively longer metacarpals than all other groups. Though interpopulation differences in the lengths of pedal elements were generally weaker than those found in the manual elements of the same individuals, these findings suggest that habitat‐associated variation in foot morphology can be detected between populations of gorilla subspecies, underscoring the value of fine‐grained, population‐level skeletal comparisons for refining locomotor inference in the hominoid and hominin fossil record.

  • Open Access

    Trabecular structure of the proximal and distal ulna in extant primates

    by Georgina Raventós-Izard, Marine Cazenave, Oriol Monclús-Gonzalo, Tracy L. Kivell, David M. Alba, Julia Arias-Martorell

    Trabecular bone (re)models in response to localized mechanical loading, potentially enabling inferences about the positional behavior of extinct taxa. However, the trabecular architecture of the ulna remains understudied in extant primates, particularly regarding whether it reflects habitual joint posture and loading. Across a broad sample of anthropoid primates, including apes, atelids, and cercopithecoids, we quantified the relative bone volume fraction (rBV/TV) of trabeculae in the proximal and distal ulna and applied a two-block partial least squares analysis between rBV/TV and locomotor frequencies to explore the relationship between trabecular bone and locomotor behavior. In the distal ulna, high rBV/TV values at the tip of the styloid process in non-hominoids are consistent with its known role in load transmission through the ulnocarpal articulation. In hominoids, the absence of direct articulation with the carpus offloads internal stresses, weakening the functional signal in the trabeculae, which is consistent with the lack of covariation between rBV/TV and the quantified locomotor behaviors. In contrast, proximal ulnar trabecular structure covaries with the frequency of quadrupedalism and captures clearer functional signals; arboreal monkeys display mediolateral stress patterns consistent with mobile, semipronated elbow use, whereas terrestrial monkeys show compressive patterns linked to semiflexed, pronated elbow use. Symphalangus show dense trabecular reinforcement around the triceps insertion related to forelimb overhead reaching, while hominid trabecular patterns appear related to more versatile locomotor behaviors, with Gorilla and Pongo showing evidence of extended-elbow loading. Overall, our results indicate that the proximal ulna more accurately reflects loadings related to locomotor behavior than the distal ulna, providing a valuable framework for inferring locomotor behaviors in fossil primates.

  • Open Access

    A Year in the Bones: Investigating Bone Resorption Across a Reproductive Year in Wild Female Assamese Macaques

    by Verena Behringer, Ruth Sonnweber, Suchinda Malaivijitnond, Suthirote Meesawat, Tracy L. Kivell, Oliver Schülke, Julia Ostner

    Reproduction places considerable metabolic demands on females, particularly during pregnancy and lactation, when calcium homeostasis and bone metabolism are challenged. Urinary C‐terminal telopeptide of type I collagen (CTX‐I) offers a useful non‐invasive marker to assess bone resorption. We measured urinary CTX‐I in wild female Assamese macaques ( Macaca assamensis ) living at Phu Khieo Wildlife Sanctuary, Thailand. A total of 663 urine samples were collected from 19 adult females between June 2017 and January 2019 and analysed using a CTX‐I ELISA. Generalised additive modelling revealed a non‐linear relationship between days relative to conception and urinary CTX‐I levels, with higher values before conception and after parturition, and lower levels during pregnancy. However, this pattern remained when lactating females from the previous year (6 out of 19) were excluded, and further analyses showed that the seasonal, rather than the reproductive term, best‐explained variation in urinary CTX‐I levels. CTX‐I levels showed two annual peaks, with the main one occurring in the late rainy season (August–September). Seasonal changes in urine concentration did not account for this pattern. These findings suggest that, in the study population of Assamese macaques, bone resorption varies with season, possibly in response to environmental or endocrine cycles, rather than being primarily driven by the metabolic demands of reproduction.

