Peter L. Nuthall
Research Subjects
Peter L. Nuthall has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Bruce Greig
Lincoln University, Lincoln, New Zealand
4 shared publicationsKevin Old
Lincoln University, Lincoln, New Zealand
4 shared publicationsK. M. Old
Department of Land Management and Systems, Lincoln University, Canterbury, New Zealand
1 shared publication- Sambodo
The National Development Planning Agency , Jakarta, Indonesia
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 24 October 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 12 (11) , 409
Assessing the Core Variables of Business Managers’ Intuitive Decision Ability: A Review and Analysis
Business decisions are frequently based on informed intuition in contrast to a formal analysis. Early man used simple intuition, but through time knowledge increases allowed decision makers (DMs) to move to ‘objectively informed intuition’ (OII). This uses inherent and learnt cognition at both unconscious and conscious levels. A model of business OII is proposed and evaluated using as variables the managers’ personal characteristics and their unique set of objectives. The resultant equation allows assessing decision quality and provides a framework for DMs to work on improvements relative to their objectives. The literature suggests OII stems from a DM’s makeup (business related phenotype), training and experience in a dynamic trio leading to the defining equation. Analyses show business related phenotype is the most important determinant as well as confirming the proposed theory on the determinants of OII success. Practical methods of improving OII are reviewed, and issues worth further investigation outlined. This research is the first encompassing quantitative relationships explaining business OII quality thus enabling improving OII. Suggested further research may refine the equation and expand its core base. This work involves a range of disciplines as different aspects of human characteristics impact on how decisions are made.
- 24 October 2022
- Published by MDPI AG in Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 12 (11) , 409
Open AccessAssessing the Core Variables of Business Managers’ Intuitive Decision Ability: A Review and Analysis
Business decisions are frequently based on informed intuition in contrast to a formal analysis. Early man used simple intuition, but through time knowledge increases allowed decision makers (DMs) to move to ‘objectively informed intuition’ (OII). This uses inherent and learnt cognition at both unconscious and conscious levels. A model of business OII is proposed and evaluated using as variables the managers’ personal characteristics and their unique set of objectives. The resultant equation allows assessing decision quality and provides a framework for DMs to work on improvements relative to their objectives. The literature suggests OII stems from a DM’s makeup (business related phenotype), training and experience in a dynamic trio leading to the defining equation. Analyses show business related phenotype is the most important determinant as well as confirming the proposed theory on the determinants of OII success. Practical methods of improving OII are reviewed, and issues worth further investigation outlined. This research is the first encompassing quantitative relationships explaining business OII quality thus enabling improving OII. Suggested further research may refine the equation and expand its core base. This work involves a range of disciplines as different aspects of human characteristics impact on how decisions are made.
- 3 December 2021
- Published by CABI Publishing
- p. 168-181
You owe it to yourself.
In this chapter the farmers reflect on the overall results of the experiment. The farmers have also learned different data analysis techniques and...
- 3 December 2021
- Published by CABI Publishing
- p. 168-181
You owe it to yourself.
In this chapter the farmers reflect on the overall results of the experiment. The farmers have also learned different data analysis techniques and...
- 6 February 2021
- Published by CABI Publishing in CABI Reviews
Demystifying intuition as the main decision system used by farmers
Over the decades, many researchers have explored the concept of intuition as a decision-making process. However, most of this research does not quantify the important aspects of intuition, making it difficult to fully understand its nature and improve the intuitive process, enabling an efficient method of decision-making. The research described here, through a review of the relevant literature, demystifies intuition as a decision system by isolating the important intuition determining variables and relating them to quantitative intuition research. As most farm decisions are made through intuition, farmers, consultants, researchers and students of farm management will find the review useful, stimulating efforts for improving decision-making skills in farmers. The literature search covered all journals and recent decades and includes articles that consider the variables to be targeted in improving intuitive skill. This provides a basis for thinking about intuition and its improvement within the farming world. It was found from the literature that most of the logical areas that should influence decisions do in fact do so and should be targeted in improving intuition. One of the most important improvement processes is a farmer’s self-criticism skills through using a decision diary in conjunction with reflection and consultation leading to improved decisions. This must be in conjunction with understanding, and learning about, the many other variables also impacting on intuitive skill.
