Annakaisa von Lerber
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Annakaisa von Lerber has a total of 102 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Dmitri Moisseev
Finnish Meteorological Institute, Erik Palmenin aukio 1, FI-00560 Helsinki, Finland
15 shared publications - Jussi Tiira
Institute for Atmospheric and Earth System Research/Physics, Faculty of Science, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
5 shared publications - Seppo Pulkkinen
Finnish Meteorological Institute, Helsinki, Finland
5 shared publications - Walter A. Petersen
NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, Alabama, USA
5 shared publications - Davide Ori
Institute of Geophysics and Meteorology, University of Cologne, Cologne, Germany
4 shared publications Larry F. Bliven
NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Wallops Flight Facility Wallops Island VA USA
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Vicarious use of calibration scans from the operational FMI weather radar network
The Finnish operational weather radar network has 12 C-band polarimetric radars covering the country. Altough primarily scanning at low elevation angles, the operational scanning schedule for the weather radars contains a vertical ‘birdbath scan’ which is repeated every 15 minutes. The ‘birdbath’ scan is designed for calibrating differential reflectivity (ZDR) and the antenna rotates 360 degrees in azimuth while remaining vertically-pointing. All pulses within the scanning time (< 30 s for a full rotation) are then averaged and processed as normal to provide one vertical profile with the three Doppler moments (Z, v, and spectral width) and the polarimetric variables ZDR and cross-correlation coefficient rho_hv. ZDR at vertical is not useful for meterological purposes but the remaining variables can be utilised in the same manner as for a vertically-pointing Doppler (cloud radar (Frech et al., 2026). It should be noted that the spectral width is broadened due to the rotation. Rho_hv is an excellent indicator of the melting level and can be employed in the same way as LDR or slanted-LDR is used within the Cloudnet processing scheme, and hence the collection of vertical ‘birdbath’ scans can be concatenated to provide very similar output to vertically-pointing Doppler cloud radars and used for satellite and model evaluation in the same way.Although the effective temporal resolution is rather coarse, this data has the advantage of no Doppler aliasing and minimal attenuation, even in heavy rain. The sensitivity appears sufficient to capture the majority of ice clouds (although maybe missing some liquid layers) including ice clouds above strong precipitation which would be missed by Doppler cloud radars operating at Ka- or W-band. After adjusting for the frequency difference (for both Z and v), these observations have exceptional potential to complement the satellite cal/val and model evaluation activities being performed by cloud radar networks. Frech, M., S. Kneifel, P. Ockenfuss, and M. Gergely, 2026: Exploring the Untapped Potential of Operational Weather Radars for Vertical Profiling of Precipitation and Clouds. Bull. Amer. Meteor. Soc., 107, E127–E141, https://doi.org/10.1175/BAMS-D-24-0113.1.
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessVicarious use of calibration scans from the operational FMI weather radar network
The Finnish operational weather radar network has 12 C-band polarimetric radars covering the country. Altough primarily scanning at low elevation angles, the operational scanning schedule for the weather radars contains a vertical ‘birdbath scan’ which is repeated every 15 minutes. The ‘birdbath’ scan is designed for calibrating differential reflectivity (ZDR) and the antenna rotates 360 degrees in azimuth while remaining vertically-pointing. All pulses within the scanning time (< 30 s for a full rotation) are then averaged and processed as normal to provide one vertical profile with the three Doppler moments (Z, v, and spectral width) and the polarimetric variables ZDR and cross-correlation coefficient rho_hv. ZDR at vertical is not useful for meterological purposes but the remaining variables can be utilised in the same manner as for a vertically-pointing Doppler (cloud radar (Frech et al., 2026). It should be noted that the spectral width is broadened due to the rotation. Rho_hv is an excellent indicator of the melting level and can be employed in the same way as LDR or slanted-LDR is used within the Cloudnet processing scheme, and hence the collection of vertical ‘birdbath’ scans can be concatenated to provide very similar output to vertically-pointing Doppler cloud radars and used for satellite and model evaluation in the same way.Although the effective temporal resolution is rather coarse, this data has the advantage of no Doppler aliasing and minimal attenuation, even in heavy rain. The sensitivity appears sufficient to capture the majority of ice clouds (although maybe missing some liquid layers) including ice clouds above strong precipitation which would be missed by Doppler cloud radars operating at Ka- or W-band. After adjusting for the frequency difference (for both Z and v), these observations have exceptional potential to complement the satellite cal/val and model evaluation activities being performed by cloud radar networks. Frech, M., S. Kneifel, P. Ockenfuss, and M. Gergely, 2026: Exploring the Untapped Potential of Operational Weather Radars for Vertical Profiling of Precipitation and Clouds. Bull. Amer. Meteor. Soc., 107, E127–E141, https://doi.org/10.1175/BAMS-D-24-0113.1.
