Anne Njoroge
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Anne Njoroge has a total of 54 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- George Owiso
International Training and Education Center for Health University of Washington Seattle, WA United States
6 shared publications - Nancy Puttkammer
Department of Global Health, Schools of Public Health and Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, USA
6 shared publications - Penina Onyango
County Department of Health Siaya County Siaya Kenya
6 shared publications - Peter MacGarr Rabinowitz
Department of Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences, University of Washington
6 shared publications - Rachel Wittenauer
Comparative Health Outcomes, Policy, and Economics (CHOICE) Institute, School of Pharmacy, University of Washington, USA
6 shared publications - Samantha B. Dolan
Department of Global Health University of Washington Seattle, WA United States
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 11 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Antimicrobial Resistance & Infection Control
- Vol. 14 (1) , 1-8
Implementing a surveillance and prevention program for post-caesarean surgical site infections in Kenya
Surgical Site Infection (SSI) surveillance efforts in sub-Saharan Africa have largely been documented in research settings. Such programs need to be institutionalized within routine healthcare settings for sustainability. We evaluate the feasibility of setting up an SSI surveillance and prevention program within public settings in Kenya. Facility infection prevention and control (IPC) committees were established, trained, and resourced on SSI surveillance and prevention in two large hospitals in Kenya. A surgical checklist and monitoring form assessing surgical care bundle implementation and wound status before discharge was included in the medical charts of women who had cesarean section (CS) deliveries. Post-discharge wound assessment interviews were targeted for completion 14–30 days after surgery. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and chi-square tests (χ2) for differences. The program enrolled 1,039 women undergoing CS. Only 65% (675/1039) were reached for any post-discharge wound assessment, with 28% (186/675) reached within the targeted 30 days. Of these, 7% (12/186) had an SSI. Six of these women (6/37 = 16%) were identified within 14 days post-operatively while the remaining six (6/149 = 4%) were identified 15–30 days post-operatively. Surgical care bundle implementation differed by site, with pre-operative antibiotic use at 100% in Thika vs. 66% in Kitale, with variation in the antibiotics used. Blood glucose monitoring at 23 vs. 32% respectively. Hair removal was low overall at 2%. While setting up an SSI surveillance and prevention program is feasible, efforts and resources targeting post-discharge follow-up and case finding should be prioritized. National guidelines standardizing surgical antibiotic prophylaxis are needed as part of antimicrobial stewardship programs.
- 11 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Antimicrobial Resistance & Infection Control
- Vol. 14 (1) , 1-8
Open AccessImplementing a surveillance and prevention program for post-caesarean surgical site infections in Kenya
Surgical Site Infection (SSI) surveillance efforts in sub-Saharan Africa have largely been documented in research settings. Such programs need to be institutionalized within routine healthcare settings for sustainability. We evaluate the feasibility of setting up an SSI surveillance and prevention program within public settings in Kenya. Facility infection prevention and control (IPC) committees were established, trained, and resourced on SSI surveillance and prevention in two large hospitals in Kenya. A surgical checklist and monitoring form assessing surgical care bundle implementation and wound status before discharge was included in the medical charts of women who had cesarean section (CS) deliveries. Post-discharge wound assessment interviews were targeted for completion 14–30 days after surgery. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and chi-square tests (χ2) for differences. The program enrolled 1,039 women undergoing CS. Only 65% (675/1039) were reached for any post-discharge wound assessment, with 28% (186/675) reached within the targeted 30 days. Of these, 7% (12/186) had an SSI. Six of these women (6/37 = 16%) were identified within 14 days post-operatively while the remaining six (6/149 = 4%) were identified 15–30 days post-operatively. Surgical care bundle implementation differed by site, with pre-operative antibiotic use at 100% in Thika vs. 66% in Kitale, with variation in the antibiotics used. Blood glucose monitoring at 23 vs. 32% respectively. Hair removal was low overall at 2%. While setting up an SSI surveillance and prevention program is feasible, efforts and resources targeting post-discharge follow-up and case finding should be prioritized. National guidelines standardizing surgical antibiotic prophylaxis are needed as part of antimicrobial stewardship programs.
- Open Access
- 22 February 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sage Open Pediatrics
- Vol. 12
Viral Load Monitoring Practices and Correlates of Viral Non-suppression Among Children and Young Adolescents Living With HIV in Kiambu County, Kenya
Introduction. Viral suppression rates among children and young adolescents living with HIV (CYALHIV) has been reported to be lower compared to adults. Follow up through viral load monitoring may influence their health outcomes. Objective. In this cross-sectional study we determined viral load monitoring practices and correlates of viral non-suppression of all CYALHIV in the main public hospitals in Kiambu County, Kenya. Data was abstracted from electronic medical records. Methods. Multivariable log binomial regression was used to estimate prevalence ratios (PR) and assess correlates of viral non-suppression. Adherence to viral load testing guidelines was also assessed. Viral non-suppression was defined as a viral load (VL) >1000c/ml. Results. Of the 252 CYALHIV, the median age was 11 (IQR: 7-13) years. At the most current VL, 14% were non-suppressed. Correlates of non-suppression included a history of Tuberculosis, [aPR = 4.25; 95% CI = 1.41-12.8; p = .01], antiretroviral drug side effects [aPR = 3.01; 95% CI = 1.37-6.62; p = 0.006] and having received enhanced adherence counselling (EAC) [aPR = 5.32; 95% CI = 2.00-14.15; p = .001]. Although the timing of baseline VL tests improved over the years, routine VL monitoring as per the guidelines remained suboptimal. Conclusions. There is need for adherence to VL monitoring guidelines for prompt action among non-suppressed children.
