Natalia Maloshonok
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Natalia Maloshonok has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Evgeniy Terentev
HSE University, Moscow, Russian Federation
10 shared publications - Irina Shcheglova
Academy of Future Education Xi'an Jiaotong‐Liverpool University Suzhou People's Republic of China
7 shared publications - Saule Bekova
University of Technology Sydney
7 shared publications - Kseniia A. Vilkova
HSE University
5 shared publications - Oksana Dremova
HSE University
4 shared publications - Svetlana V. Zhuchkova
National Research University Higher School of Economics (HSE)
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 July 2026
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in The Journal of Social Policy Studies
- Vol. 24 (2) , 331-352
Студенческая вовлеченность в вузах Дальнего Востока: региональные особенности и вызовы образовательной политики
Дальневосточный федеральный округ (ДВФО) сталкивается с дефицитом высококвалифицированных кадров, что актуализирует вопросы качества высшего образования и формирования человеческого капитала в регионе. Одним из инструментов оценки образовательной среды в международной практике выступает концепция студенческой вовлеченности, рассматриваемая как индикатор участия студентов в образовательных практиках, способствующих обучению и развитию. Цель статьи заключается в выявлении особенностей студенческой вовлеченности в вузах ДВФО и определении их значения для образовательной политики региона. Эмпирическую основу исследования составляют данные всероссийского опроса студентов, проведенного в 401 вузе из 81 региона России (N=16118). В анализ включены три измерения студенческой вовлеченности: вовлеченность в работу в классе, социальная вовлеченность и нарушение требований учебного процесса. Результаты показывают, что студенты ДВФО демонстрируют менее благоприятный профиль вовлеченности по сравнению с большинством других федеральных округов: они реже участвуют в образовательной и социальной активности и чаще нарушают требования учебного процесса. При этом выявлены как общие для российской системы высшего образования закономерности вовлеченности, связанные с направлением подготовки, профессиональными планами и занятостью студентов, так и специфические особенности ДВФО. К последним относятся отсутствие выраженных гендерных и социально-экономических различий в вовлеченности, более высокая вовлеченность студентов старших курсов, а также особенности вовлеченности студентов педагогических, гуманитарных направлений подготовки и обучающихся по целевому набору. Полученные результаты свидетельствуют о необходимости учитывать региональную специфику студенческой вовлеченности при разработке образовательной политики в ДВФО. Особое значение могут иметь меры, направленные на развитие образовательной среды, распространение активных образовательных практик и поддержку групп студентов, демонстрирующих повышенные риски снижения вовлеченности.
- 18 July 2026
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in The Journal of Social Policy Studies
- Vol. 24 (2) , 331-352
Open AccessСтуденческая вовлеченность в вузах Дальнего Востока: региональные особенности и вызовы образовательной политики
Дальневосточный федеральный округ (ДВФО) сталкивается с дефицитом высококвалифицированных кадров, что актуализирует вопросы качества высшего образования и формирования человеческого капитала в регионе. Одним из инструментов оценки образовательной среды в международной практике выступает концепция студенческой вовлеченности, рассматриваемая как индикатор участия студентов в образовательных практиках, способствующих обучению и развитию. Цель статьи заключается в выявлении особенностей студенческой вовлеченности в вузах ДВФО и определении их значения для образовательной политики региона. Эмпирическую основу исследования составляют данные всероссийского опроса студентов, проведенного в 401 вузе из 81 региона России (N=16118). В анализ включены три измерения студенческой вовлеченности: вовлеченность в работу в классе, социальная вовлеченность и нарушение требований учебного процесса. Результаты показывают, что студенты ДВФО демонстрируют менее благоприятный профиль вовлеченности по сравнению с большинством других федеральных округов: они реже участвуют в образовательной и социальной активности и чаще нарушают требования учебного процесса. При этом выявлены как общие для российской системы высшего образования закономерности вовлеченности, связанные с направлением подготовки, профессиональными планами и занятостью студентов, так и специфические особенности ДВФО. К последним относятся отсутствие выраженных гендерных и социально-экономических различий в вовлеченности, более высокая вовлеченность студентов старших курсов, а также особенности вовлеченности студентов педагогических, гуманитарных направлений подготовки и обучающихся по целевому набору. Полученные результаты свидетельствуют о необходимости учитывать региональную специфику студенческой вовлеченности при разработке образовательной политики в ДВФО. Особое значение могут иметь меры, направленные на развитие образовательной среды, распространение активных образовательных практик и поддержку групп студентов, демонстрирующих повышенные риски снижения вовлеченности.