- Open Access
- 13 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 18 (3) , 793-816
Benchmarking KDP in rainfall: a quantitative assessment of estimation algorithms using C-band weather radar observations
Accurate and precise KDP estimates are essential for radar-based applications, especially in quantitative precipitation estimation and radar data quality control routines. The accuracy of these estimates largely depends on the post-processing of the radar's measured ΦDP, which aims to reduce noise and backscattering effects while preserving fine-scale precipitation features. In this study, we evaluate the performance of several publicly available KDP estimation methods implemented in open-source libraries such as Py-ART (the Python ARM (atmospheric radiation measurement) Radar Toolkit) and ωradlib and the method used in the Vaisala weather radars. To benchmark these methods, we employ a polarimetric self-consistency approach that relates KDP to reflectivity and differential reflectivity in rain, providing a reference self-consistent KDP ( ) for comparison. This approach allows for the construction of the reference KDP observations that can be used to assess the accuracy and robustness of the studied KDP estimation methods. We assess each method by quantifying uncertainties using C-band weather radar observations, where the reflectivity values ranged between 20 and 50 dBZ. Using the proposed evaluation framework, we were able to define optimized parameter settings for the methods that have user-configurable parameters. Most of these methods showed a significant reduction in the estimation errors after the optimization, with respect to the default settings. We have found significant differences in the performance of the studied methods, where the best-performing methods showed smaller normalized biases in the high reflectivity values (i.e., ≥ 40 dBZ) and overall smaller normalized root-mean-square errors across the range of reflectivity values.- 13 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 18 (3) , 793-816
Open AccessBenchmarking KDP in rainfall: a quantitative assessment of estimation algorithms using C-band weather radar observations
Accurate and precise KDP estimates are essential for radar-based applications, especially in quantitative precipitation estimation and radar data quality control routines. The accuracy of these estimates largely depends on the post-processing of the radar's measured ΦDP, which aims to reduce noise and backscattering effects while preserving fine-scale precipitation features. In this study, we evaluate the performance of several publicly available KDP estimation methods implemented in open-source libraries such as Py-ART (the Python ARM (atmospheric radiation measurement) Radar Toolkit) and ωradlib and the method used in the Vaisala weather radars. To benchmark these methods, we employ a polarimetric self-consistency approach that relates KDP to reflectivity and differential reflectivity in rain, providing a reference self-consistent KDP ( ) for comparison. This approach allows for the construction of the reference KDP observations that can be used to assess the accuracy and robustness of the studied KDP estimation methods. We assess each method by quantifying uncertainties using C-band weather radar observations, where the reflectivity values ranged between 20 and 50 dBZ. Using the proposed evaluation framework, we were able to define optimized parameter settings for the methods that have user-configurable parameters. Most of these methods showed a significant reduction in the estimation errors after the optimization, with respect to the default settings. We have found significant differences in the performance of the studied methods, where the best-performing methods showed smaller normalized biases in the high reflectivity values (i.e., ≥ 40 dBZ) and overall smaller normalized root-mean-square errors across the range of reflectivity values. - Open Access
- 4 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-34
Comment on amt-2024-155
Accurate and precise KDP estimates are essential for radar-based applications, especially in quantitative precipitation estimation and radar data quality control routines. The accuracy of these estimates largely depends on the post-processing of the radar's measured ΦDP, which aims to reduce noise and backscattering effects while preserving fine-scale precipitation features. In this study, we evaluate the performance of several publicly available KDP estimation methods implemented in open-source libraries such as PyArt and Wradlib, and the method used in the Vaisala weather radars. To benchmark these methods, we employ a polarimetric self-consistency approach that relates KDP to reflectivity and differential reflectivity in rain, providing a reference self-consistency KDP (KDPSC ) for comparison. This approach allows for the construction of the reference KDP observations that can be used to assess the accuracy and robustness of the studied KDP estimation methods. We assess each method by quantifying uncertainties using C-band weather radar observations where the reflectivity values ranged between 20 and 50 dBZ. Using the proposed evaluation framework we could define optimized parameter settings for the methods that have user-configurable parameters. Most of such methods showed significant reduction in the estimation errors after the optimization with respect to the default settings. We have found significant differences in the performances of the studied methods, where the best performing methods showed smaller normalized biases in the high reflectivity values (i.e., ≥ 40 dBZ) and overall smaller normalized root mean squared errors across the range of reflectivity values.