  • Open Access

    Peak pressure experienced by the human hand during suspension and vertical climbing

    by Victoria A. Lockwood, Szu-Ching Lu, Samantha L. Winter, Hui Yang, Tracy L. Kivell

    Reconstructions of potential arboreal capabilities in extinct human ancestors (hominins) are typically inferred from upper limb morphology. Arboreal environments are complex with multiple support sizes and orientations. However, data are limited on how arboreal support variables may affect hand loading during arboreal activities. Using a custom-built climbing frame with interchangeable support diameters (45 mm, 80 mm, 105 mm), we investigated the effects of support diameter and horizontal/vertical orientation on the pressure experienced by the human hand during postural and locomotor suspension and vertical climbing (n=14 participants each). Support diameter had a consistent effect on suspension and vertical climbing normalized peak pressure values, but thumb positioning or postural versus locomotor activities had no significant relationship. The 45 mm diameter had significantly greater normalized peak pressure values compared to the 80 mm and 105 mm diameters. Postural and locomotor activity differences were only observed during vertical climbing but varied with support diameter size. Suspension and vertical climbing frequently load the third ray but distal-proximal peak pressure location patterns differ with support orientation. Support diameter and, less so, orientation influence the magnitude of loading in the human hand during the investigated arboreal behaviors. Peak pressure location patterns can distinguish suspension and vertical climbing locomotor categories within our experimental setting.


  • New hominin postcranial fossils from Kromdraai, South Africa (2014–2025)

    by Jeremy M. DeSilva, Catherine K. Miller, Marine Cazenave, Gideon Chinamatira, Habiba Chirchir, Ashley S. Hammond, Tracy L. Kivell, Klara Komza, Ellison J. McNutt, Kimberleigh Tommy, et al.

    Kromdraai, South Africa is the type locality of Paranthropus robustus . Renewed paleontological exploration of the site has yielded over 50 hominin fossils since 2014, including 21 postcranial elements. These finds nearly triple the number of postcranial remains previously known from Kromdraai. We describe here four partial humeri, five manual phalanges, two femora, two patellae, and eight pedal elements. Twenty of the fossils derive from Unit P, which dates to over 2.0 million years old and includes craniodental material from Paranthropus and Homo . One fossil, a patella, may derive from the stratigraphically older Unit O. Interestingly, while more than half of the craniodental remains from Unit P are identified as juvenile, all of the postcrania are adult. Furthermore, though none of the postcrania are directly associated with craniodental finds, we tentatively propose taxonomic assignments for some of these fossils, including two humeri and two femora that may belong to Paranthropus .

  • Open Access

    Swartkrans Paranthropus and Sterkfontein Australopithecus from southern Africa had different locomotor repertoires

    by Marine Cazenave, Annalisa Pietrobelli, Andrea Luková, Sebastian Bachmann, Matthew V. Caruana, Ronald J. Clarke, Christopher J. Dunmore, Ashley S. Hammond, Jason L. Heaton, A. J. Heile, et al.

    Southern African hominin fossils traditionally attributed to Paranthropus robustus and Australopithecus africanus are differentiated from each other by their dentition and cranial architecture, but their postcranial anatomy has typically been regarded functionally as broadly similar (i.e., terrestrial bipedalism with some degree of arboreal locomotion). Testing the hypothesis of a similar locomotor repertoire between these two taxa has been complicated by a lack of postcranial fossils attributable to P. robustus . Here, we detail our comparative examination of the internal bone anatomy of a recently described c. 1.8 Ma P. robustus articulating femur and tibia, which suggests distinct patterns of joint loading and locomotor behavior. Our analysis of cortical bone in the hip and trabecular bone in the ankle, knee, and hip joints suggests that P . robustus habitually adopted a high frequency of ankle, knee, and hip flexion, as required for climbing, while Australopithecus from a c. 3.4 Ma level at the site of Sterkfontein displays a more modern human-like structural pattern across the lower limb joints consistent with comparatively more frequent terrestrial bipedalism. These results reveal that geologically younger P . robustus likely used arboreality more frequently than older Sterkfontein Australopithecus . Together with differences in masticatory behavior, this line of evidence indicates that these two hominin taxa occupied distinct ecological niches.


  • Open Access

    Frequency of arboreality is correlated with longer hand skeletons in Gorilla : Analysis of a new skeletal sample of Bwindi mountain gorillas

    by Elliot G. Greiner, Christopher B. Ruff, Charlotte King, Aventino Nkwasibwe, Thadee Muhire, Emmanuel Tibenda, Jason S. Massey, Juho‐Antti Junno, Rowan M. Sherwood, Jean Bosco Noheri, et al.