- 22 February 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sage Open Pediatrics
- Vol. 12
Open AccessViral Load Monitoring Practices and Correlates of Viral Non-suppression Among Children and Young Adolescents Living With HIV in Kiambu County, Kenya
Introduction. Viral suppression rates among children and young adolescents living with HIV (CYALHIV) has been reported to be lower compared to adults. Follow up through viral load monitoring may influence their health outcomes. Objective. In this cross-sectional study we determined viral load monitoring practices and correlates of viral non-suppression of all CYALHIV in the main public hospitals in Kiambu County, Kenya. Data was abstracted from electronic medical records. Methods. Multivariable log binomial regression was used to estimate prevalence ratios (PR) and assess correlates of viral non-suppression. Adherence to viral load testing guidelines was also assessed. Viral non-suppression was defined as a viral load (VL) >1000c/ml. Results. Of the 252 CYALHIV, the median age was 11 (IQR: 7-13) years. At the most current VL, 14% were non-suppressed. Correlates of non-suppression included a history of Tuberculosis, [aPR = 4.25; 95% CI = 1.41-12.8; p = .01], antiretroviral drug side effects [aPR = 3.01; 95% CI = 1.37-6.62; p = 0.006] and having received enhanced adherence counselling (EAC) [aPR = 5.32; 95% CI = 2.00-14.15; p = .001]. Although the timing of baseline VL tests improved over the years, routine VL monitoring as per the guidelines remained suboptimal. Conclusions. There is need for adherence to VL monitoring guidelines for prompt action among non-suppressed children.
- Open Access
- 6 January 2025
- Published by AOSIS in Journal of Public Health in Africa
- Vol. 16 (1)
Hypoxia predicts COVID-19 mortality: Evidence to inform low-resource care
Background: Hypoxia is a critical yet under-recognised driver of poor outcomes in coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). Early detection with cheap pulse oximetry is feasible in resource-limited settings. Aim: This study estimated the prevalence of hypoxia at admission and its role in predicting mortality in three facilities in diverse resource settings in Kenya. Setting: The study was conducted in three Kenyan hospitals. Methods: We retrospectively analysed 1124 COVID-19 patient hospitalisation records (October 2020 – December 2021). Hypoxia was defined as the saturation of peripheral oxygen (SpO2) ≤ 94% at admission. Differences in categorical variables were assessed using the χ2 test. We used a multivariable Cox proportional hazards model to identify mortality predictors and Kaplan–Meier methods to estimate survival probabilities, with or without oxygen supplementation. Results: Hypoxia was present in 81.4% of patients; 39.9% had no dyspnoea. Hypoxic patients compared to non-hypoxic patients were older (≥ 60 years: 44.6% vs. 24.4%) and had higher rates of dyspnoea (60.1% vs. 36.9%), hypertension (40.4% vs. 25.8%), and tachycardia (38.2% vs. 24.6%) (all p < 0.001). Only 68.6% of hypoxic patients received oxygen. Mortality was higher among hypoxic (38.0%) vs. non-hypoxic patients (13.6%, p < 0.001). Hypoxia independently predicted mortality (adjusted hazard ratio [aHR]: 1.9; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.2–2.8), particularly in older adults (aHR: 1.8) and those with dyspnoea (aHR: 1.5). Survival probabilities were worse for hypoxic patients regardless of dyspnoea or oxygen supplementation (p < 0.001). Conclusion: Hypoxia was prevalent and significantly increased the mortality risk among hospitalised COVID-19 patients. Contribution: Routine SpO2 monitoring and targeted hypoxia management are critical in low-resource settings, particularly for vulnerable patients.
- 6 January 2025
- Published by AOSIS in Journal of Public Health in Africa
- Vol. 16 (1)
Open AccessHypoxia predicts COVID-19 mortality: Evidence to inform low-resource care
Background: Hypoxia is a critical yet under-recognised driver of poor outcomes in coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). Early detection with cheap pulse oximetry is feasible in resource-limited settings. Aim: This study estimated the prevalence of hypoxia at admission and its role in predicting mortality in three facilities in diverse resource settings in Kenya. Setting: The study was conducted in three Kenyan hospitals. Methods: We retrospectively analysed 1124 COVID-19 patient hospitalisation records (October 2020 – December 2021). Hypoxia was defined as the saturation of peripheral oxygen (SpO2) ≤ 94% at admission. Differences in categorical variables were assessed using the χ2 test. We used a multivariable Cox proportional hazards model to identify mortality predictors and Kaplan–Meier methods to estimate survival probabilities, with or without oxygen supplementation. Results: Hypoxia was present in 81.4% of patients; 39.9% had no dyspnoea. Hypoxic patients compared to non-hypoxic patients were older (≥ 60 years: 44.6% vs. 24.4%) and had higher rates of dyspnoea (60.1% vs. 36.9%), hypertension (40.4% vs. 25.8%), and tachycardia (38.2% vs. 24.6%) (all p < 0.001). Only 68.6% of hypoxic patients received oxygen. Mortality was higher among hypoxic (38.0%) vs. non-hypoxic patients (13.6%, p < 0.001). Hypoxia independently predicted mortality (adjusted hazard ratio [aHR]: 1.9; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.2–2.8), particularly in older adults (aHR: 1.8) and those with dyspnoea (aHR: 1.5). Survival probabilities were worse for hypoxic patients regardless of dyspnoea or oxygen supplementation (p < 0.001). Conclusion: Hypoxia was prevalent and significantly increased the mortality risk among hospitalised COVID-19 patients. Contribution: Routine SpO2 monitoring and targeted hypoxia management are critical in low-resource settings, particularly for vulnerable patients.