- 6 February 2021
- Published by CABI Publishing in CABI Reviews
Demystifying intuition as the main decision system used by farmers
Over the decades, many researchers have explored the concept of intuition as a decision-making process. However, most of this research does not quantify the important aspects of intuition, making it difficult to fully understand its nature and improve the intuitive process, enabling an efficient method of decision-making. The research described here, through a review of the relevant literature, demystifies intuition as a decision system by isolating the important intuition determining variables and relating them to quantitative intuition research. As most farm decisions are made through intuition, farmers, consultants, researchers and students of farm management will find the review useful, stimulating efforts for improving decision-making skills in farmers. The literature search covered all journals and recent decades and includes articles that consider the variables to be targeted in improving intuitive skill. This provides a basis for thinking about intuition and its improvement within the farming world. It was found from the literature that most of the logical areas that should influence decisions do in fact do so and should be targeted in improving intuition. One of the most important improvement processes is a farmer’s self-criticism skills through using a decision diary in conjunction with reflection and consultation leading to improved decisions. This must be in conjunction with understanding, and learning about, the many other variables also impacting on intuitive skill.
- 2 September 2019
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Agricultural Finance Review
- Vol. 79 (5) , 614-632
Farmers’ characteristics’ and the propensity to reduce debt
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to investigate a farm manager’s personal characteristics (personality, age, education, objectives, experience, etc.) as drivers of debt payback success and rates. Traditionally bankers have used historic business statistics, and equity levels, to assess loans and credit worthiness. It is hypothesised that a managers’ personal characteristics are likely to be a better predictor of future debt payback performance. Design/methodology/approach: The literature was searched to isolate the managers’ personal variables likely to determine debt payback. The information led to defining a quantitative model based on the theory of planned behaviour (TPB) which was hypothesised as determining payback rates where a choice was available. A postal random stratified survey of NZ owner operator farm managers provided the data to test the model and define its parameters using regressions, structural equation modelling and statistical comparisons. Findings: The modelling results make it clear a manager’s personal characteristics are highly correlated with debt payback and, logically, are very likely to be the drivers. Four random effects equations and a comparison of high- and low-debt payback managers led to this conclusion. Practical implications: Bankers should use the managers’ personal characteristics, as defined in the regressions, alongside traditional measures when assessing farm business loan requests. This approach is opposite to the traditional methods using mainly historic data. Originality/value: The use of the TPB in assessing debt payback is a new and novel approach showing how enduring personal characteristics can be used in assessing proposals, and particularly, entrepreneurs’ adventurist investments in situations where historic data are not available.
- 2 September 2019
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Agricultural Finance Review
- Vol. 79 (5) , 614-632
Farmers’ characteristics’ and the propensity to reduce debt
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to investigate a farm manager’s personal characteristics (personality, age, education, objectives, experience, etc.) as drivers of debt payback success and rates. Traditionally bankers have used historic business statistics, and equity levels, to assess loans and credit worthiness. It is hypothesised that a managers’ personal characteristics are likely to be a better predictor of future debt payback performance. Design/methodology/approach: The literature was searched to isolate the managers’ personal variables likely to determine debt payback. The information led to defining a quantitative model based on the theory of planned behaviour (TPB) which was hypothesised as determining payback rates where a choice was available. A postal random stratified survey of NZ owner operator farm managers provided the data to test the model and define its parameters using regressions, structural equation modelling and statistical comparisons. Findings: The modelling results make it clear a manager’s personal characteristics are highly correlated with debt payback and, logically, are very likely to be the drivers. Four random effects equations and a comparison of high- and low-debt payback managers led to this conclusion. Practical implications: Bankers should use the managers’ personal characteristics, as defined in the regressions, alongside traditional measures when assessing farm business loan requests. This approach is opposite to the traditional methods using mainly historic data. Originality/value: The use of the TPB in assessing debt payback is a new and novel approach showing how enduring personal characteristics can be used in assessing proposals, and particularly, entrepreneurs’ adventurist investments in situations where historic data are not available.
