RGRebecca Gregg

Rebecca Gregg

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Rebecca Gregg has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    BEhavioural Weight Management: COMponents of Effectiveness (BE:COME) Synopsis

    by Rebecca Gregg, Nishant Jaiswal, Sahar Sharif, Alison Avenell, Louisa Ells, Sandra Jayacodi, Ruth Mackenzie, Sharon Simpson, Olivia Wu, Jennifer Logue

    Background: Behavioural weight management interventions are the main treatment for obesity in the United Kingdom; however, there are limitations in the published evidence on their effectiveness which in turn affects the available guidance. This research aims to determine which individual components of behavioural weight management programmes are associated with greater attendance, intervention completion and weight loss. Objective(s): To map individual components of behavioural weight management interventions. To analyse individual participant data using network meta-analyses at the level of the intervention and component network meta-analysis to investigate the relative effectiveness of components of behavioural weight management interventions for weight loss outcomes. Design: A two-stage Bayesian network meta-analysis and component network meta-analysis of individual participant data from randomised controlled trials and real-world services. Setting: Data obtained from two separate scenarios: randomised controlled trials and real-world services. Participants: Anonymous individual participant data of adults over 18 years of age, living in the United Kingdom and attending behavioural weight management interventions in randomised controlled trials ( n = 4051) and in the real world ( n = 76,201). Interventions: Behavioural weight management interventions. Main outcome measures: Mean change in weight at 12 weeks of active weight loss session of both randomised controlled trials and real-world service data. Results: Mapping of participating services demonstrated variating between the two scenarios (randomised controlled trial and real-world service) despite all following National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidance. At intervention level, network meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials found that all behavioural weight management interventions lead to weight loss at 12 weeks, with Football Fans in Training showing the greatest weight loss (mean difference −4.65, 95% credible intervals −5.24 to −4.07) compared with all other interventions. The intervention-level individual participant data network meta-analysis of real-world services included data from 19 services ( n = 76,201). The analysis for change in weight (kg) showed that face-to-face intervention with weekly sessions on diet and physical activity was associated with the greatest weight loss (programme 1; mean difference −4.03, 95% credible interval −4.12 to −3.94) when compared with other programmes; while interventions of group-based weekly sessions focusing solely on physical activity was associated with very low weight loss (programme 7; mean difference −0.28, 95% credible interval −0.40 to −0.15). Network meta-analysis at component level showed that components associated with weight loss in randomised controlled trials were tailoring (mean difference −5.54, 95% credible interval −7.72 to −3.35), flexibility (mean difference −3.18, 95% credible interval −4.29 to −2.07) and multimodal referral (mean difference −2.57, 95% credible interval −4.89 to −0.25). Based on the data from real-world services, the components associated with change in weight were multimodal referral (mean difference −2.01, 95% credible interval −2.13 to −1.88), personalised dietary advice (mean difference −1.22, 95% credible interval −1.33 to −1.11), flexibility (mean difference −0.41, 95% credible interval −0.47 to −0.35) and person delivery (mean difference −0.45, 95% credible interval −0.52 to −0.38). Limitations: Mapping was performed at service level, not individual. Completeness of the data from services was an issue in terms of missing weights and dates. The meta-analyses were limited due to missing information about ethnicity and socioeconomic status. Due to limited data, the analysis could not explore the interactions between the components. The components in real-world service interventions were not clearly defined, and therefore an element of uncertainty remains. Conclusions: Behavioural weight management interventions are effective in weight loss during initial phase, though there is a big variation in weight loss achieved at 12 weeks. Intervention components, including tailoring, flexibility to attend over weekends and weekdays, and multimodal referral pathways along with in-person delivery and personalised dietary advice are associated with weight loss. Future work: This research leaves a network of behavioural weight management programmes engaged in research and data sets available for future researchers in this field. Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number NIHR129523.

