MTMallory D. Thorp

Mallory D. Thorp

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years

Research Subjects


Mallory D. Thorp has a total of 194 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The ALMaQUEST Survey

    by Alice Concas, Sara L. Ellison, Lihwai Lin, Mallory D. Thorp, Hsi-An Pan, Simone Bianchi, Edvige Corbelli, Leslie Hunt

    Aims. We investigate the relation between molecular gas and dust extinction on kiloparsec scales. Methods. We analysed 15 253 spaxels across 51 nearby galaxies with CO(1–0) measurements and optical spectroscopy from the ALMA-MaNGA QUEnching and STar formation (ALMaQUEST) survey. Dust extinction was traced by the Balmer decrement (H α /H β ), while molecular gas was traced by the CO(1–0) line intensity ( I CO ). Results. Focusing on the 12 173 spaxels classified as star-forming, we found a significant and robust correlation between H α /H β and I CO (Pearson r = 0.61, Spearman ρ = 0.59). This correlation becomes even stronger when considering deprojected quantities ( r = 0.65, ρ = 0.64), revealing a close connection between the effective V -band optical depth ( τ V ) inferred from the Balmer decrement and the molecular gas surface density (Σ mol ), derived assuming a constant CO-to-H 2 conversion factor. The observed Σ mol – τ V relation is sub-linear, deviating from the expectation for a simple foreground-screen geometry and suggesting a more complex distribution of dust, molecular gas, and emitting regions, and/or variations in the CO-to-H 2 conversion factor. Existing literature prescriptions fail to reproduce the observed distribution over the full extinction range. We parametrized this relation and derived a new empirical calibration linking Σ mol and τ V . The relation is largely independent of galaxy stellar mass, star formation rate, gas-phase metallicity, morphology, and specific star formation rate, but it shows a secondary dependence primarily on inclination, highlighting the role of geometry. The relation becomes less tight in both composite and active galactic nucleus (AGN)-dominated regions, which exhibit a substantially larger scatter than star-forming regions. Using the independent EDGE–CALIFA dataset, we show that the ALMaQUEST calibration predicts Σ mol with a scatter of ∼0.3 dex and no significant systematic offset (−0.01 dex), demonstrating its applicability to independent kiloparsec-scale datasets. Conclusions. Our calibration thus provides a practical empirical method for estimating molecular gas surface density from optical spectroscopy alone, without requiring direct CO observations.

  • Open Access

    From gas to stars along the spiral wave: CO, HCN, and star formation variations across the spiral arms in NGC 4321 and M51

    by Minou Greve, Lukas Neumann, Mallory Thorp, Dario Colombo, Frank Bigiel, Miguel Querejeta, Sharon E. Meidt, Ashley T. Barnes, Zein Bazzi, Ralf S. Klessen, et al.

    Context. Molecular clouds form stars from the interstellar medium via gravitational collapse, following a sequence from low-density gas to high-density cores and eventually the formation of stars. In classical density wave theory, gas clouds orbiting the galaxy experience gas compression and triggered star formation, while encountering the gravitational well of spiral arms. Aims. We aim to trace these different phases of the molecular cloud life cycle via tracers of molecular gas (CO), dense molecular gas (HCN), and star formation (H α , 24 μm) within the spiral arms of two grand-design spiral galaxies: NGC 4321 and M51 (NGC 5194). Methods. In the spiral arms of these galaxies, we investigate the relation between molecular gas, dense gas, and star formation (CO-HCN-SFR) at matched physical resolutions of 270 pc and 125 pc in NGC 4321 and M51, respectively. We employed spiral arm masks for these galaxies and investigate trends of HCN/CO and SFR/HCN (SFR/CO), which serve as proxies for the dense gas fraction and dense (molecular) gas star formation efficiency, perpendicular to the spiral arm spines. Results. We find that HCN/CO, SFR/CO, and SFR/HCN increase from the upstream towards the downstream side of both spiral arms of NGC 4321, while their trends are less prominent in M51. Conclusions. Our results indicate that large-scale galactic dynamics (e.g. density waves) can induce a sequence of gas density and star formation-to-gas density variations perpendicular to the spiral arms. This sequence contributes to the increased scatter seen among spectroscopic ratios such as HCN/CO and SFR/HCN at sub-kiloparsec scales.