- Open Access
- 30 March 2023
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , e39383
Usability and Acceptability of Electronic Immunization Registry Data Entry Workflows From the Health Care Worker Perspective in Siaya, Kenya (Part 3): Pre-Post Study
Background: Digital health tools such as electronic immunization registries (EIRs) have the potential to improve patient care and alleviate the challenges that arise from the use of paper-based clinic records for reporting. To address some of these challenges, the Kenya Ministry of Health and the International Training and Education Center for Health Kenya implemented an EIR system in 161 immunizing clinics in Siaya County between 2018 and 2019. The successful implementation of digital health tools depends on many factors, one of which is alignment between the technology and the context in which it is used. One important aspect of that implementation context is the perceptions of the health care workers (HCWs) using the EIR. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate HCWs’ perceptions of the usability and acceptability of multiple clinic workflows using the new EIR. Methods: We performed a mixed methods pre-post study using semistructured interviews with HCWs at 6 facilities in Siaya County, Kenya. We interviewed HCWs at each facility 4 times: at baseline and once after the implementation of 3 different workflow modifications (n=24 interviews). The baseline state was dual data entry with paper records and the EIR. We then implemented 3 workflow modifications for 1 full day each: fully paperless data entry, preparation of an appointment diary before patient visits for the day, and a combination of the 2 workflows. We compared ratings and themes across interviews after each of the 4 workflows to understand the changes in the usability and acceptability of the EIR. Results: HCWs considered the EIR clinic workflows to be usable and acceptable. Of the modified workflows, HCWs perceived the fully paperless workflow most favorably. In all workflows, HCWs’ perceived benefits included ease of clinical decision-making using the EIR, reduced mental burden of data entry when using the EIR, and ease of identification of errors. Perceived barriers to the workflow included contextual challenges such as staffing shortages and lack of network connectivity, EIR platform challenges such as errors in saving records and missing fields, and workflow challenges such as the dual data entry burden of using paper and digital tools simultaneously. Conclusions: Fully paperless EIR implementation shows great promise from a workflow acceptability standpoint, contingent upon the presence of supporting contextual clinic factors and the resolution of system performance and design challenges. Rather than trying to identify a singular best workflow, future efforts should provide adequate flexibility for HCWs to implement the new system in their unique clinic context. Future EIR implementation stands to benefit from continued monitoring of EIR adoption acceptability during implementation, both for Siaya’s program and for other efforts around the globe, as digital health interventions become more widely used.
- 30 March 2023
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , e39383
Open AccessUsability and Acceptability of Electronic Immunization Registry Data Entry Workflows From the Health Care Worker Perspective in Siaya, Kenya (Part 3): Pre-Post Study
Background: Digital health tools such as electronic immunization registries (EIRs) have the potential to improve patient care and alleviate the challenges that arise from the use of paper-based clinic records for reporting. To address some of these challenges, the Kenya Ministry of Health and the International Training and Education Center for Health Kenya implemented an EIR system in 161 immunizing clinics in Siaya County between 2018 and 2019. The successful implementation of digital health tools depends on many factors, one of which is alignment between the technology and the context in which it is used. One important aspect of that implementation context is the perceptions of the health care workers (HCWs) using the EIR. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate HCWs’ perceptions of the usability and acceptability of multiple clinic workflows using the new EIR. Methods: We performed a mixed methods pre-post study using semistructured interviews with HCWs at 6 facilities in Siaya County, Kenya. We interviewed HCWs at each facility 4 times: at baseline and once after the implementation of 3 different workflow modifications (n=24 interviews). The baseline state was dual data entry with paper records and the EIR. We then implemented 3 workflow modifications for 1 full day each: fully paperless data entry, preparation of an appointment diary before patient visits for the day, and a combination of the 2 workflows. We compared ratings and themes across interviews after each of the 4 workflows to understand the changes in the usability and acceptability of the EIR. Results: HCWs considered the EIR clinic workflows to be usable and acceptable. Of the modified workflows, HCWs perceived the fully paperless workflow most favorably. In all workflows, HCWs’ perceived benefits included ease of clinical decision-making using the EIR, reduced mental burden of data entry when using the EIR, and ease of identification of errors. Perceived barriers to the workflow included contextual challenges such as staffing shortages and lack of network connectivity, EIR platform challenges such as errors in saving records and missing fields, and workflow challenges such as the dual data entry burden of using paper and digital tools simultaneously. Conclusions: Fully paperless EIR implementation shows great promise from a workflow acceptability standpoint, contingent upon the presence of supporting contextual clinic factors and the resolution of system performance and design challenges. Rather than trying to identify a singular best workflow, future efforts should provide adequate flexibility for HCWs to implement the new system in their unique clinic context. Future EIR implementation stands to benefit from continued monitoring of EIR adoption acceptability during implementation, both for Siaya’s program and for other efforts around the globe, as digital health interventions become more widely used.
