Mark Laubach
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Mark Laubach has a total of 115 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nandakumar S. Narayanan
Department of Neurology, University of Iowa, Iowa City, USA
12 shared publications - Linda M. Amarante
Department of Neuroscience, American University
10 shared publications - Samantha R. White
Department of Neuroscience, American University
7 shared publications Kyra Swanson
Department of Neuroscience, American University
6 shared publicationsEyal Y. Kimchi
C Medical Scientist Training Program, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA, 06520
4 shared publications- Kyra Swanson
Department of Neuroscience, American University, Washington
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 September 2024
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 44 (46)
The Role of the Rat Prefrontal Cortex and Sex Differences in Decision-Making
The prefrontal cortex is critical for decision-making across species, with its activity linked to choosing between options. Drift diffusion models (DDMs) are commonly employed to understand the neural computations underlying this behavior. Studies exploring the specific roles of regions of the rodent prefrontal cortex in controlling the decision process are limited. This study explored the role of the prelimbic cortex (PLC) in decision-making using a two-alternative forced-choice task. Rats first learned to report the location of a lateralized visual stimulus. The brightness of the stimulus indicated its reward value. Then, the rats learned to make choices between pairs of stimuli. Sex differences in learning were observed, with females responding faster and more selectively to high-value stimuli than males. DDM analysis found that males had decreased decision thresholds during initial learning, whereas females maintained a consistently higher drift rate. Pharmacological manipulations revealed that PLC inactivation reduced the decision threshold for all rats, indicating that less information was needed to make a choice in the absence of normal PLC processing. μ-Opioid receptor stimulation of the PLC had the opposite effect, raising the decision threshold and reducing bias in the decision process toward high-value stimuli. These effects were observed without any impact on the rats’ choice preferences. Our findings suggest that PLC has an inhibitory role in the decision process and regulates the amount of evidence that is required to make a choice. That is, PLC activity controls “when,” but not “how,” to act.
- 26 September 2024
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 44 (46)
Open AccessThe Role of the Rat Prefrontal Cortex and Sex Differences in Decision-Making
The prefrontal cortex is critical for decision-making across species, with its activity linked to choosing between options. Drift diffusion models (DDMs) are commonly employed to understand the neural computations underlying this behavior. Studies exploring the specific roles of regions of the rodent prefrontal cortex in controlling the decision process are limited. This study explored the role of the prelimbic cortex (PLC) in decision-making using a two-alternative forced-choice task. Rats first learned to report the location of a lateralized visual stimulus. The brightness of the stimulus indicated its reward value. Then, the rats learned to make choices between pairs of stimuli. Sex differences in learning were observed, with females responding faster and more selectively to high-value stimuli than males. DDM analysis found that males had decreased decision thresholds during initial learning, whereas females maintained a consistently higher drift rate. Pharmacological manipulations revealed that PLC inactivation reduced the decision threshold for all rats, indicating that less information was needed to make a choice in the absence of normal PLC processing. μ-Opioid receptor stimulation of the PLC had the opposite effect, raising the decision threshold and reducing bias in the decision process toward high-value stimuli. These effects were observed without any impact on the rats’ choice preferences. Our findings suggest that PLC has an inhibitory role in the decision process and regulates the amount of evidence that is required to make a choice. That is, PLC activity controls “when,” but not “how,” to act.
- Open Access
- 9 May 2024
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in eneuro
- Vol. 11 (5)
Learning to Choose: Behavioral Dynamics Underlying the Initial Acquisition of Decision-Making
Current theories of decision-making propose that decisions arise through competition between choice options. Computational models of the decision process estimate how quickly information about choice options is integrated and how much information is needed to trigger a choice. Experiments using this approach typically report data from well-trained participants. As such, we do not know how the decision process evolves as a decision-making task is learned for the first time. To address this gap, we used a behavioral design separating learning the value of choice options from learning to make choices. We trained male rats to respond to single visual stimuli with different reward values. Then, we trained them to make choices between pairs of stimuli. Initially, the rats responded more slowly when presented with choices. However, as they gained experience in making choices, this slowing reduced. Response slowing on choice trials persisted throughout the testing period. We found that it was specifically associated with increased exponential variability when the rats chose the higher value stimulus. Additionally, our analysis using drift diffusion modeling revealed that the rats required less information to make choices over time. These reductions in the decision threshold occurred after just a single session of choice learning. These findings provide new insights into the learning process of decision-making tasks. They suggest that the value of choice options and the ability to make choices are learned separately and that experience plays a crucial role in improving decision-making performance.
