Elizabeth H. Dingle
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Elizabeth H. Dingle has a total of 66 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jeremy G. Venditti
School of Environmental Science Simon Fraser University Burnaby BC Canada
10 shared publications - Hugh. D. Sinclair
School of Geosciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, EH8 9XP, UK
6 shared publications - Mikael Attal
School of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
5 shared publications - Chenge An
China Institute of Water Resources and Hydropower Research
4 shared publications - Gary Parker
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering University of Illinois at Urbana‐Champaign Urbana IL USA
4 shared publications Jeremy Venditti
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Exploring the effects of immobile sediment cover on patterns and rates of bedrock erosion
Existing mechanistic models of bedrock erosion by particle impacts describe the competing effects of sediment supply in terms of erosional ‘tools’ or alluvial ‘cover’ which incise or protect bedrock river beds, respectively (Sklar & Dietrich, 2001). An oversight of this dynamic model is that bedrock channels episodically receive inputs of very coarse sediment from hillslopes (e.g., Dini et al., 2021; Shobe et al., 2016, 2021) and from bedrock detachment (plucking) and transport associated with extreme discharges (e.g., Cook et al., 2018). These coarse, often meter scale blocks or boulders, can persist on channel beds where they may remain immobile for hundreds to thousands of years (e.g., Nativ et al., 2022) and can exceed the maximum grain size that can be transported by typical flow conditions. Our ability to predict erosion rates and patterns are currently limited by complex feedbacks between relatively immobile bed cover, bed topography and bedload transport. Here, we present initial results from a series of experiments in a 2% tilting flume (10 m x 0.4 m) with a polyurethane foam board as an erodible bedrock proxy, 60-100 mm diameter particles as immobile sediment cover, and a constant feed of 5-8 mm angular gravel to drive erosion. Experiments were conducted using variable initial bed states (e.g., smooth/rough topography) and immobile sediment coverages for a duration of 25 hours. Observations suggest that rates and patterns of bedrock erosion are remarkably sensitive to the presence of immobile sediment cover. Erosion often appears locally enhanced around immobile elements, although this is offset to some degree by the cover effect produced by bedload deposited in association with hydraulic heterogeneity generated by the immobile sediment. Self-formed and imposed bed topographies also yield different patterns of erosion, suggesting initial boundary conditions may produce distinct patterns of sediment cover and erosion.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessExploring the effects of immobile sediment cover on patterns and rates of bedrock erosion
Existing mechanistic models of bedrock erosion by particle impacts describe the competing effects of sediment supply in terms of erosional ‘tools’ or alluvial ‘cover’ which incise or protect bedrock river beds, respectively (Sklar & Dietrich, 2001). An oversight of this dynamic model is that bedrock channels episodically receive inputs of very coarse sediment from hillslopes (e.g., Dini et al., 2021; Shobe et al., 2016, 2021) and from bedrock detachment (plucking) and transport associated with extreme discharges (e.g., Cook et al., 2018). These coarse, often meter scale blocks or boulders, can persist on channel beds where they may remain immobile for hundreds to thousands of years (e.g., Nativ et al., 2022) and can exceed the maximum grain size that can be transported by typical flow conditions. Our ability to predict erosion rates and patterns are currently limited by complex feedbacks between relatively immobile bed cover, bed topography and bedload transport. Here, we present initial results from a series of experiments in a 2% tilting flume (10 m x 0.4 m) with a polyurethane foam board as an erodible bedrock proxy, 60-100 mm diameter particles as immobile sediment cover, and a constant feed of 5-8 mm angular gravel to drive erosion. Experiments were conducted using variable initial bed states (e.g., smooth/rough topography) and immobile sediment coverages for a duration of 25 hours. Observations suggest that rates and patterns of bedrock erosion are remarkably sensitive to the presence of immobile sediment cover. Erosion often appears locally enhanced around immobile elements, although this is offset to some degree by the cover effect produced by bedload deposited in association with hydraulic heterogeneity generated by the immobile sediment. Self-formed and imposed bed topographies also yield different patterns of erosion, suggesting initial boundary conditions may produce distinct patterns of sediment cover and erosion.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Carbonate bedrock channel erosion dynamics inhibit weathering effect on bedrock erodibility
