David V. Budescu
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
David V. Budescu has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- David R. Mandel
Intelligence, Influence, and Collaboration Section Defence Research and Development Canada Toronto Ontario Canada
7 shared publications - Mark Himmelstein
Department of Psychology, Fordham University
7 shared publications Stephen B. Broomell
5 shared publicationsHan-Hui Por
3 shared publicationsStephen Broomell
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
3 shared publications- Boris Maciejovsky
School of Business Administration, University of California, USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 39 (2) , e70078
On Sharing Benefits Created by Costly Help
Cases in which a costly helping act by a benefactor can greatly improve the outcomes of a beneficiary abound. Such help conforms with prevalent social norms and can increase collective welfare. We study how the surplus created through such help is shared by the benefactor and the beneficiary. We hypothesized that aspects of the situation, such as relative wealth, social distance, whether the help increased gains or prevented losses, and perspective may result in variations in this division. In two experiments, we compare participants' judgments ( N = 695) and participants' bargaining choices ( N = 617 dyads). In both tasks, the proposed compensation for the cost incurred, while the benefits of helping exceeded the cost and was affected similarly by the manipulated factors. We observed pro‐social equalizing of outcomes, less indebtedness to family benefactors than to commercial ones, and sensitivity to the fact that help‐seeker was suffering a loss. However, whereas the judgments allocated to the beneficiary about 80% of the surplus generated, in (consequential) minimal bargaining, the surplus was split more equally, as expected by economic theory. This gap raises doubts about the validity of using nonconsequential measures.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 39 (2) , e70078
On Sharing Benefits Created by Costly Help
Cases in which a costly helping act by a benefactor can greatly improve the outcomes of a beneficiary abound. Such help conforms with prevalent social norms and can increase collective welfare. We study how the surplus created through such help is shared by the benefactor and the beneficiary. We hypothesized that aspects of the situation, such as relative wealth, social distance, whether the help increased gains or prevented losses, and perspective may result in variations in this division. In two experiments, we compare participants' judgments ( N = 695) and participants' bargaining choices ( N = 617 dyads). In both tasks, the proposed compensation for the cost incurred, while the benefits of helping exceeded the cost and was affected similarly by the manipulated factors. We observed pro‐social equalizing of outcomes, less indebtedness to family benefactors than to commercial ones, and sensitivity to the fact that help‐seeker was suffering a loss. However, whereas the judgments allocated to the beneficiary about 80% of the surplus generated, in (consequential) minimal bargaining, the surplus was split more equally, as expected by economic theory. This gap raises doubts about the validity of using nonconsequential measures.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Causal Inference in the Absence of Direct Measurement Using Planned Missing Data
Many psychological studies seek to quantify how treatments modify beliefs, attitudes, or behaviors by measuring the same participants on the same constructs both at baseline, before the treatment is administered, and again after it is administered. This procedure raises a problematic counterfactual: how do we know that the treatment is causing observed changes, and not the act of collecting a baseline measurement itself? This threat to validity is often referred to as \textit{measurement reactivity}. Researchers can attempt to quantify and even mitigate measurement reactivity by experimentally truncating baseline measurements, but those baseline measurements improve statistical power and may be critical for key analyses the researchers wish to conduct. We show that it is possible to indirectly recover baseline measurements by using auxiliary variables: variables which don't directly represent baseline measurements but have strong enough correlations with baseline measurements to facilitate informative imputation. We show how the measurement reactivity problem can be reframed using the logic of missing data mechanisms, demonstrate the feasibility of our proposed method in a simulation study, and then implement it in an experimental design on advice taking in which measurement reactivity is a known problem. We show that advice taking behavior clearly depends on the presence or absence of baseline measurement, and that important and ecologically valid insights about how people update their beliefs would remain undetected if measurement reactivity had remained unaddressed.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessCausal Inference in the Absence of Direct Measurement Using Planned Missing Data
Many psychological studies seek to quantify how treatments modify beliefs, attitudes, or behaviors by measuring the same participants on the same constructs both at baseline, before the treatment is administered, and again after it is administered. This procedure raises a problematic counterfactual: how do we know that the treatment is causing observed changes, and not the act of collecting a baseline measurement itself? This threat to validity is often referred to as \textit{measurement reactivity}. Researchers can attempt to quantify and even mitigate measurement reactivity by experimentally truncating baseline measurements, but those baseline measurements improve statistical power and may be critical for key analyses the researchers wish to conduct. We show that it is possible to indirectly recover baseline measurements by using auxiliary variables: variables which don't directly represent baseline measurements but have strong enough correlations with baseline measurements to facilitate informative imputation. We show how the measurement reactivity problem can be reframed using the logic of missing data mechanisms, demonstrate the feasibility of our proposed method in a simulation study, and then implement it in an experimental design on advice taking in which measurement reactivity is a known problem. We show that advice taking behavior clearly depends on the presence or absence of baseline measurement, and that important and ecologically valid insights about how people update their beliefs would remain undetected if measurement reactivity had remained unaddressed.