- 4 November 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-34
Open AccessComment on amt-2024-155
Accurate and precise KDP estimates are essential for radar-based applications, especially in quantitative precipitation estimation and radar data quality control routines. The accuracy of these estimates largely depends on the post-processing of the radar's measured ΦDP, which aims to reduce noise and backscattering effects while preserving fine-scale precipitation features. In this study, we evaluate the performance of several publicly available KDP estimation methods implemented in open-source libraries such as PyArt and Wradlib, and the method used in the Vaisala weather radars. To benchmark these methods, we employ a polarimetric self-consistency approach that relates KDP to reflectivity and differential reflectivity in rain, providing a reference self-consistency KDP (KDPSC ) for comparison. This approach allows for the construction of the reference KDP observations that can be used to assess the accuracy and robustness of the studied KDP estimation methods. We assess each method by quantifying uncertainties using C-band weather radar observations where the reflectivity values ranged between 20 and 50 dBZ. Using the proposed evaluation framework we could define optimized parameter settings for the methods that have user-configurable parameters. Most of such methods showed significant reduction in the estimation errors after the optimization with respect to the default settings. We have found significant differences in the performances of the studied methods, where the best performing methods showed smaller normalized biases in the high reflectivity values (i.e., ≥ 40 dBZ) and overall smaller normalized root mean squared errors across the range of reflectivity values.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-34
Benchmarking KDP in Rainfall: A Quantitative Assessment of Estimation Algorithms Using C-Band Weather Radar Observations
Accurate and precise KDP estimates are essential for radar-based applications, especially in quantitative precipitation estimation and radar data quality control routines. The accuracy of these estimates largely depends on the post-processing of the radar's measured ΦDP, which aims to reduce noise and backscattering effects while preserving fine-scale precipitation features. In this study, we evaluate the performance of several publicly available KDP estimation methods implemented in open-source libraries such as PyArt and Wradlib, and the method used in the Vaisala weather radars. To benchmark these methods, we employ a polarimetric self-consistency approach that relates KDP to reflectivity and differential reflectivity in rain, providing a reference self-consistency KDP (KDPSC ) for comparison. This approach allows for the construction of the reference KDP observations that can be used to assess the accuracy and robustness of the studied KDP estimation methods. We assess each method by quantifying uncertainties using C-band weather radar observations where the reflectivity values ranged between 20 and 50 dBZ. Using the proposed evaluation framework we could define optimized parameter settings for the methods that have user-configurable parameters. Most of such methods showed significant reduction in the estimation errors after the optimization with respect to the default settings. We have found significant differences in the performances of the studied methods, where the best performing methods showed smaller normalized biases in the high reflectivity values (i.e., ≥ 40 dBZ) and overall smaller normalized root mean squared errors across the range of reflectivity values.
- 18 September 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2024, 1-34
Open AccessBenchmarking KDP in Rainfall: A Quantitative Assessment of Estimation Algorithms Using C-Band Weather Radar Observations
Accurate and precise KDP estimates are essential for radar-based applications, especially in quantitative precipitation estimation and radar data quality control routines. The accuracy of these estimates largely depends on the post-processing of the radar's measured ΦDP, which aims to reduce noise and backscattering effects while preserving fine-scale precipitation features. In this study, we evaluate the performance of several publicly available KDP estimation methods implemented in open-source libraries such as PyArt and Wradlib, and the method used in the Vaisala weather radars. To benchmark these methods, we employ a polarimetric self-consistency approach that relates KDP to reflectivity and differential reflectivity in rain, providing a reference self-consistency KDP (KDPSC ) for comparison. This approach allows for the construction of the reference KDP observations that can be used to assess the accuracy and robustness of the studied KDP estimation methods. We assess each method by quantifying uncertainties using C-band weather radar observations where the reflectivity values ranged between 20 and 50 dBZ. Using the proposed evaluation framework we could define optimized parameter settings for the methods that have user-configurable parameters. Most of such methods showed significant reduction in the estimation errors after the optimization with respect to the default settings. We have found significant differences in the performances of the studied methods, where the best performing methods showed smaller normalized biases in the high reflectivity values (i.e., ≥ 40 dBZ) and overall smaller normalized root mean squared errors across the range of reflectivity values.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Earth and Space Science
- Vol. 11 (5)
A Comprehensive Northern Hemisphere Particle Microphysics Data Set From the Precipitation Imaging Package
Microphysical observations of precipitating particles are critical data sources for numerical weather prediction models and remote sensing retrieval algorithms. However, obtaining coherent data sets of particle microphysics is challenging as they are often unindexed, distributed across disparate institutions, and have not undergone a uniform quality control process. This work introduces a unified, comprehensive Northern Hemisphere particle microphysical data set from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration precipitation imaging package (PIP), accessible in a standardized data format and stored in a centralized, public repository. Data is collected from 10 measurement sites spanning 34° latitude (37°N–71°N) over 10 years (2014–2023), which comprise a set of 1,070,000 precipitating minutes. The provided data set includes measurements of a suite of microphysical attributes for both rain and snow, including distributions of particle size, vertical velocity, and effective density, along with higher‐order products including an approximation of volume‐weighted equivalent particle densities, liquid equivalent snowfall, and rainfall rate estimates. The data underwent a rigorous standardization and quality assurance process to filter out erroneous observations to produce a self‐describing, scalable, and achievable data set. Case study analyses demonstrate the capabilities of the data set in identifying physical processes like precipitation phase‐changes at high temporal resolution. Bulk precipitation characteristics from a multi‐site intercomparison also highlight distinct microphysical properties unique to each location. This curated PIP data set is a robust database of high‐quality particle microphysical observations for constraining future precipitation retrieval algorithms, and offers new insights toward better understanding regional and seasonal differences in bulk precipitation characteristics.
