Christopher Newdick
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Christopher Newdick has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Brian Hurwitz
1 shared publicationChristopher Danbury
Department of ICU, Royal Berkshire NHS Foundation Trust, University of Reading, Reading, Berkshire, UK Visiting Fellow in Medical Law, School of Law, University of Reading, Reading, Berkshire, UK
1 shared publication- Christopher Danbury
Royal Berkshire Hospital, Reading
1 shared publication - James Raftery
Faculty of Medicine, University of Southampton, Highfield Campus, Southampton, UK
1 shared publication - Mark Sheehan
Ethox Centre, Oxford Population Health, University of Oxford, UK
1 shared publication - Michael Dunn
Centre for Biomedical Ethics, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 24 August 2022
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 48 (10) , 678-679
Root causes of organisational failure: look up, not down
- 24 August 2022
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 48 (10) , 678-679
Root causes of organisational failure: look up, not down
- Open Access
- 7 August 2020
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 46 (10) , 646-651
Tragic choices in intensive care during the COVID-19 pandemic: on fairness, consistency and community
Tragic choices arise during the COVID-19 pandemic when the limited resources made available in acute medical settings cannot be accessed by all patients who need them. In these circumstances, healthcare rationing is unavoidable. It is important in any healthcare rationing process that the interests of the community are recognised, and that decision-making upholds these interests through a fair and consistent process of decision-making. Responding to recent calls (1) to safeguard individuals’ legal rights in decision-making in intensive care, and (2) for new authoritative national guidance for decision-making, this paper seeks to clarify what consistency and fairness demand in healthcare rationing during the COVID-19 pandemic, from both a legal and ethical standpoint. The paper begins with a brief review of UK law concerning healthcare resource allocation, considering how community interests and individual rights have been marshalled in judicial deliberation about the use of limited health resources within the National Health Service (NHS). It is then argued that an important distinction needs to be drawn between procedural and outcome consistency, and that a procedurally consistent decision-making process ought to be favoured. Congruent with the position that UK courts have adopted for resource allocation decision-making in the NHS more generally, specific requirements for a procedural framework and substantive triage criteria to be applied within that framework during the COVID-19 pandemic are considered in detail.
- 7 August 2020
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 46 (10) , 646-651
Open AccessTragic choices in intensive care during the COVID-19 pandemic: on fairness, consistency and community
Tragic choices arise during the COVID-19 pandemic when the limited resources made available in acute medical settings cannot be accessed by all patients who need them. In these circumstances, healthcare rationing is unavoidable. It is important in any healthcare rationing process that the interests of the community are recognised, and that decision-making upholds these interests through a fair and consistent process of decision-making. Responding to recent calls (1) to safeguard individuals’ legal rights in decision-making in intensive care, and (2) for new authoritative national guidance for decision-making, this paper seeks to clarify what consistency and fairness demand in healthcare rationing during the COVID-19 pandemic, from both a legal and ethical standpoint. The paper begins with a brief review of UK law concerning healthcare resource allocation, considering how community interests and individual rights have been marshalled in judicial deliberation about the use of limited health resources within the National Health Service (NHS). It is then argued that an important distinction needs to be drawn between procedural and outcome consistency, and that a procedurally consistent decision-making process ought to be favoured. Congruent with the position that UK courts have adopted for resource allocation decision-making in the NHS more generally, specific requirements for a procedural framework and substantive triage criteria to be applied within that framework during the COVID-19 pandemic are considered in detail.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2018
- Vol. 20 (1) , 107-120
Can Judges Ration with Compassion? A Priority-Setting Rights Matrix
How should courts supervise health service resource allocation? Although practice varies widely, four broad approaches can be represented on a matrix comparing, on two axes, (a) individual-community rights and (b) substantive-procedural remedies. Examples from each compartment of the matrix are discussed and, although the community-procedural approach is recommended as a general rule, a range of other responses within the matrix may also be desirable.