- 9 May 2024
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in eneuro
- Vol. 11 (5)
Open AccessLearning to Choose: Behavioral Dynamics Underlying the Initial Acquisition of Decision-Making
Current theories of decision-making propose that decisions arise through competition between choice options. Computational models of the decision process estimate how quickly information about choice options is integrated and how much information is needed to trigger a choice. Experiments using this approach typically report data from well-trained participants. As such, we do not know how the decision process evolves as a decision-making task is learned for the first time. To address this gap, we used a behavioral design separating learning the value of choice options from learning to make choices. We trained male rats to respond to single visual stimuli with different reward values. Then, we trained them to make choices between pairs of stimuli. Initially, the rats responded more slowly when presented with choices. However, as they gained experience in making choices, this slowing reduced. Response slowing on choice trials persisted throughout the testing period. We found that it was specifically associated with increased exponential variability when the rats chose the higher value stimulus. Additionally, our analysis using drift diffusion modeling revealed that the rats required less information to make choices over time. These reductions in the decision threshold occurred after just a single session of choice learning. These findings provide new insights into the learning process of decision-making tasks. They suggest that the value of choice options and the ability to make choices are learned separately and that experience plays a crucial role in improving decision-making performance.
- Open Access
The role of rat prelimbic cortex in decision making
The frontal cortex plays a critical role in decision-making. One specific frontal area, the anterior cingulate cortex, has been identified as crucial for setting a threshold for how much evidence is needed before a choice is made (Domenech & Dreher, 2010). Threshold is a key concept in drift diffusion models, a popular framework used to understand decision-making processes. Here, we investigated the role of the prelimbic cortex, part of the rodent cingulate cortex, in decision making. Male and female rats learned to choose between stimuli associated with high and low value rewards. Females learned faster, were more selective in their responses, and integrated information about the stimuli more quickly. By contrast, males learned more slowly and showed a decrease in their decision thresholds during choice learning. Inactivating the prelimbic cortex in female and male rats sped up decision making without affecting choice accuracy. Drift diffusion modeling found selective effects of prelimbic cortex inactivation on the decision threshold, which was reduced with increasing doses of the GABA-A agonist muscimol. Stimulating the prelimbic cortex through mu opioid receptors slowed the animals’ choice latencies and increased the decision threshold. These findings provide the first causal evidence that the prelimbic cortex directly influences decision processes. Additionally, they suggest possible sex-based differences in early choice learning.
Open AccessThe role of rat prelimbic cortex in decision making
The frontal cortex plays a critical role in decision-making. One specific frontal area, the anterior cingulate cortex, has been identified as crucial for setting a threshold for how much evidence is needed before a choice is made (Domenech & Dreher, 2010). Threshold is a key concept in drift diffusion models, a popular framework used to understand decision-making processes. Here, we investigated the role of the prelimbic cortex, part of the rodent cingulate cortex, in decision making. Male and female rats learned to choose between stimuli associated with high and low value rewards. Females learned faster, were more selective in their responses, and integrated information about the stimuli more quickly. By contrast, males learned more slowly and showed a decrease in their decision thresholds during choice learning. Inactivating the prelimbic cortex in female and male rats sped up decision making without affecting choice accuracy. Drift diffusion modeling found selective effects of prelimbic cortex inactivation on the decision threshold, which was reduced with increasing doses of the GABA-A agonist muscimol. Stimulating the prelimbic cortex through mu opioid receptors slowed the animals’ choice latencies and increased the decision threshold. These findings provide the first causal evidence that the prelimbic cortex directly influences decision processes. Additionally, they suggest possible sex-based differences in early choice learning.