  • Open Access

    Mapping components of behavioural weight management interventions using electronic survey and component selection by expert consensus: the BE:COME Study

    by Rebecca Gregg, Nishant Jaiswal, Sahar Sharif, Alison Avenell, Louisa Ells, Sandra Jayacodi, Ruth Mackenzie, Sharon Simpson, Olivia Wu, Jennifer Logue

    Background: Behavioural weight management interventions are the main funded interventions for people living with obesity in the United Kingdom, but there is high intervention variability, including mode of delivery, dietary, physical activity and behavioural components. Objective: To map individual components of behavioural weight management interventions used in pragmatic clinical trials and those commissioned in the real world. To decide on the components which vary across the interventions and are hypothesised to be of importance to attendance, completion and weight loss. Design: Cross-sectional survey. Setting: Behavioural weight management interventions in two separate scenarios: randomised controlled trials and real-world services (local authority and commercial) Main outcome measure: Identification of components of interest that demonstrate variation in both settings. Methods: Mapping exercise of randomised controlled trials and real-world services using the standardized reporting of adult behavioural weight management interventions to aid evaluation. Selection of components by expert group consensus derived from online survey and discussion. Data sources: Mapping performed by a local contact for real-world services and by one BECOME researcher for randomised controlled trials. Study expert group provided their opinions via online survey and discussion. Results: Real-world services providing data on 19 services and 6 randomised controlled trials were mapped using an intervention template. Survey and discussion led to expert group consensus of components for analysis within a meta-analysis. Summary descriptions are provided for each programme displaying variability in eligibility and exclusion criteria. Results provide a description of real-world services and randomised controlled trials, demonstrating variation between the programme components, for example, programme delivery (face-to-face group based was the most common answer for 28.6% randomised controlled trials and 63.2% real-world services), setting (community centre was the most common answer for 0% of randomised controlled trials and 69.2% real-world services) and total duration of the programme (12 weeks for 7.1% randomised controlled trials and 57.9% real-world services). Limitations: The standardised reporting template is lengthy and can take up to 1.5 hours to complete. The template for randomised controlled was not completed by the trials themselves. An expert group derived the components of interest, which could produce different results with a different group of people. Conclusions: Our work has provided an example of how standardized reporting of adult behavioural weight management interventions to aid evaluation can be implemented. Interventions were included in this study if they were compliant with National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidance. We have described important differences between interventions used in randomised controlled trials and in existing services. The interventions vary in many components, particularly between real-world services and randomised controlled trials; United Kingdom trials differed to those delivered in the real world. This lack of evidence to inform decision-making as to the most effective components of behavioural weight management interventions will ultimately hamper the commissioning of such programmes. Future work: There were components that were of interest to the expert group, which were not either suitable for analysis or part of the standardized reporting template of adult behavioural weight management interventions to aid evaluation template; there were also population subgroups that we were unable to include in future research as we did not include this information on the data request. This research is preparatory work for the BECOME study, and further planned work will determine which components are effective and their effects on different subgroups, along with a cost-effectiveness analysis of any effective component. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number NIHR129523.

  • Open Access

    Dismantling behavioural weight management interventions: component network meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials and real-world services

    by Nishant Jaiswal, Rebecca Gregg, Neil Hawkins, Sahar Sharif-Hurst, Alison Avenell, Louisa Ells, Sandra Jayacodi, Ruth Mackenzie, Sharon Anne Simpson, Olivia Wu, et al.

