LMLindsay Melvin

Lindsay Melvin

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Lindsay Melvin has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    “Patients Are the People Who Teach Me the Most”: Exploring the Development of Communication Skills During Internal Medicine Residency

    by Gabriel Burke, Lindsay Melvin, Shiphra Ginsburg

    Background: Physician-patient communication training is a vital component of medical education, yet physicians do not always achieve the communication expertise expected of them. Despite extensive literature on the efficacy of various training interventions, little is known about how residents believe they learn to communicate. Objective: To understand residents' perspectives on the development of their communication skills. Methods: Between November 2020 and January 2021 recruitment emails were sent to all 225 internal medicine residents at the University of Toronto; one-on-one interviews were conducted with 15 residents. Participants were asked to reflect on communication skills development. Interviews were conducted and analyzed using constructivist grounded theory. Results: Participants credited the majority of their skills development to unsupervised interactions with patients, without explicit guidance from an attending physician. Attendings' contributions were primarily seen through role modeling, with little perceived learning coming from feedback on observed interactions. This was partly explained by residents' proclivity to alter their communication styles when observed, rendering feedback less relevant to their authentic practice, and by receiving generically positive feedback lacking in constructive features. Time constraints led to communication styles that prioritized efficiency at the cost of patient-centeredness. Conclusions: These findings suggest that current models of communication training and assessment may fall short due to overreliance on observation by attendings and examiners, which may fail to unearth the authentic and largely self-taught communication behaviors of residents. Further research is required to ascertain the feasibility and potential value of other forms of communication training and assessment, such as through patient feedback.


  • Supervising the senior medical resident: Entrusting the role, supporting the tasks

    by Rose Hatala, Shiphra Ginsburg, Stephen Gauthier, Lindsay Melvin, David Taylor, Andrea Gingerich

    Introduction: Postgraduate competency‐based medical education has been implemented with programmatic assessment that relies on entrustment‐based ratings. Yet, in less procedurally oriented specialties such as internal medicine, the relationship between entrustment and supervision remains unclear. We undertook the current study to address how internal medicine supervisors conceptualise entrusting senior medical residents while supervising them on the acute care wards. Methods: Guided by constructivist grounded theory, we interviewed 19 physicians who regularly supervised senior internal medicine residents on inpatient wards at three Canadian universities. We developed a theoretical model through iterative cycles of data collection and analysis using a constant comparative process. Results: On the internal medicine ward, the senior resident role is viewed as a fundamentally managerial and rudimentary version of the supervisor's role. Supervisors come to trust their residents in the senior role through an early ‘hands‐on’ period of assessment followed by a gradual withdrawal of support to promote independence. When considering entrustment, supervisors focused on entrusting a particular scope of the senior resident role as opposed to entrustment of individual tasks . Irrespective of the scope of the role that was entrusted, supervisors at times stepped in and stepped back to support specific tasks. Conclusion: Supervisors' stepping in and stepping back to support individual tasks on the acute care ward has an inconsistent relationship to their entrustment of the resident with a particular scope of the senior resident role . In this context, entrustment‐based assessment would need to capture more of the holistic perspective of the supervisor's entrustment of the senior resident role. Understanding the dance of supervision, from relatively static overall support of the resident in their role, to fluidly stepping in and out for specific patient care tasks, allows us insight into the affordances of the supervisory relationship and how it may be leveraged for assessment.


  • Open Access

    Understanding the Use and Perceived Impact of a Medical Podcast: Qualitative Study

    by Sarah L Malecki, Kieran L Quinn, Nathan Zilbert, Fahad Razak, Shiphra Ginsburg, Amol A Verma, Lindsay Melvin

    Background: Although podcasts are increasingly being produced for medical education, their use and perceived impact in informal educational settings are understudied. Objective: This study aimed to explore how and why physicians and medical learners listen to The Rounds Table (TRT), a medical podcast, as well as to determine the podcast’s perceived impact on learning and practice. Methods: Web-based podcast analytics were used to collect TRT usage statistics. A total of 17 medical TRT listeners were then identified and interviewed through purposive and convenience sampling, using a semistructured guide and a thematic analysis, until theoretical sufficiency was achieved. Results: The following four themes related to podcast listenership were identified: (1) participants thought that TRT increased efficiency, allowing them to multitask, predominantly using mobile listening platforms; (2) participants listened to the podcast for both education and entertainment, or “edutainment”; (3) participants thought that the podcast helped them keep up to date with medical literature; and (4) participants considered TRT to have an indirect effect on learning and clinical practice by increasing overall knowledge. Conclusions: Our results highlight how a medical podcast, designed for continuing professional development, is often used informally to promote learning. These findings enhance our understanding of how and why listeners engage with a medical podcast, which may be used to inform the development and evaluation of other podcasts.