- 15 May 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Earth and Space Science
- Vol. 11 (5)
Open AccessA Comprehensive Northern Hemisphere Particle Microphysics Data Set From the Precipitation Imaging Package
Microphysical observations of precipitating particles are critical data sources for numerical weather prediction models and remote sensing retrieval algorithms. However, obtaining coherent data sets of particle microphysics is challenging as they are often unindexed, distributed across disparate institutions, and have not undergone a uniform quality control process. This work introduces a unified, comprehensive Northern Hemisphere particle microphysical data set from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration precipitation imaging package (PIP), accessible in a standardized data format and stored in a centralized, public repository. Data is collected from 10 measurement sites spanning 34° latitude (37°N–71°N) over 10 years (2014–2023), which comprise a set of 1,070,000 precipitating minutes. The provided data set includes measurements of a suite of microphysical attributes for both rain and snow, including distributions of particle size, vertical velocity, and effective density, along with higher‐order products including an approximation of volume‐weighted equivalent particle densities, liquid equivalent snowfall, and rainfall rate estimates. The data underwent a rigorous standardization and quality assurance process to filter out erroneous observations to produce a self‐describing, scalable, and achievable data set. Case study analyses demonstrate the capabilities of the data set in identifying physical processes like precipitation phase‐changes at high temporal resolution. Bulk precipitation characteristics from a multi‐site intercomparison also highlight distinct microphysical properties unique to each location. This curated PIP data set is a robust database of high‐quality particle microphysical observations for constraining future precipitation retrieval algorithms, and offers new insights toward better understanding regional and seasonal differences in bulk precipitation characteristics.
- Open Access
- 6 July 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
OPERA5 – the renewal of the production lines
For over 20 years, the Operational Programme on the Exchange of Weather Radar Information (OPERA) has been coordinating radar cooperation among national weather services in Europe, operating under the umbrella of the European Meteorological Services Network, EIG EUMETNET. More information on this programme can be found at www.eumetnet.eu/opera [Saltikoff et al. 2019].Since 2011, the OPERA data center (ODC), also known as Odyssey, has been producing three Pan-European radar composite products, with spatial resolution of 2 km and 15-minute update cycle. The composite products are: maximum reflectivity, rain rate, and 1-hour accumulation. Additionally, Odyssey provides the quality-controlled (QC) single-site volume radar data for the numerical weather prediction (NWP) consortia to be used for assimilation. OPERA data are utilized for a variety of applications, including nowcasting, NWP assimilation, and flood warnings. As the OPERA data archive has grown to over ten years, also the creation of climatological applications is possible based on OPERA data. Different user groups have various needs for the data, with some requiring advanced QC and production of complex products, while others prioritize timely access to the data.During the current OPERA phase 5 (2019-2023), the programme's main focus is to gradually replace the ODC with three new production lines:The CUMULUS/STRATUS line is responsible for gathering incoming radar data and forwarding it to other production lines. The CIRRUS line generates a high-resolution maximum reflectivity composite (updated every 5 minutes with 1 km horizontal resolution). The NIMBUS line produces precipitation composites and provides quality-controlled volume radar data for the purpose of NWP assimilation. Additionally, OPERA centrally monitors the network's performance, including the level of radio frequency interference and the antenna pointing using methods such as solar monitoring [Huuskonen and Holleman, 2007].During the conference, we will present the updated production lines and preliminary results of their performance compared to the ODC. The CIRRUS represents an updated version of the ODC software, but due to the different spatial and temporal resolutions, the CIRRUS maximum reflectivity product is inherently different from the ODC equivalent composite. The methodology used to compare these two products is based on the SAL method [Wernli et al. 2008], which not only compares the amplitude but also the structural differences of the two products. The NIMBUS production is based on the BALTRAD open radar software, and its performance for the rain accumulation composite product is compared to gauge observations, similar as in the study by [Park et al. 2019].We will also provide insights for data sharing in OPERA. The EU Implementing Regulation has defined weather radar data as High-Value Datasets (HVD) that should be shared free of charge, openly accessible via Application Programming Interfaces (APIs), machine-readable, and bulk downloadable in the coming years.
