Miguel Mascarenhas
Research Subjects
Miguel Mascarenhas has a total of 263 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Carlos Fonseca
CESAM and Department of Biology, University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal
8 shared publications - Joana Bernardino
University of Porto
8 shared publications Hugo Costa
5 shared publications- Maria João Ramos Pereira
Programa de Pós-Graduação em Biologia Animal, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Brazil
4 shared publications - Ana Teresa Marques
CIBIO, Centro de Investigação em Biodiversidade e Recursos Genéticos, InBIO Laboratório Associado, Campus de Vairão, Universidade do Porto, Vairão, Portugal
3 shared publications - Gonçalo Ferrão da Costa
CESAM and Department of Biology, University of Aveiro Aveiro Portugal
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (6)
Making the most of hard‐won data: Incorporating commonly discarded information from unidentifiable samples improves precision and cost‐effectiveness in wolf population monitoring
Standard spatial capture–recapture (SCR) models routinely discard a large fraction of non‐invasive genetic detections that fail genotyping, wasting costly field effort and undermining the precision of population estimates. In environmental impact assessments (EIA), where conclusions must withstand regulatory scrutiny under fixed monitoring budgets, this data loss is a problem that can be solved. We applied the random‐thinning SCR framework (RT‐SCR) to a three‐year Iberian wolf ( Canis lupus signatus ) EIA monitoring programme in northern Portugal. We treat genotyping failure as a stochastic thinning process within a multisession Bayesian model with covariates on density and detection. Of 173 confirmed wolf scats, 56 (32%) lacked individual identity, and rather than discarding them, we analysed them alongside 117 identified samples. We benchmarked RT‐SCR against standard SCR, evaluated model fit using posterior predictive checks and used simulation to test whether gains generalised beyond this specific dataset. Incorporating unidentified detections improved precision for the habitat effect on density (15% CV improvement), estimates of space use (8% CV improvement) and detection parameter (up to 5% CV improvement). Wolves had stable year‐to‐year density (2.89–5.07 wolves/100 km 2 ). Simulations showed that RT‐SCR yielded consistent precision gains and restored near‐nominal coverage for detection parameters, whereas excluding unidentified samples produced overconfident credible intervals under standard SCR (0.920 vs. 0.505; nominal 0.89). Posterior predictive checks found no strong evidence of systematic lack of fit, even for a pack‐living species. Synthesis and applications . RT‐SCR provides a principled and cost‐effective way to recover information from samples that are usually discarded, improving both precision and the reliability of parameter estimates without extra field or laboratory investment. Gains were strongest for shared ecological parameters, including detection, space use and habitat associations, and are expected to be even greater where genotyping success is lower. This makes the framework especially valuable for EIA and other conservation monitoring programmes where every hard‐won sample matters.
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (6)
Open AccessMaking the most of hard‐won data: Incorporating commonly discarded information from unidentifiable samples improves precision and cost‐effectiveness in wolf population monitoring
Standard spatial capture–recapture (SCR) models routinely discard a large fraction of non‐invasive genetic detections that fail genotyping, wasting costly field effort and undermining the precision of population estimates. In environmental impact assessments (EIA), where conclusions must withstand regulatory scrutiny under fixed monitoring budgets, this data loss is a problem that can be solved. We applied the random‐thinning SCR framework (RT‐SCR) to a three‐year Iberian wolf ( Canis lupus signatus ) EIA monitoring programme in northern Portugal. We treat genotyping failure as a stochastic thinning process within a multisession Bayesian model with covariates on density and detection. Of 173 confirmed wolf scats, 56 (32%) lacked individual identity, and rather than discarding them, we analysed them alongside 117 identified samples. We benchmarked RT‐SCR against standard SCR, evaluated model fit using posterior predictive checks and used simulation to test whether gains generalised beyond this specific dataset. Incorporating unidentified detections improved precision for the habitat effect on density (15% CV improvement), estimates of space use (8% CV improvement) and detection parameter (up to 5% CV improvement). Wolves had stable year‐to‐year density (2.89–5.07 wolves/100 km 2 ). Simulations showed that RT‐SCR yielded consistent precision gains and restored near‐nominal coverage for detection parameters, whereas excluding unidentified samples produced overconfident credible intervals under standard SCR (0.920 vs. 0.505; nominal 0.89). Posterior predictive checks found no strong evidence of systematic lack of fit, even for a pack‐living species. Synthesis and applications . RT‐SCR provides a principled and cost‐effective way to recover information from samples that are usually discarded, improving both precision and the reliability of parameter estimates without extra field or laboratory investment. Gains were strongest for shared ecological parameters, including detection, space use and habitat associations, and are expected to be even greater where genotyping success is lower. This makes the framework especially valuable for EIA and other conservation monitoring programmes where every hard‐won sample matters.