  • Open Access

    Surveying the Whirlpool at Arcseconds with NOEMA (SWAN)

    by Mallory D. Thorp, Antonio Usero, Frank Bigiel, Ina Galić, Smita Mathur, Sophia K. Stuber, Jennifer A. Rodriguez, Dario Colombo, Bret Lehmer, Eva Schinnerer, et al.

    Context. Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) are intertwined with galaxy evolution, injecting energy into the interstellar medium (ISM) and possibly regulating star formation as a galaxy evolves. However, the phenomena through which we observe AGN are multiphase and multiscale, which can lead to conflicting results for how significantly and to what extent AGN influence the ISM. Aims. M51 is a perfect case study of the boundary between where AGN feedback and star formation feedback dominate the ISM, hosting a low-luminosity type II Seyfert nucleus with a well-defined molecular and ionized outflow. We endeavor to characterize the spatial extent and dominant modes of AGN feedback in M51 utilizing multiple phases of the ISM. Methods. Using integral field spectroscopy observations from VENGA of the central 3 kpc, we identified regions dominated by AGN ionization using an emission line ratio (ELR) function. We then combined this information with new observations of the dense molecular ISM in M51 from SWAN, including cloud-scale mapping of HCN(1–0), HNC(1–0), HCO + (1–0), and N 2 H + (1–0). Both datasets allowed us to achieve ∼180 pc resolution, allowing for a clear demarcation of where AGN feedback dominates the ISM. We then tested how the ELR compares to other tracers of AGN activity, using both millimeter emission line ratios as well as X-ray observations from Chandra to assess the dominant mode of feedback. Results. If we assume that N 2 H + (1–0) is the best tracer of dense, cold gas in SWAN, then AGN-dominated regions defined by the ELR all have greater emission in (1–0) transitions in HCN, HNC, and HCO + than would be expected if they traced dense gas alone, implying excitation of these lines from AGN feedback. The ELR is better at selecting these regions compared to molecular tracers of AGN activity, such as HCN(1–0)/HCO + (1–0), which are heightened for a greater extent in M51. Some of the highest ELR values are also associated with fast shocks evident in the optical, which are concurrent with large HNCO(4–3)/CO(1–0) values that point to slow shocks near the nucleus. The presence of shocks and heightened N 2 H + (1–0) near the nucleus indicate a potential dense molecular outflow, meaning heightened dense tracer emission could be partly due to larger abundance rather than excitation alone in this limited region. Conclusions. All tracers of AGN activity point to a “two-stage” feedback scenario, whereby mechanical feedback from the jet-ISM interaction spurs soft X-ray emission that excites molecules such as HCN. Dense gas entrenched in a molecular outflow may also lead to a greater chemical abundance of multiple tracers measured with SWAN, but to a lesser extent than excitation from AGN feedback.

  • Open Access

    PHANGS-JWST: The largest extragalactic molecular cloud catalog traced by polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon emission

    by Z. Bazzi, D. Colombo, F. Bigiel, A. K. Leroy, E. Rosolowsky, K. Sandstrom, A. Duarte-Cabral, H. Faustino Vieira, M. I. N. Kobayashi, H. He, et al.