- Open Access
- 15 September 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Experimental Economics
- Vol. 28 (3) , 401-408
Introduction to the special issue in honor of Amnon Rapoport, Part 2
This introduction presents the two-part Special Issue of honoring the life and work of Amnon Rapoport (1936–2022), a pioneering scholar whose six decades of research shaped experimental studies of interactive decision making. Rapoport’s hallmark was the interplay between formal game-theoretic modeling and rigorous laboratory testing, advancing understanding in coalition formation, social dilemmas, market entry, traffic networks, decision timing, resource dilemmas, behavioral operations, and methodological innovation. The 27 articles collected across the volumes revisit and extend these themes, offering fresh insights into how rationality assumptions succeed and fail in predicting human behavior. Together, the contributions reflect both continuity with Rapoport’s intellectual credo—“model first, test second, refine third”—and renewal through new methods and applications. Beyond scholarship, the issue pays tribute to Rapoport’s extraordinary role as a mentor and his enduring influence on the evolution of behavioral and experimental economics
- 15 September 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Experimental Economics
- Vol. 28 (3) , 401-408
Open AccessIntroduction to the special issue in honor of Amnon Rapoport, Part 2
This introduction presents the two-part Special Issue of honoring the life and work of Amnon Rapoport (1936–2022), a pioneering scholar whose six decades of research shaped experimental studies of interactive decision making. Rapoport’s hallmark was the interplay between formal game-theoretic modeling and rigorous laboratory testing, advancing understanding in coalition formation, social dilemmas, market entry, traffic networks, decision timing, resource dilemmas, behavioral operations, and methodological innovation. The 27 articles collected across the volumes revisit and extend these themes, offering fresh insights into how rationality assumptions succeed and fail in predicting human behavior. Together, the contributions reflect both continuity with Rapoport’s intellectual credo—“model first, test second, refine third”—and renewal through new methods and applications. Beyond scholarship, the issue pays tribute to Rapoport’s extraordinary role as a mentor and his enduring influence on the evolution of behavioral and experimental economics
- Open Access
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 237-246
Expert Judgment and Communication of Uncertainty
Knowledge built through the scientific study of climate is essential for informed decision-making. In the presence of irreducible uncertainty, the results of climate science must be gathered and synthesized through expert judgment. Experts communicate uncertainty to the public to support their understanding of the science and actionable options. Building on the efforts of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, we introduce psychological research on judgment and decision-making with the goal of building a representation of scientific uncertainty that can facilitate communication between experts and the public. We propose that scientific representations of uncertainty can be recast as decision uncertainty, translating scientific knowledge into expected outcomes and their chances of occurrence. This approach is supported by broader evidence from the social sciences that the public does not view scientific results in terms of scientific methods (e.g., data quality and sample sizes). Instead, the public sees uncertainty in scientific results when they fail to reflect their lived experiences and personal perceptions. Additionally, while disagreement and debate are an essential part of scientific exploration, the communication of such disagreements may, in some cases, undermine confidence in the science itself rather than help calibrate perceptions of uncertainty.