- 6 July 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessOPERA5 – the renewal of the production lines
For over 20 years, the Operational Programme on the Exchange of Weather Radar Information (OPERA) has been coordinating radar cooperation among national weather services in Europe, operating under the umbrella of the European Meteorological Services Network, EIG EUMETNET. More information on this programme can be found at www.eumetnet.eu/opera [Saltikoff et al. 2019].Since 2011, the OPERA data center (ODC), also known as Odyssey, has been producing three Pan-European radar composite products, with spatial resolution of 2 km and 15-minute update cycle. The composite products are: maximum reflectivity, rain rate, and 1-hour accumulation. Additionally, Odyssey provides the quality-controlled (QC) single-site volume radar data for the numerical weather prediction (NWP) consortia to be used for assimilation. OPERA data are utilized for a variety of applications, including nowcasting, NWP assimilation, and flood warnings. As the OPERA data archive has grown to over ten years, also the creation of climatological applications is possible based on OPERA data. Different user groups have various needs for the data, with some requiring advanced QC and production of complex products, while others prioritize timely access to the data.During the current OPERA phase 5 (2019-2023), the programme's main focus is to gradually replace the ODC with three new production lines:The CUMULUS/STRATUS line is responsible for gathering incoming radar data and forwarding it to other production lines. The CIRRUS line generates a high-resolution maximum reflectivity composite (updated every 5 minutes with 1 km horizontal resolution). The NIMBUS line produces precipitation composites and provides quality-controlled volume radar data for the purpose of NWP assimilation. Additionally, OPERA centrally monitors the network's performance, including the level of radio frequency interference and the antenna pointing using methods such as solar monitoring [Huuskonen and Holleman, 2007].During the conference, we will present the updated production lines and preliminary results of their performance compared to the ODC. The CIRRUS represents an updated version of the ODC software, but due to the different spatial and temporal resolutions, the CIRRUS maximum reflectivity product is inherently different from the ODC equivalent composite. The methodology used to compare these two products is based on the SAL method [Wernli et al. 2008], which not only compares the amplitude but also the structural differences of the two products. The NIMBUS production is based on the BALTRAD open radar software, and its performance for the rain accumulation composite product is compared to gauge observations, similar as in the study by [Park et al. 2019].We will also provide insights for data sharing in OPERA. The EU Implementing Regulation has defined weather radar data as High-Value Datasets (HVD) that should be shared free of charge, openly accessible via Application Programming Interfaces (APIs), machine-readable, and bulk downloadable in the coming years.
- Open Access
- 7 June 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 22 (11) , 7287-7317
Evaluating seasonal and regional distribution of snowfall in regional climate model simulations in the Arctic
In this study, we investigate how the regional climate model HIRHAM5 reproduces the spatial and temporal distribution of Arctic snowfall when compared to CloudSat satellite observations during the examined period of 2007–2010. For this purpose, both approaches, i.e., the assessments of the surface snowfall rate (observation-to-model) and the radar reflectivity factor profiles (model-to-observation), are carried out considering spatial and temporal sampling differences. The HIRHAM5 model, which is constrained in its synoptic representation by nudging to ERA-Interim, represents the snowfall in the Arctic region well in comparison to CloudSat products. The spatial distribution of the snowfall patterns is similar in both identifying the southeastern coast of Greenland and the North Atlantic corridor as regions gaining more than twice as much snowfall as the Arctic average, defined here for latitudes between 66 and 81∘ N. Excellent agreement (difference less than 1 %) in the Arctic-averaged annual snowfall rate between HIRHAM5 and CloudSat is found, whereas ERA-Interim reanalysis shows an underestimation of 45 % and significant deficits in the representation of the snowfall rate distribution. From the spatial analysis, it can be seen that the largest differences in the mean annual snowfall rates are an overestimation near the coastlines of Greenland and other regions with large orographic variations as well as an underestimation in the northern North Atlantic Ocean. To a large extent, the differences can be explained by clutter contamination, blind zone or higher resolution of CloudSat measurements, but clearly HIRHAM5 overestimates the orographic-driven precipitation. The underestimation of HIRHAM5 within the North Atlantic corridor south of Svalbard is likely connected to a poor description of the marine cold air outbreaks which could be identified by separating snowfall into different circulation weather type regimes. By simulating the radar reflectivity factor profiles from HIRHAM5 utilizing the Passive and Active Microwave TRAnsfer (PAMTRA) forward-modeling operator, the contribution of individual hydrometeor types can be assessed. Looking at a latitude band at 72–73∘ N, snow can be identified as the hydrometeor type dominating radar reflectivity factor values across all seasons. The largest differences between the observed and simulated reflectivity factor values are related to the contribution of cloud ice particles, which is underestimated in the model, most likely due to the small sizes of the particles. The model-to-observation approach offers a promising diagnostic when improving cloud schemes, as illustrated by comparison of different schemes available for HIRHAM5.