    High-resolution JWST images of nearby spiral galaxies reveal polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) structures that potentially trace molecular clouds, even CO-dark regions. For this paper, we identified ISM cloud structures in PHANGS-JWST 7.7 μm PAH emission maps for 66 galaxies, smoothed to a common physical resolution of 30 pc and at native resolution. We extracted 108 466 cloud structures in the 30 pc sample and 146 040 clouds in the native resolution sample. We then calculated their molecular properties following a linear conversion from PAH to CO. Given the tendency for clouds in galaxy centers to overlap in velocity space, we opted to flag these clouds and omit them from the analysis in this work. The remaining clouds correspond to giant molecular clouds, such as those detected in CO(2 − 1) emission by ALMA, or lower surface density clouds that either fall below the ALMA detection limits of existing maps or genuinely have no molecular counterpart. We specifically used the homogenized sample for our analysis. Upon cross-matching the PAH clouds to the ALMA CO clouds at a homogenized resolution of 90 pc in 27 galaxies, we find that 41% of the PAH clouds are associated with a CO counterpart. We also show that the converted molecular cloud properties of the PAH clouds do not differ much when compared in different galactic environments. However, outside the central environment, the highest molecular mass surface density clouds are preferentially found in spiral arms. We further apply a lognormal fit to the mass spectra to an unprecedented extragalactic completeness limit of 2 × 10 3 M ⊙ , and find that spiral arms contain the most massive clouds compared to other galactic environments. Our findings support the idea that spiral arm gravitational potentials foster the formation of high surface density clouds, and that lower surface density clouds form in the interarm regions. The cloud Σ mol values show a decline of a factor of ∼1.5 − 2 toward the outer 2 − 3 R e . However, the trend largely varies in individual galaxies, with flat, decreasing, and even no trend as a function of R gal . Factors such as large-scale processes, galaxy types, and morphologies might influence the observed trends. We note that combining homogenized molecular properties of individual galaxies leads to the loss of information about the physical processes that are driving deviations in trends of those properties across different galactic environments. We published two catalogs at the CDS, one at the common resolution of 30 pc and another at the native resolution. We expect them to have broad utility for future studies of PAH clouds, molecular clouds, and star formation.


  • Open Access

    Surveying the Whirlpool at Arcseconds with NOEMA (SWAN)

    by I. Galić, Mallory Thorp, Frank Bigiel, Eva Schinnerer, Jakob Den Brok, Hao He, María J. Jiménez-Donaire, Lukas Neumann, Jerome Pety, Sophia K. Stuber, et al.

    Context. CO isotopologues are common tracers of the bulk molecular gas in extragalactic studies, providing insights into the physical and chemical conditions of the cold molecular gas, a reservoir for star formation. Aims. Since star formation occurs within molecular clouds, mapping CO isotopologues on the scale of clouds is important to understanding the processes driving star formation. However, achieving this mapping at such scales is challenging and time-intensive. The Surveying the Whirlpool Galaxy at Arcseconds with NOEMA (SWAN) survey addresses this by using the Institut de radioastronomie millimétrique (IRAM) NOrthern Extended Millimeter Array (NOEMA) to map the 13 CO(1−0) and C 18 O(1−0) isotopologues, alongside several dense gas tracers, in the nearby star-forming galaxy M51 at high sensitivity and spatial resolution (≈125 pc). Methods. We examine the 13 CO(1−0) to C 18 O(1−0) line emission ratio as a function of galactocentric radius and star formation rate surface density to infer how different chemical and physical processes affect this ratio at cloud scales across different galactic environments: nuclear bar, molecular ring, and northern and southern spiral arms. Results. In line with previous studies conducted at kiloparsec scales for nearby star-forming galaxies, we find a moderate positive correlation with galactocentric radius and a moderate negative correlation with star formation rate surface density across the field of view (FoV), with slight variations depending on the galactic environment. Conclusions. We propose that selective nucleosynthesis and changes in the opacity of the gas are the primary drivers of the observed variations in the ratio.


  • Open Access

    The SWAN view of dense gas in the Whirlpool

    by Sophia K. Stuber, Eva Schinnerer, Antonio Usero, Frank Bigiel, Jakob Den Brok, Jerome Pety, Lukas Neumann, María J. Jiménez-Donaire, Jiayi Sun, Miguel Querejeta, et al.