- 15 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 237-246
Open AccessExpert Judgment and Communication of Uncertainty
Knowledge built through the scientific study of climate is essential for informed decision-making. In the presence of irreducible uncertainty, the results of climate science must be gathered and synthesized through expert judgment. Experts communicate uncertainty to the public to support their understanding of the science and actionable options. Building on the efforts of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, we introduce psychological research on judgment and decision-making with the goal of building a representation of scientific uncertainty that can facilitate communication between experts and the public. We propose that scientific representations of uncertainty can be recast as decision uncertainty, translating scientific knowledge into expected outcomes and their chances of occurrence. This approach is supported by broader evidence from the social sciences that the public does not view scientific results in terms of scientific methods (e.g., data quality and sample sizes). Instead, the public sees uncertainty in scientific results when they fail to reflect their lived experiences and personal perceptions. Additionally, while disagreement and debate are an essential part of scientific exploration, the communication of such disagreements may, in some cases, undermine confidence in the science itself rather than help calibrate perceptions of uncertainty.
- Open Access
- 19 June 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The Effect of Source Reliability and Information Credibility on Judgments of Information Quality in Intelligence Analysis
The quality of information that informs decisions in expert domains such as law enforcement and national security often requires assessment based on meta-informational attributes such as source reliability and information credibility. Across two experiments with intelligence analysts (n = 74) and non-experts (n = 175), participants rated the accuracy, informativeness, trustworthiness and usefulness of information varying in source reliability and information credibility. The latter two attributes were communicated using ratings from the Admiralty Code, an information evaluation system widely used in the defence and security domain since the 1940s. Ratings of accuracy, informativeness, and likelihood of use were elicited as repeated measures to examine intra-individual reliability. Across experiments, intra-individual reliability was best when levels of source reliability and information credibility were moderately consistent compared to when they were maximally inconsistent (i.e., one low and one high) or maximally consistent (both high or low). As well, trustworthiness ratings depended more on source reliability than on information credibility. Finally, the likelihood of using information was consistently predicted by accuracy ratings and not by judged informativeness or trustworthiness. The current findings offer insights into the ability of experts and novices to reliably use information evaluation systems for structuring human judgments about intelligence.
- 19 June 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe Effect of Source Reliability and Information Credibility on Judgments of Information Quality in Intelligence Analysis
The quality of information that informs decisions in expert domains such as law enforcement and national security often requires assessment based on meta-informational attributes such as source reliability and information credibility. Across two experiments with intelligence analysts (n = 74) and non-experts (n = 175), participants rated the accuracy, informativeness, trustworthiness and usefulness of information varying in source reliability and information credibility. The latter two attributes were communicated using ratings from the Admiralty Code, an information evaluation system widely used in the defence and security domain since the 1940s. Ratings of accuracy, informativeness, and likelihood of use were elicited as repeated measures to examine intra-individual reliability. Across experiments, intra-individual reliability was best when levels of source reliability and information credibility were moderately consistent compared to when they were maximally inconsistent (i.e., one low and one high) or maximally consistent (both high or low). As well, trustworthiness ratings depended more on source reliability than on information credibility. Finally, the likelihood of using information was consistently predicted by accuracy ratings and not by judged informativeness or trustworthiness. The current findings offer insights into the ability of experts and novices to reliably use information evaluation systems for structuring human judgments about intelligence.
- Open Access
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
The Psychometric Properties of Probability and Quantile Forecasts
Forecasting tournaments are a well established method for assessing human forecasting skills. Most forecasting tournaments are based on a format where participants estimate the probabilities of discrete events. For predictions of continuous values, the possible range of outcome values is divided into mutually exclusive bins covering the entire outcome distribution so that probabilities for each bin can be elicited. An alternative approach involves directly eliciting forecasts about quantiles of the continuous quantity. Using both simulated data and data from 1,147 participants who completed five surveys focused on forecasting tasks in a longitudinal study, we compared the psychometric properties of quantile and probability elicitation methods. In the simulation, we demonstrated that items in the quantile format recovered parameters that defined forecasters’ latent forecasting skill in fewer items than the probability format, and identified several idiosyncrasies in accuracy scores for the probability format that drive these differences. In the empirical analyses, we elicited forecasts about a set of 36 forecasting questions in both formats: quantile forecasts at five fixed probability values (5%, 25%, 50%, 75%, 95%) and probability forecasts for five pre-determined item-specific bins. Consistent with the simulated results, our findings revealed that forecasts in the quantile format showed considerably stronger internal consistency, achieving a suitable reliability level with fewer items. When cross-validating how well individual forecasters’ accuracy on in-sample questions predicted their performance in out-of-sample questions, the variability in the accuracy of quantile forecasts was more statistically explainable. Despite its desirable properties, errors and signs of comprehension difficulties were more frequently observed in the quantile format. Further research is needed to refine elicitations that optimize the effectiveness of quantile-based forecasting judgments.