The interplay of rock weathering and erosion processes controls rock erodibility throughout a bedrock channel cross-section. Existing models of these processes in bedrock river channels have been developed using observations largely from silicate lithologies, with rock erodibility increasing with height above the channel. The effects of the dissolution of soluble minerals in carbonate lithologies has been understudied. Here, we present a study of rock erodibility in two limestone bedrock channels in the North Pennines, UK. Patterns in rock erodibility were assessed using Schmidt hammer surveys conducted in 12 cross-sections and were analysed alongside calculations of bedrock inundation interval, observations of sediment transport from bedload impact plates and long-term estimates of limestone dissolution rates from environmental data and in-situ field observations. Results show that erosion via dissolution can result in similar patterns of rock erodibility observed in silicate channels where erosion outpaces weathering. Bedrock inundation interval is a key control on bedrock erodibility; where the channel margin is not regularly inundated by flow, weathering processes which weaken the rock are still present but may be locally offset by dissolution driven by soil seepage of low pH runoff which erodes weathered material. Long-term estimates of abrasion and dissolution rate are broadly equivalent at our study site further demonstrating the effectiveness of dissolution at eroding carbonate lithologies. Future studies of bedrock incision processes in carbonate landscapes should re-evaluate how mechanical erosion and dissolution are represented, and how sensitive the balance of these processes is to potential changes in inundation frequency and climate.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessCarbonate bedrock channel erosion dynamics inhibit weathering effect on bedrock erodibility
The interplay of rock weathering and erosion processes controls rock erodibility throughout a bedrock channel cross-section. Existing models of these processes in bedrock river channels have been developed using observations largely from silicate lithologies, with rock erodibility increasing with height above the channel. The effects of the dissolution of soluble minerals in carbonate lithologies has been understudied. Here, we present a study of rock erodibility in two limestone bedrock channels in the North Pennines, UK. Patterns in rock erodibility were assessed using Schmidt hammer surveys conducted in 12 cross-sections and were analysed alongside calculations of bedrock inundation interval, observations of sediment transport from bedload impact plates and long-term estimates of limestone dissolution rates from environmental data and in-situ field observations. Results show that erosion via dissolution can result in similar patterns of rock erodibility observed in silicate channels where erosion outpaces weathering. Bedrock inundation interval is a key control on bedrock erodibility; where the channel margin is not regularly inundated by flow, weathering processes which weaken the rock are still present but may be locally offset by dissolution driven by soil seepage of low pH runoff which erodes weathered material. Long-term estimates of abrasion and dissolution rate are broadly equivalent at our study site further demonstrating the effectiveness of dissolution at eroding carbonate lithologies. Future studies of bedrock incision processes in carbonate landscapes should re-evaluate how mechanical erosion and dissolution are represented, and how sensitive the balance of these processes is to potential changes in inundation frequency and climate.
- Open Access
- 12 February 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 62 (2)
Flow History Effects on River Bifurcation Dynamics in a Himalayan River
Dynamic gravel bed rivers experience frequent changes in channel position and flow distribution between branches, which can alter the location and extent of flooding. Changes in flow routing can significantly impact livelihoods, habitats and infrastructure in adjacent floodplains. Here, we test whether variations in seasonal discharge patterns cause instability in channel position and flow distribution in a gravel bed river system around a major channel bifurcation. Satellite images of the Karnali River, Nepal, were assessed over a 30‐year period to identify changes in channel position and flow partitioning downstream of the bifurcation. These observations were compared with daily discharge records to establish whether the sequencing of peak monsoonal flows coincided with geomorphic changes in the river. Changes to flow partitioning trends were consistently preceded by monsoon seasons with two large peak flows, suggesting a history‐dependent threshold in the channels. To explain this observation, we use grain‐size data from gravel bars that reveal variable grain clustering and bed armoring across the channel network. We propose that two high discharges are needed to transition between phases of bifurcation stability or instability, where the first event acts to break down the bed armor layer, allowing the second high flow to drive enlargement/closure of branches and reworking of the bed. Our findings suggest that flow sequencing is an important driver in flow distribution and stability at bifurcations in gravel bed rivers. Although the focus is on Himalayan rivers, the findings may be of relevance in other areas that experience changing seasonal flood regimes.
