Tim Hunt

I learned so much from Stan Cohen, my tennis partner in the summer of 1977. He was funny and wise. His account of how he purified and characterized epidermal growth factor, using the time of opening of baby mice’s eyes as the assay, opened my eyes too, previously blinded by spectrophotometric biochemical assays. As long as you can measure something quantitatively, it really doesn’t matter what it is. Two years later in Woods Hole I learned from John Gerhart about MPF (Maturation Promoting Factor), apparently the enzyme that catalyzes entry into mitosis. Again, a far cry from the Krebs cycle and the details of bioenergetics that generations of biochemists grew up with. Years later, after he had won a Nobel Prize for his work on EGF and its receptor, I visited Stan Cohen at his laboratory at Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tennessee. He was 75 years old, but I found him dressed in a lab coat in his cold room. “Stan,” I said, “What are you doing—you don’t need this!” “Tim,” he answered, “It’s pain and suffering, pain and suffering. I can’t stand not knowing the answer. And I putschke around, and every ten years of so I find out something interesting.” Indeed, he had just published a paper in Science describing the behavior of what came to be known as Stat5. In this talk, I want to explore and describe the variety of approaches to finding out how the world works and how to get at the answer.

The binding of cyclin A to p34cdc2 and p32cdk2 and the protein kinase activity of the complexes has been measured by cell-free translation of the corresponding mRNA in extracts of frog eggs, followed by immunoprecipitation. A variety of mutant cyclin A molecules have been constructed and tested in this assay. Small deletions and point mutations of highly conserved residues in the 100-residue "cyclin box" abolish binding and activation of both p34cdc2 and p32cdk2. By contrast, large deletions at the N-terminus have no effect on kinase binding and activation, until they remove residues beyond 161, where the first conserved amino acids are found in all known examples of cyclin A. At the C-terminus, removal of 14 or more amino acids abolishes activity. We also demonstrate that deletion of, or point mutations, in the cyclin A homologue of the 10-residue "destruction box," previously described in cyclin B (Glotzer et al., 1991) abolish cyclin proteolysis at the transition from M-phase to interphase.

A system is described in which transcription of cDNA clones by bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase is coupled to translation in the micrococcal nuclease treated rabbit reticulocyte lysate in a single reaction of coupled transcription-translation. The monovalent and divalent cation requirements for translation are dominant for optimum expression In this coupled system, so that transcription is relatively Inefficient. Nevertheless, the use of appropriate DNA concentrations leads to the synthesis of sufficient RNA to saturate the protein synthesis capacity of the system. The fidelity and efficiency of expression in this coupled system are high, and the degree of purification of the plasmid DNA is relatively uncritical. The system therefore offers very considerable advantages for rapid screening of ‘mini-preparations’ of cDNA plasmid constructs for retention of the correct reading frame and expression of the desired protein product.

Fertilization of clam oocytes initiates a series of cell divisions, of which the first three--meiosis I, meiosis II, and the first mitotic division--are highly synchronous. After fertilization, protein synthesis is required for the successful completion of every division except meiosis I. When protein synthesis is inhibited, entry into meiosis I and the maintenance of M phase for the normal duration of meiosis occur normally, but the chromosomes fail to interact correctly with the spindle in meiosis II metaphase. By contrast, inhibition of protein synthesis immediately after completion of meiosis or mitosis stops cells entering the next mitosis. We describe the behavior of cyclins A and B in relation to these "points of no return." The cyclins are synthesized continuously and are rapidly destroyed shortly before the metaphase-anaphase transition of the mitotic cell cycles, with cyclin A being degraded in advance of cyclin B. Cyclin destruction normally occurs during a 5-min window in mitosis, but in the monopolar mitosis that occurs after parthenogenetic activation of clam oocytes, or when colchicine is added to fertilized eggs about to enter first mitosis, the destruction of cyclin B is strongly delayed, whereas proteolysis of cyclin A is maintained in an activated state for the duration of metaphase arrest. Under either of these abnormal conditions, inhibition of protein synthesis causes a premature return to interphase that correlates with the time when cyclin B disappears.

Cyclins are regulatory molecules that undergo periodic accumulation and destruction during each cell cycle. By activating p34^cdc2 and related kinase subunits they control important events required for normal cell cycle progression. Cyclin A, for example, regulates at least two distinct kinase subunits, the mitotic kinase subunit p34^cdc2 and related subunit p33^cdk2, and is widely believed to be necessary for progression through S phase. However, cyclin A also forms a stable complex with the cellular transcription factor DRTF1 and thus may perform other functions during S phase. DRTF1, in addition, associates with the tumour suppressor retinoblastoma (Rb) gene product and the Rb-related protein p107. We now show, using biologically active fusion proteins, that cyclin A can direct the binding of the cdc2-like kinase subunit, p33^cdk2, to complexed DRTF1, containing either Rb or p107, as well as activate its histone H1 kinase activity. Cyclin A cannot, however, direct p34^cdc2 to the DRTF1 complex and we present evidence suggesting that the stability of the cyclin A-p33^cdk2 complex is influenced by DRTF1 or an associated protein. Cyclin A, therefore, serves as an activating and targeting subunit of p33^cdk2 The ability of cyclin A to activate and recruit p33^cdk2 to DRTF1 may play an important role in regulating cell cycle progression and moreover defines a mechanism for coupling cell-cycle events to transcriptional initiation.