- Open Access
- 16 March 2023
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 7, e39777
Time Utilization Among Immunization Clinics Using an Electronic Immunization Registry (Part 2): Time and Motion Study of Modified User Workflows
Background: Digital health interventions have the potential to improve the provision of health care services through digitized data collection and management. Low- and middle-income countries are beginning to introduce electronic immunization registries (EIRs) into their routine immunization services to better capture and store childhood vaccination information. Especially in Africa, where 25% of children remain unimmunized or underimmunized, technologies that can help identify children due for a vaccination are particularly important for improving vaccination coverage. However, an improved understanding of the effectiveness of these systems is needed to develop and deploy sustainable EIRs in low- and middle-income countries. Objective: We conducted an interventional pretest-posttest design study that sought to improve time efficiency through workflow modifications in Kenyan immunization clinics. Our aim was to describe how activity times differed after introducing workflow modifications that could potentially reduce the time needed to perform routine data entry activities. Our intent was to demonstrate changes in efficiency when moving from the existing dual–data entry workflow to a future paperless workflow by health facility size and experience length of health care workers (HCWs). Methods: We tested how 3 workflow modifications would affect time utilization among HCWs using the EIR at the point of care compared with baseline immunization clinic workflows. Our outcome of interest was the time taken to complete individual activities and a patient’s total time in the clinic where we compared the time spent during the baseline workflow with that during the modified workflow. We used a standardized tool to observe and document the immunization clinic workflow. To estimate differences in time utilization, we used bivariate analyses and fit multivariate linear mixed-effects models. Results: Our study found that for HCWs using an EIR, the introduction of modified workflows decreased the amount of time needed to provide services to children seen in the immunization clinic. With a baseline mean time of 10 minutes spent per child, this decreased by about 3 minutes when the preparation modification was introduced and almost 5 minutes for the paperless and combined modifications. Results pertaining to the EIR’s performance and ability to connect to the internet were particularly insightful about potential causes of delays. Conclusions: We were able to conduct a concise clinical simulation exercise by introducing modified workflows and estimating their impact on time utilization in immunization clinics using an EIR. We found that the paperless workflow provided the largest time savings when delivering services, although this was threatened by poor EIR performance and internet connectivity. This study demonstrated that not only should digital health interventions be built and adapted for particular use cases but existing user workflows also need to adapt to new technology.
- 16 March 2023
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 7, e39777
Open AccessTime Utilization Among Immunization Clinics Using an Electronic Immunization Registry (Part 2): Time and Motion Study of Modified User Workflows
Background: Digital health interventions have the potential to improve the provision of health care services through digitized data collection and management. Low- and middle-income countries are beginning to introduce electronic immunization registries (EIRs) into their routine immunization services to better capture and store childhood vaccination information. Especially in Africa, where 25% of children remain unimmunized or underimmunized, technologies that can help identify children due for a vaccination are particularly important for improving vaccination coverage. However, an improved understanding of the effectiveness of these systems is needed to develop and deploy sustainable EIRs in low- and middle-income countries. Objective: We conducted an interventional pretest-posttest design study that sought to improve time efficiency through workflow modifications in Kenyan immunization clinics. Our aim was to describe how activity times differed after introducing workflow modifications that could potentially reduce the time needed to perform routine data entry activities. Our intent was to demonstrate changes in efficiency when moving from the existing dual–data entry workflow to a future paperless workflow by health facility size and experience length of health care workers (HCWs). Methods: We tested how 3 workflow modifications would affect time utilization among HCWs using the EIR at the point of care compared with baseline immunization clinic workflows. Our outcome of interest was the time taken to complete individual activities and a patient’s total time in the clinic where we compared the time spent during the baseline workflow with that during the modified workflow. We used a standardized tool to observe and document the immunization clinic workflow. To estimate differences in time utilization, we used bivariate analyses and fit multivariate linear mixed-effects models. Results: Our study found that for HCWs using an EIR, the introduction of modified workflows decreased the amount of time needed to provide services to children seen in the immunization clinic. With a baseline mean time of 10 minutes spent per child, this decreased by about 3 minutes when the preparation modification was introduced and almost 5 minutes for the paperless and combined modifications. Results pertaining to the EIR’s performance and ability to connect to the internet were particularly insightful about potential causes of delays. Conclusions: We were able to conduct a concise clinical simulation exercise by introducing modified workflows and estimating their impact on time utilization in immunization clinics using an EIR. We found that the paperless workflow provided the largest time savings when delivering services, although this was threatened by poor EIR performance and internet connectivity. This study demonstrated that not only should digital health interventions be built and adapted for particular use cases but existing user workflows also need to adapt to new technology.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2023
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , e39775
Integration of a Digital Health Intervention Into Immunization Clinic Workflows in Kenya: Qualitative, Realist Evaluation of Technology Usability
Background: In an effort to increase vaccination coverage in low-resource settings, digital tools have been introduced to better track immunization records, improve data management practices, and provide improved access to vaccination coverage data for decision-making. Despite the potential of these electronic systems to improve the provision of health services, few digital health interventions have been institutionalized at scale in low- and middle-income countries. Objective: In this paper, we aimed to describe how health care workers in Kenya had integrated an electronic immunization registry into their immunization clinic workflows and to use these findings to inform the development of a refined program theory on the registry’s usability. Methods: Informed by realist methodology, we developed a program theory to explain usability of the electronic immunization registry. We designed a qualitative study based on our theory to describe the barriers and facilitators influencing data entry and use. Qualitative data were collected through semistructured interviews with users and workflow observations of immunization clinic sessions. Our findings were summarized by context-mechanism-outcome relationships formed after analyzing our key themes across interviews and workflow observations. Using these relationships, we were able to identify common rules for future implementers. Results: Across the 12 facilities included in our study, 19 health care workers were interviewed, and 58 workflow sessions were observed. The common rules developed from our qualitative findings are as follows: rule 1—ensure that the users complete training to build familiarity with the system, understand the value of the system and data, and know where to find support; rule 2—confirm that the system captures all data needed for users to provide routine health care services and is easy to navigate; rule 3—identify work-arounds for poor network, system performance, and too few staff or resources; and rule 4—make users aware of expected changes to their workflow, and how these changes might differ over time and by facility size or number of patients. Upon study completion, we revised the program theory to reflect the importance of the goals and workflows of electronic immunization registries aligning with reality. Conclusions: We created a deeper understanding of the underlying mechanisms for usability of the registry. We found that the electronic immunization registry had high acceptability among users; however, there were numerous barriers to using the system, even under ideal conditions, causing a misalignment between the system and the reality of the users’ workflows and their environment. Human-centered design and human-factors methods can assist during pilot stages to better align systems with users’ needs and again after scale-up to ensure that interventions are suitable for all user settings.