- Open Access
- 18 June 2024
- Published by Wiley in Wildlife Biology
- Vol. 2024 (6) , e01230
Environmental impact assessment for large carnivores: a methodological review of the wolf Canis lupus monitoring in Portugal
The continuous growth of the global human population results in increased use and change of landscapes, with infrastructures like transportation or energy facilities being a particular risk to large carnivores. Environmental impact assessments were established to identify the probable environmental consequences of any new proposed project, find ways to reduce impacts, and provide evidence to inform decision making and mitigation. Portugal has a wolf population of approximately 300 individuals, designated as an endangered species with full legal protection. They occupy the northern mountainous areas of the country which has also been the focus of new human infrastructures over the last 20 years. Consequently, dozens of wolf monitoring programs have been established to evaluate wolf population status, to identify impacts, and to inform appropriate mitigation or compensation measures. We reviewed Portuguese wolf monitoring programs to answer four key questions. Do wolf programs examine adequate biological parameters to meet monitoring objectives? Is the study design suitable for measuring impacts? Are data collection methods and effort sufficient for the stated inference objectives? Do statistical analyses of the data lead to robust conclusions? Overall, we found a mismatch between the stated aims of wolf monitoring and the results reported, and often neither aligns with the existing national wolf monitoring guidelines. Despite the vast effort expended and the diversity of methods used, data analysis makes almost exclusive use of relative indices or summary statistics, with little consideration of the potential biases that arise through the (imperfect) observational process. This makes comparisons of impacts across space and time difficult and is therefore unlikely to contribute to a general understanding of wolf responses to infrastructure‐related disturbance. We recommend the development of standardized monitoring protocols and advocate for the use of statistical methods that account for imperfect detection to guarantee accuracy, reproducibility, and efficacy of the programs.
- 18 June 2024
- Published by Wiley in Wildlife Biology
- Vol. 2024 (6) , e01230
Open AccessEnvironmental impact assessment for large carnivores: a methodological review of the wolf Canis lupus monitoring in Portugal
The continuous growth of the global human population results in increased use and change of landscapes, with infrastructures like transportation or energy facilities being a particular risk to large carnivores. Environmental impact assessments were established to identify the probable environmental consequences of any new proposed project, find ways to reduce impacts, and provide evidence to inform decision making and mitigation. Portugal has a wolf population of approximately 300 individuals, designated as an endangered species with full legal protection. They occupy the northern mountainous areas of the country which has also been the focus of new human infrastructures over the last 20 years. Consequently, dozens of wolf monitoring programs have been established to evaluate wolf population status, to identify impacts, and to inform appropriate mitigation or compensation measures. We reviewed Portuguese wolf monitoring programs to answer four key questions. Do wolf programs examine adequate biological parameters to meet monitoring objectives? Is the study design suitable for measuring impacts? Are data collection methods and effort sufficient for the stated inference objectives? Do statistical analyses of the data lead to robust conclusions? Overall, we found a mismatch between the stated aims of wolf monitoring and the results reported, and often neither aligns with the existing national wolf monitoring guidelines. Despite the vast effort expended and the diversity of methods used, data analysis makes almost exclusive use of relative indices or summary statistics, with little consideration of the potential biases that arise through the (imperfect) observational process. This makes comparisons of impacts across space and time difficult and is therefore unlikely to contribute to a general understanding of wolf responses to infrastructure‐related disturbance. We recommend the development of standardized monitoring protocols and advocate for the use of statistical methods that account for imperfect detection to guarantee accuracy, reproducibility, and efficacy of the programs.
