CMChristopher A. Mebane

Christopher A. Mebane

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Christopher A. Mebane has a total of 140 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Fate and effects to the benthic community of a copper treatment to eradicate invasive mussels in a large western river, USA

    by Austin K Baldwin, Erin M Murray, Lauren M Zinsser, Tyler V King, Scott D Ducar, India Southern, Theresa A Thom, Christopher A Mebane

    Copper-based chemical treatments are commonly used to eradicate invasive mussels in small ponds and lakes, but their use in large rivers has been limited. In 2023, in response to a detection of invasive quagga mussels, a 10-km reach of the Snake River (Idaho, USA), was treated with an unprecedented 19,300 kg of chelated copper molluscicide to a target concentration of 1,000 µg/L for 10 days. We assessed the transport and fate of the copper and its exposure and effects on the nontarget benthic community downstream. Water samples were collected at seven locations throughout the treatment period, and sediment, periphyton, and benthic macroinvertebrates were collected pre- and posttreatment. Nearly half of the original mass of copper was removed from the water column via sedimentation, sorption to algae, or biological uptake within the 10-km treatment reach and the first 15 km downstream. Even so, dissolved copper concentrations exceeded the acute toxicity threshold at least as far as 28 km downstream for more than 2 weeks. Sediment copper increased by up to 8.3-fold, exceeding the consensus-based sediment quality threshold effect concentration at several sites. Effects on benthic macroinvertebrates varied by taxa. From 0–28 km downstream, invertebrate abundances decreased 52%–94%, with gastropods among the most affected. Of the unique taxa present at these sites pretreatment, 52%–64% were not found posttreatment but were replaced by other taxa, indicating a reorganization of the base of the food web. Additionally, from 0–15 km downstream, the percentage of individuals from tolerant taxa increased two to15-fold. Findings from this study can help watershed managers plan future invasive mussel responses while protecting culturally, economically, and ecologically important nontarget species in large rivers.


  • Open Access

    Bioaccumulation and trophic transfer of selenium in a large oligotrophic river

    by Christopher A Mebane, A Robin Stewart, Erin M Murray, Terry M Short, Veronika A Kocen, Lauren M Zinsser

    In flowing waters with elevated selenium concentrations, fish are often considered to be at risk from selenium toxicity owing to dietary exposure and accumulation in ovarian tissues and subsequent deformities in developing larvae. We studied selenium throughout components of the aquatic food webs at geomorphically distinct locations along the oligotrophic Kootenai River (Montana and Idaho, USA), a river with moderately elevated dissolved selenium concentrations (∼ 1 µg/L). Components included water, sediment, freshly accrued biofilms, in-situ periphyton, sestonic detritus, aquatic invertebrates, and fish, with spring and fall sampling. Selenium concentrations were similar among the sediment, biofilm, periphyton, and detritus samples. Among the aquatic invertebrates, the highest selenium concentrations were observed in Paraleptophlebia sp. mayflies and oligochaetes. No consistent concentration patterns with season or feeding traits were observed. Fish tissue selenium concentrations were highly variable among species and tissue type. Selenium in fish tissues tended to be highest in livers of rainbow trout and mountain whitefish relative to ovarian, muscle, and carcass tissues. With northern pikeminnow, redside shiner, and slimy sculpin, selenium concentrations tended to be highest in ovarian tissues. The trophic transfer factors of selenium from particulates to invertebrates and fish was higher in the lotic sites than in the lentic site. The results question the validity of the lotic/lentic risk paradigm for selenium beyond the small stream versus wetland/pond settings from which the paradigm was developed. Potential alternative monitoring approaches are illustrated using aquatic invertebrates or using the food web monitoring results to derive monitoring targets for selenium in water or invertebrate tissue that could avoid the need to kill fish to assess whether fish protection guidelines are met.


  • Is double-blind peer review detrimental to scientific integrity? Author’s reply

    by Christopher A Mebane

    To the Editor: I previously made six arguments on how double-blind peer review procedures can be a vulnerability for bad or fraudulent science slipping into environmental sciences journals and argued instead for more transparent and open alternative approaches ( Mebane, 2025). Eltaybani (2025) writes with cautions on these arguments, some of which I share. However, to me, the relative risks of implicit bias creeping into article acceptance decisions versus publishing questionable or outright fraudulent articles are not similar. The former is a concern that editors need to be cognizant of and the latter is an existential threat to the scientific credibility of environmental science publishing. In just the months since submitting my article ( Mebane, 2025), two major journals in the field of environmental chemistry and toxicology have been delisted from Clarivate’s Web of Science database (Chemosphere and Environmental Science and Pollution Research) owing to publishing excessive questionable or fraudulent articles. A third major journal, Science of the Total Environment, has had the indexing of their content in the Web of Science database placed on hold. These are serious, lasting hits to the reputation of journals that also can reflect on its editors and the thousands of legitimate authors who have published in their pages. And while mulling my response to Dr. Eltaybani, the journal Environmental Toxicology announced multiple retractions for publishing fraudulent materials ( Orrall, 2025), There but for fortune go society journals such as Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (ET&C).