    Understanding how ecological variation shapes skeletal morphology is important for linking observed locomotor behavior to anatomical correlates in extant hominoids, and for the subsequent interpretation of locomotor behavior in extinct taxa. In this study, we investigate ecomorphological variation in the metacarpals and phalanges across all five manual rays within Gorilla , focusing particularly on differences between western lowland gorilla ( Gorilla gorilla gorilla ) and the Rwandan (Volcanoes National Park) and Ugandan (Bwindi Impenetrable National Park) populations of mountain gorilla ( Gorilla beringei beringei ). This work incorporates the first substantial set of skeletal measurements from the Bwindi mountain gorilla population, derived from individuals recovered by the Mountain Gorilla Skeletal Project between 2018 and 2025. By comparing these data with samples from low and high‐elevation Grauer's gorillas ( Gorilla beringei graueri ), we assess how variation in arboreality correlates with digit element lengths, demonstrating that the Bwindi mountain gorillas exhibit intermediate metacarpal and phalangeal lengths between the more arboreal western lowland gorillas and the more terrestrial Virunga mountain gorillas. These findings indicate a correlation between longer digital rays in more arboreal populations, even within the same species, which may enhance grasping and stability on arboreal substrates. We show a population‐specific relationship between ecology and hand morphology in Gorilla and emphasize the value of documenting localized skeletal responses to environmental and behavioral variation to better interpret patterns in the hominoid fossil record.


  • Open Access

    Integration of distal tibial shape and internal trabecular bone structure among catarrhine primates

    by Annalisa Pietrobelli, Marine Cazenave, Alexander Synek, Sebastian Bachmann, Matthew M. Skinner, Tracy L. Kivell, Zewdi J. Tsegai

    Primates display a wide range of locomotor behaviours, each resulting in distinct mechanical demands on the ankle joint. This study examines how variation in distal tibial shape and internal bone structure captures these locomotor adaptations. We examined the morphology of distal tibiae from eight extant catarrhine genera using canonical holistic morphometric analysis. Relative trabecular bone volume fraction was quantified across homologous three-dimensional volumes, and shape was assessed via a new geometric morphometric-based approach. Our analyses reveal taxonomic and locomotor differences in both distal tibial trabecular distribution and shape. Humans exhibit a squared tibial plafond with trabecular reinforcement at its center, reflecting vertical axial loading. African apes show a trapezoidal plafond with trabecular reinforcement linked to ankle flexion during climbing and quadrupedalism. Orangutans and hylobatids exhibit diverse trabecular distribution and morphology, consistent with multidirectional loading. Cercopithecoids display posterior trabecular reinforcement and narrower joint morphology, consistent with plantarflexed postures during quadrupedalism. Substantial covariation between tibial shape and trabecular distribution was identified across taxa, with functional gradients aligning with ankle loading regimes, showing that analyzing trabecular structure and external shape enhances our understanding of joint mechanics, offering critical insight for interpretation of primate locomotor diversity and evolution.


  • Open Access

    Functional Morphology of the Scaphoid in Extant African Apes, Humans and Fossil Hominins

    by Nadine G. Steer, Ameline Bardo, Thomas W. Davies, Antonio Rosas, Matthew M. Skinner, Tracy L. Kivell

    Objectives: The morphology of the hominoid scaphoid has played a key role in functional and evolutionary hypotheses related to the emergence of hominin bipedalism and tool use. However, the scaphoid's complex morphology is challenging to comparatively analyze via traditional 2D linear measurements. This study quantifies scaphoid morphology utilizing 3D geometric morphometrics (3D GM) in African apes, humans and extinct hominins to provide a more holistic functional understanding of scaphoid morphology. Materials and Methods: We use 3D GM, including anatomical and sliding semi‐landmarks, to quantify scaphoid morphology in a comparative sample of African apes ( Gorilla , Gorilla beringei , Pan paniscus and Pan troglodytes ) ( N = 54), extant and fossil Homo sapiens ( N = 20) and nine fossil hominin scaphoids from Australopithecus sp., Australopithecus sediba , Homo naledi and Neandertals. Results: Principal component analysis indicates that extant species can be distinguished by differences in scaphoid shape that are consistent with variation in hand use during locomotion and manipulation. The australopith scaphoids plot between the African ape and modern human distributions, whereas H. naledi falls between Gorilla and human distributions. Discussion: Results confirm previous studies describing differences between extant African apes and modern human scaphoids that were interpreted as advantageous for knuckle‐walking and forceful manipulation, respectively. However, we highlight greater variation between Pan and Gorilla than previously recognized. The fossil hominin scaphoids present differing mosaics of joint orientation and shape, creating a distinct overall morphology in each hominin species. This may reflect differing functional pressures acting upon hominin wrists resulting from disparate combinations of locomotor and manipulative behaviors.


  • First known fossil hand of the hominin Paranthropus boisei

    by Tracy L. Kivell, Samar M. Syeda