- 12 February 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 62 (2)
Open AccessFlow History Effects on River Bifurcation Dynamics in a Himalayan River
Dynamic gravel bed rivers experience frequent changes in channel position and flow distribution between branches, which can alter the location and extent of flooding. Changes in flow routing can significantly impact livelihoods, habitats and infrastructure in adjacent floodplains. Here, we test whether variations in seasonal discharge patterns cause instability in channel position and flow distribution in a gravel bed river system around a major channel bifurcation. Satellite images of the Karnali River, Nepal, were assessed over a 30‐year period to identify changes in channel position and flow partitioning downstream of the bifurcation. These observations were compared with daily discharge records to establish whether the sequencing of peak monsoonal flows coincided with geomorphic changes in the river. Changes to flow partitioning trends were consistently preceded by monsoon seasons with two large peak flows, suggesting a history‐dependent threshold in the channels. To explain this observation, we use grain‐size data from gravel bars that reveal variable grain clustering and bed armoring across the channel network. We propose that two high discharges are needed to transition between phases of bifurcation stability or instability, where the first event acts to break down the bed armor layer, allowing the second high flow to drive enlargement/closure of branches and reworking of the bed. Our findings suggest that flow sequencing is an important driver in flow distribution and stability at bifurcations in gravel bed rivers. Although the focus is on Himalayan rivers, the findings may be of relevance in other areas that experience changing seasonal flood regimes.
- Open Access
- 15 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth Surface Dynamics
- Vol. 12 (1) , 367-380
Dimensionless argument: a narrow grain size range near 2 mm plays a special role in river sediment transport and morphodynamics
The grain size 2 mm is the conventional border between sand and gravel. This size is used extensively, and generally without much physical justification, to discriminate between such features as sedimentary deposit type (clast-supported versus matrix-supported), river type (gravel bed versus sand bed), and sediment transport relation (gravel versus sand). Here we inquire as to whether this 2 mm boundary is simply a social construct upon which the research community has decided to agree or whether there is some underlying physics. We use dimensionless arguments to show the following for typical conditions on Earth, i.e., natural clasts (e.g., granitic or limestone) in 20 ∘C water. As grain size ranges from 1 to 5 mm (a narrow band including 2 mm), sediment suspension becomes vanishingly small at normal flood conditions in alluvial rivers. We refer to this range as pea gravel. We further show that bedload movement of a clast in the pea gravel range with, for example, a size of 4 mm moving over a bed of 0.4 mm particles has an enhanced relative mobility compared to a clast with a size of 40 mm moving over a bed of the same 4 mm particles. With this in mind, we use 2 mm here as shorthand for the narrow pea gravel range of 1–5 mm over which transport behavior is distinct from both coarser and finer material. The use of viscosity allows the delineation of a generalized dimensionless bed grain size discriminator between “sand-like” and “gravel-like” rivers. The discriminator is applicable to sediment transport on Titan (ice clasts in flowing methane/ethane liquid at reduced gravity) and Mars (mafic clasts in flowing water at reduced gravity), as well as Earth.
- 15 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth Surface Dynamics
- Vol. 12 (1) , 367-380
Open AccessDimensionless argument: a narrow grain size range near 2 mm plays a special role in river sediment transport and morphodynamics
The grain size 2 mm is the conventional border between sand and gravel. This size is used extensively, and generally without much physical justification, to discriminate between such features as sedimentary deposit type (clast-supported versus matrix-supported), river type (gravel bed versus sand bed), and sediment transport relation (gravel versus sand). Here we inquire as to whether this 2 mm boundary is simply a social construct upon which the research community has decided to agree or whether there is some underlying physics. We use dimensionless arguments to show the following for typical conditions on Earth, i.e., natural clasts (e.g., granitic or limestone) in 20 ∘C water. As grain size ranges from 1 to 5 mm (a narrow band including 2 mm), sediment suspension becomes vanishingly small at normal flood conditions in alluvial rivers. We refer to this range as pea gravel. We further show that bedload movement of a clast in the pea gravel range with, for example, a size of 4 mm moving over a bed of 0.4 mm particles has an enhanced relative mobility compared to a clast with a size of 40 mm moving over a bed of the same 4 mm particles. With this in mind, we use 2 mm here as shorthand for the narrow pea gravel range of 1–5 mm over which transport behavior is distinct from both coarser and finer material. The use of viscosity allows the delineation of a generalized dimensionless bed grain size discriminator between “sand-like” and “gravel-like” rivers. The discriminator is applicable to sediment transport on Titan (ice clasts in flowing methane/ethane liquid at reduced gravity) and Mars (mafic clasts in flowing water at reduced gravity), as well as Earth.