  • Open Access

    Double-blind peer review is detrimental to scientific integrity

    by Christopher A Mebane

    I make six arguments for why double-blind peer review practices increase vulnerability to scientific integrity lapses over more transparent peer review practices: (1) obscuring data from reviewers is detrimental; (2) obscuring sponsorship makes bias harder to detect; (3) author networks can be revealing; (4) undue trust and responsibility are placed on editors; (5) double-blind reviews are not really all that blind; and (6) willful blindness is not the answer to prestige bias. I offer an alternative approach that could provide a more transparent approach for improving scientific integrity and equity in publishing.


  • Open Access

    Double-blind peer review is detrimental to scientific integrity

    by Christopher Mebane

    I make six arguments for why double-blind peer review practices increase vulnerability to scientific integrity lapses over more transparent peer review practices: 1) Obscuring data from reviewers is detrimental; 2) Obscuring sponsorship makes bias harder to detect; 3) Author networks can be revealing; 4) Undue trust and responsibility are placed upon editors; 5) Double-blind reviews aren’t really all that blind; and 6) Willful blindness is not the answer to prestige bias. I offer an alternative approach that could provide a more transparent approach for ensuring scientific integrity and equity in publishing.

  • Open Access

    Bioavailability and Toxicity Models of Copper to Freshwater Life: The State of Regulatory Science

    by Christopher A. Mebane

    Efforts to incorporate bioavailability adjustments into regulatory water quality criteria in the United States have included four major procedures: hardness-based single-linear regression equations, water-effect ratios (WERs), biotic ligand models (BLMs), and multiple-linear regression models (MLRs) that use dissolved organic carbon, hardness, and pH. The performance of each with copper (Cu) is evaluated, emphasizing the relative performance of hardness-based versus MLR-based criteria equations. The WER approach was shown to be inherently highly biased. The hardness-based model is in widest use, and the MLR approach is the US Environmental Protection Agency's (USEPA's) present recommended approach for developing aquatic life criteria for metals. The performance of criteria versions was evaluated with numerous toxicity datasets that were independent of those used to develop the MLR models, including olfactory and behavioral toxicity, and field and ecosystem studies. Within the range of water conditions used to develop the Cu MLR criteria equations, the MLR performed well in terms of predicting toxicity and protecting sensitive species and ecosystems. In soft waters, the MLR outperformed both the BLM and hardness models. In atypical waters with pH 9, neither the MLR nor BLM predictions were reliable, suggesting that site-specific testing would be needed to determine reliable Cu criteria for such settings. The hardness-based criteria performed poorly with all toxicity datasets, showing no or weak ability to predict observed toxicity. In natural waters, MLR and BLM criteria versions were strongly correlated. In contrast, the hardness-criteria version was often out of phase with the MLR and, depending on waterbody and season, could be either strongly overprotective or underprotective. The MLR-based USEPA-style chronic criterion appears to be more generally protective of ecosystems than other models. Environ Toxicol Chem 2023;42:2529–2563. © 2023 The Authors. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of SETAC.


  • Open Access

    Bioavailability and toxicity models of copper and zinc to freshwater life: the state of the science and alternatives for water quality criteria