- 14 March 2023
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , e39775
Open AccessIntegration of a Digital Health Intervention Into Immunization Clinic Workflows in Kenya: Qualitative, Realist Evaluation of Technology Usability
Background: In an effort to increase vaccination coverage in low-resource settings, digital tools have been introduced to better track immunization records, improve data management practices, and provide improved access to vaccination coverage data for decision-making. Despite the potential of these electronic systems to improve the provision of health services, few digital health interventions have been institutionalized at scale in low- and middle-income countries. Objective: In this paper, we aimed to describe how health care workers in Kenya had integrated an electronic immunization registry into their immunization clinic workflows and to use these findings to inform the development of a refined program theory on the registry’s usability. Methods: Informed by realist methodology, we developed a program theory to explain usability of the electronic immunization registry. We designed a qualitative study based on our theory to describe the barriers and facilitators influencing data entry and use. Qualitative data were collected through semistructured interviews with users and workflow observations of immunization clinic sessions. Our findings were summarized by context-mechanism-outcome relationships formed after analyzing our key themes across interviews and workflow observations. Using these relationships, we were able to identify common rules for future implementers. Results: Across the 12 facilities included in our study, 19 health care workers were interviewed, and 58 workflow sessions were observed. The common rules developed from our qualitative findings are as follows: rule 1—ensure that the users complete training to build familiarity with the system, understand the value of the system and data, and know where to find support; rule 2—confirm that the system captures all data needed for users to provide routine health care services and is easy to navigate; rule 3—identify work-arounds for poor network, system performance, and too few staff or resources; and rule 4—make users aware of expected changes to their workflow, and how these changes might differ over time and by facility size or number of patients. Upon study completion, we revised the program theory to reflect the importance of the goals and workflows of electronic immunization registries aligning with reality. Conclusions: We created a deeper understanding of the underlying mechanisms for usability of the registry. We found that the electronic immunization registry had high acceptability among users; however, there were numerous barriers to using the system, even under ideal conditions, causing a misalignment between the system and the reality of the users’ workflows and their environment. Human-centered design and human-factors methods can assist during pilot stages to better align systems with users’ needs and again after scale-up to ensure that interventions are suitable for all user settings.
- Open Access
- 23 May 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Usability and Acceptability of Electronic Immunization Registry Data Entry Workflows From the Health Care Worker Perspective in Siaya, Kenya (Part 3): Pre-Post Study (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Digital health tools such as electronic immunization registries (EIRs) have the potential to improve patient care and alleviate the challenges that arise from the use of paper-based clinic records for reporting. To address some of these challenges, the Kenya Ministry of Health and the International Training and Education Center for Health Kenya implemented an EIR system in 161 immunizing clinics in Siaya County between 2018 and 2019. The successful implementation of digital health tools depends on many factors, one of which is alignment between the technology and the context in which it is used. One important aspect of that implementation context is the perceptions of the health care workers (HCWs) using the EIR. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to evaluate HCWs’ perceptions of the usability and acceptability of multiple clinic workflows using the new EIR. METHODS We performed a mixed methods pre-post study using semistructured interviews with HCWs at 6 facilities in Siaya County, Kenya. We interviewed HCWs at each facility 4 times: at baseline and once after the implementation of 3 different workflow modifications (n=24 interviews). The baseline state was dual data entry with paper records and the EIR. We then implemented 3 workflow modifications for 1 full day each: fully paperless data entry, preparation of an appointment diary before patient visits for the day, and a combination of the 2 workflows. We compared ratings and themes across interviews after each of the 4 workflows to understand the changes in the usability and acceptability of the EIR. RESULTS HCWs considered the EIR clinic workflows to be usable and acceptable. Of the modified workflows, HCWs perceived the fully paperless workflow most favorably. In all workflows, HCWs’ perceived benefits included ease of clinical decision-making using the EIR, reduced mental burden of data entry when using the EIR, and ease of identification of errors. Perceived barriers to the workflow included contextual challenges such as staffing shortages and lack of network connectivity, EIR platform challenges such as errors in saving records and missing fields, and workflow challenges such as the dual data entry burden of using paper and digital tools simultaneously. CONCLUSIONS Fully paperless EIR implementation shows great promise from a workflow acceptability standpoint, contingent upon the presence of supporting contextual clinic factors and the resolution of system performance and design challenges. Rather than trying to identify a singular best workflow, future efforts should provide adequate flexibility for HCWs to implement the new system in their unique clinic context. Future EIR implementation stands to benefit from continued monitoring of EIR adoption acceptability during implementation, both for Siaya’s program and for other efforts around the globe, as digital health interventions become more widely used. CLINICALTRIAL