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessThe Psychometric Properties of Probability and Quantile Forecasts
Forecasting tournaments are a well established method for assessing human forecasting skills. Most forecasting tournaments are based on a format where participants estimate the probabilities of discrete events. For predictions of continuous values, the possible range of outcome values is divided into mutually exclusive bins covering the entire outcome distribution so that probabilities for each bin can be elicited. An alternative approach involves directly eliciting forecasts about quantiles of the continuous quantity. Using both simulated data and data from 1,147 participants who completed five surveys focused on forecasting tasks in a longitudinal study, we compared the psychometric properties of quantile and probability elicitation methods. In the simulation, we demonstrated that items in the quantile format recovered parameters that defined forecasters’ latent forecasting skill in fewer items than the probability format, and identified several idiosyncrasies in accuracy scores for the probability format that drive these differences. In the empirical analyses, we elicited forecasts about a set of 36 forecasting questions in both formats: quantile forecasts at five fixed probability values (5%, 25%, 50%, 75%, 95%) and probability forecasts for five pre-determined item-specific bins. Consistent with the simulated results, our findings revealed that forecasts in the quantile format showed considerably stronger internal consistency, achieving a suitable reliability level with fewer items. When cross-validating how well individual forecasters’ accuracy on in-sample questions predicted their performance in out-of-sample questions, the variability in the accuracy of quantile forecasts was more statistically explainable. Despite its desirable properties, errors and signs of comprehension difficulties were more frequently observed in the quantile format. Further research is needed to refine elicitations that optimize the effectiveness of quantile-based forecasting judgments.
- 4 January 2025
- Published by World Scientific Pub Co Pte Ltd in Water Economics and Policy
- Vol. 11 (01)
Reverse Contests as a Means to Reduce Polluting Activity
Contests are situations in which contestants invest efforts, time or money to win a valuable prize (e.g., political or advertising campaigns, R&D races) forfeiting their bids irrespective of the outcome of the contest. Game-theoretic analyses stipulate that, in equilibrium, total investment would dissipate — equal the value of the prize. However, experimental studies of contests revealed considerable over-dissipation, with investments exceeding the value of the prize. In light of these findings, and findings that punishments are more effective than rewards in bringing about socially desirable behavior, we propose a reverse contest, in which contestants compete to avoid a penalty imposed on the highest polluter, to curb polluting production. “Investments” are thus the profits given up by reducing profitable (but polluting) production. In four experiments (total [ ]), groups of randomly re-matched agents repeatedly (for 40 rounds) decided how much of their available funds to invest in profitable production, knowing that the one who invested the most would be fined. Players were characterized by their funds and productivity rate. In every group there was at least one agent who would profit if investing all funds and being penalized. We tested (a) If agents invest, in production, less than their full funds. (b) Whether the profits given up by reduced production exceed the penalty. (c) How any effects observed change with time. We manipulated group size, penalty size, group composition (homogeneous or heterogeneous), and whether the participants knew that production was polluting. Across the four experiments, we observed that: (a) Investments in production were much lower than the maximum possible (64% of the maximum). (b) The profits given up by reduced investments were higher than the penalty (by 57%). (c) Investments went up and the profits given up went down over the first few rounds, but then stabilized. All in all, our data indicate that reverse context may prove a valuable tool at the hands of policy makers wishing to curb polluting activity.
