Carl Veller
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Carl Veller has a total of 71 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Martin A. Nowak
Department of Mathematics, Harvard University, Cambridge, USA
14 shared publications - Pavitra Muralidhar
Department of Ecology & Evolution, University of Chicago
14 shared publications - Jason Olejarz
Department of Immunology and Infectious Diseases, Harvard T. H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, MA 02115, USA
6 shared publications - Graham Coop
Department of Evolution & Ecology and Center for Population Biology, University of California, Davis
5 shared publications - Kamran Kaveh
Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
3 shared publications - Nathaniel Bernard Edelman
Harvard University
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 20 March 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123 (12)
Quantitative system drift
We consider a biological system composed of multiple genetically variable components, the combined result of which is a quantitative trait under stabilizing selection for an optimal value. We show mathematically that, while the mean value of the system is ultimately constrained to remain near its optimum, the mean contributions of individual components are free to drift far from their initial values. Each component’s drift, though qualitatively identical to neutral drift, is slower by a factor that depends on the fraction of the system’s genetic variance contributed by the component. We further show that symmetric mutation between alleles that increase and decrease components’ contributions to the system imposes a weak long-term brake on components’ drift. Our results provide a population-genetic basis for “system drift,” the concept that individual components of a biological system can evolve despite selective constraint on their combined product. A special case is a single polygenic trait under stabilizing selection, where our results predict that the mean contributions to the trait of different subregions of the genome, such as the chromosomes, can drift despite constraint on the genome-wide value. To indicate the broad applicability of our results, we explore their implications for the evolution of gene expression, selection against interspecific hybrids, selection against turnovers of sex-determining systems, and the division of labor in mutualisms.
- 20 March 2026
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 123 (12)
Open AccessQuantitative system drift
We consider a biological system composed of multiple genetically variable components, the combined result of which is a quantitative trait under stabilizing selection for an optimal value. We show mathematically that, while the mean value of the system is ultimately constrained to remain near its optimum, the mean contributions of individual components are free to drift far from their initial values. Each component’s drift, though qualitatively identical to neutral drift, is slower by a factor that depends on the fraction of the system’s genetic variance contributed by the component. We further show that symmetric mutation between alleles that increase and decrease components’ contributions to the system imposes a weak long-term brake on components’ drift. Our results provide a population-genetic basis for “system drift,” the concept that individual components of a biological system can evolve despite selective constraint on their combined product. A special case is a single polygenic trait under stabilizing selection, where our results predict that the mean contributions to the trait of different subregions of the genome, such as the chromosomes, can drift despite constraint on the genome-wide value. To indicate the broad applicability of our results, we explore their implications for the evolution of gene expression, selection against interspecific hybrids, selection against turnovers of sex-determining systems, and the division of labor in mutualisms.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 9 March 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Genetics
- Vol. 22 (3) , e1012035
The effect of long-range linkage disequilibrium on allele-frequency dynamics under stabilizing selection
Stabilizing selection on a polygenic trait reduces the trait’s genetic variance by (i) generating correlations (linkage disequilibria) between opposite-effect alleles throughout the genome, and (ii) selecting against rare alleles at loci that affect the trait, eroding heterozygosity at these loci. Here, we show that the linkage disequilibria, which stabilizing selection generates on a rapid timescale, slow down the subsequent allele-frequency dynamics at individual loci, which proceed on a much longer timescale. Exploiting this separation of timescales, we obtain expressions for the expected per-generation change in minor-allele frequency at individual loci, as functions of the effect sizes at these loci, the strength of selection on the trait, its variance and heritability, and the linkage relations among loci. Using whole-genome simulations, we show that our expressions predict allele-frequency dynamics under stabilizing selection more accurately than the formulae that have previously been used for this purpose. Our results have implications for understanding the genetic architecture of complex traits.