  • Open Access

    Understanding the Use and Perceived Impact of a Medical Podcast: Qualitative Study (Preprint)

    by Sarah L Malecki, Kieran L Quinn, Nathan Zilbert, Fahad Razak, Shiphra Ginsburg, Amol A Verma, Lindsay Melvin

    BACKGROUND Although podcasts are increasingly being produced for medical education, their use and perceived impact in informal educational settings are understudied. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to explore how and why physicians and medical learners listen to The Rounds Table (TRT), a medical podcast, as well as to determine the podcast’s perceived impact on learning and practice. METHODS Web-based podcast analytics were used to collect TRT usage statistics. A total of 17 medical TRT listeners were then identified and interviewed through purposive and convenience sampling, using a semistructured guide and a thematic analysis, until theoretical sufficiency was achieved. RESULTS The following four themes related to podcast listenership were identified: (1) participants thought that TRT increased efficiency, allowing them to multitask, predominantly using mobile listening platforms; (2) participants listened to the podcast for both education and entertainment, or “edutainment”; (3) participants thought that the podcast helped them keep up to date with medical literature; and (4) participants considered TRT to have an indirect effect on learning and clinical practice by increasing overall knowledge. CONCLUSIONS Our results highlight how a medical podcast, designed for continuing professional development, is often used informally to promote learning. These findings enhance our understanding of how and why listeners engage with a medical podcast, which may be used to inform the development and evaluation of other podcasts.

  • Resident and attending perceptions of direct observation in internal medicine: a qualitative study

    by Stephen Gauthier, Lindsay Melvin, Maria Mylopoulos, Nadine Abdullah

    Objectives: Direct observation is the foundation of assessment and learning in competency‐based medical education ( CBME ). Despite its importance, there is significant uncertainty about how to effectively implement frequent and high‐quality direct observation. This is particularly true in specialties where observation of non‐procedural skills is highly valued and presents unique challenges. It is therefore important to understand perceptions of direct observation to ensure successful acceptance and implementation. In this study, we explored perceptions of direct observation in internal medicine. Methods: We interviewed internal medicine attending physicians ( n = 9) and residents ( n = 8) at the University of Toronto, purposively sampled for diversity. Using a constructivist grounded theory approach, constant comparative analysis was performed to develop a framework to understand perceptions of direct observation on the clinical teaching units. Results: Participants articulated a narrow perception of what constitutes direct observation, in contrast to their own descriptions of skills that were observed. This resulted in the perception that certain valuable skills that participants felt were routinely observed were nonetheless not ‘directly observable’, such as clinical reasoning, observed through case presentations and patient care discussions. Differentiating direct observation from informal observation led to overestimation of the time and resource requirements needed to enhance direct observation, which contributed to scepticism and lack of engagement related to CBME implementation. Conclusions: In an internal medicine training programme, perceptions of what constitutes direct observation can lead to under‐recognition and hinder acceptance in workplace‐based assessment and learning. Our results suggest a reframing of ‘direct observation’ for residents and attending physicians, by explicitly identifying desired skills in non‐procedurally‐based specialties. These findings may help CBME ‐based training programmes improve the process of direct observation, leading to enhanced assessment and learning.


  • Improving medical students’ written communication skills: design and evaluation of an educational curriculum

    by L Melvin, K Connolly, L Pitre, K L Dore, P Wasi

    Background and objectives Written and verbal communication skills are important skills for all physicians. While verbal skills are taught and assessed in medical school, medical students report limited instruction in written communication skills. This study examined the impact of a curriculum delivered during a 6-week clinical rotation in Internal Medicine on the objective assessment of medical students’ written communication skills. Methods The curriculum consisted of two educational programmes: a medical student communication tutorial and a resident feedback workshop. The study was conducted from March 2012 to January 2013 at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. The study featured three arms: (1) control, (2) medical student communication tutorial alone and (3) student tutorial and resident feedback workshop. Data were collected on 126 students during 6-week Internal Medicine clerkship rotations. Students’ written consultation notes were collected prior to the educational programmes and at 6 weeks. Blinded faculty assessors used an independently validated Assessment Checklist to evaluate consultation notes. Results Consultation note scores improved from week 1 to week 6 across all study arms. However, the change was statistically significant only in arm 3, featuring both the medical student tutorial and the resident feedback workshop, with mean scores improving from 4.75 (SD=1.496) to 5.56 (SD=0.984) out of 7. The mean difference between week 1 and week 6 was significantly different (0.806, p=0.002, 95% CI 0.306 to 1.058). Conclusions The combination of a resident feedback workshop with medical student written communication tutorial improves objective evaluations of consultation note scores over student tutorial alone.


  • What Makes a Great Resident Teacher? A Multicenter Survey of Medical Students Attending an Internal Medicine Conference

    by Lindsay Melvin, Zain Kassam, Andrew Burke, Parveen Wasi, John Neary

    Background: Residents have a critical role in the education of medical students and have a unique teaching relationship because of their close proximity in professional development and opportunities for direct supervision. Although there is emerging literature on ways to prepare residents to be effective teachers, there is a paucity of data on what medical students believe are the attributes of successful resident teachers. Objective: We sought to define the qualities and teaching techniques that learners interested in internal medicine value in resident teachers. Methods: We created and administered a resident-as-teacher traits survey to senior medical students from 6 medical schools attending a resident-facilitated clinical conference at McMaster University. The survey collected data on student preferences of techniques employed by resident teachers and qualities of a successful resident teacher. Results: Of 90 student participants, 80 (89%) responded. Respondents found the use of clinical examples (78%, 62 of 80) and repetition of core concepts (71%, 58 of 80) highly useful. In contrast, most respondents did not perceive giving feedback to residents, or receiving feedback from residents, was useful to their learning. With respect to resident qualities, respondents felt that a strong knowledge base (80%, 64 of 80) and tailoring teaching to the learner's level (83%, 66 of 80) was highly important. In contrast, high expectations on the part of resident supervisors were not valued. Conclusions: This multicenter survey provides insight into the perceptions of medical students interested in internal medicine on the techniques and qualities that characterize successful resident teachers. The findings may be useful in the future development of resident-as-teacher curricula.