- 28 March 2026
- Published by Federal Center of Theoretical and Applied Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences (FCTAS RAS) in Sociological Journal
- Vol. 32 (1) , 156-176
The Correlation Between Opportunities for Choosing Learning Courses at University and Student Engagement
The article presents the results of an empirical study aimed at exploring the relationship between providing students with the opportunity to choose academic disciplines and their engagement in the learning process. In recent decades, the flexibility of educational programs and offering students the choice of courses has become essential for shaping non-linear career trajectories and soft skills that meet the demands of the modern labor market. However research shows that in Russian higher education institutions there is a belief among faculty and administration that, when given the choice, students tend to select courses in order to reduce their workload and minimize effort to complete them. This belief hinders the increased flexibility of educational programs at universities. Based on data from a large-scale sociological survey of Russian students (N = 14 988), we examine the relationships between students’ opportunities to choose courses and four types of engagement (class engagement, extra effort, collaborative learning, and disengagement). It was found that the opportunity to choose courses related to the area of study or within a narrow specialization is statistically significantly and positively correlated with class engagement, and may also contribute to students’ extra efforts and engagement in collaborative learning practices. In contrast, the opportunity to choose courses unrelated to the field of study was significantly associated only with engagement in collaborative learning practices but showed no statistically significant effect on class engagement or extra effort. Attending elective courses was positively related to class engagement, collaborative learning and extra effort, as well as to disengagement. The findings are useful for researchers in higher education, university leaders, faculty and academic support staff involved in organizing the learning process and developing curricula in universities.
- 28 March 2026
- Published by Federal Center of Theoretical and Applied Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences (FCTAS RAS) in Sociological Journal
- Vol. 32 (1) , 156-176
The Correlation Between Opportunities for Choosing Learning Courses at University and Student Engagement
The article presents the results of an empirical study aimed at exploring the relationship between providing students with the opportunity to choose academic disciplines and their engagement in the learning process. In recent decades, the flexibility of educational programs and offering students the choice of courses has become essential for shaping non-linear career trajectories and soft skills that meet the demands of the modern labor market. However research shows that in Russian higher education institutions there is a belief among faculty and administration that, when given the choice, students tend to select courses in order to reduce their workload and minimize effort to complete them. This belief hinders the increased flexibility of educational programs at universities. Based on data from a large-scale sociological survey of Russian students (N = 14 988), we examine the relationships between students’ opportunities to choose courses and four types of engagement (class engagement, extra effort, collaborative learning, and disengagement). It was found that the opportunity to choose courses related to the area of study or within a narrow specialization is statistically significantly and positively correlated with class engagement, and may also contribute to students’ extra efforts and engagement in collaborative learning practices. In contrast, the opportunity to choose courses unrelated to the field of study was significantly associated only with engagement in collaborative learning practices but showed no statistically significant effect on class engagement or extra effort. Attending elective courses was positively related to class engagement, collaborative learning and extra effort, as well as to disengagement. The findings are useful for researchers in higher education, university leaders, faculty and academic support staff involved in organizing the learning process and developing curricula in universities.
- Open Access
- 10 January 2026
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (12) , 33-63
Perceptions of the Practices and the Experience of Securing Supplemental Funding among Doctoral Students
Insufficient financial support for doctoral students is a significant obstacle to increasing the number of on-time dissertation defenses. Many countries and universities, striving to enhance the effectiveness of their doctoral programmes, employ practices of additional funding awarded on a competitive basis to those candidates who are most likely to successfully defend high-quality dissertations on time. However, there is currently a lack of sufficient empirical research that fully assesses the effectiveness and implications of additional financial support for doctoral students. Drawing on the analysis of data from an online survey of Russian doctoral students (N = 231), this article examines the specifics of the students’ experience with the competitive application process for additional funding including both successful and unsuccessful attempts, their perceptions of the consequences of such funding, as well as the obstacles they face in securing it. The data analysis revealed that additional funding plays a significant role for doctoral students under the age of 30 who reside in university housing and are enrolled in mathematics and natural science programs. The majority of doctoral students rate the ability of such funding to resolve their financial problems and eliminate the need to seek supplementary income as low. However, they highly value the role that winning a competitive grant play in enhancing their integration into the academic community and boosting their confidence in their ability to complete their dissertation defense on time. In contrast to grants and direct monetary payments, employment for doctoral students is associated with a higher degree of integration into the academic community, greater confidence in the successful defense of their dissertation, as well as more positive assessments of their own financial well-being and their ability to focus on their dissertation research. The primary obstacles to applying for and obtaining additional funding are the insufficient amount of support, the low probability of securing it, and the lack of timely and accessible information about available funding opportunities. Informed by the findings of this study, the article’s conclusion discusses prospects for future research and outlines potential improvements to doctoral student financial support measures.