- Open Access
Learning to Choose: Behavioral Dynamics Underlying the Initial Acquisition of Decision Making
Current theories of decision making propose that decisions arise through competition between choice options. Computational models of the decision process estimate how quickly information about choice options is integrated and how much information is needed to trigger a choice. Experiments using this approach typically report data from well-trained participants. As such, we do not know how the decision process evolves as a decision-making task is learned for the first time. To address this gap, we used a behavioral design separating learning the value of choice options from learning to make choices. We trained male rats to respond to single visual stimuli with different reward values. Then, we trained them to make choices between pairs of stimuli. Initially, the rats responded more slowly when presented with choices. However, as they gained experience in making choices, this slowing reduced. Response slowing on choice trials persisted throughout the testing period. We found that it was specifically associated with increased exponential variability when the rats chose the higher value stimulus. Additionally, our analysis using drift diffusion modeling revealed that the rats required less information to make choices over time. Surprisingly, we observed reductions in the decision threshold after just a single session of choice learning. These findings provide new insights into the learning process of decision-making tasks. They suggest that the value of choice options and the ability to make choices are learned separately, and that experience plays a crucial role in improving decision-making performance.
Open AccessLearning to Choose: Behavioral Dynamics Underlying the Initial Acquisition of Decision Making
Current theories of decision making propose that decisions arise through competition between choice options. Computational models of the decision process estimate how quickly information about choice options is integrated and how much information is needed to trigger a choice. Experiments using this approach typically report data from well-trained participants. As such, we do not know how the decision process evolves as a decision-making task is learned for the first time. To address this gap, we used a behavioral design separating learning the value of choice options from learning to make choices. We trained male rats to respond to single visual stimuli with different reward values. Then, we trained them to make choices between pairs of stimuli. Initially, the rats responded more slowly when presented with choices. However, as they gained experience in making choices, this slowing reduced. Response slowing on choice trials persisted throughout the testing period. We found that it was specifically associated with increased exponential variability when the rats chose the higher value stimulus. Additionally, our analysis using drift diffusion modeling revealed that the rats required less information to make choices over time. Surprisingly, we observed reductions in the decision threshold after just a single session of choice learning. These findings provide new insights into the learning process of decision-making tasks. They suggest that the value of choice options and the ability to make choices are learned separately, and that experience plays a crucial role in improving decision-making performance.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 23 March 2023
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife
- Vol. 12
Open-source tools for behavioral video analysis: Setup, methods, and best practices
Recently developed methods for video analysis, especially models for pose estimation and behavior classification, are transforming behavioral quantification to be more precise, scalable, and reproducible in fields such as neuroscience and ethology. These tools overcome long-standing limitations of manual scoring of video frames and traditional ‘center of mass’ tracking algorithms to enable video analysis at scale. The expansion of open-source tools for video acquisition and analysis has led to new experimental approaches to understand behavior. Here, we review currently available open-source tools for video analysis and discuss how to set up these methods for labs new to video recording. We also discuss best practices for developing and using video analysis methods, including community-wide standards and critical needs for the open sharing of datasets and code, more widespread comparisons of video analysis methods, and better documentation for these methods especially for new users. We encourage broader adoption and continued development of these tools, which have tremendous potential for accelerating scientific progress in understanding the brain and behavior.
- 23 March 2023
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife
- Vol. 12
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessOpen-source tools for behavioral video analysis: Setup, methods, and best practices
Recently developed methods for video analysis, especially models for pose estimation and behavior classification, are transforming behavioral quantification to be more precise, scalable, and reproducible in fields such as neuroscience and ethology. These tools overcome long-standing limitations of manual scoring of video frames and traditional ‘center of mass’ tracking algorithms to enable video analysis at scale. The expansion of open-source tools for video acquisition and analysis has led to new experimental approaches to understand behavior. Here, we review currently available open-source tools for video analysis and discuss how to set up these methods for labs new to video recording. We also discuss best practices for developing and using video analysis methods, including community-wide standards and critical needs for the open sharing of datasets and code, more widespread comparisons of video analysis methods, and better documentation for these methods especially for new users. We encourage broader adoption and continued development of these tools, which have tremendous potential for accelerating scientific progress in understanding the brain and behavior.