- 1 June 2018
- Vol. 20 (1) , 107-120
Open AccessCan Judges Ration with Compassion? A Priority-Setting Rights Matrix
How should courts supervise health service resource allocation? Although practice varies widely, four broad approaches can be represented on a matrix comparing, on two axes, (a) individual-community rights and (b) substantive-procedural remedies. Examples from each compartment of the matrix are discussed and, although the community-procedural approach is recommended as a general rule, a range of other responses within the matrix may also be desirable.
- 2 May 2017
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Health Economics, Policy and Law
- Vol. 12 (4) , 411-433
Health equality, social justice and the poverty of autonomy
How does the concept of autonomy assist public responses to ‘lifestyle’ diseases? Autonomy is fundamental to bioethics, but its emphasis on self-determination and individuality hardly supports public health policies to eat and drink less and take more exercise. Autonomy rejects a ‘nanny’ state. Yet, the cost of non-communicable diseases is increasing to individuals personally and to public health systems generally. Health care systems are under mounting and unsustainable pressure. What is the proper responsibility of individuals, governments and corporate interests working within a global trading environment? When public health care resources are unlikely to increase, we cannot afford to be so diffident to the cost of avoidable diseases.
- 2 May 2017
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Health Economics, Policy and Law
- Vol. 12 (4) , 411-433
Health equality, social justice and the poverty of autonomy
How does the concept of autonomy assist public responses to ‘lifestyle’ diseases? Autonomy is fundamental to bioethics, but its emphasis on self-determination and individuality hardly supports public health policies to eat and drink less and take more exercise. Autonomy rejects a ‘nanny’ state. Yet, the cost of non-communicable diseases is increasing to individuals personally and to public health systems generally. Health care systems are under mounting and unsustainable pressure. What is the proper responsibility of individuals, governments and corporate interests working within a global trading environment? When public health care resources are unlikely to increase, we cannot afford to be so diffident to the cost of avoidable diseases.
- 30 September 2016
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Global capitalism and the crisis of the public interest – sleepwalking into disaster
One of law’s central concerns is equality of rights, yet law is conspicuous by its absence from the debate about global inequality. Extraordinary numbers of people have inadequate access to the basic necessities of life: food, water, education, health and a decent environment. For billions of people, this is a disaster. At a time of unparalleled global affluence, when the need for sharing global wealth and opportunity is more important than ever, the gap between rich and poor is expanding. How should we explain this process? This chapter considers Karl Polanyi’s contribution to our understanding of social rights and the ways in which public interests evolved during the last century. The discussion examines how subsequent norms of global capitalism have encouraged private interests to undermine collective welfare and the consequences of the law’s failure to engage itself with the problem.
- 30 September 2016
- Published by Edward Elgar Publishing
Global capitalism and the crisis of the public interest – sleepwalking into disaster
One of law’s central concerns is equality of rights, yet law is conspicuous by its absence from the debate about global inequality. Extraordinary numbers of people have inadequate access to the basic necessities of life: food, water, education, health and a decent environment. For billions of people, this is a disaster. At a time of unparalleled global affluence, when the need for sharing global wealth and opportunity is more important than ever, the gap between rich and poor is expanding. How should we explain this process? This chapter considers Karl Polanyi’s contribution to our understanding of social rights and the ways in which public interests evolved during the last century. The discussion examines how subsequent norms of global capitalism have encouraged private interests to undermine collective welfare and the consequences of the law’s failure to engage itself with the problem.