- 10 January 2026
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (12) , 33-63
Open AccessPerceptions of the Practices and the Experience of Securing Supplemental Funding among Doctoral Students
Insufficient financial support for doctoral students is a significant obstacle to increasing the number of on-time dissertation defenses. Many countries and universities, striving to enhance the effectiveness of their doctoral programmes, employ practices of additional funding awarded on a competitive basis to those candidates who are most likely to successfully defend high-quality dissertations on time. However, there is currently a lack of sufficient empirical research that fully assesses the effectiveness and implications of additional financial support for doctoral students. Drawing on the analysis of data from an online survey of Russian doctoral students (N = 231), this article examines the specifics of the students’ experience with the competitive application process for additional funding including both successful and unsuccessful attempts, their perceptions of the consequences of such funding, as well as the obstacles they face in securing it. The data analysis revealed that additional funding plays a significant role for doctoral students under the age of 30 who reside in university housing and are enrolled in mathematics and natural science programs. The majority of doctoral students rate the ability of such funding to resolve their financial problems and eliminate the need to seek supplementary income as low. However, they highly value the role that winning a competitive grant play in enhancing their integration into the academic community and boosting their confidence in their ability to complete their dissertation defense on time. In contrast to grants and direct monetary payments, employment for doctoral students is associated with a higher degree of integration into the academic community, greater confidence in the successful defense of their dissertation, as well as more positive assessments of their own financial well-being and their ability to focus on their dissertation research. The primary obstacles to applying for and obtaining additional funding are the insufficient amount of support, the low probability of securing it, and the lack of timely and accessible information about available funding opportunities. Informed by the findings of this study, the article’s conclusion discusses prospects for future research and outlines potential improvements to doctoral student financial support measures.
- 5 December 2025
- Published by Russian State Vocational Pedagogical University in The Education and science journal
- Vol. 27 (10)
The student social experience in individual versus cohort-based learning
Introduction. The introduction of programmes with individual learning pathways in Russian universities, where students study in temporary rather than permanent academic groups, emphasises the issue of their impact on students’ social experience and integration. Aim. The present study aimed to identify differences in the social integration of students in programmes with traditional cohort-based learning compared to those following an individual learning pathway. Methodology and research methods . As part of the qualitative methodology, 15 semi-structured interviews were conducted with students from both study models, followed by a thematic analysis of the transcripts. Results . The research findings demonstrated that stable groups foster the development of enduring social ties, yielding both positive effects (such as motivation through group norms) and negative effects (including pressure and conflict). In the context of individual learning pathways, the inconsistency of study groups diminishes motivation to sustain long-term relationships, thereby increasing autonomy but restricting opportunities for social integration, which adversely affects the university experience. Scientific novelty. The scientific novelty of this study lies in its shift of focus from academic to social aspects of individual learning pathways. Practical significance is in providing data to university administrators responsible for student adaptation and academic performance.
- 5 December 2025
- Published by Russian State Vocational Pedagogical University in The Education and science journal
- Vol. 27 (10)
The student social experience in individual versus cohort-based learning
Introduction. The introduction of programmes with individual learning pathways in Russian universities, where students study in temporary rather than permanent academic groups, emphasises the issue of their impact on students’ social experience and integration. Aim. The present study aimed to identify differences in the social integration of students in programmes with traditional cohort-based learning compared to those following an individual learning pathway. Methodology and research methods . As part of the qualitative methodology, 15 semi-structured interviews were conducted with students from both study models, followed by a thematic analysis of the transcripts. Results . The research findings demonstrated that stable groups foster the development of enduring social ties, yielding both positive effects (such as motivation through group norms) and negative effects (including pressure and conflict). In the context of individual learning pathways, the inconsistency of study groups diminishes motivation to sustain long-term relationships, thereby increasing autonomy but restricting opportunities for social integration, which adversely affects the university experience. Scientific novelty. The scientific novelty of this study lies in its shift of focus from academic to social aspects of individual learning pathways. Practical significance is in providing data to university administrators responsible for student adaptation and academic performance.