- 4 January 2025
- Published by World Scientific Pub Co Pte Ltd in Water Economics and Policy
- Vol. 11 (01)
Reverse Contests as a Means to Reduce Polluting Activity
Contests are situations in which contestants invest efforts, time or money to win a valuable prize (e.g., political or advertising campaigns, R&D races) forfeiting their bids irrespective of the outcome of the contest. Game-theoretic analyses stipulate that, in equilibrium, total investment would dissipate — equal the value of the prize. However, experimental studies of contests revealed considerable over-dissipation, with investments exceeding the value of the prize. In light of these findings, and findings that punishments are more effective than rewards in bringing about socially desirable behavior, we propose a reverse contest, in which contestants compete to avoid a penalty imposed on the highest polluter, to curb polluting production. “Investments” are thus the profits given up by reducing profitable (but polluting) production. In four experiments (total [ ]), groups of randomly re-matched agents repeatedly (for 40 rounds) decided how much of their available funds to invest in profitable production, knowing that the one who invested the most would be fined. Players were characterized by their funds and productivity rate. In every group there was at least one agent who would profit if investing all funds and being penalized. We tested (a) If agents invest, in production, less than their full funds. (b) Whether the profits given up by reduced production exceed the penalty. (c) How any effects observed change with time. We manipulated group size, penalty size, group composition (homogeneous or heterogeneous), and whether the participants knew that production was polluting. Across the four experiments, we observed that: (a) Investments in production were much lower than the maximum possible (64% of the maximum). (b) The profits given up by reduced investments were higher than the penalty (by 57%). (c) Investments went up and the profits given up went down over the first few rounds, but then stabilized. All in all, our data indicate that reverse context may prove a valuable tool at the hands of policy makers wishing to curb polluting activity.
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Forecasting
- Vol. 41 (2) , 596-612
Measuring probabilistic coherence to identify superior forecasters
- 27 March 2024
- Published by Elsevier in International Journal of Forecasting
- Vol. 41 (2) , 596-612
Measuring probabilistic coherence to identify superior forecasters
- Open Access
- 11 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 37 (2)
Algorithms in selection decisions: Effective, but unappreciated
Selection decisions are often affected by irrelevant variables such as gender or race. People can discount this irrelevant information by adjusting their predictions accordingly, yet they fail to do so intuitively. In five online studies (N = 1077), participants were asked to make selection decisions in which the selection test was affected by irrelevant attributes. We examined whether in such decisions people are willing to be advised by algorithms, human advisors or prefer to decide without advice. We found that people fail to adjust for irrelevant information by themselves, and those who received advice from an algorithm or human advisor made better decisions. Interestingly, although most participants stated they prefer advice from human advisors, they tend to rely equally on algorithms in actual selection tasks. The sole exception is when they are forced to choose between an algorithm and a human advisor. In that case, they pick human advisors. We conclude that while algorithms may not be people's preferred source of advice in selection decisions, they are equally useful and can be implemented.
- 11 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 37 (2)
Open AccessAlgorithms in selection decisions: Effective, but unappreciated
Selection decisions are often affected by irrelevant variables such as gender or race. People can discount this irrelevant information by adjusting their predictions accordingly, yet they fail to do so intuitively. In five online studies (N = 1077), participants were asked to make selection decisions in which the selection test was affected by irrelevant attributes. We examined whether in such decisions people are willing to be advised by algorithms, human advisors or prefer to decide without advice. We found that people fail to adjust for irrelevant information by themselves, and those who received advice from an algorithm or human advisor made better decisions. Interestingly, although most participants stated they prefer advice from human advisors, they tend to rely equally on algorithms in actual selection tasks. The sole exception is when they are forced to choose between an algorithm and a human advisor. In that case, they pick human advisors. We conclude that while algorithms may not be people's preferred source of advice in selection decisions, they are equally useful and can be implemented.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Decision
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-6
Introduction to the special issue on judgment and decision research on the wisdom of the crowds.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Decision
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-6
Introduction to the special issue on judgment and decision research on the wisdom of the crowds.