We have measured the levels of cyclin mRNAs and polypeptides during oogenesis, progesterone-induced oocyte maturation, and immediately after egg activation in the frog, Xenopus laevis. The mRNA for each cyclin is present at a constant level of approximately 5 x 10(7) molecules per oocyte from the earliest stages of oogenesis until after fertilization. The levels of polypeptides show more complex patterns of accumulation. The B-type cyclins are first detectable in stage IV and V oocytes. Cyclin B2 polypeptide is present at approximately 2 x 10(9) molecules (150 pg) per oocyte by stage VI. The amount increases after progesterone treatment, but returns to its previous level after GVBD and undergoes no further change until it is destroyed at fertilization. Cyclin B1 is present at 4 x 10(8) molecules per oocyte in stage VI oocytes, and rises steadily during maturation, ultimately reaching similar levels to cyclin B2 in unfertilized eggs. Unlike the B-type cyclins, cyclin A is barely detectable in stage VI oocytes, and only starts to be made in significant amounts after oocytes are exposed to progesterone. A portion of all the cyclins are destroyed after germinal vesicle breakdown (GVBD), and cyclins B1 and B2 also experience posttranslational modifications during oocyte maturation. Progesterone strongly stimulates both cyclin and p34cdc2 synthesis in these oocytes, but whereas cyclin synthesis continues in eggs and after fertilization, synthesis of p34cdc2 declines strongly after GVBD. The significance of these results is discussed in terms of the activation and inactivation of maturation-promoting factor.

Progesterone induces fully grown, stage VI, Xenopus oocytes to pass through meiosis I and arrest in metaphase of meiosis II. Protein synthesis is required twice in this process: in order to activate maturation promoting factor (MPF) which induces meiosis I, and then again after the completion of meiosis I to reactivate MPF in order to induce meiosis II. We have used antisense oligonucleotides to destroy maternal stores of cyclin mRNAs, and demonstrate that new cyclin synthesis is not required for entry into either meiosis I or II. This finding is consistent with the demonstration that stage VI oocytes contain a store of B-type cyclin polypeptides (Kobayashi, H., J. Minshull, C. Ford, R. Golsteyn, R. Poon, and T. Hunt. 1991. J. Cell Biol. 114:755-765). Although approximately 70% of cyclin B2 is destroyed at first meiosis, the surviving fraction, together with a larger pool of surviving cyclin B1, must be sufficient to allow the reactivation of MPF and induce entry into second meiotic metaphase. Since stage VI oocytes do not contain any cyclin A, our results show that cyclin A is not required for meiosis in Xenopus. We discuss the possible nature of the proteins whose synthesis is required to induce meiosis I and II.

The cyclins comprise a family of proteins which combine with protein kinase subunits encoded by members of the cdc2 family. The active protein kinase thus formed phosphorylates target proteins in the cell and promotes certain cell cycle transitions. Cyclins A and B show the unusual property of sudden and specific proteolysis shortly before the metaphase-anaphase transition during mitosis. The destruction of the cyclins leads to rapid loss of activity of their kinase companions. The 'simple idea' referred to in the title of this article was that accumulation of cyclin formed maturation promoting factor (MPF), the enzyme that promotes the G2-M transition, and cyclin destruction turned off MPF. The complexity refers to additional controls of cdc2 activity, such as its reversible phosphorylation. Furthermore, many new members of the cyclin family have recently been discovered that may play a role in the regulation of the G1-S transition, and in higher organisms, the cdc2 family is also more numerous than was at first appreciated. Cyclins make important contributions both to subcellular localization and the substrate specificity of their companion kinase subunits. It is too early to say if the entire range of cyclin-like and cdc2-like protein kinases are involved in the control of the cell cycle.

IN vertebrates, mature eggs are arrested at the second meiotic metaphase by the cytostatic factor (CSF)¹, now known to be thec-mos proto-oncogene product (Mos)^{2, 3}. Fertilization or egg activaá-tion triggers a transient increase in the cytoplasmic free calcium^{4, 5} and releases the meiotic arrest by inactivating maturation/mitosis-promoting factor (MPF)^{6, 7}. CSF or Mos, which is also inactivated by the calcium transient^{8, 9}, seems to stabilize MPF in mature eggs and CSF-injected embryos^{2, 6, 10}. Thus, it was assumed that CSF inactivation is the primary cause of MPF inactivation on meiotic release^{2, 6, 8, 10–14}. We have directly compared the degradation kinetics of CSF (Mos) and MPF during meiotic release, using the same batch of Xenopus eggs. We report here that, at the molecular level, cyclin subunits of MPF are degraded before Mos is degraded and, at the physiological level, that MPF activity is inactivated before CSF activity during activation of Xenopus eggs. These results, in conjunction with circumstantial evidence, support the novel view that a calcium transient on fertilization induces a CSF-independent pathway for MPF inactivation, whereas CSF inactivation during meiotic release serves only to allow the fertilá-ized egg to enter mitosis.