- 9 March 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Genetics
- Vol. 22 (3) , e1012035
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe effect of long-range linkage disequilibrium on allele-frequency dynamics under stabilizing selection
Stabilizing selection on a polygenic trait reduces the trait’s genetic variance by (i) generating correlations (linkage disequilibria) between opposite-effect alleles throughout the genome, and (ii) selecting against rare alleles at loci that affect the trait, eroding heterozygosity at these loci. Here, we show that the linkage disequilibria, which stabilizing selection generates on a rapid timescale, slow down the subsequent allele-frequency dynamics at individual loci, which proceed on a much longer timescale. Exploiting this separation of timescales, we obtain expressions for the expected per-generation change in minor-allele frequency at individual loci, as functions of the effect sizes at these loci, the strength of selection on the trait, its variance and heritability, and the linkage relations among loci. Using whole-genome simulations, we show that our expressions predict allele-frequency dynamics under stabilizing selection more accurately than the formulae that have previously been used for this purpose. Our results have implications for understanding the genetic architecture of complex traits.
- Open Access
Quantitative system drift
We consider a biological system composed of multiple genetically variable components, the combined result of which is a quantitative trait under stabilizing selection for an optimal value. We show mathematically that, while the mean value of the system is ultimately constrained to remain near its optimum, the values of individual components are free to drift far from their initial values. Each component’s drift, though qualitatively similar to neutral drift, is slower by a factor that depends on the fraction of the system’s genetic variance contributed by the component. Our results provide a population-genetic basis for ‘system drift’, the concept that individual components of a biological system can evolve despite selective constraint on their combined product. A special case is a single polygenic trait under stabilizing selection, where our results predict that the mean genetic contributions to the trait of different subregions of the genome, such as the chromosomes, can drift despite constraint on the genome-wide genetic value. We explore the implications of this latter result for selection against interspecific hybrids and selection against turnovers of sex-determining systems. We further apply our general results to a continuous public goods game played between two species, where they predict that individual species’ contributions to a costly public good can drift freely. Finally, we show that symmetric mutation between alleles that increase and decrease components’ contributions to the system provides a weak long-term brake on components’ drift.
Open AccessQuantitative system drift
We consider a biological system composed of multiple genetically variable components, the combined result of which is a quantitative trait under stabilizing selection for an optimal value. We show mathematically that, while the mean value of the system is ultimately constrained to remain near its optimum, the values of individual components are free to drift far from their initial values. Each component’s drift, though qualitatively similar to neutral drift, is slower by a factor that depends on the fraction of the system’s genetic variance contributed by the component. Our results provide a population-genetic basis for ‘system drift’, the concept that individual components of a biological system can evolve despite selective constraint on their combined product. A special case is a single polygenic trait under stabilizing selection, where our results predict that the mean genetic contributions to the trait of different subregions of the genome, such as the chromosomes, can drift despite constraint on the genome-wide genetic value. We explore the implications of this latter result for selection against interspecific hybrids and selection against turnovers of sex-determining systems. We further apply our general results to a continuous public goods game played between two species, where they predict that individual species’ contributions to a costly public good can drift freely. Finally, we show that symmetric mutation between alleles that increase and decrease components’ contributions to the system provides a weak long-term brake on components’ drift.
- Open Access
- 13 September 2024
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 121 (38)
Causal interpretations of family GWAS in the presence of heterogeneous effects
Family-based genome-wide association studies (GWASs) are often claimed to provide an unbiased estimate of the average causal effects (or average treatment effects; ATEs) of alleles, on the basis of an analogy between the random transmission of alleles from parents to children and a randomized controlled trial. We show that this claim does not hold in general. Because Mendelian segregation only randomizes alleles among children of heterozygotes, the effects of alleles in the children of homozygotes are not observable. This feature will matter if an allele has different average effects in the children of homozygotes and heterozygotes, as can arise in the presence of gene-by-environment interactions, gene-by-gene interactions, or differences in linkage disequilibrium patterns. At a single locus, family-based GWAS can be thought of as providing an unbiased estimate of the average effect in the children of heterozygotes (i.e., a local average treatment effect; LATE). This interpretation does not extend to polygenic scores (PGSs), however, because different sets of SNPs are heterozygous in each family. Therefore, other than under specific conditions, the within-family regression slope of a PGS cannot be assumed to provide an unbiased estimate of the LATE for any subset or weighted average of families. In practice, the potential biases of a family-based GWAS are likely smaller than those that can arise from confounding in a standard, population-based GWAS, and so family studies remain important for the dissection of genetic contributions to phenotypic variation. Nonetheless, their causal interpretation is less straightforward than has been widely appreciated.