- 7 June 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
- Vol. 22 (11) , 7287-7317
Open AccessEvaluating seasonal and regional distribution of snowfall in regional climate model simulations in the Arctic
In this study, we investigate how the regional climate model HIRHAM5 reproduces the spatial and temporal distribution of Arctic snowfall when compared to CloudSat satellite observations during the examined period of 2007–2010. For this purpose, both approaches, i.e., the assessments of the surface snowfall rate (observation-to-model) and the radar reflectivity factor profiles (model-to-observation), are carried out considering spatial and temporal sampling differences. The HIRHAM5 model, which is constrained in its synoptic representation by nudging to ERA-Interim, represents the snowfall in the Arctic region well in comparison to CloudSat products. The spatial distribution of the snowfall patterns is similar in both identifying the southeastern coast of Greenland and the North Atlantic corridor as regions gaining more than twice as much snowfall as the Arctic average, defined here for latitudes between 66 and 81∘ N. Excellent agreement (difference less than 1 %) in the Arctic-averaged annual snowfall rate between HIRHAM5 and CloudSat is found, whereas ERA-Interim reanalysis shows an underestimation of 45 % and significant deficits in the representation of the snowfall rate distribution. From the spatial analysis, it can be seen that the largest differences in the mean annual snowfall rates are an overestimation near the coastlines of Greenland and other regions with large orographic variations as well as an underestimation in the northern North Atlantic Ocean. To a large extent, the differences can be explained by clutter contamination, blind zone or higher resolution of CloudSat measurements, but clearly HIRHAM5 overestimates the orographic-driven precipitation. The underestimation of HIRHAM5 within the North Atlantic corridor south of Svalbard is likely connected to a poor description of the marine cold air outbreaks which could be identified by separating snowfall into different circulation weather type regimes. By simulating the radar reflectivity factor profiles from HIRHAM5 utilizing the Passive and Active Microwave TRAnsfer (PAMTRA) forward-modeling operator, the contribution of individual hydrometeor types can be assessed. Looking at a latitude band at 72–73∘ N, snow can be identified as the hydrometeor type dominating radar reflectivity factor values across all seasons. The largest differences between the observed and simulated reflectivity factor values are related to the contribution of cloud ice particles, which is underestimated in the model, most likely due to the small sizes of the particles. The model-to-observation approach offers a promising diagnostic when improving cloud schemes, as illustrated by comparison of different schemes available for HIRHAM5.
- Open Access
- 28 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Beyond hazard: Combining pan-European exposure data with flash flood hazard forecasts to create impact forecasts for civil protection agencies
As part of TAMIR, a European Commission Civil Protection Preparedness project (ID. 874435), probabilistic operational pan-European flash flood impact forecasts with lead times from 0 to 120 hours have been developed by combining flash flood hazard forecasts with exposure data. Working with civil protection agencies, the aim is to develop forecasts which clearly identify the areas most at risk of serious impacts and therefore may require their intervention. Firstly, the project engaged with these agencies to identify their requirements of flash flood impact forecasts and which elements of exposure and important to them when assessing impacts. Accordingly, pan-European exposure data for population and critical infrastructure (health, education, transport, and energy generation facilities) were sourced from several open source datasets (HARCI-EU, OSM, GHS). These exposure data were (if necessary) regridded and cropped to the spatial domain, transformed to reduce skewness, and rescaled between 1 and 2 to give the datasets common units. The five exposure types were then added together and re-scaled, to produce a combined exposure layer with values ranging from 1 (low exposure) to 2 (high exposure). Flash flood hazard forecasts were created in a previous project by blending hourly ensemble precipitation nowcasts with ensemble numerical weather predictions (NWP) from the ECMWF IFS (Integrated Forecast System). These forecasts are created once per hour and have a lead time of up to 5 days. The flash flood impact forecasts were created by combining the hazard forecasts and exposure data on a two-dimensional impact matrix. Both axes of matrix are split into 3 categories (low, medium, high). For exposure, the ranges for each category were chosen based on the distribution of the data. For hazard, the low, medium, and high categories indicate where the forecast probability shows a 5%-50%, 50%-80%, and 80%+ likelihood of exceeding the 5-year return period threshold.Once developed, the impact forecasts were applied to 6 case studies of single flash flooding events across Europe chosen by the civil protection agencies, and the results presented to them. This helped evaluate the impact forecasts and enabled end users to provide feedback for further improvement. Results indicated the impact forecasts provided considerable added value compared to the hazard forecasts, by identifying targeted areas where serious impacts were observed. In the final stages of the project, the methods and products described here will be implemented in the European Flood Awareness System (EFAS) platform as a quasi-operational experimental product, and made available to the wider scientific community in the form of a Web Map Service Time (WMS-T) layer. Overall, this presentation focuses on the creation and communication of the exposure data and subsequent impact forecasts. Additionally, it outlines the evaluation of the impact forecasts, and the benefits obtained from engaging end users throughout the process. Finally, it highlights some of the challenges of using pan-European data and a continental scale forecast system to provide impact forecasts useful at the smaller scales required by decision makers.