    by Christopher Mebane

    The importance of water conditions on the bioavailability and toxicity of metals has long been recognized. In the United States and elsewhere, regulatory criteria to protect aquatic life have likewise acknowledged factors that modify bioavailability, and incorporated water hardness-toxicity regressions into criteria for several metals. Biotic ligand models (BLMs) became a dominant paradigm in predicting the aquatic toxicology of metals as mechanistic functions of modeled metals speciation and cation competition for binding to ionoregulatory sites on the gill or biotic ligand surface, disrupting the internal mineral balance of organisms and leading to stress or death. Following development of software that efficiently executed BLM calculations, in 2007 the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) published national recommended aquatic life criteria for copper (Cu) that was based upon the BLM construct and software. However, there has not been widespread adoption by states of the USEPA’s recommended BLM-based aquatic life criteria into their water quality standards. Reasons for the languishing of the BLM-based Cu criteria presumably include that the BLM-based Cu criteria are far more complex than any previous aquatic life criteria and that the BLM requires much more data than water hardness to calculate the criteria. pH, dissolved organic carbon (DOC), a suite of major ions, alkalinity, and specialized software are required to calculate BLM-based criteria. The purpose of the present study is to compare the leading available aquatic life criteria models for predicting Cu and zinc (Zn) toxicity (or lack of toxicity) to diverse freshwater species and ecosystems: 1) the single linear regression hardness models; 2) Multiple Linear Regression (MLR) models that predict toxicity as a function of DOC, hardness, and pH, and 3) BLM-based criteria. The scope of the review for Zn was truncated relative to that of Cu because no generally applicable MLR model for Zn was available at the time of writing.The comparisons included evaluating the performance of the models for predicting Cu toxicity and the models’ behavior in natural waters. The evaluations of toxicity predictions were limited to freshwater animals and included testing model predictions against literature reports of observed acute and chronic responses with trout, other fish, mussels and other invertebrates, and olfactory impairment or avoidance responses in salmonids. The presumed “safe” criteria concentrations were also compared against effects attributed to Cu in field studies or ecosystem experiments. The comparisons emphasize natural waters in California, however conditions in California waters are diverse and the comparisons are broadly relevant to other freshwaters.The results were consistent with previous work that found that the MLR toxicity predictions were generally more reliable than the BLM for predicting Cu toxicity across the vast majority of natural water types, but that the BLM predictions were more reliable in situations with low or high pH (less than about 5.7 or greater than about 9) or in waters with unusual ionic composition. However, both the MLR and BLM performed well with many datasets and aquatic life criteria calculation procedures both produced criteria concentrations that mostly appeared safe in comparisons with field and ecosystem studies and with particularly sensitive species and endpoints such as chemoreception and avoidance behaviors in salmonids. In marked contrast, the hardness-regression model toxicity predictions performed poorly with all datasets tested, with little correspondences between predicted and observed effects. The comparisons of the hardness-criteria concentrations with Cu effects thresholds estimated from field and ecosystem studies showed that the hardness-based criteria failed to reliably produce protective concentrations. In soft waters with less than about 40 mg/L hardness, the hardness-based criteria would be protective but not at higher hardnesses. In natural waters, the hardness criteria had little correlation to the MLR, which was the most accurate proxy for truly toxic or nontoxic conditions, and in some steams, the hardness-based criteria actually had negative correlations with the MLR criteria.Th performance and protectiveness of the Cu MLR and BLM models and criteria were largely similar. However, the Cu MLR has advantages for adoption into water quality standards over the BLM because of its reduced data requirements, simpler form, ease of calculation, transparency, and non-dependence on specialized computer software. The Cu MLR could be structured in tiers to accommodate missing data by setting conservative default values for pH or DOC, for example, pH 7 and 1 mg/L DOC. Then, only if environmental Cu concentrations exceeded criteria as calculated with default values would actual DOC and pH data be needed.


  • The Capacity of Freshwater Ecosystems to Recover from Exceedences of Aquatic Life Criteria

    by Christopher A. Mebane

    In the United States, national chemical water quality criteria for the protection of aquatic life assume that aquatic ecosystems have sufficient resiliency to recover from criteria exceedences occurring up to once every 3 years. This resiliency assumption was critically reviewed through two approaches: (1) synthesis of case studies, and (2) population modeling. The population modeling examined differences in recovery of species with widely different life histories. One invertebrate (Hyalella azteca) and four fish species were modeled (fathead minnow, brook trout, lake trout, and shortnose sturgeon) with various disturbance magnitudes and intervals. The synthesis of ecosystem case studies showed generally faster recoveries for insect communities rather than fish, and recoveries from pulse (acute) disturbances were often faster than recoveries from press (chronic) disturbances. When the recovery dataset excluded severe disturbances that seemed unrepresentative of common facility discharge upsets that might cause criteria exceedences, the median recovery time was 1 year, 81% of the cases were considered recovered within 3 years, and 95% were considered recovered within 10 years. The modeling projected that short-lived fish species with high recovery times could thrive despite enduring 50% mortality disturbances every other year. However, long-lived fish species had longer recovery times and declined under the one disturbance every 3 years scenario. Overall, the analyses did not refute the long-standing judgements that 3 years is generally sufficient for recovery from nonrepetitive, moderate intensity disturbances of a magnitude up to 2× the chronic criteria in waters without other pollution sources or stresses. However, these constraints may not always be met and if long-lived fish species are a concern, longer return intervals such as 5–10 years could be indicated. Environ Toxicol Chem 2022;41:2887–2910. Published 2022. This article is a U.S. Government work and is in the public domain in the USA.


