Cornelius Langenbruch
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Cornelius Langenbruch has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Serge Alexander Shapiro
Freie Universität Berlin 1 , Department of Geophysics, Berlin, Germany
14 shared publications Carsten Dinske
Freie Universität Berlin 1 , Fachrichtung Geophysik, Fachbereich Geowissenschaften, Berlin, .;;;
3 shared publicationsC. Dinske
Fachrichtung Geophysik; Freie Universität Berlin; Berlin; Germany
2 shared publications- Mark D. Zoback
Stanford University, Stanford, USA
2 shared publications - Mohammad Javad Afshari Moein
Department of Earth Sciences, Geological Institute ETH Zurich Zurich Switzerland
2 shared publications - Andreas Barth
Geophysical Institute, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Karlsruhe, Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Comparing water-disposal and CO2-storage induced earthquakes
To date, only several small-scale CO2 storage projects, injecting about 1 Mt of CO2 per year, exist worldwide. Induced seismicity has been recorded during operation. Overall, magnitudes of the seismic events are small (below M=3). Nevertheless, there is the concern that future large-scale projects will induce significantly larger magnitudes, like it is observed for basin-scale waste-water disposal. For instance, large-scale water disposal in Oklahoma and Kansas (USA) induced thousands of widely felt M3+ earthquakes with a maximum magnitude of M=5.8. We analyze seismicity and injection data from CO2-storage projects including Quest (CA), Decataur (USA), In-Sahla (Algeria), Otway (AUS) and Gorgon (AUS). We compute the normalized seismic response of the subsurface to injection of a unit volume of CO2 using the Seismogenic Index (SI) and compare it to water-disposal case studies. We find that the SI at CO2-storage sites is smaller compared to water-disposal cases. It indicates a lower seismic hazard per injected volume of CO2. We discuss physical processes that could explain our observations and show how earthquake magnitude probabilities can potentially be upscaled, considering CO2 storage volumes needed in the future.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessComparing water-disposal and CO2-storage induced earthquakes
To date, only several small-scale CO2 storage projects, injecting about 1 Mt of CO2 per year, exist worldwide. Induced seismicity has been recorded during operation. Overall, magnitudes of the seismic events are small (below M=3). Nevertheless, there is the concern that future large-scale projects will induce significantly larger magnitudes, like it is observed for basin-scale waste-water disposal. For instance, large-scale water disposal in Oklahoma and Kansas (USA) induced thousands of widely felt M3+ earthquakes with a maximum magnitude of M=5.8. We analyze seismicity and injection data from CO2-storage projects including Quest (CA), Decataur (USA), In-Sahla (Algeria), Otway (AUS) and Gorgon (AUS). We compute the normalized seismic response of the subsurface to injection of a unit volume of CO2 using the Seismogenic Index (SI) and compare it to water-disposal case studies. We find that the SI at CO2-storage sites is smaller compared to water-disposal cases. It indicates a lower seismic hazard per injected volume of CO2. We discuss physical processes that could explain our observations and show how earthquake magnitude probabilities can potentially be upscaled, considering CO2 storage volumes needed in the future.
- Open Access
- 29 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 129 (11)
Mitigation and Optimization of Induced Seismicity Using Physics‐Based Forecasting
Fluid injection can induce seismicity by altering stresses on pre‐existing faults. Here, we investigate minimizing induced earthquake potential by optimizing injection operations in a physics‐based forecasting framework. We built a 3D finite element model of the poroelastic crust for the Raton Basin, Central US, and used it to estimate time dependent Coulomb stress changes due to 25 years of wastewater injection in the region. Our finite element model is complemented by a statistical analysis of the seismogenic index (SI), a proxy for critically stressed faults affected by variations in the pore pressure. Forecasts of seismicity rate from our hybrid physics‐based statistical model suggest that induced seismicity in the Raton Basin, from 2001 to 2022, is still driven by wastewater injection despite declining injection rates since 2011. Our model suggests that pore pressure diffusion is the dominant cause of Coulomb stress changes at seismogenic depth, with poroelastic stress changes contributing about 5% to the driving force. Linear programming optimization for the Raton Basin reveals that it is feasible to reduce earthquake potential for a given amount of injected fluid (safety objective) or maximize fluid injection for a prescribed earthquake potential (economic objective). The optimization tends to spread out high‐rate injectors and shift them to regions of lower SI. The framework has practical importance as a tool to manage injection rate per unit field area to reduce induced earthquake potential. Our optimization framework is both flexible and adaptable to mitigate induced earthquake potential in other regions and for other types of subsurface fluid injection.