    Background: Behavioural weight management interventions are complex interventions having several coexisting components designed to facilitate weight loss. Existing evidence has shown behavioural weight management interventions to be effective; however, the magnitude of weight loss varies among programmes. There is value in understanding whether differences in the intervention components influence the overall effectiveness of the interventions. The current study is the first attempt to explore the effects of individual components of interventions using data from both randomised controlled trials and real-world services based in the United Kingdom. Objective: To deconstruct behavioural weight management interventions into constituent components and identify the effectiveness of individual components for weight loss. Design: A component network meta-analysis of data from randomised controlled trials and real-world services. Setting: Real-world services and randomised controlled trials based in the United Kingdom for weight management in adults. Participants: Adults over 18 years of age, living in the United Kingdom and attending behavioural weight management interventions in the real world ( n = 76,201) or participating in randomised controlled trials ( n = 4051). Main outcome measure: Mean change in weight after 12 weeks of active weight loss sessions. Methods: Bayesian two-staged component network meta-analysis using an additive model. Results: In the analysis of randomised controlled trials, significant weight loss was associated with components tailoring (mean difference −5.54 kg; 95% credible interval −7.72 to −3.35), flexibility in attendance (mean difference −3.18 kg; 95% credible interval −4.29 to −2.07) and multimodal referral (mean difference −2.57 kg; 95% credible interval −4.89 to −0.25). In real-world services, the components associated with significant weight loss included multimodal referral (mean difference −2.01, 95% credible interval −2.13 to −1.88), personalised dietary advice (mean difference −1.22, 95% credible interval −1.33 to −1.11), flexibility (mean difference −0.41, 95% credible interval −0.47 to −0.35) and in-person delivery (mean difference −0.45, 95% credible interval −0.52 to −0.38). However, co-design (mean difference 3.46 kg; 95% credible interval 2.12 to 4.82) in randomised controlled trials, and added extras (mean difference 0.99 kg; 95% credible interval 0.88 to 1.10) and tailoring (mean difference 0.33 kg; 95% credible interval 0.27 to 0.40) in real-world services, were not shown to be effective in short-term weight loss. Conclusions: The findings from this study highlight the importance of understanding the impact of intervention components such as accessibility, flexibility, tailoring and dietary advice and in-person delivery in weight loss at 12 weeks. Future research should consider exploring the component interactions and long-term weight loss for improved understanding and developing effective programmes. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number NIHR129523.


  • Open Access

    Behavioural weight management interventions for the treatment of obesity: network meta-analysis of trial and real-world individual participant data

    by Nishant Jaiswal, Rebecca Gregg, Neil Hawkins, Sahar Sharif-Hurst, Alison Avenell, Louisa Ells, Sandra Jayacodi, Ruth Mackenzie, Sharon Anne Simpson, Olivia Wu, et al.

    Background: Behavioural weight management interventions are the primary treatment for obesity in the United Kingdom. These interventions focus on diet, physical activity and behaviour change, and are typically delivered over a period of 12 weeks. Although National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidance makes recommendations on the content of behavioural weight management interventions, there are substantial variations in practice. As a result, what constitutes the most effective composition of behavioural weight management interventions is unclear. Objective: To determine the effectiveness of different types of behavioural weight management interventions in achieving weight loss, using individual participant data from randomised controlled trials and real-world services. Design: A network meta-analysis of individual participant data. Setting: Behavioural weight management interventions delivered in the community. Participants: Anonymous individual participant data of adults (> 18 years), living in the United Kingdom and attending behavioural weight management interventions in the real world ( n = 76,201) and randomised controlled trial’s ( n = 4051). Main outcome measure: Mean change in weight at 12 weeks. Methods: Two-staged Bayesian network meta-analysis of individual participant data from included randomised controlled trials and real-world services was performed. Risk of bias was assessed for randomised controlled trials using Cochrane Risk of Bias 2.0. Prior to analysis, received data were checked, for consistency with the requests and cleaned for all anomalies. Results: All behavioural weight management interventions resulted in weight loss compared to usual care. In the randomised controlled trials, the 52-week weightloss programme referrals for adults in primary care (WRAP) with participants attending intervention achieved the greatest weight reduction at 12 weeks (mean difference = −2.58 kg, 95% credible interval −3.19 to −1.96). However, when a male-only intervention (football fans in training) was included in a sensitivity analysis, it demonstrated the largest short-term weight loss (mean difference = −4.65 kg, credible interval −5.24 to −4.07). In the real-world services, several programmes achieved substantial weight loss, with greater programme attendance associated with improved outcomes. Conclusions: The behavioural weight management intervention in both real-world services and randomised controlled trials are effective for weight loss, but there is a variation in the weight loss achieved at the end of active weight loss period depending upon the structure of intervention and participant engagement. Future work: Dismantling the interventions into component parts will help determine which components or combination of components are associated with greater weight loss. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number NIHR129523.