- 13 September 2024
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 121 (38)
Open AccessCausal interpretations of family GWAS in the presence of heterogeneous effects
Family-based genome-wide association studies (GWASs) are often claimed to provide an unbiased estimate of the average causal effects (or average treatment effects; ATEs) of alleles, on the basis of an analogy between the random transmission of alleles from parents to children and a randomized controlled trial. We show that this claim does not hold in general. Because Mendelian segregation only randomizes alleles among children of heterozygotes, the effects of alleles in the children of homozygotes are not observable. This feature will matter if an allele has different average effects in the children of homozygotes and heterozygotes, as can arise in the presence of gene-by-environment interactions, gene-by-gene interactions, or differences in linkage disequilibrium patterns. At a single locus, family-based GWAS can be thought of as providing an unbiased estimate of the average effect in the children of heterozygotes (i.e., a local average treatment effect; LATE). This interpretation does not extend to polygenic scores (PGSs), however, because different sets of SNPs are heterozygous in each family. Therefore, other than under specific conditions, the within-family regression slope of a PGS cannot be assumed to provide an unbiased estimate of the LATE for any subset or weighted average of families. In practice, the potential biases of a family-based GWAS are likely smaller than those that can arise from confounding in a standard, population-based GWAS, and so family studies remain important for the dissection of genetic contributions to phenotypic variation. Nonetheless, their causal interpretation is less straightforward than has been widely appreciated.
- Open Access
Stabilizing selection generates selection against introgressed DNA
DNA introgressed from one population into another is often deleterious to the recipient population if the two populations have diverged genetically from one another. Previous explanations of this phenomenon have posited negative interactions between donor-population alleles and the recipient population’s genome or environment, or higher genetic load in the donor population. Here, we show that stabilizing selection on quantitative traits—even around the same optimal trait values in the two populations and when the populations are demographically identical—generates selection against the minor-parent ancestry in a population formed via unequal admixture of the two populations. We calculate the rate at which minor-parent ancestry is purged under this mechanism, both in the early generations after admixture and in the long term, and we verify these calculations with whole-genome simulations. Because of its ubiquity, stabilizing selection offers a general mechanism for the deleterious effect of introgressed ancestry.
Open AccessStabilizing selection generates selection against introgressed DNA
DNA introgressed from one population into another is often deleterious to the recipient population if the two populations have diverged genetically from one another. Previous explanations of this phenomenon have posited negative interactions between donor-population alleles and the recipient population’s genome or environment, or higher genetic load in the donor population. Here, we show that stabilizing selection on quantitative traits—even around the same optimal trait values in the two populations and when the populations are demographically identical—generates selection against the minor-parent ancestry in a population formed via unequal admixture of the two populations. We calculate the rate at which minor-parent ancestry is purged under this mechanism, both in the early generations after admixture and in the long term, and we verify these calculations with whole-genome simulations. Because of its ubiquity, stabilizing selection offers a general mechanism for the deleterious effect of introgressed ancestry.
- Open Access
The effect of long-range linkage disequilibrium on allele-frequency dynamics under stabilizing selection
Stabilizing selection on a polygenic trait reduces the trait’s genetic variance by (i) generating correlations (linkage disequilibria) between opposite-effect alleles throughout the genome, and (ii) selecting against rare alleles at loci that affect the trait, eroding heterozygosity at these loci. Here, we show that the linkage disequilibria, which stabilizing selection generates on a rapid timescale, slow down the subsequent allele-frequency dynamics at individual loci, which proceed on a much longer timescale. Exploiting this separation of timescales, we obtain expressions for the expected per-generation change in minor-allele frequency at individual loci, as functions of the effect sizes at these loci, the strength of selection on the trait, its variance and heritability, and the linkage relations among loci. Using whole-genome simulations, we show that our expressions predict allele-frequency dynamics under stabilizing selection more accurately than the formulae that have previously been used for this purpose. Our results have implications for understanding the genetic architecture of complex traits.