- 1 January 2016
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 123-140
Rebalancing the Rationing Debate: Tackling the Tensions Between Individual and Community Rights
- 1 January 2016
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 123-140
Rebalancing the Rationing Debate: Tackling the Tensions Between Individual and Community Rights
- Open Access
- 1 July 2014
- Published by Elsevier in Revista Portuguesa de Saúde Pública
- Vol. 32 (2) , 151-157
Health care rights and NHS rationing: Turning theory into practice
- 1 July 2014
- Published by Elsevier in Revista Portuguesa de Saúde Pública
- Vol. 32 (2) , 151-157
Open AccessHealth care rights and NHS rationing: Turning theory into practice
- 1 June 2014
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 22 (2) , 162-179
From Hippocrates to Commodities: Three Models of NHS Governance
A series of inquiries and reports suggest considerable failings in the care provided to some patients in the NHS. Although the Bristol Inquiry report of 2001 led to the creation of many new regulatory bodies to supervise the NHS, they have never enjoyed consistent support from government and the Mid Staffordshire Inquiry in 2013 suggests they made little difference. Why do some parts of the NHS disregard patients' interests and how we should we respond to the challenge? The following discusses the evolution of approaches to NHS governance through the Hippocratic, Managerial and Commercial models, and assesses their risks and benefits. Apart from the ethical imperative, the need for effective governance is driven both by the growth in information available to the public and the resources wasted by ineffective systems of care. Appropriate solutions depend on an understanding of the perverse incentives inherent in each model and the need for greater sensitivity to the voices of patients and the public.
- 1 June 2014
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 22 (2) , 162-179
From Hippocrates to Commodities: Three Models of NHS Governance
A series of inquiries and reports suggest considerable failings in the care provided to some patients in the NHS. Although the Bristol Inquiry report of 2001 led to the creation of many new regulatory bodies to supervise the NHS, they have never enjoyed consistent support from government and the Mid Staffordshire Inquiry in 2013 suggests they made little difference. Why do some parts of the NHS disregard patients' interests and how we should we respond to the challenge? The following discusses the evolution of approaches to NHS governance through the Hippocratic, Managerial and Commercial models, and assesses their risks and benefits. Apart from the ethical imperative, the need for effective governance is driven both by the growth in information available to the public and the resources wasted by ineffective systems of care. Appropriate solutions depend on an understanding of the perverse incentives inherent in each model and the need for greater sensitivity to the voices of patients and the public.
Why there is no legal or medical justification for the Saatchi bill
More a memorial to deeply missed partner than a contribution to improving cancer care Consultation on the Medical Innovation (Saatchi) Bill attracted 18 000 responses, which are being analysed by the Department of Health.1 2 The health secretary, Jeremy Hunt, the prime minister, and several cabinet colleagues support the bill,3 which may become part of next year’s proposed legislation. Much medical opinion has been against the bill, but several eminent doctors and judges favour it. The original bill was proposed by Maurice Saatchi, whose wife died from a rare form of ovarian cancer in 2011, aged 67. He believes her death was wasted because it did not help advance scientific understanding. She does not seem to have been denied any specific treatment. Her cancer was “advanced, malignant and inoperable.” Saatchi described her radiotherapy and chemotherapy as “degrading and ineffective.”4 5 He believes that she received “standard treatment.” This is the target of the bill, which sees current law favouring it over innovative treatment. Commentary supporting the bill states: “Under present law, any deviation by a doctor from standard procedure is likely to result in a verdict of guilt …
Why there is no legal or medical justification for the Saatchi bill
More a memorial to deeply missed partner than a contribution to improving cancer care Consultation on the Medical Innovation (Saatchi) Bill attracted 18 000 responses, which are being analysed by the Department of Health.1 2 The health secretary, Jeremy Hunt, the prime minister, and several cabinet colleagues support the bill,3 which may become part of next year’s proposed legislation. Much medical opinion has been against the bill, but several eminent doctors and judges favour it. The original bill was proposed by Maurice Saatchi, whose wife died from a rare form of ovarian cancer in 2011, aged 67. He believes her death was wasted because it did not help advance scientific understanding. She does not seem to have been denied any specific treatment. Her cancer was “advanced, malignant and inoperable.” Saatchi described her radiotherapy and chemotherapy as “degrading and ineffective.”4 5 He believes that she received “standard treatment.” This is the target of the bill, which sees current law favouring it over innovative treatment. Commentary supporting the bill states: “Under present law, any deviation by a doctor from standard procedure is likely to result in a verdict of guilt …
- 28 April 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP)
- p. 107-128
Promoting Access and Equity in Health
The Right to Health at the Public/Private Divide - April 2014
- 28 April 2014
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP)
- p. 107-128
Promoting Access and Equity in Health
The Right to Health at the Public/Private Divide - April 2014