- Open Access
- 8 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of Higher Education
- Vol. 16 (2) , 220-245
Using Astin’s I-E-O model to explain the supervisor’s role in doctoral outcomes at a highly selective Russian university
- 8 September 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in European Journal of Higher Education
- Vol. 16 (2) , 220-245
Open AccessUsing Astin’s I-E-O model to explain the supervisor’s role in doctoral outcomes at a highly selective Russian university
- Open Access
- 31 August 2025
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (7) , 27-51
The Role of Student Behavior in the Development of Critical Thinking at the University
Critical thinking is considered to be one of the key educational outcomes, and its development is an important goal of higher education worldwide. However, the question of whether universities contribute to the development of students’ critical thinking and the extent of this contribution remains open. The aim of this study is to examine the role of students’ behavior in the development of critical thinking during their university studies. The study utilizes data from two waves of a longitudinal study conducted in eight selective Russian universities (N = 888). The results indicate that students’ critical thinking levels increased over one year of study, although the effect size is relatively small. Moreover, none of the aspects of educational behavior contribute to an increase in critical thinking levels. On the contrary, aspects such as creating a positive self-image and extracurricular involvement are negatively associated with the development of this skill. These findings may be explained by the characteristics of the educational process in Russian universities, where passive teaching practices still dominate. Based on the obtained results, the article provides several recommendations for fostering students’ critical thinking.
- 31 August 2025
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (7) , 27-51
Open AccessThe Role of Student Behavior in the Development of Critical Thinking at the University
Critical thinking is considered to be one of the key educational outcomes, and its development is an important goal of higher education worldwide. However, the question of whether universities contribute to the development of students’ critical thinking and the extent of this contribution remains open. The aim of this study is to examine the role of students’ behavior in the development of critical thinking during their university studies. The study utilizes data from two waves of a longitudinal study conducted in eight selective Russian universities (N = 888). The results indicate that students’ critical thinking levels increased over one year of study, although the effect size is relatively small. Moreover, none of the aspects of educational behavior contribute to an increase in critical thinking levels. On the contrary, aspects such as creating a positive self-image and extracurricular involvement are negatively associated with the development of this skill. These findings may be explained by the characteristics of the educational process in Russian universities, where passive teaching practices still dominate. Based on the obtained results, the article provides several recommendations for fostering students’ critical thinking.
- Open Access
- 3 July 2025
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (5) , 29-48
Do Individual Educational Trajectories Contribute to Better Student Skill Development: An Empirical Study in Russian Universities
In recent decades, an increasing number of educational programs offering students individual educational trajectories (IET) have appeared in Russian universities. It is believed that such programs better contribute to the development of students’ generic skills due to a personalized approach and providing students with wide opportunities to choose courses that match their interests. However, at this moment, there is no empirical evidence to support this thesis. In this work, based on survey data (N=1647 students) collected at seven Russian universities combining traditionally fixed-group programs with IET programs, the authors examined the relationship between students’ assessment of their universal skills development and their learning in IET programs. According to student evaluations, IET-based curricula fostered higher levels of cognitive, communicative, socioemotional and self-organization skills. These findings can be explained by the fact that such programs afford students broad opportunities for choice, which may more effectively enhance intrinsic motivation for university studying, as well as provide novel experiences distinct from those encountered in school, thereby facilitating more intensive development of the aforementioned skills. In the concluding section, we discuss recommendations for higher education institutions aimed at potentially augmenting the contribution of IET programs to students’ transferable skill development. The work is of interest to researchers in the field of higher education, university administrators, and university teachers aimed at developing student generic skills.