- Open Access
- 27 November 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 128 (11)
Experiments on Gravel‐Sand Transitions: Behavior of the Grain Size Gap Material
River bed sediments often lack fine gravel between 1 and 5 mm, a phenomenon referred to as the “grain size gap.” The gap corresponds to the rapid reduction in grain size associated with the gravel‐sand transition (GST), where median bed material grain size reduces from ∼10 mm gravel to ∼1 mm sand. Fine gravel grain sizes are often present in hillslope sediment, so it is not clear why they are absent on riverbed surfaces. We present a phenomenological laboratory experiment examining changes in sediment dynamics across a GST to examine the behavior of grain size gap material when included in the bed and feed grain size distributions. Our observations indicate that where sand falls out of washload, forming persistent surficial deposits at the GST, grain size gap material experiences enhanced mobility. This is due to hydraulic smoothing by sand that occurs because of a geometric effect, where medium sand bridges interstitial pockets in fine gravel bed surfaces. Our experiments show that gap gravel flux is enhanced by sand deposition, making gravel beds mobile at the threshold of motion. We are unable to maintain an immobile grain size gap gravel bed when sand is fed which explains why gravel beds composed of 1–5 mm particles are so rare on Earth. We hypothesize that in natural systems, grain size gap particles are either buried in the diffuse extension of GSTs or transported into coastal and marine environments where they are more commonly observed.
- 27 November 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 128 (11)
Open AccessExperiments on Gravel‐Sand Transitions: Behavior of the Grain Size Gap Material
River bed sediments often lack fine gravel between 1 and 5 mm, a phenomenon referred to as the “grain size gap.” The gap corresponds to the rapid reduction in grain size associated with the gravel‐sand transition (GST), where median bed material grain size reduces from ∼10 mm gravel to ∼1 mm sand. Fine gravel grain sizes are often present in hillslope sediment, so it is not clear why they are absent on riverbed surfaces. We present a phenomenological laboratory experiment examining changes in sediment dynamics across a GST to examine the behavior of grain size gap material when included in the bed and feed grain size distributions. Our observations indicate that where sand falls out of washload, forming persistent surficial deposits at the GST, grain size gap material experiences enhanced mobility. This is due to hydraulic smoothing by sand that occurs because of a geometric effect, where medium sand bridges interstitial pockets in fine gravel bed surfaces. Our experiments show that gap gravel flux is enhanced by sand deposition, making gravel beds mobile at the threshold of motion. We are unable to maintain an immobile grain size gap gravel bed when sand is fed which explains why gravel beds composed of 1–5 mm particles are so rare on Earth. We hypothesize that in natural systems, grain size gap particles are either buried in the diffuse extension of GSTs or transported into coastal and marine environments where they are more commonly observed.
- Open Access
- 17 October 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-19
Response to Referee Comments
The grain size 2 mm is the conventional border between sand and gravel. This size is used extensively, and generally without much physical justification, to discriminate between such features as sedimentary deposit type (clast-supported versus matrix-supported), river type (gravel-bed versus sand-bed) and sediment transport relation (gravel versus sand). Here we inquire as to whether this 2 mm boundary is simply a social construct upon which the research community has decided to agree via repetition, convergence and rearticulation, or whether there is some underlying physics. We use dimensionless arguments to show the following for typical conditions on Earth, i.e., natural clasts (e.g. granitic or limestone) in 20 °C water. As grain size ranges from 1 to 5 mm (a narrow band including 2 mm), sediment suspension becomes vanishingly small at normal flood conditions in alluvial rivers. We refer to this range as pea gravel. We further show that bedload movement of a clast in the pea gravel range, e.g. with a size of 4 mm moving over a bed of 0.4 mm particles has an enhanced relative mobility as compared to a clast with a size of 40 mm moving over a bed of the same 4 mm particles. With this in mind, we use 2 mm here as shorthand for the narrow pea gravel range of 1 – 5 mm, over which transport behaviour is distinct from both coarser and finer material. The use of viscosity allows delineation of a generalized dimensionless bed grain size discriminator between “sand-like” and “gravel-like” rivers that is applicable to sediment transport on Titan (ice clasts in flowing methane/ethane liquid at reduced gravity) and Mars (mafic clasts in flowing water at reduced gravity) as well as Earth.
