MTMatt Tincani

Matt Tincani

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Matt Tincani has a total of 81 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Peer Review Guidance to Address Selective Reporting in Single-Case Experimental Design Research

    by Matt Tincani, Shawn P. Gilroy, Jason Travers

    Questionable research practices (QRPs) inject bias into single-case experimental design (SCED) research. A prominent QRP is selective reporting, the omission or selective depiction of data or research procedures to inflate the appearance of positive experimental effects. Open and transparent research practices, including clear and appropriate research questions, transparent procedural reporting, and unbiased outcomes reporting, provide evidence that researchers have taken steps to avoid selective reporting in SCED. Peer reviewers have substantial influence in evaluating whether submitted articles reflect these practices. We provide explicit guidance for peer reviewers to appraise how SCED research articles submitted for publication reflect open and transparent reporting as well as describe ways in which clear and constructive feedback to authors can reduce QRPs in behavior science research.

  • Open Access

    Behavior Skills Training to Teach Parent Implemented Preference Assessments in the Home Setting: A Case Study

    by Bianca Scott, Matt Tincani

    Identifying effective reinforcers is a critical component of successful applied behavior analysis (ABA) programs. Preference assessments are an evidence-based method to identify stimuli that function as reinforcers in ABA programs. This study examined the effects of behavior skills training (BST) to teach a parent to implement three common direct preference assessments: free-operant, paired-stimulus, and multiple-stimulus without replacement. A multiple probe across behaviors design showed that BST increased the parent’s accurate implementation of each preference assessment type from low levels in baseline to 100% accuracy post-training. Probes indicated parent assessment skills generalized to assessments performed with their child.


  • Recommendations and guidance for enhancing systematic reviews of single‐case experimental design research

    by Shawn P. Gilroy, Matt Tincani, Christopher A. Podlesnik

    Systematic reviews based on single‐case experimental designs (SCED) are increasingly common in the scientific literature. However, researchers reviewing SCED research may employ varying approaches and strategies, not all of which correspond with recognized standards of review quality, including those specific to SCED. Furthermore, unique features of SCED may necessitate the development of new standards specific to research synthesis. In this article, we provide an overview of the current status and functions of systematic reviews in SCED research. We offer recommendations and guidance to novice and advanced researchers to support consistency, replicability, and transparency of systematic reviews that include SCED research.


  • Open Access

    Assent in Applied Behavior Analysis

    by Matt Tincani, Matthew Thornton Brodhead

    Assent is an individual’s agreement to participate in educational and clinical interventions. Some practitioners have argued opportunities for assent (and dissent) should be presented and reinforced with all individuals across all contexts, irrespective of circumstance or benefit. Yet as verbal behavior, assent is constrained by contingencies of reinforcement and the individual’s ability to appraise benefits and risks of a treatment decision, or capacity. Some opportunities for assent may be necessary and beneficial for the individual, whereas others may conflict with their learning goals, the preferences of their caregivers, and the ethical obligations of professionals who support them. We are concerned a newly proposed approach, “assent-based ABA,” departs from a humanistic, behavior-analytic account of assent, diminishing therapeutic learning opportunities. In this paper, we examine assent in ABA programming, addressing issues of capacity, assent and dissent, autonomy and the best interest standard, voluntariness versus coercion, and social validity. We outline our concerns with “assent-based ABA” and conclude with practical considerations for assent in ABA programming.

  • Open Access

    Systematic Review of Crisis Management Programs for Students with Disabilities

    by Amy K Wasersztein, Matt Tincani, Tess Fruchtman, Jason C Travers, Katie Kostin, Olivia Layne Wallace, Bruna Fusco Gonçalves, Bryan Cook, Art Dowdy

    Crisis management programs are marketed to help special education professionals support students with disabilities who engage in challenging behavior. There is a critical need to appraise the evidence supporting these programs, particularly whether they benefit students in crisis intervention and prevention. This need is particularly urgent given documented misapplication and overuse of physical restraint, which is a common component of these programs. The purpose of this systematic review was to evaluate the research in support of crisis management programs that target PK-12 students with disabilities who display challenging behavior in educational settings. We conducted database searches, ancestral searches, and website searches of organizations that produce crisis management programs to identify published and unpublished studies evaluating the programs. Our search process yielded just six studies evaluating five of 23 commercially available crisis management programs. Given the scarcity of supporting studies, none of the programs meet currently established thresholds for evidence-based practice in special education. Our review identifies a critical need for rigorous research on these programs to inform practice and policy, ensuring student safety and wellbeing. Consumers should exercise caution in adopting these programs based on claims made by the programs’ producers.