- Open Access
- 7 April 2022
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 12 (4) , e8811
Individual variability in space use near power lines by a long‐lived territorial raptor
Evaluating species responses to anthropogenic infrastructures and other habitat changes is often used to assess environmental impacts and to guide conservation actions. However, such studies are generally carried out at the population level, disregarding inter‐individual variability. Here, we investigate population‐ and individual‐level responses toward power lines of a territorial raptor, the Bonelli's eagle Aquila fasciata. We used GPS‐PTT tracking data of 17 adult eagles to model space use as a function of distance to transmission and distribution lines, while accounting for other habitat features known to affect this species. At population level, eagles increased the intensity of space use in the proximity of power lines (up to 1,000 m), suggesting an attraction effect. At individual level, some eagles shared the general population attraction pattern, while others showed reduced intensity of space use in the proximity of power lines. These differential responses were unrelated to the sex of individuals, but were affected by the characteristics of the power grid, with a tendency for apparent attraction to be associated with individuals occupying home ranges with a denser network of transmission lines and transmission pylons. However, the study could not rule out the operation of other potentially influential factors, such as individual idiosyncrasies, the spatial distribution of prey availability, and the availability of natural perches and nesting sites. Overall, these results suggest that power lines may drive different behaviors and have differential impacts across individuals, with those attracted to the proximity of power lines potentially facing increased risk of mortality through electrocution and collision, and those avoiding power lines being potentially subject to exclusion effects. More generally, our results reinforce the need to understand individual variability when assessing and mitigating impacts of anthropogenic infrastructures.
- 7 April 2022
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 12 (4) , e8811
Open AccessIndividual variability in space use near power lines by a long‐lived territorial raptor
Evaluating species responses to anthropogenic infrastructures and other habitat changes is often used to assess environmental impacts and to guide conservation actions. However, such studies are generally carried out at the population level, disregarding inter‐individual variability. Here, we investigate population‐ and individual‐level responses toward power lines of a territorial raptor, the Bonelli's eagle Aquila fasciata. We used GPS‐PTT tracking data of 17 adult eagles to model space use as a function of distance to transmission and distribution lines, while accounting for other habitat features known to affect this species. At population level, eagles increased the intensity of space use in the proximity of power lines (up to 1,000 m), suggesting an attraction effect. At individual level, some eagles shared the general population attraction pattern, while others showed reduced intensity of space use in the proximity of power lines. These differential responses were unrelated to the sex of individuals, but were affected by the characteristics of the power grid, with a tendency for apparent attraction to be associated with individuals occupying home ranges with a denser network of transmission lines and transmission pylons. However, the study could not rule out the operation of other potentially influential factors, such as individual idiosyncrasies, the spatial distribution of prey availability, and the availability of natural perches and nesting sites. Overall, these results suggest that power lines may drive different behaviors and have differential impacts across individuals, with those attracted to the proximity of power lines potentially facing increased risk of mortality through electrocution and collision, and those avoiding power lines being potentially subject to exclusion effects. More generally, our results reinforce the need to understand individual variability when assessing and mitigating impacts of anthropogenic infrastructures.
- Open Access
MAMMALS IN PORTUGAL: A data set of terrestrial, volant, and marine mammal occurrences in Portugal
Mammals are threatened worldwide, with ~26% of all species being included in the IUCN threatened categories. This overall pattern is primarily associated with habitat loss or degradation, and human persecution for terrestrial mammals, and pollution, open net fishing, climate change, and prey depletion for marine mammals. Mammals play a key role in maintaining ecosystems functionality and resilience, and therefore information on their distribution is crucial to delineate and support conservation actions. MAMMALS IN PORTUGAL is a publicly available data set compiling unpublished georeferenced occurrence records of 92 terrestrial, volant, and marine mammals in mainland Portugal and archipelagos of the Azores and Madeira that includes 105,026 data entries between 1873 and 2021 (72% of the data occurring in 2000 and 2021). The methods used to collect the data were: live observations/captures (43%), sign surveys (35%), camera trapping (16%), bioacoustics surveys (4%) and radiotracking, and inquiries that represent less than 1% of the records. The data set includes 13 types of records: (1) burrows | soil mounds | tunnel, (2) capture, (3) colony, (4) dead animal | hair | skulls | jaws, (5) genetic confirmation, (6) inquiries, (7) observation of live animal (8), observation in shelters, (9) photo trapping | video, (10) predators diet | pellets | pine cones/nuts, (11) scat | track | ditch, (12) telemetry and (13) vocalization | echolocation. The spatial uncertainty of most records ranges between 0 and 100 m (76%). Rodentia (n =31,573) has the highest number of records followed by Chiroptera (n = 18,857), Carnivora (n = 18,594), Lagomorpha (n = 17,496), Cetartiodactyla (n = 11,568) and Eulipotyphla (n = 7008). The data set includes records of species classified by the IUCN as threatened (e.g., Oryctolagus cuniculus [n = 12,159], Monachus monachus [n = 1,512], and Lynx pardinus [n = 197]). We believe that this data set may stimulate the publication of other European countries data sets that would certainly contribute to ecology and conservation‐related research, and therefore assisting on the development of more accurate and tailored conservation management strategies for each species. There are no copyright restrictions; please cite this data paper when the data are used in publications.