- 3 July 2025
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (5) , 29-48
Open AccessDo Individual Educational Trajectories Contribute to Better Student Skill Development: An Empirical Study in Russian Universities
In recent decades, an increasing number of educational programs offering students individual educational trajectories (IET) have appeared in Russian universities. It is believed that such programs better contribute to the development of students’ generic skills due to a personalized approach and providing students with wide opportunities to choose courses that match their interests. However, at this moment, there is no empirical evidence to support this thesis. In this work, based on survey data (N=1647 students) collected at seven Russian universities combining traditionally fixed-group programs with IET programs, the authors examined the relationship between students’ assessment of their universal skills development and their learning in IET programs. According to student evaluations, IET-based curricula fostered higher levels of cognitive, communicative, socioemotional and self-organization skills. These findings can be explained by the fact that such programs afford students broad opportunities for choice, which may more effectively enhance intrinsic motivation for university studying, as well as provide novel experiences distinct from those encountered in school, thereby facilitating more intensive development of the aforementioned skills. In the concluding section, we discuss recommendations for higher education institutions aimed at potentially augmenting the contribution of IET programs to students’ transferable skill development. The work is of interest to researchers in the field of higher education, university administrators, and university teachers aimed at developing student generic skills.
- 31 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Education
- Vol. 60 (3)
What Is a “Healthy” Balance Between Students' Involvement in Curricular and Extracurricular Activities? Evidence From a Highly Selective Russian University
Although many researchers and policy‐makers emphasise the benefits of extracurricular involvement, others state that intense extracurricular involvement might be harmful to students' achievements and development. This paper aims to estimate the “healthy” time proportion between curricular and extracurricular activities at university and what patterns of their combination with students' activities outside of campus can positively affect students' academic performance and mental health. Data from an undergraduate survey conducted at a highly selective Russian university and matched with administrative records about students' GPA ( N = 2753) were utilised. The study revealed that there are cut‐off points for student participation in research activities and applied projects at university, as well as volunteering and organising activities. After these cut‐off points are reached, the positive effects of extracurricular involvement disappear. The findings highlight the importance of maintaining a balance between both curricular and extracurricular activities as well as making time for sleeping, socialising and leisure activities. This study provides valuable insights into optimising student involvement in activities, offering actionable recommendations for educational policy‐makers and university administrators to increase student well‐being and academic performance.
- 31 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Education
- Vol. 60 (3)
What Is a “Healthy” Balance Between Students' Involvement in Curricular and Extracurricular Activities? Evidence From a Highly Selective Russian University
Although many researchers and policy‐makers emphasise the benefits of extracurricular involvement, others state that intense extracurricular involvement might be harmful to students' achievements and development. This paper aims to estimate the “healthy” time proportion between curricular and extracurricular activities at university and what patterns of their combination with students' activities outside of campus can positively affect students' academic performance and mental health. Data from an undergraduate survey conducted at a highly selective Russian university and matched with administrative records about students' GPA ( N = 2753) were utilised. The study revealed that there are cut‐off points for student participation in research activities and applied projects at university, as well as volunteering and organising activities. After these cut‐off points are reached, the positive effects of extracurricular involvement disappear. The findings highlight the importance of maintaining a balance between both curricular and extracurricular activities as well as making time for sleeping, socialising and leisure activities. This study provides valuable insights into optimising student involvement in activities, offering actionable recommendations for educational policy‐makers and university administrators to increase student well‐being and academic performance.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (2) , 86-107
Financial Support for Doctoral Students: Practices’ typologies and Perspectives
. Insufficient financial well-being of doctoral students is a crucial problem in doctoral education worldwide. This can result in a significant decrease in the effectiveness of doctoral programs and an increase in dropout rates. This problem is especially relevant for Russia because, on one hand, our country has extremely low completion rates. However, most doctoral students studying full-time are forced to pay work. A significant share of these students work outside the academy, and their work is not related to their dissertation research. Such work significantly distracts them from academic activities during their doctoral studies. To solve this problem, various financial support instruments for doctoral students are being developed and implemented by governments and universities. However, despite the widespread use of such instruments worldwide, no studies have attempted to systematize these instruments of financial support. The lack of such systematization limits opportunities for the implementation and replication of effective financial instruments in different national contexts. This study aims to construct the author’s typology of existing financial instruments based on a systematic review of publications dedicated to the effectiveness of financial instruments. Papers published between 1980 and 2024 were selected for review. Three main types of financial instruments were identified: 1) available to all doctoral students; 2) available to outstanding doctoral students and provided on a competitive basis; and 3) available to doctoral students from vulnerable social groups. The advantages and disadvantages of each type of instrument, their applicability to the Russian context, and the limitations of research on the effectiveness of financial support and directions for future research are discussed in the final part of the article.