- Open Access
Open-Source Tools for Behavioral Video Analysis: Setup, Methods, and Development
Recently developed methods for video analysis, especially models for pose estimation and behavior classification, are transforming behavioral quantification to be more precise, scalable, and reproducible in fields such as neuroscience and ethology. These tools overcome long-standing limitations of manual scoring of video frames and traditional "center of mass" tracking algorithms to enable video analysis at scale. The expansion of open-source tools for video acquisition and analysis has led to new experimental approaches to understand behavior. Here, we review currently available open-source tools for video analysis and discuss how to set up these methods for labs new to video recording. We also discuss best practices for developing and using video analysis methods, including community-wide standards and critical needs for the open sharing of datasets and code, more widespread comparisons of video analysis methods, and better documentation for these methods especially for new users. We encourage broader adoption and continued development of these tools, which have tremendous potential for accelerating scientific progress in understanding the brain and behavior.
Open AccessOpen-Source Tools for Behavioral Video Analysis: Setup, Methods, and Development
Recently developed methods for video analysis, especially models for pose estimation and behavior classification, are transforming behavioral quantification to be more precise, scalable, and reproducible in fields such as neuroscience and ethology. These tools overcome long-standing limitations of manual scoring of video frames and traditional "center of mass" tracking algorithms to enable video analysis at scale. The expansion of open-source tools for video acquisition and analysis has led to new experimental approaches to understand behavior. Here, we review currently available open-source tools for video analysis and discuss how to set up these methods for labs new to video recording. We also discuss best practices for developing and using video analysis methods, including community-wide standards and critical needs for the open sharing of datasets and code, more widespread comparisons of video analysis methods, and better documentation for these methods especially for new users. We encourage broader adoption and continued development of these tools, which have tremendous potential for accelerating scientific progress in understanding the brain and behavior.
- 1 December 2022
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Behavioral Neuroscience
- Vol. 136 (6) , 551-560
The rostral medial frontal cortex is crucial for engagement in consummatory behavior.
The medial frontal cortex (MFC) in rodents emits rhythmic activity that is entrained to the animal's licking cycle during consumption and encodes the value of consumed fluids. These signals are especially prominent in the rostral half of the MFC. This region is located above an orbitofrontal region where mu-opioid receptors regulate intake and reversible inactivation reduces behavioral measures associated with the incentive value and palatability of liquid sucrose. Here, we examined the effects of reversible inactivation and stimulation of mu-opioid receptors in rostral MFC on behavior in an incentive contrast licking task. Adult male rats licked to receive access to liquid sucrose, which alternated between high (16%) and low (4%) values over 30 s periods. Bilateral infusion of muscimol reduced the total number of licks over the 30 min test sessions, the time spent actively consuming sucrose, and the ratio of licks for the higher and lower value fluids. Inactivation did not alter licking frequency or variability or microstructural measures such as the duration of licking bouts that are classically associated with the palatability of a liquid reward. Infusions of [d-Ala2, N-Me-Phe4, Gly5-ol]-enkephalin (DAMGO; 1 μg/μL) at the same sites had inconsistent behavioral effects across different subjects. Our findings suggest that the rostral MFC has a distinct role in the control of consummatory behavior and contributes to persistent consumption and not to the expression of palatability. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 December 2022
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Behavioral Neuroscience
- Vol. 136 (6) , 551-560
The rostral medial frontal cortex is crucial for engagement in consummatory behavior.