- 23 May 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessUsability and Acceptability of Electronic Immunization Registry Data Entry Workflows From the Health Care Worker Perspective in Siaya, Kenya (Part 3): Pre-Post Study (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Digital health tools such as electronic immunization registries (EIRs) have the potential to improve patient care and alleviate the challenges that arise from the use of paper-based clinic records for reporting. To address some of these challenges, the Kenya Ministry of Health and the International Training and Education Center for Health Kenya implemented an EIR system in 161 immunizing clinics in Siaya County between 2018 and 2019. The successful implementation of digital health tools depends on many factors, one of which is alignment between the technology and the context in which it is used. One important aspect of that implementation context is the perceptions of the health care workers (HCWs) using the EIR. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to evaluate HCWs’ perceptions of the usability and acceptability of multiple clinic workflows using the new EIR. METHODS We performed a mixed methods pre-post study using semistructured interviews with HCWs at 6 facilities in Siaya County, Kenya. We interviewed HCWs at each facility 4 times: at baseline and once after the implementation of 3 different workflow modifications (n=24 interviews). The baseline state was dual data entry with paper records and the EIR. We then implemented 3 workflow modifications for 1 full day each: fully paperless data entry, preparation of an appointment diary before patient visits for the day, and a combination of the 2 workflows. We compared ratings and themes across interviews after each of the 4 workflows to understand the changes in the usability and acceptability of the EIR. RESULTS HCWs considered the EIR clinic workflows to be usable and acceptable. Of the modified workflows, HCWs perceived the fully paperless workflow most favorably. In all workflows, HCWs’ perceived benefits included ease of clinical decision-making using the EIR, reduced mental burden of data entry when using the EIR, and ease of identification of errors. Perceived barriers to the workflow included contextual challenges such as staffing shortages and lack of network connectivity, EIR platform challenges such as errors in saving records and missing fields, and workflow challenges such as the dual data entry burden of using paper and digital tools simultaneously. CONCLUSIONS Fully paperless EIR implementation shows great promise from a workflow acceptability standpoint, contingent upon the presence of supporting contextual clinic factors and the resolution of system performance and design challenges. Rather than trying to identify a singular best workflow, future efforts should provide adequate flexibility for HCWs to implement the new system in their unique clinic context. Future EIR implementation stands to benefit from continued monitoring of EIR adoption acceptability during implementation, both for Siaya’s program and for other efforts around the globe, as digital health interventions become more widely used. CLINICALTRIAL
- Open Access
- 23 May 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Integration of a Digital Health Intervention Into Immunization Clinic Workflows in Kenya: Qualitative, Realist Evaluation of Technology Usability (Preprint)
BACKGROUND In an effort to increase vaccination coverage in low-resource settings, digital tools have been introduced to better track immunization records, improve data management practices, and provide improved access to vaccination coverage data for decision-making. Despite the potential of these electronic systems to improve the provision of health services, few digital health interventions have been institutionalized at scale in low- and middle-income countries. OBJECTIVE In this paper, we aimed to describe how health care workers in Kenya had integrated an electronic immunization registry into their immunization clinic workflows and to use these findings to inform the development of a refined program theory on the registry’s usability. METHODS Informed by realist methodology, we developed a program theory to explain usability of the electronic immunization registry. We designed a qualitative study based on our theory to describe the barriers and facilitators influencing data entry and use. Qualitative data were collected through semistructured interviews with users and workflow observations of immunization clinic sessions. Our findings were summarized by context-mechanism-outcome relationships formed after analyzing our key themes across interviews and workflow observations. Using these relationships, we were able to identify common rules for future implementers. RESULTS Across the 12 facilities included in our study, 19 health care workers were interviewed, and 58 workflow sessions were observed. The common rules developed from our qualitative findings are as follows: rule 1—ensure that the users complete training to build familiarity with the system, understand the value of the system and data, and know where to find support; rule 2—confirm that the system captures all data needed for users to provide routine health care services and is easy to navigate; rule 3—identify work-arounds for poor network, system performance, and too few staff or resources; and rule 4—make users aware of expected changes to their workflow, and how these changes might differ over time and by facility size or number of patients. Upon study completion, we revised the program theory to reflect the importance of the goals and workflows of electronic immunization registries aligning with reality. CONCLUSIONS We created a deeper understanding of the underlying mechanisms for usability of the registry. We found that the electronic immunization registry had high acceptability among users; however, there were numerous barriers to using the system, even under ideal conditions, causing a misalignment between the system and the reality of the users’ workflows and their environment. Human-centered design and human-factors methods can assist during pilot stages to better align systems with users’ needs and again after scale-up to ensure that interventions are suitable for all user settings.