- 17 October 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-19
Open AccessResponse to Referee Comments
The grain size 2 mm is the conventional border between sand and gravel. This size is used extensively, and generally without much physical justification, to discriminate between such features as sedimentary deposit type (clast-supported versus matrix-supported), river type (gravel-bed versus sand-bed) and sediment transport relation (gravel versus sand). Here we inquire as to whether this 2 mm boundary is simply a social construct upon which the research community has decided to agree via repetition, convergence and rearticulation, or whether there is some underlying physics. We use dimensionless arguments to show the following for typical conditions on Earth, i.e., natural clasts (e.g. granitic or limestone) in 20 °C water. As grain size ranges from 1 to 5 mm (a narrow band including 2 mm), sediment suspension becomes vanishingly small at normal flood conditions in alluvial rivers. We refer to this range as pea gravel. We further show that bedload movement of a clast in the pea gravel range, e.g. with a size of 4 mm moving over a bed of 0.4 mm particles has an enhanced relative mobility as compared to a clast with a size of 40 mm moving over a bed of the same 4 mm particles. With this in mind, we use 2 mm here as shorthand for the narrow pea gravel range of 1 – 5 mm, over which transport behaviour is distinct from both coarser and finer material. The use of viscosity allows delineation of a generalized dimensionless bed grain size discriminator between “sand-like” and “gravel-like” rivers that is applicable to sediment transport on Titan (ice clasts in flowing methane/ethane liquid at reduced gravity) and Mars (mafic clasts in flowing water at reduced gravity) as well as Earth.
- Open Access
- 15 September 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-19
Comment on egusphere-2023-1705
The grain size 2 mm is the conventional border between sand and gravel. This size is used extensively, and generally without much physical justification, to discriminate between such features as sedimentary deposit type (clast-supported versus matrix-supported), river type (gravel-bed versus sand-bed) and sediment transport relation (gravel versus sand). Here we inquire as to whether this 2 mm boundary is simply a social construct upon which the research community has decided to agree via repetition, convergence and rearticulation, or whether there is some underlying physics. We use dimensionless arguments to show the following for typical conditions on Earth, i.e., natural clasts (e.g. granitic or limestone) in 20 °C water. As grain size ranges from 1 to 5 mm (a narrow band including 2 mm), sediment suspension becomes vanishingly small at normal flood conditions in alluvial rivers. We refer to this range as pea gravel. We further show that bedload movement of a clast in the pea gravel range, e.g. with a size of 4 mm moving over a bed of 0.4 mm particles has an enhanced relative mobility as compared to a clast with a size of 40 mm moving over a bed of the same 4 mm particles. With this in mind, we use 2 mm here as shorthand for the narrow pea gravel range of 1 – 5 mm, over which transport behaviour is distinct from both coarser and finer material. The use of viscosity allows delineation of a generalized dimensionless bed grain size discriminator between “sand-like” and “gravel-like” rivers that is applicable to sediment transport on Titan (ice clasts in flowing methane/ethane liquid at reduced gravity) and Mars (mafic clasts in flowing water at reduced gravity) as well as Earth.
- 15 September 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2023, 1-19
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2023-1705
The grain size 2 mm is the conventional border between sand and gravel. This size is used extensively, and generally without much physical justification, to discriminate between such features as sedimentary deposit type (clast-supported versus matrix-supported), river type (gravel-bed versus sand-bed) and sediment transport relation (gravel versus sand). Here we inquire as to whether this 2 mm boundary is simply a social construct upon which the research community has decided to agree via repetition, convergence and rearticulation, or whether there is some underlying physics. We use dimensionless arguments to show the following for typical conditions on Earth, i.e., natural clasts (e.g. granitic or limestone) in 20 °C water. As grain size ranges from 1 to 5 mm (a narrow band including 2 mm), sediment suspension becomes vanishingly small at normal flood conditions in alluvial rivers. We refer to this range as pea gravel. We further show that bedload movement of a clast in the pea gravel range, e.g. with a size of 4 mm moving over a bed of 0.4 mm particles has an enhanced relative mobility as compared to a clast with a size of 40 mm moving over a bed of the same 4 mm particles. With this in mind, we use 2 mm here as shorthand for the narrow pea gravel range of 1 – 5 mm, over which transport behaviour is distinct from both coarser and finer material. The use of viscosity allows delineation of a generalized dimensionless bed grain size discriminator between “sand-like” and “gravel-like” rivers that is applicable to sediment transport on Titan (ice clasts in flowing methane/ethane liquid at reduced gravity) and Mars (mafic clasts in flowing water at reduced gravity) as well as Earth.