The medial frontal cortex (MFC) in rodents emits rhythmic activity that is entrained to the animal's licking cycle during consumption and encodes the value of consumed fluids. These signals are especially prominent in the rostral half of the MFC. This region is located above an orbitofrontal region where mu-opioid receptors regulate intake and reversible inactivation reduces behavioral measures associated with the incentive value and palatability of liquid sucrose. Here, we examined the effects of reversible inactivation and stimulation of mu-opioid receptors in rostral MFC on behavior in an incentive contrast licking task. Adult male rats licked to receive access to liquid sucrose, which alternated between high (16%) and low (4%) values over 30 s periods. Bilateral infusion of muscimol reduced the total number of licks over the 30 min test sessions, the time spent actively consuming sucrose, and the ratio of licks for the higher and lower value fluids. Inactivation did not alter licking frequency or variability or microstructural measures such as the duration of licking bouts that are classically associated with the palatability of a liquid reward. Infusions of [d-Ala2, N-Me-Phe4, Gly5-ol]-enkephalin (DAMGO; 1 μg/μL) at the same sites had inconsistent behavioral effects across different subjects. Our findings suggest that the rostral MFC has a distinct role in the control of consummatory behavior and contributes to persistent consumption and not to the expression of palatability. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
- Open Access
The rostral medial frontal cortex is crucial for engagement in consummatory behavior
The medial frontal cortex (MFC) in rodents emits rhythmic activity that is entrained to the animal’s licking cycle during consumption and encodes the value of consumed fluids (Horst and Laubach, 2013; Amarante et al., 2017; Amarante and Laubach, 2021). These signals are especially prominent in the rostral half of the MFC. This region is located above an orbitofrontal region where mu opioid receptors regulate intake (Mena et al., 2011; Castro and Berridge, 2017) and reversible inactivation reduces behavioral measures associated with the incentive value and palatability of liquid sucrose (Parent et al., 2015a). Here, we examined the effects of reversible inactivation and stimulation of mu opioid receptors in rostral MFC on behavior in an incentive contrast licking task. Adult male rats licked to receive access to liquid sucrose, which alternated between high (16%) and low (4%) values over 30 sec periods. Bilateral infusion of muscimol reduced the total number of licks emitted over the 30 min test sessions, the time spent actively consuming sucrose, and the ratio of licks for the higher and lower value fluids. Inactivation did not alter licking frequency or variability or microstructural measures such as the duration of licking bouts that are classically associated with the palatability of a liquid reward. Infusions of DAMGO (1μg/μL) at the same sites had inconsistent behavioral effects across different subjects. Our findings suggest that the rostral MFC has a distinct role in the control of consummatory behavior and contributes to peristent consumption and not to the expression of palatability. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT The medial frontal cortex (MFC) of rodents has received attention in recent years and is considered as a singular cortical region with a potential unitary function. Increasing evidence suggests that MFC is composed of distinct subregions, with unique roles in the control of behavior. The present study adds to this literature by showing unique effects of reversibly inactivating the most rostral part of the medial frontal cortex and a lack of consistent effects of stimulating mu opioid receptors in the subregion. Findings are in contrast to previous reports on the more ventral orbitofrontal cortex and caudal medial frontal cortex and are important for understanding the general role of the rodent frontal cortex and how opioids may act to control behavior.
Open AccessThe rostral medial frontal cortex is crucial for engagement in consummatory behavior
The medial frontal cortex (MFC) in rodents emits rhythmic activity that is entrained to the animal’s licking cycle during consumption and encodes the value of consumed fluids (Horst and Laubach, 2013; Amarante et al., 2017; Amarante and Laubach, 2021). These signals are especially prominent in the rostral half of the MFC. This region is located above an orbitofrontal region where mu opioid receptors regulate intake (Mena et al., 2011; Castro and Berridge, 2017) and reversible inactivation reduces behavioral measures associated with the incentive value and palatability of liquid sucrose (Parent et al., 2015a). Here, we examined the effects of reversible inactivation and stimulation of mu opioid receptors in rostral MFC on behavior in an incentive contrast licking task. Adult male rats licked to receive access to liquid sucrose, which alternated between high (16%) and low (4%) values over 30 sec periods. Bilateral infusion of muscimol reduced the total number of licks emitted over the 30 min test sessions, the time spent actively consuming sucrose, and the ratio of licks for the higher and lower value fluids. Inactivation did not alter licking frequency or variability or microstructural measures such as the duration of licking bouts that are classically associated with the palatability of a liquid reward. Infusions of DAMGO (1μg/μL) at the same sites had inconsistent behavioral effects across different subjects. Our findings suggest that the rostral MFC has a distinct role in the control of consummatory behavior and contributes to peristent consumption and not to the expression of palatability. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT The medial frontal cortex (MFC) of rodents has received attention in recent years and is considered as a singular cortical region with a potential unitary function. Increasing evidence suggests that MFC is composed of distinct subregions, with unique roles in the control of behavior. The present study adds to this literature by showing unique effects of reversibly inactivating the most rostral part of the medial frontal cortex and a lack of consistent effects of stimulating mu opioid receptors in the subregion. Findings are in contrast to previous reports on the more ventral orbitofrontal cortex and caudal medial frontal cortex and are important for understanding the general role of the rodent frontal cortex and how opioids may act to control behavior.