- 28 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessBeyond hazard: Combining pan-European exposure data with flash flood hazard forecasts to create impact forecasts for civil protection agencies
As part of TAMIR, a European Commission Civil Protection Preparedness project (ID. 874435), probabilistic operational pan-European flash flood impact forecasts with lead times from 0 to 120 hours have been developed by combining flash flood hazard forecasts with exposure data. Working with civil protection agencies, the aim is to develop forecasts which clearly identify the areas most at risk of serious impacts and therefore may require their intervention. Firstly, the project engaged with these agencies to identify their requirements of flash flood impact forecasts and which elements of exposure and important to them when assessing impacts. Accordingly, pan-European exposure data for population and critical infrastructure (health, education, transport, and energy generation facilities) were sourced from several open source datasets (HARCI-EU, OSM, GHS). These exposure data were (if necessary) regridded and cropped to the spatial domain, transformed to reduce skewness, and rescaled between 1 and 2 to give the datasets common units. The five exposure types were then added together and re-scaled, to produce a combined exposure layer with values ranging from 1 (low exposure) to 2 (high exposure). Flash flood hazard forecasts were created in a previous project by blending hourly ensemble precipitation nowcasts with ensemble numerical weather predictions (NWP) from the ECMWF IFS (Integrated Forecast System). These forecasts are created once per hour and have a lead time of up to 5 days. The flash flood impact forecasts were created by combining the hazard forecasts and exposure data on a two-dimensional impact matrix. Both axes of matrix are split into 3 categories (low, medium, high). For exposure, the ranges for each category were chosen based on the distribution of the data. For hazard, the low, medium, and high categories indicate where the forecast probability shows a 5%-50%, 50%-80%, and 80%+ likelihood of exceeding the 5-year return period threshold.Once developed, the impact forecasts were applied to 6 case studies of single flash flooding events across Europe chosen by the civil protection agencies, and the results presented to them. This helped evaluate the impact forecasts and enabled end users to provide feedback for further improvement. Results indicated the impact forecasts provided considerable added value compared to the hazard forecasts, by identifying targeted areas where serious impacts were observed. In the final stages of the project, the methods and products described here will be implemented in the European Flood Awareness System (EFAS) platform as a quasi-operational experimental product, and made available to the wider scientific community in the form of a Web Map Service Time (WMS-T) layer. Overall, this presentation focuses on the creation and communication of the exposure data and subsequent impact forecasts. Additionally, it outlines the evaluation of the impact forecasts, and the benefits obtained from engaging end users throughout the process. Finally, it highlights some of the challenges of using pan-European data and a continental scale forecast system to provide impact forecasts useful at the smaller scales required by decision makers.
- Open Access
- 27 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Machine learning tools for predicting multi-hazards caused by convective storms - the TAMIR project
Convective storms and long-lasting mesoscale convective systems have the potential to cause heavy rainfall, flooding, hail, wind gusts and lightning that can result in significant damage to property and loss of lives. Accurate prediction of the location or severity of such storms (e.g. in the sub-kilometer resolution for the next hour) to assist the decision-making of civil protection authorities is beyond the capabilities of the current numerical weather prediction models. Thus, weather radar and machine learning-based methods provide an important tool to predict such events and their impacts in advance. Identifying a storm cell or system as an “object” from a radar image provides a natural way for associating different meteorological attributes of a storm with its impacts. In the TAMIR project funded by the EU Civil Protection Mechanism, we have implemented this by combining a cell tracking system with a machine learning model. The hazard levels of storms are estimated from their distance and time delay to the associated emergency reports obtained from the PRONTO database provided by the Finnish civil protection authorities. Using several meteorological attributes related to severe weather (e.g. lightning flash, hail and wind observations and indicators of convective potential), a random forest model was trained for predicting the storm hazard level. This was done by using a large sample of data during summer months between 2013-2020. The model for predicting the hazard level was verified by cross-validation. A Kalman filter-based methodology was applied for probabilistic nowcasting of future storm locations, which was combined with the model for hazard level prediction. Finally, the hazard nowcasts were combined with different exposure layers to translate them into prediction of impacts caused by convective storms. In the presentation, we demonstrate the added value of the implemented hazard and impact nowcast products with case studies. The products have also been evaluated by the Finnish civil protection authorities during the test period June-September 2021 with largely positive feedback. While the feasibility of the proposed methodology is demonstrated in Finland, discussion about its transferability to other parts of the world is also given.
- 27 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMachine learning tools for predicting multi-hazards caused by convective storms - the TAMIR project
Convective storms and long-lasting mesoscale convective systems have the potential to cause heavy rainfall, flooding, hail, wind gusts and lightning that can result in significant damage to property and loss of lives. Accurate prediction of the location or severity of such storms (e.g. in the sub-kilometer resolution for the next hour) to assist the decision-making of civil protection authorities is beyond the capabilities of the current numerical weather prediction models. Thus, weather radar and machine learning-based methods provide an important tool to predict such events and their impacts in advance. Identifying a storm cell or system as an “object” from a radar image provides a natural way for associating different meteorological attributes of a storm with its impacts. In the TAMIR project funded by the EU Civil Protection Mechanism, we have implemented this by combining a cell tracking system with a machine learning model. The hazard levels of storms are estimated from their distance and time delay to the associated emergency reports obtained from the PRONTO database provided by the Finnish civil protection authorities. Using several meteorological attributes related to severe weather (e.g. lightning flash, hail and wind observations and indicators of convective potential), a random forest model was trained for predicting the storm hazard level. This was done by using a large sample of data during summer months between 2013-2020. The model for predicting the hazard level was verified by cross-validation. A Kalman filter-based methodology was applied for probabilistic nowcasting of future storm locations, which was combined with the model for hazard level prediction. Finally, the hazard nowcasts were combined with different exposure layers to translate them into prediction of impacts caused by convective storms. In the presentation, we demonstrate the added value of the implemented hazard and impact nowcast products with case studies. The products have also been evaluated by the Finnish civil protection authorities during the test period June-September 2021 with largely positive feedback. While the feasibility of the proposed methodology is demonstrated in Finland, discussion about its transferability to other parts of the world is also given.