- 29 October 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 129 (11)
Open AccessMitigation and Optimization of Induced Seismicity Using Physics‐Based Forecasting
Fluid injection can induce seismicity by altering stresses on pre‐existing faults. Here, we investigate minimizing induced earthquake potential by optimizing injection operations in a physics‐based forecasting framework. We built a 3D finite element model of the poroelastic crust for the Raton Basin, Central US, and used it to estimate time dependent Coulomb stress changes due to 25 years of wastewater injection in the region. Our finite element model is complemented by a statistical analysis of the seismogenic index (SI), a proxy for critically stressed faults affected by variations in the pore pressure. Forecasts of seismicity rate from our hybrid physics‐based statistical model suggest that induced seismicity in the Raton Basin, from 2001 to 2022, is still driven by wastewater injection despite declining injection rates since 2011. Our model suggests that pore pressure diffusion is the dominant cause of Coulomb stress changes at seismogenic depth, with poroelastic stress changes contributing about 5% to the driving force. Linear programming optimization for the Raton Basin reveals that it is feasible to reduce earthquake potential for a given amount of injected fluid (safety objective) or maximize fluid injection for a prescribed earthquake potential (economic objective). The optimization tends to spread out high‐rate injectors and shift them to regions of lower SI. The framework has practical importance as a tool to manage injection rate per unit field area to reduce induced earthquake potential. Our optimization framework is both flexible and adaptable to mitigate induced earthquake potential in other regions and for other types of subsurface fluid injection.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
- Vol. 382 (2276) , 20230184
Are maximum magnitudes of induced earthquakes controlled by pressure diffusion?
There is an ongoing discussion about how to forecast the maximum magnitudes of induced earthquakes based on operational parameters, subsurface conditions and physical process understanding. Although the occurrence of damage caused by induced earthquakes is rare, some cases have caused significant economic loss, injuries and even loss of life. We analysed a global compilation of earthquakes induced by hydraulic fracturing, geothermal reservoir stimulation, water disposal, gas storage and reservoir impoundment. Our analysis showed that maximum magnitudes scale with the characteristic length of pressure diffusion in the brittle Earth’s crust. We observed an increase in the nucleation potential of larger-magnitude earthquakes with time and explained it by diffusion-controlled growth of the pressure-perturbed part of faults. Numerical and analytical fault size modelling supported our findings. Finally, we derived magnitude scaling laws to manage induced seismic hazard of upcoming energy projects prior to operation. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Induced seismicity in coupled subsurface systems’.
- 1 July 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
- Vol. 382 (2276) , 20230184
Open AccessAre maximum magnitudes of induced earthquakes controlled by pressure diffusion?
There is an ongoing discussion about how to forecast the maximum magnitudes of induced earthquakes based on operational parameters, subsurface conditions and physical process understanding. Although the occurrence of damage caused by induced earthquakes is rare, some cases have caused significant economic loss, injuries and even loss of life. We analysed a global compilation of earthquakes induced by hydraulic fracturing, geothermal reservoir stimulation, water disposal, gas storage and reservoir impoundment. Our analysis showed that maximum magnitudes scale with the characteristic length of pressure diffusion in the brittle Earth’s crust. We observed an increase in the nucleation potential of larger-magnitude earthquakes with time and explained it by diffusion-controlled growth of the pressure-perturbed part of faults. Numerical and analytical fault size modelling supported our findings. Finally, we derived magnitude scaling laws to manage induced seismic hazard of upcoming energy projects prior to operation. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Induced seismicity in coupled subsurface systems’.