- 26 February 2025
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (2) , 86-107
Open AccessFinancial Support for Doctoral Students: Practices’ typologies and Perspectives
. Insufficient financial well-being of doctoral students is a crucial problem in doctoral education worldwide. This can result in a significant decrease in the effectiveness of doctoral programs and an increase in dropout rates. This problem is especially relevant for Russia because, on one hand, our country has extremely low completion rates. However, most doctoral students studying full-time are forced to pay work. A significant share of these students work outside the academy, and their work is not related to their dissertation research. Such work significantly distracts them from academic activities during their doctoral studies. To solve this problem, various financial support instruments for doctoral students are being developed and implemented by governments and universities. However, despite the widespread use of such instruments worldwide, no studies have attempted to systematize these instruments of financial support. The lack of such systematization limits opportunities for the implementation and replication of effective financial instruments in different national contexts. This study aims to construct the author’s typology of existing financial instruments based on a systematic review of publications dedicated to the effectiveness of financial instruments. Papers published between 1980 and 2024 were selected for review. Three main types of financial instruments were identified: 1) available to all doctoral students; 2) available to outstanding doctoral students and provided on a competitive basis; and 3) available to doctoral students from vulnerable social groups. The advantages and disadvantages of each type of instrument, their applicability to the Russian context, and the limitations of research on the effectiveness of financial support and directions for future research are discussed in the final part of the article.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2025
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (1) , 106-127
Self-Regulated Learning is not for Everyone: Towards an Explanation for the Heterogeneous Effects of Interventions
The learning success of students depends largely on the extent to which they have developed self-regulated learning skills. These are expressed as a set of cognitive, behavioral, and motivational strategies that help students set learning goals, develop a sequence of actions to achieve them, control their behavior and surrounding circumstances, and reflect on the outcomes of their learning. Existing research shows that many students have difficulty completing courses that require a high degree of student autonomy (e.g., online courses). And these difficulties are due to the fact that selfregulated learning skills are weak among students. To develop these skills, special interventions are used, which take the form of lectures, assignments and comprehensive training courses. However, research shows that such interventions have a heterogeneous effect: They can lead to an increase in skills for some socio-demographic groups, while being ineffective for other groups of students. The observed heterogeneous effect of interventions has not yet been explained, which prevents the development of an effective strategy to improve self-regulated learning skills in all students. This paper attempts to explain this phenomenon using qualitative research. Interviews were conducted with students who participated in the comprehensive intervention “Self-regulated learning: how to develop self-control and metacognition”. Based on these data, a conceptual model was created that explains the differences in the effectiveness of interventions depending on the individual characteristics of the students and the characteristics of the intervention itself. The findings formed the basis for practical recommendations for the development and implementation of interventions to develop self-regulated learning skills in universities. The article will be of interest to researchers in the field of pedagogy and educational psychology, teachers and methodologists at universities, as well as managers whose activities are related to the organization of the educational process.
- 1 February 2025
- Published by Moscow Polytechnic University in Vysshee Obrazovanie v Rossii = Higher Education in Russia
- Vol. 34 (1) , 106-127
Open AccessSelf-Regulated Learning is not for Everyone: Towards an Explanation for the Heterogeneous Effects of Interventions
The learning success of students depends largely on the extent to which they have developed self-regulated learning skills. These are expressed as a set of cognitive, behavioral, and motivational strategies that help students set learning goals, develop a sequence of actions to achieve them, control their behavior and surrounding circumstances, and reflect on the outcomes of their learning. Existing research shows that many students have difficulty completing courses that require a high degree of student autonomy (e.g., online courses). And these difficulties are due to the fact that selfregulated learning skills are weak among students. To develop these skills, special interventions are used, which take the form of lectures, assignments and comprehensive training courses. However, research shows that such interventions have a heterogeneous effect: They can lead to an increase in skills for some socio-demographic groups, while being ineffective for other groups of students. The observed heterogeneous effect of interventions has not yet been explained, which prevents the development of an effective strategy to improve self-regulated learning skills in all students. This paper attempts to explain this phenomenon using qualitative research. Interviews were conducted with students who participated in the comprehensive intervention “Self-regulated learning: how to develop self-control and metacognition”. Based on these data, a conceptual model was created that explains the differences in the effectiveness of interventions depending on the individual characteristics of the students and the characteristics of the intervention itself. The findings formed the basis for practical recommendations for the development and implementation of interventions to develop self-regulated learning skills in universities. The article will be of interest to researchers in the field of pedagogy and educational psychology, teachers and methodologists at universities, as well as managers whose activities are related to the organization of the educational process.