- Open Access
- 2 August 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2023, 1-19
Dimensionless argument: a narrow grain size range near 2 mm plays a special role in river sediment transport and morphodynamics
The grain size 2 mm is the conventional border between sand and gravel. This size is used extensively, and generally without much physical justification, to discriminate between such features as sedimentary deposit type (clast-supported versus matrix-supported), river type (gravel-bed versus sand-bed) and sediment transport relation (gravel versus sand). Here we inquire as to whether this 2 mm boundary is simply a social construct upon which the research community has decided to agree via repetition, convergence and rearticulation, or whether there is some underlying physics. We use dimensionless arguments to show the following for typical conditions on Earth, i.e., natural clasts (e.g. granitic or limestone) in 20 °C water. As grain size ranges from 1 to 5 mm (a narrow band including 2 mm), sediment suspension becomes vanishingly small at normal flood conditions in alluvial rivers. We refer to this range as pea gravel. We further show that bedload movement of a clast in the pea gravel range, e.g. with a size of 4 mm moving over a bed of 0.4 mm particles has an enhanced relative mobility as compared to a clast with a size of 40 mm moving over a bed of the same 4 mm particles. With this in mind, we use 2 mm here as shorthand for the narrow pea gravel range of 1 – 5 mm, over which transport behaviour is distinct from both coarser and finer material. The use of viscosity allows delineation of a generalized dimensionless bed grain size discriminator between “sand-like” and “gravel-like” rivers that is applicable to sediment transport on Titan (ice clasts in flowing methane/ethane liquid at reduced gravity) and Mars (mafic clasts in flowing water at reduced gravity) as well as Earth.
- 2 August 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2023, 1-19
Open AccessDimensionless argument: a narrow grain size range near 2 mm plays a special role in river sediment transport and morphodynamics
The grain size 2 mm is the conventional border between sand and gravel. This size is used extensively, and generally without much physical justification, to discriminate between such features as sedimentary deposit type (clast-supported versus matrix-supported), river type (gravel-bed versus sand-bed) and sediment transport relation (gravel versus sand). Here we inquire as to whether this 2 mm boundary is simply a social construct upon which the research community has decided to agree via repetition, convergence and rearticulation, or whether there is some underlying physics. We use dimensionless arguments to show the following for typical conditions on Earth, i.e., natural clasts (e.g. granitic or limestone) in 20 °C water. As grain size ranges from 1 to 5 mm (a narrow band including 2 mm), sediment suspension becomes vanishingly small at normal flood conditions in alluvial rivers. We refer to this range as pea gravel. We further show that bedload movement of a clast in the pea gravel range, e.g. with a size of 4 mm moving over a bed of 0.4 mm particles has an enhanced relative mobility as compared to a clast with a size of 40 mm moving over a bed of the same 4 mm particles. With this in mind, we use 2 mm here as shorthand for the narrow pea gravel range of 1 – 5 mm, over which transport behaviour is distinct from both coarser and finer material. The use of viscosity allows delineation of a generalized dimensionless bed grain size discriminator between “sand-like” and “gravel-like” rivers that is applicable to sediment transport on Titan (ice clasts in flowing methane/ethane liquid at reduced gravity) and Mars (mafic clasts in flowing water at reduced gravity) as well as Earth.
- Open Access
- 25 July 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 128 (7)
Experiments on Gravel‐Sand Transitions: Examination of Washload Deposition
An abrupt transition in bed grain size occurs in river systems. Over a short downstream distance, often only a few channel widths, the bed surface fines from gravel (∼10 mm) to sand (∼1 mm). This is the gravel‐sand transition (GST), and it is the only abrupt downstream reduction in grain size within fluvial systems. There are several theories for the origin of the GST, including size‐selective deposition of bimodal grain size distributions and the rapid onset of washload deposition due to changes in particle suspension properties at shear velocities of ∼0.1 m/s. Here, we present a laboratory experiment examining changes in fluid and sediment dynamics across a GST. We developed a stable gravel bed reach that was just below the threshold of motion, then fed sand. We observed sand carried as washload in the gravel reach fall out of suspension, forming a sand bed and a stable GST. Shear velocity was 0.09–0.10 m/s upstream of the GST and <0.10 m/s downstream, consistent with the washload deposition hypothesis. We were then able to perturb the position of the GST by systematically varying discharge and/or sand supply, shifting it downstream with an increase in discharge or a reduction in sediment supply. A decrease in discharge or increase in sand supply caused upstream migration. Our observations support an abrupt change in washload transport conditions across a narrow range of shear velocities, consistent with the washload deposition theory and measurements taken across GSTs in natural river systems.