    Tracing dense molecular gas, the fuel for star formation, is essential for understanding the evolution of molecular clouds and star-formation processes. We compared the emission of HCN (1–0), HNC (1–0), and HCO+(1–0) with the emission of N2H+(1–0) at cloud scales (125 pc) across the central 5 × 7 kpc of the Whirlpool galaxy, M51a, from “Surveying the Whirlpool galaxy at Arcseconds with NOEMA” (SWAN). We find that the integrated intensities of HCN, HNC, and HCO+ are more steeply correlated with N2H+ emission compared to the bulk molecular gas tracer CO, and we find variations in this relation across the center, molecular ring, northern, and southern disk of M51. Compared to HCN and HNC emission, the HCO+ emission follows the N2H+ emission more closely across the environments and physical conditions, such as the surface densities of molecular gas, stellar mass, star-formation rate, dynamical equilibrium pressure, and radius. Under the assumption that N2H+ is a fair tracer of dense gas at these scales, this makes HCO+ a more favorable dense gas tracer than HCN within the inner disk of M51. In all environments within our field of view, even when the central 2 kpc are removed, the ratio HCN/CO, which is commonly used to trace average cloud density, is only weakly dependent on molecular gas mass surface density. While ratios of other dense gas lines to CO show a steeper dependence on the surface density of molecular gas, this relation is still shallow in comparison to other nearby star-forming disk galaxies. One reason might be physical conditions in M51, which are different from other normal star-forming galaxies. Increased ionization rates, increased dynamical equilibrium pressure in the central few kiloparsecs, and the impact of the dwarf companion galaxy NGC 5195 are proposed mechanisms that might enhance HCN and HNC emission over HCO+ and N2H+ emission at larger-scale environments and cloud scales.


  • Open Access

    Azimuthal offsets in spiral arms of nearby galaxies

    by Miguel Querejeta, Sharon E. Meidt, Yixian Cao, Dario Colombo, Eric Emsellem, Santiago García-Burillo, Ralf S. Klessen, Eric W. Koch, Adam K. Leroy, Marina Ruiz-García, et al.

    Spiral arms play a central role in disc galaxies, but their dynamical nature remains a long-standing open question. Azimuthal offsets between molecular gas and star formation are expected if gas crosses spiral arms, as predicted by quasi-stationary density wave theory. In this work, we measure offsets between CO and Hα peaks in radial bins for 24 galaxies from the PHANGS survey that display a well-delineated spiral structure. The offsets exhibit substantial scatter, implying that star formation is not exclusively initiated at a coherent spiral shock. We define offsets such that positive values mean Hα peaks lie ahead of CO peaks in the direction of galactic rotation. With this convention, 14 galaxies show mean positive CO-Hα offsets, typically of a few hundred parsecs. In four of these 14 galaxies (17% of the total), offsets become smaller with increasing radius, as expected for a single quasi-stationary spiral density wave. Ten galaxies (42%) show positive mean offsets but no clear correlation with radius, which is compatible with multiple overlapping modes. In the remaining ten galaxies (42%), we find no significantly positive offsets, which could point to transient dynamical spirals or material arms, where gas and stars co-rotate with the spiral perturbation. Across the full sample, we find mostly positive offsets between CO peaks and the gravitational potential minimum, confirming that gas often crosses the spiral perturbation. For the four galaxies with clear positive offsets and a radial trend, we derived pattern speeds in good agreement with the literature. Overall, our results suggest that even well-delineated spirals in the local Universe can arise from a variety of underlying dynamical mechanisms.


  • Open Access

    PHANGS-MeerKAT and MHONGOOSE HI observations of nearby spiral galaxies: Physical drivers of the molecular gas fraction, Rmol

    by Cosima Eibensteiner, Jiayi Sun, Frank Bigiel, Adam K. Leroy, Eva Schinnerer, Erik Rosolowsky, Sushma Kurapati, D. J. Pisano, W. J. G de Blok, Ashley T. Barnes, et al.