- 23 May 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessIntegration of a Digital Health Intervention Into Immunization Clinic Workflows in Kenya: Qualitative, Realist Evaluation of Technology Usability (Preprint)
BACKGROUND In an effort to increase vaccination coverage in low-resource settings, digital tools have been introduced to better track immunization records, improve data management practices, and provide improved access to vaccination coverage data for decision-making. Despite the potential of these electronic systems to improve the provision of health services, few digital health interventions have been institutionalized at scale in low- and middle-income countries. OBJECTIVE In this paper, we aimed to describe how health care workers in Kenya had integrated an electronic immunization registry into their immunization clinic workflows and to use these findings to inform the development of a refined program theory on the registry’s usability. METHODS Informed by realist methodology, we developed a program theory to explain usability of the electronic immunization registry. We designed a qualitative study based on our theory to describe the barriers and facilitators influencing data entry and use. Qualitative data were collected through semistructured interviews with users and workflow observations of immunization clinic sessions. Our findings were summarized by context-mechanism-outcome relationships formed after analyzing our key themes across interviews and workflow observations. Using these relationships, we were able to identify common rules for future implementers. RESULTS Across the 12 facilities included in our study, 19 health care workers were interviewed, and 58 workflow sessions were observed. The common rules developed from our qualitative findings are as follows: rule 1—ensure that the users complete training to build familiarity with the system, understand the value of the system and data, and know where to find support; rule 2—confirm that the system captures all data needed for users to provide routine health care services and is easy to navigate; rule 3—identify work-arounds for poor network, system performance, and too few staff or resources; and rule 4—make users aware of expected changes to their workflow, and how these changes might differ over time and by facility size or number of patients. Upon study completion, we revised the program theory to reflect the importance of the goals and workflows of electronic immunization registries aligning with reality. CONCLUSIONS We created a deeper understanding of the underlying mechanisms for usability of the registry. We found that the electronic immunization registry had high acceptability among users; however, there were numerous barriers to using the system, even under ideal conditions, causing a misalignment between the system and the reality of the users’ workflows and their environment. Human-centered design and human-factors methods can assist during pilot stages to better align systems with users’ needs and again after scale-up to ensure that interventions are suitable for all user settings.
- Open Access
- 23 May 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Time Utilization Among Immunization Clinics Using an Electronic Immunization Registry (Part 2): Time and Motion Study of Modified User Workflows (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Digital health interventions have the potential to improve the provision of health care services through digitized data collection and management. Low- and middle-income countries are beginning to introduce electronic immunization registries (EIRs) into their routine immunization services to better capture and store childhood vaccination information. Especially in Africa, where 25% of children remain unimmunized or underimmunized, technologies that can help identify children due for a vaccination are particularly important for improving vaccination coverage. However, an improved understanding of the effectiveness of these systems is needed to develop and deploy sustainable EIRs in low- and middle-income countries. OBJECTIVE We conducted an interventional pretest-posttest design study that sought to improve time efficiency through workflow modifications in Kenyan immunization clinics. Our aim was to describe how activity times differed after introducing workflow modifications that could potentially reduce the time needed to perform routine data entry activities. Our intent was to demonstrate changes in efficiency when moving from the existing dual–data entry workflow to a future paperless workflow by health facility size and experience length of health care workers (HCWs). METHODS We tested how 3 workflow modifications would affect time utilization among HCWs using the EIR at the point of care compared with baseline immunization clinic workflows. Our outcome of interest was the time taken to complete individual activities and a patient’s total time in the clinic where we compared the time spent during the baseline workflow with that during the modified workflow. We used a standardized tool to observe and document the immunization clinic workflow. To estimate differences in time utilization, we used bivariate analyses and fit multivariate linear mixed-effects models. RESULTS Our study found that for HCWs using an EIR, the introduction of modified workflows decreased the amount of time needed to provide services to children seen in the immunization clinic. With a baseline mean time of 10 minutes spent per child, this decreased by about 3 minutes when the preparation modification was introduced and almost 5 minutes for the paperless and combined modifications. Results pertaining to the EIR’s performance and ability to connect to the internet were particularly insightful about potential causes of delays. CONCLUSIONS We were able to conduct a concise clinical simulation exercise by introducing modified workflows and estimating their impact on time utilization in immunization clinics using an EIR. We found that the paperless workflow provided the largest time savings when delivering services, although this was threatened by poor EIR performance and internet connectivity. This study demonstrated that not only should digital health interventions be built and adapted for particular use cases but existing user workflows also need to adapt to new technology.
