Tohren C. G. Kibbey has a total of 53 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:

  • Lixia Chen

    School of Civil Engineering and Environmental Science University of Oklahoma Norman Oklahoma USA

    6 shared publications
  • Denis Michael O'Carroll

    Water Research Centre, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia

    5 shared publications
  • Lili Hou

    School of Civil Engineering and Environmental Science University of Oklahoma 202 W Boyd Street, Rm. 334 Norman OK 73019 USA

    4 shared publications
  • Yi Gao

    School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Water Research Centre and Water Research Laboratory

    4 shared publications
  • David A. Sabatini

    School of Civil Engineering and Environmental Science University of Oklahoma 202 W Boyd Street, Rm. 334 Norman OK 73019 USA

    3 shared publications
  • Song-Thao Le

    School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Water Research Centre

    3 shared publications

Latest Publications

  • Predicting Salt Effects on the Binding of PFAS to Protein

    by Yi Gao, Tohren C. G. Kibbey, Matthew J. Lee, Denis M. O’cArroll

    Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are known to bind to specific proteins, leading to their accumulation in specific organs/tissues, ultimately resulting in adverse health effects. Salts strongly impact PFAS and protein behaviors in the environment and biota, but the impact of salt on PFAS/protein interaction has not been assessed. In this study, we investigated the impact of salt on anionic PFAS (including PFBA, PFHxA, PFHpA, PFOA, PFNA, PFDA, PFBS, PFHxS, PFOS, and GenX) and bovine serum albumin (BSA) interactions. PFAS/BSA binding affinity was found to depend on PFAS chain length and headgroup, salt composition, ionic strength, and solution pH. PFAS/BSA interactions weakened with increasing ionic strength and decreasing cation valency. The molecular structure of PFAS did not affect how the ionic strength influenced binding affinities. However, the binding affinity exhibits pH dependence, with salt effects becoming more pronounced as the pH decreased. Thermodynamic analysis indicated a hydrophobic-dominant interaction between PFAS and BSA. Additionally, we developed a model to predict binding affinity under varying salt conditions, suggesting that different PFAS associate with wastewater to differing extents, strongly influenced by salt content. This model can be used to predict PFAS environmental fate and toxicity.


  • Prediction of the Impact of Hydrochemistry on PFAS Removal Using Ion Exchange Resins

    by Yi Gao, Song-Thao Le, Jennifer Hou, James McDonald, Aaron Colusso, Matthew J. Lee, Matthew Raymond, Brian Oldland, Craig Smith, Marc Roehl, et al.


  • Open Access

    Removal of Attached Zinc Oxide and Titanium Dioxide Nanoparticles from Spinach Leaves by Rinsing in the Absence and Presence of Preexisting Surface Extracellular Polymeric Substances (EPS)

    by Jack E. Bezdek, Keith A. Strevett, Tohren C. G. Kibbey

    Interest in the use of nanoparticles in agriculture has grown in recent years due to their potential abilities across a range of applications that could increase agricultural production, improve the efficiency of nutrient delivery, or improve pest management. However, as with any application of nanomaterials, concern exists about potential risks to human health. Because many applications might result in the attachment of nanoparticles to produce surfaces, it is important to understand the conditions under which rinsing is likely to remove nanoparticles from surfaces and the degree to which they can be removed. This work explored the rinsing removal of two types of nanoparticles, titanium dioxide (TiO2) and zinc oxide (ZnO), from spinach leaf surfaces in the absence and presence of biofilms based on extracellular polymeric substances (EPS). A hypothesis driving the work was that the presence of biofilms might enhance the retention of nanoparticles. The work combined experiments to determine surface energy parameters for fresh and rotten spinach, for use in extended DLVO (xDLVO) calculations, as well as direct rinsing experiments to explore nanoparticle removal from spinach surfaces. Nanoparticles were quantified using backscattered scanning electron microscopy using techniques developed for the work. Results of xDLVO calculations suggest that the presence of biofilms may actually be likely to reduce the retention of nanoparticles by produce surfaces, although this effect was not apparent in rinsing experiments, which exhibited similar removal of high-concentration TiO2 from spinach leaves. Overall, nanoparticles deposited from high-concentration suspensions were found to be removed to a greater degree by rinsing, while those deposited from low-concentration suspensions exhibited no apparent release, even under conditions where release might be favored.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Underestimated burden of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances in global surface waters and groundwaters

    by Diana Ackerman Grunfeld, Daniel Gilbert, Jennifer Hou, Adele M. Jones, Matthew J. Lee, Tohren C. G. Kibbey, Denis M. O’carroll

    Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a class of fluorinated chemicals used widely in consumer and industrial products. Their human toxicity and ecosystem impacts have received extensive public, scientific and regulatory attention. Regulatory PFAS guidance is rapidly evolving, with the inclusion of a wider range of PFAS included in advisories and a continued decrease in what is deemed safe PFAS concentrations. In this study we collated PFAS concentration data for over 45,000 surface and groundwater samples from around the world to assess the global extent of PFAS contamination and their potential future environmental burden. Here we show that a substantial fraction of sampled waters exceeds PFAS drinking water guidance values, with the extent of exceedance depending on the jurisdiction and PFAS source. Additionally, current monitoring practices probably underestimate PFAS in the environment given the limited suite of PFAS that are typically quantified but deemed of regulatory concern. An improved understanding of the range of PFAS embodied in consumer and industrial products is required to assess the environmental burden and develop mitigation measures. While PFAS is the focus of this study, it also highlights society’s need to better understand the use, fate and impacts of anthropogenic chemicals.


  • Open Access

    Multi-class machine learning classification of PFAS in environmental water samples: a blinded test of performance on unknowns

    by Tohren C. G. Kibbey, Denis M. O'CArroll, Andrew Safulko, Greg Coyle

    A multi-class method was developed to identify PFAS origin based on chemical composition, and performance of the method was evaluated in a blinded test against unknowns. The method showed great promise in its ability to recognize sample origin.


  • Open Access

    The Influence of Evaporation and Seasonal Effects on the Water Content in the Unsaturated Zone: A Multi-Year Laboratory Study

    by Aderonke O. Adegbule, Tohren C. G. Kibbey

    The unsaturated zone of the subsurface plays a critical role in the environmental fate and transport of a wide range of environmental contaminants, and is also important for plant growth and agriculture. Quantitative prediction of processes in the unsaturated zone requires knowledge of how water content varies with elevation above the water table, a relationship known as the capillary pressure (Pc)–saturation (S) relationship. While the Pc–S relationship is conventionally thought of as being primarily a property of the porous medium and fluids, previous work found evidence suggesting that it actually results from a dynamic equilibrium between capillary forces and phenomena driven by evaporation. The focus of this work was on gaining a further understanding of the role of evaporation on the Pc–S relationship. The work made use of a tall instrumented laboratory column connected to an external reservoir for maintaining water table height. Following an initial imbibition experiment, the column was saturated and allowed to drain, and then water content was monitored in the column as a function of height over 1207 days (3.31 years). While initial imbibition and drainage were rapid, on the order of hours, redistribution and evaporation effects became apparent over longer time scales (hundreds of hours). A drying front moving downward in the column was apparent from changes in the slopes of saturation vs. time curves as it passed individual sensors; unlike previous experiments with a more fully-vented column, the evaporation front appeared to stall, balanced by the capillary-driven upward flow of water. Over the full multi-year duration of the experiment, seasonal trends in water saturation were apparent, with significant, reversible variations observed that closely followed atmospheric conditions. Specifically, saturation above the water table appeared to increase during the spring and summer months and decrease during the fall and winter months, despite the constant water table location, consistent with a changing driving force for evaporation. This result may suggest the likelihood of seasonal effects in the long-term transport and fate of contaminants in the unsaturated zone.


  • The effect of mixed micelle formation on the dynamics of phase partitioning for a polydisperse ethoxylated nonionic surfactant

    by Tohren C. G. Kibbey, Lixia Chen

    Mixed surfactants are common in practical applications, and their behaviors are often observed to deviate from the behaviors of pure surfactants with similar average properties in striking, and sometimes unexpected ways. The focus of this work was on exploring the role of mixed micelle formation in a mixed ethoxylated nonionic surfactant on the dynamics of partitioning between immiscible phases. The work examined partitioning of an ethoxylated nonylphenol surfactant between water and tetrachloroethylene (PCE) in a stagnant system at two different phase volume ratios. A model describing partitioning rate was developed and calibrated to experimental data, and then used to predict the long‐term dynamic approach to equilibrium in mixed and pure systems. The work suggests that micelle formation slows partitioning time by limiting the concentration of monomers in water; in pure systems, time to approach equilibrium increases with increasing concentration, but then reaches a maximum. However, in mixed systems, time to approach equilibrium continues to increase with increasing concentration over the physically‐possible concentration range. For the mixed system studied here, partitioning could be expected to take two orders of magnitude longer at very high concentrations than a similar pure system. Because of the similarity of the mathematics, this result might be expected for any monomer‐driven interaction, such as adsorption or interfacial tension reduction.