    The molecular-to-atomic gas ratio is crucial to our understanding of the evolution of the interstellar medium (ISM) in galaxies. We investigated the balance between the atomic (ΣHI) and molecular gas (ΣH2) surface densities in eight nearby star-forming galaxies using new high-quality observations from MeerKAT and ALMA (for H I and CO, respectively). We defined the molecular gas ratio as Rmol = ΣH2/ΣHI and measured how Rmol depends on local conditions in the galaxy disks using multiwavelength observations. We find that, depending on the galaxy, H I is detected at > 3σ out to 20 − 120 kpc in galactocentric radius (rgal). The typical radius at which ΣHI reaches 1 M⊙ pc−2 is rH I ≈ 22 kpc, which corresponds to 1 − 3 times the optical radius (r25). We note that, Rmol correlates best with the dynamical equilibrium pressure, PDE, among potential drivers studied, with a median correlation coefficient of ⟨ρ⟩ = 0.89. Correlations between Rmol and the star formation rate surface density, total gas surface density, stellar surface density, metallicity, and ΣSFR/PDE (a proxy for the combined effect of the UV radiation field and number density) are present but somewhat weaker. Our results also show a direct correlation between PDE and ΣSFR, supporting self-regulation models. Quantitatively, we measured similar scalings as previous works, and attribute the modest differences that we do find to the effect of varying resolution and sensitivity. At rgal ≳ 0.4r25, atomic gas dominates over molecular gas among our studied galaxies, and at the balance of these two gas phases (Rmol = 1), we find that the baryon mass is dominated by stars, with Σ* > 5 Σgas. Our study constitutes an important step in the statistical investigation of how local galaxy properties (stellar mass, star formation rate, or morphology) impact the conversion from atomic to molecular gas in nearby galaxies.


  • Open Access

    Are all starbursts equal? Star-formation-rate profiles in merger versus secular starbursts

    by Mallory D. Thorp, Sara L. Ellison, Ana Galicia

    Aims. Galaxy interactions can trigger drastic changes in the resolved star-forming properties of their constituents, but it remains unclear as to whether those changes are discernible from secular starburst triggers. In this Letter we investigate whether or not post-merger galaxies create unique star-forming trends on a kiloparsec scale. Methods. We present radial trends in star-formation-rate (SFR) surface density (ΣSFR) for 150 post-merger galaxies with moderate to extremely heightened global SFRs using observations from the Mapping Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory (MaNGA) survey. We juxtapose these profiles with those of noninteracting galaxies (excluding both galaxy pairs and post-merger galaxies) with similarly enhanced global SFRs. Results. Post-merger galaxies have a much stronger central starburst than isolated galaxies with similar global star-formation enhancements. Indeed, isolated starburst galaxies (SBs) lack a marked central enhancement and instead show a fairly uniform enhancement in ΣSFR with radius. Moreover, the difference in central star formation between post-merger galaxies and noninteracting galaxies is more radially extended and pronounced when the global enhancement in star formation is larger. We conclude that post-merger galaxies create a unique signature in their resolved star-forming properties that is distinct from secular processes that can trigger similar global SFR enhancements.


  • Open Access

    The ALMaQUEST Survey XI: a strong but non-linear relationship between star formation and dynamical equilibrium pressure

    by Sara L Ellison, Hsi-An Pan, Asa F L Bluck, Mark R Krumholz, Lihwai Lin, Leslie Hunt, Edvige Corbelli, Mallory D Thorp, Jorge Barrera-Ballesteros, Sebastian F Sánchez, et al.

    We present the extended ALMA MaNGA QUEnching and STar formation survey, a combination of the original 46 ALMaQUEST galaxies plus new ALMA observations for a further 20 interacting galaxies. Three well-studied scaling relations are fit to the 19,999 star-forming spaxels in the extended sample, namely the resolved Schmidt-Kennicutt (rSK) relation, the resolved star forming main sequence (rSFMS) and the resolved molecular gas main sequence (rMGMS). We additionally investigate the relationship between the dynamical equilibrium pressure (PDE) and star formation rate surface density (ΣSFR), which we refer to as the resolved PDE (rPDE) relation. Contrary to previous studies that have focussed on normal star-forming galaxies and found an approximately linear rPDE relation, the presence of more vigourously star-forming galaxies in the extended ALMaQUEST sample reveals a marked turnover in the relation at high pressures. Although the scatter around the linear fit to the rPDE relation is similar to the other three relations, a random forest analysis, which can extract non-linear dependences, finds that PDE is unambiguously more important than either |$\Sigma _{\rm H_2}$| or Σ⋆ for predicting ΣSFR. We compare the observed rPDE relation to the prediction of the pressure-regulated feedback-modulated (PRFM) model of star formation, finding that galaxies residing on the global SFMS do indeed closely follow the rPDE relation predicted by the PRFM theory. However, galaxies above and below the global SFMS show significant deviations from the model. Galaxies with high SFR are instead consistent with models that include other contributions to turbulence in addition to the local star formation feedback.