- 23 May 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessTime Utilization Among Immunization Clinics Using an Electronic Immunization Registry (Part 2): Time and Motion Study of Modified User Workflows (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Digital health interventions have the potential to improve the provision of health care services through digitized data collection and management. Low- and middle-income countries are beginning to introduce electronic immunization registries (EIRs) into their routine immunization services to better capture and store childhood vaccination information. Especially in Africa, where 25% of children remain unimmunized or underimmunized, technologies that can help identify children due for a vaccination are particularly important for improving vaccination coverage. However, an improved understanding of the effectiveness of these systems is needed to develop and deploy sustainable EIRs in low- and middle-income countries. OBJECTIVE We conducted an interventional pretest-posttest design study that sought to improve time efficiency through workflow modifications in Kenyan immunization clinics. Our aim was to describe how activity times differed after introducing workflow modifications that could potentially reduce the time needed to perform routine data entry activities. Our intent was to demonstrate changes in efficiency when moving from the existing dual–data entry workflow to a future paperless workflow by health facility size and experience length of health care workers (HCWs). METHODS We tested how 3 workflow modifications would affect time utilization among HCWs using the EIR at the point of care compared with baseline immunization clinic workflows. Our outcome of interest was the time taken to complete individual activities and a patient’s total time in the clinic where we compared the time spent during the baseline workflow with that during the modified workflow. We used a standardized tool to observe and document the immunization clinic workflow. To estimate differences in time utilization, we used bivariate analyses and fit multivariate linear mixed-effects models. RESULTS Our study found that for HCWs using an EIR, the introduction of modified workflows decreased the amount of time needed to provide services to children seen in the immunization clinic. With a baseline mean time of 10 minutes spent per child, this decreased by about 3 minutes when the preparation modification was introduced and almost 5 minutes for the paperless and combined modifications. Results pertaining to the EIR’s performance and ability to connect to the internet were particularly insightful about potential causes of delays. CONCLUSIONS We were able to conduct a concise clinical simulation exercise by introducing modified workflows and estimating their impact on time utilization in immunization clinics using an EIR. We found that the paperless workflow provided the largest time savings when delivering services, although this was threatened by poor EIR performance and internet connectivity. This study demonstrated that not only should digital health interventions be built and adapted for particular use cases but existing user workflows also need to adapt to new technology.
- Open Access
- 4 April 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Antimicrobial Resistance & Infection Control
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-11
Improving hand hygiene practices in two regional hospitals in Kenya using a continuous quality improvement (CQI) approach
Background: Hand hygiene (HH) is central in prevention of health care-associated infections. In low resource settings, models to improve HH compliance are needed. We implemented a continuous quality improvement (CQI) program targeting HH in two hospitals in Kenya. Objective: To determine the impact of the HH CQI program and identify factors associated with HH compliance between 2018 and 2019. Methods: A CQI project targeting the improvement of hand hygiene was implemented, including training and mentorship. Data were collected monthly between April 2018 and December 2019 in Thika and Kitale Hospitals. Healthcare workers trained on Infection Prevention and Control (IPC) observed and recorded HH opportunities and subsequent compliance among staff, including nurses, clinicians, and auxiliary staff, using the World Health Organization’s “My Five Moments for Hand Hygiene” tool. Covariates were explored using mixed-effects logistic regression with random department-level intercepts. Results: Hand hygiene compliance improved from 27% at baseline to 44% after 21 months. Indication/moment for HH was significantly associated with compliance. Adjusting for site, professional category and department, compliance was higher after a moment of body fluid exposure (aOR 1.43, 95% CI 1.17–1.74, p value < 0.001) and lower before an aseptic procedure (aOR 0.12, 95% CI 0.08–0.17, p value < 0.001) compared to after patient contact. Wearing of gloves often replaced proper HH in surgical departments, which although not significant, had lower compliance compared to departments for internal medicine (aOR 0.93, 95% CI 0.85–1.02). Adjusted HH compliance from all quarters improved from baseline, but comparing each quarter to the previous quarter, the improvement fluctuated over time. Conclusion: Training and mentorship on the importance of HH for all moments is needed to improve overall HH compliance. CQI with regular monitoring and feedback of HH performance can be an effective approach in improving HH compliance in public hospitals in Kenya.
- 4 April 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Antimicrobial Resistance & Infection Control
- Vol. 11 (1) , 1-11
Open AccessImproving hand hygiene practices in two regional hospitals in Kenya using a continuous quality improvement (CQI) approach
Background: Hand hygiene (HH) is central in prevention of health care-associated infections. In low resource settings, models to improve HH compliance are needed. We implemented a continuous quality improvement (CQI) program targeting HH in two hospitals in Kenya. Objective: To determine the impact of the HH CQI program and identify factors associated with HH compliance between 2018 and 2019. Methods: A CQI project targeting the improvement of hand hygiene was implemented, including training and mentorship. Data were collected monthly between April 2018 and December 2019 in Thika and Kitale Hospitals. Healthcare workers trained on Infection Prevention and Control (IPC) observed and recorded HH opportunities and subsequent compliance among staff, including nurses, clinicians, and auxiliary staff, using the World Health Organization’s “My Five Moments for Hand Hygiene” tool. Covariates were explored using mixed-effects logistic regression with random department-level intercepts. Results: Hand hygiene compliance improved from 27% at baseline to 44% after 21 months. Indication/moment for HH was significantly associated with compliance. Adjusting for site, professional category and department, compliance was higher after a moment of body fluid exposure (aOR 1.43, 95% CI 1.17–1.74, p value < 0.001) and lower before an aseptic procedure (aOR 0.12, 95% CI 0.08–0.17, p value < 0.001) compared to after patient contact. Wearing of gloves often replaced proper HH in surgical departments, which although not significant, had lower compliance compared to departments for internal medicine (aOR 0.93, 95% CI 0.85–1.02). Adjusted HH compliance from all quarters improved from baseline, but comparing each quarter to the previous quarter, the improvement fluctuated over time. Conclusion: Training and mentorship on the importance of HH for all moments is needed to improve overall HH compliance. CQI with regular monitoring and feedback of HH performance can be an effective approach in improving HH compliance in public hospitals in Kenya.