- Top Cited Papers
- 5 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Earth & Environment
- Vol. 4 (12) , 847-863
The physical mechanisms of induced earthquakes
- 5 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Reviews Earth & Environment
- Vol. 4 (12) , 847-863
Top Cited PapersThe physical mechanisms of induced earthquakes
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Pressure diffusion controls maximum induced earthquake magnitudes
It is an open question if maximum induced earthquake magnitudes can be determined based on knowledge about operational parameters, subsurface conditions and physical process understanding. We analyzed a global compilation of earthquakes induced by hydraulic fracturing, geothermal reservoir stimulation, water disposal, gas storage and reservoir impoundment. Our analysis showed that maximum magnitudes scale with the characteristic length of pressure diffusion in the brittle Earth’s crust. An observed increase of the nucleation potential of larger magnitude earthquakes with time is likely governed by diffusion-controlled growth of pressure perturbed fault sizes. Numerical and analytical fault size modelling confirmed the findings. Finally, we derived scaling laws for the maximum possible and maximum expected magnitude for induced seismic hazard and risk forecasting and management.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessPressure diffusion controls maximum induced earthquake magnitudes
It is an open question if maximum induced earthquake magnitudes can be determined based on knowledge about operational parameters, subsurface conditions and physical process understanding. We analyzed a global compilation of earthquakes induced by hydraulic fracturing, geothermal reservoir stimulation, water disposal, gas storage and reservoir impoundment. Our analysis showed that maximum magnitudes scale with the characteristic length of pressure diffusion in the brittle Earth’s crust. An observed increase of the nucleation potential of larger magnitude earthquakes with time is likely governed by diffusion-controlled growth of pressure perturbed fault sizes. Numerical and analytical fault size modelling confirmed the findings. Finally, we derived scaling laws for the maximum possible and maximum expected magnitude for induced seismic hazard and risk forecasting and management.
- Open Access
- 26 September 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 9 (1) , 1-10
Physics-based forecasting of man-made earthquake hazards in Oklahoma and Kansas
Reinjection of saltwater, co-produced with oil, triggered thousands of widely felt and several damaging earthquakes in Oklahoma and Kansas. The future seismic hazard remains uncertain. Here, we present a new methodology to forecast the probability of damaging induced earthquakes in space and time. In our hybrid physical–statistical model, seismicity is driven by the rate of injection-induced pressure increases at any given location and spatial variations in the number and stress state of preexisting basement faults affected by the pressure increase. If current injection practices continue, earthquake hazards are expected to decrease slowly. Approximately 190, 130 and 100 widely felt M ≥ 3 earthquakes are anticipated in 2018, 2019 and 2020, respectively, with corresponding probabilities of potentially damaging M ≥ 5 earthquakes of 32, 24 and 19%. We identify areas where produced-water injection is more likely to cause seismicity. Our methodology can be used to evaluate future injection scenarios intended to mitigate seismic hazards.
- 26 September 2018
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 9 (1) , 1-10
Open AccessPhysics-based forecasting of man-made earthquake hazards in Oklahoma and Kansas
Reinjection of saltwater, co-produced with oil, triggered thousands of widely felt and several damaging earthquakes in Oklahoma and Kansas. The future seismic hazard remains uncertain. Here, we present a new methodology to forecast the probability of damaging induced earthquakes in space and time. In our hybrid physical–statistical model, seismicity is driven by the rate of injection-induced pressure increases at any given location and spatial variations in the number and stress state of preexisting basement faults affected by the pressure increase. If current injection practices continue, earthquake hazards are expected to decrease slowly. Approximately 190, 130 and 100 widely felt M ≥ 3 earthquakes are anticipated in 2018, 2019 and 2020, respectively, with corresponding probabilities of potentially damaging M ≥ 5 earthquakes of 32, 24 and 19%. We identify areas where produced-water injection is more likely to cause seismicity. Our methodology can be used to evaluate future injection scenarios intended to mitigate seismic hazards.
- Open Access
- 4 August 2017
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 3 (8) , eaao2277
Response to Comment on “How will induced seismicity in Oklahoma respond to decreased saltwater injection rates?”