- Open Access
- 14 January 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2022, 1-44
Evaluating seasonal and regional distribution of snowfall in regional climate model simulations in the Arctic
In this study, we investigate how the regional climate model HIRHAM5 reproduces the spatial and temporal distribution of Arctic snowfall when compared to CloudSat satellite observations during the examined period of 2007–2010. For this purpose, both approaches, i.e. the assessment of surface snowfall rate (observation-to-model) and the radar reflectivity factor profiles (model-to-observation), are carried out considering spatial and temporal sampling differences. The HIRHAM5 model, which is constrained in its synoptic representation by nudging to ERA-Interim, represents the snowfall in the Arctic region well in comparison to CloudSat products. The spatial distribution of the snowfall patterns is similar in both identifying the southeastern coast of Greenland and the North Atlantic corridor as regions gaining more than twice as much snowfall as the Arctic average, defined here for latitudes between 66° N and 81° N. An excellent agreement (difference less than 1 %) in Arctic averaged annual snowfall rate between HIRHAM5 and CloudSat is found whereas ERA-Interim reanalysis shows an underestimation of 45 % and significant deficits in the representation of the snowfall frequency distribution. From the spatial analysis it can be seen that the largest differences in the mean annual snowfall rates are an overestimation near the coastlines of Greenland and other regions with large orographical variations, as well as an underestimation in the northern North Atlantic ocean. To a large extent, the differences can be explained by clutter contamination, blind zone or higher resolution of CloudSat measurements, but clearly HIRHAM5 overestimates the orographic-driven precipitation. The underestimation of HIRHAM5 within the North Atlantic corridor south of Svalbard is likely connected to a poor description of the marine cold air outbreaks which could be identified by separating snowfall into different circulation weather type regimes. By simulating the radar reflectivity factor profiles from HIRHAM5 utilizing the PAMTRA forward-modeling operator, the contribution of individual hydrometeor types can be assessed. Looking at a latitude band at 72–73° N, snow can be identified as the hydrometeor type dominating radar reflectivity factor values across all seasons. The largest differences between the observed and simulated reflectivity factor values are related to the contribution of cloud ice particles, which is underestimated in the model most likely due to the small size of the particles. The model-to-observation approach offers a promising diagnostic when improving cloud schemes as illustrated by comparison of different schemes available for HIRHAM5.
- 14 January 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2022, 1-44
Open AccessEvaluating seasonal and regional distribution of snowfall in regional climate model simulations in the Arctic
In this study, we investigate how the regional climate model HIRHAM5 reproduces the spatial and temporal distribution of Arctic snowfall when compared to CloudSat satellite observations during the examined period of 2007–2010. For this purpose, both approaches, i.e. the assessment of surface snowfall rate (observation-to-model) and the radar reflectivity factor profiles (model-to-observation), are carried out considering spatial and temporal sampling differences. The HIRHAM5 model, which is constrained in its synoptic representation by nudging to ERA-Interim, represents the snowfall in the Arctic region well in comparison to CloudSat products. The spatial distribution of the snowfall patterns is similar in both identifying the southeastern coast of Greenland and the North Atlantic corridor as regions gaining more than twice as much snowfall as the Arctic average, defined here for latitudes between 66° N and 81° N. An excellent agreement (difference less than 1 %) in Arctic averaged annual snowfall rate between HIRHAM5 and CloudSat is found whereas ERA-Interim reanalysis shows an underestimation of 45 % and significant deficits in the representation of the snowfall frequency distribution. From the spatial analysis it can be seen that the largest differences in the mean annual snowfall rates are an overestimation near the coastlines of Greenland and other regions with large orographical variations, as well as an underestimation in the northern North Atlantic ocean. To a large extent, the differences can be explained by clutter contamination, blind zone or higher resolution of CloudSat measurements, but clearly HIRHAM5 overestimates the orographic-driven precipitation. The underestimation of HIRHAM5 within the North Atlantic corridor south of Svalbard is likely connected to a poor description of the marine cold air outbreaks which could be identified by separating snowfall into different circulation weather type regimes. By simulating the radar reflectivity factor profiles from HIRHAM5 utilizing the PAMTRA forward-modeling operator, the contribution of individual hydrometeor types can be assessed. Looking at a latitude band at 72–73° N, snow can be identified as the hydrometeor type dominating radar reflectivity factor values across all seasons. The largest differences between the observed and simulated reflectivity factor values are related to the contribution of cloud ice particles, which is underestimated in the model most likely due to the small size of the particles. The model-to-observation approach offers a promising diagnostic when improving cloud schemes as illustrated by comparison of different schemes available for HIRHAM5.