- 26 August 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Agromedicine
- Vol. 25 (1) , 135-146
An Analysis of Farmers’ Human Characteristics as Drivers of Their Anxiety
Background: Past research has shown farmer anxiety and stress have significantly affected many farmers and their families due not only to the impact on feelings of happiness and success, but also on output efficiency, accident rates, and health. The past approach to ameliorating anxiety has been through utilizing coping mechanisms such as sharing with significant others, venting, planning, self-blame, and positive thinking. A problem has also been farmers’ reluctance to voice difficulties and seek help. Method: An alternative, more basic approach to anxiety amelioration is possible. This involves isolating the human characteristics that lead to anxiety, and subsequently modifying these to reduce anxiety and its associated impacts. Accordingly, the extensive literature on anxiety and stress was reviewed to facilitate developing an hypothesis outlining the important components explaining farmer anxiety. To assess the parameters of farmer anxiety, a random survey of New Zealand farmers was used to obtain their ratings on their anxiety. Regression models were used to quantify the relationships. Results: Specific farmer personal characteristics were shown to be highly related to anxiety. These included a farmer’s personality, objective set, belief in their ability to control outcomes, as well as education and age. Conclusion: This analysis provides the information required to direct counseling efforts to modify the anxiety creating personal variables and, consequently, reduce anxiety and its impact on a longer term basis.
- 26 August 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Agromedicine
- Vol. 25 (1) , 135-146
An Analysis of Farmers’ Human Characteristics as Drivers of Their Anxiety
Background: Past research has shown farmer anxiety and stress have significantly affected many farmers and their families due not only to the impact on feelings of happiness and success, but also on output efficiency, accident rates, and health. The past approach to ameliorating anxiety has been through utilizing coping mechanisms such as sharing with significant others, venting, planning, self-blame, and positive thinking. A problem has also been farmers’ reluctance to voice difficulties and seek help. Method: An alternative, more basic approach to anxiety amelioration is possible. This involves isolating the human characteristics that lead to anxiety, and subsequently modifying these to reduce anxiety and its associated impacts. Accordingly, the extensive literature on anxiety and stress was reviewed to facilitate developing an hypothesis outlining the important components explaining farmer anxiety. To assess the parameters of farmer anxiety, a random survey of New Zealand farmers was used to obtain their ratings on their anxiety. Regression models were used to quantify the relationships. Results: Specific farmer personal characteristics were shown to be highly related to anxiety. These included a farmer’s personality, objective set, belief in their ability to control outcomes, as well as education and age. Conclusion: This analysis provides the information required to direct counseling efforts to modify the anxiety creating personal variables and, consequently, reduce anxiety and its impact on a longer term basis.
- 4 January 2019
- Published by Wiley in New Zealand Geographer
- Vol. 75 (1) , 21-33
Resilience and finances on Aotearoa New Zealand farms: Evidence from a random survey on the sources and uses of debt
Debt and income are keystones to financial resilience on New Zealand farms. This article utilises a survey on finance to assess farm financial health using a new model of resilience. It shows the majority of farms are financially strong. Further borrowing and development are possible. With increasing variability resulting from the longer term trade liberalisation as well as global warming impacts, the high equity will provide future resilience. On the other hand, profit levels are not high relative to the investment, but this has been the case for decades and has not caused problems due to farmer and farm family resilience.
- 4 January 2019
- Published by Wiley in New Zealand Geographer
- Vol. 75 (1) , 21-33
Resilience and finances on Aotearoa New Zealand farms: Evidence from a random survey on the sources and uses of debt
Debt and income are keystones to financial resilience on New Zealand farms. This article utilises a survey on finance to assess farm financial health using a new model of resilience. It shows the majority of farms are financially strong. Further borrowing and development are possible. With increasing variability resulting from the longer term trade liberalisation as well as global warming impacts, the high equity will provide future resilience. On the other hand, profit levels are not high relative to the investment, but this has been the case for decades and has not caused problems due to farmer and farm family resilience.
- 1 July 2018
- Published by Wiley in Kōtuitui: New Zealand Journal of Social Sciences Online
- Vol. 13 (2) , 261-270
The reality of net capital gains and annual profit on NZ primary producing businesses: data from a recent survey of all farm types
Annual net cash returns and net capital gains provide farmers with their actual and potential monetary rewards, respectively. This article reports on a national farm survey showing both actual and potential returns, on average, are not as high as might be imagined. This is supported by the findings of earlier studies and has implications for rural societies and their associated economies. Data on income, expenses and profit is presented as is data on farm value changes over the life of each farm. The information is adjusted for inflation to provide ‘real’ data. The profit and net capital gain figures are divided into groupings based on a range of criteria such as total farm capital, and labour compliment as a reflection of farm size. Statistically significant differences occur for some groupings such as farm type and farm size.