Goebel et al. question our forecasted response of induced seismicity to reduction of saltwater injection rates in north-central Oklahoma and raise the concern that “the probability of future damaging earthquakes may be underestimated.” We compare our prediction to earthquake data recorded in the 8 months after publication. Observed seismicity rates and magnitudes agree with the forecast of our model. Our use of a probabilistic model accounts for uncertainties and observed M ≥ 4.5 to date confirm the conservative nature of our prediction. The “realistic parameter range” suggested by Goebel et al. is based on a misunderstanding of our statistical model and disagrees with the long-term decay of seismicity in the region.
- 4 August 2017
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 3 (8) , eaao2277
Open AccessResponse to Comment on “How will induced seismicity in Oklahoma respond to decreased saltwater injection rates?”
Goebel et al. question our forecasted response of induced seismicity to reduction of saltwater injection rates in north-central Oklahoma and raise the concern that “the probability of future damaging earthquakes may be underestimated.” We compare our prediction to earthquake data recorded in the 8 months after publication. Observed seismicity rates and magnitudes agree with the forecast of our model. Our use of a probabilistic model accounts for uncertainties and observed M ≥ 4.5 to date confirm the conservative nature of our prediction. The “realistic parameter range” suggested by Goebel et al. is based on a misunderstanding of our statistical model and disagrees with the long-term decay of seismicity in the region.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 4 November 2016
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 2 (11) , e1601542-1601542
How will induced seismicity in Oklahoma respond to decreased saltwater injection rates?
In response to the marked number of injection-induced earthquakes in north-central Oklahoma, regulators recently called for a 40% reduction in the volume of saltwater being injected in the seismically active areas. We present a calibrated statistical model that predicts that widely felt M ≥ 3 earthquakes in the affected areas, as well as the probability of potentially damaging larger events, should significantly decrease by the end of 2016 and approach historic levels within a few years. Aftershock sequences associated with relatively large magnitude earthquakes that occurred in the Fairview, Cherokee, and Pawnee areas in north-central Oklahoma in late 2015 and 2016 will delay the rate of seismicity decrease in those areas.
- 4 November 2016
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science Advances
- Vol. 2 (11) , e1601542-1601542
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessHow will induced seismicity in Oklahoma respond to decreased saltwater injection rates?
In response to the marked number of injection-induced earthquakes in north-central Oklahoma, regulators recently called for a 40% reduction in the volume of saltwater being injected in the seismically active areas. We present a calibrated statistical model that predicts that widely felt M ≥ 3 earthquakes in the affected areas, as well as the probability of potentially damaging larger events, should significantly decrease by the end of 2016 and approach historic levels within a few years. Aftershock sequences associated with relatively large magnitude earthquakes that occurred in the Fairview, Cherokee, and Pawnee areas in north-central Oklahoma in late 2015 and 2016 will delay the rate of seismicity decrease in those areas.
- Open Access
- 12 December 2015
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 42 (24) , 10,601-10,606
A statistical model for seismic hazard assessment of hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced seismicity
We analyze the interevent time distribution of hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced seismicity collected during 18 stages at four different regions. We identify a universal statistical process describing the distribution of hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced events in time. The distribution of waiting times between subsequently occurring events is given by the exponential probability density function of the homogeneous Poisson process. Our findings suggest that hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced seismicity is directly triggered by the relaxation of stress and pore pressure perturbation initially created by the injection. Therefore, compared to this relaxation, the stress transfer caused by the occurrence of preceding seismic events is mainly insignificant for the seismogenesis of subsequently occurring events. We develop a statistical model to compute the occurrence probability of hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced seismicity. This model can be used to assess the seismic hazard associated with hydraulic fracturing operations. No aftershock triggering has to be included in the statistical model.
- 12 December 2015
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Geophysical Research Letters
- Vol. 42 (24) , 10,601-10,606
Open AccessA statistical model for seismic hazard assessment of hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced seismicity
We analyze the interevent time distribution of hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced seismicity collected during 18 stages at four different regions. We identify a universal statistical process describing the distribution of hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced events in time. The distribution of waiting times between subsequently occurring events is given by the exponential probability density function of the homogeneous Poisson process. Our findings suggest that hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced seismicity is directly triggered by the relaxation of stress and pore pressure perturbation initially created by the injection. Therefore, compared to this relaxation, the stress transfer caused by the occurrence of preceding seismic events is mainly insignificant for the seismogenesis of subsequently occurring events. We develop a statistical model to compute the occurrence probability of hydraulic‐fracturing‐induced seismicity. This model can be used to assess the seismic hazard associated with hydraulic fracturing operations. No aftershock triggering has to be included in the statistical model.