  • Open Access

    Type and density of independent takeaway outlets: a geographical mapping study in a low socioeconomic ward, Manchester

    by Jennifer Blow, Rebecca Gregg, Ian G Davies, Sumaiya Patel

    Objectives The socioeconomic disparity in childhood and early adult obesity prevalence has been well characterised. Takeaway outlets may cluster in lower socioeconomic areas and their proximity to schools is of concern. This study aimed to map takeaway food outlets, characterise takeaway types and their proximity to educational institutions within a low socioeconomic ward in Manchester. Design The Rusholme ward and a 2 km Euclidean buffer were included as the study area. Local authority Environmental Health data were used to map the takeaway outlets, using QGIS V.2.18.0 (OPENGIS.ch LLC, Einsiedeln, Switzerland). The types of takeaway outlets and major roads were included. Number of outlets within a 400 m Euclidean walking buffer of educational institutions were mapped. Setting Rusholme, Manchester, UK. Results Within the study area, 202 takeaway food outlets were identified and mapped as cluster points. Of these, 62.3% are located on major (A and B) roads, while the remaining outlets were located on minor roads. The majority (57.4%) of takeaway outlets sold similar items (fried chicken, burgers, pizzas, kebabs), with the remainder offering more diverse menus. Of the 53 schools, colleges and universities within the study area, 28 (52.8%) had 1–5 takeaway food outlets within 400 m, 9 (17.0%) had 6–10 outlets; 4 (7.5%) more than 11 outlets with 12 (22.6%) having zero outlets within 400 m. Conclusion Within this low socioeconomic area, there was a high concentration of takeaway food outlets, predominantly along major roads and in easy walking distance of educational establishments with the majority offering similar foods. In addition, a high proportion of these outlets were in easy walking distance of educational establishments. Public health policy needs to consider the implications of current takeaway food outlets and not just the proliferation of these outlets with current planning laws.


  • Open Access

    Sociocultural aspects of takeaway food consumption in a low-socioeconomic ward in Manchester: a grounded theory study

    by Jennifer Blow, Sumaiya Patel, Ian G Davies, Rebecca Gregg

    Objectives Takeaway foods form a growing proportion of the UK diet. This consumption is linked with poor health outcomes due to their adverse nutritional profile. However, there is little research regarding the sociocultural context surrounding the consumption of takeaway meals. This research aimed to explore the sociocultural factors that influence the consumption of takeaway foods. Design The study employed constructivist grounded theory (GT) methodology. Data were collected using one-to-one semi-structured interviews from an inner-city area of Manchester (Rusholme). Data sorting and analysis was implemented using the GT constant comparative method. Setting Rusholme, Manchester, UK. Participants Adult participants (aged 18 to 65 years) consuming takeaway meals at least once/month were recruited using social media and community settings. Results 13 participants were interviewed (female 69%, mean age=38 years). Three superordinate themes were derived from data: social factors, personal factors and resources. Social Factors included the influence of routines and traditions, influential others and a sense of community in the bonding and affirming of relationships. Personal Factors explored the subordinate themes of controlling damage and values relating to food choice. The third theme ‘Resources’ included time, availability, cost and quality. Conclusion This study shows the sociocultural influences on food choice decisions are complex and may go beyond access and availability. Any policy change to limit takeaway consumption should acknowledge these vital processes in food choice to inform targeted effective approaches.