Open AccessThe effect of long-range linkage disequilibrium on allele-frequency dynamics under stabilizing selection
Stabilizing selection on a polygenic trait reduces the trait’s genetic variance by (i) generating correlations (linkage disequilibria) between opposite-effect alleles throughout the genome, and (ii) selecting against rare alleles at loci that affect the trait, eroding heterozygosity at these loci. Here, we show that the linkage disequilibria, which stabilizing selection generates on a rapid timescale, slow down the subsequent allele-frequency dynamics at individual loci, which proceed on a much longer timescale. Exploiting this separation of timescales, we obtain expressions for the expected per-generation change in minor-allele frequency at individual loci, as functions of the effect sizes at these loci, the strength of selection on the trait, its variance and heritability, and the linkage relations among loci. Using whole-genome simulations, we show that our expressions predict allele-frequency dynamics under stabilizing selection more accurately than the formulae that have previously been used for this purpose. Our results have implications for understanding the genetic architecture of complex traits.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 11 April 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Biology
- Vol. 22 (4) , e3002511
Interpreting population- and family-based genome-wide association studies in the presence of confounding
A central aim of genome-wide association studies (GWASs) is to estimate direct genetic effects: the causal effects on an individual’s phenotype of the alleles that they carry. However, estimates of direct effects can be subject to genetic and environmental confounding and can also absorb the “indirect” genetic effects of relatives’ genotypes. Recently, an important development in controlling for these confounds has been the use of within-family GWASs, which, because of the randomness of mendelian segregation within pedigrees, are often interpreted as producing unbiased estimates of direct effects. Here, we present a general theoretical analysis of the influence of confounding in standard population-based and within-family GWASs. We show that, contrary to common interpretation, family-based estimates of direct effects can be biased by genetic confounding. In humans, such biases will often be small per-locus, but can be compounded when effect-size estimates are used in polygenic scores (PGSs). We illustrate the influence of genetic confounding on population- and family-based estimates of direct effects using models of assortative mating, population stratification, and stabilizing selection on GWAS traits. We further show how family-based estimates of indirect genetic effects, based on comparisons of parentally transmitted and untransmitted alleles, can suffer substantial genetic confounding. We conclude that, while family-based studies have placed GWAS estimation on a more rigorous footing, they carry subtle issues of interpretation that arise from confounding.
- 11 April 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Biology
- Vol. 22 (4) , e3002511
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessInterpreting population- and family-based genome-wide association studies in the presence of confounding
A central aim of genome-wide association studies (GWASs) is to estimate direct genetic effects: the causal effects on an individual’s phenotype of the alleles that they carry. However, estimates of direct effects can be subject to genetic and environmental confounding and can also absorb the “indirect” genetic effects of relatives’ genotypes. Recently, an important development in controlling for these confounds has been the use of within-family GWASs, which, because of the randomness of mendelian segregation within pedigrees, are often interpreted as producing unbiased estimates of direct effects. Here, we present a general theoretical analysis of the influence of confounding in standard population-based and within-family GWASs. We show that, contrary to common interpretation, family-based estimates of direct effects can be biased by genetic confounding. In humans, such biases will often be small per-locus, but can be compounded when effect-size estimates are used in polygenic scores (PGSs). We illustrate the influence of genetic confounding on population- and family-based estimates of direct effects using models of assortative mating, population stratification, and stabilizing selection on GWAS traits. We further show how family-based estimates of indirect genetic effects, based on comparisons of parentally transmitted and untransmitted alleles, can suffer substantial genetic confounding. We conclude that, while family-based studies have placed GWAS estimation on a more rigorous footing, they carry subtle issues of interpretation that arise from confounding.