Open AccessMAMMALS IN PORTUGAL: A data set of terrestrial, volant, and marine mammal occurrences in Portugal
Mammals are threatened worldwide, with ~26% of all species being included in the IUCN threatened categories. This overall pattern is primarily associated with habitat loss or degradation, and human persecution for terrestrial mammals, and pollution, open net fishing, climate change, and prey depletion for marine mammals. Mammals play a key role in maintaining ecosystems functionality and resilience, and therefore information on their distribution is crucial to delineate and support conservation actions. MAMMALS IN PORTUGAL is a publicly available data set compiling unpublished georeferenced occurrence records of 92 terrestrial, volant, and marine mammals in mainland Portugal and archipelagos of the Azores and Madeira that includes 105,026 data entries between 1873 and 2021 (72% of the data occurring in 2000 and 2021). The methods used to collect the data were: live observations/captures (43%), sign surveys (35%), camera trapping (16%), bioacoustics surveys (4%) and radiotracking, and inquiries that represent less than 1% of the records. The data set includes 13 types of records: (1) burrows | soil mounds | tunnel, (2) capture, (3) colony, (4) dead animal | hair | skulls | jaws, (5) genetic confirmation, (6) inquiries, (7) observation of live animal (8), observation in shelters, (9) photo trapping | video, (10) predators diet | pellets | pine cones/nuts, (11) scat | track | ditch, (12) telemetry and (13) vocalization | echolocation. The spatial uncertainty of most records ranges between 0 and 100 m (76%). Rodentia (n =31,573) has the highest number of records followed by Chiroptera (n = 18,857), Carnivora (n = 18,594), Lagomorpha (n = 17,496), Cetartiodactyla (n = 11,568) and Eulipotyphla (n = 7008). The data set includes records of species classified by the IUCN as threatened (e.g., Oryctolagus cuniculus [n = 12,159], Monachus monachus [n = 1,512], and Lynx pardinus [n = 197]). We believe that this data set may stimulate the publication of other European countries data sets that would certainly contribute to ecology and conservation‐related research, and therefore assisting on the development of more accurate and tailored conservation management strategies for each species. There are no copyright restrictions; please cite this data paper when the data are used in publications.
- 26 March 2019
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 165-177
Camera-Trapping Versus Conventional Methodology in the Assessment of Carcass Persistence for Fatality Estimation at Wind Farms
- 26 March 2019
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 165-177
Camera-Trapping Versus Conventional Methodology in the Assessment of Carcass Persistence for Fatality Estimation at Wind Farms
Classification success of six machine learning algorithms in radar ornithology
Radar systems have been increasingly used to monitor birds. To take full advantage of the large datasets provided by radars, researchers have implemented machine learning (ML) techniques that automatically read and attempt to classify targets. Here we used data collected from two locations in Portugal with two marine radar antennas (VSR and HSR) to apply and compare the performance of six ML algorithms that are widely used in the literature: random forests (RF), support vector machine (SVM), artificial neural networks (NN), linear discriminant analysis (LDA), quadratic discriminant analysis (QDA) and decision trees (DT), all trained with several dataset configurations. We found that all algorithms performed well (area under the receiver operating characteristic (AUC) and accuracy > 0.80, P < 0.001) when discriminating birds from non‐biological targets such as vehicles, rain or wind turbines, but greater variance in the performance among algorithms was apparent when separating different bird functional groups or bird species (e.g. herons vs. gulls). In our case study, only RF was able to hold an accuracy > 0.80 for all classification tasks, although SVM and DT also performed well. Further, all algorithms correctly classified 86% and 66% (VSR and HSR) of the target points, and only 2% and 4% of these points were misclassified by all algorithms. Our results suggest that ML algorithms are suitable for classifying radar targets as birds, and thereby separating them from other non‐biological targets. The ability of these algorithms to correctly identify among bird species functional groups was found to be much weaker, but if properly trained and supported by a good ground truthing dataset, targeted to the relevant species groups, some of these algorithms are still able to achieve high accuracies in classification tasks. Such results indicate that ML algorithms are suitable for use in near real‐time monitoring of bird movements, and may help to mitigate collision of birds with, for example, wind turbines or airplanes.