  • Systematic Review of Crisis Management Programs for Students With Disabilities

    by Amy K. Wasersztein, Matt Tincani, Tess Fruchtman, Jason C. Travers, Katie Kostin, Olivia Wallace, Bruna F. Gonçalves, Bryan G. Cook, Art Dowdy

    Crisis management programs are marketed to help special education professionals support students with disabilities who engage in challenging behavior. There is a critical need to appraise the evidence supporting these programs, particularly whether they benefit students in crisis intervention and prevention. This need is particularly urgent given documented misapplication and overuse of physical restraint, which is a common component of these programs. The purpose of this systematic review was to evaluate the research in support of crisis management programs that target PK–12 students with disabilities who display challenging behavior in educational settings. We conducted database searches, ancestral searches, and website searches of organizations that produce crisis management programs to identify published and unpublished studies evaluating the programs. Our search process yielded just six studies evaluating five of 23 commercially available crisis management programs. Given the scarcity of supporting studies, none of the programs meet currently established thresholds for evidence-based practice in special education. Our review identifies a critical need for rigorous research on these programs to inform practice and policy, ensuring student safety and wellbeing. Consumers should exercise caution in adopting these programs based on claims made by the programs’ producers.

  • Perceptions of Single-Case Experimental Design Researchers About Questionable and Improved Research Practices

    by Jason C. Travers, Art Dowdy, Matt Tincani, Tim Slocum

    Questionable research practices (QRPs) are methodological decisions motivated and reinforced by publication that can distort conclusions drawn from the scientific literature. This study surveyed 143 single-case experimental design (SCED) researchers from various backgrounds about their perceptions of QRPs and corresponding improved research practices (IRPs). Participants rated the problematic nature, prevalence, validity-enhancing potential, and feasibility of 64 QRP-IRP pairs. We found broad agreement that most QRPs undermine SCED research integrity, and IRPs could further enhance SCED validity. Exploratory analyses revealed a strong correlation between perceived QRP severity and likelihood of IRP adoption. However, variability existed in observed QRP prevalence and feasibility of IRP implementation. We discuss ways to increase awareness about QRPs and IRPs, potential journal editorial policy shifts, and SCED researcher development to strengthen transparency and rigor. Implications for advancing SCED methodology also are discussed with emphasis on fostering a culture of improved SCED transparency and rigor.


  • Open Access

    In Defense of Applied Behavior Analysis and Evidence-Based Practice

    by Jason Travers, Matt Tincani

    This commentary critically appraises attacks on applied behavior analysis (ABA) from outside and—increasingly—within the field. Commonly repeated attacks are that ABA is coercive and suppresses individual identity, aligns with the medical model, causes trauma, and, in more extreme cases, constitutes abuse. We illustrate how these claims are based on unfounded criticism and longstanding myths about ABA and stand in direct contrast to the empirical foundations of behavior analysis. We also highlight how such criticism conflicts with over half a century of evidence that ABA supports autonomy and enhances wellbeing of people with autism and developmental disabilities. We call for self-reflection among well-meaning behavior analysts who repeat such criticisms and greater attention to evidence-based practice.


  • Open Access

    Questionable and Improved Research Practices in Single-Case Experimental Design: Initial Investigation and Findings

    by Matt Tincani, Jason C Travers, Art Dowdy, Timothy A. Slocum

    Researchers and methodologists in the group comparison tradition have identified questionable research practices that can compromise replicability and validity of conclusions. However, this concept of questionable research practices has not been widely applied to single-case experimental designs (SCED). This paper describes initial steps toward identifying questionable and improved research practices in SCED. Participants were 63 SCED researcher experts with varying backgrounds and expertise. They attended a one-day virtual microconference that included focus groups designed to solicit examples of questionable and improved research practices at different stages of the research process. A qualitative thematic analysis of over 2,000 notes from the participants resulted in 69 specific questionable and improved research practices. We discuss results in relation to the open science movement and quality indicators for SCED studies and explore future directions of research, including investigating whether consensus exists about the identified practices.

  • Open Access

    Questionable and Improved Research Practices in Single-Case Experimental Design: Initial Investigation and Findings

    by Matt Tincani, Jason Travers, Art Dowdy, Timothy A. Slocum, Ronnie Deitrich

    Researchers have identified questionable research practices that compromise replicability and validity of conclusions. However, this concept of questionable research practices has not been widely applied to single-case experimental designs (SCED). Moreover, to date researchers have focused little attention on improved research practices as alternatives to questionable practices. This article describes initial steps toward identifying questionable and improved research practices in SCED. Participants were 63 SCED researcher experts with varying backgrounds and expertise. They attended a 1-day virtual microconference with focus groups to solicit examples of questionable and improved research practices at different stages of the research process. A qualitative analysis of over 2,000 notes from the participants yielded shared perspectives, resulting in 64 pairs of questionable and improved research practices in SCED. Our results highlight the need for further evaluation and efforts to disseminate improved research practices as alternatives to questionable practices.