- 14 October 2021
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Behavioral Neuroscience
- Vol. 136 (1) , 84-99
Noradrenergic regulation of two-armed bandit performance.
Reversal learning depends on cognitive flexibility. Many reversal learning studies assess cognitive flexibility based on the number of reversals that occur over a test session. Reversals occur when an option is repeatedly chosen, e.g. eight times in a row. This design feature encourages win-stay behavior and thus makes it difficult to understand how win-stay decisions influence reversal performance. We used an alternative design, reversals over blocks of trials independent of performance, to study how perturbations of the medial orbital cortex and the noradrenergic system influence reversal learning. We found that choice accuracy varies independently of win-stay behavior and the noradrenergic system controls sensitivity to positive feedback during reversal learning.
- 14 October 2021
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Behavioral Neuroscience
- Vol. 136 (1) , 84-99
Noradrenergic regulation of two-armed bandit performance.
Reversal learning depends on cognitive flexibility. Many reversal learning studies assess cognitive flexibility based on the number of reversals that occur over a test session. Reversals occur when an option is repeatedly chosen, e.g. eight times in a row. This design feature encourages win-stay behavior and thus makes it difficult to understand how win-stay decisions influence reversal performance. We used an alternative design, reversals over blocks of trials independent of performance, to study how perturbations of the medial orbital cortex and the noradrenergic system influence reversal learning. We found that choice accuracy varies independently of win-stay behavior and the noradrenergic system controls sensitivity to positive feedback during reversal learning.
- Open Access
- 10 September 2021
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife
- Vol. 10
Coherent theta activity in the medial and orbital frontal cortices encodes reward value
This study examined how the medial frontal (MFC) and orbital frontal (OFC) cortices process reward information. We simultaneously recorded local field potentials in the two areas as rats consumed liquid sucrose rewards. Both areas exhibited a 4–8 Hz ‘theta’ rhythm that was phase-locked to the lick cycle. The rhythm tracked shifts in sucrose concentrations and fluid volumes, demonstrating that it is sensitive to differences in reward magnitude. The coupling between the rhythm and licking was stronger in MFC than OFC and varied with response vigor and absolute reward value in the MFC. Spectral analysis revealed zero-lag coherence between the cortical areas, and found evidence for a directionality of the rhythm, with MFC leading OFC. Our findings suggest that consummatory behavior generates simultaneous theta range activity in the MFC and OFC that encodes the value of consumed fluids, with the MFC having a top-down role in the control of consumption.
- 10 September 2021
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife
- Vol. 10
Open AccessCoherent theta activity in the medial and orbital frontal cortices encodes reward value
This study examined how the medial frontal (MFC) and orbital frontal (OFC) cortices process reward information. We simultaneously recorded local field potentials in the two areas as rats consumed liquid sucrose rewards. Both areas exhibited a 4–8 Hz ‘theta’ rhythm that was phase-locked to the lick cycle. The rhythm tracked shifts in sucrose concentrations and fluid volumes, demonstrating that it is sensitive to differences in reward magnitude. The coupling between the rhythm and licking was stronger in MFC than OFC and varied with response vigor and absolute reward value in the MFC. Spectral analysis revealed zero-lag coherence between the cortical areas, and found evidence for a directionality of the rhythm, with MFC leading OFC. Our findings suggest that consummatory behavior generates simultaneous theta range activity in the MFC and OFC that encodes the value of consumed fluids, with the MFC having a top-down role in the control of consumption.