- 26 August 2015
- Published by Society of Exploration Geophysicists in Geophysics
- Vol. 80 (6) , WC73-WC88
Quantitative analysis of rock stress heterogeneity: Implications for the seismogenesis of fluid-injection-induced seismicity
We compared elastic-rock heterogeneity measured by borehole logging to the occurrence of seismic events caused by hydraulic fracturing of the corresponding rock sections. Our observations made from two hydraulic fracturing case studies suggest that elastic-rock heterogeneity controls the occurrence of fluid-injection-induced seismicity. The seismic events occurred preferentially in rock sections characterized by low Poisson’s ratio and high Young’s modulus. Based on analytic solutions of stress fluctuations in elastically heterogeneous media in equilibrium to a homogeneous far-field stress, we quantified the relation between elastic-rock heterogeneity and stress changes leading to fracture opening and reactivation in two end member models of 1D and 3D heterogeneity. We found that significant fluctuations of rock stress originated from elastic rock heterogeneity. Moreover, we found that stress changes leading to fracture opening and reactivation in rocks undergo scale invariance spatial fluctuations. This gave a possible physical explanation for the observed scale invariance of seismogenic processes. We analyzed the physical meaning of a heterogeneity index of rocks, which indicated rock sections of high Young’s modulus and low Poisson’s ratio. We found that this index can be used to identify rock sections of high differential stress. In addition, our results suggest that it is related to the occurrence probability of brittle rock failure during hydraulic fracturing. Nevertheless, we found that fluctuations of Poisson’s ratio showed an even stronger correlation to critical stress changes which resulted in opening and reactivation of fractures in rocks. We obtained an analytic solution of stress fluctuations in vertical transverse isotropic layers such as shale deposits and applied it to a hydraulic fracturing case study of a shale gas reservoir. Also in this case, we observed strong relations between seismicity and fluctuations of stress in space.
- 26 August 2015
- Published by Society of Exploration Geophysicists in Geophysics
- Vol. 80 (6) , WC73-WC88
Quantitative analysis of rock stress heterogeneity: Implications for the seismogenesis of fluid-injection-induced seismicity
We compared elastic-rock heterogeneity measured by borehole logging to the occurrence of seismic events caused by hydraulic fracturing of the corresponding rock sections. Our observations made from two hydraulic fracturing case studies suggest that elastic-rock heterogeneity controls the occurrence of fluid-injection-induced seismicity. The seismic events occurred preferentially in rock sections characterized by low Poisson’s ratio and high Young’s modulus. Based on analytic solutions of stress fluctuations in elastically heterogeneous media in equilibrium to a homogeneous far-field stress, we quantified the relation between elastic-rock heterogeneity and stress changes leading to fracture opening and reactivation in two end member models of 1D and 3D heterogeneity. We found that significant fluctuations of rock stress originated from elastic rock heterogeneity. Moreover, we found that stress changes leading to fracture opening and reactivation in rocks undergo scale invariance spatial fluctuations. This gave a possible physical explanation for the observed scale invariance of seismogenic processes. We analyzed the physical meaning of a heterogeneity index of rocks, which indicated rock sections of high Young’s modulus and low Poisson’s ratio. We found that this index can be used to identify rock sections of high differential stress. In addition, our results suggest that it is related to the occurrence probability of brittle rock failure during hydraulic fracturing. Nevertheless, we found that fluctuations of Poisson’s ratio showed an even stronger correlation to critical stress changes which resulted in opening and reactivation of fractures in rocks. We obtained an analytic solution of stress fluctuations in vertical transverse isotropic layers such as shale deposits and applied it to a hydraulic fracturing case study of a shale gas reservoir. Also in this case, we observed strong relations between seismicity and fluctuations of stress in space.