Classification success of six machine learning algorithms in radar ornithology
Radar systems have been increasingly used to monitor birds. To take full advantage of the large datasets provided by radars, researchers have implemented machine learning (ML) techniques that automatically read and attempt to classify targets. Here we used data collected from two locations in Portugal with two marine radar antennas (VSR and HSR) to apply and compare the performance of six ML algorithms that are widely used in the literature: random forests (RF), support vector machine (SVM), artificial neural networks (NN), linear discriminant analysis (LDA), quadratic discriminant analysis (QDA) and decision trees (DT), all trained with several dataset configurations. We found that all algorithms performed well (area under the receiver operating characteristic (AUC) and accuracy > 0.80, P < 0.001) when discriminating birds from non‐biological targets such as vehicles, rain or wind turbines, but greater variance in the performance among algorithms was apparent when separating different bird functional groups or bird species (e.g. herons vs. gulls). In our case study, only RF was able to hold an accuracy > 0.80 for all classification tasks, although SVM and DT also performed well. Further, all algorithms correctly classified 86% and 66% (VSR and HSR) of the target points, and only 2% and 4% of these points were misclassified by all algorithms. Our results suggest that ML algorithms are suitable for classifying radar targets as birds, and thereby separating them from other non‐biological targets. The ability of these algorithms to correctly identify among bird species functional groups was found to be much weaker, but if properly trained and supported by a good ground truthing dataset, targeted to the relevant species groups, some of these algorithms are still able to achieve high accuracies in classification tasks. Such results indicate that ML algorithms are suitable for use in near real‐time monitoring of bird movements, and may help to mitigate collision of birds with, for example, wind turbines or airplanes.
- 14 April 2015
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Wildlife Research
- Vol. 41 (8) , 717-725
Camera-trapping as a methodology to assess the persistence of wildlife carcasses resulting from collisions with human-made structures
Context: To assess the real impact of human-made structures on bird and bat communities, a significant number of carcass-removal trials has been performed worldwide in recent decades. Recently, researchers have started to use camera traps to record carcasses exact removal time and better understand the factors that influence this event. Aims: In our study, we endeavoured to identify the factors that significantly affect carcass-persistence time, such as (1) season, (2) scavenger guild, (3) type of carcass, (4) habitat and (5) weather conditions. Additionally, we aimed to assess the performance of camera-trapping technology in comparison to the conventional method typically used in carcass-removal trials. Methods: We conducted two trials in two wind farms during early spring and during summer season. In each trial, we used 30 bird carcasses and 30 mice carcasses as surrogates for bats. Digital infrared camera traps were used to monitor each carcass. Chi-squared test was used to investigate differences between wind farms regarding the scavenger guild. A log-rank test was used to compare carcass-persistence times for both wind farms. Carcass-persistence times were analysed using both non-parametric and parametric survival models. Finally, we evaluated the percentage of carcasses removed during the day time and night time. Key results: In our study area, carcass-persistence times were influenced by the scavenger guild present and by the exposure to rain. Camera traps allowed to record the exact removal time for the majority of the carcasses, reducing the number of visits to the study site about five times. However, there were also cases wherein loss of data occurred as a result of equipment flaws or camera theft. Conclusions: Results demonstrated the importance of undertaking site-specific carcass-removal trials. Use of camera-trap methodology is a valid option, reducing displacement costs. Costs related to equipment purchase and the risk of camera theft should be taken into consideration. Implications: When choosing camera-trapping, the main aspect to evaluate is the balance between the investment in equipment purchase and the cost savings through reduced displacement costs. Further studies are required concerning the real effects of the data collected on the accuracy of carcass-removal correction factor obtained.