- 1 July 2018
- Published by Wiley in Kōtuitui: New Zealand Journal of Social Sciences Online
- Vol. 13 (2) , 261-270
The reality of net capital gains and annual profit on NZ primary producing businesses: data from a recent survey of all farm types
Annual net cash returns and net capital gains provide farmers with their actual and potential monetary rewards, respectively. This article reports on a national farm survey showing both actual and potential returns, on average, are not as high as might be imagined. This is supported by the findings of earlier studies and has implications for rural societies and their associated economies. Data on income, expenses and profit is presented as is data on farm value changes over the life of each farm. The information is adjusted for inflation to provide ‘real’ data. The profit and net capital gain figures are divided into groupings based on a range of criteria such as total farm capital, and labour compliment as a reflection of farm size. Statistically significant differences occur for some groupings such as farm type and farm size.
- 29 June 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension
- Vol. 23 (1) , 39-60
Farm owners’ reluctance to embrace family succession and the implications for extension: the case of family farms in New Zealand
Purpose: Despite the benefits of early planning for business succession, and plan implementation, many owners/managers fail to act expeditiously. Factors such as a reluctance to accept ageing, a concern over the risks involved and inappropriate objectives may be causative. This research moves towards explaining this reluctance and, consequently, suggesting ways to reduce the problem. Design/approach/methodology: Using the literature outlining the variables associated with succession, a hypothesis using the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) is developed to explain the differences between planned and actual asset transfer (using a structural equation model of the TPB). Data to explore the problem and test the model were obtained from a postal survey of 2300 New Zealand farms (36% response). Findings: The results show manager attitudes related to their personality and objectives are the main causes of reluctance. The financial benefits from successful succession also need determining to provide incentives. Practical applications: Support systems are required to modify farmer attitudes and consequently reduce the reluctance. Originality/value: This work presents one of the first attempts to quantify and systems model (using the TPB) the succession process in a rural setting, and provides clear conclusions on reducing succession reluctance. Theoretical implications: Farming is controlled by humans reinforcing that farm studies must include the personal aspects of the decision-makers.
- 29 June 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension
- Vol. 23 (1) , 39-60
Farm owners’ reluctance to embrace family succession and the implications for extension: the case of family farms in New Zealand
Purpose: Despite the benefits of early planning for business succession, and plan implementation, many owners/managers fail to act expeditiously. Factors such as a reluctance to accept ageing, a concern over the risks involved and inappropriate objectives may be causative. This research moves towards explaining this reluctance and, consequently, suggesting ways to reduce the problem. Design/approach/methodology: Using the literature outlining the variables associated with succession, a hypothesis using the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) is developed to explain the differences between planned and actual asset transfer (using a structural equation model of the TPB). Data to explore the problem and test the model were obtained from a postal survey of 2300 New Zealand farms (36% response). Findings: The results show manager attitudes related to their personality and objectives are the main causes of reluctance. The financial benefits from successful succession also need determining to provide incentives. Practical applications: Support systems are required to modify farmer attitudes and consequently reduce the reluctance. Originality/value: This work presents one of the first attempts to quantify and systems model (using the TPB) the succession process in a rural setting, and provides clear conclusions on reducing succession reluctance. Theoretical implications: Farming is controlled by humans reinforcing that farm studies must include the personal aspects of the decision-makers.
- 22 September 2010
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension
- Vol. 16 (3) , 281-296
Should Farmers' Locus of Control be used in Extension?
To explore whether Farmers' Locus of Control (LOC) could be useful in agricultural extension programmes to improve managerial ability. This test records a farmer's belief in her/his control over production outcomes. A mail survey of 2300 New Zealand farmers was used to obtain a range of variables, and to measure their LOC using a question set created from farming situations and terminology. Using regression analysis the farmer LOCs were related to many variables including the Farmers' self assessment of his/her managerial ability as well as their true ability. The LOC had adequate reliability and consistency. The analysis indicated LOC measures some independent characteristics of farmers as its prediction from other variables is by no means perfect. Furthermore, LOC proved to be partially related to a range of output variables. This indicates a farmer's LOC originates in part from fundamental personality traits which in turn relate to managerial ability. When the fundamental variables are available they can be used to help explain, and improve, managerial ability. However, extension programme efforts to change a farmer's view of his control (LOC) will have benefits as, when considered on its own, a farmer's LOC is still related to successful outcomes. Furthermore, LOC may be related to other aspects of farming such as the general satisfaction obtained. The LOC test provides benchmarks to assess Farmers' control belief, and improvements from training.