- 25 July 2023
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface
- Vol. 128 (7)
Open AccessExperiments on Gravel‐Sand Transitions: Examination of Washload Deposition
An abrupt transition in bed grain size occurs in river systems. Over a short downstream distance, often only a few channel widths, the bed surface fines from gravel (∼10 mm) to sand (∼1 mm). This is the gravel‐sand transition (GST), and it is the only abrupt downstream reduction in grain size within fluvial systems. There are several theories for the origin of the GST, including size‐selective deposition of bimodal grain size distributions and the rapid onset of washload deposition due to changes in particle suspension properties at shear velocities of ∼0.1 m/s. Here, we present a laboratory experiment examining changes in fluid and sediment dynamics across a GST. We developed a stable gravel bed reach that was just below the threshold of motion, then fed sand. We observed sand carried as washload in the gravel reach fall out of suspension, forming a sand bed and a stable GST. Shear velocity was 0.09–0.10 m/s upstream of the GST and <0.10 m/s downstream, consistent with the washload deposition hypothesis. We were then able to perturb the position of the GST by systematically varying discharge and/or sand supply, shifting it downstream with an increase in discharge or a reduction in sediment supply. A decrease in discharge or increase in sand supply caused upstream migration. Our observations support an abrupt change in washload transport conditions across a narrow range of shear velocities, consistent with the washload deposition theory and measurements taken across GSTs in natural river systems.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Experiments on the grain size gap in river bed sediments
Riverbed sediments often lack fine gravel between 1 and 5 mm, a phenomenon referred to as the ‘grain size gap’. The gap corresponds to the rapid reduction in grain size associated with the gravel-sand transition, where median bed material grain size reduces from ~10 mm gravel to ~1 mm sand. Fine gravel grain sizes are often present in hillslope sediment, so it is not clear why they are absent on riverbed surfaces. We present a phenomenological laboratory experiment examining changes in sediment dynamics across a gravel-sand transition to explore the fate of grain size gap material. Our observations indicate that where sand falls out of washload, forming persistent surficial deposits at the gravel-sand transition, grain size gap material experiences enhanced mobility. This is due to hydraulic smoothing by sand that occurs because of a geometric effect, where medium sand bridges interstitial pockets in fine gravel bed surfaces. Our experiments show that fine gravel flux is enhanced by sand deposition making gravel beds at the threshold of motion, mobile. We are unable to maintain an immobile fine gravel bed when sand is fed, which explains why gravel beds composed of 1 to 5 mm particles are so rare on Earth. Our experiment shows that fine gravel particles mobilized by sand deposition are transported out of the flume. We hypothesize that in natural systems, fine gravel particles are either buried in the diffuse extension of gravel-sand transitions or transported into coastal and marine environments where they are more commonly observed.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessExperiments on the grain size gap in river bed sediments
Riverbed sediments often lack fine gravel between 1 and 5 mm, a phenomenon referred to as the ‘grain size gap’. The gap corresponds to the rapid reduction in grain size associated with the gravel-sand transition, where median bed material grain size reduces from ~10 mm gravel to ~1 mm sand. Fine gravel grain sizes are often present in hillslope sediment, so it is not clear why they are absent on riverbed surfaces. We present a phenomenological laboratory experiment examining changes in sediment dynamics across a gravel-sand transition to explore the fate of grain size gap material. Our observations indicate that where sand falls out of washload, forming persistent surficial deposits at the gravel-sand transition, grain size gap material experiences enhanced mobility. This is due to hydraulic smoothing by sand that occurs because of a geometric effect, where medium sand bridges interstitial pockets in fine gravel bed surfaces. Our experiments show that fine gravel flux is enhanced by sand deposition making gravel beds at the threshold of motion, mobile. We are unable to maintain an immobile fine gravel bed when sand is fed, which explains why gravel beds composed of 1 to 5 mm particles are so rare on Earth. Our experiment shows that fine gravel particles mobilized by sand deposition are transported out of the flume. We hypothesize that in natural systems, fine gravel particles are either buried in the diffuse extension of gravel-sand transitions or transported into coastal and marine environments where they are more commonly observed.