- 14 April 2015
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Wildlife Research
- Vol. 41 (8) , 717-725
Camera-trapping as a methodology to assess the persistence of wildlife carcasses resulting from collisions with human-made structures
Context: To assess the real impact of human-made structures on bird and bat communities, a significant number of carcass-removal trials has been performed worldwide in recent decades. Recently, researchers have started to use camera traps to record carcasses exact removal time and better understand the factors that influence this event. Aims: In our study, we endeavoured to identify the factors that significantly affect carcass-persistence time, such as (1) season, (2) scavenger guild, (3) type of carcass, (4) habitat and (5) weather conditions. Additionally, we aimed to assess the performance of camera-trapping technology in comparison to the conventional method typically used in carcass-removal trials. Methods: We conducted two trials in two wind farms during early spring and during summer season. In each trial, we used 30 bird carcasses and 30 mice carcasses as surrogates for bats. Digital infrared camera traps were used to monitor each carcass. Chi-squared test was used to investigate differences between wind farms regarding the scavenger guild. A log-rank test was used to compare carcass-persistence times for both wind farms. Carcass-persistence times were analysed using both non-parametric and parametric survival models. Finally, we evaluated the percentage of carcasses removed during the day time and night time. Key results: In our study area, carcass-persistence times were influenced by the scavenger guild present and by the exposure to rain. Camera traps allowed to record the exact removal time for the majority of the carcasses, reducing the number of visits to the study site about five times. However, there were also cases wherein loss of data occurred as a result of equipment flaws or camera theft. Conclusions: Results demonstrated the importance of undertaking site-specific carcass-removal trials. Use of camera-trap methodology is a valid option, reducing displacement costs. Costs related to equipment purchase and the risk of camera theft should be taken into consideration. Implications: When choosing camera-trapping, the main aspect to evaluate is the balance between the investment in equipment purchase and the cost savings through reduced displacement costs. Further studies are required concerning the real effects of the data collected on the accuracy of carcass-removal correction factor obtained.
- 1 February 2015
- Published by Elsevier in Environmental Impact Assessment Review
- Vol. 51, 10-22
How to mitigate impacts of wind farms on bats? A review of potential conservation measures in the European context
- 1 February 2015
- Published by Elsevier in Environmental Impact Assessment Review
- Vol. 51, 10-22
How to mitigate impacts of wind farms on bats? A review of potential conservation measures in the European context
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 November 2014
- Published by Elsevier in Biological Conservation
- Vol. 179, 40-52
Understanding bird collisions at wind farms: An updated review on the causes and possible mitigation strategies
- 1 November 2014
- Published by Elsevier in Biological Conservation
- Vol. 179, 40-52
Top Cited PapersUnderstanding bird collisions at wind farms: An updated review on the causes and possible mitigation strategies
- 27 February 2013
- Published by Wiley in New Zealand Journal of Zoology
- Vol. 40 (1) , 63-74
Estimating bird and bat fatality at wind farms: a practical overview of estimators, their assumptions and limitations
Over the last few years, great efforts have been made to improve the methodologies used to assess bird and bat fatalities at wind farms. For that purpose, several mortality estimators have been proposed. In general, these estimators account for: 1) partial coverage; 2) carcass removal (e.g. by scavengers or decay); and 3) imperfect detection. Perhaps surprisingly, a universal estimator that ensures good quality estimates under general circumstances is still lacking. Further, the existing estimators include different adjustment approaches and a variety of often implicit and misunderstood assumptions that may not be valid, making it difficult for practitioners to choose between them. Focusing on bird and bat fatality at onshore wind farms, we summarise and discuss implementation aspects and the assumptions involved in seven commonly used estimators. This should provide researchers requiring these methods with a basis to choose the most appropriate estimator under a given set of conditions, and contribute to increased standards in wind farm wildlife fatality estimation.
- 27 February 2013
- Published by Wiley in New Zealand Journal of Zoology
- Vol. 40 (1) , 63-74
Estimating bird and bat fatality at wind farms: a practical overview of estimators, their assumptions and limitations
Over the last few years, great efforts have been made to improve the methodologies used to assess bird and bat fatalities at wind farms. For that purpose, several mortality estimators have been proposed. In general, these estimators account for: 1) partial coverage; 2) carcass removal (e.g. by scavengers or decay); and 3) imperfect detection. Perhaps surprisingly, a universal estimator that ensures good quality estimates under general circumstances is still lacking. Further, the existing estimators include different adjustment approaches and a variety of often implicit and misunderstood assumptions that may not be valid, making it difficult for practitioners to choose between them. Focusing on bird and bat fatality at onshore wind farms, we summarise and discuss implementation aspects and the assumptions involved in seven commonly used estimators. This should provide researchers requiring these methods with a basis to choose the most appropriate estimator under a given set of conditions, and contribute to increased standards in wind farm wildlife fatality estimation.