  • Open Access

    The protectiveness of aquatic life criteria for threatened or endangered aquatic species: Cadmium in California

    by Christopher Mebane

    In the United States, conflicts can arise between the processes to derive aquatic life criteria (ALC) for chemicals under the Clean Water Act (CWA) and the evaluation procedures used in Endangered Species Act (ESA) consultations on the protectiveness of those criteria for protected species. This paper examines the roots of, and possible reconciliation of, one longstanding conflict over cadmium aquatic life criteria in California. This case study includes 1) an overview of occurrences of cadmium in the aquatic environment, 2) factors affecting toxicity of cadmium to aquatic life, 3) a contrast between the analytical procedures of CWA aquatic life criteria derivation and ESA consultation, 4) quantitative estimates of no-effect concentrations of cadmium for 44 ESA listed species in comparison with updated aquatic life criteria, and 5) concludes with suggestions to update California’s aquatic life criteria for cadmium that would be more protective of sensitive ESA listed species.A root cause of conflict is the different levels of biological organization that are the focus of CWA and ESA procedures. The CWA ALC are intended to protect diverse ecosystems by protecting at least 95% of the species richness in communities, allowing that it is acceptable for some species in the residual most sensitive 5% of the community richness to be harmed or even locally extirpated so long as they are not societally important species. The ESA is charged with minimizing harm to individual organisms and disallows increasing risk of extinction or impeding recovery of protected species. With cadmium in California, these procedures converge because some of the most sensitive species to cadmium happen to be surrogates for protected species (acute responses of steelhead/rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss, and chronic responses of threespine stickleback, Gasterosteus aculeatus). The present review concludes that while the superseded 1996 cadmium criteria versions would not be fully protective for up to half of the 44 ESA listed aquatic species in California, the updated 2016 versions would be more protective. Still, the review shows that the updated acute criteria would only fully protect the less sensitive half of the distribution of data for steelhead/rainbow trout sensitivity to cadmium, and the chronic criterion still would not protect the listed threespine stickleback. With a data rich species such as rainbow trout, instead of defining acute criteria using a central tendency statistic such as the geometric mean of multiple test responses, using a lower statistic such as the 10th percentile would ensure that the vast majority of a sensitive, protected species (and all less sensitive species) would be protected. Available data for the stickleback indicate it may be highly sensitive to cadmium, but no threshold can be derived from existing data. Additional testing with cadmium and stickleback would be needed to suggest an alternative, quantitative approach.

  • Open Access

    Direct and Delayed Mortality of Ceriodaphnia dubia and Rainbow Trout Following Time-Varying Acute Exposures to Zinc

    by Christopher A. Mebane, Christopher D. Ivey, Ning Wang, Jeffery A. Steevens, Danielle Cleveland, Michael C. Elias, James R. Justice, Kathryn Gallagher, Robert N. Brent

    The potential for delayed mortality following short-term episodic pollution events was evaluated by exposing cladocerans (Ceriodaphnia dubia) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) to zinc (Zn) in various 1- to 48-h and 1- to 96-h exposures, respectively, followed by transferring the exposed organisms to clean water for up to 47 h for C. dubia and up to 95 h for trout for additional observation. For C. dubia, 1-h exposures of up to 3790 µg Zn/L never resulted in mortality during the actual Zn exposures, but by 48 h, a 1-h exposure to 114 µg/L, a concentration similar to the present US national water quality acute criterion for the test water conditions, ultimately killed 70% of C. dubia. With C. dubia, the speed of action of Zn toxicity was faster for intermediate concentrations than for the highest concentrations tested. For rainbow trout, pronounced delayed mortalities by 96 h only occurred following ≥8-h exposures. For both species, ultimate mortalities from Zn exposures ≤8 h mostly presented as delayed mortalities, whereas for exposures ≥24 h, almost all ultimate mortalities presented during the actual exposure periods. With Zn, risks of delayed mortality following exposures to all concentrations tested were much greater for the more sensitive, small-bodied invertebrate (C. dubia) than for the less sensitive, larger-bodied fish (rainbow trout). These results, along with previous studies, show that delayed mortality is an important consideration in evaluating risks to aquatic organisms from brief, episodic exposures to some substances. Environ Toxicol Chem 2021;40:2484–2498. © 2021 The Authors. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of SETAC. This article has been contributed to by US Government employees and their work is in the public domain in the USA. Abstract Rainbow trout could withstand extreme Zn pulses of 1 to 3 h, with few subsequent deaths. Few Ceriodaphnia dubia died during 1- to 3-h Zn pulses, but after 48 h, most were dead. Time to effects decreased as expected as rainbow trout were exposed to increasing Zn concentrations. Not so with C. dubia: time to effects was fastest in intermediate Zn exposures, with longer survivals in higher Zn exposures.