- Top Cited Papers
- 1 December 2023
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science
- Vol. 382 (6674) , 1013-+
Two teosintes made modern maize
The origins of maize were the topic of vigorous debate for nearly a century, but neither the current genetic model nor earlier archaeological models account for the totality of available data, and recent work has highlighted the potential contribution of a wild relative, Zea mays ssp. mexicana . Our population genetic analysis reveals that the origin of modern maize can be traced to an admixture between ancient maize and Zea mays ssp. mexicana in the highlands of Mexico some 4000 years after domestication began. We show that variation in admixture is a key component of maize diversity, both at individual loci and for additive genetic variation underlying agronomic traits. Our results clarify the origin of modern maize and raise new questions about the anthropogenic mechanisms underlying dispersal throughout the Americas.
- 1 December 2023
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science
- Vol. 382 (6674) , 1013-+
Top Cited PapersTwo teosintes made modern maize
The origins of maize were the topic of vigorous debate for nearly a century, but neither the current genetic model nor earlier archaeological models account for the totality of available data, and recent work has highlighted the potential contribution of a wild relative, Zea mays ssp. mexicana . Our population genetic analysis reveals that the origin of modern maize can be traced to an admixture between ancient maize and Zea mays ssp. mexicana in the highlands of Mexico some 4000 years after domestication began. We show that variation in admixture is a key component of maize diversity, both at individual loci and for additive genetic variation underlying agronomic traits. Our results clarify the origin of modern maize and raise new questions about the anthropogenic mechanisms underlying dispersal throughout the Americas.
- Open Access
Causal interpretations of family GWAS in the presence of heterogeneous effects
Family-based genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have emerged as a gold standard for assessing causal effects of alleles and polygenic scores. Notably, family studies are often claimed to provide an unbiased estimate of the average causal effect (or average treatment effect; ATE) of an allele, on the basis of an analogy between the random transmission of alleles from parents to children and a randomized controlled trial. Here, we show that this interpretation does not hold in general. Because Mendelian segregation only randomizes alleles among children of heterozygotes, the effects of alleles in the children of homozygotes are not observable. Consequently, if an allele has different average effects in the children of homozygotes and heterozygotes, as can arise in the presence of gene-by-environment interactions, gene-by-gene interactions, or differences in LD patterns, family studies provide a biased estimate of the average effect in the sample. At a single locus, family-based association studies can be thought of as providing an unbiased estimate of the average effect in the children of heterozygotes (i.e., a local average treatment effect; LATE). This interpretation does not extend to polygenic scores, however, because different sets of SNPs are heterozygous in each family. Therefore, other than under specific conditions, the within-family regression slope of a PGS cannot be assumed to provide an un-biased estimate for any subset or weighted average of families. Instead, family-based studies can be reinterpreted as enabling an unbiased estimate of the extent to which Mendelian segregation at loci in the PGS contributes to the population-level variance in the trait. Because this estimate does not include the between-family variance, however, this interpretation applies to only (roughly) half of the sample PGS variance. In practice, the potential biases of a family-based GWAS are likely smaller than those arising from confounding in a standard, population-based GWAS, and so family studies remain important for the dissection of genetic contributions to phenotypic variation. Nonetheless, the causal interpretation of family-based GWAS estimates is less straightforward than has been widely appreciated.