- 22 September 2010
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension
- Vol. 16 (3) , 281-296
Should Farmers' Locus of Control be used in Extension?
To explore whether Farmers' Locus of Control (LOC) could be useful in agricultural extension programmes to improve managerial ability. This test records a farmer's belief in her/his control over production outcomes. A mail survey of 2300 New Zealand farmers was used to obtain a range of variables, and to measure their LOC using a question set created from farming situations and terminology. Using regression analysis the farmer LOCs were related to many variables including the Farmers' self assessment of his/her managerial ability as well as their true ability. The LOC had adequate reliability and consistency. The analysis indicated LOC measures some independent characteristics of farmers as its prediction from other variables is by no means perfect. Furthermore, LOC proved to be partially related to a range of output variables. This indicates a farmer's LOC originates in part from fundamental personality traits which in turn relate to managerial ability. When the fundamental variables are available they can be used to help explain, and improve, managerial ability. However, extension programme efforts to change a farmer's view of his control (LOC) will have benefits as, when considered on its own, a farmer's LOC is still related to successful outcomes. Furthermore, LOC may be related to other aspects of farming such as the general satisfaction obtained. The LOC test provides benchmarks to assess Farmers' control belief, and improvements from training.
- 9 June 2010
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension
- Vol. 16 (2) , 111-129
A Behavioural Approach to Understanding Semi-subsistence Farmers' Technology Adoption Decisions: The Case of Improved Paddy-Prawn System in Indonesia
Purpose. This study traced the origins of subsistence Farmers' technology adoption attitudes and extracted the critical elements in their decision making systems. Design/Methodology/Approach. The analysis was structured using a model based on the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB). The role of a ‘bargaining process’ was particularly explored to partially represent the socio-cultural influences, as it became clear social influences were important to decision-making in subsistence situations. The adoption of an improved paddy-prawn system in Indonesia was used as a case study. Findings. The results highlighted the Farmers' use of rational strategies and the socio-cultural interactions in decision-making. Before they would fully adopt the farmers needed to confirm that a new technology was significantly superior to the existing system and could provide a secure income. The role of, largely, a family bargaining process was found to be important. Practical Implications. The model parameters offer a realistic description of the subsistence farmers' decision-making process and consequently provide food for thought when developing extension programmes. Originality/Value. The use of the bargaining process has not been considered in previous studies using a TPB model. This bargaining process seemed to integrate different sets of decision criteria the farmers had learned and in which they believed. Such a process indicated the importance of considering the adoption decision and the relevant changes resulting from the farmers' cognition and interaction.
- 9 June 2010
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension
- Vol. 16 (2) , 111-129
A Behavioural Approach to Understanding Semi-subsistence Farmers' Technology Adoption Decisions: The Case of Improved Paddy-Prawn System in Indonesia
Purpose. This study traced the origins of subsistence Farmers' technology adoption attitudes and extracted the critical elements in their decision making systems. Design/Methodology/Approach. The analysis was structured using a model based on the Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB). The role of a ‘bargaining process’ was particularly explored to partially represent the socio-cultural influences, as it became clear social influences were important to decision-making in subsistence situations. The adoption of an improved paddy-prawn system in Indonesia was used as a case study. Findings. The results highlighted the Farmers' use of rational strategies and the socio-cultural interactions in decision-making. Before they would fully adopt the farmers needed to confirm that a new technology was significantly superior to the existing system and could provide a secure income. The role of, largely, a family bargaining process was found to be important. Practical Implications. The model parameters offer a realistic description of the subsistence farmers' decision-making process and consequently provide food for thought when developing extension programmes. Originality/Value. The use of the bargaining process has not been considered in previous studies using a TPB model. This bargaining process seemed to integrate different sets of decision criteria the farmers had learned and in which they believed. Such a process indicated the importance of considering the adoption decision and the relevant changes resulting from the farmers' cognition and interaction.