Open AccessCausal interpretations of family GWAS in the presence of heterogeneous effects
Family-based genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have emerged as a gold standard for assessing causal effects of alleles and polygenic scores. Notably, family studies are often claimed to provide an unbiased estimate of the average causal effect (or average treatment effect; ATE) of an allele, on the basis of an analogy between the random transmission of alleles from parents to children and a randomized controlled trial. Here, we show that this interpretation does not hold in general. Because Mendelian segregation only randomizes alleles among children of heterozygotes, the effects of alleles in the children of homozygotes are not observable. Consequently, if an allele has different average effects in the children of homozygotes and heterozygotes, as can arise in the presence of gene-by-environment interactions, gene-by-gene interactions, or differences in LD patterns, family studies provide a biased estimate of the average effect in the sample. At a single locus, family-based association studies can be thought of as providing an unbiased estimate of the average effect in the children of heterozygotes (i.e., a local average treatment effect; LATE). This interpretation does not extend to polygenic scores, however, because different sets of SNPs are heterozygous in each family. Therefore, other than under specific conditions, the within-family regression slope of a PGS cannot be assumed to provide an un-biased estimate for any subset or weighted average of families. Instead, family-based studies can be reinterpreted as enabling an unbiased estimate of the extent to which Mendelian segregation at loci in the PGS contributes to the population-level variance in the trait. Because this estimate does not include the between-family variance, however, this interpretation applies to only (roughly) half of the sample PGS variance. In practice, the potential biases of a family-based GWAS are likely smaller than those arising from confounding in a standard, population-based GWAS, and so family studies remain important for the dissection of genetic contributions to phenotypic variation. Nonetheless, the causal interpretation of family-based GWAS estimates is less straightforward than has been widely appreciated.
- Open Access
Interpreting population and family-based genome-wide association studies in the presence of confounding
A central aim of genome-wide association studies (GWASs) is to estimate direct genetic effects: the causal effects on an individual’s phenotype of the alleles that they carry. However, estimates of direct effects can be subject to genetic and environmental confounding, and can also absorb the ‘indirect’ genetic effects of relatives’ genotypes. Recently, an important development in controlling for these confounds has been the use of within-family GWASs, which, because of the randomness of Mendelian segregation within pedigrees, are often interpreted as producing unbiased estimates of direct effects. Here, we present a general theoretical analysis of the influence of confounding in standard population-based and within-family GWASs. We show that, contrary to common interpretation, family-based estimates of direct effects can be biased by genetic confounding. In humans, such biases will often be small per-locus, but can be compounded when effect size estimates are used in polygenic scores. We illustrate the influence of genetic confounding on population- and family-based estimates of direct effects using models of assortative mating, population stratification, and stabilizing selection on GWAS traits. We further show how family-based estimates of indirect genetic effects, based on comparisons of parentally transmitted and untransmitted alleles, can suffer substantial genetic confounding. In addition to known biases that can arise in family-based GWASs when interactions between family members are ignored, we show that biases can also arise from gene-by-environment (G×E) interactions when parental genotypes are not distributed identically across interacting environmental and genetic backgrounds. We conclude that, while family-based studies have placed GWAS estimation on a more rigorous footing, they carry subtle issues of interpretation that arise from confounding and interactions.
Open AccessInterpreting population and family-based genome-wide association studies in the presence of confounding
A central aim of genome-wide association studies (GWASs) is to estimate direct genetic effects: the causal effects on an individual’s phenotype of the alleles that they carry. However, estimates of direct effects can be subject to genetic and environmental confounding, and can also absorb the ‘indirect’ genetic effects of relatives’ genotypes. Recently, an important development in controlling for these confounds has been the use of within-family GWASs, which, because of the randomness of Mendelian segregation within pedigrees, are often interpreted as producing unbiased estimates of direct effects. Here, we present a general theoretical analysis of the influence of confounding in standard population-based and within-family GWASs. We show that, contrary to common interpretation, family-based estimates of direct effects can be biased by genetic confounding. In humans, such biases will often be small per-locus, but can be compounded when effect size estimates are used in polygenic scores. We illustrate the influence of genetic confounding on population- and family-based estimates of direct effects using models of assortative mating, population stratification, and stabilizing selection on GWAS traits. We further show how family-based estimates of indirect genetic effects, based on comparisons of parentally transmitted and untransmitted alleles, can suffer substantial genetic confounding. In addition to known biases that can arise in family-based GWASs when interactions between family members are ignored, we show that biases can also arise from gene-by-environment (G×E) interactions when parental genotypes are not distributed identically across interacting environmental and genetic backgrounds. We conclude that, while family-based studies have placed GWAS estimation on a more rigorous footing, they carry subtle issues of interpretation that arise from confounding and interactions.